0:02 Hello and welcome to your True Crime Podcast. On May 30, 2023, a man was lured to a garage in Mansfield, Ohio, with the promise of a job opportunity and was seriously injured in an attack. Detectives later questioned Chad Henthorne about 0:17 what happened. You'll hear excerpts from that interrogation. 0:21 Where's he at? Where's he at? Fucking watching us. Stand up, you're going to take care of here. Threatened Jim all day today. All right. Well, we can't. She talked to Perry. 0:33 I know. I know. And she got her brought in, too. 0:38 I know. I know. She's got some other stuff she's got to answer for. Do you want to take them out of them so you can sign this? I mean, I ain't going there. Listen, here's the deal, man. If you do something stupid in here, we're just going to 0:51 rock your world. Okay? We don't want to do that. 0:53 I know. I haven't done either. All right. So when he's done, we're going to have you sit down. I've always been brought to you. Okay. All right, so all those rights that he read, I'm going to need your initials all down there. I need you to sign this 1:07 right here first saying that we read those rights to you, okay? 1:11 Can I ask you an honest question, though? Sure can. 1:14 I mean, is your intent to charge me for something on this? Well, we've got to figure out what you're going to say. We don't know your story. Oh, the truth. 1:21 That's what I'm going to say. All right. Well, I appreciate that. The truth is what we need right now. 1:28 You have to sign both of them. How is he? 1:33 Not good. No? No. Like, not really. He's still alive? 1:39 He's still alive. Okay. So, let me ask you a question. 1:48 You want to talk to me, right? Yes, I do. 1:50 All right. So, let me ask you a question, Chad. 1:53 What happened on that night? I did. Mm-hmm. What happened? 1:58 I was in the garage working on bikes and my buddy, I mean, I've known him, we've known each other for a long time. Who? Rob Virgilio. Okay. That's his name. 2:10 He started coming around and got into the bikes, you know, and so he was coming every day helping me run bikes. Okay. 2:17 And he started getting real, I don't know, I want to start at the beginning. I'm not defending him at all, but I was starting to get possessive towards my old lady. 2:31 Who's your old lady, Jennifer? Jen. Okay. And, uh, like, over my kid, and, I mean, he was threatening people that would come over and stuff. This was all, like, about two weeks, probably, before this incident happened. And, uh, I mean, I had said some things to him about it, 2:48 you know, but, and he'd calm down, and then, the next day or two, you know, he'd say something again. And, uh, So, whatever. Anyways, I went down to Luke. I think his name's Aswell. 3:06 I went down to his house to get him. He was going to help me meter valve four carburetors on 750. Okay. 3:16 Rob had just pulled up, and he pulled around the back of my garage, like through the yard. Okay. I'm like, what the f * * * are you doing, Rob? 3:25 And he's like, oh, that ain't nothing, man. I'm sorry, Rob. 3:28 I want to do it again. Okay. I said, well, I'm going down to Luke's to get him. You're going to go where? Luke's. Okay. Which, you know, we're going to walk. Yep, yep. We're going to go right to that little trailer park. Yep. So, I used to hit 3:44 his car, though. Okay. And I drove down there, and Luke was on the couch, and I told him, I said, hey, you ready? You know, I am. So, I'm going to get him first. There's more about it than I do it. Uh, Jen, Jen had left. She went to the store. She walked 4:03 to the store. Um, my daughter was not even there. Um, because they shut the water off a few days before. 4:10 And I was told that that's a good way to lose your kid is not have water at all. So I sent her to the babysitter. She was there. It was, uh, the second day. She was there the week before for a few days. It's the first time she's ever been 4:24 out without us. Um, and then, She was there for, that was the second day that she was there. When I got back, opened my garage door, and I had, it was, it was bad, man. So when you got back from doing that, you opened the garage door. And 4:43 what did you see in the garage door? Fucking, uh, garage was jilted over the top of that guy. And it was probably everywhere, man. Probably everywhere. So, prior to that, when Rob came in the back, you know, He had a guy with him. He said he was a friend 5:01 of his or something. At what point did you leave? 5:04 Right then, after he got here. So you left? In his vehicle. Was anybody else in the garage with you? 5:12 Shannon Johnson. So what was he doing in there? He always stops and hangs out for an hour or whatever. 5:21 So you saw nothing inside the garage then? No, I didn't. 5:27 I came back, yes. That's when you saw it? Yes. Okay. 5:32 Is that you? Yes. Okay. Yeah, it's an old picture. 5:36 I thought you were going to be honest with me, but you're lying to me already. What's that? That's you. Yeah. 5:45 Setting up a video camera. We have it all on video. 5:49 Every bit of it we have on video. We have you inside that garage when he's getting his ass kicked with a chain. I was not that. No, you didn't. 5:59 We have you on video in there while it's going down. 6:02 You eventually leave. Yeah, and you shut the door. You're there when the assault first started. You shut the garage door so the guy can't leave. Why would you do that? 6:10 I didn't shut the door. You never shut that garage door. 6:14 Maybe I did. Maybe I did. Yeah. Yeah. Why did you do that? I don't know. Now the guy can't leave. 6:23 He's getting his ass kicked and he can't leave. So explain to me why you did that. Did you think he was going to survive that beating? No. No, no, no, no. 6:36 Look at this. I promise you, man. Chad, understand this. 6:40 Stop for a second. Understand this. I seen him with the chain, and I got the out of there. Okay, so now you want to be honest with me now, right? 6:47 You saw him hit him with the chain. I can't not be honest with you. I can't not be honest. Okay, so I didn't know, all I know is the guy, I was handing the guy a f * * * ing lighter. I know you were, I saw it. And so was Shannon. I saw that too. We both went 7:02 to hand him the lighter. And this f * * * ing idiot comes in, I didn't know what to f * * * ing do, man. I got more in town than Dinah, more in town than Manseal, you know. Shelby? 7:13 You do? So did you do anything else inside the garage? No, I left. When you came back in, what did you do? 7:21 When I came back, uh... Shit. Come in. Luke was letting him go. Yeah, Luke saved his life, probably. Thanks fucking God. Mm-hmm. Uh... And then he stumbled out back or something, and I went out there. The neighbor lady talked to us, and we told her we were trying 7:46 to get him help. Okay. So, clearly... Well, that's not necessarily true. Okay? I knew it was not true, but I'm telling you, I did. That's what... I went back out the door... Chad, listen to me. Everything from start to finish is on that videotape. So what did you 8:08 do when he fled out the door? What did you do after that? What did you come back inside and do? 8:16 Before he actually let him out, As Luke was letting him loose, what did you do? What did you have in your hand? Because I'm going to tell you what you had in your hand. And it's going to be all over. Your DNA is going to be all over that. 8:28 What DNA? I've got my DNA all over it. Okay. Well, I have video of you holding a crowbar. Oh, well, what did I do? Pick it up or something? Yeah. 8:38 And what else did you do after that? When you left, when he came back out, what did you do? I was in shock. What did you smash? And where did you dispose of it? What was it? I think it was my phone. Whose phone was it? I don't know. 8:58 Why are you smashing your phone? Are you smashing your phone? Rob. 9:03 I wasn't smashing my phone. I don't know who smashed it. 9:05 Why are you smashing Rob's phone? That's what I thought. 9:08 Why would you be smashing Rob's phone? What sense does that make? I don't even know. I was in shock. Man, I promise you. I didn't know what I was doing. 9:16 I do remember smashing the phone though. And where'd you put it? Where's the phone at? In the garage. Where? 9:25 Think about where you put the phone. I don't remember. Dude, I don't know what I was doing. So you had his coat in your hand, right? Who? You had his jacket that he was wearing, that army jacket. Who's jacket? 9:39 The guy that... Mm-hmm. Why would I have that in my hand? I don't know. You tell me. Where did I come up with that? Inside the garage. Or outside. 9:48 You came back in with it. When I came back in, the door was open. The back door. Not the side door. Right, the back door. And I came in there, there was blood like this. Yeah. And there was something, and I pushed it, and I seen it all, and I took it, 10:09 and I put it in the room. That's where you put the phone. I don't know, you put the jacket outside. 10:20 So let me ask you this. Let me ask you this. Yes. 10:25 Why did you set that video camera up the way you set that video camera up? What do you mean why? 10:30 Because I was having a test story on my guys. 10:34 So I set it up just to catch anybody stealing from me. That's a fact. Okay. So you're going to go to a jury trial, right? You're going to go to a jury and you're going to expect that jury to to believe that you set that video camera up. 10:48 I've been up there for three months, bud. Seriously, I promise you. Why did you set it back up that night? 10:54 What do you mean? We have the whole scan disc. 10:56 We have the whole drive. What drive are you talking about? 11:00 The only thing I have is a little white camera. Right, and there's a disc inside of that that we recovered. 11:04 I don't know. So there's no other video. There's a disc in the front one. Right, and on that one. 11:10 There's no other coverage. There's no other footage on there. 11:12 See that? Right there in that corner. Yeah. That camera's seen the door and the big door. It's seen the whole garage. If you look at it, I watched it. Yeah. 11:23 That's why I put it there. It watches the whole garage. 11:25 So it just so happened to be convenient that you did it that night? What do you mean, that night? 11:32 The night when he was asleep. I never went back. 11:38 I've never been back to that house. That's not what I'm saying. That's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is the night that day when he came over to fix motorcycles under the guise of fixing motorcycles, I have 11:51 you in the corner over there fixing that video camera. Why? Why? Now, listen. 11:57 I do know why. Did Robert tell you to do that? No, he did not. If you look, go back on it and you'll see. It was covered up. And I was pissed. 12:07 My camera was covered up. And Rob said to somebody, I don't remember who, but it's only one of our, we got everything recorded from Rob. Everything he said, everything he's done. Where's that at? I don't know. Some of them have already been sent to Perry. Okay. Okay. And 12:25 then today, all the touching stuff he made, I don't know if they've been sent or not. My girlfriend Jen has them. So where's Robert right now? Listen. I could get him. I don't know where he's at. I promise you that. I do not know, because if I did, 12:40 you'd already have a... He threatened my girl all day today. 12:45 All f * * * ing day. He threatened her. Listen, that camera, I was standing there with Troy Jack and Shannon Johnson, all right? And I was flipped out on both of them a hundred times over. I was with my cameras, because they turned them up. And I looked, 13:02 and I seen there was all these rags. As a matter of fact, Rob even talked about putting that orange rag on that camera. He planned this. He had to. 13:11 Why else would he cover that camera? So, why did you come out tonight? What made you tired? Got tired of running? Yes. And this needs to be handled. I mean... Okay. 13:26 I don't know what I can do to make you believe me, but... Well, you didn't start off right. I know that. I know that. Okay, so right now you've got warrants out of Richland County, Shelby, Edina. Yes. Okay, so you're going to go sit on those warrants. I 13:43 hear that. That's going to be a rough minute, too. Okay. 13:45 But listen, I've just bought that house, all right? She's going to be two in December. Here are those daughters. 13:55 They took, you know, because of him calling Children's Services. Rob? Yes. 14:01 That's why they took her. He mixed every bit of it on recordings. Okay. We recorded everything. Listen, man, I promise you, I don't do shit like that at all. Okay. 14:12 I don't. I'm a pretty good guy, actually. Okay. I've got a drug problem now. So, when's the last time you did drugs? Today. Okay. What's your drug of choice? 14:23 Isn't that... But... All right. Do you have anything else to add to your statement? I mean... I want to tell you, I don't know what else to tell you, but I didn't know what to do. I didn't. I've never seen. Why did you come to us? When I 14:40 went down, because I was warning. And my kid was already at the baby station. He didn't have water. Jim was scared to death. Rob dragged a hold of her after. 14:52 I know. She told me. And she was scared to death. 14:55 I didn't know what to do. The only thing I could do was take my girlfriend. I mean, we've been together three years, man. Okay. Let's take her and get her out of there so that she can feel safe. 15:05 And we've been hiding ever since. All right, people already, I mean, well, I know. All right, so right now, like I said, you're going to go and sit on your wards, okay? Well, I mean, can you tell me honestly? 15:22 I mean, I'll testify against him, whatever, okay? I don't know where he's at, but I can tell you a few places you might be able to look. Where? There's a girl named Scott. He frequently goes there. Believe it or not, he goes to the Speedway about every night 15:37 that this other girl is working. She lives on 750 Maple? 47, I think is the number, maybe. 750 Maple? It's a local city department, yeah. Number 47, though, I think. I don't really know that because we didn't take a shower there. So, 15:56 where else does she go? He... Bob... Yeah. Speedway? Yeah, he's up there every night. I'll tell you the same thing. 16:07 She talks to that girl at work there, and she... Rob, he's still going to come in even though he knows he's wanted? He just did it last night. The night before that. 2013, so... Okay. And it's... He beat it with a ball bat in my front yard three days 16:27 before this happened. Just flipped out out of the front yard, beating this vehicle with a ball bat. Okay. I mean, I don't know what happened to him. I really don't. 16:37 Something did, though. And it's bad. All right. So I will let the prosecutor know that you're talking to me. Okay? Obviously, like we said earlier, we can't make any threats or promises to you. I know that. We'll talk to the prosecutor. Okay? Okay. 16:53 So right now we're going to end the statement and you're going to go set your warrants. You're going to get dope sick, but you'll be clean. I hope not. 17:04 I don't do dope. It's just meth. Okay. But there's a guy named Rich. I don't know his last name. 17:11 There's another one in Kentucky somewhere. Is it Ricky? Ricky Miller? Rich? Rich? 17:20 If you show me a picture, I can tell you if it's him or not. But he hangs out there. 17:23 He's been going there a lot, I know. He literally... 17:30 So he's not fleeing the states? No, he's not, man. 17:33 He's right here. He keeps saying, we're owing money. Yeah, I talked to somebody today about that. He keeps saying that we got guns. He said he did. Now, the pistol... 17:47 A pistol? A handgun? Yeah, that's what he said. He said he had a gun. He was coming to kill me. 17:53 He was coming to kill Luke. I mean, he... So you knew this was all going to go down, right? 18:01 What happened in the garage? No. I did not know anything about this. He showed up with a guy I'd never seen before in my life, ever. And said he was a buddy of his. That was out there. I knew you don't have that on video. Why would you 18:18 come back in your garage, panic and pick up a... 18:22 Because I'm willing to get hit and fuck out of there. 18:24 You grab a chainsaw, you pick it up and you move that. Chainsaw, yeah. Yeah, you picked up a chainsaw, you moved it. You're wiping things down. You're wiping things down like you're cleaning up the area. There's no cleaning that up. I know I did push that. I saw 18:37 it in the video too. I understand. And just so, by looking at it, it looks to me, I want to tell you what it looks to me. I'm looking at it. It looks like you're setting this up like there's going to be an event that's going to happen. 18:48 The next thing, a boy comes in. The next thing, another guy comes in, wails him with a chain. They get to a fight, hits him with a chain. He grabs a crowbar, stomps him, everything else, okay? Then we watch all this. You come back in later. First thing 19:04 you do, you go over there by, well, I remember, you go grab a chainsaw. You move that. You got a crowbar. You're wiping stuff off. You grab a comb. 19:13 You're smashing it, you got it wrapped in your shirt so you don't have your prints on the phone or DNA, okay? 19:18 You remember doing that? So it's like, listen to me. 19:22 So what I'm looking at, I'm thinking, you knew this was all going on, and you're there to help clean up so you're not implicated in anything there, right? You get what I'm saying? I do, totally. You see our perspective, right? Yeah, 19:35 that's right. I get it. Yeah, you understand that, right? 19:40 I mean, the dude almost died. And it's just hard for me to believe that you didn't know that this was going to go down. I promise you I did not know. I promise. What was this about? I didn't even fucking know. Not even probably. Not yesterday. Nothing that 19:55 came up. I mean, I've heard rumors. I've heard rumors that he did it for somebody because he beat his daughter up. That's the only thing I've been told. Who's this? Dad, I don't know. I don't know. I don't even have a name. All I know is I heard that. And 20:16 that's why he said something about he's supposed to have money. 20:20 I've never done any shit like that in my life. Ever. 20:23 I will do it. This is your house. It's mine. 20:26 I know. It's on their property. Dude's getting whaled on. 20:30 After this getting wailed on a couple times, you jump over. 20:33 I'm going to go out the back door. And shut the door. You didn't call 911, did you? You didn't try to intervene, nothing? No, I do not know what the f * * * is going on. Dude, I never seen anybody get hit with a f * * * ing chain. Okay, but you did see it, though. Yeah, 20:48 I didn't know what to do. After the fact, the dude is running for his life, screaming for help. I went down the route. Because I didn't know what to do. 20:56 So me and Luke went back. Where was Luke at? 20:58 His trailer. How far is that from your house? It's fucking right through on the road. Yeah, it's literally right through. 21:06 It's two houses at the end of the street, and there's a tree line right through there, and there's a trailer park. And that's what I went and got. And I got with him, and I told him, there's something I didn't know what to do. So he came back 21:20 to help me. Why do you have a cell phone in your shirt? I don't know. You see what I'm saying? 21:26 I'm looking at that. I understand. I think you've got a heart. You've got a heart. I don't know what to tell you. It is what it is, you know? 21:36 It doesn't look good. No. I know it don't. That's why I'll do anything you need to do. I will. 21:44 Who else wants the truth? I'm telling you the truth. 21:45 I did it. I went and got Luke. We come back. 21:48 Luke said... He was tied. Yeah, he was tied in the vice coach's arm. Luke saved that dude's life. You realize that, right? I know. And I looked at Luke. 21:58 You didn't ask him. I'm not saying you didn't, but... 22:01 I did. I didn't know what to do. I pinned. 22:04 Straight pinned. I was high, and I was like, oh my God, what the... So you guys making meth? No. 22:12 You just use it? Yes. Not making no meth. There's no dice here, James. You don't affiliate with anybody? I was an A.B. a long time ago. I could see that. 22:22 I mean, I'll probably get that. And I ain't even known that. I haven't been for years. I'm telling you. I, I panicked. I did. Normally, I'm cool, smooth. I mean, I've never been in a situation like this, ever. But, I didn't know what the fuck to do, man. I 22:40 just didn't. And I, the warrants, and, Jen, you know, she's fucking grabbed her, threatened her, and, The only way to protect people like that is through love. I know it is. I do. I mean, the street stuff is only good for so long. It doesn't look where you're 22:56 at now. Yeah. Right? So if you want to get taken care of, you come, you turn yourself in. I would have done it too when they came out. Well, finally. 23:05 I know. I was packing a search warrant. Swallow's going to come kick your door in. You don't want that. No, I don't. And believe it or not, I mean, you can talk to the metrics. I've worked with all of them. 23:19 I don't doubt that. I'm not saying... I'm not this guy. 23:22 I don't know what happened. Listen, we're not saying you're a bad guy. You just made a bad decision not to call us when it all went down. Okay? For sure. 23:30 We're going to be done with this, okay? I'm not going to talk about nothing else about it, but I know there's nobody to even get me out, but if I could go, I would get that motherfucker for you. 23:45 I mean, you've got warrants, man. There's nothing I can do. Oh, I know that. We can talk to the prosecutor about our charges we have on you. Okay? Which we don't know yet. It's up to the prosecutor. It's not up to us at this point. Okay? I can talk to him. 24:01 All right? We'll talk to him. But you still have to take care of your responsibilities that you already have outstanding right now. Yeah, I know that. That's what I have. 24:08 So you're going to give me treatment. Okay. Well, then maybe that's what you need. It is. 24:12 Chad Henthorne was convicted of complicity to kidnapping, complicity to felonious assault, and two counts of tampering with evidence. In January 2026, an Ohio appeals court upheld his convictions but ordered resentencing after finding an error in the kidnapping sentence. 24:28 You've been listening to True Crime from Podcast Studios. Thanks for being here, and we'll see you in the next one.
Community discussion