Early stage CPG Investing, Strategic LPs and What Investors Need to See Before Writing a Check
In this Investor Spotlight, host Hannah Dittman sits down with Jacob Afriat, Managing Partner at Great Circle Ventures, a $20 million early-stage fund investing in food, beverage, and vitamins and supplements. They cover what investors need to see on growth and unit economics, how to answer vague diligence questions, and what actually happens once an investor says yes.
Jacob started his career in banking at HSBC and Credit Suisse, then earned an MBA and joined an early-stage food startup. He later became CFO and Director of Finance at KIND, where the company raised more than $200 million from Series B through Series E. He then moved into corporate venture at Danone, investing in dairy, water, and nutrition across the U.S., Europe, India, and Israel, where Danone acquired Harmless Harvest and Michel et Augustin. Great Circle brings those three seats together: operator, corporation, and investor.
Hannah and Jacob dig into Great Circle’s model, which gives its LPs a mix of large CPG corporations access to early brands that could become acquisition targets. They also cover why Jacob prefers pre-seed to Series A, the lessons he has learned as a follow-on investor, and how founders should talk about growth, unit economics, and marketing. They close with a Slack community case study on what happens after an investor is ready to invest.
Listen in as they discuss:
- How Jacob went from banking to early-stage food, KIND, and corporate venture
- How Great Circle replicates a corporate venture arm outside of a large corporation, with strategic LPs from large CPG food groups
- Why a long runway between first investment and acquisition can lead to better post-acquisition outcomes
- Great Circle’s mandate: a $20 million fund investing in food, beverage, and vitamins and supplements, with non-lead checks of $100K to $700K and 2% to 5% ownership
- How LPs interact with portfolio companies, from investor reporting to introductions and learning sessions
- Why follow-on investors should know the lead investor and their reputation before investing
- Why Great Circle prefers pre-seed to Series A, and what changes in its second fund
- What “venture-backable” growth looks like, from 3x to 4x at $2M to $3M in revenue to at least 2x at $10M
- How to answer unit economics and marketing questions in investor meetings
- What happens after an investor says yes, from investment memo to closing through AngelList in 24 to 48 hours
Join the team: Great Circle runs a Venture Fellowship for first- and second-year MBA students (minimum six-month commitment, about 15 hours a week) and a lighter program for undergraduates in their junior or senior year. Reach out to Jacob on LinkedIn or by email to learn more.
Want to connect with buyers, investors, and industry experts in real time? Join our free Slack community with over 40,000 members. Get access to exclusive events and trade shows where you can meet buyers and investors in person, plus free resources and more. Just text CPG to 833-605-7002 and we’ll get in touch.
Episode Links:
- Jacob Afriat LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/jacob-afriat
- Great Circle Ventures LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/company/great-circle-vc
- Great Circle Ventures Website: www.greatcircle.vc
- Great Circle Ventures Instagram: @greatcirclevc
- Great Circle Ventures newsletter: sign up at www.greatcircle.vc
- Contact Jacob directly: [email protected]
Don’t forget to leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify if you enjoyed this episode. For potential sponsorship opportunities or to join the Startup CPG community, visit www.startupcpg.com.
Show Links:
- Transcripts of each episode are available on the Transistor platform that hosts our podcast here (click on the episode and toggle to “Transcript” at the top)
- Join the Startup CPG Slack community (40K+ members and growing!)
- Follow @startupcpg
- Visit host Hannah’s LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/hannah-dittman-011b844b
- Questions or comments about the episode? Email [email protected]
- Episode music by Super Fantastics
Jacob Afriat I see a lot of founders sometimes trying to launch a business and they quit their job and they're not ready for even the financial struggle that comes with it, which is the first few months, you're probably not able to raise money, you're probably not able to pay yourself. And so before launching a business, make sure you know what you're getting into, meaning make sure you have the right risk profile, you're the right profile person. Meaning that it is very risky and it's a very binary outcome. So you either create a company that has an exit or you create a company where you can scramble along the way and then at the end the exit only pays back the investors who you come across with just learning experience.
00:51 Hannah Dittman Hey everyone, I'm Hannah Dittman. I'm the Finance and Operations host of the Startup CPG podcast and today I'm joined by Jacob Afriat, Managing Partner at Great Circle Ventures. Jacob brings a unique and very thoughtful perspective on the CPG ecosystem, having worked in finance operations at Emerging Brands, Corporate Venture Capital, and now early stage investing at Great Circle. GreatCircle also has a differentiated model with strategic LPs that include large CPG corporations, creating opportunities for portfolio brands to access industry expertise, strategic partnerships and potentially future acquisition opportunities.
01:28 Hannah Dittman In this episode we talk about what investors need to see from a growth perspective, how to tackle unit economics and pools of marketing spend questions and early diligence and what actually happens from a logistical standpoint after an investor says yes, we dig into the white space in pre seed investing, what follow on capital means and unpack the different ways LPs can interact with portfolio companies. Jacob's insights are both practical and provide valuable context on the fundraising process and what's happening on the investor side of the table. And if you're looking to connect with buyers, investors and industry experts in real time, you need to be in our community. Join our free Slack community with over 40,000 members. Get access to exclusive events and trade shows where you can meet those buyers and investors in real life. Tap into free resources and more.
02:20 Hannah Dittman Text CPG to 833-605-7002 that's 833-605-7002 and we will get in touch. Enjoy the episode. Hey everybody, welcome back to the Startup CPG Podcast. This is Hannah and today I'm excited to be here for an investor spotlight with Jacob Afriat of Great Circle Ventures. Jacob, welcome to the show.
02:49 Jacob Afriat Yeah,.
02:50 Hannah Dittman We're super excited that you're here today. I'd love to dive straight in and get a Little bit of your background, the path that led you through consumer and to where you are today at Great Circle.
03:00 Jacob Afriat Yes, of course. So I started my career in banking with HSBC and Credit Suisse both in the US and overseas. Then in 2008 I realized it wasn't for me so I decided to move into to get an MBA actually. So I went to business school in Europe, came back here in the US and joined an early stage food startup, Kuala Aloha. So at the time we're making protein powder and peel smack and green juice. Very different company than it is today. But I did learn a ton there sitting on the operating side of the business. After a few years there I moved into another startup called Kimi where I spent a few years there as well as CFO and director of finance. It was more of a later stage company. So from a series B to series E we raised more than 200 million.
03:43 Jacob Afriat It was very different environment, a little bit more structured but also a continuity on my learning curves from you know Aloha where it was from 0 to 1. This one was more from like 1 to 3 and after that I transitioned so I moved away from being an operator to being at the corporation but in the CVC environment. So corporate venture arm. So I joined Danone where I was investing on behalf of the group in dairy, water and nutrition both in the US in Europe, India, Israel and we had two investment thesis. One was on the food tech side. So really invest to learn.
04:16 Jacob Afriat The idea was to invest in early stage company in technology that could become relevant for some of the business units and the second one was on the CPG side is was invest to acquire and the idea there was to invest in CPG businesses that were taking away market share from our core business and potentially acquire some of those down the line and we did that. So during my time there we acquired Harmless Harvest which is a coconut water brand in our water division. We also acquired a different business called Michelangelo Augustin. So it was a very interesting learning curve for me from standpoint where what large corporations are looking for in early stage companies but also innovation and in partnership and also what happens post acquisition. Right, which is like always like a big question for corporations but also sometimes for investors themselves.
05:03 Hannah Dittman Great background Jacob. You've seen so many super relevant interesting things on the operating side and also have like the quant finance background as well to partner with a foundation for the investing side. So really cool everything that you've gotten to experience and bring to the table as an investment partner. I'd love to dive a little bit more into Great Circle Ventures as well. If you could go ahead and give the firm overview, I'd love to better understand your mandate criteria, stage focus and differentiation as a fund.
05:34 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, of course. So basically I've seen the business from three seats, right? So one as an operator, two from the corporation angle and three as an investor. And so this is really great. Circle is bringing those three perspectives together. So the idea of greatcircle Investment Thesis is to replicate the business model of a CVC or corporate venture arm, but outside of a large corporation. So let me explain. So we have basically one side the LPs, right? Typically your LPs are large institution. They're usually looking just for the return. They're not looking for anything else. What we learn especially in cpg is that most businesses in CPG are not ipoing, right? So their exit strategy is to like a corporate M and A.
06:18 Jacob Afriat And so we thought why not bring on the LP side a lot of large corporate food group and then have them invest in a fund. And that fund would basically learn as much as possible for them and find assets early that could become relevant to them down the line for a potential M and A target. This way we can not only invest, win the exit in mind, but also maybe even shorten the window from investment all the way to acquisition where there's a lot of partnership relationship that needs to be built. And typically we learned that at Danone. I don't know, Danone was a great example where when we invested the first time in Harmless Harvest, all the way to when we acquired the business, it was like a long window, it was six to eight years. It took a long time.
07:01 Jacob Afriat But that really enabled both parties to get to know each other. It's like getting married. So they get to know each other, they spend time together before fully committed, which is 100% acquisition. And so I think that was very important when you want to have a post acquisition success, right? When you get to meet someone, you make an offer to buy a business from 0 to 100% within six months. You make an offer, you buy then. And then there's always a big question, then what? Like who did integrate? Well, is everyone happy? You know, it's kind of. It's a massive transition for the team versus like slowly transitioning inside the large group progressively, right? So I thought that was a pretty interesting. And that's why we created Great Circle.
07:39 Jacob Afriat So to go back to your question, so we are a $20 million fund focusing on food, beverage and vitamin and supplements. Right. So VMs, we invest mostly in brands, so I want to say 80% in brand, but we reserve 20% for whether it's a technology, a food tech or anything that touches the ecosystem of food and beverage. And bms, we typically don't lead, especially with this fund. So we haven't led any round and we aim for 2 to 5% ownership. So small checks 100k to 700k usually we have a good reserve for. Follow on. We're quite diversified. We're now looking for 10 investment only in this fund. So more about 30 investments. And again, our number one goal is to try to find assets that could become relevant to the large corporate food group that we have on our catapult. Right.
08:23 Jacob Afriat So that's one key differentiation.
08:25 Hannah Dittman Amazing pitch and super helpful to get the baseball scorecard stats as well. At the same time, really interesting. And just to clarify, follow on for the audience, that's additional investment in companies that you've made an initial investment in. So maybe you gave them a smaller check with the hope that in a year or something like that you'll be writing another check into that business and it'll be a follow on investment for you. So many questions for you. When you constructed your LP base, how were you getting in touch with these larger corporations? Did they not already have their own CVC arms? And what do you think made that partnership work and was a compelling pitch to them? Because I feel like Those are hard LPs to get interested in you and to partner with in that way.
09:07 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, this is a great question. Right. So a few of those large corporations have already a CVC structure. A few of them do not. Right. A few of them like have made historically a few investments here and there, but they don't have any structure. The one that have structure are typically the larger corporation that are creating. They have like a pretty decent budget to hire a whole team around cvc. And this was us at the node. Right. And that budget is quite big. Right. So it's a whole team. You have investors, you have finance folks, you have legal folks, you have admin. Right. It's a whole team that would make investment.
09:41 Jacob Afriat I think the math has to make sense sometimes where the cost of the team basically like those investment returns need to be able to pay back the cost of the team and hopefully make money. Right. Granted that this is not the strategy for typical cvc. The strategy for CVC is yes, ideally we don't lose money, but at the minimum we want to learn from the market we want to connect, we want to stay plugged on the market, potentially find assets that way, increase our deal flow, et cetera. What we did with both type of organizations, whether they had a CVC unit or not, the one that had the CVC unit, we told them, hey, we're a very specialized fund. We are focused in the U.S. we're focused on food and beverage and VMs, and we're focused early stage.
10:19 Jacob Afriat And even though you do have a cvc, maybe you have a CVC with a team that is outside of the U.S. or maybe you have one member in the U.S. but we can really enlarge that. We can be really the boots on the ground that provide massive deal flow, but also a thought partner, as you think about trends, as you think about learnings, et cetera. That resonated with a lot of large corporations. The ones that don't have a cvc, we thought it would be an easier sell because they don't have a cvc. They need help, right? But then they had no idea where to begin. They had no understanding of the concept. So it was a lot of education. It took a few years. It wasn't straightforward, but yeah, we managed to convince a few.
10:55 Hannah Dittman Super exciting and kudos to you. Good job. Obviously, being in the founder seat, founders have to like convince investors to invest in them. And investors have a similar process convincing their LPs to invest in them. And there's so many different types of LPs out there. I mean, there's people that have zero connection to anything really, what the fund is doing whatsoever. That is just like very passive, random money in a way, all the way down to something super specialized like this, where there's a lot of synergies and a very targeted focus of the LP base. So very interesting. Something we haven't covered on this podcast yet. And I don't want to take us down too long of a rabbit hole, but would love to use this opportunity to shed some light on what the interaction between LPs and portfolio companies are.
11:40 Hannah Dittman In what ways do LPs have an understanding, connection or interaction whatsoever with the portfolio companies of an investment firm? And how does that come to fruition down the road specifically for you all, given your special circumstances?
11:54 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, it's a good question. You know, we do have some concrete examples, so it really depends. Right. So at the beginning, obviously, because we do invest pre seed, sometimes pre revenue, there is no point, there is a need to have a conversation that early with a large corporations as things progress, right. We do track those companies we do provide investor reporting to just share not only financial performance, but also financial performance of the companies. And some investors, some LPs could see themselves a little bit more involved in the business, right? And so the way we see it is that we are the first check with the fund in a company, then we reserve a portion of that for follow on.
12:32 Jacob Afriat If we exercise that right, and we use that follow on portion, then the next check is basically we could have a parada that we could give away to our LPs. And so that's when the LP want to have like a deeper conversation, right? As the company is maturing, they're growing, but also now they have an indirect stake in the company through us, but they can have a direct stake in the company directly to get even closer to the company, you know, so that it could have I guess like to increase the chance of a potential M and A down the line, right? So it's like slowly acquiring more and more of the business. And so that's when that typically makes sense for us to connect the two.
13:08 Jacob Afriat But what we've done in the past, so we've had some requests from our large corporation to connect earlier with those LPs just to learn a very specific topic. We had one corporation that asked us about how to build a business from zero to one with very limited marketing budget, right. And so we brought a founder that shared her experience and that was extremely valuable for the whole corporation. And they invited the CEO, the cfo, but also like business manager from different business unit from different geographical locations. So it was a pretty fruitful, I guess, zoom call. And so but that was like another way were able to introduce our portfolio company to the large corporations.
13:46 Hannah Dittman A great circle of perspectives, the full circle. I think that's so awesome. And also just to shed some light for everyone listening in too, you know, investment funds, they have to put on annual meetings where their LPs kind of congregate and get an update on what's going on in the investment firm and within the portfolio companies. So they'll kind of keep track of companies performance. They get a presentation on how a company is doing. And then there's LP reporting every quarter as well where you're reporting on fund performance, which obviously is directly impacted by portfolio company performance. So they'll get the financials of the portfolio companies, they'll understand which ones are growing and which ones are really driving, hopefully all of them, but really driving the returns for a fund.
14:28 Hannah Dittman And so even without such a advantageous LP relationship, there still are a lot of ways that LPs kind of have a pulse on companies with an investment firm just in a normal steady state situation with any type of LP as well. I'd love to pivot us into a little bit of lessons learned. You know, normally that's something we want to reflect back at the end of the conversation, but I'd love to kick us off and jump straight into it at the beginning here. Reflecting on your career, the different perspectives that you've seen in the different chairs that you've sat in, what are some of the lessons learned or compelling anecdotes that you've gathered that you think others would be able to learn from?
15:03 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, very interesting. I guess maybe the first one. And this is mostly for follow on investors, right. So as follow on investors, typically easier for us to get access to the cap table because we're not fighting for that only seat of a lead. Right. So we're not looking to be a lead or a co lead. We're a follow on investor. We're a small check. It's usually easier to make room for us, especially at the beginning. I think one thing that is very important is who is the lead investor and what would be their involvement in the business. Right. So I think that's something that as follow an investor we should spend a bit more time thinking about do we know that lead? Do they have a great reputation at helping the companies?
15:42 Jacob Afriat Because we learned this the hard way, but there's a few when unless you know the lead and they have a good reputation and they're a pretty strong lead at driving the company and helping them, especially when there's issues, et cetera, that board member lead could actually also destroy the company or like create some tension inside the company. And so the fact that we don't have that driving seat, we're in the passenger seat. As Zach follow on. It could be sometimes very painful to see the type of decision that the board members are taking and the direction that the company is taking. So I guess my number one recommendation for other venture fund that are follow on investors is make sure you know the lead. They have a great reputation, you've spoken to them, you have ideally a relationship with them.
16:24 Jacob Afriat Before you jump in, some of the other learning curve is created the fund and our idea was to invest early and early could be pre seed series A. And so we've done a little bit of the three. What we found out is that especially on the series A deal is that by the time we got access to a series A deal, the one were reviewing were the ones that were overshot that were potentially rejected by most people and then we ended up investing in some of them and the performance hasn't been there. This is very different for pre seed deal. Right. So pre seed deal I think there's still not enough player in the market.
16:57 Jacob Afriat I think also there is a lot of short term return that can be made from pre seed to seed where a lot of value creation for early investors that are able to be the first one to dip their toes and with a very small check pre revenue even though there is nothing yet and we have some concrete example on our portfolio. For example one of the company we invested in back in March, were one of the first VC check there still no leads so no board seats. Right. But the first VC check and they are currently doing around at about 7x our investment. So insane return. And this is from pre seed to seed right. And so were able to identify that asset invest and de risk as much as possible to create the most value for the next investors.
17:44 Jacob Afriat And so I think that's combination of the founder luck and a little bit of our work. Right. But I think those are the type of deal we look for more now. So for fund two we'll be focusing a little bit more on the earlier stage. So pre seed versus Precede all the way to series A and we'll be also investing a little bit heavier. So instead of 100k we'll probably do 200, 250 as a first check and then save it a bit for four on as well.
18:08 Hannah Dittman I love your perspective and so many things my mind was thinking as you were speaking. I totally agree with what you're saying. Precede. I think when LPs got a little anxious of CPG as an asset class a way that investors kind of de risk that sentiment was to go a bit later stage because there's more data available and therefore it feels a little bit less risky and there's a little bit more traction to bet on. But like you're saying, when everyone kind of focuses in that middle zone it gets really competitive and there's only so many standout CPG companies that are going to be making it in each cohort and a lot of times you need to go a bit earlier to be able to find something really interesting because CPG brands also require capital to scale.
18:52 Hannah Dittman So a lot of under capitalized businesses also exist a little earlier on that can have a big inflection point when they just get a bit of capital in the door. So I think that makes a lot of sense and really smart and thoughtful the way you're thinking about this all as investors. The second thing is, I just wanted to clarify for the audience the term follow on, because we're using it two different ways in this conversation. One is follow on investors. So there's lead investors that lead around, meaning the largest check or maybe even the first large check going into a company that kind of establishes the round. And then there's follow on investments, which is what we described earlier, which is maybe you are putting additional capital into it, preexisting investment that you've already made. So really interesting dynamics here.
19:36 Hannah Dittman And I love the lesson that you called out, which wouldn't have been one that immediately comes to mind, which is the thought of what happens to an investor if you don't have control and you don't have a board seat and you don't get to influence the company as much as another investor that you're alongside. And I think that's a really interesting dynamic and point that you're calling out that maybe not everyone has thought through or experienced themselves or are aware of, especially on the founder side, when you're not thinking about their side of the equation all the time. Do you have any lessons learned that you'd like to share with operators as well? Is there anything that you wish more founders or operators knew or understood that you think would be really helpful for them?
20:15 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, it's a good question. I think a few things. One is, before launching a business, make sure you know what you're getting into. Meaning make sure you have the right risk profile. You're the risk profile person. Meaning that it is very risky and it's a very binary outcome. So you either create a company that has an exit or you create a company where you can scramble along the way. And then at the end, the exit only pays back the investor. So you come across with just learning experience. I see a lot of founders sometimes trying to launch a business and they quit their job and they're not ready for even the financial struggle that comes with it, which is the first few months, you're probably not able to raise money, you're probably not able to pay yourself.
20:58 Jacob Afriat And so this is like something you need to keep in mind when you launch a business. The second thing is, are you launching a venture, backable business, or are you launching a business that can grow organically? Right. So sometimes I get pitched by founders, a revenue curve that is way too low. Right. And so I see, you know, year one, we're going to do 100K year two, we're going to do 250. Right. And it's already not as aggressive as we would want as an investor. And so it means that's probably not venture backable at this stage at least. So always keep that in mind. Right. Like what are investors looking for? Because we are looking for aggressive curve because we're taking so much bet and so many of the company we invest in are going to die.
21:36 Jacob Afriat The one that are successful need to return enough to make up for all that and create some profit. Right. For our lp. So that's the idea. The third thing is also just like being ready for those costs, those investors costs. So obviously knowing that you have to be aggressive, et cetera. But if you're not aggressive, like that's not even. You shouldn't even launch a business. Or maybe you shouldn't even raise from ventures. Maybe figure out friends and family and just keep on growing this business and reinvesting until you achieve a certain growth. And then you can decide do I want to get to the next road with venture or do I want to keep it as 100% ownership.
22:11 Jacob Afriat The other one is when you jump on a call with an investor, I think it's important to do your research like understand what this investor is looking for. Are there a follow on investor or not? Right. Like what we discussed, what ownership do they require are their lead investor? I usually encourage founders to ask questions first because sometimes your pitch could be tilted or could be a little bit different based on who you're talking to. Right. It shouldn't be like just a robot and just press play and go for the pitch. So ideally you try to put yourself in the shoes of the investor and how they would analyze your business and you do that work for them, that thinking process because that really helps align everything.
22:50 Jacob Afriat The other thing, I mean once you have the investors, I think once you start building your investor list and you start seeing some investment. The other thing I really encourage founders doing, I think it's an obvious one, but it's really like reporting. Right. So sharing some updates to investor on a consistent manner. I have seen in our portfolio that there's a massive correlation between investors that stop reporting or that do not report on a quarterly basis, on a monthly basis, whatever it is, and the success of their company. Right. And sometimes sharing updates, you know, it's not an easy thing when there's nothing new to share or when there is no great news, it's only bad news. Right. So it's a hard thing. But it creates this environment, this openness, this conversation.
23:36 Jacob Afriat And at the end of this update, you ask a specific, ask those investors. And it's really helped the investor narrow it down to, okay, where can I be helpful? Where can I add the most value? And I always jump on those emails. So I read those emails from top to the bottom right away when I received it. And I try to go at the ARIA where they ask for how can you help? And we try to do all that. Right. Like all the time. Even though we're just a small investor, we have only a very small ownership. So definitely do that. Send those updates to investors.
24:06 Hannah Dittman Yeah. And some of your investors require things like that, some of them don't. But I agree, it's like, especially if you have a fuller cap table, you have more people around the table to ask opinions, favors and network with. So I think making use of that as a founder, that's the reason why you want experienced operational capital a lot of the times is to be able to have the additional value other than just the money from someone you're working with. So making the most of that makes a ton of sense. All really great pieces of advice and I think super helpful. You mentioned when you were speaking about aggressive growth, could we quantify that a little bit?
24:42 Hannah Dittman Obviously this is nebulous and super dependent on so many different things, but can you maybe help paint a picture for founders listening in on what scale of growth we're talking about? Maybe from a revenue multiple perspective, pre seed to seed or something like that?
24:58 Jacob Afriat Yeah. So I think growth is very different for a business that just got started versus a business that is already doing 5 to 10 million. Right. So obviously we don't really care. Right. So really, year one, you launched a business. Obviously some people set the baseline at a high number. Right. So you can launch a D2C business, month one you make 10k or you can launch another business where month one you make a million. Right. So the baseline is like already like, you know, at a different level. And we've had both in our portfolio. You know, once you reach say 2 to 3 million in revenue and annual revenue, I think we expect those early years to be more of a 3-4x growth or at least the forecast or something you're aiming for.
25:38 Jacob Afriat If you fall short and you are at 2x, it's pretty good. Right. But we're aiming for something a bit more aggressive, especially because now you just raise money, you're still very early. This is when you try to grow as fast as possible and Then growth is going to slow down as you grow as a company naturally. But yes, once you reach 10 million, we try to aim for founders that are trying to grow at least 2x year over year. And sometimes in the forecast they show 3x and they end up growing at 2x and we're still happy. But if you show a growth, if you're doing for example, 10 million, but then you're showing a growth of 10%, 20%, even 30%. Right. It's not venture backbone. Right. Like it's going to be hard.
26:17 Jacob Afriat The alignment is not there with investors especially like then why do you need money to grow? Right? Like the idea of like taking outside money is to actually grow much faster. Otherwise maybe you don't need money.
26:28 Hannah Dittman Great point and I think really helpful. I think a lot of founders get anxious of like over promising and I feel like there's like the two camps, the like hardcore over promise and the sandbagging yourself. And I think it's an art and a science to figure out. But I would say I think what you're kind of the point you're making, which is make sure what you're communicating in your narrative, regardless of your numbers, is that you're really looking to grow and scale the business and use the capital to drive venture level growth and aggressive growth. And obviously the numbers are going to shake out a certain way or not. It's a forecast you'll get discounted as a founder. When you're forecasting with an investor, they're going to assume you're painting like a very rosy picture.
27:11 Hannah Dittman Then they need to bring back down to reality in some ways. So also keep that in the back of your mind, but super duper helpful context and answer to that question. I'd love to kind of dive into a few other ambiguous type of questions that founders typically get asked investor meetings or have questions about how to answer. One of them, I think that comes up frequently is a question like what are your unit economics? Like obviously there's many different ways that a founder could answer a question like that. What do you think the best way and diligence to answer something like that would be for a founder in a live meeting.
27:45 Jacob Afriat Yeah, it's a good question. So yeah, I think it is very important for a founder to have a very good grasp on the unit economics. Right. And so unit economics mean where you are today, where you're aiming to go and how, I guess what's the probability for you to get there? Right. Because I used to be an investor in the Food Tech Environment. We saw a lot of cell based company, right? Plant based, cell based, like cell based, meat cell based, cacao, et cetera. The unit economics was always, we are like, you know, $10,000 right now per unit, but were planning to get at 100 right, in the next 20 years. So that's not helpful for CPT, right. So we need to be much more concrete.
28:20 Jacob Afriat So I think unit economic is really like the margin, like at the end of the day after you sell your product, like how much profit can you actually generate? And this helps us forecast the EBITDA at scale for the corporation at the time of the acquisition. Right? And this could make a massive difference because companies are not acquired just as a multiple of net revenue, they're acquired also as a multiple of ebitda. Right? That's like, you know, what large corporations are looking for. And EBITDA is basically a straight reflection of the margin, right? So first of all you have product margin and then you have the margin with all in cost. So you know, employees and marketing, et cetera. So having those margins are very important.
28:54 Jacob Afriat I think understanding at least the product margin when you're pre launch, when you're like pre revenue, et cetera, is the minimum. I think as you start growing and launching the business, assuming it's a business that you launch online, then you start getting a little bit more understanding on the fulfillment costs on the cac, how much it costs to acquire a customer. You have a little bit on retention. So now you get into the nitty gritty of acquiring a customer. When do we get paid back and how much money can we extract from that customer over the long haul? Right? So we expect founders to have some ideas or at least some assumption, right? We don't expect them to have all the assumptions wrong, but we expect them to think about it and to build a financial forecast based on that. Right?
29:36 Jacob Afriat Based on unit economics that they verify they've tried to assemble together.
29:40 Hannah Dittman Super helpful and I think great answer that you're kind of alluding to as well, which is paint the picture of where your margins are today, know where they're going to grow and how in the future, and that the investor is really trying to understand the scalability and the future profitability and ability to fundamentally work from a financial perspective in a steady state of the business. One question that we get frequently from founders is how do I answer? How am I marketing my business? Like what does that actually mean when someone is asking me a vague question about marketing? What are they actually trying to get me to answer what do they want to understand about the business?
30:16 Jacob Afriat Yeah, if I was to think about marketing. Right. So I guess the first thought of an investor is to understand is a business mostly D2C or on retail? Right. So that's one of my first question we did in the first meeting. I'm trying to understand where is revenue coming from and what's the split between retail and D2C. Once you've identified that, then you understand that the marketing expense for each bucket are different. Right. So on D2C you spend money to acquire a customer. On digital platform, think meta, think like you know, any platform to acquire some customer attention and that obviously it costs money but at least it's traceable and you know, you're able to tilt and to learn to constantly reiterate and a B test, et cetera. The other marketing bucket for retail is basically on tradespan. Right.
31:04 Jacob Afriat So once you go into retailer, getting accepted to a retailer is an amazing step. It's just the beginning. I think the holy grail is staying at the retailer and showing velocity or showing turnover that is 2x, 3x 4x whatever it is, but better than the average performance or the expected performance by the buyer so that you stay on the shelf and you grow within that shelf. So the marketing expense for a retail are basically, you know, trade span demo. You know how you're driving traffic there. If you're at Walmart, for example, like Walmart would expect you to drive traffic to their website to walmart.com so you need to acquire customer now. But instead of driving them to your website, you want to send it to their website so that they can credit you.
31:45 Jacob Afriat They can say, okay, this product is actually working and we want to keep it right. So we want to keep you on the shelf. So it depends, you know, on the marketing side. Yeah, that's what I can come up with.
31:55 Hannah Dittman Super helpful. And I think just thinking about the way that you're thinking about that and again, trying to understand the narrative of a business through different types of questions is helpful. At the beginning it seems like you're really just trying to paint a picture of what's going on. Where is investment being made in this company? What's the bet that is being made on where customers will be acquired or where energy or capital will be spent and if you're aligned kind of with the thought process maybe of how a founder is thinking about building their business and moving forward with maybe your future capital one day.
32:29 Jacob Afriat Yeah,.
32:30 Hannah Dittman I'd love to pivot us into a canvas Slack case study Question. I could chat with you all day. Jacob, I think you have such a sharp, really great understanding of the industry and especially the sectors that you're playing in. I love your thoughtful responses and I'd love to get a thoughtful response today's question. As you know, startup CPG has the largest Slack community in the industry with now over 40,000 members. I'd love to pull a question directly from our channel and have you answer it as a case study for any founders that might have a similar question. Today's question is what happens when an investor is ready to invest? What is the process like when you get an offer from them?
33:08 Jacob Afriat It's a great question. And again here I'm going to go back to lead investor and follow on investor. So it depends for each one of them if it's a lead investor, expect the process to be much longer. Right. Because once they're ready to invest, they have to do a full fledged due diligence. They have to also price the round. They come up with the pricing, the valuation and all those metric. As a follow on investor, it's a little bit easier for us. It's, there's a little bit less work. It's basically this is the deal, you can jump on board or not, you know, so the question is a little bit easier. Also what's easier for us is that because there's already a lead investor, we know who's the lead, we know there is money coming in, we're not the first check, right.
33:45 Jacob Afriat So we know the company would be capitalized, it would be safe for at least the next 12 to 16 months depending on how much Runway they would have with that lead. We know who's the board member and so we have a clearer picture and it's a little bit easier for us to decide whether or not we want to jump in. But assuming we're ready to jump in, right. So it's for us, you know, selfishly, I can walk you through our process. So we basically, maybe even before that, so before confirming that we decided to jump in, we'll basically do an investment memo. So we'll write a whole investment memo. We'll ask a lot of questions along the way. We'll talk to and existing investors to former employers.
34:21 Jacob Afriat I mean we'll do like the whole thing to try to get as much information and make sure we miss as little as possible to depict the best picture. Then we present that to our board. Right. And unless we have any veto, that means that we can move forward. And because our initial check size is Very small. So we do like 100k to 700. We are able to move like quite fast. So the next step is that we literally get access to final documents. So the document that were provided by the lead investor on the round, whether it's a safe, whether it's a price round, we review that internally and then we connect basically Angelist, which is our admin, to the founder and we connect Angelist, we take care of the closing.
34:59 Jacob Afriat And so what you would expect from Angelist is within usually like 24 to 48 hours, they would send you the signature block, they would sign the document and queue the wire. That's it.
35:09 Hannah Dittman Super helpful and I think a really interesting deep dive into kind of the nuances of the admin that a lot of people interact with for the first time when they're going through it and have no idea what to expect. And it feels like really a nervous question to ask an investor who you're really worried you're going to like turn off in the last minute if you need to ask them a question that maybe you should already know or something. So really helpful to get your color there. I would also like to say you should be comfortable asking your investors questions and doing that with them and that should be a safe space, especially getting into a relationship like that with them. But empathize with the founder experience as well. Well, Jacob, this has been so insightful and amazing.
35:50 Hannah Dittman Like I said, I could talk to you all day. You're a wealth of knowledge and have a lot of great perspectives. For any founders that might want to get in touch, continue the conversation or think they may be a good fit for you, what's the best way for them to reach out? And the second part of my question is, do you have any advice or opportunities for anyone interested in joining your team or your space?
36:08 Jacob Afriat Yeah, no, It's a great question. So to reach us out, we've actually, over the past six to eight months, we've decided to spend a little bit more resource on branding. And so now we have a pretty strong newsletter. We're actually just rebranding it, so we're going to send that one out in a week. The way to get access to the newsletter is to go on the website and just click on newsletter and put your email address. So we have a newsletter, we have a substack channel, we have an Instagram channel. We are pretty present on LinkedIn and very active, so you can find us anywhere. I have some investors, I have some founders reaching out on Instagram, some on LinkedIn, some directly my email address is Jacob@GreatCircle VC. So that's pretty straightforward as well.
36:44 Jacob Afriat So for advice or opportunity for anyone interested in joining our team, we have two programs we're running right now. One is a Venture Fellowship. It's typically for year one or year two MBA students. It's a minimum commitment of six months. You get to explore everything we're doing and it's quite intense. So it's a minimum like 15 hours commitment per week. And we have another program for undergrads which is a little bit less intense, but it's you can start year three or year four. So when you're junior or senior and you can join the program, it's a little bit lighter and you get touch different area of what we do on a daily basis.
37:21 Hannah Dittman Wow. Amazing opportunities and I hope some of the audience takes you up on those options and I hope founders reach out if they think that they're a good fit. I'm sure you're an amazing investment partner to work alongside and I'm really excited to keep following along on your journey and see all the exciting things that you get interested in the future. Thank you so much for your time today, Jacob. It's been a real pleasure and a treat to talk to you.
37:42 Jacob Afriat Yeah, same. And I thank you so much for making the time and yeah, it was really fun.
37:47 Hannah Dittman Well friends, we've now arrived together at the end of another episode of the Startup CPG podcast, the top globally ranked podcast in cpg. And if you like love this podcast, you'll love our Slack community even more. Here at Startup cpg, we're a community of brands and experts and you should join. Sign up @startupcpg.com you'll then get an invite to our online Slack community of over 35,000 All Star CPG members. Hear about amazing events near you and all our special opportunities to get you in front of buyers, investors, brands and more. It's a free community. So what are you waiting for? I'll catch you on the next episode and I'll see you on the Slack.
You May Also Like

Earn Your Leisure
iHeartPodcasts

RADIO 007
RADIO007

The #WhatsNext Podcast
nextAdvisory

Happy Work - Bien-être au travail et management bienveillant
Gaël Chatelain-Berry

Dagen med Di
Dagens industri

The Wolf Of All Streets
Scott Melker

Patrick Boyle On Finance
Patrick Boyle

Self-Publishing with ALLi
Alliance of Independent Authors

経済ニュース 今日の気になる話題
元証券マン しんさん

Stock Movers
iHeartPodcasts
Community discussion