True Crime Garage artwork
Podcast · True Crime · New episodes usually on Wednesday

True Crime Garage

85 episodes 0 followers
Support

At the table this season

NEW Season 1 Nov 18, 2026 · 51 min

Burger Chef Murders /// Part 3 /// 971

On November 17, 1978, four young employees disappeared from the Burger Chef located at 5725 Crawsfordville Road in Speedway, Indiana. Late that night as they performed their closing routine, Burger Chef Assistant Manager Jayne Fried and her teenaged colleagues, Ruth Shelton, Daniel David, and Mark Flemmonds vanished - leaving an eerily empty restaurant with its back door ajar. $581 was missing from the restaurant. Two days later and over twenty miles away their lifeless bodies were found. The case is still unsolved and involves many unproven theories, including drugs, and a robbery gang. We do our best to touch on all of the theories. During these episodes we also discuss the unsolved murder of Mary Ann Higginbotham and the disappearance of Timothy Willoughby.

Moments: 0
0:00 50:46
Ask the hosts

Your questions for the next episode

When True Crime Garage joins OndaCast, the hosts see these first.

Your question goes to the community board, tied to True Crime Garage. The most upvoted ones get answered on air.

No questions yet

Ask True Crime Garage anything. When the hosts join OndaCast they will see every question.

The True Crime Garage table

Notes from the hosts, episode talk and everything posted with #truecrimegarage on the Community Board.
Be the first at the True Crime Garage table

Share a thought about an episode, suggest a guest or say hello.

Lines people keep sharing

Make the first clip

Pick 15 seconds you love and share them.