0:03 This episode contains graphic content that may not be suitable for all ages. Listener discretion is advised. If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available. 0:15 Call or text 988 or chat with someone at 988lifeline. org. 0:21 Those outside of the U.S., reach out to someone at your local crisis center or hotline. Please do not suffer in silence. Just across the water from the coastal town of Fernandina Beach, Florida, in the unincorporated community of Yulee, 0:51 there is a small plaza tucked along State Road A1A, the main road that runs through Nassau County. It's a type of strip that you've probably seen a thousand times before. 1:02 It has a few storefronts, a restaurant or two, and plenty of parking. It's exactly the kind of place that you would pass along the highway and never think twice about. 1:11 Inside one of the storefronts was a hair salon called Tangles. 1:15 It was a pretty modest establishment, a place where stylists built their clientele through word of mouth and a steady social media presence. If you lived in the area and needed a haircut, chances are you knew someone who went to Tangles. In February of 2018, a new stylist began 1:32 working at the salon. She called herself Jennifer Seibert. She was quiet, maybe a bit standoffish. But she made an impression on just about everyone who encountered her. Not always a positive one, mind you. Clients and co-workers described her 1:48 as secretive, over-the-top, paranoid even. The kind of person who seemed to carry a weight behind her eyes that nobody could quite place. Within three months of her arrival at Pangol's, this new stylist would set into motion a chain of 2:03 events that would unravel one of the most bizarre criminal histories that investigators had ever encountered. It included a trail of stolen identities, false documents, and unanswered questions that stretched across more than two decades and at least 14 states. 2:20 But before any of that could be discovered, a young mother had to first vanish. This is the story of Kimberly Kessler. Welcome to Unresolved. I'm your host, Michael Whelan. 2:55 Before we get into the story, I would like to take a quick moment to let you know how you can help support the show. Unresolved is a completely independent show. 3:04 We have never had the backing of any major studio or production company or anything like that, and we never will. 3:10 And that is made possible entirely by you, the listener, as well as the people who support this show over on Patreon. If you would like to join them, please head over to patreon.com slash unresolvedpod, where you can find a few perks for supporters along the way. more about 3:25 those perks at the end of the show. But if supporting the show financially isn't in the cards for you right now, that is completely fine. Another thing you can do that would help support the show is leave us a rating or a review over on Spotify or Apple 3:38 Podcasts or wherever you happen to be listening right now. 3:41 That takes about 30 seconds and it genuinely helps new listeners find the show. So I'm sure you're off to do that right now as you listen, right? Anyways, without any further ado, let's head to Northeast Florida. Jolene Rebecca Jensen was born in 1984, and she grew up in 4:05 Nassau County, Florida. She lived with her mother, Ann Johnson, and her stepfather, and was known even from a young age for her energy and her sense of fun. Her friend Alma Powers later told Oxygen, Jolene had a large 4:19 circle of friends. Everybody loved Jolene. After high school, Jolene studied cosmetology in nearby Jacksonville, with the dream of eventually opening up her own salon. She had a natural ability to connect with people, and those who knew her would 4:35 later describe her as one of those people who could light up a room without even trying. In time, Jolene became a mother. She had a daughter first. Then, after marrying Jason Cummings in 2013 and taking his last name, 4:48 she had two more children. Both boys. Her friend, Mariah Lorraine, later told Oxygen, She was so obsessed with those babies that nothing else mattered. Those kids came first. By her mid-thirties, Jolene Cummings was a devoted mother of three, working as 5:05 a hairstylist at Tangle's Hair Salon in Yulee, where she had started to build up a loyal clientele through social media and her natural people skills. Unfortunately, the Cummings' marriage began to falter, and Jolene and Jason separated in 2017. 5:22 But even after the separation, those who knew them would say that the two remained on good terms, with the children being their shared priority. Jason Cummings himself would later tell officials that he still loved Jolene and that she 5:34 was a great mother. By the spring of 2018, Jolene's life seemed to be on an upward trajectory. She was close with her mother Anne, she was dedicated to her kids, and she was well-liked by just about everyone who crossed her path at the salon. She was, by all accounts, 5:51 exactly where she wanted to be. But in early 2018, a new hire at Tangle's Hair Salon would change everything. 6:02 The woman who arrived at Tangles introduced herself as Jennifer Seibert. 6:07 According to salon owner Vicki Simmons, who would later testify, Seibert started at Tangles in February of 2018, and it did not take long for coworkers and clients to notice something off about her. She was guarded, sometimes moody, and 6:22 she rubbed clients the wrong way. And this wasn't the first salon she had worked at in the area either. 6:29 According to an investigative report, she had previously worked at a Great Clips in St. John's County under the name Mia Siebert. The last name was spelled differently. Employees there reportedly said that they felt uncomfortable working alongside her. She 6:44 seemed paranoid, and she had obtained the job using false information. 6:48 Now at Tangles, those same qualities were on full display. 6:52 And Jolene Cummings, who had been at the salon for years and knew the rhythms of the place better than anyone... 6:58 quickly developed a sense that something was off about her new coworker. According to that same investigative report, Jolene asked the salon's owner for Jennifer Seibert's personal information so that she could run an online criminal record search. According to 7:13 multiple sources, she also told another coworker that she intended to dig into this Jennifer's background and expose her. In doing so, Jolene Cummings had gravely underestimated the danger that she was now in. Saturday, May 12th, 2018, was the 7:38 last day that anyone saw Jolene Cummings alive. The next day, Sunday, May 13th, was Mother's Day. Jolene had plans to pick up her three children from her ex-husband Jason's home in Hilliard, Florida. 7:51 It was supposed to be a simple, happy weekend. That Saturday, Jolene worked at Tangle's, closing up the salon at around 5 p.m. According to the salon's owner, Vicki Simmons, Jolene and her new co-worker, Jennifer Seibert, were the only two 8:07 stylists working that day. Customers who visited the salon that day would later say that they noticed some tension between the two women. One client recalled that Jennifer had been pacing a lot and seemed unable to stay still. Others 8:21 noted a palpable friction, though nobody could have predicted what was about to unfold. After the salon closed on Saturday evening, there is no further confirmed sighting of Jolene Cummings. She simply vanished. The following day, Mother's Day, Jolene failed the 8:37 show to pick up her children from Jason. This was completely out of character. She had never done anything like that before. Jason tried reaching her, and when he couldn't, he called Ann Johnson, Jolene's mother. Neither of them could 8:50 get in touch with Jolene. The following morning, Monday, May 14th, Ann Johnson called the Nassau County Sheriff's Office to report her daughter missing. When deputies from the Nassau County Sheriff's Office began investigating Jolene's disappearance, one of the first things 9:07 they did was to visit Tangle's Hair Salon and speak with the people who had been there on Saturday. That included the salon's owner, who told them that the last person to see Jolene at the salon had been her co-worker, 9:19 Jennifer Seibert. But Seibert never came back to work. On Tuesday, May 15th, The first day that the salon reopened after Jolene's disappearance, she did not show up. Instead, she called to say that she was leaving town. She claimed that 9:34 she could not be involved in any law enforcement investigation because she was being stalked by an ex-boyfriend. Then, she disappeared. 9:43 That same day, a tip came in. Someone had spotted Jolene's beige 2006 Ford Expedition sitting in the parking lot of a Home Depot along A1A in Yulee, Florida. When investigators pulled surveillance footage from the area, they found something chilling. 9:59 At approximately 1.17am on May 13th, Mother's Day, a figure is seen exiting the driver's side of Jolene's SUV and walking away. But there was no sign of Jolene anywhere in the footage, and the figure appeared to match the 10:14 description of Jennifer Seibert. The figure walked from that Home Depot parking lot to a nearby Gate gas station, where additional surveillance cameras captured her buying a bottle of water. 10:26 She then borrowed an employee's phone to call for a taxi. 10:30 Investigators obtained a warrant to examine Tangle's hair salon. Using liminal, a chemical agent used to detect trace amounts of blood, crime scene investigators discovered massive amounts of blood residue throughout the salon. They found it on the walls, the chairs, 10:47 the cabinets, and the sink drain. Subsequent DNA testing confirmed what investigators feared. Much of the blood belonged to Jolene Cummings. 10:56 Yet some of it, a detective would later acknowledge, belonged to the woman calling herself Jennifer Seibert. There had been a significant cleanup effort. Blood was found on a bleach bottle and a mop inside the store. A blacklight photograph 11:11 of the mop showed visible blood and mop strokes on the floor. remnants of someone's attempt to wash away the evidence. 11:18 Nassau County Sheriff Bill Lieber addressed the public's fears directly, telling reporters, We know that Jolene is not alive. We know that she was murdered in that salon. With a BOLO, a Be On The Lookout alert, now issued for Jennifer 11:33 Seibert and her black Kia Soul, investigators fanned out across the region. But they did not have to search for very long. On May 16th, Jennifer Seibert was found sleeping in her car at a rest area along Interstate 95 11:47 in St. Johns County, sandwiched between two semi-trucks. She appeared to be living out of her vehicle. When officers approached, they noticed something immediately. Jennifer Seibert had band-aids covering her face and hands, attempting to conceal visible injuries. There was 12:05 a pretty nasty cut below her left eye, along with bruises on her hands, arms, and shoulders. She told officers that the injuries were from running into a tree branch while riding her bicycle. But investigators did not buy that 12:18 story for a single second. She was arrested and charged with grand theft auto for being in possession of Jolene's SUV. 12:26 But as the questioning continued over the following 48 hours, detectives would learn that the woman sitting across from them was not who she claimed to be. She never had been. 12:36 During a videotaped interview at the station... The woman who had been living as Jennifer Cyber decided to come clean about at least one thing. Her true name. She told investigators, When you run my fingerprints through, they come up as 12:50 Kimberly Lee Kessler. I am 50 years old and I've been running for over 25 years. In the footage, you can see the detectives in the room exchange a glance. 13:00 They had been investigating a missing person. A presumed murder. 13:05 Now they were staring at something much larger. They had a woman with decades of false identities, who had just admitted to living as a fugitive for the majority of her adult life. At the two-hour mark of the interview, 13:18 when detectives shifted the focus to Jolene Cummings and what had happened at Tangle's Hair Salon, Jennifer Seibert, or Kimberly Kessler's, casual demeanor began to change. She said, And with that, the interview was over. Thanks for watching! As investigators began 14:11 to piece together what had happened to Jolene Cummings, they also began to unravel the staggering web of false identities that Kimberly Kessler had constructed over the course of more than two decades. According to Nassau County Sheriff Bill Lieber, 14:26 Kessler had used at least 18 different aliases across 33 cities in 14 states since 1996. In her vehicle, investigators found multiple fake documents and identification cards, each bearing a different name, a different face, and a different life. Among 14:44 the names that she had used were Jennifer Seibert, Melissa McKernan, Christina Melissa Brooke, Pamela Kleber, and Mia Stone, among many others. 14:54 She had worked as a hairdresser in some locations, but details about her movements in many of these cities remain murky. 15:01 She had drifted from state to state like a ghost, leaving behind confused landlords, alarmed co-workers, and, as investigators would soon discover, more than a few people who had been physically harmed by her. But the alias that she had 15:15 been using most recently, Jennifer Seibert, told the story all of its own. The real Jennifer Marie Seibert was born in 1974 in Butler County, Pennsylvania, the same area where Kimberly Kessler had grown up. The real Jennifer had died at just 12 or 13 years of age in a 15:33 car accident in Germany in June of 1987. She was buried at the Northside Cemetery in Butler. According to Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger, who spoke to ABC News, Kimberly Kessler would allegedly visit cemeteries to find aliases on 15:50 the gravestones, and she appears to have taken the dead girl's identity this way. Evidence from her phone backed this up. 15:57 Her browser history showed that she had been researching deceased individuals online through a website called Victimpedia, and she had been found with screenshots of obituaries, including one where she had circled a name. Her ex-boyfriend, Tim Barnes, who apparently 16:12 dated Kimberly Kessler while she was living in Pennsylvania, told detectives about an experience that seemed to confirm this pattern. 16:20 He told investigators that he recalled visiting a cemetery with her, and he said, When we went down there, the reason I thought was to see her father's grave. Instead, it appears Kimberly Kessler may have been shopping for her next identity. 16:45 In the days and weeks following the discovery of blood evidence at Tangles Hair Salon, the investigation into Jolene Cummings' murder accelerated. Investigators had already found Jolene's blood throughout the salon, but now they were building a detailed timeline, and the 17:00 evidence against Kimberly Kessler continued to mount. Surveillance footage from a nearby Walmart showed Kessler entering the store on the night of May 12th and buying a short, very specific list of items. This included 30-gallon trash bags, cleaning gloves, 17:17 a large bottle of ammonia, and, most disturbingly, an electric carving knife. A receipt confirmed the purchases. Additional surveillance footage showed Kessler returning to Tangle's hair salon after it had closed for the evening. From there, cameras captured her carrying 17:34 heavy trash bags, making multiple trips to a dumpster behind a nearby restaurant, Dick's Wings. A garbage truck later emptied that dumpster, and its contents were hauled off to a landfill. 17:46 Detectives also found a storage unit rented under the name Jennifer Seibert at a facility called Storage on Sadler in Fernandina Beach. Her personal gate code had been used to access the facility on May 12th, May 13th, and several 18:01 other days. Inside the unit, investigators found a pair of combat boots, the same boots that Kessler had been seen wearing on the day that Jolene disappeared, with dried blood drops on them. A sock inside the unit also tested 18:14 positive for blood. A Florida Department of Law Enforcement DNA analysis concluded that the blood found on the boots, the sock, and a pair of haircutting shears recovered from Kimberly Kessler's car was a near-certain match to Jolene Cummings. But perhaps 18:29 most chilling of all, investigators found part of one of Jolene's fingernails inside a blue bin in Kimberly Kessler's storage unit. 18:38 Then there was the digital evidence. A forensic examination of Kessler's iPhone revealed that on April 30th, 2018, less than two weeks before Jolene's disappearance, she had searched for According to phone records reported by News 4 Jaxx, on May 4th, 18:58 she had searched how to tie a tourniquet and inject someone with something. The next day, she bought zip ties. 19:05 And in the 48 hours after Jolene was reported missing, Kimberly Kessler searched for Jolene Cummings' name a staggering 457 times, including the phrase, Jolene Cummings, no body, no crime. She had also searched for a list of female murderers in 19:22 Florida on the website Murderpedia. So with all of this, on September 7th, 2018, a Nassau County grand jury indicted Kimberly Kessler on a charge of first-degree premeditated murder. Nassau County Sheriff's Office Detective Wayne Harrington, the lead investigator on 19:40 the case, would later lay out the theory of what had happened to Jolene Cummings. He stated, Kimberly attacked Jolene with the scissors and stabbed her. Despite this, though, Jolene Cummings' body was never found. In July of 2018, the 20:18 FBI launched a massive search at the Chesser Island Road landfill in Folkestone, Georgia, just across the state line, where the contents of that dumpster had been taken. For seven days, from 7am to 7pm, a team of 27 searchers drawn 20:33 from FBI evidence response teams in Jacksonville, Florida, Atlanta, Georgia, and Jackson, Mississippi, sifted through approximately 3,300 tons of trash in heat indexes that the FBI said reached 116 at times. 20:48 They tried to move through 6.6 million pounds of garbage. 20:52 They found what Sheriff Lieber would later describe as items of interest, which were sent to a lab for analysis. 20:59 But sadly, Jolene's remains were not among them. What followed over the next three years was one of the most chaotic pretrial periods in recent Florida memory. From the moment of her arrest, Kimberly Kessler embarked on a pattern of bizarre, erratic, 21:28 and often violent behavior that ground the legal proceedings to a near halt. She refused food again and again while incarcerated. 21:37 In June of 2018, barely a month after her arrest, she was moved to the Duval County Jail after going more than a week without eating In 2020, her attorneys told the court that she had refused to eat for 56 days. That same year, Sheriff Leeper filed a petition 21:54 asking a judge for the authority to intervene, arguing that Kessler was attempting suicide by starvation. According to that petition, she had dropped to 89 pounds. She was often wheeled into court in a wheelchair, emaciated and disoriented. Beth Smith, 22:11 a jailer at the facility where Kessler was being held, described the escalation to ABC News' 2020. She said, Kessler was subsequently charged with two counts of battery on a law enforcement officer for flinging feces at jail staff. She 22:23 refused tuberculosis testing, resulting in her being required to wear a mask during court appearances. During the pretrial process, Kessler's mental competency became a central issue. In the spring of 2019, a psychiatrist hired by her defense had found her incompetent 22:54 to stand trial. Prosecutors disagreed and asked for a second opinion. 23:00 But the state-appointed psychologist, Dr. Louis Legum, came to the same conclusion, finding that Kessler suffered from a delusional disorder. 23:09 On July 2, 2019, Circuit Judge James Daniel ruled her not competent to proceed, and she was committed to Florida State Hospital in Chattahoochee to have her competency restored. It did not take long. By that October, staff at the 23:24 hospital had notified the court that Kessler was now competent. 23:28 At a hearing in February of 2020, Dr. Graham Danzer, a psychologist at the hospital, testified that he had run Kessler through three tests and believed she could assist in her own defense. Dr. Legum disagreed, but this time on 23:42 March 24th, Judge Daniel sided with Dr. Danzer and ruled Kessler competent to stand trial. And then came the outburst. 23:52 At virtually every court appearance, Kessler would shout the same false claim. Jordan Beard is Jolene's cousin. Jordan Beard was a public defender who had previously represented Kessler. and her defense counsel told the judge that the claim was factually inaccurate. 24:10 It became so disruptive that Kessler was removed from the courtroom at nearly every hearing. Meanwhile, others who had crossed paths with Kessler since her arrest were talking to detectives. 24:22 According to documents obtained by Action News Jax, a Fernandina Beach woman told investigators that Kessler had admitted to her that she used to rob banks and she had five aliases. 24:34 Kessler herself had told detectives that she had been running from the FBI for 25 years. And several female inmates at the St. Johns County Jail told investigators that Kessler had shared her real name with them, claimed she got 24:47 her alias from a tombstone, and asked how another inmate, one charged with murder, had hidden the body of her victim. 25:11 The trial of Kimberly Kessler finally began in late November of 2021, more than three years after Jolene's disappearance. Jury selection commenced on November 29th. Almost immediately, Kessler was removed from the courtroom after shouting her familiar refrain about Jordan 25:30 Beard being Jolene's cousin. From that point forward, she was not present in the courtroom for a single day of her own murder trial. The prosecution, led by assistant state attorneys Donna Thurston and Ashley Young Terry, presented a case 25:45 built on circumstantial evidence. There was no body, no confession, no murder weapon that had been definitively identified, and no eyewitnesses to the murder itself. But what they had was a mountain of physical, digital, and forensic evidence that painted 26:00 an overwhelming picture. They walked the jury through the surveillance footage. 26:04 Kessler entering and exiting the salon, shopping for supplies at Walmart, driving Jolene's SUV to the Home Depot parking lot, disposing of heavy trash bags behind the nearby restaurant. They presented the DNA analysis showing Jolene's blood on the salon walls, 26:21 on Kessler's boots, on the haircutting shears. They showed the jury Kessler's internet search history. The 457 searches for Jolene's name the day after she went missing. The research into female murderers. And they presented testimony from those who had 26:37 known Jolene, painting a picture of a woman who would never have simply walked away from her children. Anne Johnson, Jolene's mother, took the stand and teared up when telling the jury that Jolene would never have disappeared without talking 26:50 to her kids. Jason Cummings, Jolene's ex-husband. told the jury that despite their separation, he still loved her, and that she was a devoted mother above all else. The defense, led by the Public Defender's Office and attorney Terry Sopp, 27:05 rested after calling only one witness, lead detective Wayne Harrington, who had already testified for the prosecution. The defense suggested that Jolene Cummings and Kimberly Kessler had gotten into a fight, and that Kessler's visible injuries at the time of her 27:21 arrest were evidence of self-defense. Their attorney showed Harrington a baggie, possibly containing drugs, that had been found in the salon days after Jolene disappeared. Weeks earlier, they had filed a motion claiming that the two women had argued over drugs 27:36 in the workplace. They also argued that, without a body, the state could not prove murder beyond a reasonable doubt. 27:44 In the end, the jury deliberated for just over an hour. 27:48 On December 9th, 2021, Kimberly Kessler was found guilty of first-degree murder and grand theft of a motor vehicle. State Attorney Melissa Nelson released a statement following the verdict, which read, Ann Johnson, spoke to the press after the verdict, her 28:22 voice shaking but resolute. She said, Justice has been served. 28:27 Everything that came through me was through Jolene. Jolene was here. 28:32 On January 27th, 2022, Judge James Daniel sentenced Kimberly Kessler to life in prison without the possibility of parole, along with five years for grand theft to run concurrently. Even though the life sentence was mandatory for a first-degree murder conviction, 28:50 the judge stated that he would have imposed the same sentence regardless. Kessler was wheeled into the courtroom that day, shouting, and was promptly wheeled back out. Jolene's mother, Ann Johnson, delivered a victim impact statement that captured the agony that 29:05 this family had endured over the previous three years and eight months, telling the judge that their lives had become a never-ending nightmare. She said, Nassau County Sheriff Bill Lieber had his own words for Kimberly Kessler following the sentencing. 29:18 Lieber also revealed that over the previous few years, her home going, because her new home for the rest of her life until she takes her last breath is going to be Florida State Prison. Lieber also revealed that over the previous few weeks, Kimberly Kessler had attempted to take 29:42 her own life while in custody at the Nassau County Jail. 29:46 According to jail records obtained by First Coast News, she had made two attempts since her conviction in December. Early the next morning, the day after her sentencing, she was transferred to the Florida Women's Reception Center in Marion County 30:00 to begin her sentence. Leeper treated his jail staff to cake and ice cream. But it was something else that Sheriff Leeper said in the immediate aftermath of the guilty verdict that has continued to hang over this case. He stated, 30:14 I don't believe for one second that Kimberly Kessler, or whatever name she's going by today, I don't believe this is her first murder. I don't at all. She's evil. 30:24 She's evil in the flesh. Kimberly Lee Kessler was born in 1968 and raised in Butler, a small city about 30 miles north of Pittsburgh. By most accounts, her early years were relatively unremarkable, at least on the surface. She 30:54 attended local schools and had a circle of friends, though some of those friends would later describe a noticeable shift in her personality as she got older. One unnamed high school classmate told a Nassau County detective, Another recalled Kessler 31:11 undergoing a kind of transformation, not just in personality, but in her entire outward appearance. They stated, My neighbor remembers Kim going into that like witchcraft or voodoo mode, or something real dark because around the time that Kim changed, 31:26 it wasn't just her personality that changed. It was the heavier makeup, the rougher look, the rougher clothing. She went from dating one of the most popular students in high school to this guy, who would have been a little older than Kim by a year or two. But he 31:40 was a very rough individual, partying and probably sold drugs, that type of person. After high school, Kimberly Kessler dated Tim Barnes, who told detectives about a relationship defined by sudden, shocking violence. During a phone interview, Tim Barnes told detectives, 31:59 Tim Barnes also told detectives that Kessler had killed his cat with a shotgun. When the detective on the phone told Barnes that Kessler was the main person of interest in a homicide, he said, Evidence released during the investigation 32:24 also contained interviews with friends and acquaintances who recalled Kessler attempting to hit her brother with a baseball bat, and her ex-husband, Zylon Lossie, who married Kessler twice, both times when she was using the alias Melissa McKernan while they 32:39 were living in Arizona. described her to investigators as a woman who wore many faces. A detective confirmed to Losey during their interview, She's a master of disguises. She changes her looks and wears a lot of wigs. Losey also 32:53 told police that Kimberly Kessler may have had a child while living in Jacksonville. He said, That child was real. 32:59 His name was Evans. Tim Edwards dated a woman he knew as Melissa McKernan, yet another use of that alias. 33:32 From around 1997 to 1999, the two had a son together in 1998. Kessler signed the birth certificate under the name Christina Melissa Brooke. She told Edwards that she was using aliases to prevent her family, including her mother, from 33:48 finding her. Almost immediately afterward, the relationship deteriorated rapidly. Tim Edwards described Kessler as having a temper, and said that something changed in her at around the time she lost custody of their son, Evan. According to Timothy Edwards... Kessler 34:04 showed up at social services carrying a handgun in an attempt to get Evan back. Edwards later told First Coast News, I honestly don't because I haven't spoken to her or seen her since. When asked whether Kessler was a violent person, 34:32 Edwards paused for a long time before responding, Edwards told detectives that Kessler had tried to rope him into what he described only as a violent event at around that same time. He declined to provide any further details publicly, 34:52 saying that he had discussed it with the FBI. Kessler's mother, Connie Kessler, told investigators that her daughter began using aliases in 2004, seeming to blame Tim Edwards for telling Kessler that Evan had died. According to Connie, Kimberly said that 35:09 she feared the father of her child and wanted to find where her son was buried. But Tim Edwards disputed this claim entirely. After all, Evan was alive and in his custody. And the timeline did not match up regardless, since Kimberly Kessler had been using fake names since at 35:27 least 1997. In July of 2004, Kimberly Kessler was last seen in Butler, Pennsylvania. According to Pennsylvania State Police, before leaving, she told family members that she was heading south to assume a new identity. She had even picked out the 35:43 name already, Pamela Kleber. But her family would not report her missing until 2012, eight years later. When Pennsylvania State Police eventually looked into the case, trooper Jim Long told reporters that they had never believed she was a genuine 35:59 missing person. He said, Between 2004 and 2018, the 14 years between Kessler's disappearance from Pennsylvania and the murder of Jolene Cummings, Kessler drifted across the country under an ever-rotating cast of identities. Including the years before she left Butler, 36:23 she lived in at least 33 cities across 14 states, working various jobs, moving frequently, avoiding the kind of long-term relationships or connections that might expose her. In Rochester, Minnesota, she rented an apartment under the name Jennifer Seibert from 36:39 a man named Bill Dunn, who was a doctor at the Mayo Clinic. Dunn was her landlord for approximately a year before he says he was forced to terminate her lease. 36:49 He later told a Nassau County detective, She had quite a bit of obvious personality disorder. She had no furniture in her apartment. She would not allow me to give her furniture. Dunn told investigators that Kessler had become too 37:03 dangerous and too paranoid to keep around, and he did not feel safe being around her alone. This pattern of short stays, alarmed landlords, frightened acquaintances, and sudden departures seems to have defined the majority of Kimberly Kessler's adult life. 37:20 She maintained fake identities on social media, including a Facebook profile under the name Mia Stone, which she used to contact a childhood friend's cousin. That cousin, David Trempus, would later learn that Kessler had driven from Florida to Texas 37:36 to propose marriage to him, seemingly out of nowhere. Kim McCall, a childhood friend of Kessler's who used to ride horses with her, told First Coast News that a detective had informed her family about the stalking. The detective told him 37:49 that she was stalking him under several different profiles on Facebook. 37:54 Evidence from Kessler's phone also showed that she was reading obituaries online, circling names and keeping lists of names with no explanation. She searched for deceased individuals on various websites and kept screenshots of those searches on her phone. It 38:09 was a systematic approach to identity theft, and one that she had apparently been perfecting for decades. But the darkest questions surrounding Kimberly Kessler aren't about the aliases, or the fake documents, or even the murder of Jolene Cummings. The 38:27 darkest questions are the ones that remain unanswered. The ones that Sheriff Lieber was alluding to when he said that he did not believe this was Kimberly Kessler's first murder. 38:37 Within the hundreds of pages of evidence released during the investigation, The I-team from News 4 Jax found that investigators from both the FBI and the Nassau County Sheriff's Office had asked questions about two other deaths that appeared to intersect 38:51 with Kessler's life. The first involved a man named Kurt Christopher Allen, who died in Jacksonville in 2014. On Kessler's iPhone, investigators found a list of more than 60 names, alongside the words Satanist, Witch, and Evil Murderous Gang. Front and 39:10 center on that list was the name Kurt Christopher Allen. 39:13 In phone interviews, investigators repeatedly asked Kessler's acquaintances about Bob Allen, and whether he also went by the name Christopher Kurt Allen. 39:23 In fact, an unnamed woman who went to high school with Kessler told detectives, She went from dating the most popular guy in school to dating Bob Allen. The I-Team found an obituary for a Kurt Christopher Allen who died in Jacksonville in 2014. The obituary did not list a 39:40 cause of death, and investigators have not publicly stated whether or how Allen's death was connected to Kessler. But the fact that his name was on her phone and that investigators were asking about him specifically raises questions that have 39:54 not been publicly answered. The second death that investigators have looked into involved a woman named Grace, who died in Kessler's hometown in 2009. The I-Team believes that investigators were referring to Grace Darling Bartley. Bartley's cause of death was 40:11 not listed in her obituary either, but she was married to a man named Tim Bartley. Both Tim Bartley and his brother, Wayne, appeared on Kessler's list of names. Investigators repeatedly asked about the Bartley brothers during interviews, and it 40:26 is believed that they went to high school with Kessler and that she may have dated one of them. One of Kessler's unnamed classmates provided yet another lead to investigators, one that predated all of these. They stated, Back in 1987, 40:41 the year I graduated, my best friend was killed in a motorcycle accident. Back in the day, people said, oh, maybe someone ran them off the road, if you could just check into that. It is unclear whether investigators followed up on any of these leads, or what, if anything, 40:55 they found. Kimberly Kessler has never been charged with any other murders. But the constellation of unanswered questions has led many to wonder whether Jolene Cummings was truly the only victim. 41:08 After all, she had the long trail of aliases, the violent history, the paranoid behavior, the list of names on her phone... the deaths that intersected her orbit, and the long chunk of time in which we don't know where she was or what she was doing. In the years 41:28 since her conviction, Kimberly Kessler has continued to fight her sentence from behind the bars. Her public defenders appealed, and on October 31st, 2023, Florida's 5th District Court of Appeal affirmed her conviction and sentence without a written opinion. Then, 41:45 in the summer of 2024, Kessler took matters into her own hands. She filed a handwritten 224-page motion on notebook paper, asking for her conviction to be thrown out. In it, she claimed that Jolene Cummings is merely a missing person, 42:01 not a murder victim, and that the evidence against her was circumstantial and insufficient. She accused witnesses of lying, claimed that she had been framed, and insisted that she was at a gym in Jacksonville at the time surveillance footage 42:15 showed her driving Jolene's vehicle. She also insisted that she had never been disruptive or disrespectful during her trial, despite the hours of courtroom footage showing otherwise. She cited 62 laws and cases as precedent. In December of 2024, while 42:33 that motion was still working its way through the state court in Nassau County, Kessler also filed a petition in federal court, In February of 2025, U.S. District Judge Marcia Morales Howard dismissed it as premature because Kessler had not 42:49 finished her appeals at the state level. The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed her follow-up appeal that April after she failed to file the required paperwork. And on January 12th, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear her case. As 43:06 of this recording, Kimberly Kessler remains incarcerated in the Florida state prison system, serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole. She has never revealed what happened to Jolene Cummings' remains. She has never shown remorse. And she has 43:22 never explained the full scope of what she was running from for all of those years, or who else may have crossed her path during her long, shadowy journey across America. 43:39 Jolene Cummings was 34 years old when she disappeared. She was a mother of three. She was beloved by everyone who knew her. And she was taken from all of them. 43:50 Her friends, her family, her community, her children. In one of the most senseless acts of violence you'll ever hear about. 43:57 Her mother, Ann Johnson, has continued to advocate for Jolene's memory in the years since her daughter's murder. She has spoken publicly about the toll this case has taken on her family, and has never stopped pleading for the return 44:10 of Jolene's remains. If you have any information about this case, or about Kimberly Kessler's movements during the years she spent crisscrossing the country under false identities, please contact the Nassau County Sheriff's Office or the FBI's Jacksonville Field Office. You 44:26 can also leave an anonymous tip with First Coast Crime Stoppers at 866-845-8477. As of this episode's recording, the story of Jolene Cummings remains unresolved. Thank you for listening to this episode of Unresolved. Before I go, I want to 45:15 thank the people who make this show possible. The producers of Unresolved, who support it every single month on Patreon. 45:23 These awesome people are... Alex Kalogaropoulos, Robert Porter III, Stacey Hauser, Kevin Tweedy, Anna T, Cece, Marcus Mitchell, Donya Alchemist, Tabitha Colvin, Trixie Fink, Beck Empress, Elizabeth Bolas, Caroline Dijon, Brutalist, J-Law, 45:55 Thomas Budkin, Catherine Rich, Sophie Wise, Letitia Ortiz, Barry Ronk, Kathy Conop, Fractalman, Amy Haynes, Jamie Stevenson, Heather Horton-Wieden, and Elizabeth Colecchio. Hopefully I got that name right. If I did not, if I messed up any of your names, 46:15 please let me know and I will correct it in the future. But anyways, if I just said your name, each and every one of you help keep the lights on around here, and I am so incredibly grateful. If you listening out there would like to see your own 46:27 name on that list... please head over to patreon.com slash unresolvedpod. 46:32 A dollar a month gets you every episode of Unresolved early and ad-free. $ 2. 50 a month adds the Unresolved bonus episodes. 46:41 $ 5 a month gets you Resolved, the show we make just for Patreon. And the higher tiers come with some exclusive merch and producer credits, which means I will read your name at the end of episodes just like this one. Now, as I said at the beginning of the episode, if 46:55 a monthly pledge isn't doable right now, that is completely fine. 46:59 Something incredibly valuable you can do to help this show is completely free. You can give us a rating or a review on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you happen to be listening. After all, there's no network behind this podcast, 47:13 no investors, no big money sponsors. It's just me, the people on that list, and listeners like you telling a friend about it. For a completely independent show like this one, that's how new people find us. And whatever help you can give means more than I can say. So thank 47:28 you all for what you do. Until next time, I hope you all stay safe and stay healthy. And please take care of yourselves. Bye everyone.
Community discussion