The Uninsurable Future: How Climate-Driven Insurance Risk is Reshaping Real Estate
The Canary in the CRE Coal Mine
If insurance is the canary in the coal mine for climate risk, then the bird has stopped singing. That's the warning from Dave Jones, former California Insurance Commissioner and current Director of the Climate Risk Initiative at UC Berkeley. In a conversation that touches on reinsurance markets, mortgage delinquencies, lender behavior, and regulatory dysfunction, Jones laid out the most sobering climate-related CRE risk analysis to date: we are already living through a systemic insurance crisis—and commercial real estate is not exempt.
"We are marching steadily towards an uninsurable areas in this country," Jones warns.
From Homeowners to High-Rises: What the Data Shows
Much of the early distress has been observed in the residential and small business markets, where data is more publicly available. A study by the Dallas Fed, cited by Jones, found a direct correlation between areas hardest hit by climate events and surging insurance premiums, non-renewals, and mortgage delinquencies.
But commercial real estate isn't insulated. While pricing data is less transparent due to looser filing requirements, Jones states, "everything that I've seen indicates that those [commercial] rates are going up too," particularly in regions where catastrophic climate events are becoming more frequent and severe.
Take Florida. One of our clients' office tower's premiums jumped from $300,000 to $1.2 million in a single renewal cycle. That's straight off the bottom line. The hit is entirely non-accretive; it's pure cost.
The Feedback Loop: Insurance, Lending, and Liquidity
As insurance availability shrinks and prices soar, lending dries up. Lenders want to see that there is property and casualty insurance yet, as it becomes harder to get, that has implications in credit markets… and flow-through implications to the real economy.
