0:03 This episode contains graphic content that may not be suitable for all ages. Listener discretion is advised. If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available. 0:15 Call or text 988 or chat with someone at 988lifeline. org. 0:21 Those outside of the U.S., reach out to someone at your local crisis center or hotline. Please do not suffer in silence. 0:41 On the night of Thursday, May 29th, 2025, a 15-year-old girl named Kylie Arellano was at home in Garden City, Utah, a town of about 600 people on the western shore of Bear Lake. 1:06 According to her mother, Stephanie Coleman, at 9.44, Kylie texted her, At 9.52, Kylie's phone went dark, its last signal placing it just a few hundred feet from the house. At 10.52, according to the Rich County Sheriff's Office, she was last 1:24 seen near her home, carrying a skull-print suitcase she had bought at a thrift shop earlier that day. The next morning, her jacket was in the driveway and her Xbox was gone. Then, for 17 months, nothing. No phone activity, no social media. 1:41 Just a string of sightings, from a rest stop in Perry, Utah, to Salt Lake City, to Alabama and Georgia. None of them confirmed. Stephanie told people who would listen that Kylie had been groomed online, pointing to money that unknown people 1:55 had sent her through PayPal, and gifts that arrived in the mail. The Rich County Sheriff's Office, which at one point in the summer of 2025 was down to the sheriff and just two deputies, worked the case largely alone. 2:09 Sheriff Dale Stacey told Dateline that his office had contacted the FBI at least twice, and both times the Bureau had decided the case, in his words, does not fit what they need to get involved. We released our episode on Kylie on May 29th, 2026, one year to the 2:24 day after she disappeared. At the time, there had not been any substantial updates in Kylie's case for quite a while. 2:33 But on the afternoon of Sunday, November 1st, 2026, police in Oregon found a 17-year-old girl in the company of a 39-year-old man. He was taken into custody without incident. 2:47 That night, the FBI's Salt Lake City field office announced that a teen missing from Garden City since May of 2025 had been safely recovered. The release... did not name this missing teen, but it did not need to. Finally, after 521 days, it has been confirmed that Kylie Ariano 3:07 is alive. What has been officially released about Kylie's recovery at this point is very little. According to the FBI, Oregon law enforcement, acting on information from the FBI's Salt Lake City field office, located Kiley on Sunday afternoon. Per 3:33 various outlets, the Oregon State Police, the FBI's Portland field office, and the Utah Department of Public Safety all assisted. The FBI said that the investigation had run for more than a year and had chased leads across the United States 3:47 and in other countries. But in their announcement, the FBI closed with the line that every outlet has since repeated. 3:54 As this case is ongoing, no further information will be released at this time. So as of this recording, we don't know the man's name or what he has been charged with. We don't know where in Oregon Kylie was found, how long she had been there, or whether she had 4:09 been with this man for all 17 months she was gone. 4:12 We don't know whether anyone else was involved. Though FBI Director Kash Patel did say that the Bureau would continue working with our partners to hold those responsible accountable. That may be a signal that maybe those responsible means something plural. 4:28 Or it may just be how the press release was written. 4:31 But according to Emma Bussey at Fox News Digital, a law enforcement source said that the man allegedly contacted Kylie on Snapchat before she disappeared. That's a single unnamed source, and neither the FBI nor the sheriff has confirmed it 4:45 thus far. But if it holds up, it's exactly what Stephanie Coleman has been saying from the beginning. Which makes the timing of what happened three days before this announcement all the more striking. On Thursday, October 29th, just a 5:00 few days ago, KUTV's Nate Carlisle reported on three search warrants in Kylie's case, recently unsealed and served in April and May of 2026. That means they were served right before our original episode came out. Nobody outside of the 5:16 investigation knew about them. They were not about Kylie's accounts. 5:20 They were about her mother. According to KUTV, investigators had come to suspect that Stephanie Coleman hadn't told the truth. 5:29 The Warrants cited an allegation that in 2024, Kylie said her mother had choked her. They said investigators could not find on Stephanie's phone the text that she said she had exchanged with Kylie that last night. And they said 5:43 that when police walked through the home in spring of 2026, they saw what looked like blood or blood patterns. Stephanie denied all of it. She told KUTV, I know that this makes me look bad. I've never abused my child. 5:57 She then added, I pray every day that my daughter is still alive. It has been 517 nights. Two things from that interview matter for our original episode. First, Kylie had run away before. We did not know that at the time, and the episode treated May 29th as a 6:16 first break. Second, so much of what the public knew about that night, including the timeline and the text, came from Stephanie. So, you deserve to hear that investigators were scrutinizing her account. You also deserve to hear what Sunday 6:30 changes about those warrants. Whatever police found in that house, it was not evidence that Kylie died there. So the 2024 allegation remains just that, an allegation in a court filing which was denied, never charged, and never tested. And 6:46 it also proves that for 17 months, Kylie's mother Stephanie had been saying one thing over and over again, that her daughter had been lured away by someone she met online. Now, the line from Sunday's announcement that got the most attention 7:14 came from Director Kash Patel. He said, He also said that the Bureau is using every tool at our disposal to combat nihilistic violent extremism. That vocabulary doesn't usually show up in a press release about a runaway. Now, you 7:38 may be unfamiliar, but gore groups, G-O-R-E, is the FBI's term for online communities that, according to it, are built to lure and exploit vulnerable children. The best known is a network called 764. The FBI says 764 and groups 7:55 like it target kids struggling with depression and mental illness, some as young as 13, and pressure them into producing extreme content, including self-harm and sexual exploitation. But as Newsweek pointed out, the FBI has not said what role these 8:11 groups played in Kiley's disappearance. FBI Director Kash Patel has made 764 a public priority all fall, and Sunday gave him a large audience. That being said, 764 is a very dangerous phenomenon. I've been debating trying to cover it 8:28 in a widespread format on this podcast, but I'm really not sure how to do that because groups like that relish being publicized, so it's really hard to determine what to cover and when. In our original episode, I laid out three possibilities. That Kylie ran away and was surviving 8:48 on her own, that she had been groomed online and lured away, or something happened to her that night near Garden City. The third, thank goodness, seems to be off the table. Based on what's been made public so far, the second looks to be the closest. But I said 9:03 then that these were not mutually exclusive, and I stand by it. A 15 year old who packs a suitcase and walks out can still be the victim of an adult waiting for her. A 15 year old cannot consent her way out of being exploited. I also said in 9:18 the original episode that this case exposed a classification problem. 9:22 The system needed to decide what kind of missing Kylie was before it knew how hard to look. The announcement from Sunday does not change that. In a GoFundMe from October 2025, Stephanie wrote that police had classified Kylie as 9:36 a runaway and told her that Now, that's her recollection, and the sheriff's office has not publicly responded to it. 9:46 What we know is that it ultimately took more than a year, two FBI field offices, state agencies in two different states, and a federal agency that had twice declined to get involved to find Kylie. Maybe the FBI saw something back in April that it could not have seen 10:02 the August before. Cases do evolve. But if you're a parent in a small town whose kid is gone, and someone is telling you that she's just a runaway who will come home when she calms down, Kylie's case is now evidence in your favor. Keep pushing. The man who 10:22 is with Kylie is in custody, and soon he'll have a name, charges, and a court date. When that happens, I'll be back. No charges have been filed against Stephanie Coleman, and she denies any wrongdoing. By all accounts, she now seems to be vindicated. Where Kylie goes from here is 10:40 for people who know far more than I do to decide. 10:43 And one more thing about this show. Kylie is 17 years old, she's a minor, and by every indication, the victim of a crime. What happened to her over those 17 months is not content. When charges are filed, I'll try and cover the case against the man responsible and 10:59 the institutions that took so long to find her. But I will not be trying to chase the details of what she went through. In our first episode, I mentioned that Christmas was Kylie's favorite holiday, because every year, she 11:12 and her mom made homemade tamales. She missed Christmas last year. 11:16 She turned 16, then 17, somewhere that none of us could see her. Thankfully, she will be back for this Christmas. 11:27 If you have any information about this case, the FBI is still investigating. You can submit a tip at tips.fbi.gov or you can call 1-800-CALL-FBI. You can also reach the Rich County Sheriff's Office at 435-793-2285. Reference the case number 25-R308. 11:49 And if you are a kid, or you know one, being pressured online by someone into sending pictures, hurting yourself, or keeping secrets, please report it to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children's CyberTip line at report.cybertip.org or 12:07 at 1-800-843-5678. NCMEC's free Take It Down service can help get explicit images of minors removed from the internet. Just know and spread the message. You are not in trouble. 12:19 You are not the one who did something wrong.
Community discussion