0:00 Welcome to The Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:20 [music] 0:46 Welcome back to The Messy City Podcast. 0:47 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:50 You might be surprised to hear this, but he has been a multiple requested guest to have on the show here today. 0:56 I'm really happy to have Lars Doucet on with us from the Center for Land Economics and from his Substack Progress and Poverty. 1:05 Lars, thanks so much for joining me. 1:08 Well, I appreciate it. 1:08 I'm honored. 1:09 Multiple requests. 1:10 Gosh. 1:10 Yeah, I know. 1:11 How about that? 1:12 It's, you know, we are going to nerd out on taxation and property taxation in specific today. 1:18 So that's like everybody's fair warning ahead of time. 1:22 I promise to make it very interesting. 1:24 Yes. 1:24 Well, I mean, your writing is very, very good and very interesting. 1:28 So that that's a big help. 1:29 I first want to start a little bit about tell me what the Center for Land Economics is. 1:34 Center for Land Economics is a 501C3. 1:37 I forget if the C or the three comes first, but it's- It's the C, yeah. 1:40 Yeah, yeah, 501C3. 1:42 Yeah, that's Greg's job is to handle that part of the job. 1:45 But so we're a nonprofit organization, and we study land value tax, which for people who don't know what that is, it's a specific reform to property taxes. 1:53 So I guess we study property taxes as well. 1:55 And we basically do a lot of public research, data-driven analysis, and public writing and education. 2:03 Basically so that everyone from the general public to local officials can understand how the property tax system works and ways we can make it much, much better. 2:12 And how does one come to be an expert in land value taxation? 2:16 Did you have a background in like economics or something or how did you come to this? 2:19 It is a very strange accidental series of events. 2:23 It was completely unintentional. 2:25 I do actually have a relevant degree. 2:27 I got an undergraduate degree in architecture and then a master's degree in visualization sciences, which is kind of, you know, a little bit computer graphics, a little bit like data visualization kind of stuff. 2:39 So not an irrelevant background. 2:42 But my career was in video games for 15 years of all things. 2:46 Wow. 2:46 And so although I was a pretty competent software developer, which, you know, wound up being quite relevant to my day job today, I basically just stumbled upon it through reading and a bunch of other anecdotes. 2:58 I won't derail this completely, but while I was a game developer, you know, as games got more sophisticated, they started to have economies. 3:05 And I noticed this really strange trend in online games repeated over multiple decades, different games from different companies, going back 30, probably now 40 years of recessions in online economies, which seemed insane that we could reproduce the problems of the real world 3:20 and fake worlds where the rules are made up. 3:22 But housing scarcity was one of the ones that was the most common. 3:27 And there's even been cases of economists experimenting with things like land value tax and online games that are actually working. 3:34 That was not the basis on which I became convinced of these theories by any means, but that was one of the many little breadcrumbs along the trail that led me to it was that the more I started looking for it, I just saw the problem of what economists call the land problem 3:49 in all these unexpected places. 3:50 And of course, I like anyone else played Monopoly growing up and then as a lot of your listeners have probably mentioned at some point is that Monopoly is actually based off an earlier game which was meant explicitly 4:01 to be designed to make you upset when one person winds up with all the property because that is the didactic goal of the game. 4:08 It's supposed to be a learning tool. 4:09 It's effectively propaganda. 4:11 So yeah, so it was a series of very strange and convoluted events that led me here. 4:15 Mostly I wrote some stuff online and then people got really excited about and demanded I keep writing. 4:20 And so it's basically like people like you's fault that accidentally wound up here. 4:27 Well, I mean, it's interesting. 4:28 I can't tell you how many people actually know that have come to either urban planning or, you know, interest in this larger world through video games and through software development. 4:39 It's kind of fascinating. 4:41 So we have a couple things in common then. 4:43 You know, one is I also have an architecture degree. 4:47 And so I became accidentally interested in taxation really as I got more into urban planning and doing work for communities and for developers. 4:58 And I still find myself feeling like very much like a rookie in this world and probably have more questions than answers on any of it. 5:08 My friend Phil, who I'm sure is going to be listening today, I think he likes to refer to me as a land value tax skeptic. 5:15 But in fairness, I'm a skeptic of everything. 5:18 So it's not unique to this at all. 5:20 And it's really just more based on, as we will talk today, kind of thinking through real world implications and that sort of thing. 5:28 So the other interesting thing that may come in handy as part of this now, as part of my day job, I actually manage two districts that have a special assessment. 5:37 Oh, cool. 5:38 On property as part of the funding mechanism. 5:41 What state? 5:42 I'm in Missouri. 5:43 Okay. 5:44 So my organization manages community improvement districts or SIDS, which in most states are bids or business improvement districts. 5:51 Right. 5:52 But we have a variety of ways that we can create revenue. 5:57 It's usually a sales tax or a special assessment on property. 6:01 And we do both with the three districts we manage. 6:04 We do special assessment and sales tax. 6:07 So that's actually given me a fascinating insight into this in some ways I never would have expected when I was like 19 years old in architecture school. 6:16 Yeah. 6:17 So at any rate... 6:20 I highly suggest before I forget about it, anybody, if you go take a look at Lars's Substack called Progress and Property, there's actually, I was rereading today one really great piece called So You Want 6:30 to Abolish Property Taxes or How Not to Turn Your Red State into California. 6:35 Very, very long piece, very, very detailed and interesting as well. 6:40 And some really, really great, I just think a lot of good sort of arguments and counting arguments that you can use for different approaches. 6:47 So Lars, why don't we start at the very most basic level and let's just talk to me about what's the elevator pitch for what a land value tax is and what the top two or three benefits are for changing to this approach versus how many places do property taxes today? 7:07 Yeah, so it helps a little to explain what a property tax is. 7:10 A land value tax is basically just a property tax that only taxes you on the value of the land, which is to say the location, and not the value of the buildings. 7:19 And other than that, it functions much like a conventional property tax. 7:23 So why would anyone get so excited about this idea that they make it their whole personality, right? 7:28 Well, they made some bad choices and life is the answer, but here we are. 7:31 And so Yeah. 7:56 And a conventional property tax actually has a recurring development impact fee built into it, which is the recurring assessment that falls on the value of the building, right? 8:07 And if you capitalize that out, basically, we kind of show that that's equivalent And so conventional tax theory says that if you tax something, you get less of it. 8:20 And most of the things in the world are produced assets, whether it's pencils, whether it's work, right? 8:27 I could work harder, I could work less. 8:30 You know, whether it's machinery, anything in the world, you know, we kind of are used to this trade-off. 8:36 What's interesting about land is that land is an asset that doesn't have the same properties as pretty much anything else in the economy. 8:43 And one of those is that it's non-produced. 8:45 And by that, we mean the location itself. 8:48 Locations, there's only so many on Earth. 8:49 There's never going to be any more, any less of them. 8:53 How much demand there is for any particular location changes over time, but the amount of land never changes. 8:58 The other thing is that land is this rival asset. 9:01 Everybody needs it. 9:02 I like to say you can't eat, sleep, work, or poop without access to land. 9:06 And if you do any of those things in land that you're not authorized to be on, some bad things can happen to you, including being executed or arrested, right? 9:14 And so everyone needs land. 9:17 Only one person can have exclusive use of land, right? 9:20 Only one person can be the exclusive determiner of who uses that land because exclusive by definition means everyone else is excluded. 9:27 And also land has this interesting property. 9:29 The realtors give it away, location, location, location, that the value of land It basically depends on its surroundings. 9:36 So there's a certain amount of the value that comes from just the site itself. 9:40 But a lot of the value, most of the value even, especially in a big city, is coming from what's next to it. 9:44 You know, if you put a lemonade stand out in the desert, you're not selling any lemonade. 9:47 You put it in Times Square, you'll sell a lot of lemonade. 9:50 You can have the same product, same hustle, but it's basically the value of the location. 9:56 And so there's several different arguments for why land value tax is good. 9:59 And this is why land value tax is a big coalition. 10:02 It depends on where you're coming from. 10:05 There are some people who make the moral argument for land value tax. 10:08 There's some people who make the economic efficiency argument for it. 10:12 And then there's other people who basically just are, and then there's people who are just like conservative and don't like taxes at all. 10:19 Like this one's the least worst, you know, which is basically Milton Friedman's position. 10:24 So to outline those three like cases real quick, you know, Milton Friedman's position was like, this is the least distortive tax, right? 10:31 Because we're not going to destroy any land by taxing it. 10:34 It's going to have the least distortions on the economy. 10:37 And so we would prefer to tax land before we tax buildings or incomes or anything else. 10:43 And that's related to the efficiency argument. 10:45 The efficiency argument is also tied up with if you reduce taxes on everything else and increase taxes on land, you know, multi-million dollar surface parking lots in downtown Houston will finally... 10:57 You can only have something built on them or sold to someone who will instead of just sitting there, which causes the city to sprawl out and has all these other inefficiencies. 11:04 And then there's the moral argument, which is that if you work, you produce the value of that labor. 11:10 That was your effort. 11:12 If you made something, you put that thing together yourself. 11:15 If you invested all this human activity The results of that are something that you produced. 11:22 But if you just put a fence around land, you didn't even provide the land, you unprovided it, and then you charged a toll and basically got to collect value from your neighbors. 11:32 So people who support land value tax will come at it from one of several different directions. 11:36 They'll either come at it from all three places or just one, depending on their personality. 11:43 And now there's a subset of land value tax advocates who call themselves Georgists or Geoists who really are kind of like, we want land value tax at the same time we want to get rid of other taxes. 11:54 And then there are other advocates who are like, well, I just like this tax and I may or may not have opinions on other taxes, but I just like my ideology goes no further than, you know, I like the tax. 12:04 My particular perspective is I like the tax and I'd like to reduce the other taxes at the same time. 12:09 And that's real important to understanding my actual position here. 12:12 So like my actual reform is I think we should start with reforming the property tax in place, reduce the tax on buildings, because if you tax buildings, you get less buildings, and increase the tax on land. 12:22 And that's kind of where I start from this. 12:24 And then there's a bunch of follow-up questions people have after that of what does that entail? 12:28 What will that result in? 12:29 And that's the entire mission of my organization is to actually do that math, to actually engage with the critics, and actually see if we can figure out Pragmatically speaking, what's going to happen? 12:39 What are the political obstacles? 12:40 Who are the winners and losers going to be? 12:42 And just kind of take it from there because it's no use just arguing online or in textbooks. 12:46 We want to actually see what's going to happen in the real world or otherwise, what's the point? 12:49 Yeah. 12:50 Yeah. 12:51 So I think I first came to hearing about this topic probably 20 years ago now or so relative to work that I was doing in urban planning. 13:00 And as we started to, you know, as a much younger person, I started to like work in And that was really at the point where I first began to understand that, you know, like a parking lot in a downtown, because every architect, 13:17 every urban planner just bemoans like the surface parking lot in downtown. 13:21 And you're like, oh my God, why is that there? 13:23 Yeah. 13:25 Why would somebody not build something on that? 13:28 It's this incredible location. 13:30 And then you come to realize, well, in many cases, there's actually a tremendous economic advantage you have in not building on it because it's taxed. 13:39 So maybe you could expand a little bit on that notion, especially as it relates to really desirable urban property. 13:54 Right. 13:55 So one thing is that the scale of this is sometimes something people don't quite appreciate. 13:59 And so one thing is that we've gone out and measured this in a lot of cities. 14:02 So we have these cool 3D maps you can look at on civicmapper.org. 14:06 And we have a tab there where you can go to the surface parking. 14:09 And so in downtown Houston, there's almost half a billion dollars of assessed land value just in the downtown district. 14:14 And there's $3.5 billion of surface parking, not including parking garages, just surface parking throughout the entire city. 14:21 And so why are these here? 14:23 So in some cities, people will be like, well, no one would ever hold super valuable land like that out of use. 14:28 There must be In other cities, they're like, okay, well, it's got to be the zoning. 14:33 There's got to be restrictions. 14:34 Well, Houston has no zoning. 14:36 And downtown, there's no like quasi restrictions or things that would explain these parking lots. 14:41 And so it really is the tax advantage that I think is at least one of the things that's driving it. 14:46 There can be other reasons. 14:47 You know, if there's empty lots in Detroit, well, I mean, that could just be declined, right? 14:52 You know, if not all land has value, and if there's no value to it, someone will probably leave it empty. 14:58 But when someone pays $10 million for it, It's, you know, why does land have value in the first place? 15:04 It has value because someone somewhere would ever have the idea of building something really valuable there. 15:11 And so someone who's holding it out of use knows that, otherwise they would never pay $10 million for it because they know someone in the future, a developer might pay $15 million for it. 15:20 And while they hold it, they know that it'll probably increase in value. 15:24 That's not a guarantee, but it's a decent guess, right? 15:27 Especially if the city looks like it's not collapsing and it looks like it's growing. 15:32 And secondly, it's an asset that's unlikely to dwindle away You know, there's that old saying, buy land, it's the one thing they're not making any more of. 15:40 You know, it's a safe harbor in times of fear, right? 15:44 So it's perfectly rational for someone to treat this asset this way. 15:48 You can hold on to the asset, hope that it's going to go up in value. 15:51 And meanwhile, you want to minimize your tax burden. 15:54 And the tax code says, we're going to tax you on its ad valorem value. 15:58 Ad valorem is probably Latin for buy the value. 16:02 I never took Latin, but I'm going to take a big guess there. 16:05 And so the value is based off of the land value and off of the improvement value. 16:11 And improvement means building. 16:12 So if you improve the lot, You're gonna pay more taxes. 16:16 Now, clearly, this incentive is not strong enough to prevent all development, but tax policy is all about marginal effects. 16:23 And there's enough of an effect on the margin for someone to be like, you know what, I'm gonna build less than I was otherwise if I wasn't taxed on the building. 16:32 And there's also, you know, maybe they're planning on building next year. 16:36 Maybe they think, you know, I could build 10 stories this year, but I could build 20 in five years if the economy improves. 16:42 And so there's just like, There's all these reasons that are quite rational for being like, well, not yet. 16:48 But not yet can be 10, 15 years. 16:51 And if only one person ever does this, it's not such a big deal. 16:55 When everybody does it, it starts to have a pretty big effect on society. 16:59 Because land is rival. 17:01 If I just have some produced good that I'm hoarding in my house, waiting for the right time, that doesn't necessarily affect anyone else. 17:09 But because there's only so much land in Houston, every prime lot someone's not using Pushes everyone else out further. 17:16 Same thing in other cities, especially ones that are constrained by boundaries. 17:19 Everyone's like, well, we'll just sprawl in Houston. 17:20 And it's like, okay, but there's costs to sprawl. 17:23 And there are constrained areas like the Bay Area where there is no room to sprawl necessarily. 17:27 They've kind of reached the limit of that. 17:29 And then what happens is that demand just continues to push the prices up rather than pushing the development out further and further to sprawl. 17:35 So, I'm going to stop there because I think I've almost lost track of the original question. 17:39 No, it's fine. 17:41 It's fine. 17:41 So, the other way I think about it is, so, there's sort of that scale of thinking about, you know, the downtown lots that you just aren't. 17:50 They always are mystified. 17:51 It was like why they're vacant, you know, why isn't somebody built on there? 17:56 At the opposite end of the scale spectrum, there's also the homeowner who thinks, you know, well, boy, we'd like to build an addition onto our house and add like a bedroom and a bathroom, or maybe we'd like to have an ADU in the backyard. 18:11 And they think about that and they're like, oh, that would be great. 18:13 And then all of a sudden, or they do it and they're like, then they're hit with a property tax bill that goes up 50%. 18:19 And so there is this, when we have this system like we have today, there's actually a built-in disincentive for a lot of people to enhance or improve their own properties. 18:29 Right, and you don't even have to build anything new because another, maybe because you are taxed on your square footage and on your amenities, but you're also taxed on your physical condition. 18:39 You're what they call effective age, right? 18:41 And so there's a depreciation schedule to the value of your improvements. 18:45 And so if you fix up your house in a way that is noticeable and improves the condition, You know, you're going to pay more because it's worth more. 18:52 So we're effectively incentivizing, you know, there's a whole history of this with property taxation. 18:57 If you look back in history, cruder property tax systems would do things like tax the number of windows on a house because that was like a good proxy for, you know, how rich you were. 19:06 So what did they do? 19:06 They started boarding up the windows, you know? 19:09 And so there's all these kind of negative disincentives that are unintended, you know, property tax, it's You know, pick because it's a convenient thing to measure, but it has the negative effect of this disadvantage on the production of 19:22 the things we say we want more of, which is housing. 19:25 Yeah. 19:25 So in the work that you've done, how common is it, or does every state have a formula that values land and improvements, and do they publish that, or is it only certain states that actually break it down that way today? 19:42 It is quite heterogeneous. 19:46 I would say if you just assign me a random jurisdiction, they would almost certainly nominally have some notion of the two lines, land value and improvement value. 19:55 Whether they were doing a particularly good job overall or getting the split right is going to depend. 20:01 But I can tell you what features would predict that they were doing a good job. 20:06 And the number one feature besides like, are they big and well funded, is going to be, do they revalue their property frequently? 20:14 If they revalue their property frequently, they're going to be better at everything. 20:18 And for this reason, it's usually states in the Northeast in particular, I've noticed, often have very weird property tax systems because it's much more... 20:29 Right. 20:29 Right. 20:29 Right. 20:29 Right. 20:44 Whereas if you're revaluing every year, every two years, down in the Sunbelt, where they're much more averse to other kinds of taxes, ironically, they force their property tax systems to like, even when they have structural problems to like, have to get kind of pretty good. 20:59 Because the more you revalue every year, like the more practice you get. 21:02 The most prevalent mass appraisal system, we could talk about mass appraisal all day long. 21:07 That's like one of my subspecialties. 21:09 But the most prevalent method for mass appraisal and mass appraisal is when they value all the properties at once through some method. 21:17 As opposed to fee appraisals when the guy from the bank comes to your house and values just your house so they can decide like how big of a loan you qualify for. 21:24 So fee appraisal, one house, mass appraisal, like all of them. 21:28 And so the most common mass appraisal method is what's called the sales adjusted cost approach. 21:33 And what's cool about this is that, and what basically that is, it's like you're going to value the improvements based off of how much it costs to replace them, like an insurance company would do. 21:42 And then you discount it by the age and condition for depreciation, right? 21:46 So if your house burns down in a fire, how much is a fair price for me to put on your policy to replace that house? 21:52 In theory, they're supposed to value the value of your improvements in a similar way. 21:57 But then they go look at market sales and there's always going to be a gap between construction costs and houses because anyone who studied housing knows that there's this mysterious difference Between what it costs to produce a house and what it actually sells for, right? 22:11 And reconciling that gap is the sales adjusted part of the sales adjusted cost approach. 22:17 And reconciling that gap usually comes down to establishing a site value, a land value. 22:23 So even though these jurisdictions don't necessarily have anything on the books for their property tax to tax land and building at separate rates, the most popular method, caveat when it is done correctly, which it isn't always, 22:37 That would necessarily imply that they have an interest in knowing what the land value is just because how else do you reconcile depreciated replacement costs and what's actually happening in the market other than being like location, location, location. 22:50 It's more valuable to be in this neighborhood than that neighborhood. 22:52 And we see these kind of houses in two neighborhoods, but they sell for very different prices. 22:56 We can like do a little Sudoku here. 22:57 And the whole method is like a whole thing I can get into, which would take hours to talk about. 23:03 But... 23:04 Most jurisdictions, at least nominally, are writing down two numbers. 23:08 Now, whether those numbers are up to date or whether they're actually doing the method properly or whether they're actually recognizing that locational differences should be put onto the land rather than just randomly piled into the buildings, 23:20 as some jurisdictions do, you know, you'd have to show me the actual jurisdiction. 23:24 So practice is very fragmented and heterogeneous. 23:27 I think if my memory is correct, when we lived in Georgia... 23:32 The county, when the tax bill came each year, it actually broke it out on the bill showing land assessment versus improvement assessment. 23:42 And where we are in my county, Missouri, I think we just get a single number on the property tax bill. 23:48 Yeah, most places in the U.S. do not have any kind of split rate or land value tax. 23:52 It's just a regular property tax. 23:54 But a lot of them will split out the number just because they got to explain the property tax, right? 23:59 They got to explain the valuation, so they got to explain the components. 24:02 Yeah. 24:25 So let's talk about some places that have implemented a land value tax or switched over to that as the primary source. 24:33 And, you know, I think there's a couple, I think like Pittsburgh and Harrisburg in Pennsylvania, I remember are pretty common examples. 24:40 Can you talk about like what has happened in some places that have made transition over and is there a way to measure success in those cases? 24:48 Yeah. 24:48 Yeah, so there's, what's interesting is that the evidence right now, so land value tax is a policy that has a big theoretical backing. 24:56 And there's been some empirical cases, but like most things in econ, like we don't have like the beautiful experimental cases we'd like. 25:03 We've got some pretty good ones. 25:05 A lot of the strongest cases are actually historical. 25:08 And so they're like 100 years old. 25:10 You know, there was like a German colony that ran entirely in China that ran entirely on land value tax for like 20 years and was really successful. 25:17 But that was 100 years ago, people want something a little more fresh. 25:19 And so the fresher examples tend to be a little lower power. 25:22 They tend to be more modest. 25:23 Most of them in the US were in Pennsylvania. 25:26 So you had cases in Pennsylvania where a split rate property tax has been allowed for a while. 25:32 Places like Pittsburgh was one and there was, I think Scranton had one for a long time. 25:36 There were various places that have had them. 25:39 They don't have the numbers in front of me. 25:40 I'm sure there's a report on my website that like listed out. 25:43 But the main thing they saw was that the vacant lots built in, you know, there was, I think it was like 14% increase in building permits over the period that they had them. 25:53 The sky, importantly, did not fall, right? 25:56 As some people think that like this policy was like crazy and dangerous or something. 26:00 It's like, Like life mostly continued, you know, it got cheaper to build. 26:05 And, you know, the way these implementations are usually done is revenue neutral. 26:10 So you'd swap to this. 26:11 So it's not like revenue would change after. 26:14 So they tended to be pretty pro-growth in an area where, which at the time had been pretty post-industrial, right? 26:21 So a lot of the places that did this did better than the other post-industrial cities in the area. 26:25 You know, I think one of them was Allentown. 26:27 And there's a famous, who has the song? 26:29 I forget. 26:30 Is that Springsteen? 26:31 I think so. 26:32 And so it's like a kind of dystopian song, right? 26:34 But like Allentown, like modern day Allentown is doing like better than the song suggests. 26:38 And in one part, you know, some people attribute that to the split rate tax they had in the meantime. 26:43 And So that is the evidence that's most commonly cited from the United States. 26:49 There are some other examples, particularly the historical examples, which had much higher land value tax rates. 26:55 The city of Vancouver historically ran itself on LVT for a really long time, but they eventually did away with that in modern times. 27:04 And then there are some other interesting modern examples, which is If you're really trying to prove something, you shouldn't just look for evidence for it. 27:13 You should see what happens when you do the opposite. 27:16 And one of the most interesting cases of this is in Hawaii, which had an anti-land value tax. 27:21 Because they had a split rate tax provisions, but the local NIMBYs were like, actually, development is bad. 27:30 So we want less development, so we should tax buildings at a higher rate, and we should tax land less. 27:37 And you get all of the opposite theorized effects that you would see from a land value tax. 27:41 You basically got low-rise sprawl and massively high expensive housing prices and kind of this big tax on development. 27:51 And Prop 13 is not like a clean anti-land value tax. 27:55 It's just like a really, really, really badly configured property tax. 28:00 And, you know, the situation in California is quite dire, but it basically hands an enormous subsidy to the people who have lived there the longest. 28:08 And so it's not a perfect anti-land value tax, but it's a crude anti-land value tax. 28:14 And then there are examples of just conventional property tax, which is conventional property tax is already a land value tax, but with a building tax on top. 28:29 What's interesting about that is that examples from places like Texas and other places show that you get at least some of the effects that are theorized from a land value tax in high property tax states. 28:39 You also get that tax on production at the same time, so you get some negative effects But so when you take a kind of holistic view of it like this, rather than kind of waiting for the perfect day, where just like 100%, you know, 28:53 like 100% prescription strength land value tax just like descends from the heavens before we can say anything, you can look at, you know, the negative uno reverse policy, and then like the pure but kind of weak policy, 29:06 and then the like, you know, fairly strong but It's not exactly a land value tax. 29:12 It's got this other thing in the mix at the same time through conventional property taxes because there's just much more sample size there. 29:18 And so that's how I kind of triangulate my evidence base. 29:21 Yeah, I mean, I think that framing a property tax is actually two taxes. 29:26 That's a land tax and a building tax. 29:28 I think that's a really important distinction and a really good way to communicate it. 29:35 If I wanted to, if my city wanted to initiate a land value tax, what are the chances that I need like a state enabling legislation for that to happen? 29:45 It depends on the state you're in, right? 29:47 But the chances are pretty good because most states, if I didn't know what state you're in, most states in the United States have what's called a uniformity clause. 29:55 Every state in the United States has some form of property tax, and most of them have a uniformity clause in their state constitution, which says that, and it's a well-intentioned clause, and it just says that ad valorem taxes on real property shall be assessed. 30:10 What they're saying is like everything's got 30:25 It's got to be assessed like at market value. 30:27 Or maybe the voters decided it shouldn't be market value. 30:30 It should be half of market value or whatever they decide. 30:33 It's just whatever your rule is, it needs to be applied without bias. 30:38 The problem is these can, So 30:47 it depends. 30:47 But some of these clauses are flexible. 30:49 Some will be like, you can be uniform within classes. 30:52 Usually this is used to be like, okay, you can levy a different rate on commercial than on residential. 31:00 But within that class, you gotta be uniform. 31:03 If you've already got that language, you can be like, hey, we're introducing buildings and land as two different classes. 31:07 We're not gonna monkey with uniformity within the class. 31:09 We just wanna be able to treat them separately. 31:12 And honestly, even though the law is the law and you have to follow it as written, The spirit is everyone already has agreed that they don't want to tax everything 100% uniformity because everyone wants to give a break to residential, right? 31:24 This is usually done through exemptions, homestead exemptions and things like that. 31:29 Usually in states like Texas, those are all enumerated in the Constitution rather than having this machinery you can piggyback on for other things. 31:37 But this is why when we pitch land value tax, Sometimes we'll pitch it as universal building exemption, not just because that plays way better because everyone hates taxes, but everyone loves an exemption. 31:48 Not only because it plays better, but because like that's literally the legal mechanism. 31:51 It's like there's already a mechanism for an exemption. 31:54 And so even though they won't let us assign two different rates, they will allow us to just exempt the building value and keep the revenue neutral. 32:01 So in some places, we'll just push for building exemptions. 32:04 And other places, they won't even have that. 32:07 Like they won't allow a split rate. 32:08 They won't allow an exemption. 32:09 In those cases, your options are to either just punch through and just like Just try to win at politics. 32:16 And we've done that in a couple states. 32:17 You know, you just amend the Constitution. 32:19 It can be done. 32:20 The other way to do it is sometimes there'll be a provision for a temporary abatement. 32:25 And actually, this is another piece of evidence. 32:28 New York City in the 1920s, under Lawson Purdy and Al Smith, they instituted a 10-year abatement on the improvement value of new construction. 32:37 And it was one of the things that led to the famous building boom in New York in the 1920s. 32:44 Was that if you built a new building, you would not pay taxes on the value of that building for 10 years. 32:50 And because of the way that finance works, you care much more about money today than you do money 30 years from now. 32:57 So the front-loaded value of even a temporary abatement can actually approximate a lot of the effects of a land value tax. 33:04 And I've written this article about how Even if you could just do a 10-year abatement on the improvement value, I mean, 15 or 20 would be even better. 33:12 If you can just abate the improvement value, that could get you like 80-20 of a land value tax and it might be easier to pass. 33:19 And it might even be easier to explain. 33:22 And so we try to be very flexible with our policy and just like, you know, figure the first thing we do in any new state is just like figure out like what we're up against and just find a way to work within the legal language and decide like how ambitious 33:34 a reform needs, you know, reform needs to be. 33:36 But, you know, it's all about working. 33:38 And it's usually it's usually pull rather than push. 33:41 It's always a local advocate that comes to us first. 33:44 And then we just help them work out, you know, the scenario planning and then just help them do what they want to do. 33:49 Yeah, you might want to look at my city, Kansas City, as a case study sometime. 33:54 We have been very aggressive in our use of tax abatements for probably over 30 years now. 34:00 It's an extremely common tool in new development, and they're almost all exclusively granted. 34:06 And some of them are as long as 25 years. 34:09 It's really an interesting, might be an interesting study. 34:12 So one other thing I wanted to ask you about. 34:14 So like in my city also, there's been a lot of discussion in part due to frustration with like speculators, you know, hoarding large amounts of land into saying, well, why don't we just pass a vacant land tax? 34:28 yeah. 34:29 So I wanted like pros and what do you think about that approach versus, you know, because it seemed to me it's like, okay, you could do that, but that's kind of adding another layer onto the system, another layer of complexity onto an already complex system. 34:44 It's kind of like Mamdani's pita tier tax, right? 34:46 It's just like supposed to be this little surgical strike on this like one thing that you're upset about. 34:51 And I won't say it's bad. 34:54 I just can kind of predict what's going to happen. 34:55 And it's the concrete port-a-potty problem. 34:58 What's the definition of vacant, right? 35:00 You know, it's going to be like, okay, there's no structure on it. 35:03 It's like, okay, what's the minimal definition of a structure? 35:06 And it's like, oh, a concrete port-a-potty. 35:07 It's like, okay, every vacant lot will have a concrete port-a-potty and no more. 35:11 And so there's a kind of welfare cliff problem with vacant lot taxes. 35:16 I'm not saying they have no effect and that they're like bad policy. 35:19 I think that you'll just be disappointed that it's not that they won't work, it's that they will work less well than you expect just because they can be evaded by just building an extremely low value minimal structure and they're just on or off. 35:35 It's not proportional to the... 35:37 Whereas a land value tax is just, we're just going I'm going to tax you based on how valuable the land is. 35:41 If the land is worthless, you pay almost nothing. 35:43 If the land is extremely valuable, you'll pay a lot more. 35:46 And if you had a nice big building that was putting that land to use, whose building value was not taxed, then you would be like, well, this is great. 35:54 I'm doing fine. 35:55 I'm doing better than I was than under a property tax. 35:58 Whereas if a land speculator basically flips the incentive from rewarding the land speculator to rewarding the person who actually puts the site to a good use. 36:07 And that has its strongest effect like downtown. 36:09 A vacant lot tax is supposed to kind of do the same thing, but it's much more binary. 36:14 If you put anything here, suddenly the tax vanishes. 36:17 And if you have nothing on it, then you got to pay the tax. 36:20 This is similar to things like parcel taxes, which is just a flat tax for every parcel you have. 36:26 And those, because they're not targeted to the value of the site, they're less effective. 36:32 If someone was literally doing nothing with a parcel, they might be like, Oh, why am I holding this? 36:36 Let's sell it. 36:37 But if you're holding a $10 million parcel, a flat parcel tax, or a vacant lot tax, you'll just figure out what the lowest value use is. 36:44 Yeah. 36:46 So let's also talk about the assessment process a little bit. 36:50 And just by way of background, you know, in my county, we have had two major reassessments. 36:57 We reassess every four years in my county. 37:00 And we've had two major changes in the last, you know, in the last two cycles that have had massive increases in valuations. 37:10 And so... 37:12 You know, all this probably is, you know, in the weeds and too complex, but basically for a lot of years, property just was not reassessed properly to the market. 37:22 And so I think we probably had a lot of property that was from the assessor's level was undervalued. 37:28 And so then we had a new administrative regime that decided we're going to update it and get things up to the values that they're supposed to be. 37:37 Which caused, as you might imagine, like a shitstorm of protest as property taxes just went through the roof for homeowners and for commercial properties. 37:46 So it sort of begs the question then, is this just a feature of any property taxation system that has assessment to it? 37:54 Or how might this be different under a land value tax system? 37:58 Yeah, I mean, land value tax does kind of inherit this problem, you know, but I think there's a way through it, and that is to just commit to just updating your values every year. 38:07 There are states that update their values every year. 38:09 It can be done, and you tend to get less protests when that happens. 38:14 Another thing, this is another digression we can get into, which I'll try to avoid, is that now there's AI-generated protests, so the volume of protests is increasing year over year, not because people are necessarily more mad because it's so easy to protest now, 38:26 and so the assessors are having to fight back with You know, their own AI systems or whatever. 38:30 That's a whole nother thing. 38:31 But if you don't reassess your properties for a long time, people get used to the idea that their property has an increase in value. 38:38 You know, they'll be like, why haven't you know, the minute you buy your house, you stop paying attention to the market. 38:43 And you're like, well, I bought it for $30,000 back in 1980. 38:46 So what do you mean it's worth this much now? 38:49 The other thing is that there can sometimes be an unhelpful political game that's played between elected officials and the assessor. 38:56 And that is to make the assessor the whipping boy. 38:58 Because you said property taxes increased. 39:01 Valuations increasing doesn't necessarily mean that there's no reason that the aggregate property tax has to increase just because the property values increase. 39:09 Property values increasing is an observational fact of reality. 39:14 And the assessor is supposed to be a neutral fact finder. 39:17 They don't have taxing powers. 39:18 They're just like... 39:19 Look, I'm just telling you the same thing Zillow is, right? 39:22 Like that is what people are offering for a property like this. 39:25 That's what they seem to be selling for. 39:27 That's what the rent support. 39:28 That's what the comparable sales support. 39:31 Like that just seems to be our best estimate of the truth of the market. 39:35 Now, what we should do about that with regards to what your tax bill should be, that is a political decision for an elected official. 39:43 And that's basically a math question of what's the tax rate supposed to be. 39:48 And so what happens down here in Texas, let me Throw the draw on. 39:51 Let me tell you how we do it down here in Texas. 39:52 What happens is I sit up on my hickory stump and I wave the flag in the background as an eagle soars, crying majestically. 39:59 And then I put my hand on my heart and my other hand on the Bible and I swear, my fellow red-blooded Texans, I haven't raised that millage rate in 10 years, I swear to you. 40:08 But that mean old property tax assessor, well, he done doubled your values. 40:13 You go send your debt threats to him while I collect twice the revenue. 40:17 And so it's like, you're the dude who controls the tax rate. 40:20 And you're just like, I've seen politicians like chumming the water, sending people like yelling at that mean old property appraiser. 40:29 And like, these are the same ones, like you send people from your local government unit to sit on the appraisal board. 40:35 Like, you know what's going on. 40:37 Like, you just want to be able to collect more revenue and not get yelled at. 40:42 You want it to be, it's a beautiful, like... 40:45 Permission structure in a way if it's not, you know, I feel kind of cynical about it. 40:50 And so what happens is that assessors are yelled at all the time. 40:53 I mean, this is not to say that I like defend the practices of every assessor everywhere who could be doing a better job, you know, but by and large, people don't understand the mass appraisal system. 41:04 When they get their valuation, they think it's a bill. 41:07 You know, it's like the valuation goes up. 41:09 They think taxes have to go up. 41:11 They do not have to go up. 41:12 That is a political decision. 41:13 And so one thing with land value tax reforms, we will inherit like challenges with the I will say there's a lot of different ways to do assessments. 41:23 Historically, land value taxes were actually done in the United States, actually, by consensus land valuation. 41:30 They would just get the whole town in a big meeting and just get a big map on the back. 41:34 And they'd just be like, okay, folks, what's the most valuable stretch of frontage in town? 41:38 Main Street from first to third. 41:39 It's like, all right, let's put a big X here. 41:41 Now, what's the second most valuable stretch of frontage from town? 41:44 Well, that's Main Street from third to second. 41:46 Well, relative to X, would you say that's 0.99, 0.9? 41:49 And they would just like argue for hours and like probably have some drinks or whatever. 41:53 Like the whole town would just get together as a community and just value all their land with their own irreducible local knowledge. 41:59 That is a completely different way from the way we do things now. 42:02 I'm sure it would be illegal according to all our statutes. 42:05 But if some, I don't know, Central European country wants to adopt that system, nothing would stop them. 42:10 But the way we value it now, we would inherit the existing appraisal system. 42:14 There's enough infrastructure in there, especially with the sales-adjusted cost approach and stuff, and the way insurers value buildings, that we could get the job done. 42:22 So really, the challenge is just political. 42:24 And we have enough history from the property tax system to know where the landmines are and how to put best practices into place so you can explain your valuations to the public, you can message well, you can keep your stuff up to date. 42:37 With advances in GIS and aerial imagery and computer processing, good valuation is mostly a running a tight ship problem and a data quality and curation problem. 42:48 Like running the fancy algorithms is actually the easy part. 42:51 It's just the pipeline of being like, are you keeping characteristics up to date? 42:55 Do you know which houses are new construction? 42:58 Do you know when they were built? 43:00 Do you have photographs? 43:01 You know what I mean? 43:02 Once you do that, then you can do a pretty good job of constructing a credible model and even explaining it to people who do not have degrees in math. 43:11 You know, is everyone doing that? 43:12 Not necessarily. 43:13 Is... 43:15 It's kind of incumbent on me to kind of distill all of that stuff into policy recommendations people can follow. 43:21 I'm actually going to the Assessors Conference in Calgary, the International Association of Assessors Officers. 43:28 It's in Calgary this year. 43:30 I think next year it's in, I forget, it's in the States next year, but to talk about these issues. 43:34 Mm-hmm. 43:35 So we will inherit assessment challenges, but I think most of the obstacles are political rather than necessarily technical. 43:41 I mean, they're technical in certain places where they need to like up their game, but most of the challenges are political. 43:47 And I think a lot of this is that we've neglected our civil service. 43:50 We've kind of demonized them. 43:52 And also just like, There's no rich or scary anthropomorphic animal that's like municipal property tax assessor. 43:58 No kid goes into that career. 44:00 They call it the accidental profession. 44:02 And so, yeah, it's a whole spiel I can go into. 44:05 There's issues. 44:07 We can fix them if we have the will to have nice things. 44:09 Yeah, I mean, to your point, it's funny how people don't understand it's a two-part formula. 44:14 You know, it's your assessment, your value times the millage levy. 44:19 Right. 44:20 And it's often a variety of levies because it's going to multiple taxing jurisdictions on your tax bill. 44:26 Like, for example, in my county, one of the biggest issues I had, we had this massive reassessment and all the values went way up. 44:34 And so in this county, we have probably like 10 different school districts Nine of them chose to lower the village levy to offset the increase. 44:43 One of them, the one where I lived, of course, did not. 44:46 And then they just blamed the county. 44:49 Well, the county assessor, you know, this, oh, you mean you got a 27% tax increase because of the county assessor. 44:54 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. 44:57 Yeah, no, exactly. 44:58 Or there's another way they do it. 45:00 So one of the fun things they do in Texas is that they brag about how big they made your homestead exemption. 45:04 You've got this huge homestead exemption that only applies to the school millage rate. 45:09 You're still paying county taxes. 45:11 You're still paying city taxes. 45:12 You're still paying special district taxes at the full valuation. 45:17 The homestead exemption only applies to your school taxes. 45:20 But they can be like, you got $100,000 or $250,000 or whatever. 45:24 And so like, it's similar to the way politicians message Homestead exemptions and things. 45:28 Yeah. 45:51 So, I mean, I also want to say I get the frustration that a lot of people have with the increase in property taxes in so many jurisdictions. 46:00 There often does feel like there's a lack of transparency and there's a lot of confused messages that come from elected officials. 46:07 And there's a lot of questions that I think people rightfully have, like, what are we paying for? 46:13 And could it be spent more efficiently or better or different or whatever? 46:17 But there's one argument you made in a piece I mentioned earlier I thought was really interesting that's something for people to think about. 46:24 When you switch to a really low property tax model like Hawaii used as example, one of the results for that is a lot more land speculation. 46:37 And I guess that logistically that makes sense. 46:38 I wonder if you could talk a little bit about that. 46:40 So one of the things is, is imagine, imagine you've got a pencil, right? 46:45 And what does a pencil cost? 46:46 Like, I don't know, maybe 10 cents, you buy them in a big pack. 46:49 Imagine if it costs you one cent a year to hold that pencil. 46:53 You know what I mean? 46:54 You would probably like, if you've got like several boxes of pencils, you'd probably go sell them all on eBay right now or throw them out. 46:59 You know what I mean? 47:00 Like any pencils you're not using, you're not going to use. 47:02 Now, this would be a bad policy for pencils because we can have pencil abundance. 47:07 It's fine. 47:08 You know what I mean? 47:09 But when it's something that everybody needs and that nobody can make any more of and that owning it basically entitles you to charge rent for it that someone else has to pay, you wind up with situations where Larry Ellison is a billionaire and he owns an entire Hawaiian island. 47:24 And he's paying low property taxes on that. 47:28 We're basically reconstructing feudalism at some point. 47:32 In California, that's exactly what we're doing. 47:34 With Prop 13, basically, one of the traditional privileges of the aristocratic European Landed gentry was the right to not pay taxes. 47:42 That was for peasants. 47:44 And so what was interesting is that, and also the right to pass on that benefit to your heirs. 47:51 And that sounds great. 47:52 I don't want to ever pay any taxes. 47:54 I want my kids to have, you know, just like extremely easy lives. 47:58 But the problem is everyone can't do that. 48:01 And so what happens is that society divides into have nots, haves and have nots, blue bloods and peasants. 48:07 And in California, Prop 13 means your property is valued at its 1970 value or whatever, 1975, six, and is only allowed to increase so much a year. 48:20 Well, it's only allowed to increase X a year, but it's actually increased So over time, it's been 50 years since Prop 13 passed. 48:29 So you have houses that are taxed as if they're worth $30,000 and they're worth $3 million. 48:35 And so you can have two side-by-side houses, someone that bought a house this year and someone who bought a house since the 70s and has held onto it. 48:44 And there's like a 10x difference in what they're paying in taxes. 48:48 And basically, and even worse, there was an additional prop that passed that allowed you to pass that on. 48:54 Like the valuation is supposed to change when you sell unless you give it to your heir. 48:59 So now there is a class of people in California who are just better than you. 49:04 They're literal... 49:05 Like entitled landed gentry with the privilege of paying much lower taxes because they've been there longer. 49:12 And who makes up the burden? 49:13 Everybody else. 49:14 Everybody who moves in later, everybody who has to commute into the city because it increased the income tax and sales taxes and all these other taxes to make up for that lost tax base. 49:24 And also at the same time, basically pushes the burden to new people. 49:27 And so one of the challenges with getting rid of property taxes is that it's not a static system. 49:34 Every small town is going to become speed trap central and have all these nickel and dime fees, and they're going to get them from wherever they can get them. 49:41 And So it's a kind of be careful what you wish for situation because it's not like we haven't run this experiment. 49:47 We've run this experiment in many of the states, ironically, and mostly in blue states because blue states are much more tolerant of other taxes. 49:55 Red states are much less tolerant of other taxes, which is ironically why they tend to be much more property tax friendly because that's basically the only thing that's left. 50:03 Interesting. 50:05 And it also seems like it's one of the challenges to reform or more adoption is the longer you have a property tax system that has lots of exemptions and everything carved out into it, you end up with a class of owners, 50:19 and I'm not talking I'm not talking about wealthy individuals or homeowners, but I'm talking about also large property owners that are benefiting from that system. 50:26 So like in my city, I can think of banks that own huge amounts of property, insurance companies, nonprofits that own large areas of land that are benefiting from the system as it is. 50:40 And then it becomes, I think, even harder to change that system because you've got some pretty entrenched people who really like it the way it is. 50:47 Right. 50:47 And I want to mention, I'm a homeowner. 50:49 I live in the suburbs, right? 50:50 And in most of my modeling, land value tax is either neutral or slightly beneficial for homeowners. 50:55 A lot of these big property tax carve-outs are sold to homeowners, but some of the biggest beneficiaries are often other people. 51:03 In California, the biggest beneficiaries of Prop 13 is actually the commercial property and specifically vacant land. 51:09 Vacant land enjoys the greatest tax advantage of Based on its parcel type, rather than the tax advantage for a typical residential home is much smaller in comparison, even though that's still huge. 51:24 And so you see these kind of things. 51:28 We hosted an example from a friend on our blog, which talked about this case of nonprofits basically... 51:35 Non-profit medical organizations would buy up private clinics because then the real estate of the private clinic would become part of their portfolio. 51:43 And as a non-profit, it's no longer taxed. 51:45 And so you see all these private real estate empires being built on the backs of things that were sold to homeowners as, you know, and then they just like quietly, you know, pocket the advantage. 51:55 Yeah, it's great. 51:55 I mean, I run a nonprofit, but it's like, don't even get me started. 51:58 Like nonprofit ownership of property and how it's just gotten so distorted so many places, whether it's, you know, college, nonprofit, quote unquote, nonprofit colleges that really actually are private for-profit institutions in many ways, medical, you know, hospitals, etc. 52:13 It's crazy. 52:14 But it's just been a great way for people to kind of work around the system. 52:18 The other thing, like in the California example, we've certainly seen this, but I've seen this in Midwestern cities as well, is if the property taxes, if the local government's ability to Collect much from property taxes is diminished or if it's not very high, 52:34 then they'll compete against each other for sales taxes pretty aggressively. 52:39 And so you actually end up with a lot more, there's a lot of incentive for sort of like commercial sprawl in adjoining jurisdictions because they're competing, you know, everybody wants that Costco or that the Home Depot or the shopping mall 52:52 or whatever that's going to generate a ton of sales tax in theory for them. 52:55 And you also have weird cases where basically it screws up the incentives of your government for what it wants their city to look like. 53:03 Because they're like, I just want a big box store that I can charge some sales tax to. 53:07 They'll go to the historic main town. 53:09 It's like, I don't like that business. 53:10 I can't wait for it to get out of here. 53:11 And someone will be like, why? 53:13 Everyone loves that business. 53:13 It's like, I don't get enough sales tax revenue from it. 53:16 You know what I mean? 53:17 As in, well, what's interesting is that if you think about it, if you have a land value tax, Then a property tax approximates it, although imperfectly. 53:27 Your incentive is to increase the land value. 53:29 What does it mean to increase the land value? 53:30 To make your city a nicer place. 53:33 Land value is just the desirability of the place. 53:35 So if you revitalize that downtown rather than let it get hollowed out, that becomes your tax base and that pays for everything. 53:43 Whereas if you're constantly chasing people down for sales tax, well, then the businesses are just going to hug that border, right? 53:52 And they're just going to play you against each other because that's the other advantage of land value tax and property tax as well, but land value tax even more. 53:59 All the other taxes are more mobile. 54:01 Like this billionaire wealth tax that, you know, they were trying to pass in California. 54:05 Like, I don't really care about the fate of billionaires personally or anything like that. 54:11 But compared to other wealth taxes in the world, they basically designed the most likely one to possibly be evaded. 54:18 Like there's a Norwegian, like I'm a Norwegian citizen too. 54:21 There's a Norwegian wealth tax, like say what you will about wealth taxes, but at least that one was pretty good at not being evadeable. 54:26 Like over half of the billionaire tax bill was We'll see you next time. 54:54 Shower them with subsidies. 54:56 And then they're going to nommel up that subsidy. 54:58 They're going to go nom, nom, nom, nom, nom, thanks. 55:00 They're going to employ a bunch of like low paid workers, like minimum wage basically for a couple of years. 55:06 As soon as the subsidy is gone, they're going to skip town and go do it again in the next town over that gives them the same thing. 55:13 And you're going to be left with this giant blighted property with no tenants. 55:16 And it's like, what was the point of that? 55:19 And I just think that a lot of local jurisdictions just have this very limited vocabulary for how to promote growth. 55:25 And they just kind of keep going back to these same, like, we'll just give them 100% exemption on all the property tax and give them active subsidies. 55:33 And why does nothing work? 55:37 Last little wonky question I'm going to ask you about is let's talk a little bit about real estate transfer taxes because this is also often part of the conversation. 55:44 Maybe you can reduce property taxes and you can have transfer taxes instead when properties sell. 55:50 What kind of work have you done or what have you been able to work on in that area? 55:53 Oh, that's the topic of next week's article, actually. 55:56 I have an article next week about comparing transfer taxes. 55:59 And so the problem, sales taxes in general, like on produced goods, like pencils and groceries and stuff, are already known to be like very regressive. 56:10 And they also have the problem of they discourage transactions, they discourage trade, they discourage commerce. 56:16 It's literally like If you think of commerce like the blood of your economy, then any kind of sales tax is basically 56:24 like cholesterol clogging up the veins and slowing the flow of blood. 56:27 Right? 56:28 You know, and when it completely blocks it, you get a heart attack and you die. 56:31 You know, not to stretch the metaphor to the point of absurdity. 56:35 But transfer taxes, and these have been disastrous in the UK and in American cities that have these, they create this lock-in effect where people who would otherwise want to move are like, I don't want to sell my house because then I'm going to like base like 56:53 that action is going to be taxed with this big upfront tax. 56:56 And so it increases the friction before they're going to rationally decide they want to move. 57:00 Even if like normally they would have decided it's like, yeah, I want to move. 57:03 And so when less people move, less items are trading, it pushes up the cost of housing. 57:09 And then especially when it's paired to assessment caps, especially caps like Prop 13, but other states have like lesser caps, it creates this double lock in. 57:17 Because not only do I not want to sell because of the assessment, because of the sales tax on the transfer, I also don't want to move because any house I buy will have its valuation reset. 57:30 And so it creates this double lock in effect. 57:32 It makes people stay in their houses much longer than they naturally would have. 57:36 So it's like people are always like, Lars, you're bad because you want to force people out of their homes. 57:40 It's like, why are you forcing people to stay longer than they naturally would? 57:45 Right. 57:45 There's this opposite effect going where it's like people are staying in houses long after their kids have moved out when they would much rather like downsize and like save some money in a normal, healthy market where they can go and buy a less expensive home. 57:59 But because the market has been frozen in amber, that less expensive home, especially if its property value is going to reset. 58:06 Will not be cheaper to do. 58:08 And so they'd rather just stay on, hold onto this asset forever. 58:13 And when one person does that, it's not a big deal. 58:15 When everybody does that, it really clogs up the housing market. 58:18 It increases prices for everyone. 58:20 It makes it so young people can't ever get a start. 58:23 And I can just tell you that having an entire class of restless young people is not good for society. 58:29 That's right. 58:30 So Lars has been really, really helpful. 58:32 I appreciate your time today. 58:34 You've talked a little bit about some things that you've got coming up. 58:37 What else is next for you and for the Substack or for what your organization is doing? 58:42 Yeah, so we just hired a new person, Jeff Fong, who's done a lot of work with the YIMBYs. 58:47 You know, we like to think of ourselves as a connective tissue between movements like YIMBY on the one hand, but then also movements like Strong Towns, which are sometimes a little more skeptical of the mainstream YIMBY stuff. 58:57 And, you know, we kind of get down in the details. 58:59 You know, it's not just entirely a just build baby build conversation. 59:03 There's also tax policy and regulations and all these other things to think about. 59:07 And we like to fill that gap. 59:08 I'm going to the appraisal conference, you know, next week. 59:12 And what's going to come from us in the next year is we're going to put out more reports. 59:17 We've already teased an upcoming report about valuations in New York City. 59:21 I think Greg has posted about that on Twitter. 59:24 And we've got to, you know, so we'll have more to say about that. 59:27 And then, yeah, just more of the stuff we've been doing, more reports, more case studies, more open source software, more map visualizations and hopefully more podcasts. 59:37 We'll see. 59:37 All right. 59:38 Well, terrific. 59:39 Well, definitely check out Lars at his Substack, Progress and Poverty. 59:45 It's very good reading, even if it seems a little weedsy for you. 59:49 It's actually, he relates it, I think, really well to a mass audience. 59:53 Lars, you say, thanks so much for coming on the show, and I hope to talk to you again. 59:57 Thanks very much, Kevin. 59:58 Farewell, [music]
Community discussion