0:04 For nearly 20 years, Christopher Vaughn has been serving four consecutive life sentences for the deaths of his wife, Kimberly, and their three children. The state said Christopher murdered his family and then staged the scene, but Christopher has always 0:18 maintained his innocence. As the country follows the Lindsay Clancy trial and confronts an unbearable question, whether a mother in the midst of profound psychiatric illness can kill her children, another question comes into sharp focus. Did investigators in Christopher 0:35 Vaughn's case fully examine that possibility? In a case where the mother did not survive to explain what she was experiencing, was a difficult possibility dismissed before the evidence was allowed to lead? Today, I'm joined by renowned defense attorney Robert Mata, 0:54 who attended every day of the Lindsay Clancy trial, as well as my friend and journalist Lauren Breypacheco, who's reporting on murder in Illinois, has done a deep dive into the extraordinary case against Christopher Vaughn. So, Bob, Lauren, welcome. 1:11 Thanks for being here. 1:13 Thanks for having us. 1:13 Thanks for having us, Jason. 1:15 I'm really looking forward to this conversation because it's a vexing case and it's captured the imagination of the American public in a way that few others have in history. Lauren, you and I have been working on the Christopher Vaughn 1:31 case for several years now. You made that extraordinary podcast, Murder in Illinois. I have no doubt in my mind, and the evidence proves, in my opinion, that Christopher Vaughn is, in fact, innocent, but he's been in prison for 19 and a half long, miserable years. 1:50 It's actually the reason why Bob and I connected as well, because Bob has a tremendous and very involved following with his Defense Diaries podcast. And they wanted his take on Christopher Vaughn. And so when Bob reached out, I said, 2:05 have at it. I sent him everything, the full discovery. 2:09 He got back to me and it very much shifted your meter. And Bob has sat with Vaughn as well. 2:17 I have. I have. 2:18 In person. 2:19 Wow. And I want to hear about that too. And, you know, the issue at hand is the technical term is maternal filicide, right? It's not a term you hear often. 2:28 Many people probably hadn't heard it until now. Almost everyone that's watching and listening to us now is familiar with the Lindsay Clancy case to some degree, but they're probably not familiar with Kimberly Vaughn, Christopher Vaughn, and the countless 2:45 other cases that mirror this, which have had wildly different outcomes and wildly different verdicts, sentences, you name it. Can you give us a summary of the Christopher Vaughn case so we can start to have a conversation about how these are connected? 3:01 Absolutely. So on June 14th, 2007, the Vaughn family were traveling on an impromptu early morning trip to a water park. 3:11 And Kimberly Vaughn, who was experiencing migraine headaches and was on two specific medications to handle those migraines, tapiramate and nortriptyline, And she was found after the murder to have low near toxic levels of nortriptyline. That's important to remember. From 3:31 what the investigation knew, the family pulled over because she was experiencing nausea, which was in keeping with the migraines and the reactions to the medication. Christopher Vaughn claims to have gotten out of the car to check on the 3:47 luggage rack so as to give her some privacy. The three children, so Abigail, Cassandra, and Blake, who were 12, 11, and 8, I believe at the time, were asleep. This is in the pre-dawn hours, basically, before 6 a.m. And 4:05 all three were shot at point-blank range. Now, Christopher Vaughn claims that he heard this cacophony of sounds in keeping with gunfire in a small contained space. He ran to the passenger door. 4:21 I pulled the door open. I was looking at Kim holding the gun. My mind was just reeling. I just couldn't understand what was going on. She looked at me and she said, she says, she says, she says, you won't take my kids away from me. You killed them. 4:40 And then she starts firing a gun at me. And that's when she turned the gun on herself. 4:46 She shot him twice. One shot ricocheted off of his watch on his left wrist, but the other shot went clear through his upper left thigh. And it came within, take your pick, either a hair's breadth of blowing off his sexual organs or severing a major artery. It is 5:07 not a kind of self-inflicted shot that a man would happily make. In other words, it wasn't pressed against the leg. 5:16 It was done at a distance. Kimberly Vaughn was found in the passenger seat. Her safety belt was removed. And the shot is in keeping with having been firmly pressed underneath her chin. The gun was ultimately found by the 5:32 feet in the passenger seat. And the original crime scene investigator, Bob Diehl, had put Kimberly Vaughn as suspect number one and Christopher Vaughn as suspect number two because his feeling was the bullet trajectory and the way in which Kimberly 5:49 Vaughn's shot was fired was all in keeping with murder-suicide. 5:54 As the only surviving member of that family, he was immediately the suspect, and that never wavered. 6:04 There was no indication that Christopher Vaughn was any sort of criminal mastermind at all. He was just sort of a regular guy who suffered the worst imaginable fate, like to lose your family, your whole family, and then be sent to prison for the rest of your life for 6:21 a crime you didn't commit. So the parallels in these two horrible cases are extraordinary. So much so that my understanding is that you basically emailed each other simultaneously when the news broke. 6:38 The day it happened in real time as it was hitting the news feeds. And I do want to say, I think it's very important, we are in no way, shape, or form vilifying Kimberly Vaughn. But it is important to note the parallels that you mentioned. And Kimberly was experiencing 6:59 behavioral changes that were in keeping with the levels of medication that were being adjusted. Two weeks before this horrible tragedy, she has an email with Chris in which she said, I spoke to the doctor. I told him about the 7:16 personality changes that we've seen. So these were very real. 7:20 Her children had confided. One of her daughters had confided to a friend that her mother was acting crazy and that she was talking to people who weren't there. keep in mind this is almost 20 years ago. We're at a very different understanding in terms of medications and the 7:38 reactions to them, but also the stress of motherhood and the acknowledgement of that. 7:44 And we covered this when we did the Dr. Phil show together in this case, that one or both of the two medications that Kimberly was prescribed were blackboxed for having been found to cause suicidal and homicidal ideations, right? 7:59 I mean, like, Jesus, that one comes with instructions right there. 8:02 I mean, it gives me the chills to think about it. 8:15 When this little synchronicity happened, when you guys both immediately thought of each other and immediately connected the dots, what was the most profound sort of connection that you felt between these two cases. 8:30 When I was looking objectively at Lindsay's case and having a deeper understanding of what happened or what we believe happened with her, and I started thinking immediately in terms of Chris and Kimberly's case, because the thing that really 8:46 turned me was when Lauren disclosed that Kimberly was on those two pharmaceutical drugs. And I thought it was profound. 8:57 And I realized in short order that what had gone on with Lindsay was very similar in a lot of different ways to what had happened with Kimberly. And that kind of connective tissue for me immediately made me start thinking about Patrick in the role of Christopher Vaughn, except 9:21 a different factual scenario because it's Lindsay survived, whereas Kimberly didn't. 9:28 And it was the same thing in my estimation that was probably going on with Kim. And this concept of women's mental health became an imperative for me. For me, it was a thing that I thought that we could try to take this opportunity out of this awful case 9:52 to push a narrative forward that will pull women's mental health and how it's dealt with in society in general out of the Stone Ages. I thought there was an opportunity to re-evaluate what happened in Chris's case and compare 10:08 and contrast the difference between those two cases and the similarities, which I think are, frankly, stunning. 10:15 I think it's... And this is my... layman's perspective, I'm not a psychologist or an expert on psychotropic medications or anything like that, but as a human being and as someone who had a mother and a father and kids of my own, the impulse for us in a case 10:36 like this, and sadly they're not that uncommon, it's easier for us to point to the dad and say, A. 10:45 Thousand percent, but that goes in keeping with our societal expectations and interpretations of women and motherhood. You know, there are no shortages of examples of, you know, going back to Medea, you know, going back to Andrea Yates, going 11:03 back to Susan Smith. We know that it can happen, but we have this archetype of the mother, and it is very difficult. We will do mental acrobatics to figure out some way to not blame the mother even in a case like Lindsay Clancy where she confessed there is 11:24 no shortage of conspiracy theorists all over the internet who are still trying to ultimately blame Patrick and that was when Bob reached out to me we both had this feeling that is it possible that the biggest difference between 11:40 these two cases is that Lindsay Clancy survived. Had she not, would Patrick Clancy be Christopher Vaughn? 11:51 Quite possibly. And it's, I mean, it upsets the whole order of the universe when a parent buries a child. 12:01 It's a tragedy that I think it's impossible for almost anyone to imagine. 12:08 Someone has to be held accountable. 12:10 Because if that's true, then it could possibly happen to them, their grandchild, their niece, nephew, somebody they love dearly. So it's just, it's almost like a fallback to say, well, if there was a bad guy, then that's not likely to happen to me or my family. And so it's 12:30 comforting in some weird way. Patrick had to bury all. 12:35 Three of his kids. 12:36 And then. 12:37 he all of a sudden finds himself in the glare of the internet spotlight of these people who want to make him the villain because somehow or other it gives them some either feeling of comfort or what, I don't know. 12:56 But there are... these theories, Bob, you and I have talked about this, that have been floated. Well, what about the missing timeline? I think you can look at any event in history and come up with all kinds of things that you go, wait, that looks a little odd, right? So, 13:12 can we just quickly go through some of these things? 13:16 And if you can debunk them, and if anyone can, you probably can, then please do, because I think it's an important thing for us to cover. 13:22 When the Patrick Clancy theory started kind of developing online. 13:28 And specifically, I think it was probably on TikTok more than anything else. 13:32 He was a bad husband. He took too long to get to the drugstore. 13:37 That kind of thing I was fine with in terms of, you know, if you're going to have judgments about his ability to be able to handle what was going on with his wife and being critical of that, that's fair. 13:47 But it turned much uglier, much quicker in terms of People were literally coming up with the concept that he had done this and somehow had framed his wife for it. 13:57 And married a woman who looked just like Lindsay. 14:00 Oh, yeah, that's a big one. 14:02 You know, but it was actually three years after the fact. 14:04 And I don't think any of us, I think we would all agree, I'm never going to judge somebody in terms of how they process trauma ever. 14:11 Or grief. 14:12 Or all different human beings. What kind of started coming out, like you were talking about with the timeline, in terms of was it possible for him to have done it? 14:21 I'm going to back up just a bit because the problem that we get in a lot of cases that all of us deal with is terrible police investigations, law enforcement investigations that are awful from the get. And if that's due to confirmation bias, if it's tunnel vision, it 14:39 was the same thing here. They jumped to a conclusion based on what Patrick had told them because Lindsay couldn't speak. 14:47 It was entirely based on Patrick's recount of what had happened when he got home. Him discovering this nightmare scenario that was going on in his home. Patrick had said that when he got to the house, discovered it was quiet, 15:01 went upstairs, doors locked, opened the door, sees the windows open, sees blood on the ground, runs outside, finds his wife laying under the window. She can barely talk. She's crushed her thyroid, her pancreas. spine is shattered. She's now paraplegic. 15:18 And by all accounts, all she could do was kind of grunt and groan. When he got to Lindsay, he had asked her what happened. She said to him, I tried to kill myself. He then said, well, where are the kids? And she said, well, they're in the basement. So, 15:31 and those were things that he testified to that she said to him. Physiologically, that doesn't seem like that that could actually happen in terms of the injuries she had sustained. So, I think if you kind of like stretch it out and think about what he was going through at that 15:47 moment in time, there's a pretty reasonable explanation in terms of how our mind is going to try to process that kind of trauma. 15:53 That it's going to connect the dots. It's going to. 15:56 Right. 15:56 You're going to fill in the gaps or, you know, whatever you observed might be something that you think that she said to you. Who knows? My mind would crack in half. I walked in and my four children were dead. 16:07 You know, I have four kids. It's as a father and as a mother, you know, trying to come to grips with what that would be like in that moment is impossible. We can't even bring our mind to it. 16:18 In reality, we could conceptualize it maybe, but we can never understand what it would feel like. In my position as a content creator, but lawyer first and foremost, was like, I'm not going to give this oxygen. As you stated, I'd flown out and I was covering the trial and 16:33 I had a friendship with Kevin Reddington, her attorney. And my position on it was We're talking about an old war horse attorney who's been doing it for 50 years. 16:44 And if you watch that trial, you see what type of lawyer he is. He is a highly competent attorney in that courtroom. And there's no way that any defense attorney, when they get this case and it lands on their desk and he was involved immediately. If you don't think 17:00 that he would have looked into Patrick Clancy as a possibility of being the culprit in this thing, you're out of your mind. I mean, that was the first thing he would have done. He has a client. that at some point was able to speak again, who he obviously 17:14 had conversations with, who had some recollection of what happened. 17:19 So that concept of, one, you've got an attorney who has a client who's speaking and has memory of what happened, and two, that he would have looked into any possibility that he could have pointed the finger at Patrick Clancy as opposed to trying to run a not guilty by 17:35 lack of criminal responsibility case, which is always possible. It's always a defensive last resort because it's the hardest defense to convince a jury of. And you saw it here and you see it in every not guilty by reason 17:49 insanity case. There's a cognitive dissonance that happens with jurors where they're like, okay, they did this horrible thing, but I have to utter the words or mark off not guilty on a piece of paper. And I can't bring myself to do it because of the horrible act. They 18:08 just have a very difficult time separating the act from the responsibility, the criminal responsibility aspect of it. And in this case, you know, which again was another thing that I was thinking about with Chris. It's this thing where 18:24 people just have this inability of being able to accept the concept that a mother could do that to her children. 18:31 It's like that mama bear concept is. 18:34 And I want to point out that so did Christopher Vaughn. 18:37 They questioned him for, I think, 17 hours over the course of the next few days. Initially, he was questioned in his hospital gown, bleeding through his leg. 18:49 Question is a kind way to put it. 18:51 He was interrogated, and they were showing pictures of the kids, and he defended his wife throughout. because even he could not understand. It was so not in keeping. Well, if she did have some kind of medically induced psychosis, that 19:09 is the only thing that would have made sense to him, but they didn't understand that at the time. So he said she would never do this. She would never hurt the kids. So even as he's being interrogated, even as they're lying to him and telling him that they have 19:24 footage of what happened, and they know exactly because of video cameras what transpired, he is still adamantly defending his wife and begging for them to explain what happened. 19:36 Yeah, there's almost a sort of nobility in what he did. 19:41 And people may get mad at me for saying that, but the fact is, he had an out, right? If he was some sort of mastermind and they portrayed him to be, paid him to be, the first thing he would have said is, yeah, she did it. I saw her do it, then shot me twice, almost blew off 19:59 my private parts. I mean, it's logical, right? But the idea too, that They interrogated this poor man, this grieving father and husband. 17 hours in this hospital, guys want to let that linger for a second, right? And then 20:17 to make matters worse, they arrested him at his kid's funeral. 20:22 A perp walk of the highest order. What does that do to the optics? When you know that someone's been arrested at his children's funeral, there's no presumption of innocence, right? 20:35 There's none. And so keep in mind that then, Vaughn, this happened in 2007. He was up against the death penalty, and that wasn't taken off the table in Illinois until 2011. 20:45 Had it not been, we wouldn't be sitting here talking about it because Christopher Vaughn would likely have been executed already. 20:51 So when Vaughn walked into that courtroom in 2012, it was with the full weight of guilt. He had already been raked through the coals. in public forum and media. 21:06 It was a done deal. There was no presumption of innocence, but I would argue that there was none from the beginning. 21:12 A day after this happened, put forth the narrative that Vaughn was a criminal mastermind. And first of all, what criminal mastermind would have chosen to annihilate their family in an SUV on the way to a water park? It's 21:27 just beyond. But the state's attorney- James Glasgow said, according to Bob Deal, who was a 25-year crime scene investigator at that point, when Deal pointed out, no, no, no, no, I'm telling you, at some point that gun was in 21:46 Kimberly Bond's hand. James Glasgow turned to him and said, don't you ever say that again. She was an angel and she never would have held a gun. And from that moment, Deal was removed from anything that had anything to do with the case. 22:00 Sick. 22:00 Well, that is the definition of tunnel vision. There is no presumption of innocence. 22:06 I think tunnel vision might be too kind because it starts to sound like, wait, you're being confronted with evidence by an actual expert who's saying, hey, boss, that's not the way this went down. And you're going, shut the fuck up. 22:19 It's that insidious thing that you were talking about where we need a bad guy. Somebody's got to pay for this. 22:24 And he needs to solve the case because it's good for his career. I mean, you know, this is a high profile case in a relatively small community, right? Huge case. 22:33 But then confirmation bias takes care of the rest. They didn't have a great marriage. They had issues within the marriage. 22:41 He had gone to strip clubs. There was a case of infidelity. So all of these things then snowball. And that is what they had. There was nothing other than circumstantial evidence at best, but there was no evidence within that car that backs up Vaughn having fired those shots. 23:04 There was gunshot residue on everybody, but it was on Kimberly Vaughn's hands. They never bagged and tested Vaughn's hands. 23:13 I want to go back to the Lindsay Clancy situation. 23:16 You raised this before, that one of the things these armchair sleuths are clinging on to is, oh, he went and started a new relationship with someone who looked something like, I don't know how close the resemblance really is. People 23:31 can disagree on that. Okay, fine. So maybe he has a type. I don't know. And I don't care. Who are we to judge? Like, by the way, you know, and I think you'd mentioned this before, Lauren, like whatever you're going to do with that grief is your business 23:45 and none of mine. And I think if people can, in general, let people be and stop trying to insert themselves in places they have no business being and maybe try to develop some empathy rather than feeding this sort of urge that you have to pin, assign, blame. And 24:10 it cuts across various other aspects of life as well. 24:13 But I think this is a pretty profound example of that. 24:16 And so now you've debunked A couple of the major things in the Clancy case, it's some of these conspiracists or whatever, these Patrick. 24:25 Guilters. 24:26 Guilters, yeah. 24:27 The biggest thing for me is that if Reddington says there was nothing there, it was a nothing burger. 24:32 I implicitly trust him as her attorney in terms of his ability to be able to try a case and do what he has an ethical duty to do, which is to investigate the crime. And there's... zero doubt that he did all of that. Had this investigation been anything 24:52 beyond putrid, we wouldn't be having this discussion as to Patrick Clancy. I mean, there is a drawer, a bedside stand drawer filled with pill bottles that somehow the cops didn't find. Reddington, two days after he's hired, goes in 25:11 with his PI. They're looking in the house when the scene was cleared. He pulls this drawer open filled with medical prescription bottles. He's like, holy shit. He's like, they didn't take this? He calls up the prosecutor. He's like, yeah, 25:25 I found a drawer full of drug bottles. Everything that happened was indicative of an awful investigation when you have an awful investigation that leaves a huge, wide gaping hole in terms of evidence. And the lack thereof creates a 25:44 All kinds of issues moving forward. We see it all the time in our wrongful conviction work. I mean, you get that confirmation bias, you get the tunnel vision, and then you compound it with a shitty investigation. And it's trying to move mountains to get the things undone. And 25:58 we can always look back to the investigation or lack thereof as one of the major culprits of that. And it was no different here. But the problem in this case is that that resulted in Patrick starting to take heat online. To the point where the guy's life is. 26:14 The narrative wrote itself. Surviving husband. 26:18 New wife. Looks just like Lindsay. Moved on too quickly. 26:22 All that, yeah. 26:34 There are a few things that I hope will result from this episode that we're doing together today. One is I hope that people will leave Patrick the fuck alone and that he can live out his life in whatever way he wants and try to find some peace. I 26:53 don't know how you ever do it, but I wish it for him with all my heart. I also think it's important that we are shining a light on this issue. 27:02 I hope that people who are professionals in this field will be more quicker to make moves that they might hesitate, well, they did hesitate to do in her case, whether that means removing a parent, a mother, or, you know, caregiver, whatever, 27:22 who is suffering from this type of psychosis or whatever the technical term is, until they can figure out what's going on. And then maybe another family won't be decimated in this way. And I hope also, and I want to talk about this, it's such an important thing and 27:41 it cuts across all the work that we do, is the aspect of racial bias in this case. And we know there's rich people justice and there's poor people justice. 27:49 And there's the famous saying in America, it's better to be rich and guilty than it is to be poor and innocent. But I'm talking specifically now about skin color, right? 27:58 We know there are many cases of women of color who have experienced similar postpartum issues, whether or not they're triggered by medications or just physiology, whatever it is, those women don't typically get the same type of attention or outcomes. 28:18 Yeah, that's for certain. 28:20 People can look up some of these other cases where women of color are serving life sentences. 28:26 Well, oddly enough... The very judge who was sitting on the Lindsay Clancy case was overturned on a woman of color named Latarsha Sanders, who was convicted for killing her child or children. He had made the decision not to allow, 28:42 I think it was because of a late disclosure, medical records to come in, which obviously in a case like that would be very important to look at her medical history. 28:51 Her conviction was reversed and it was remanded for a new trial. So she's going to get another shot at justice for her. But it's symptomatic of exactly what you're talking about. I mean, anybody who in any way, shape or form objectively and with intellectual honesty looks at our 29:09 system of justice in this country knows that people of color who don't have the resources have no shot at defeating the government in this country. And that's facts. And it's disproportionate as to the representation they can afford. The 29:25 treatment they can get in hospitals. Everything goes back to the systemic issue of racism in this country. And it's undeniable. 29:36 And it's a hill that I'll die on every day. 29:39 It also is fodder for headlines. You know, unfortunately, there is a voracious appetite if you have an affluent white family that has had this kind of tragedy. That's what happened with Vaughn. That's what's happened with the Clancy case 29:59 as well. You know, we have these preconceived notions of what people are capable of. And unfortunately, media coverage tends to favor whether it is a missing person case. If it is a attractive white female, it's going to be everywhere. 30:18 Of course. 30:19 You know, that is going to bump everything else out of the lead headline. 30:26 We can't control the media. The media is going to do what they need to do to get clicks. 30:30 That's just it. It has a voracious appetite for what it thinks are central casting, tragedy befalling somebody. 30:38 What they declare to be newsworthy. I could walk down the street here in Manhattan and ask eight out of 10 people, ask them the question if they could tell me anything about indigenous missing and murdered people. And not one of them would have a fucking clue that it 30:52 was even a thing. And that's why I'm a big fan of podcasts and YouTube channels that elect to spend their time and energy on trying to push stories that matter to educate people into the realities of what's going on in our world. They're important, and they make a difference. 31:12 And it allows the cases to be retried in the court of public opinion in a very different way. You know, I would love nothing more than this. to have people revisit the Vaughn case. We have had incredible difficulty securing 31:32 legal counsel. We've all spoken about it. Unfortunately, there have been attorneys who have attached themselves to it for bragging rights, for publicity. Christopher has adversely been impacted that people have interest in it, but in terms of actually having somebody 31:52 do what you did, which was the actual work of digging through it, he deserves justice. 31:59 And by the way, Dr. Phil, no lefty, no softy on crime or anything you want to call that. He featured the case on his show. He put his reputation on the line. He doesn't do that without doing a ton of due diligence. But he went and did that 32:15 episode and encouraged people to go pull it up on his website, whatever, and see for yourself. And you'll see the evidence on there that this is actually an impossibility, right? 32:26 I mean, you can say and think what you want, but when you look at the actual evidence, Christopher couldn't have fired those shots. He couldn't have fired the shots that killed his family. 32:36 Your generosity funded the crime scene reconstruction, and it was a physical impossibility. Everything that transpired in that car in terms of the blood evidence was in keeping with the story that Vaughn finally shared in 2019. 32:54 So we're looking for the right representation for him. If anyone out there is open to it or interested, reach out. 33:04 We're not hard to find. 33:05 And I would have them start with Bob Deal, the crime scene investigator's deposition. That lays it out entirely. 33:13 Yeah, there's no question about that. When you think about it in that framework, there's no fucking way that he's doing what we're talking about. It's the diametric opposite to think that, all right, I want to go live this life. 33:29 whatever wildlife thing. 33:31 Off the grid. 33:32 Off the grid. 33:32 So I'm going to shoot myself through the leg before I do it. 33:35 But beyond that, I'm going to get rid of my family. 33:37 And the way that I'm going to elect to do it is I'm going to decide to say, hey, let's go down to a water park to St. Louis, wake my kids up at 430 in the morning and decide to do it on the side of the road where there's no other person that could possibly be blamed other 33:50 than me. That makes no sense. So What I'd suggest if there's any attorneys and I'm available, you can find me through Defense Diaries podcast. I am very easy to find online and I'd be happy to talk to you about the case at length. But if you're going to 34:07 think about doing this, what I'd ask you to do is strip away the narrative and ask yourself, what evidence did the state have to prove that he was guilty of committing these crimes beyond a reasonable doubt? And I'll submit to you, it does not exist. 34:24 And it was tried in the media, right? And we know that in these cases where it is tried in the media, and of course, Amanda Knox is a notable example of that, probably one of the best known examples of that, but it's almost impossible to get a fair trial. 34:37 And these family annihilator cases are generally tried in the media. 34:41 And where are you going to find a juror that hasn't seen something? It's next to impossible. If you do, they might be a shut-in, and I'm not sure that's who you want on the jury either. But so yeah, we need to find representation for Chris. And Lauren, if 34:55 you and I have to, we'll just go to law school and do it ourselves. You know what? 34:58 I actually joked with Chris about this. I said, had I known because we did this podcast in 2019, I would have gone to law school. I could have been through. 35:10 I feel that strongly in his innocence. And this is a travesty of justice. I've always said that the only thing that could be more horrible than what happened that day is is that the wrong person is serving four 35:24 consecutive life sentences after losing his entire family. It's a travesty. 35:31 It's the hardest thing about the case from the timeframe that we're currently in with it in terms of post-conviction work is it's got to be actual innocence. We have to prove actual innocence, which is going to be the challenge. 35:46 We were talking about other attorneys that have looked at it. 35:49 There was one thing that This particular attorney said to me that was pretty profound, which I think really accurately depicted what was going on in that car. He's like, there was a third person, and that was Kimberly on 36:00 the drugs. It wasn't Kimberly not on the drugs, which, again, is the parallel between Lindsay Clancy. 36:07 It was postpartum psychosis. 36:10 But also on 13 different pharmaceuticals that had been prescribed by medical providers who weren't looking back at her medical history. 36:18 That's a whole thing. That's another episode that we should do in terms of women's mental health and how that's been viewed and treated in this country in particular. Because if you look at the UK, there are light years ahead of us in terms of how women that are 36:33 going through it in terms of postpartum depression and or psychosis are treated. 36:37 Because they have a team approach to working with it when you're going to different practitioners and getting prescribed different things by five different people. It's, you know, you have seven different limbs. 36:48 Yeah. 36:49 That's the thing with, with Kim to restate this concept that we are not in any way, shape or form attacking Kimberly. If it's big pharma to blame, that's who I'm pointing my finger at because I believe wholeheartedly that's exactly what happened here. And I don't blame the woman 37:05 who was prescribed that medication by a doctor who had some pharmaceutical rep saying, and here's the shit you're pushing now. 37:12 Yeah. 37:13 And then come and speak at our conference and you'll get a nice, uh, a nice payday and a nice vacation. 37:18 I mean, I'm not throwing shade at all doctors, but certainly that's a factor in American society. It shouldn't be, but that's the way it's evolved. And you don't have to take my word for it. You know, look it up. 37:31 It's really nuts how that is, you know, a reality of our situation. It's like, you can't do it more wrong than that. And I think, Lauren, you were talking earlier too, and I want to come back to this. 37:42 You're the only one here who That's a mom, obviously. 37:45 You brought up the idea that for women who are in this haze, this postpartum state of non-reality, well, you could say it better than I can. 37:58 It's statistically proven that if a mother gets to the point where she is contemplating self-harm or taking her own life, that statistically, they will make the decision to take their children with them. 38:15 To spare them. 38:16 To spare them because they're ultimately trying to protect the children or that is the last tether, the ultimate obligation that they have before they leave this earth. And it is tragic. Unfortunately, I think it's also very important to 38:30 bring education and awareness to this. What Lindsay Clancy said, experienced was not a question of just being overwhelmed by motherhood. 38:42 She was actually having audio hallucinations telling her to harm herself and her children. And so, When it becomes social media fodder where you have a bunch of women saying, I am Lindsay Clancy, I hope to hell they're not 39:00 because postpartum psychosis is not understood. There's not enough education. 39:06 There's not enough awareness. And there needs to be that awareness. 39:09 Because we have to remove the shame from it. We need to take this seriously. And I don't think that the reaction that we're seeing unfold in real time, as well-meaning as the support may be, it's not taking it seriously. 39:26 It feels a little gross. 39:28 If anything, it is. 39:31 Not doing it justice. 39:33 Well, I think that the problem is that when you're actually speaking to the women who are supporting her, it's being misconstrued and reported in a different way than it actually exists. And I was talking to you guys about 39:47 this off-camera bit right now. a woman named Lisa Tremaine, and I'm going to shout her out because she deserves it. 39:54 She's going to change the world and I'm going to do everything in my power to help her do it. 39:58 She's got these PMAD centers, which allows women to go in because what the problem is, is that women that are going through this because of everything that exists in the world, the stigmatization, the repercussions of being able to 40:12 openly and honestly report fully what you're going through. It causes women to under-report, meaning that they're not going to say everything I'm going through because of fear of, I'm going to get Baker Act. I'm going to lose my 40:25 kids to DC. Judgment. All of it, but beyond judgment. 40:30 But I'm talking about losing your license to be a nurse, everything. 40:33 The ramification for a situation that is temporary and treatable. 40:39 We're not talking about regular psychosis. That's the difference. That is the thing that people need to come to grips with. 40:46 And the reality is that most people's idea of what psychosis is based on TV and movies. When I sat there in that courtroom and watched the Commonwealth of Massachusetts sit there and talk about invisible unicorns in the corner, I about lost my fucking mind because what that does 41:04 is it just keeps pushing this ridiculous narrative. What organ in our body is more important than our brain? At what point in time are we going to decide, you know what? This is the thing that we need to be figuring out what the fuck to do with when 41:19 it goes wrong. And we just don't give a shit. 41:22 So for me, that's been really my mission statement with this case. And I'm passionate about it, as you can see. 41:30 But if we had one of these PMAD centers where what they do there is they bring in the mother and the child. It's outpatient. They will treat. They bring them in. If you're on Medicaid, they don't care. There is no, no one is pushed away. No one is 41:44 turned away. They bring them all in. Lisa Tremaine and her staff, which is unbelievable. And they treat them all the way through. They come in, they incorporate the families. 41:53 They incorporate the medication and the schedule of medication they're going to take. They have psychiatry, everything that you would need to get you through that thing safely with your child so that you're not losing the mother-child bond. That's 42:06 so very important. This place, the things that she's doing, she's an amazing person. We're going to get one of these built in every city in the country. It's going to save mothers' lives. It's going to save children's lives. 42:17 And what a brilliant idea. It's amazing. And we'll link to that as well. That's an incredible resource, and I hope people will take advantage of it. 42:23 And why it's taken so long to get here is beyond me. So if there is, unfortunately, any kind of silver lining of covering such horrible cases like this, it is raising awareness. 42:37 And maybe we can prevent these things from happening in the future or some of them from happening in the future. 42:42 And I'm so glad you brought that up. That sounds extraordinary. 42:47 I mean, yeah, of course. Let them be together. I mean, duh. 42:51 That is exactly the response I had. 42:54 Is there a website or something people can go to to learn more about that? Instagram? 42:58 I'll give all of the contact information for her. We'll have it listed. 43:02 Okay, great. 43:02 For contact for her and the PMAD. 43:04 It's so important. 43:06 We have a couple minutes left. And I would like to, first of all, thank both of you, Lauren Breypacheco, Bob Mata for being here. It's been extraordinary for me. I learned so much from you and I appreciate it a lot. 43:20 And I hope we've really made a difference, not just in these cases, but in the general landscape. So now it's up to you to take a speed round. Bob, why don't you go first and we'll let Lauren take us off into the sunset. 43:36 I think that the takeaway from this episode, I hope, is number one, that people will take another look at Chris's case under the understanding that what happened with Kimberly wasn't her fault. And this isn't a situation where we're 43:55 pointing the finger at Kim and saying, you're the bad guy. 43:58 She's not. If, in fact, it went down the way that we believe that it did, there's a different culprit. 44:04 And it's the same culprit that I believe played a strong, strong part in what happened with Lindsay Clancy. I just think that this is a very good opportunity for people to be able to revisit that case while also gaining 44:21 a greater understanding of what's going on with women's mental health in this country and trying to push both of those things forward if at all possible. 44:30 I agree. And I also think that We need to be a little more nuanced in the narratives that we accept as absolute truths, not just in terms of a mother's ability to do something that we deem completely heinous and out of character, but also how easy it is 44:53 to vilify the surviving spouse. And we saw it definitely with Christopher Bond, but we're seeing history repeat itself again with the vilification of Patrick Clancy. So I would say that we need to hold ourselves to a higher level 45:10 when it comes to really exploring the presumption of innocence and factual evidence and how that fuels the narrative that we are fed, not just in the media, but unfortunately in courtrooms as well. 45:26 Well said. And thanks again for being here and for all you do. We'll keep the pressure on. We're not going to stop fighting, Chris. If you can hear our voices, we're not going to stop fighting for you. And Patrick, we're sending you our best wishes as well. We wish you peace. 45:41 Absolutely. 45:41 Absolutely.
Community discussion