First Date: The Shayna Hubers Case
Episode S12 · Ep 16 1 hr 1 min
On the night of October 12, 2012, 21-year-old graduate student Shayna Hubers called 911 from her boyfriend’s Highland Heights, Kentucky condominium and calmly told the dispatcher she had just killed him in self-defense. What investigators found when they arrived was a scene that didn’t match her story—and an interrogation that would become one of the most talked-about in Kentucky true-crime history.

Ryan Poston, a 29-year-old attorney, had been getting ready for a first date with Miss Ohio USA 2012 when Shayna showed up unannounced. By the end of the night, he had been shot six times with his own gun. Shayna claimed an abusive, volatile relationship had finally exploded into violence. Prosecutors painted a different picture: an obsessive, on-again-off-again girlfriend who refused to let go, especially once she learned Ryan was moving on with someone else.

Timestamps:
10:35 A Relationship Begins to Fracture
18:21 Police Arrive at the Scene
28:40 Claims of Abuse
39:14 Domestic Violence and the Investigation
42:01 Inside Ryan’s Apartment
53:18 Shana’s Behavior During Questioning
55:32 Neighbors Offer New Perspectives
1:00:09 Digital Evidence

Unspeakable on Patreon!
Click Here:

Tags:
Ryan Poston, Shana Huber, relationship, recurring conflicts, 2011, shooting, self-defense, evidence, neighbor statements, investigation, phone records, detectives

Community discussion