0:06 Welcome to Unspeakable, a true crime podcast where I tell stories of real crimes with real victims, whose cases are so shocking that many are left wondering how is this even real? I use my experiences in law enforcement corrections, and 0:25 combined with my years as a criminal justice educator, dig deep into complex cases of evil acts, some so evil many feel they are unspeakable. Warning. 0:51 Unspeakable as intended for mature audiences. If you are easily offended, then I'm not your girl. Listening discretion is advised. Hey, y'all, kJ You're back for another episode of Unspeakable. What's going on, y'all? I have 1:03 been working my rear end off on this live show that's gonna be coming up this week. I am so excited. I have researched my little fingers to the bone and I'm gonna put on a good show for you. So I'm excited. I can't wait to meet everybody that's coming. And if you're not 1:18 coming, do not worry, because we are going to release an entire series on the Derek Toddlee serial killings in Baton Rouge. So you if you can't make it, no worries. I'm gonna break it down. I'm gonna tell you more than you probably ever wanted to know, but I'm gonna do it 1:34 for you, so no worries. But if you're coming, cannot wait. 1:37 It's gonna be fun. Remember food, trucks and drinks and merch and camaraderie, right, So, I can't wait to see y'all there. I'm gonna jump right into this story though today, and this one's gonna take place in 1:47 two thousand and one, and it's gonna involve a twenty five year old named Amy Saint Lawrence. And Amy was described as a hard working and independent minded New Englander, and she was full of life, and she wanted to live 2:00 life to every extent of the word. She was someone that just would not settle for average. She wanted all of the color and all of the sparkle and the fun. She wanted all of it in her life. And she was described by her friends as someone that just wanted more in every sense of 2:17 the word. And Amy had always been driven. She had goals that she wanted to reach and even as a teenager, she was, you know, financially responsible. She worked at a Donkin Donuts on Broadway in South Portland all 2:32 throughout high school. She was so she was a committed employee, and they thought she was great. She was very intelligent and charismatic. But to her, 2:43 even though she was a high schooler, high school just seemed bland. 2:46 You know, it didn't spark any imagination. She didn't feel like she was growing in any way. It was more of like the rat race of life. 2:53 Just show up and you know, go through the jump through the hoops and then get your degree. And to be honest, I've seen a lot of kids even today that feel like that. You know, it's like it's not inspiring. It doesn't make you think, it doesn't make you grow. 3:05 It's like I just have to show up and punch the clock and you know, check the boxes. And that's pretty much how Amy felt. She just thought it to be flat out uninspiring. You know, she would graduate though, 3:16 she would graduate high school in nineteen ninety four with honors because she was a smart girl. But when asked about you know, how was you know, what was it? Like, how do you feel you're graduate? She just was kind of like, I guess it was great. I don't feel 3:31 like I accomplished much. I mean it was easy, you know, it was boring. It was I don't know that I've done some grandiose thing like people make it out to be. So she did have plans to go to college, and she was hoping that it would be this huge boom in life, 3:47 right and she would really get to start experiencing things. And she prayed to God, you know, please don't let this be like high school, because if it was, my God, the next few years are about to be pretty boring. But a few years after high school, she ended up 4:00 finding a job as a third shift assembler at the Pratt and Whitney aerospace manufacturing plant in North Berwick, Maine. And she wasn't by herself while this was happening. She was dreaming of this life, you know, she was dreaming 4:15 of this life together with her boyfriend at the time. His name was Richard Sparrow, and together they moved to South Berwick so her commute would be shorter and she could excel at her new job and really, you know, be 4:25 firmly planted in the area where she was working. And the employers noticed her from the get go, you know, they saw things about her that not everybody has. She was a self starter, a consummate, professional which didn't 4:40 go unnoticed, and soon she advanced. It had her in a junior level administrative position, and she was proud to work there. You know, this was this was going to be almost like a career for her. She was 4:53 really proud to work there. She was always sporting this favorite sweatshirt of hers. 4:58 It had the name of her agency across the front of it, and she was so proud to work there. She didn't care if anybody knew it either. She sported that shirt with, you know, just a smile on her face. So while Amy and Richard had talked about marriage before, this 5:12 relationship, by the way, had been going on for five years, by the summer of two thousand and one, things were getting a little bit shaky. 5:19 I guess this is one of those things where it's kind of like if he wanted to, he would, but he hadn't. Okay, he hadn't proposed. And you know, Amy's over here dreaming of this bigger than bigger than life existence and full of travel and going to art museums and talking, 5:34 loving and laughing and doing, and it just wasn't going that way. And part of the problem was that Richard, it was a bit of a couch potato, y'all. He was happy sitting at home just kind of doing nothing, you know, just kind of the mundane ins and outs of life, 5:54 and you know, doing basically what she did in high school, just show up, punch the clock, and kind of go about your day. And that's not what she wanted. She wanted so much more. She wanted to be out there and living and doing and seeing and smelling, you know what 6:08 I'm saying, really taking it all in. One of those people that when life is over, she wants to just come just sliding through the finish line, you know, torn up and have done it all. And I just felt that, you know, when I was reading about her, that she 6:24 was not going to be just one of the regulars. She was going to slay life. And basically what it boiled down to was Richard just couldn't keep up with her, and the relationship fizzled and they ended up splitting up, but they would remain friends. This was this was not you know, a 6:42 bad thing, It just kind of it had run its course. So after the breakup, life had to go on, right You can't just sit there and be sad about it. So she decided to keep moving and to keep going and keep doing. And on a Saturday night in the fall of two 7:03 thousand and one, that's when the pretty young Amy Saint Lawrence decided to go out on the town with a new friend she had met and go try out the night life along the Old Port section of Portland, Maine. And this 7:16 friend that she was taken happened to be someone that she had met on a trip a previous trip at Fort Myers, Florida, just a few weeks before, and his name was Eric Rubright. So when they met, they really seemed to hit it off, and Rubright felt like she was quote really cool 7:34 end quote I hope I'm described as more as quote really cool. Like that's what he thought, right, She was a cool girl, and he wanted to see her again. Now, we've all met people that, you know, that we thought were really cool and we liked him, but were we 7:48 willing to fly from Florida to Maine just a few weeks later to go be with them some more. Well, this cat was. He was really into her, and he made that trip all the way and he flew to Maine to go be with her. The trip had really come to fruition and during 8:05 the day that Saturday, Like during the day, they spent it in Boston, and they were touring museums and doing you know what young adults would do, checking out all the sites, and they got along really well. But 8:16 by the time the evening rolled around and they reached Oldport where they were headed, it was about ten thirty at night, and Amy just kind of wasn't feeling it. You know, it had been made pretty clear by this point 8:28 that this wasn't going to be a relationship, but the friendship was fun and they could continue to hang out, but she just wasn't She really wasn't into him after spending all day with him, So what had started out, you 8:41 know, as a spark on a trip, had really fizzled after spending that time together. But that wasn't going to stop them from having fun and enjoying the evening. So they decided to stop at a sports bar called the four 8:50 Play Sports Bar. Telling not really because she wasn't into him, but they're at the four Play Sports Bar, and there she played some pool with some other men while Rubright sipped on a beer and he watched them play well. 9:05 After she completed a few games, they moved on and they ended up at a different dance club called Pavilion. Now it turns out that Rubyright wasn't much of a dancer, but that was okay. Right. He kind of sat off to the side and he sat watching people, and he was drinking his 9:18 beers while Amy hit the dance floor and coincidentally, two of those men that she had been playing pool with before at the four play bar they showed up and she ended up dancing with those two men. So Amy continued to have 9:33 fun dancing and Rubright was watching the nightlife around him, and it was just it was going, you know, it was going okay. But it was about one am when Rubright got up and he said, you know, I got to use the restroom. I'll be back, and it was getting closer 9:50 to closing time. So when he returned from the bathroom, he started looking for Amy, but she was really nowhere to be found. And he looked around, he walked around, asked around, but Amy seemed to have simply 10:01 just disappeared. He couldn't find her anywhere. So curiously, the men that he was, you know, that she had been out there dancing with and he was watching, they weren't there either. But Amy wasn't like flaky, you know. Amy wasn't a flaky girl who was just gonna up and just 10:18 disappear, So it seemed really odd to him, even though he had just known her a short while. But even stranger was the fact that he was her ride home. They had ridden together, so for her to not ride back home with him was extremely odd. Right, that drive would have taken 10:35 her all the way back to South Berwick, which is a you know, a main New Hampshire border town, about forty miles of Portland, So it really wasn't sitting right with him because even if she had been flaky and gone off with someone, she left her coat and her purse and her cell phone 10:54 and everything that a woman would never leave, you know, behind, it was still left in his rental car, so he was kind of confused. 11:03 So he went outside and he waited by the door until the bar closed and waited for her to come out, but he didn't see her, and as time passed and the bar emptied, eventually the last person came out and Amy wasn't one of them. So by this point, and I think it only 11:20 human, Rubright was frustrated and he realized, my god, she left me, she went with those other people and she left me like what the hell. 11:30 So, you know, as you can imagine, it left him completely annoyed. But he decided that he would just drive back to her place, considering she had already gone and she probably had gotten another ride and she had gotten from point A to point B on her own. So on his way 11:43 back to her house, he did stop, he got some gas, and then he took a toll road that eventually led him to the Wells exit. 11:50 But see, he wasn't familiar with the area, and so when he went down the road and he realized, oh crap, it's a toll, he didn't have any money. He didn't have any cash on him to pay the toll. So luckily for him, he was able to talk the toll taker, 12:03 you know, into letting him drive through. The guy understood his predicament and he just let him drive through. But things were just not going well for rubright at this point. But eventually he did make it back to Amy's 12:15 house, but she wasn't there. So she he looks around and he's like, well, she didn't drive herself anywhere, because her car is still in the driveway right where we had left it that morning when they rode out together to go to Boston. So with no way of getting inside of the house, 12:30 and he's in another state with you know, no other contacts that he can get a hold of, and it's two o'clock in the morning. He kind of felt weird about it, but he went through Amy's purse and he dug for the keys to her house. So he pulls the keys out and 12:46 he decides that he's going to go in the house. But it just didn't sit right. You know, this is her house, and I don't have her permission, and I don't want to look like a creep or anything. 12:54 So he made the uncomfortable yet gentlemanly decision to sleep in his rental car. 13:01 So he spent the night in the rental car, and by the next morning he woke up, Amy still hadn't returned. So he's very angry at this point, right I would be too, So he makes the decision to hell with it. He grabs the keys, he opens up her house, and 13:16 he goes inside and what he sees. He looks around and this is an extremely neat home. It's very clean, and it's filled with potted plants. 13:26 You can see just she loved potted plants and they were growing and had ivs everywhere, lots of pictures of her family and whatnot. But he went inside and he found the bathroom and he took a shower. But as he's showering, 13:37 he's becoming increasingly more irritated. I mean, who goes out on what should have been a date? Right? Even though it went south? It wasn't you know, there was no spark. Really, who just up and leaves and abandons someone in a strange city when they've come all the way from 13:52 Florida to Maine to have a date with you? Obviously you knew I was interested, right, It's extremely rude ed at minimum, And even though it wasn't a formal date and they weren't a couple or anything, it just was very rude. But once he finished his shower, he decided, whatever, 14:09 I'm done with this, and he drove back to Portland, where he wanted to spend a few days there and check out the sights. But before he left the house, he put all of her belongings back in. He went to the rental car and he got her purse, her cell phone and all 14:26 the kind of stuff and He put it on the kitchen table, and then he found a sheet of paper and he wrote a note on it. He left it on the door when he left, and it said, where the fuck did you go? And then he shut the door and he left. 14:37 He drove away. But little did he know that that note was a great question that many people would soon be asking themselves where did Amy go? Now? 14:50 Without me even telling you, I'm sure you could guess who was one of the first people to grow extremely concerned when Amy didn't show up on that Sunday. That's right, it was mama. A mama is gonna worry when her baby doesn't show back up. So Amy's mother, Diane Jenkins, was 15:09 very upset because it was not like her to leave without making arrangements. It wasn't like her to not tell someone where she was, and specifically, it wasn't like her to not make plans for her beloved cat Alex. She would 15:22 not have left that animal unattended. There was no question in her mother's mind that something was amiss and that Amy was in trouble, so she called the sheriff's department with hopes of making a missing person's report. The main issue is 15:35 one though that I've mentioned a million times, and that's that Amy was an adult and she's allowed to go missing if she wants to. Also, there was no immediate evidence of a crime. The house was tidy, all of her things were there. No you know, breaking in, no blood, 15:52 no nothing. Amy could be anywhere. I mean, she could have run off to start a new life. She could have decided to go on an ill advised you know, fleeing away with a random person she was dancing with at the club. She could have flown back to Florida with the guy that 16:06 came to meet her. Nobody really knew where she was or what she could have done, and honestly, it was her prerogative. You can do that. 16:14 Police did, though, look into it, and they even tracked down Eric Rubright and asked him some questions about that Saturday night. And the way that they found him was they went through the rental car company and that's how 16:26 they were able to find the records and that's what drew them straight to his door. And no lie. When Rubright explained to the police what had happened, from the get go, red flags were going off and it seemed extremely 16:38 suspicious. I mean, you're telling the police that you're standing in line to go to the bathroom and the girl that you arrived with just randomly disappeared after admittedly dancing and playing pool with another man, and you just accepted thattis fact 16:55 randomly found your way back to her home and slept in your car. Sure right, I mean, doesn't that just sound like something that happens every day. 17:03 Well. Adding to that was the fact that Rubright also came across as extremely nervous, but he said, look, I'll take a polygraph test. 17:11 I have no problems because the police asked if he would, and when it was all said and done, the test came back inconclusive, so police had to go another route to try to find more concrete evidence, but they surely 17:22 were sniffing on on Eric Rubright's trail. Here. Amazingly, though, everything that Rubright had told them seemed to pan out whenever the police contacted people that could could verify it. They spoke to the toll taker on the road, 17:37 who confirmed that he did in fact come through, and that he didn't have the money, but that tolltaker allowed him to pass through anyway. The police then went to the gas station, where he claimed he went, they pulled 17:48 security camera. Sure enough, he stopped by at one thirty eight am, which indeed showed him getting gas. So by the next Tuesday morning, after Amy seemed to have just van police decided to hold a press conference because their 18:03 belief was now that this likely was a criminal situation based on the type of person that Amy was, So Portland Police Chief Michael Chitwood would advise the community that he felt that this was quote not a typical missing person and that all 18:18 investigative leads led to the fact that something criminal was happening here end quote. 18:23 So adding to the intensity of the situation was the fact that Amy, the consummate professional, also did not show up for work that following Monday, and she was just simply too ambitious and too dedicated to her job for this to 18:37 be the case. Call it a mother's intuition, but Mama Diane knew something had happened to her girl from the get go, and she didn't just walk away from this. And her mom even said, this is literally my worst nightmare coming true. Where is my baby? So, hoping to spark some 18:56 movement in the community, Amy's family held another pet press conference just two days later, where they offered a thirty five thousand dollars reward for information for her return. They were willing to put up their own money. Just give her 19:08 back to us. And you know, you read enough cases, and you watch enough press conferences, and you see enough trauma of people going missing in your life, and the desperation in a mother's voice when she is pleading she 19:23 will give you everything she owns, Just give her her baby back. It's sickening. It makes your heart hurt. You know, you can have whatever you want, Just give me my child back. Well, obviously, the 19:37 investigation had to continue, and there were many detectives and investigators on the case who kept looking back at Rubrit no matter what was asked of him. Though his story was consistent, and while it was strange as hell, everything that 19:52 he said it just continued to be truthful. It was at his suggestion that the police decided to try and track down the two men who Amy had played pool with and was doing all the dancing with the night before she disappeared. 20:06 He's like, talk to them, I don't know where she is. I told you what happened, You've checked it out. What else can I do? 20:14 What else can I say? Rub Wright was also able to give a description of the men, saying that one had long hair and the other one was about five foot nine and his hair was gelled back with blonde streaks in it. Well, I mean, I guess he was able to give a 20:29 description because that was like a description in the man's sense of the word. 20:33 Right, It wasn't very detailed. I mean, it's super basic and literally could fit anyone. But he did give the descriptions, and the police would then get a lucky break because they set up a tip line. They were like, let's put a tip line. Let's just see if people can call 20:48 in and see what we can drum up. And you'll never guess who was one of the first callers to the tip line. You got it, it's one of the men that Rubright was talking. He called in himself and he would be identified as twenty one year old Jeffrey Gorman. Now to his friends 21:07 and family, they referred to him as Russ and coincidentally, Russ also had been raised in Florida, but it was a different city than Rubright had been raised him, and he came from a family divorced parents and he had a 21:19 record of a rather troubled childhood, and it seemed to be one of those typical stories where a kid goes between his mother and his grandmother and you know, just kind of a blase childhood. But other than that, there was 21:32 nothing incredibly impressive about him. Now as an adult, he had moved to the Portland area around the year two thousand and he was working as a part time car detailer, So he wasn't like this huge success or anything, and 21:45 he was a bit of a couch surfer from what I understand. He spent a lot of time at an apartment on Brighton Avenue in Portland, which was just a short drive from Old Port where Amy and Rubright had gone out for that casual date. Now, when Ross called into the tip line, it 22:02 wasn't necessarily out of you know, the straight up goodness of his heart. 22:07 You know, it wasn't anything good. He was doing it out of he was really out of the pressure he was feeling from his friends. Because it turns out that when Amy's family and her sisters had been putting up those missing 22:17 person flyers all over the Oldport area, they were trying to drum up some interest in the case. Well it worked because the friends of Ross Gorman saw these posters and were kind of curious as to why, you know, she 22:30 had gone missing, what could have happened to her? And specifically they recognized her as having been with Russ the night in question. So, as you can imagine, after he called the police wanting to give up this information, 22:44 police wanted to have a word with him. So during their questioning, Russ Gorman said that he and his roommate named Cush Sharma met Amy at the club for play, and then he gave a story that really aligned with what Rubright 22:56 had said. He said they had played pool while Rubright sat back and was watching them play, and then later on the night they went to a place called the Pavilion where they met up with Amy again it was just by chance, and they were dancing, and then at some point, he said, 23:10 he and Amy got lost, you know, in the time and the fun, they lost track and they didn't see where Rubright was. It had become closing time, and so she agreed to just go back to that Brighton Avenue apartment with he and his roommates and they were going to have like a little 23:26 after party there that they would be throwing and so Amy agreed. She said, sure, I'll go, no problem. Well, once they got back to the apartment, he said that people didn't show up like they were expected to, and so when the party really didn't take off like they imagined it 23:41 would, she started becoming uncomfortable because she was at this house with these two basic, you know, strangers that she had met, and she she just didn't want to be there anymore. So he started sensing her discomfort and said, 23:53 look, let's just get in the car and I'll take you back to Oldport and I'll bring you back to the Pavilion. And she was like cool, So they did just that. They got back to the Pavilion nightclub at around one forty five that morning, she got out and then he went back 24:08 home. So as investigators would question him about what he knew, they noted that he was extremely skittish while they were talking to him. And he was so skittish that it was like bizarre, because, dude, you voluntarily called 24:26 us. You made yourself a witness, you know, to her disappearance. 24:30 So I don't understand why we are making you so nervous. You called us. 24:36 So police said, well, look, let's go ahead and take a polygraph and we'll just you know, see where it takes us. And he declined, He said, no, I think that I want a lawyer first. 24:45 Well, cool, all right, you have rights, you can you can you can ask for that if you'd like. So then police said, well, can we go ahead and look at your vehicle? And he said that he was a little too busy for that, And even though that was 24:59 literally based on his own story, the last place that she would have been known whereabouts. He said, no, I don't think we're gonna do that. 25:07 I've got things I need to go do. But just because you refuse to go along with everything the police ask of you doesn't make you guilty by any stretch of the imagination. It does, however, make you look suspicious as hell. So that's why the police decided to go and talk to his 25:22 roommates and see what they had to say about him the night that Amy went missing. So they talked to Sharma. So his roommate, Sharma confirmed everything Russ stated, and he even added that Russ was at home and was definitely in the bed by two a m. It lined up right, I mean, 25:40 if he dropped her off at you know, the early morning hours and then was in the bed by two. It's really making sense. And this was nice and all, but the police were not gonna take anyone at their word, and you know, they were gonna need some more to go off 25:56 of to really solidify the story that these men had given. The good news was that Russ remembered lots of details of that evening, including the fact that when he got home, his roommate Jason Cook, had been on the computer 26:08 and was sending emails, specifically to one of his aunts in Florida. He also said, and I made a phone call. I don't remember who I was talking to exactly. You know, they'd been out dancing and drinking and whatnot. But I did make a phone call, and I made that right 26:25 before I went to bed. So the police did what police do, and they pulled the computer and cell phone records to verify the story. And this is where the problems begin, because there was no email whatsoever sent, and 26:40 the cell phone records did not show us a phone call during any of the times that he says he definitely made a phone call. Now that doesn't necessarily mean you did anything. Your timeline could be wrong, but it just seemed 26:56 super detailed to be wrong, right. I mean, he was sending an email to his aunt and then there's no email at all, and you would know if it was one am versus the afternoon before. But again not a smoking gun, but it was a u oh. So while this information was 27:14 definitely not looking good for Russ, it was additional information from another roommate named Dave Grasier. That's how I would say it. Dave Grasier. That would become rather damning for Old Russ because it turns out that Dave and his girlfriend 27:30 Dawn were together that night and had gone out for a really early breakfast Saturday night, which rolled into Sunday morning. So that being said, they returned back to the apartment and it was between three and three point fifteen am. 27:45 And guess who wasn't there when they returned, Old Russy Boy. So now the timeline isn't making sense. Additionally, roommate Dave also said that he woke back up early in those morning hours, between four thirty and five because he 28:00 had to use the bathroom. And when he got up to go use the bathroom, he found Russ in there and he was washing his hands and kind of cleaning up and while washing your hands, y'all. It's not criminal, Okay. The timeline wasn't adding up, and the roommate said that Russ was 28:15 fully clothed while he was in the bathroom washing his hands. He wasn't in his boxers or in his pajamas as one would expect if someone had woken up and gone to use the bathroom. He was fully dressed and was kind of 28:29 like cleaning up for the evening. So now it was time to really apply the pressure, as we call it, and the police started honing in on old Cush Sharma, saying, look, I think we need to get a polygraph test from you as well, if you would be so inclined. But 28:45 whenever it was time for him to take the polygraph, that's when Sharma's story changed, and it changed a little bit because now he says, well, maybe my timeline wasn't right, Maybe it wasn't quite correct. I can be 28:57 certain though, that Russ was home by four point fifteen. Am okay, Well that's great, Sharma, But that changes everything. That changes everything. 29:08 Right, if before he dropped her off and then he was in bed by two, now we've added an additional two hours and fifteen minutes and we have a missing girl. Do the math. So, as you can imagine, the bullshit meter is flashing big time now and police have just about had enough, 29:27 so they say, look, Russ, we need to look at your car. We need to check out and see if there's any evidence inside. 29:33 Now. People have habits, right, people have habits. If you look in my car right now, I guarantee you there's gonna be some kind of can drink can in the bag, and probably some spilled nerds on the floor, and some candy and a whole bunch of other crap I don't want want 29:48 back there. And there's always one sock. I don't know where the other sock went. But my children that's what they do, all right. That's not gonna change until they're older. All right. There's always going to be a mess in the back of my car. Everybody knows it. Everybody knows 30:03 it. Well, Ross is no different. He was a creature of habit, and he was known to drive a red Pontiac Sedan, and he was also known to be absolutely filthy, disgusting. The car was always an absolute you know, filth fest. Well about that time another call would come into 30:22 the tip line, but what was interesting about this one is that it was a friend of Russ's roommate. Okay, so it wasn't a roommate. It was a friend of a roommate and his name was Matt Despin's and he had called in to tell police. Look, then, maybe this is nothing. 30:37 I don't know, but I do find it really odd that right after that Amy girl went missing, Russ's car, which is normally a complete and total wreck. He took it and he got a deluxe bumper to bumper detailed job on the car, and it just stood out as weird because it just wasn't 30:56 something he usually cared about. So police still want it inside of that car, and they wanted inside of it now, so as expected, when they were inside of the car, it had been cleaned. However, something extremely 31:10 strange had happened to it, either during or after the cleaning. It turned out that parts of the paneling on the doors had literally been cut away, as in like it was down to the internal mechanisms of the door. So 31:26 there's literally no explanation cosmetically to have done that, and there's also no explanation and functionality as to why you would do that either. So sometimes it's it's the lack of evidence that's overshadowed by the extreme unexplained circumstantial evidence that you have 31:44 to pay attention to. It's kind of like in that Zachariah Anderson case that I did, where the body is missing and he's the only one who had emotive to do so, and all of the evidence points to him, and he's all like, oh, well, no body's ever been found, so 31:57 he must. You know, you can't say I did something. Well, yeah, actually I can. And that doesn't mean that something hasn't happened to him. It just means that his body had been found, right, And it's crazy to think otherwise. You are wilfully ignorant if you think something didn't 32:12 happen to him in that case, you know what I mean, And that's it's no different in this situation. So the police took a step and they decided to run a check through NCIC, which is the National Crime Information Center, 32:22 and it houses a ton of information about you know, criminals and vehicles, et cetera. And what was most impressive about that is the fact that Russ had actually been stopped by police recently, and most stunningly was that he 32:37 not only had been pulled over recently, but one of the violations he was pulled over for it was for a headlight issue, but it happened at a time that was really glaring. He had been pulled over in the Portland suburb 32:51 of Westbrook at three point fourteen am on the very morning that Amy went missing, and more than an hour or after he claimed that he was in bed, and definitely after his roommate originally said that he was in bed. So 33:07 if you can't tell by now, the lies are catching up and the story's fallen apart. And what's worse is that Amy was still missing and no one had heard from her. So where is Amy? Russ? Quit thinking about yourself and tell us where Amy is. As any investigation goes on, I 33:27 know you know that it takes time and everything is kind of slow, and it's frustrating for everyone involved. But only so much can be done in a day, and sometimes that time that it takes can actually make a picture come 33:40 together in a weird way, because originally, when Russ came and met with the police, he was a very salt of the earth looking guy, very very wholesome. By looking at him, he almost had like a childlikeness about him. He dressed nicely, his hair was well groomed. He just looked 33:59 like the boy next door. And once the questioning was over, I guess that's when things really changed drastically, because as that time went on, and I guess Russ thought that he wasn't really being looked at. That's whenever he 34:16 switched from that boyish look, it faded and Russ started doing a little shape shifting. I mean like his head was now shaved, he was covered in tattoos, he had multiple piercings about him, and if you looked at him and sized him up, he'd be like, dude, he looks like he's 34:34 gonna be the main act in like a punk rock band or something. Now, don't come after me. I'm not saying tattoos and piercings and all of that makes you, you know, a murderer. My own husband has tattoos and used to have a bunch of piercings. Okay, Mama liked the Mama 34:47 likes some wild. But it does make you wonder why someone would do this. 34:53 You know, onein eighty and now be no one near what they looked like when they went in and spoke to the police. So were you faking it before or are you trying to all of a sudden look hard now, which wouldn't make sense because you're kind of under investigation. You know it, 35:08 Just it wasn't normal. Okay. Ross was no longer though the person of interest, he was the main suspect. More information was also being fed to the police, and this time it came from Russ's mother's boyfriend. Let me 35:27 tell you something. This is a warning. If you're ever gonna borrow a tool from a man, you better return the damn thing. You better return his tools. I mean, I learned this when I was eight years old from my own stepdaddy. You don't take a man's tool and not return it. 35:42 You put the screwdriver back in the exact drawer where you borrowed it from, or there will be hell to pay. You don't go around borrow a man's tools unless you're gonna return them. And in this case, that's what came back to bite Ross in the ass, because he had borrowed a shovel 36:01 two days after Amy went missing. This led to the obvious assumption that not only was Amy dead, but possibly she had been buried, but I mean her body could be anywhere. I mean some people might go, man, that's a large jump, but I mean when you have no other evidence to 36:17 go off of, I mean, that's really the only conclusion they could come to. So taking everything into account that investigators knew, a multi agency task force came together and they started considering likely locations based on the disappearance location and 36:36 the apartment where he stayed, where Russ stayed, and they came up with nineteen likely sites of where Amy would possibly be buried, and it consisted of multiple wooded remote locations right where someone would be able to go kind of hide 36:52 a body and it not be noticed. And in their early morning hours of December eighth, over one hundred officers plus a search and rescue team started searching one of those nineteen sites that they had narrowed down. And this location was 37:07 also chosen because it was just minutes from where Russ had gotten that headlight violation triangulated with his home and the bar. So this is actually genius, right, It's kind of a it's a good plan in my opinion. Another tool 37:25 that they were using while they were doing all of this were cadaver dogs, and they covered several one hundred acres during the process. And it was about two thirty pm and eight hours in when they were passing through a Macadam road 37:40 and this road was, you know, had lots of mud and lots of thick overgrowth. So a cadaver dog was with them, and as they were walking, a volunteer stepped on what appeared to be like some recently removed dirt. 37:55 So the volunteer stepped back. I was like this done, look right. 38:00 They bring over the cadaver dog, and as you've already probably expected, the dog positively hit on the scent of decomposition. So one detective was literally on his hands and knees and he was kind of digging through the dirt carefully 38:15 when he finally pulled what seemed to be a piece of gray fleece from the dirt, and as he pulled up, it was a visual match for the sweatshirt that Amy was last seen wearing when she vanished. So they did a 38:31 little bit further digging and police found what they already knew. Amy was dead and she had been buried by her killer. Amy had been found, so now they shifted gears and the hunt was on for the predator. So her 38:52 body was collected and immediately was sent to the medical Examiner's office. And this murder had an element that I don't often see in a lot of cases that I cover, at least not in more recent times. But not only had 39:07 Amy been brutally assaulted, but in this case, she also had been drugged. 39:14 And GHB, which is commonly known as the date rape drug, was the drug that was used on her. Now, what was interesting about that was police had been told through accounts of some of Russ's friends that he wasn't 39:29 necessarily above drugging women to get them to go to bed with him. Now that's not concrete evidence by any means, but what are the chances, right of your friend group being like, he ain't above it. You know, he would drug a girl if he thought he could sleep with her, And 39:42 then they find a dead girl, buried and she has GHB in her system. 39:47 Also adding to that was the fact that she was not a drug user, and she was not a recreational drug user, and she would not have used GHB. So obviously something more sinister was at play here, and she 40:00 had definitely struggled in this fight for her life. Her panties were twisted around her ankles and they remained there even after death. The killer didn't even finish undressing her like they were fighting in any you know, her panties just got 40:17 twisted up and rolled down to her ankles while he raped her. Can you imagine disgusting And looking at the autopsy report, you can see multiple head wounds and there's a large one above her ear. Some are straight on top of 40:35 her scalp, and she also had damage to her lips. I guess as if she was punched or cut in the face. There were cuts on her arms, on the tops of her legs where the leg bends, like where your leg comes up and meets your vagina, she had cuts there. She 40:51 had damage to her ankles and the backs of both of her legs as well. 40:57 And not only had she been violently raped, but sadly, there was no seamen or other bodily fluids and enough of a quantity to be tested for DNA, so that kind of put a little hindrance to the investigation. But the autopsy also showed that not only had Amy been beaten, she had also 41:22 been raped, but she had also been shot in the head executed with a nine millimeter weapon. Now, that weapon would never be recovered, But a suspect's behavior is so telling when they start to panic, and Russ was no 41:42 different. It turns out, right before they found Amy's body, Russ randomly decided that he needed to get out of town, so he headed to Troy, Alabama. Now, any movie you watch where there's a bad guy, you know, who's going to go kill other people, well, they cast 42:00 a certain character to play that killer, right, Well, it's my humble opinion that Russ would never be cast as that character because it turns out that Russ is a little bitch, all right. No, sooner did he get back to Alabama did he place a phone call on December ninth, at two 42:16 thirty pm to his mother, Tammy Westbrook. Now, while growing up their relationship it hadn't been perfect. Rememory bounced back and forth between his grandma and his mama. He now felt that it was time to make sure his mother 42:29 knew that her terrible parenting had caused him such distress that he had acted out. 42:37 He also decided, over the next couple of weeks to just give her a confession of what he had done. His own mother felt that he was involved in some way, and she kept asking him and asking him, but he continued to deny it until her body was found, and that's when he 42:53 completely fell apart and he told his mother, Yes, I did it. 42:58 Quote, I killed that girl end quote. He also added the sick twist that while he was killing her, he supposedly it was imagining that it was his own mother and he just snapped. So this grown ass man is now so wounded by his mother that it caused him to drug a girl, rape 43:25 her, and shoot her in the head. Sounds like a friggin cop out to me. Why would you date rape a girl if you snapped, you wouldn't you imagining you date rape in your own mom. I mean, that's a whole new set of problems. That's what we call bullshit. It sounds 43:43 to me like you couldn't take accountability for your own actions, so you're immediately trying to minimize and self preserve by placing distance and reasoning as far as you see it between you and what you've done to a girl that you killed. 44:00 In his less than remorseful twenty two minute conversation with his mom, he claimed that he was just walking with her in the woods, which I'm gonna call bullshit there too. I don't see her just walking randomly in the woods through 44:10 the thick overgrowth and mud. Don't see it happening. But they were just walking through the woods when Amy said something that irritated him, so he just started beating her and then shot her in the head. I don't believe that as far as I can throw him. Why do you have a gun on 44:27 you in the first place? Where did the GHB come from? How did she have time to metabolize it? When did she take the drink? Why would she go from clubbing to randomly walking out in the woods with you? 44:42 Sorry, don't buy it that dog. Don't hunt. Then, in a total bitch move, he decides that he's gonna pull a gun on a man outside of a gas station because he said that the guy was quote staring at him end quote, I mean, what are we? Are we in the 44:57 fourth grade now? So he pulls a gun on the start screaming at him what are you looking at? And obviously the guy was freaked out, like what do you mean? What am I looking at? And he reported the incident to the police. So the following day police were able to identify who 45:09 it was, and they cornered Russ at a family friend's home, and this is where the douchebag kept the police watching him for six hours with two guns in his hands, claiming that he was gonna kill himself. Well call me 45:23 the Meani Weeni of Reddit if you will, but maybe you should have just killed yourself, bro, before you went and did that to an innocent woman and raped her in all of the above, but I digress. Then, in typical trash fashion, he decided to trade his guns for cigarettes and a 45:43 cold drink, and that's when the police promptly took him into custody at that moment. But guess why they took him into custody. You're gonna love this on a probation violation from a charge that was completely unrelated. So this dude's 46:00 been a little asshole for a while committing crimes for a minute. Are you shocked? Because I'm not. And it was around this same time that Russ's mom was upset about the fact that her son had admitted to killing someone, 46:15 but she refused to call the police because that was quote unquote her baby. 46:20 So she called a close friend and told the close friend and this is where the beauty of the courts come in, because she was pulled in front of a grand jury and she was told that she was going to be held in 46:32 contempt of court and threatened with criminal charges if she would not speak. So, just a little side note for you, real quick. Spouses cannot be compelled to testify against spouses, but parents can be compelled to testify against criminals 46:49 in trials. So on February eighth of two thousand and two, Russ's mother gave a grand jury a full account of the confession from her son. She was crying and sobbing through it all, and I imagine it hurt as a 47:01 mother, but she gave the full, detailed confession and shortly thereafter Russ Gorman was indicted for murder. Now he would ultimately go on trial on January thirteenth, two thousand and three, when, like something out of a down soap 47:19 opera, Russ's mother now claimed that she had developed amnesia and she couldn't remember anything about the conversation, nor did she ever give testimony to a grand jury about her son's confession. Well, maybe that might work in a movie script, 47:36 but here on earth, here in real life. Nobody was buying that, okay. But also in current times we have things called tape recorders, and I guess Russ's mom hadn't taken that into consideration. But her testimony before 47:52 the grand jury had been taped, so although she was not wanting to speak, now we got the record of it. But the judge was a reluctant to play that tape at first because she knew that there could be an issue 48:08 as you normally apparently don't let grand jury testimony apply in the court case at trial. But the trial was a short one and Russ Gorman would not take the stand in his own defense, and as you can imagine, the jury 48:27 quickly returned a guilty verdict and he was sentenced to sixty years in prison. 48:30 Now, from my other MENI weenies out there, the unspeakable mini weens, some of y'all have to be like, why didn't he get the damn death penalty? He drugged, raped, and executed a girl. Why didn't he get the death penalty? It's because Maine doesn't have the death penalty, so 48:49 he got sixty years. And I wanted to give you a little follow up to about a year later, the main Supreme Judicial Court received an appeal request on behalf of Russ Gorman. Do you remember how the judge in the original 49:02 case I told you was hesitant to allow that recorded testimony in of the grand jury. Well, it did turn out to be a legitimate issue and it grounds for appeal. Thus his appeal was considered, and Russ's mama was in the gallery, and she read her Bible the entire time that she was in 49:21 the gallery and was even quoted by a reporter as having said, my son is innocent in my heart. He is a good boy, and this is in the Lord's hands now. And y'all, I know this mother didn't do it, but I have to emphatically say to her that it was always actually 49:40 in the Lord's hands. If we're going to bring that up. Bringing a Bible to court didn't change that. It turns out the Lord's hands were busy dealing with reality, and he sprinkled a little Psalm thirty seven thirteen on Russ 49:55 that day, because the High Court justices held the conviction would stand. Having to date rape someone to have sex with them is beyond reprehensible. I mean, even if you're ugly, a good personality can take you a long way. 50:16 The reality is that Amy was too good for him. She was a winner and he never had a chance with her. So he did what cowards do. He drugged her, He injured her so she couldn't defend herself before blowing a bullet through her brain and taking away her life. You Russ are 50:37 the ultimate loser, and Amy deserved better. But some things won't ever change. 50:46 However, even a blind dog gets a bone sometimes, So while attracting women isn't your skill set, you can at least still count on mosquitoes.
Community discussion