0:00 Welcome to The Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:20 [music] 0:47 Welcome back to The Messy City Podcast. 0:48 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:50 One of the issues that has been in the news a lot, especially I would say the last couple of years, has been the whole question of property taxes and property taxation. 1:02 And rightfully so, because in many communities, we've seen a real explosion of costs related to property taxes and a lot of concern and controversy surrounding And it's kind of inspired a whole lot of varied responses across the political spectrum, 1:24 across the ideological spectrum about like what to be done about all this. 1:29 Is this a good thing? 1:29 Is it a terrible thing? 1:32 What could possibly be done? 1:34 I think I'm probably gonna spend, I'm probably gonna have a few podcasts where I dive into this issue with some different perspectives, but I'm really grateful today To have Jaime Azurieta on the show. 1:47 Jaime has been on here before. 1:49 He has a terrific firm called Storefront Mastery. 1:52 But beyond his work with helping cities and downtown districts and others succeed, he's also just a really brilliant and deep thinker on a variety of issues and has a great Substack called the Vertical Sidewalk. 2:08 Is that Vertical Sidewalk? 2:09 Is that right? 2:10 Yeah. 2:11 And he is somebody that I've known and talked with for a while on a variety of things. 2:18 And I'm really, we're here to talk property taxes and we'll get into why shortly. 2:22 But Jaime, welcome back to the show. 2:25 Thank you so much. 2:26 As always, great to be here. 2:28 Sadly, we're not in Kansas City, so we cannot go, you know, food hunting, but let's close and this is good. 2:35 Well, you'll be back soon enough, one of these days. 2:39 So what really inspired me to reach out and have Jaime back on the show, you may remember I had him on last year when we were talking about, especially about retailing and trends in retailing and downtowns and experiences. 2:53 But he wrote a piece recently on his Substack, The Vertical Sidewalk, that's called When the Levee Breaks, that he says, subtitle, a few facts I'd like to throw into the dumpster fire discussion on property taxes. 3:06 This is an incredible deep dive and thorough analysis really of kind of how we got to where we are today on property taxes. 3:18 And I found it incredibly fascinating. 3:21 Some really interesting history on property taxes. 3:24 What led to the system that we have now today? 3:27 And so I wanted to talk about that because I think it's important to have the historical background before you can start to think about different ways forward. 3:37 And so Jaime, I think I'm gonna throw it to you right now and say, let's talk about why did you, first of all, why did you wanna write this piece? 3:49 Okay, that is a wonderful question to start. 3:53 Why do I want to write the piece? 3:56 First of all, I try to question things from the outcomes perspective, not from the intentions perspective. 4:05 And so we have this system that is the system that is allowing us to fund cities and to fund good things that cities can offer their residents. 4:21 And then there's this story in the city where I live, which is Montclair, New Jersey, that had an interesting pit of money that they found, $20 million in debt for the school district. 4:39 And the only solution that they found Was asking the taxpayers if they would want 4:48 to increase their taxes to pay for one time for whatever was already spent and to increase their taxes permanently for new spending that was already committed. 5:02 And paying all taxes won, paying the new taxes forever did not win. 5:08 And so we start thinking about $20 million doesn't just appear from one day to the other. 5:15 $20 million is a lot of money for a school district to have committed in one of the school districts that spends a lot of money per pupil. 5:26 I think it's over $26,000 per pupil that they spend here. 5:31 And so you start questioning. 5:34 You start questioning the The responsibility, not of individual school board members who are, by the way, elected democratically here. 5:45 You don't start questioning their decisions. 5:47 You start questioning the mechanisms that send taxpayers' money to a decision-making machine that sometimes doesn't have the best interest. 6:01 Or I shouldn't say that because they probably do have the best interest in mind. 6:06 Make decisions without knowing all the facts, probably. 6:09 That's probably the gentler thing to say. 6:12 When you start questioning that, when you start questioning and thinking that I, not me, but people pay a lot of taxes and they would want to see that money go to the best possible places to be allocated in the best possible ways. 6:30 And that doesn't happen all the time. 6:33 So I'm thinking of all these things, and I'm thinking of the big conversation that we've had for a while on the difference between property taxes as we have now and land value taxes as a more efficient way of levy, of charging taxes, and also the... 6:53 The initial thought about LVT, that would be the tax to replace all taxes. 6:59 So there's been a lot of conversation of different ways of taxing people. 7:04 Some places tax people for sales, and this is how they fund schools. 7:09 In Michigan, I believe there's a statewide system that turns sales taxes into school taxes, so they are not tied to... 7:18 To homeowner's taxes. 7:20 There's other states where this also happened. 7:24 So I started digging and I found some incredibly interesting historical facts about property taxes. 7:31 And I said, okay, if we question things and we talk about things and we open painful and difficult conversations, we might end up at the same place where we are now. 7:46 But the place where we end up will be a very informed place. 7:50 So the decisions that we make have to be informed. 7:54 If we are making the best ones right now, that's awesome. 7:58 But I think there's a lot of information we do not have. 8:00 And we should have and we should include in the conversation. 8:03 And we don't know what the answer is going to be. 8:05 We don't know what the final solution or final answer is going to be. 8:08 But whatever that answer is, is going to be an informed answer. 8:12 This is why I wrote the piece. 8:15 Yeah, and it parallels other conversations we've had related to things like zoning and transportation funding and all of these things where, you know, we have a way of doing things now that when you grow up with it, 8:32 you exist with it, you just kind of think, well, this is just the way it is. 8:36 And this is probably the way it's always been. 8:38 Or it's this way for a variety of good historical reasons. 8:42 Yeah. 8:43 And so we tend not to question a lot of the underlying thinking behind the way things are. 8:50 And I think it's also worth noting, you know, kind of as you allude to there, there's no one universal approach for property taxation in the United States anyway. 9:03 There are some states that are very heavily reliant on property tax and very minimal on sales tax. 9:08 And there are some places that are the opposite. 9:11 There are some states that are very flexible, that have home rule, that allow, you know, a wide variety of solutions. 9:17 So there's not a one-size-fits-all. 9:18 There are some pretty common practices. 9:21 But why don't you start talking about some of the things that you learned when you looked at the history of the system that we have now and kind of trace a few of the steps that got us to where we are. 9:34 I think the first thing we need to establish is that we are having two conversations, two different conversations when we talk about funding cities. 9:45 One of the conversations is How do we raise revenue to fund for whatever the city is going to do? 9:55 This is where property taxes actually come. 9:59 When we fund cities, we can do a wide variety of things, one of which is levying property or the value of property and Getting revenue from there. 10:11 And then the other conversation, which is related, but it's not the same conversation, is how are we going to provide those services? 10:19 How are we going to provide the schools? 10:21 How are we going to provide, I don't know, sewers and streetlights and roads and all these things? 10:34 It's two different conversations, related but not the same. 10:36 And this is more or less the framework to the story, the historical account that I would like to make. 10:45 So for probably the past 5,000 years, taxes have been levied on the production of land. 10:55 And this is a very important distinction. 10:57 Right now, they are levied on the assessed market value of a property, whether that property is where you live and it's your homestead, or whether you have it just to make money with it, to rent, or to have your business there, 11:20 or to have some sort of manufacturing production, whatever, in that land. 11:25 It may have an output or it may not have an output, but it is assessed on the value of that land. 11:34 For the past 5,000 years, it was not like that. 11:36 It was assessed on the production. 11:39 How much does your land make? 11:41 I will take some of what your land is making. 11:45 This is how it started in Mesopotamia. 11:48 In Egypt, in many, many places. 11:52 I think the first 11:57 times when we started levying taxes according to the assessed market value of the property was in Chicago in the 20th century, I believe. 12:12 So I'm trying to look right now to exactly what the... 12:18 What the date was. 12:21 And of course I can't find it, but yeah, I will find it because I have the piece pulled up here to remind me of any numbers that might be relevant. 12:33 So the whole idea was that when the US started, it was mostly privately developed. 12:43 Most of the roads we have right now that connect cities that right now are internal roads in our suburbs, And many of those, which are still today named turnpikes, these were private roads. 12:57 These were private toll roads that were, yes, they had a charter from the city, state, county, whatever, but they were privately built and they were funded with tolls. 13:11 And the vast majority of roads were built this way. 13:15 And there's a number that I will give you right now, which is... 13:21 In New York State, between 1790 and 1821, the state spent about $620,000 on roads and bridges. 13:32 And conversely, private investors spent, where is it, $11 million into turnpike companies, which built roads, and about a million dollars in bridges. 13:45 So you see that it was a disproportionate 13:50 These were for profit. 13:51 These were not saintly, priestly, non-profit organizations that this is for the goodness of their heart. 13:57 These were motivated by profit. 14:00 And most of the roads that we have right now are following those initial roads because they were, of course, carved through the easiest places that... 14:11 That connected different cities and those were reliable. 14:15 Those allowed people to expect things, allowed business owners to plan things and were dependable. 14:24 And so they could They could make plans in the long term, and when you make plans in the long term, there's a way of creating wealth and growing the economy and doing all these things. 14:36 And this was way before we had centralized authorities that planned and built roads. 14:44 The US only has an income tax, for example, from 1913. 14:50 Before 1913, there was no centralized income tax, and there were roads, and most of those roads were privately built. 14:59 And there's so many instances that are similar. 15:02 The New York City subway, for example, about 70% of the track miles that they have right now, currently, were built when the system was private. 15:11 Then there was a little bit of turmoil and the system was absorbed by a government company. 15:18 And then the government company became the government agency, which is what they have right now. 15:22 But initially it was built for profit. 15:26 In Seattle, there's a very interesting area in Seattle and you have two neighboring train stations because they were built by two different rail companies that were private and were working for profit and had two different railways. 15:39 So there's tons of examples of things that were built and that started and that were funded before we had these levies on the market value of properties. 15:52 So if I look at your piece, it looks like it was 1818 was Illinois adopted the first state constitutional uniformity clause requiring property to be taxed by value. 16:05 And then you noted by the end of the 19th century, there were 33 states that had adopted similar uniformity clauses. 16:12 And by 1902, property taxes comprised 68% of combined state and local revenues. 16:19 So just really about 120 years, 120, 130 years old, the system that we have right now. 16:28 Correct. 16:28 It's not an old system. 16:30 And the... 16:32 The incredible growth, I think, and you will correct me if I am wrong, that the time where the US had the most growth was between Reconstruction and 16:45 the First World War. 16:46 Yeah, that's right. 16:48 This is insane growth that the US had during this time. 16:52 And this is when these uniformity clauses were being adopted and property started to be Levied by its assessed market value. 17:03 What happened during this time is that, of course, labor started to be divided and people started specializing. 17:11 And when I specialize on something, I have less time to think of what I'm going to eat tonight. 17:17 So I need someone to cook for me. 17:19 I need someone to bring the carrots and the oranges and the beef for me, because if I do that, I will not have the time to, I don't know, invent the theme engine or something like that. 17:30 As we get more specialized, we need to focus on different things. 17:35 And the production on the land is not something that, I mean, you need to detach from that in order to invent new things and create more value and get some progress and growth. 17:49 It is just a normal process in which people are not producing much on their land. 17:55 So there needs to be some other way of finding revenue. 17:59 It's only logical that states would start adopting these uniformity clauses. 18:03 And then we go into another conversation, which is how much is your property worth? 18:08 Is your property worth what the assessor says? 18:11 Is your property worth what the comps say because your neighbor sold it at $1 million and your other neighbor sold it at $1 million and your property has a similar size and similar size of building? 18:23 Does your property cost or the property value is $1 million? 18:28 We will never know until you sell it. 18:31 You might sell it for $500,000 because you have a need. 18:35 The economy might just be destroyed and wiped out one day, and then your property is suddenly worth $200,000. 18:42 But you've been paying taxes on an assessment of $1 million. 18:45 And that is, like I said, a different conversation because we go into the territory of unrealized gains. 18:52 There's no other way of doing it. 18:55 There's no other way of doing because the only way is to have an assessed value and levy taxes according to that assessed value. 19:02 Because otherwise, if you're going to every year, you're going to go and even if you did every year, every month, you go and do comps and you go and do whatever market value. 19:11 There is no way of knowing how much that property is worth if the property has not been sold. 19:17 When the property is sold, then there's a profit. 19:20 If I buy a property in the year 1985 for $45,000 and sell it in the year 2026 for $950,000, then there's a huge profit that I have made. 19:32 And then, yes, by all means, let's tax that. 19:36 But then if you don't sell the property, there's no way of knowing how much that property is actually worth. 19:41 It's only a speculative value that we use to assess it. 19:47 That's another factor of the conversation. 19:48 We have three things now. 19:49 We have number one, are property taxes the best way to fund a city? 19:55 Number two, is the centralized way of the local government to provide services, the only way to provide those services, roads, transportation, schools, buildings? 20:09 Systems like sewers and streetlights and everything. 20:13 And then the other one is how are we taxing these things? 20:17 Land value taxes kind of solves the third question because land value taxes are it's a different kind of scheme than just saying your property is worth this much. 20:28 There's a much more complex calculation and there is. 20:32 I suppose a much fairer calculation because the land value taxes, what they are taxing is the potential of the land. 20:40 Yeah. 20:42 I want to come back to land value tax a little bit and Henry George, but I think it's important to level set like you had there and talk about what was actually happening. 20:53 In the era where we came up with the system that as we largely know it today, and there really was a lot happening. 20:58 So we had the Industrial Revolution happening, as you mentioned, we had the first wave of mass immigration to the United States. 21:08 So just complete and utter change happening. 21:11 That spawned also the creation of universal public school systems, where we sort of imported the German model for public schools. 21:26 And if you think about what your property taxes pay for, and again, this can be a little dangerous for generalizing because I know it's so different from place to place, but in the two counties that I have lived most of my life in, one in Missouri, one in Georgia, 21:42 the vast majority of the property taxes goes to the public school district. 21:46 So somewhere around 60% to two thirds. 21:50 And I'm sure that's different in other places, but I don't think you can talk about property taxes necessarily without talking about public schools because they're so deeply intertwined. 22:03 So that's an element. 22:04 So when we start to talk to the question of what is it that we're paying for, what are we levying our property to pay for, that's a big thing. 22:14 One of the things that I found the most interesting in your piece as you traced it was sort of going back a little bit before that Industrial Revolution period was, as you had talked about, the history prior to that of assessing property was really based more 22:33 on assessing property that produced income. 22:36 Correct. 22:38 And that's fascinating because that really then you made a great point here to that society changed. 22:45 We went from a roughly agrarian economy where most property produced income to an urbanized society where a lot of property is not producing income. 22:57 And so the assessment, certainly if you steel man it, the assessment idea at the time was we have to change how we're assessing things because of that. 23:06 At the same time, there's a direct tie to that element and the conversation that's had today very often, which is people feeling like they never actually own their home because there is permanent property tax assessment on it. 23:22 And if you don't keep up with it, you forfeit your home to the government. 23:27 And there have been some court cases about this. 23:30 And it's a major source of sort of political interest and controversy right now. 23:37 So I wonder if you could talk a little bit about that history, a little bit more about tying the assessment of property more directly to income production. 23:47 Yeah. 23:48 Essentially, all land was productive at some point. 23:51 If you lived in a feudal society, the way that the Lord had to come and levy taxes from you and send the evil sheriff of Nottingham to get whatever they can from your property, it was production. 24:07 So you would give them grain that you have produced in your property. 24:13 You would give them animals that you have bred in your property. 24:16 This is what you had to give. 24:18 Because the systems of trade were not as complex and evolved as we have right now, that I can pay you using cash that I have received for different transactions. 24:30 It's very, very complex and we're using cash as a more evolved system of trading. 24:38 But in that in that time, there was less trading because you had to produce for subsistence and you had to give as much as the Lord demanded. 24:50 So that is what and before that, of course, it was the same before the feudal system. 24:56 It was the same. 24:56 It was you produce something and you paid something to the king or to the pharaoh or to whoever. 25:03 So. 25:04 That is easy to collect. 25:07 It's easy to assess the thought process that is required to assess the levy from someone who has, let's say, an X number of acres of land and has produced 1000 sacks of grain. 25:24 Oh, you have 1,000? 25:26 Okay, I will take 600. 25:27 That is easy. 25:28 You're seeing the 1,000 sacks of grain and you're taking the 600 and you put them on a horse and move them into the castle. 25:37 Easy. 25:38 As we get more complex, It gets harder and harder and harder because people stop, people diversify. 25:46 Engineers start working in different things and the complexity of those things that they are working do not mean that they will get paid, for example, every month. 25:59 If I am working in a project that it will take me a year from idea to completion and to start selling, there's going to be a year where I am not getting any income. 26:10 What is going to happen when the government comes and wants to levy what I produced? 26:16 I haven't produced anything yet. 26:18 I have zero production. 26:20 So the revenue that they're going to get from me is going to be zero. 26:24 So they have to find another way. 26:27 And they have to start looking at what is the lowest hanging fruit. 26:32 And I will keep saying this lowest hanging fruit thing because it is basically a lowest hanging fruit of... 26:40 The land is there. 26:41 The land has a value. 26:42 People can buy and sell land, so it has a number. 26:46 I can see it in a piece of paper. 26:48 I can see the number, so I can see the 1,000 bags of grain, and I can take my 600 bags of grain. 26:57 So it is, again, lowest hanging fruit and it's easy. 27:00 So the transition is only logical because the economy is changing, because it's diversifying, because people are not working on the land, because people are working on longer projects. 27:10 Your long project when you are in an agrarian economy is you... 27:15 Put the seeds at the beginning of the winter, those seeds are dormant, in the spring they come out, the fall comes, you sow them, and you exchange them. 27:27 So the cycle is very, very small. 27:30 It's very short. 27:31 Whereas if you have projects that are more complex, the cycle of investment and return is going to be much longer. 27:39 And it's going to require a lot more resources. 27:42 It's going to require pooling of resources. 27:44 It's going to require getting people together. 27:46 And it's going to require a much more complex train of thought to actually establish those projects. 27:52 The revenue from the land then decreases exponentially as the revenue from other sources and from different kinds of work is increasing also exponentially. 28:03 So it's only logical that the lowest hanging fruit is how much is your land worth? 28:08 I can see it on paper. 28:09 I can take some of it on paper. 28:11 Easy. 28:13 What is not easy is when it probably gets out of hand, we can say. 28:19 Some states, like the state where I live, Property taxes in some places can reach 30, 40, 50, 60, $100,000 of property taxes. 28:31 And these are properties that are, yes, the property values in a high value state like New Jersey, of course, they're going to be higher than what you can find probably in some places in Michigan or even Kansas. 28:43 And Missouri, but the amount of the final tax bills, which is what's important for a family that receives it, are very, very high. 28:54 So if you want to keep increasing those to fund more things, it's going to be hard. 29:01 And the expectation of whoever has that property is going to be even higher. 29:06 And so... 29:08 Different types of work appear, different types of rewards for work that has nothing to do with the productivity of the land are appearing. 29:16 And so it's completely detached right now. 29:19 It's completely detached and you are just taxing Land from an assessed value that has nothing to do with productivity. 29:29 There's a straight line where productivity of the land goes down, productivity of the people goes up, and then at some point, we're just extracting value from property that's there dormant, being someone's home. 29:41 And when that someone is not making any more money, when that someone loses their job, when that someone dies and leaves a widower or a widow, 29:52 What happens with that property? 29:55 The value of the property in paper doesn't change, but the income of that person completely changes. 30:01 And if we force them to move, if we force them to sell, if we force them to do something to pay for the taxes, which is kind of ridiculous, They lose their community. 30:12 They lose their ties to their hometown. 30:16 And if you do that to elderly people, it's not great. 30:20 And we tend to say, yeah, elderly people, they are super, the boomers are super rich and they can afford everything and they're just extracting Yes, there is a very rich percentage of boomers who are doing this, but there is a huge majority of people, 30:36 of elderly people, who are not in those higher quintiles. 30:41 The people who cannot afford property tax increases that they cannot even afford if property taxes are $2,000, $3,000, $4,000, it's impossible for them to afford in fixed incomes because Social Security payments, of course, they are not million-dollar payments. 30:58 If you are in the segment of that population that has bought property, bought stocks, and became incredibly and insanely rich, yes, it's peanuts for you. 31:08 But that's going to be a small percentage. 31:10 The bigger percentage is going to be the people who are going to be struggling. 31:14 Well, and it's like you mentioned before, there's a difference between thinking about the cash that you have to spend because of your income or whatever assets you have available to you versus the unrealized gains, you know, which is something that looks really wealthy on paper, 31:29 but really it's hard to access. 31:31 Correct. 31:35 Has over several decades spawned homesteading exemptions, Prop 13 in California famously, and all sorts of efforts to either exempt certain groups from property tax increases or severely limit them. 31:54 So that's sort of been one reaction to this issue over many decades. 32:03 I think... 32:05 I think the stats that have been used to create those programs are probably not the best ones that they could have used. 32:12 We have a program here in New Jersey, which I think is called Stay New Jersey, Stay NJ, that is for seniors who have retired and cannot afford any more property taxes, and they have huge credits. 32:25 People, young couples, young families. 32:27 I mean, my own family, we don't own a house. 32:30 We haven't been able to afford a house. 32:32 And I don't know if we will be able to afford it because prices keep going up. 32:37 New Jersey is just crazy with housing prices. 32:39 So elderly people get those exemptions because of their age. 32:48 Other people do not get the exemptions because they are not of a certain age. 32:53 That I think is working from the assumption that, I don't know, elderly people cannot pay their taxes, which is as bad an assumption as the other one that I was saying before. 33:05 Elderly people are super rich and they can afford anything. 33:09 And other places, Florida, for example, has a homestead exemption where if you live in your property, I don't know if it's 100% exemption. 33:19 I don't think so. 33:20 But it's a huge chunk of your property taxes that are discounted. 33:28 It's really very hard to come up with something that everyone will agree on. 33:35 I think, again, to circle back to the LVT, I think that is probably one of the fairer ways of calculating. 33:44 It doesn't necessarily account for people who just want to grow old and die in their homes. 33:52 I mean, if you want to do that and you're in a land value tax system, it's going to be really hard because your old house could hold a... 34:02 Building that is mixed use and that can be worth millions of dollars and you have your old three bedroom house where you want to grow old and die. 34:10 You cannot do that. 34:11 Because the property tax is going to be super high because it's a land value tax. 34:15 And you are in a place that has gained tremendous value. 34:19 So I don't think there's a fair way of doing this. 34:22 I don't think there's a fair way of creating exemptions that are going to make everyone happy. 34:31 What I do know is that just levying property taxes is the lowest hanging fruit. 34:39 There is a way that many places have attempted in different ways to 34:48 get money from, for example, there's a very good example from Brazil. 34:53 They have what they call the value capture. 34:57 So, for example, the We need the planners for this. 35:01 The planners come and they say, okay, this is what we are going to do. 35:04 We're going to create this area of growth in the city and we are going to create these roads to connect the jobs to where the people live. 35:11 It's a whole huge plan and this is how much it's going to cost. 35:16 And private developers are going to do this. 35:17 We are not going to do this. 35:19 The government, we're not going to do this. 35:20 Private developers are going to do it and they have to come to us and they have to purchase credits. 35:26 For development. 35:27 However much they purchase, this is the revenue that we're going to have. 35:31 And they are going to build and they are going to profit from the land according to the plan. 35:36 And they are going to do everything that we have planned. 35:40 And they are going to purchase the credits to build whatever they want from us. 35:44 And this is a tremendous way of funding government for social problems, for social programs, for schools, for whatever they want to spend the money on. 35:57 And it's going to be paid for by the private developers who are building the infrastructure. 36:02 So this is in the piece, by the way. 36:05 I think it's called in Sao Paulo, in Brazil. 36:10 It's a very good example of how they did that. 36:13 They do it in business improvement districts all over the country where they have small assets. 36:17 Yes, they are tied to property taxes, but the point is that they are assessing only commercial property. 36:23 They are assessing only property that is producing value. 36:27 So if you have a property, and that also, by the way, is a wonderful, wonderful incentive to keep your property productive and not closed and not vacant. 36:38 There's a lot of people who keep property vacant for different reasons. 36:41 And the majority of those reasons are not because I want a tax write-off, because that is just losing money. 36:49 And nobody buys property to lose money. 36:51 But there are incentives for people to keep their property vacant. 36:55 If you are assessing property Property taxes only to commercial properties in commercial districts, then there is a huge incentive to get a tenant and get that property into production very fast because you're going to be levied a big tax anyway. 37:13 So that is a thing that can be looked at. 37:16 There's a great thing that they did in... 37:19 In Taiwan, to fund their high-speed rail. 37:22 This is a tiny country, but still, they have a high-speed rail that connects from north to south the entire country, and they have their cities. 37:29 They have only a couple of cities on the ocean side. 37:33 Most of the cities are facing China, and so it is easy to connect via a single high-speed rail line. 37:42 What they did is they... 37:45 Took the property. 37:45 They did a taking of the property around where the stations were planned. 37:49 And these are farms and these are villages, whatever it was there. 37:55 They took that property. 37:56 They did what it's called a parcel reorganization. 37:59 So they actually replotted the land to create street, create the stations, and to create commercial districts and everything. 38:07 And then they sold those rights to that land. 38:11 It's not a freehold. 38:12 It's a leasehold. 38:13 They sold the rights to the land. 38:15 And so developers came and built whatever they thought was going to get them profit. 38:21 Commercial centers, shopping centers, and of course they built the stations. 38:27 And they also built housing. 38:29 And the former owners who had been expropriated, they got housing in those same districts. 38:36 And so now you can have a... 38:39 Big tracts of land that are being productive, that are being taxed, and that are also funding the high-speed rail. 38:47 So you don't have to subsidize the high-speed rail because you have these huge commercial districts that are producing incredible, incredible profits. 38:55 And those profits are being reinvested on the trains and also property taxes are being paid anyway. 39:01 So they can have other urban services. 39:05 And the people who are expropriated, they also got housing in the same area. 39:09 They have huge projects, what they call urban operations, 39:17 and they don't take a couple of years, they take 10 years, 15 years. 39:24 It is, you know, it's not easy, but it is a way of funding progress in cities that doesn't have the straight line from, you have a property, I will tax that property, and I will fund stuff with whatever I have to do. 39:42 Yeah. 39:44 There's some other, I think, similar examples around the world. 39:47 And I think Hong Kong had built their subway system in a similar, somewhat similar fashion. 39:51 There was state ownership there that was a little bit different, but it was really sort of a value capture proposition. 39:58 And to help with the ongoing financing of it. 40:01 You know, one thing that I was thinking about Jaime is that, I mean, you can't talk about the system we have without talking also about it was sort of bound up in the progressive movement of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. 40:16 And a big part of that rationale was we could kind of figure out scientific and technical solutions to everything. 40:22 And we would hire these sort of nonpartisan experts. 40:26 Who would act in a very unemotional way and establish rates that are fair and they're applying scientific methods to everything. 40:39 I live in a county that has had two incredibly controversial property tax assessments or reassessments done in the last six years with massive issues. 40:54 Increases in property assessments, which leads to much higher taxation to the individuals, to the businesses, and incredible amounts of protest, you know, at the county courthouse and so forth. 41:09 Yeah, I think that's a good question. 41:28 It's not scientific or technical. 41:30 It's often very arbitrary in terms of taxation. 41:35 There are, in fact, individuals who influence decisions that are made about assessment levels. 41:42 So as part of your two-part system, the assessment level and the millage levy, All of those are handled very differently and very politically. 41:51 And a lot of it really kind of depends on the personalities and the views of the human beings involved. 41:57 I don't think we can kind of set that aside in this discussion that 42:05 we're not having these things operated by AI in a robotic fashion that is giving us a clear-eyed path on exactly how to do. 42:13 It's operated by humans and human systems. 42:16 And that has led to a lot of the controversy and dissatisfaction that people have around the issue period. 42:25 I don't think it has much to do with people operating it from a discretionary perspective or a computer operating from a completely non-discretionary perspective. 42:39 It's... 42:40 If you set rates and you say, I don't know, if you make over $80,000, you will have to pay full fare for something. 42:55 If you make less than $80,000, you will have a subsidy. 43:01 Okay. 43:02 So what happens if I make $79,000? 43:05 I get a subsidy. 43:09 And if my neighbor makes $81,000, they don't get a subsidy. 43:15 The unfairness of that is very complicated in my point of view. 43:23 So I think there's fair ways. 43:26 I think there's I think the more you start to think about exemptions, individual exemptions, or the need for individual exemptions, then this is where systems stop being manageable and fair. 43:43 Because the more exemptions you feel you need to have, the more people are going to be unhappy with them. 43:51 Why does this person have this and I don't? 43:54 Just because they make $1,000 more than I make or just because my property has a corner in the other district, then I have to pay more? 44:03 Something like that. 44:04 So I don't think those are inherently fair. 44:09 So this is what I'm proposing to go and look from a higher perspective and find, yes, if the system needs so many exemptions, could there be another system that doesn't require so many exemptions and that is inherently... 44:28 Flat and fair and everyone just has an opt-in, which is a basic number. 44:35 If you make 100,000, you pay 10,000. 44:37 If you make a million, you pay 100,000. 44:41 I'm sure there is a way of figuring this out. 44:46 I cannot tell you, but what I can tell you is that we need to have the conversation. 44:49 We need to have the conversation of 44:54 That particular idea of the more exemptions your system needs, the worse thought out that system is. 45:03 Yeah, and I think kind of what I'm getting to is just, it's a little bit of the arbitrariness of setting assessment levels, period, and values, kind of like you mentioned earlier, that somebody has to set a value for a piece of property for this system to work. 45:21 And how the hell do you set that value accurately? 45:23 Well, you know, it's nearly impossible to do so. 45:27 And you think about that compared to, you know, for example, like a sales tax model. 45:33 A sales tax model, you don't need... 45:35 You don't need a whole department of people to decipher what the tax rate is and what you pay. 45:41 You know exactly, you spend this amount of money, you pay this, and then you're done. 45:45 Whereas this is, I think, a huge challenge, even with the land value tax model, is somebody has to analyze and set rates. 45:54 And as long as we're doing that, we're going to have a lot of controversy, I would think, about what those rates are. 46:01 Does that make sense? 46:02 It makes perfect sense. 46:04 And it gets into the conversation of value. 46:06 What is value? 46:08 So if I am, let's say it is the month of January and I am standing in 46:22 Orlando, Florida, and we are on the phone and you are standing in Anchorage, Alaska. 46:32 And we are both at a jacket shop, and we are looking at jackets. 46:40 And I am looking at the same jacket you're looking at, and that jacket has a price of $250. 46:46 And I say, $250 for a jacket? 46:49 I'm not going to spend $250 for a jacket. 46:52 You are in the middle of Anchorage, Alaska, looking at the same jacket, freezing to death. 46:56 Are you going to pay those $250? 46:57 Easily. 46:57 Would you pay $500? 47:01 Probably also easy. 47:04 Would you pay that amount of money if you were in the same Anchorage, Alaska Street in the middle of August? 47:11 Possibly not. 47:13 So their value is incredibly subjective. 47:17 Value varies from person to person. 47:21 Value varies even the same person in different circumstances in their lives. 47:26 People assign value to things because they see what those things are going to do to them to improve their lives, to provide them some entertainment, to do anything that that object, that good, that idea, that anything that they would pay for would change their lives. 47:47 If we start talking about value, does a person who is assessing the value of my property Have the same idea of how much my property is worth than I do. 48:00 There's a very interesting meme that says it's six pictures of very, very different houses. 48:06 And it goes, how I see my house, how the tax assessor sees my house, how my wife sees my house, how my wife sees my house. 48:15 And it's very, very different ways of seeing my house. 48:19 And how my house is is a completely different thing because When the tax assessor comes, they will say, oh, this house is a very high quality house. 48:29 I should tax it more. 48:31 And you will see the house and say, yeah, but it's crumbling down. 48:36 The roof needs a new roof. 48:38 The foundation is cracking. 48:40 And there's going to be a disagreement there. 48:42 There's not going to be agreement because the value, the way we see the value of that object is going to be completely different. 48:49 So then... 48:50 When we are assessing the value of taxes, when we are assessing the land value, when we are assessing the amount and we're designing the property tax, it is completely discretionary. 49:03 And that is, I'm sure there has to be a better system. 49:08 I am not, and by the way, parentheses, I am not for abolition of property taxes. 49:14 I am not for the Right now, it cannot be for the abolition of property taxes because we do not have an alternative. 49:21 And we do need to fund things in cities. 49:24 Things need to be built. 49:26 Things need to be fixed. 49:28 Services need to be provided in cities. 49:30 So we cannot just go and boom, abolish. 49:32 That would be impossible to do. 49:34 But the conversation, what the conversation should lead to is what are we spending that money on? 49:40 How are we... 49:42 Raising those funds, are these the most efficient ways? 49:46 And what is, if any, an alternative to these things? 49:53 Yeah, yeah. 49:55 So feel like we could do a couple hours more on this because there's just so much here to talk about. 50:06 And I even think about it from the standpoint of 50:12 Just as a homeowner, you feel so helpless about the property tax issue. 50:17 Like in my county, the county can reassess our value up 15%. 50:26 Whenever they want to, and we can't even appeal. 50:29 Like if it's 15% or under, we can't appeal. 50:32 It's just automatic. 50:34 And I don't know what it is in other places. 50:36 I'm sure it's different all over the place. 50:37 But there's this real frustration that the taxing jurisdictions can kind of get whatever they want. 50:44 And you as a homeowner have very little recourse other than maybe picking up and moving somewhere else, which, you know, most of us, frankly, just that's like you don't really want to move because of the taxes. 50:57 You probably chose a community for a lot of different reasons. 51:01 And so that's an area of frustration. 51:03 I wonder if I want to tie this to some other stuff that you've written. 51:07 You've written a number of pieces for Southern Urbanism. 51:12 About America 250 and sort of tracing the history of, you know, various aspects of the American experiment. 51:22 Let me give you a harder question. 51:23 As you think about the history and intention of the American project from the beginning, and especially... 51:33 You can't disassociate the American project without thinking about property. 51:39 The individual ownership of property is a massive part of the history of our country and the appeal of it. 51:48 How do you think about a property tax system 51:54 that is a better fit for how we as Americans see that sort of sacred right of ownership? 52:06 That is a very, very good question. 52:11 First of all, we have to think about property. 52:13 And 52:16 one thing that we need to agree on is that property is the basis of civilization. 52:26 When I have property and I get the incentive of making that property better and getting something out of the work that I put into that property to make it better, that gives me the incentive to think of grander and bigger and more innovative things to do. 52:47 And this is in a very, very, very dumbly explained nutshell. 52:54 Property taxes are the basis of civilization. 53:00 When we start constraining what those rights are, then we are not necessarily stopping civilization, but we are making a dent and There's so many things that make a dent in the basic pillars of civilization at this time that it's kind of death by a thousand cuts. 53:30 I do think that respect to property should be paramount. 53:35 I do think that when you... And there is laws to prevent you from stealing property. 53:44 There's laws to prevent you from misusing property. 53:48 There's laws to prevent you from using property to harm others. 53:52 Those are already there. 53:53 We probably do not need specific laws to be added to whatever this huge code of laws in America that we have now. 54:03 And each one of those is taking a little bit of the foundations of civilization. 54:11 I... 54:14 I think the fairest ways of doing things are that we live with the consequences of the things that we do. 54:24 If I want to purchase a Bentley, I may go and purchase the Bentley. 54:30 Will I be able to afford the insurance? 54:32 Probably not. 54:34 Will I be able to afford the new tire if it breaks because I'm driving on a city that has a lot of potholes? 54:41 Probably not. 54:42 Will I be able to afford the ad valorem taxes that I have to pay every so many years? 54:49 Probably not. 54:50 Will the car turn into an unusable pile of rust because I am not able to wash it and buy the expensive leather products that I need to keep the seats? 55:04 Probably yes. 55:06 Is it wise for me to buy a Bentley? 55:07 No, it's not. 55:11 I guess everyone needs to realize that it is very hard to extend beyond our means and whatever property we have, we need to cultivate, we need to use it, we need to make it as productive as we can. 55:27 And that is incompatible, I guess, with just general blanket assessments that take a little bit of that property under threat of Foreclosure, because that is in the end, if I don't pay, I'm going to get foreclosed. 55:43 That's it. 55:43 Right. 55:44 So I think use taxes can be the best way. 55:53 So if you're using your property for like a homesteading rule, if you're using your property as your primary residence, you are not getting any money from that property and you're living there with your family, then you should get a Big or complete exemption. 56:10 If you're using that property to make money, okay, how much money are you making? 56:14 Whatever money you make from commercial property, this is how much I'm going to tax you. 56:19 I'm going to tax you for the value of the land when it's commercial, and I will tax you from the production of the land. 56:25 And if your production of the land is zero, then I guess... 56:30 Your property taxes are going to be too high because there's mechanisms for calculating land value tax. 56:38 And if the property is commercial, I think that's fair game. 56:41 I think that's absolutely fair game because someone is purchasing property So I see that as something that's probably not ideal because it will still 57:12 Take some of that property value. 57:15 I don't think that it should be done on 57:20 the threat of foreclosure. 57:23 I think there's better ways of doing it. 57:28 I think it should be opt out of services. 57:31 If you don't want to pay for a service, you should opt out. 57:35 And then the conversation about services that are... 57:39 That are impossible to opt out from. 57:41 So if there's streetlights outside and I don't pay my taxes, I'm still getting the light. 57:47 But there's ways of differentiating different services. 57:52 There's ways of assessing Let's call it taxes for uses. 57:59 And there's just different systems that we can learn from history that are tied to the production of the land. 58:07 And that is the key to the whole thing. 58:09 If your land is productive, then there's many ways of getting some of that value that you've created to provide services. 58:19 And if you're living in your property, that should be your castle. 58:23 That should be your... 58:24 I think there's actually the... 58:27 There is, I'm going to say the Fourth Amendment. 58:30 That is the castle doctrine. 58:32 This is your home. 58:33 They cannot take your home away. 58:35 In some states, if you get sued, for example, for malpractice, they cannot take your home. 58:40 They cannot make you sell your home to pay for whatever you have assigned to pay from that lawsuit. 58:48 And I think that signals an utter respect for property rights. 58:54 That is what is the basis of civilization. 58:57 So... 58:58 In order to keep building, in order to keep growing, in order to be able to provide more for more people and to provide massive value, which is what we need right now. 59:06 We need our cities and our states to provide opportunities for entrepreneurs to create massive value and to make sense for developers to come and build more property and And if you think of it, property is downstream from productivity. 59:28 If you're a developer in a place that doesn't have a moving or a dynamic economy, you may lose a lot of money from building because there's not going to be enough demand for whatever you're building. 59:40 If you are a developer who's building in a place where there's massive demand, you are probably most likely going to get a lot of profit. 59:49 Different ways of providing services, different ways of providing value, those are the things that could be taxed instead of your homestead, your castle where you live with your family. 60:01 And this is the only place where I'm talking about that there should be exemptions, by the way. 60:06 It's the only place. 60:07 It's your paid off home where you live with your family, that is your primary residence, and that's it. 60:14 Yeah. 60:18 And that is not making any money for you. 60:20 And you get one of those. 60:22 And you get one of those where you live with your family and that's it. 60:25 If you have another one, dude, that's going to get taxed because you're not living there with your family. 60:29 Because that one, if you have another one, that's probably making some kind of money. 60:34 And if not, you should make money from that house. 60:36 And when you make money from that house, I'm going to tax you. 60:39 So the exemption is very, very limited to homesteading. 60:45 Primary residents paid off and not making any money. 60:49 Yeah. 60:51 Well, Jaime, I think it's a really interesting time. 60:55 There's more discussion about this issue and all of its various permutations than there has been in my lifetime. 61:03 And I think that's probably springing from a lot of dissatisfaction, With the property tax system and rates and housing affordability, as well as, frankly, a lot of probably higher dissatisfaction than we've ever had 61:18 with public school systems and real frustrations with government services in many, many cities and towns and counties. 61:29 This seems like fertile ground to really think about what we're doing and why and try to optimize whatever systems we have. 61:38 I think what you have laid out here, especially with the background on how we got here is really incredibly important. 61:44 And I appreciate everything that you've done to get us to this point. 61:50 Thank you so much. 61:51 I think to end with a reflection, I suppose the big reflection is we, 62:00 We cannot say that our current system is the best system. 62:04 We cannot say that it is not. 62:07 And that is where the whole conversation is based on. 62:13 We cannot say that it's the best system and we cannot say that it's not the best system. 62:17 So let's have the conversation. 62:19 Let's talk about alternatives. 62:21 Let's explore history. 62:23 Let's explore facts. 62:26 Let's dispel myths. 62:29 Because most of the conversation for and against property taxes, for the abolition and against the abolition of property taxes is based on myths. 62:39 And you asked me at the beginning, and this is a very good way to close it full circle. 62:43 You asked me at the beginning, why did I decide to write this? 62:47 And I guess, yes, I was curious. 62:50 I was looking, I was reading, I was investigating. 62:52 But the main thing is that I have read such... 62:59 Infantile and dumb arguments for the abolition and against the abolition on both sides that do not stand the test of minimal fact checking, do not stand the test of common sense, do not stand the test of history whatsoever. 63:17 Pretty much do not stand any tests. 63:20 So let's have the conversation in a civilized way. 63:24 Let's have the conversation based on actual facts. 63:27 Let's try to understand the facts. 63:30 Let's try to read the numbers as they come. 63:34 And let's do it with an open perspective, with an open mind to maybe we figure out that our current system is the best. 63:44 There's no way to improve it. 63:46 That may be the case, but we do not know this. 63:49 So let's have the conversation. 63:52 Well, that's a great way to wrap it up. 63:54 You can find Jaime on Substack at the Vertical Sidewalk. 63:58 He's also a regular contributor to Southern Urbanism magazine, which is a really terrific collection of great writers and everything else exploring a lot of issues. 64:10 So Jaime, thanks so much for joining me again. 64:15 It's great, as always, talk to you. 64:16 Thanks so much, Kevin. 64:17 It has been great. 64:18 All right. 64:19 Take care. 64:20 You too. 64:23 Farewell. 64:26 Farewell. 64:29 Farewell. 64:29 Farewell. 64:30 Farewell. 64:31 Farewell. 64:33 Farewell. 64:35 Farewell. 64:36 Farewell. 64:55 Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, Farewell.
Community discussion