0401 » The Rings of Power » S3E2 » The Gift Of Men » 10 Critical Problems
5 CONTRADICTIONS & 5 CRINGE MOMENTS
Season 3 of The Rings of Power continues, and we're back with another installment of 10 Critical Problems!
This time we're examining Episode 2, "The Gift of Men," and the show's increasingly questionable portrayal of Númenor.
From confusing the Gift of Ilúvatar with the authority of the Valar to rewriting Ar-Pharazôn's usurpation, mangling the Second Age timeline, and somehow still failing to forge the One Ring, there's plenty to discuss.
And then there's the cringe: an insecure Pharazôn, the Faithful turned into political revolutionaries, the palantír used like a telephone, Meneltarma wine, and yet more crude Dwarf humor.
But our fundamental complaint goes deeper than lore accuracy.
The greatest problem with The Rings of Power isn't simply what it changes about Tolkien's stories. It's what those changes rob us of.
Join us as we explore what Amazon changed, what Tolkien actually wrote, and what we're missing because of those changes.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
TIMESTAMPS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
INTRODUCTION
00:00 — Welcome to 10 Critical Problems: Episode 2
00:29 — Why Númenor's tragedy matters
5 CONTRADICTIONS OF TOLKIEN
01:06 — #1: The Gift of Ilúvatar, not the Valar
02:36 — #2: Pharazôn's rewritten usurpation
03:46 — #3: Númenor's civil strife and King's Men
05:08 — #4: The Second Age timeline makes no sense
06:42 — #5: The One Ring STILL doesn't exist!
5 CRINGE MOMENTS
07:55 — #6: Pharazôn looks and acts all wrong
09:09 — #7: The Faithful become political revolutionaries
10:29 — #8: The wasted potential of the palantír
11:29 — #9: Meneltarma Reserve? Sacred mountain wine!
12:33 — #10: More crude Dwarf humor
CONCLUSION
13:42 — Mortality, pride, and Númenor's true tragedy
14:28 — Tolkien's Tragedy: Concerning Númenor
14:56 — Your thoughts on Episode 2
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
BIG TAKEAWAYS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
• THE GIFT OF ILÚVATAR: Mortality is the gift of Eru Ilúvatar, not the Valar. This distinction is essential to the spiritual tragedy of Númenor.
• PHARAZÔN'S USURPATION: Tolkien's proud, powerful, and arrogant king becomes an insecure politician, diminishing the tragedy of his character.
• NÚMENOR'S LOST HISTORY: The compression of more than a thousand years of history robs the story of its gradual spiritual decline.
• THE ONE RING: Sauron's master scheme remains unfinished even as the War of the Elves and Sauron rages.
• THE FAITHFUL: The show's political resistance movement misses much of the spiritual and religious significance of Tolkien's Faithful.
• WHAT WE LOST: Númenor's tragedy is about a blessed people who come to resent their mortality, ultimately sacrificing everything in pursuit of power and immortality.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
DISCOVER TOLKIEN'S TRAGEDY
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Want to discover the Second Age as Tolkien actually envisioned it?
Check out Tolkien's Tragedy: Concerning Númenor, an exploration of the rise and fall of the greatest kingdom of Men, and the spiritual tragedy of a civilization undone by its fear of death and desire for power.
GET THE BOOK:
https://tolkienstragedy.com/
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
What did you think of Season 3, Episode 2?
Did we miss any major contradictions? What made you cringe? And was there anything you actually liked?
Let us know in the comments!
More critical problems are coming in Episode 3.
THE ROAD GOES EVER ON!
Become a supporter of this podcast:
The Tolkien Road
SubscribeSign in
Playback speed
×
Share post
Share post at current time
Share from 0:00
0:00
/
0401: The Rings of Power S3E2 - The Gift Of Men - 10 Critical Problems
Rings of Power S3E2: 5 Tolkien contradictions, 5 cringe moments, and why Amazon's Númenor misses the tragedy of Tolkien's Second Age.
John Carswell
Share
Transcript
Season 3 of The Rings of Power continues, and we’re back with another installment of 10 Critical Problems: 5 Contradictions and 5 Cringe Moments!
This time, we’re examining Episode 2, “The Gift of Men,” and the show’s increasingly questionable portrayal of Númenor.
From confusing the Gift of Ilúvatar with the authority of the Valar to rewriting Ar-Pharazôn’s usurpation, compressing centuries of Númenórean history, and somehow still failing to forge the One Ring, there’s plenty to discuss.
And then there’s the cringe: an insecure Ar-Pharazôn, the Faithful transformed into a generic political resistance movement, the palantír reduced to fantasy telecommunications equipment, a mysterious Meneltarma wine vintage, and yet another unfortunate moment of Dwarf humor.
But the deeper problem remains the same:
The greatest problem with The Rings of Power isn’t simply what it changes about Tolkien’s stories. It’s what those changes rob us of.
Tolkien’s Númenor is a magnificent tragedy about mortality, pride, and a civilization that possesses almost everything the world can offer, yet comes to resent the very limits of its existence.
Join us as we explore what Amazon changed, what Tolkien actually wrote, and why the original story is so much more compelling.
TIMESTAMPS
INTRODUCTION
00:00 — Welcome to 10 Critical Problems: Episode 2
00:29 — Why Númenor’s tragedy matters
5 CONTRADICTIONS OF TOLKIEN
01:06 — #1: Death is the Gift of Ilúvatar, not the Valar
02:36 — #2: Ar-Pharazôn’s usurpation has been rewritten
03:46 — #3: Númenor’s civil strife and the King’s Men
05:08 — #4: The Second Age timeline still makes no sense
06:42 — #5: Sauron STILL hasn’t forged the One Ring!
5 CRINGE MOMENTS
07:55 — #6: Ar-Pharazôn looks and acts nothing like Tolkien’s king
09:09 — #7: The Faithful become a generic resistance movement
10:29 — #8: The palantír is another missed opportunity
11:29 — #9: Meneltarma Reserve? Númenor’s sacred mountain gets a wine vintage
12:33 — #10: The Dwarves just can’t stop being gross
CONCLUSION
13:42 — The tragedy of Númenor: mortality, pride, and power
14:28 — Discover Tolkien’s Tragedy: Concerning Númenor
14:56 — Your thoughts on Episode 2
BIG TAKEAWAYS
The Gift of Ilúvatar: The distinction between Ilúvatar and the Valar is fundamental to understanding Númenor’s rebellion against mortality.
Ar-Pharazôn’s usurpation: Tolkien’s mighty and arrogant king is transformed into an insecure political operator, diminishing the tragedy of his character.
The lost centuries of Númenor: Compressing more than a thousand years of history eliminates much of the gradual spiritual decline that makes the Downfall so compelling.
The One Ring problem continues: Sauron’s master scheme is still unfinished even as the War of the Elves and Sauron rages.
The Faithful misunderstood: Rather than emphasizing their spiritual and religious identity, the show portrays them primarily as political revolutionaries.
What we’re missing: Tolkien’s Númenor is not fundamentally a story about political intrigue, but about a people who have been given extraordinary blessings and nevertheless believe they’ve been cheated.
DISCOVER TOLKIEN’S TRAGEDY
Want to explore Tolkien’s actual story of Númenor?
Check out Tolkien’s Tragedy: Concerning Númenor, an exploration of the rise and fall of the greatest kingdom of Men, and the spiritual tragedy of a civilization undone by its fear of death and desire for power.
Get the book: https://tolkienstragedy.com/
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
What did you think of The Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 2?
Did we miss any major contradictions? What made you cringe? And was there anything you actually liked?
Let us know in the comments!
The road goes ever on!
Discussion about this video
CommentsRestacks
The Tolkien Road reply rules
The Tolkien Road
Embark upon a wondrous journey through the realms of Middle-earth and beyond with the Tolkien Road, a podcast dedicated to the enchanting tales and writings of JRR Tolkien. Come, join John, Greta, and our mighty Fellowship as we delve deep into the magic that lingers within the pages of these timeless legends. And always remember: DO NOT BE HASTY!!! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-tolkien-road--5222755/support.
Embark upon a wondrous journey through the realms of Middle-earth and beyond with the Tolkien Road, a podcast dedicated to the enchanting tales and writings of JRR Tolkien. Come, join John, Greta, and our mighty Fellowship as we delve deep into the magic that lingers within the pages of these timeless legends. And always remember: DO NOT BE HASTY!!! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-tolkien-road--5222755/support.
Subscribe
Listen on
Substack App
RSS Feed
Appears in episode
John Carswell
Recent Episodes
0233: The Book of Lost Tales I: The Early Forms of Middle-earth
• John Carswell
0232: The Book of Lost Tales I » How Tolkien’s Middle-earth Really Began
• John Carswell
0005: The Silmarillion » Ch 2 » Of Aulë and Yavanna (2015 version)
• John Carswell
0004: The Silmarillion » Ch 1 » Of the Beginning of Days (2015 version)
• John Carswell
0002: The Silmarillion - Ainulindalë (2015 version)
• John Carswell
0231: Unfinished Tales » What’s In The Book?
• John Carswell
0001: The Silmarillion - Introduction (2015 version)
• John Carswell
Ready for more?
Subscribe
© 2026 John Carswell · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.
<style> #nojs-banner { position: fixed; bottom: 0; left: 0; padding: 16px 16px 16px 32px; width: 100%; box-sizing: border-box; background: red; color: white; font-family: -apple-system, "Segoe UI", Roboto, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif, "Apple Color Emoji", "Segoe UI Emoji", "Segoe UI Symbol"; font-size: 13px; line-height: 13px; } #nojs-banner a { color: inherit; text-decoration: underline; } </style> <div id="nojs-banner"> This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please <a href="https://enable-javascript.com/" target="_blank">turn on JavaScript</a> or unblock scripts </div>
You May Also Like

Art Problems
Paddy Johnson

dc
Salai Dawtcemsang

The Newest Olympian
Mike Schubert

RISK!
Kevin Allison

Tony Katz Today
Tony Katz

The Splendid Table: Conversations & Recipes For Curious Cooks & Eaters
American Public Media

Mahlakung
Thobela FM

The Losers' Club: A Stephen King Podcast
Bloody FM
War Nerd Radio — Subscriber Feed
Gary Brecher

92NY Talks
92NY
Community discussion