Wait, Matcha Comes Decaf? Building a Brand in a New Niche
Episode S4 · Ep 402 30 min 5s

Wait, Matcha Comes Decaf? Building a Brand in a New Niche


In this Founder Feature, host Caitlin Bricker sits down with Lily Gean and Jarrod Herscu, co-founders of Caff Off, the world’s first dedicated decaf matcha brand, to talk about turning a late-night caffeine surprise into a brand built around matcha without the caffeine.


Lily was a registered nurse working shift work when she swapped coffee for matcha, started drinking far too much of it, and couldn’t sleep. She says she discovered a single cup of matcha has almost as much caffeine as a cup of coffee, and when she couldn’t find a decaf option, she and Jarrod, then a commercial real estate agent who was also drinking too much matcha, decided to build one. They quit their jobs, flew to Japan with backpacks and a translator, and met with over 100 matcha farms before finding partners willing to decaffeinate matcha without chemical solvents.


Caitlin, Lily, and Jarrod dig into how the decaffeination process works, why traditional Japanese farms were hesitant, how the team develops new flavors like their rooibos blend, why decaf matcha is incremental rather than cannibalizing for retailers, and why education is the biggest challenge for a brand in a new niche. They also cover who is buying Caff Off, from pregnant and breastfeeding moms to teens and people told by their doctors to cut caffeine, and what comes next.


Listen in as they discuss:

  • How a nurse’s caffeine surprise inspired the world’s first dedicated decaf matcha brand
  • Why Lily and Jarrod quit their jobs and flew to Japan with a translator to find a manufacturing partner
  • How Caff Off decaffeinates matcha with hot water and no chemical solvents, then returns nutrients to the leaves
  • Why decaf is not really a thing in Japan, and what that meant for finding partners
  • Why equipment, not ingredients, is the real challenge, with machinery that takes up factories
  • How Lily develops new flavors in her kitchen, including a blend with South African rooibos
  • How to prepare Caff Off at home, from a whisk to an electric frother or even a fork
  • Why decaf matcha is incremental for retailers and has earned reorders without taking sales from traditional matcha
  • Who is buying Caff Off, from people cutting back on caffeine to pregnant moms, teens, and families making matcha a weekend ritual
  • How Caff Off educates shoppers, from blind taste tests on the street to a “Wait, matcha comes decaf?” sign at a coffee expo

Want to connect with buyers, investors, and industry experts in real time?

Join our free Slack community with over 40,000 members. Get access to exclusive events and trade shows where you can meet buyers and investors in person, plus free resources and more. Just text CPG to 833-605-7002 and we’ll get in touch.

Episode Links:


Don’t forget to leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify if you enjoyed this episode. For potential sponsorship opportunities or to join the Startup CPG community, visit www.startupcpg.com.


Show Links:


Get holiday-ready with Walmart Marketplace

Community discussion