0:00 Welcome to The Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:20 [music] 0:47 Welcome back to The Messy City Podcast. 0:49 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:52 I'd like to take a few minutes today and build upon a little bit of the previous kind of solo podcast that I had and talk about housing and markets and cities, but do so in a little different manner, maybe a little more unconventional manner, I'm not sure. 1:14 So I was really pleased to get some of the feedback I got on the topic that I had about The so-called housing crisis in America and whether there is a crisis or what is the actual crisis. 1:30 I really enjoyed making that episode to kind of walk through some of the history of my own family and then And relate that to housing and the discussion of housing. 1:42 And then especially had a lot of fun talking with Chuck Maroon and two other younger professionals about the issue and their own take on it. 1:52 So I would love to keep doing more of that if anybody would like to continue on that route. 1:59 There's a lot more to say about that specific aspect of the topic. 2:04 But I want to take a different tack today and I want to talk a lot more about The importance of order, law enforcement, and crime in the discussion about cities. 2:19 And something I've talked about before in a few other podcasts, but I want to dive a little deeper and explain in some really practical terms why this is something that people who call themselves urbanists should deeply, deeply care about. 2:36 And... 2:38 And I say that because the sense that I get in a lot of this community of advocates, of city advocates and urban advocates and others, it's just a lot of hand-waving away of this issue. 2:49 Like, oh, either it's not an issue or it's not that big a deal. 2:54 Or people make too much of it. 2:56 Or it's misinformation or who knows what. 3:00 And I actually think it's fundamental for us to care about and not care about just like a little bit, but care about as a top issue. 3:09 And so let me talk about, there's two very different practical elements I want to talk about as I work through this. 3:20 And the first goes back to A video that Andres Duany made probably 30 years ago now. 3:29 In some of the early days of the new urbanism, Andres made a number of these videos, which actually at the time were even distributed on VHS tapes. 3:38 And I think I still have them in my basement. 3:40 He made maybe six or eight of these on different topics. 3:45 And one of those was about really the marketing of walkability. 3:49 And the marketing advantage that cities have and the marketing advantage that suburbs have. 3:56 And this was one at the time that really kind of opened my mind to thinking about this from a different perspective. 4:04 And there were two things that he talked about a lot in that video that were super important that I'll relate to. 4:10 There were probably 10 different things he talked about. 4:12 There were two that really stuck with me. 4:15 And one had to do with the problem a lot of city and urban advocates have is they look at cities like an insider and not an outsider. 4:28 And what do I mean by that? 4:32 Most people don't live in your city and they don't know all the ins and outs. 4:37 They don't know every business on every corner. 4:40 They don't know where there's trash or not trash. 4:42 They don't know where's a scary area or not scary area. 4:47 And so the perceptions are very, very different. 4:50 And so the challenge is if you want to actually be successful in bringing people to your city and having more people come to it to live, to do business or for entertainment or whatever, you have to really see the city through their eyes. 5:06 And especially you have to see the city through the eyes of actual Americans. 5:12 And, you know, not sort of like hypothetical Americans, but the way that Americans actually are, the environments they come from. 5:20 Most people now live in suburbs. 5:21 The majority of people, I think, live in suburbs. 5:25 Or at least the largest percentage. 5:27 You know, there are tens of millions of people who live in suburbs and small towns where issues like violent crime are very rare, where issues like homelessness are very rare. 5:38 And so you have, if you want to... 5:41 Have those people come into your city and participate in it, you know, through commerce or whatever. 5:47 You've got to understand their vantage point and where they're coming from. 5:51 And, you know, when people come to a place and they see trash everywhere, they see disorder, they see graffiti everywhere. 5:59 You know, maybe, you know, if you live in a place, maybe a lot of that really isn't a big deal for your day-to-day life, but it puts forth a perception and a perception for a lot of people that's just not good. 6:11 You know, there's so much of life that really is about the packaging of whatever we do or the marketing of whatever we do. 6:19 And if the marketing value you're putting forward is not your best possible product, your best possible image, then people are going to react to that. 6:29 And there are reasons that people generally keep coming back to the nicer places and the places that are the cleanest, that are the most well-maintained. 6:42 And there's a lot of reason that smart developers, for example, really care about the day-to-day maintenance of everything on their property or around their property. 6:53 And like the really good developers you'll even find that will go outside and pick up trash on their own property just to make sure it's really clean and attractive. 7:04 And a lot of urban and city advocates tend to look at their place as an insider instead of thinking about how its perceptions of the world. 7:14 That's something you've got to break if you really want to be successful as a community. 7:19 Related to that, the second point that Andres would talk about is understanding what is your core marketing value. 7:27 And I think this is the sort of thing that a lot of people intuitively understand, but when he just expressed it, it clicked for me. 7:33 And really, it's very simple. 7:36 You know, if you live in a suburb, the marketing value, the differentiating value is the big backyard, basically. 7:45 That you have this really nice private backyard that you control. 7:50 And, you know, because you are probably going to be spending most of your time driving around to destinations. 7:56 You're going to, you know, things are more spread apart. 8:00 It's a world built around cars and driving. 8:04 Everything, you know, post-World War II that was specifically how we planned our cities was really for driving around. 8:11 But you have this great benefit of easy parking, frankly, easy parking almost anywhere you go, easy parking and the nice big backyard. 8:19 So the nice private space. 8:22 In cities, in walkable places, you know, the key marketing distinction, because you don't have necessarily that big backyard, you don't have easy parking wherever you go. 8:33 The virtue is the great, the interesting walk. 8:37 That is the entire marketing advantage, which is a really great, interesting walk. 8:44 It's why I have been so obsessed for years about the details of the physical experience of walking, you know, not just like the sidewalk, but the trees, the landscaping, The width of the street, where the parking goes, what's the signage experience like, what's the lighting like, 9:04 whether this is a commercial street or residential street, it doesn't matter. 9:07 That quality of the walk is fundamental because that's where... 9:11 What keeps people in a more urban environment is you may sacrifice by having a smaller space. 9:19 You may not have a yard at all, or it may be a very small yard. 9:22 Parking may be a huge pain in the butt, which is a reality of a lot of modern life is most of us still are going to own cars, even in big cities. 9:32 If you have the money you can afford it, you're probably going to own a car. 9:36 And so... 9:39 That trade-off is you could walk outside your door and you have a beautiful place to walk around, an interesting and lively place to walk around with other people out and about in public spaces and lots of different choices of places to walk to, 9:56 businesses, parks, public spaces, whatever they might be, entertainment venues. 10:02 Yeah. 10:04 So that's fundamental to the entire marketing value of a city. 10:11 And so if that value is compromised by the fact that people perceive walking around to not be safe or if it is actually not safe, if that experience is burdened by tremendous disorder on the streets, whether it's just visual disorder or 10:33 whether it's human disorder like rampant homelessness, People who are obviously drug addicted or mentally ill wandering the streets, sometimes harassing people, just yelling violently. 10:49 That is something that is going to completely take away from the key differentiator for why people want to even be there in the first place. 11:00 And so, you know, I'm probably late to the party in a lot of ways in really coming to value the importance of order and the critical nature of a lot of these issues in cities. 11:15 More or less came of age in an era when all of that was really getting dramatically better. 11:22 And the places that I lived were generally pretty safe to walk around. 11:28 There were places you might not go at night, but for the most part, there wasn't a lot of fear for your life. 11:36 Just kind of walking around. 11:38 And a lot of that has changed in the last 10 years. 11:41 It has changed for the worse. 11:45 In my city and in most cities in America, the explosion of... 11:50 Persistent homelessness on the street of most cities is just, it's very obvious. 11:57 And it's a sort of thing that really begins to make people question why they live or invest in a place. 12:05 Because again, the main reason you were being there was that you could leave your place and walk around and it's attractive, it's inviting, it's interesting. 12:17 There were other The people there, the people watching was good. 12:22 The activity of all hours of the day was good. 12:26 And that was something you wanted to partake in. 12:29 And that's not something that's like just for 20-somethings. 12:32 That's something that people of all ages really are interested in. 12:37 So when that element is taken away, that's when all of a sudden you start to think, gosh, you know, well, I don't have this experience where I could go walk around anyway. 12:48 I might as well go live in a suburb where I just don't have to deal with this other stuff. 12:56 And that is a major, major issue for cities because most of our suburbs in most American cities have always had much less tolerance for that kind of disorder and for a lot of the crime that we have in big cities. 13:13 Yeah. 13:16 This has sort of always been the case. 13:17 It is still the case, I think, in most cities. 13:20 And that presents a really big competitive problem when your city is just ineffective at dealing with order on the streets. 13:32 That's even becoming more of an issue today because so many suburbs have really learned that there's a percentage in the market, maybe a sizable percentage, that really likes a walkable lifestyle. 13:50 You know, 30 years ago, I used to go around to all different venues in our region and give presentations about new urbanism and about walkability and how this was something that... 14:07 That a lot of people really are into and want, and especially young people, and it's coming and you better be ready for it. 14:14 And you should work on changing your plans and your zoning ordinances to try to prepare for this wave of people who are going to want walkability. 14:25 30 years ago, I was kind of on an island about a lot of that. 14:29 I felt very passionate about it. 14:31 And I had a lot of great discussions and seminars and ended up having a lot of clients that I worked with, communities and developers that were working in that world. 14:45 But we were really at that time on sort of the bleeding edge. 14:49 That is not the case anymore. 14:51 Even in my region, in my, you know, quiet Midwestern city that is always 10 or 20 years behind the curve of what is happening culturally on the coasts, basically every suburb in my region now has a little downtown that is actually really interesting. 15:14 Some of them are very interesting and very successful. 15:19 They have all diversified tremendously. 15:22 They've enhanced and embraced the idea of their downtowns as places to entertain, but also to live. 15:30 And so they've been building a lot of more urban housing and encouraging more of the same. 15:37 They've been changing their codes and there are now more developers and builders who know how to build this stuff and do it really well. 15:45 And this is presenting a major competitive problem for the central city because now it's possible for people to say, I could go live in one of those suburbs. 15:59 I don't have to deal with the crime and the homelessness concerns to nearly the degree that Not really anywhere near the degree that we had to in the central city. 16:09 Yeah, you know what? 16:10 I don't have the complete spectrum of choice of entertainment. 16:15 But then you say, well, how much do I really need? 16:17 You know, do I really need like 10 different coffee shops to choose from? 16:22 Or do I just need like one or two good ones? 16:25 Do I need, you know, 100 restaurants to choose from? 16:28 Or, you know, is half a dozen restaurants? 16:30 That's fine for me that we could walk to. 16:33 And what you come to understand is really for the vast majority of people, just having a small selection of any of that is really enough. 16:41 And having some attractive places to walk to, maybe hop on a bike if that's what you want to do, that it doesn't take much to really have people embrace that quasi-urban lifestyle and say that's okay. 16:57 And those might have been people who would have been central city residents at one time. 17:03 And now they're not. 17:05 And so this is, as I think about this, why I care so much about this issue, it's because it's presenting the city that I live in and other big cities with a tremendous competitive problem. 17:21 And I think people need to really wake up to this and embrace it. 17:25 So... 17:28 That's one element that I fixate on, that I say is a very practical element of why people who care about central cities and urbanism really need to value... 17:40 The issue of order and, you know, put the whole sort of umbrella of crime at the top of the list. 17:49 Because what we have in most central cities is not okay. 17:52 It's just not. 17:54 Yes, it's absolutely true that crime has come down in cities in the last year or two. 17:59 And that's a great thing. 18:03 In cities all over the country. 18:05 But it also was at unbelievably, unacceptably high levels. 18:09 And even now, it still is. 18:12 And I can tell you just from a lot of firsthand experience, there is a ton of crime that happens in cities that just does not get reported. 18:21 Police reports not filed and insurance reports not filed. 18:24 And a lot of people don't do this because they either don't want the hassle. 18:28 It's too much work. 18:29 Nothing good is going to come from it. 18:32 My insurance rates are going to go up. 18:34 There's a lot of reasons. 18:38 And so we have situations in a lot of cities that it's intolerable. 18:42 And we've got to really wake up to this and get far, far better at dealing with it. 18:48 Or if you're an urban advocate, you just settle then for the fact that you'll never have the market share of your region that you would like to have. 18:57 And you'll wonder why things just aren't really improving. 19:02 It's absolutely central to what we're talking about. 19:05 So the other aspect of then why this has another cascading effect that I care about is that most cities, including mine, have a ton of really great housing stock, really high quality, well-located housing stock that is often overlooked or abandoned completely in Um, 19:33 because it's in areas that people will not look at and why won't they look at it? 19:39 Well, the common, you know, the common thing that you will read in here is people won't look at it because they're racist, uh, and they're afraid of black people, Hispanic people, whatever. 19:53 Right. 19:54 That is the common refrain. 19:56 And, um, I don't really think that's true. 20:07 We all have it to a degree. 20:08 Everybody has prejudice to agree. 20:10 But I will tell you what you can look at objectively is that when crime was going down in cities all through the 90s, 2000s, and even into the 2010s, you had more of the market in cities expanding into areas and improving areas 20:30 that you were That you would have said people would never look at. 20:35 As soon as that flipped, people are not looking at those areas anymore. 20:41 And this is a massive problem because it's not just that we're not seeing investment, but you see further disinvestment with more people leaving. 20:52 Including, by the way, the many Black families or Hispanic families who maybe have lived there for a generation or two or three. 21:03 When the situation gets intolerable and they can afford to move out, they do it too. 21:08 And so really... 21:11 What we have, I think, in a lot of cities is we have a situation where we have an incredible resource of housing that's not being tapped because people are afraid of the crime situation primarily. 21:27 And again, this is why I want people to care so much about this issue. 21:33 By the way, the crime situation is terrible for the people who live in those neighborhoods today. 21:40 And it would be better for all the people who live in what we consider marginal or disinvested neighborhoods today if the crime in those neighborhoods was dramatically lower. 21:54 And so I want us to think about how... 21:56 How differently might the housing market look in your city, in your region, if places that are considered high crime had the same crime levels as your average suburb? 22:06 What might change in the housing market? 22:09 And I would suggest that you would have a lot more young people who would be able to come into the housing market and buy. 22:17 You would have a wealth of housing that is suddenly much more affordable that people could buy and fix up. 22:23 And some of these are not just houses that people are living in today. 22:27 There's a lot of just abandonment. 22:32 Even in a city like my region is growing as a region. 22:35 It's a growing, successful region. 22:38 We still have massive areas where there's just basically like abandonment and where if the market was functional, then you could have a lot more housing that is actually very inexpensive. 22:54 Right. 22:55 So this is an element, again, like when we talk about the housing crisis, however people want to frame that phrase, I always find it fascinating that we don't talk very much about these massive areas of our cities that there actually is a lot of housing, and frankly, 23:18 a lot of it is really good housing, that Needs investment would welcome investment, but people don't want to live there because they're afraid. 23:28 And that's really the bottom line. 23:30 And, you know, frankly, in many cases, they're right to be afraid because the crime rates are legit higher. 23:35 They are scarier places. 23:36 Yeah. 23:38 Now, and I think, you know, I think, frankly, a lot of people today are probably less inclined to even embrace a little bit of the conflict that might happen by living in a higher crime area. 23:50 So that's a whole other topic, but it's an interesting dynamic. 23:54 I think people, it's so easy to move today directly. 23:59 To places that check enough of the boxes and avoid the issues that a lot of people will just avoid them rather than saying, well, you know, here's here's a house in a rough neighborhood. 24:10 I'm going to take it on and I'm going to learn self-defense if I need to. 24:14 And I'm going to learn how to handle a handgun if I need to to protect myself. 24:20 I think that's just a lot less common, especially among the educated class, 24:28 to be able to embrace going into areas that are more marginal. 24:34 But I fundamentally believe that if you could change this scenario... 24:39 And have a lot of neighborhoods and places that people consider really out of the market today. 24:46 If those were as safe as your average suburb, not even your best suburb, but your average suburb, that the housing market dynamics would change incredibly. 24:55 One of the ways you can look at this is in most cities, you will have a ring of housing that was built in the immediate post-World War II years that is all around the city. 25:10 Joel Garreau wrote the famous book Edge City back in the 1980s, and he coined a term called the favored quarter. 25:17 Which was if your metro area is a circle and you took a slice of the pie that was a quarter of it, that every region has that one quarter where a majority of the wealth and good job has gravitated towards. 25:33 So in my region, that's the southwestern quadrant. 25:38 That's not to say there aren't nice places in all quadrants, but there are usually one that is much more dominant than the others. 25:47 Um, so, but what's fascinating, so what's fascinating is like you can look at the same 1955, uh, um, little Cape Cod or ranch house that has, that was 900 or a thousand square feet, three bedroom, one bath, two bedroom, one bath. 26:05 Built in the favored quarter versus the unfavored quarter. 26:09 And the one in the favored quarter still is in a very desirable place. 26:17 It's kept up really well. 26:19 The houses are attractive and they sell and resell. 26:23 And then you go outside the favored quarter and find that same exact house in other places. 26:28 And it's sometimes dystopian. 26:34 The houses are not selling as well. 26:36 Quite a few are abandoned. 26:38 You might find drug houses in those areas. 26:42 And the values are very, very low. 26:45 And a lot of that, again, comes back to How, at the local government level, we have just not taken care of the basics in many places. 26:56 So, to me, law and order or crime is number one in that regard. 27:02 We just haven't done very well with that as well as we should. 27:12 So, anyway... 27:16 I'm not here to be an apologist for every – 27:23 I don't mean this to be like a discussion of an apologist for every action that police departments take or everything that happens in the judicial system. 27:33 Of course, humans – humans are humans and there are good humans and bad ones in every line of work. 27:40 And horrible things happen, but we have had a lot of tremendous failures and a lack of desire to really especially enforce good behavior in public space. 27:54 Yeah. 27:56 And let's be frank about why some of that is. 27:59 When I talk about this, so the urbanist world and probably a lot of this podcast audience is heavily skewed towards professional class people who have left of center politics. 28:13 And so all of a sudden, what somebody is going to say is this whole conversation sounds like, those sound like Republican talking points. 28:21 And if they're Republican talking points, I have to be against them. 28:25 Because I'm a Democrat. 28:26 That's the viewpoint. 28:29 You know, the same way that if you go to more conservative areas, you might find folks who have a really hard time embracing a lot of basic stuff we talk about, like some simple zoning reforms, street design differences, embracing, you know, 28:46 like the ability for people to walk and bike because, you know, that's what the lefties do in the big cities. 28:52 And if they're for that, then I have to be against it. 28:55 And this whole frame of mind that we have that is so polarized politically, like if one side believes the other, I have to be against it, is just so stupid and so destructive. 29:11 And... 29:13 I hope there comes a day when we get over it and we can just talk issues, pros, cons, and not have this kind of reflection. 29:28 You know, red versus blue dynamic that 29:34 is frankly horrible for our cities and for our communities. 29:40 So that's why this issue I think is often very challenging to talk about and why a lot of people in the community. 29:47 Urbanism world don't really like to talk about it. 29:52 So anyway, I don't mind talking about it. 29:54 I've had more direct experience with it in the last seven years running a place management organization than I ever thought I would have. 30:04 And my own opinions on this have really hardened as I've seen my own city get really frustratingly bad in a lot of ways on the order and disorder issue. 30:17 And a lot of that goes back to What I said at the beginning about like, what's the value of living in a city? 30:26 You know, I want my wife and my kids to be able to walk outside of our house and walk anywhere in the neighborhoods nearest and not have to, you know, worry about some of the crap that we just have to worry about all the time now. 30:44 And There are just places now that I will say, no, don't go there. 30:51 Or don't go there after a certain hour. 30:54 Or if you're going to go to this place, just be really careful. 30:58 And I hate that that's the case. 31:01 That doesn't need to be the case. 31:03 A lot of that is happening because out of sheer just kind of mismanagement, misallocation of resources and really bad priorities on the sake of a lot of people who should know better, who are adults that should know better about all this. 31:21 You know, if it comes to an architect like me to say some of these things and to work on them, you know, so be it. 31:29 But it's grating to me that we have to put some limitations. 31:37 I put so many limitations on things that I would like for us to be able to do. 31:42 By the way, this same conversation is true of another aspect of safety that urbanists love to talk about, which is street design. 31:51 And that's a world that I've worked in forever. 31:53 I want my kids to be able to ride their bikes all over the city, but there are some hard boundaries that I have to give them now because of really bad street design. 32:06 Um, and you know, I will say here, here's your boundaries. 32:09 You do not cross, you know, X or Y street period. 32:14 Um, because I know those streets. 32:16 I know people drive too fast. 32:18 I know people aren't paying attention and, um, they might not see my eight or 10 year old kids riding on a bike or see them way too late. 32:26 So I've got to have some, some hard limitations, uh, in, in that world. 32:31 And I think urbanists especially get this. 32:33 They really understand, um, The value of street design and the importance of safety and how that is a limit on people's freedom, freedom of movement, your sense of independence, and how overall it's just kind of a real drag if you have to say, well, 32:49 you can't go there because it's just, you know, I don't trust that it's safe enough or the people driving are going to see you. 32:56 We need that same kind of intention and attention to the issue of crime and disorder, especially in public, because it's that important. 33:08 And if we don't prioritize it, then our cities will fail. 33:11 It's really going to be that simple. 33:13 They may not fail as bad as they did in the 1970s, or you know what? 33:18 They might. 33:19 It could happen. 33:21 Most people today have no idea how nice a lot of our cities and towns were in, say, the 1950s and the early 1960s. 33:30 How absolutely lively they were, vastly livelier than the sort of quote-unquote revived cities that we have today. 33:43 But they fell apart and they failed. 33:45 In a lot of ways, they failed because of terrible issues that happened in public space and disorder in our cities. 33:53 And people fled and they gave up on them. 33:56 And yeah, that happened also in the era of the suburbs being brand new and everybody wanted a car. 34:03 That was the new big thing. 34:06 And so people were excited to do that. 34:09 But it's naive to think that that can't happen again because it absolutely can't happen again. 34:13 And in some cities, it's already been happening the last five years in particular. 34:18 So... 34:20 My plea to everybody, wake up, pay attention to this issue, care as much about this issue as you do about the minutia of street design as well. 34:32 That's where I'm going to wrap today. 34:34 I really appreciate everybody for listening. 34:36 I had a break here for a couple of weeks and I've got a bunch of podcasts lined up now for the fall and into the winter and looking forward to sharing some new conversations with everybody. 34:48 Thanks so much. 34:49 Take 34:50 [music] 35:18 Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, Farewell. 35:25 [music]
Community discussion