0:00 Welcome to the Messy City Podcast where we talk with the people who design, 0:05 plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:49 Welcome back to the Messy City Podcast. 0:51 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:53 I'm joined today by my newly retired friend and partner in crime here in Kansas City, 1:00 Dennis Strait. 1:02 Dennis was on one of my earliest episodes, 1:05 was joking beforehand before I really figured out how to get the audio working well. 1:10 So the audio is not as good on that one, even though the conversation was terrific. 1:15 Uh, 1:16 and now I'm even happier cause I get to have him here in the studio and we, 1:20 uh, we can talk about things that are going on, uh, in Kansas city, but also, uh, we have, uh, I think a few, 1:26 few pieces related to the strong towns conversation and housing in particular we 1:30 want to hit on. 1:31 So, uh, Dennis, uh, welcome to the show. 1:35 Kevin, thank you for having me. 1:37 And it's good to see you again. 1:38 Yeah, I know. 1:39 It's always good. 1:39 It's always good. 1:40 We always say that we don't do this nearly enough. 1:42 So there's probably an awful lot we can cover. 1:46 Dennis was a man who professionally has worn many hats, architect, landscape architect, planner, 1:54 and one of the principals with multi-studio before he retired here in Kansas City. 2:00 but also was really a primary force behind creating this speaker series in Kansas 2:08 City called Making a City We Can All Afford. 2:10 Did I get that right? 2:12 It's Making a Great City. 2:14 And one of the bylines was City We Can Afford. 2:18 All right, well, there you go. 2:18 See, I already got something wrong right off the top. 2:22 And that speaker series and the resulting presentations that Dennis created really have had an impact on the conversation here locally about housing and about 2:35 development in particular. 2:38 And it's something that we've kind of kicked around a lot and talked about. 2:42 And it's, you know, in some quarters well-received, you've had other quarters where that was not well-received at all. 2:48 That's true. 2:49 And I'm impressed that your meter can measure impact at that scale. 2:55 It's been surprising to me how well-received most of the presentations are and how 3:02 hard it is to move that needle. 3:04 Maybe it'd be interesting for a second to talk about where it was not well-received 3:08 and what was some of the pushback that you heard. 3:10 Yeah. 3:13 Well, 3:15 the primary place it wasn't well-received was north of the river because I think there was a preconception that I was coming up with a city versus suburb discussion. 3:28 Mm-hmm. 3:29 which is the wrong way to frame it. 3:30 And the folks that were there to respond to the presentation I gave already had 3:39 their response prepared before I gave a presentation, so they didn't really get the benefit of the point I was trying to make, which is that cities 3:52 They need to be attentive to both sides of the ledger, how much it costs to run the city, to create the infrastructure, to maintain the infrastructure. 4:08 And then the good you're getting out of that investment from private investment. 4:12 And you want to get that balance. 4:13 So you're getting good tax revenue so that you're able to do the things that you 4:17 want to do as a city. 4:19 And the series is largely about helping our community understand why that's a 4:24 struggle for us, largely because of the way that we've expanded over the last 75 years. 4:32 So, you know, since that way is primarily suburban, there's an inference that the message is against suburbia. 4:45 The point would be that all cities have always had edges. 4:49 All cities have really had really highly populated, vital, valuable centers, and then they fall off as they go to the edge. 5:00 And you'd want to seek a balance there, and most cities traditionally have. 5:06 But since we adopted a car-based development style over the last 75 years, Kansas City and others have dissipated their vitality in such a way that they're 5:19 really not able to generate the resources they need. 5:23 So it's not city good, suburb bad. 5:27 It's imbalance bad. 5:29 And we need to find a way of thickening up, using a strong town term, thickening up both our central cities and our edge conditions. 5:40 And in many ways, 5:44 Kansas City was kind of a poster child for that issue because we took that idea and 5:50 probably took it to an extreme that others – I mean, a lot of people followed the same pattern, but we certainly took it to an extreme. 5:58 Yeah, 5:58 we're in like an elite five or something of cities around the country that expanded incredibly during the mid 1900s with annexation and have been spreading ourselves 6:12 out into that. 6:13 That's the other problem that we face is that. 6:16 If you look at the population curve for Kansas City from day one to now, you see we were doing really well from the 1850s up until 1940. 6:27 And the way I look at it is in 1940, 6:30 we peaked in vitality because we peaked in the number of people who were sharing 6:35 the city and helping to take care of it. 6:39 But after 1940, that started spreading out. 6:42 It coincided with... 6:46 not only the annexation, it coincided with redlining with, of course, that's related to the 30-year mortgage, which coincided with the real distortion in market economics. 7:00 So it made home ownership much more affordable to many people than it had before and, 7:07 frankly, was the beginning of the housing crisis that we have today. 7:13 And the other thing it coincided with was really the first generation of the need 7:17 for infrastructure repair. 7:18 So if you look at the central city, you know, 7:20 it was starting to come into that phase or that era when we needed to start reinvesting. 7:26 And when you had the Highway Act and all these other forces driving you or giving 7:30 you motivation to go outward, a lot of people made that choice. 7:35 The ones that could, the ones that weren't restrictive from it. 7:38 And we've been making that choice ever since. 7:42 Referring back to that curve, 7:46 most people aren't geeks like me and pay a lot of attention to this, 7:50 but what most people don't recognize is that the population loss in the central city, 7:56 which I like to think of the city being the 1940 version of Kansas City, and then we expanded. 8:05 And the population loss in that 1940 boundary of Kansas City started in the 1950s 8:13 and has never stopped. 8:15 Most people think, oh, we're growing again, and oh, the downtown's doing great, and we've got more people moving downtown, so everything's good again. 8:23 And it's just so not true. 8:25 We're still suffering from population loss throughout the central city. 8:28 And that was the original motivation of our civic leaders back in the 90s was to 8:35 turn that cycle around because, you know, downtown was a ghost town and it wasn't just people in Kansas City, Missouri. 8:43 The entire metro was starting to be concerned about, you know, 8:46 loss of your center because that was proving to be devastating to other metros. 8:51 So we started investing in downtown and, you know, through a lot of effort, we started to see some success there. 8:58 But we're still losing population at a much greater rate in the central city than 9:05 we're achieving with new population, new people moving in with the investments downtown. 9:13 I'll share some stats with you since they're Yeah. 9:15 Fresh on my mind. 9:16 Please do. 9:17 Over the last 30 years, we've grown by 75,000 people in Kansas City, Missouri, which is great. 9:23 I mean, 9:23 to look at what was happening when I first moved to town in the late 80s and we were on a downward trajectory to the bottom out and then the start coming back, 9:32 it looks great. 9:33 So I'm sure everybody feels good about that and we should. 9:37 But when you look closer at it, what you find is that during that same 30 years, we had the downtown success story. 9:44 Thank goodness. 9:46 And we gained about 10,000 people over that 30 years in the downtown area. 9:51 Meanwhile, we lost about 35,000 people everywhere else in the central city. 9:59 So the net is between now and 1990, we've lost another 25,000 people or so. 10:05 So if you've grown by 75,000, you have to count for that 25 you lost. 10:09 So that means we have about 100,000 new residences or new people that we've 10:15 accommodated in the extended Kansas City. 10:20 In that part of Kansas City that the Strong Towns Group has showed us doesn't really generate enough revenue based on the private development side of the equation to satisfy the need in terms of public sector return on investments. 10:35 So it's it's not the kind of growth that makes you healthier. 10:39 And it's it's the thing we need to find a way to get back into balance in. 10:44 And at this point, Kevin, I've been rambling so much, I'm not sure if I answered your original question. 10:48 I'm not sure I remember the original question, so it's okay. 10:51 This is like a regular conversation. 10:54 Well, yeah, exactly. 10:55 That's the point. 10:57 So as you're talking about it, it kind of makes me also think about the conversation we've had many, many times just focusing on the Midtown area because that's what I do. 11:10 It's where my work is. 11:12 And I just like to repeat the numbers because people often don't believe me. 11:18 And a lot of people in Kansas City, Missouri in particular, would say, well, Midtown, that's the nice part of town. 11:27 It is a nice part of town. 11:28 I like it. 11:30 It is definitely more successful than other parts of town. 11:33 But in the 1950 census year, it had 73,000 people. 11:39 In the 2020 census year, it had 28,000 people. 11:43 And those were all the neighborhoods, Stateline to Troost, Crown Center to Brush Creek to the plaza. 11:49 So that's a two thirds population decline in that time period. 11:55 And a lot of people will say, well, 11:57 but we've had all these like new buildings and people are moving in and we have had new buildings and we haven't had new apartment buildings and we've had people, 12:05 some people coming back to the city, which is really cool. 12:07 We'd like to see more of that. 12:09 But even over the last decade, the population's flat in that part of town. 12:14 And so there are some people who butt heads with me will say, kind of, so what? 12:21 They like it the way it is. 12:23 And I say, well, that's all well and good, but... 12:25 there's all these things that you also say you want to have as part of living in a city. 12:31 You know, you want to have lots of successful local businesses. 12:34 You want to have a fast and frequent public transportation. 12:38 You want to have vibrant schools. 12:39 Uh, we have to have people, uh, 12:42 to have those things and the city that this part of the city was built for more 12:46 people to begin with. 12:47 It was built for vastly more people than what are there today. 12:50 Uh, And so it's a huge challenge. 12:53 The interesting thing about that, Dennis, is I did have Joe Minacosi run the numbers one time. 13:00 Joe is from Urban Three, 13:02 and he's famous for running these kind of value per acre analyses of neighborhoods 13:09 and cities and towns. 13:10 And even with that population decline, 13:13 the Midtown area produces six times the revenue on average of the average Kansas City, 13:20 Missouri neighborhood. 13:22 even with that population loss. 13:25 So it shows you just how much value that area created to begin with. 13:31 And for anybody who's not familiar with this part of town, it's really just very typical, I would say, early 20th century neighborhoods. 13:42 Late 19th to early 20th century neighborhoods. 13:46 In my neighborhood, the one that I live in in this part of town, I think three quarters of the lots are still single family houses. 13:54 But there's lots of apartments, especially smaller apartment buildings mixed in and commercial spaces and everything else. 14:00 So it's not like this is, you know, this is not the Upper East Side of New York. 14:06 It's not Midtown Manhattan. 14:09 It's not that kind of area, but it still has incredible value. 14:14 And it still produces a lot of value relative to the city. 14:17 And I know you've done similar calculations relative to Westport. 14:21 Well, Urban Three just completed an economic development impact study for us in Westport. 14:29 I'm part of the Westport Regional Business League board. 14:33 And it showed the impact that Westport has. 14:38 You know, Westport's a tiny little half mile square original town of Westport. 14:47 So, you know, it's a postage stamp compared to the extent of Kansas City, Missouri. 14:53 But when you compare those two, 14:56 the value within that little half square mile is 16 times more than the average 15:02 square mile outside of it. 15:03 Mm-hmm. 15:06 Now, 15:07 it's more valuable than downtown in that regard because we only have that one 15:10 little half square mile that we're dealing with. 15:12 But the point being, and the reason we wanted to have the study done was, for one, we wanted the local investors, business owners, 15:20 property owners to understand the value that they've created and the reason why 15:26 it's valuable to be part of Westport. 15:29 But we also wanted our business 15:32 city leaders and decision makers to have tools available to understand where good 15:36 is coming from. 15:41 I listened to one of your recent podcasts and there were comments about, you know, we shouldn't run a city like a business. 15:48 I don't know if I agree completely, 15:49 but I'll at least put out there that we should at least run it more like a place 15:53 management organization. 15:55 Yeah. 15:56 where you really care about taking care of the wealth that you've inherited and the safety of the people you're responsible for and the value that they provide every day. 16:11 And I think we've lost sight of that role of city governance. 16:18 And in Westport's case, we're just trying to bring attention back to that so that we do... 16:24 uh take care of those places that are providing good back to the city and it's not 16:28 just westport it's it's uh from what minikazi study has showed us it's um 16:34 everything from the river down to almost waldo um state line to um to truce now is essentially the economic engine that runs the much greater kansas city area against 16:48 the missouri area And we don't think of it that way. 16:51 We think of it as, well, they've got their own CIDs, so they should take care of themselves, which if you understand CIDs was never the intent of a CID. 17:01 But it's kind of where we've defaulted to as a city because we don't have the 17:07 revenues we need to pay. 17:09 take care of any part of the city adequately. 17:11 And that's part of the campaign that we're on is trying to help our community understand that so we can head towards more fiscally sustainable and healthy state 17:22 in the future. 17:23 Right. 17:24 So recently you had another opportunity to kind of explore this topic as part of a 17:30 technical assistance panel through the local ULI district council, the Urban Land Institute. 17:37 ULI, most district councils organize these once or twice a year in a community where you have 17:46 a group of, uh, real estate, uh, and other, 17:49 and planning and other experts who come to the table for a couple of days to, 17:52 to tackle, um, usually a difficult problem, uh, and just bring some different thinking to it. 18:00 And, uh, so I think the one you were tasked with was the, uh, shopping area at Linwood and prospect. 18:07 Is that right? 18:08 Is it, or is it sort of a bigger area around that? 18:11 Well, it was, uh, It focused on the Sunfresh grocery store. 18:18 But then also, we looked at it in three scales. 18:20 We were asked to look at it in three scales. 18:23 The grocery store itself, at the shopping center that it sits within, and then the region around it, the area around it. 18:31 And the reason that Councilwoman Melissa Patterson-Hasley had asked for this study 18:41 to be done was because the sales at the grocery store were diminishing. 18:48 You probably know the dates better than me, 18:49 but the idea of a grocery store in Linwood that was city subsidized came up 15, 18:54 20 years ago and then it started falling off. 18:57 Then there was a reinvestment done about five or so years ago. 19:00 And, um, and then, uh, recently since COVID, um, they've noticed that, uh, you know, um, uh, the shelves aren't stocked as well as used to be. 19:13 Things seem to be, uh, losing, um, vitality. 19:16 Uh, so they asked us to take a look and, um, What we found is that, yes, those things are happening. 19:25 This is right at Prospect, which is square within the red line center of Kansas City, Missouri, the disinvested part of Kansas City, Missouri, due to red lining. 19:41 One of the best things that we've done as a city is to invest in the grocery store 19:45 to try and stabilize the continued losses that we've had there. 19:51 But, you know, what we've already talked about is those losses have been continuing. 19:56 So even since the grocery store opened, they've continued to lose population. 20:00 That's one issue. 20:02 The other thing that I know you're working on that we are concerned about is they're 20:10 I'm being nostalgic now, 20:11 but there used to be something called neighborhood policing that would take care of issues, 20:15 you know, minor issues on the street and keep, you know, public space comfortable for people. 20:23 Well, we've also adopted a free fare program for the bus system, which I hope we're getting rid of, but it's been problematic in a lot of ways. 20:34 It's going away this fall. 20:36 Yeah. 20:36 Yeah. 20:38 But, you know, what that created was an easy way, 20:40 what we learned during the TAP was that it's an easy way to rob a store in the Northland and jump on a bus and be safe down in some part south in Kansas City and 20:51 use that as your escape bus. 20:53 Mm-hmm. 20:54 and silly stories like that, that, you know, it's because of our challenges with the homelessness, we've had a number of people that resort to the buses as a safe place. 21:06 But, 21:08 you know, 21:09 the one thing about having a grocery store in a disinvested area is it's an amenity. 21:16 And so, 21:18 And we knew this from the work that Multistudio did a few years ago for the 21:23 Prospect Us study, which was a transit-oriented development study, 21:28 how to spur reinvestments along Prospect from downtown South to 75th Street or so on. 21:38 that intersection is probably as viable as any in terms of the amount of activity there. 21:43 And it's not saying that it's attracting any kind of investment yet, but of all the situations, it's one of the stronger ones. 21:51 And so having that activity there means it's attractive. 21:54 It's an attractive nuisance to people that like to create nuisances. 21:57 So that with our challenged ability to police the way that we used to. 22:05 We've got prostitution happening there, drug sales to drug use, panhandling, 22:16 harassment, if not outright threats to people who are wanting to shop. 22:22 So the other lesson that we learned was that the The remaining shoppers are the ones who don't have a choice, and that essentially equals the ones who can afford a car, are choosing to continue to try and shop there. 22:42 But most people are saying, 22:44 I'll drive two miles away and go somewhere else rather than deal with this hassle. 22:49 And it's more than the local CIDs. 22:51 They do have a CID, but it's more than they can deal with. 22:54 CIDs aren't meant to have that level of security and maintenance. 23:03 So it's challenged in a lot of ways. 23:05 And it just shows us it's a great example about why we need to reinvest and take 23:11 the disinvestment that we started 75 years ago through some 23:18 bad, I guess is a simple way to say it, 23:20 policies that we created that we now understand and that continue to threaten our future as a city because of the continued population loss in our central city. 23:34 We need to start taking that seriously. 23:36 So if, if there were a way for us to, for just for the sake of conversation, we, we can wave a magic wand and, 23:46 and the public safety issues are dramatically better if not just completely dealt 23:51 with in a situation like that. 23:54 Um, If we set that aside, what else did you all see, 24:01 did you talk about as ways to turn the tide in a part of town that is depopulating, 24:09 that has, 24:10 that certainly was disinvested historically and has been on the decline for many, 24:15 many years? 24:17 What all did you see as opportunities to just take that and turn it around? 24:26 um well um so there's the um um kind of the tactical urbanism approach or septet approach where you kind of clean up fix up and improve the physical environment so 24:42 you address the broken window syndrome so that It doesn't feel like a place where you can do wrong. 24:50 It feels like a place people care for. 24:51 That was one of the things that the group recommended, 24:55 and they gave a series of improvements that could be made to the area around the 24:59 store to address those kinds of issues, which 25:03 is a relatively minor investment and a way to at least change the implicit expectations for how you behave when you're there and what you can expect as a patron. 25:18 Beyond that, since you've already somehow cured the public safety side of it, 25:24 it's not an easy lift because we really need to repopulate those depopulating neighborhoods. 25:33 um, uh, 25:37 Back in the day, you were talking about Midtown. 25:39 We had the same proportions back in the day, back in those neighborhoods around the 31st and Linwood area. 25:48 And they're a fragment of what they were. 25:51 Now, 25:52 that's not to say they don't have neighbors and people doing good in those neighborhoods, 25:56 but they're trying to do a lot with very little. 26:01 And they just need more people sharing the neighborhood again like they used to have. 26:05 Um, 26:06 but the market's not going to take us there because of all the things we know about 26:09 what's caused the housing market to go, um, uh, askew. 26:13 Um, 26:16 so it's going to take an intervention, um, and it's going to take a reinvestment at a public scale in some way, um, to, uh, start creating, start convincing people that that's, uh, a right place for private money to go. 26:30 Um, um, 26:34 And that's a big lift that we need to be working on. 26:37 So just a little bit north and west of there is the Beacon Hill neighborhood, 26:46 Beacon Hill and Mount Prospect neighborhoods. 26:50 And... 26:53 I want to talk about like, do you see what's been done there as success or not? 26:58 Or how do you rate and discuss the changes that happened there? 27:02 So for those not familiar, these were also historically disinvested neighborhoods. 27:08 A little bit further west, so a little bit closer to some of the nicer areas, some of the job centers. 27:14 This one happens to be very close to a major medical area. 27:18 complex and district. 27:21 So it has the advantage of that. 27:23 But essentially you had a neighborhood that was Beacon Hill itself, that was mostly vacant and demoed. 27:30 And there was a long, 27:33 sometimes painful process on the part of the city and its economic development 27:36 agencies to purchase a lot of that land, sort of come up with a master development plan for the neighborhood, and then gradually redevelop it over time. 27:47 uh with mostly with brand new housing uh and i would say primarily with newer single family uh detached housing um so i i think a lot of people look at beacon hill and they say wow that that's become a really nice neighborhood it's very 28:03 attractive there's all this new housing there it's close to hospital hill um it's 28:08 got a lot going for it houses are selling for a lot of money um 28:13 I mean, 28:14 how do you think about that as a model for some of these other areas that are struggling? 28:19 Because that's a very dramatic change in a lot of ways from what was there previous to it. 28:29 Yeah, it is. 28:31 It's one of those overnight success stories that took 40 years to bring back. 28:38 And we might say in a very top-down fashion. 28:43 Well, there were civic leaders like Hugh Zimmer and Leonard Graham, Dan Musser, 28:50 who they lived that world for most of those 40 years trying to get that to happen. 28:55 And then eventually, you know, people realized I can have a brand new house overlooking downtown, just minutes from every amenity the city's got to offer. 29:07 So once people figured that out, then that area started to come back. 29:16 Let's hope on the recovery side of the redlining issue. 29:21 So we're starting to recognize those were bad policies. 29:23 Those were wrongheaded reasons for not developing east of Troost. 29:30 Troost is our red line here in Kansas City, and it's stark here. 29:34 It's black and white left and right of the red line of Troost in terms of disinvestment. 29:41 And Truce is just a mile east of Main Street. 29:45 So it's a mile from some of the most productive land, valuable land in the city. 29:50 And with all that lift over the last 40 years, this area that you're talking about has... 29:56 started coming back. 29:57 And for those of us who've been around that long and to see the reinvestment now along Troost all the way up to 35th street with the recent investments there is, 30:05 is amazing. 30:06 It's, you know, it's the kind of stuff you want to see the rest of, um, of the city become, um, 30:14 But we've got another challenge. 30:15 For one thing, Prospect's another mile even further east of that. 30:21 So, you know, 30:23 that adjacent momentum of being next to the hottest part of town along Main Street, 30:26 they don't have that advantage, and Troost is coming back, 30:29 but it's not that strong yet to go ahead and energize another mile to the east. 30:34 And then you've got the bigger challenge now that – 30:38 Whereas the red line used to be just an imaginary line that we created arbitrarily 30:42 on a map, we've now created a barrier that's called 71 Highway that is a very clear 30:50 delineation between one side and the other and a hazard to get from one side to the 30:55 other and limited access from one side to the other and all these things. 30:58 It tore neighborhoods apart when it was cleared for construction 50 years ago, 31:04 and it's never recovered. 31:07 And the area we're talking about at 31st and Prospect is on that other side of the 31:13 71 Highway intervention. 31:15 And that's an added challenge to convince private reinvestment to happen on that 31:22 other side of Prospect. 31:24 And now it should, and we should be encouraging it, 31:27 and we should be trying to figure out how to take advantage of what you've already pointed out is the land with the most potential in the footprint of Kansas City, 31:37 because it was built for sharing. 31:39 It was built for efficiency. 31:41 It was built for affordability with a scale that allows people to be close in and 31:48 have great access to amenity, to schools, to jobs, all those good things. 31:52 Um, 31:53 and public transit back from the day when we had a public transit network, all those things were working and it's hard to get all those things to work in a 32:01 footprint that was created by our car based development strategy. 32:04 Uh, I don't think the professions figured out how to solve that side of the affordability equation yet, but we know how to, it works on the other side where you, it was built naturally for that up until 1950. 32:15 Um, And that's where we ought to be focusing our efforts. 32:18 That's where we ought to be trying to get reinvestment to happen because we can do 32:23 it in a much more efficient, much more affordable, 32:25 and achieve a much higher level of return on investment with revitalization of 32:34 those parts of the city. 32:35 But it's going to take an effort because of all the damage we've done over the last 75 years. 32:39 Yeah. 32:42 And there's good to work with. 32:44 We need to take leadership and figure out a way to get that to happen and not just continue in a passive approach to development like we've had for too long. 32:55 So how do you get started? 32:59 You've thought a lot about and talked a lot about housing. 33:03 And what you've talked to me about is your housing-based economic development strategy. 33:09 Does that play a role here or how does that play a role? 33:14 Okay. 33:14 We're moving into the half-baked portion of the discussion. 33:18 We're all half-baked. 33:20 It's okay. 33:22 So we've been – we're in the seventh year this year of our series with the library. 33:31 And it was very much inspired by the Strong Towns movement, 33:34 by this recognition that Chuck Marone and others have brought to the table about – 33:39 how we've gotten out of balance in cities all around the country. 33:41 It was also very much inspired by Joe Manikazi's work with Urban Three and how we can now see very clearly how healthy our cities are or are not financially through 33:53 the mapping techniques they've introduced. 33:56 Those two were the inaugural speakers for the Making a Great City series. 34:00 And since then, 34:00 we've had a number of people come to the community to help us understand why we're 34:05 facing challenges, the things that cause that. 34:08 As well as solutions to that, you know, 34:10 other communities and what they're doing to turn that ship around and start heading 34:15 back towards a healthier, fiscally sustainable state. 34:18 Yeah. 34:20 So this year, 34:22 we're trying to take a theme or build a theme around housing because it is the 34:29 issue of the day for the country, frankly. 34:33 Just accessible housing, 34:35 not having enough housing is an existential problem for not just Kansas City, 34:40 but the country. 34:42 And we've got all sorts, we, like most cities, have all sorts of economic development strategies. 34:49 And I've been reviewing those recently. 34:52 And that's why I'm in the half-baked mode, because I'm sure there's a lot more out there. 34:56 But I can't say I can point to any of them that have a real clear urban development strategy. 35:05 And it's very clear in the work that the Civic Council has done through Casey Rising, 35:13 that housing is that existential threat, that thing that we have to solve if we're going to create opportunities, which is how you build cities, 35:21 is you create places that attract people to come and make a life for themselves. 35:25 But you got to have a place for them to live. 35:26 So that's a fundamental piece of the equation. 35:29 Mid-America Regional Council and what they call their Comprehensive Economic 35:32 Development Strategy recognizes the same thing, but they don't focus on it. 35:37 So I'm trying to figure out a way for us to focus on housing. 35:41 uh, as, uh, the primary thing we as not just a city, but as a Metro ought to be focused on because it's, um, um, it's, it's the opportunity that Kansas city has, unlike many other cities. 35:56 Um, 10 years ago, I went on one of these chamber exchange trips where we, 36:01 it's a great program that the chamber runs locally here where we go and we as a group of civic leaders go and visit other cities and we see what they're doing and 36:09 learn about their challenges and their successes. 36:12 10 years ago, we went to Portland, Oregon, which is, you know, the 0.2 city for walkability and quality of life. 36:22 And it was, we had a great trip. 36:24 They were doing amazing things. 36:26 Universities nearby, there's their public transit starting to develop all those things. 36:30 And it's an incredibly walkable, uh, central city, uh, very vital. 36:35 Uh, and the big issue we came away from, um, you know, what you learned on those trips is coming back in the plane, the buzz in the plane is really the primary things that we learned. 36:47 And, um, 36:49 everybody was worried about the housing affordability problem that Portland was having and how are we going to get on top of our housing affordability problem? 36:57 10 years ago. 36:58 10 years ago. 36:59 And I'm recognizing at that point that my goodness, that's why I moved to Kansas city. 37:04 I could have, my wife and I could afford to buy a house and to start a life here. 37:09 And compared to most cities in almost any city with the amenity we have, we're a very affordable city. 37:18 We've got a great value proposition in that regard. 37:21 And in spite of the ridiculous inflation that's happened over the last five years, 37:25 we're still relatively that affordable city. 37:28 And we have an opportunity that most cities don't have to capture that 37:33 affordability and make it part of our value proposition to people that want to, 37:41 again, get a foothold and create a life for themselves, for companies that want to take advantage of an affordable, great place to live because we have that. 37:52 And housing's the missing piece of that. 37:56 And in the disinvested part of our town, and probably most towns, the real trick to overcome there is access to capital. 38:06 So that's the piece that's a hard lift. 38:08 And Chuck Marone's recent book, Escaping the Housing Trap, 38:13 he identifies municipal funding and philanthropic funding as the places he would 38:21 start looking. 38:22 And that's probably where we need to start the conversations here. 38:29 And many of us, you included, have been trying to start those conversations, 38:34 and it's just confusing to people about why they should invest in an area that has 38:38 nowhere near the returns that you can find elsewhere. 38:42 And that's another part of the challenge that we've got to overcome, not just for the housing situation, but for the existential issue that we're facing these days. 38:54 How do we get long term thinking back into our planning? 38:58 Because we've lost it in the way that we've become too political in the way that we 39:04 think about our decision making at the municipal level, at the state level, national level. 39:09 And we've lost it in the boardrooms with the way we've come to bottom line oriented with the shareholder return as being the preoccupation as opposed to creating 39:18 something of long-term value. 39:21 And that's a bigger nut that we've got to turn around, but Kansas City can do it. 39:26 If any city can do it, why can't we do it? 39:28 We're supposed to be a big, 39:28 small town and everybody gets along and we're the happiest place on earth. 39:31 So why don't we all get together and figure out how to solve that problem and 39:34 create a great city for the next 50 years? 39:37 That's the term we need to be thinking of. 39:39 And not just the five-year return on investment, but the 20-year return on investment. 39:45 The fact that the school district has now been able to sell a major bond issue for 39:53 the first time in 60 years, something like that, is a great step forward. 39:59 I don't know if people are really recognizing that or not, but it's, to me, the first real reinvestment that we're making in the central city. 40:05 Yeah. 40:08 Because the advantage that cities around Kansas City have had for years is a 40:15 thriving school system. 40:16 Because they've all been benefiting from the sugar high of new development, 40:21 of second phase, third phase, next urban development. 40:27 And Kansas City's been on the losing end of that discussion. 40:29 And our school districts has been dealing with the diminishing population all these 40:33 last 50 years. 40:35 So now that we are stabilizing and and I think it's good that we're stabilizing, we're we're now back up to if you include which the school district did the the charter school populations in with the public school populations and think of all 40:53 that as public school, which is how it's operating. 40:56 We're getting back to a number of around 30,000 kids in the central part of Kansas 41:00 City going to school. 41:03 That's great. 41:04 Let's keep that going. 41:05 Let's get back to 45. 41:07 Let's go beyond that. 41:10 We've lost a quarter million people in the central city in the last 75 years. 41:17 we need to start gaining back to get vitality, to get the balance to work again in terms of Kansas City, Missouri. 41:26 And that reinvestment in housing is, I don't see any other way to do that. 41:32 So we've got, 41:34 for all the folks that know Kansas City, we've got the extension of the streetcar getting ready to open. 41:41 that creates motivation for reinvesting throughout this midtown area all the way 41:46 down to UMKC and then on up north to the river. 41:49 We ought to double down on that. 41:51 That is the next phase of the downtown reinvestment strategy. 41:56 So we need to keep that momentum going. 41:58 We're not even close to being done. 42:00 But even with that, we're not going to be close to being done. 42:02 We need to tap the momentum that's coming south and push it, 42:07 willfully push it east along the corridors that we have that'll support bus transit. 42:14 And we know what they are. 42:14 They're the half-mile corridors at 35th, 31st, all those streets that we need to push over towards Prospect. 42:24 Um, and then we need to revitalize prospect and complete the ideal long tourist. 42:28 Uh, and then we'll be rebuilding the, uh, the network that we had, 42:32 the city that we had that used to provide opportunity for people because it provided an affordable way for you to get a foothold in Kansas city and find a job among many options and find a good place to go to school and a good place to live 42:45 in a neighborhood you could invest in and, um, 42:48 We need to recreate that because the vitality you can create in that development 42:53 pattern cannot come. 42:55 It can't be compared to the way we've developed for the last 75 years. 43:01 So it's our best opportunity for reinvestment and getting a good return and getting 43:05 back to a healthy state. 43:07 Having said that to my friends who think I'm opposed to suburbia, we need to be doing the same thing in our suburban areas. 43:13 We need to be finding ways to create valuable development patterns there. 43:19 Other cities have done it. 43:20 We started to do it at places like Zona Rosa and even in Shoal Creek. 43:23 We started doing it in some areas there where there are ways that you can build within suburban communities centers of activity and value that can help to 43:34 again, achieve that balance that we need to get throughout the metro. 43:39 But it's time for us to quit worrying about us versus them and one side of the river versus the other and to recognize we're in this as a city and as a metro, and we need to be working together to stake our future as the Kansas City for the 43:57 entire metro. 43:58 Right. 43:59 You know, 44:00 it's funny that I think the first, 44:03 maybe the first letter to the editor that I had printed when people still cared 44:08 about letters to the editor for the newspaper, right after college, I wrote a letter. 44:16 I think I had read an article about a recent TIF plan or an economic development 44:21 plan that the city had done. 44:23 This would have been in. 44:24 Oh, probably 1994 or five. 44:29 And I wrote a letter to the editor that, to my shock, 44:32 actually got published that basically was trying to make the case that if we're 44:36 going to subsidize anything, we should be subsidizing housing. 44:41 uh, because everything follows housing or, you know, in real estate, the retail people always say retail follows rooftops. 44:49 Um, and, uh, I want to pat myself on the back for that a little bit, but, uh, because I do think there's a lot of truth to that. 44:57 I think, uh, I think housing leads everything, uh, because people, you know, are going to housing, I would say housing and education tend to lead everything. 45:07 People, uh, 45:08 often choose where they want to live based on affordability, desirability. 45:13 And then if they have kids based on schools or if they think they're going to have 45:16 kids like soon, you know, that's, that's a major factor. 45:20 And, and, and so it's interesting because you're right as a city, I mean, our differentiating factor for many, many years was that this was a pretty affordable place to live. 45:34 You could live in a major city, 45:36 but you could actually afford a house and a really good lifestyle here compared to 45:42 a lot of other metro areas. 45:45 And it does feel like we've started to lose that a little bit as a region, 45:51 as we have underbuilt on housing the last 10 or 15 years. 45:59 And it's an interesting balance. 46:01 So one of the things that Chuck talks about a lot, 46:05 when he talks about the essence of the housing trap and the different needs that 46:10 have to happen there, the people who invest in housing, who build large apartment complexes, large subdivisions, they will not build unless they can get a substantial return on it. 46:25 the places where they get the best return are the places that are the most housing 46:28 constrained because they're supply constrained on purpose. 46:34 And that allows for a major investment. 46:37 And so it's an interesting trap that we've fallen into. 46:40 And part of that dilemma, I think one of the concerns you and I share is that So much of the housing supply world now is increasingly by larger and larger 46:53 entities and fewer of them, 46:57 fewer larger entities that build a lot of the housing and they build it all over 47:01 the country. 47:02 And so there's less responsiveness at the local level to the local demand. 47:09 And it's more about what can be securitized and financialized. 47:14 So in that world, What are some of the, 47:19 if you were to tick off a few simple policy changes that you think might help get 47:24 us there, 47:24 what sort of things have you thought about that could help a city like ours begin 47:30 to make a difference? 47:34 Well, that's a long list. 47:38 The solution to the housing problem is more housing. 47:41 Getting there is a hairball that we've created over the last 75 years. 47:47 through finance, everything from financialization to zoning. 47:52 There's a lot of issues in between there, but you know, the thing to be optimistic about is that yes, 47:58 we created that hairball and think of all the good we can do over the years ahead, 48:06 decades ahead, 48:07 probably untangling that mess and essentially creating economy just by getting rid 48:12 of the red tape we've created. 48:14 Because I think most people would agree it's not doing the good we intended. 48:21 So the simple things is it ought to be really simple to rehab a house. 48:27 It ought to be really simple to build a duplex. 48:32 It ought not be a challenging development proposition because that's the smallest 48:37 scale of the development cycle and our industry. 48:40 And those folks can't afford to take a lot of risk. 48:43 And one of the biggest risks they have is getting through the entitlement process 48:48 with the local community. 48:52 And as much as we say we're trying to make that better, 48:56 there's a lot of hair around that problem that's hard to get your way through. 49:00 And it breaks most efforts. 49:02 It breaks most projects before they're able to get done. 49:04 So we need to work on that. 49:07 And again, it's not going to be an overnight thing, but we can start gradually. 49:11 What you did recently with the ADUs, That's a step. 49:15 We need like seven or eight more steps here over the next few years and then 20 or 49:19 30 more steps over the next decade. 49:22 Just to detangle, 49:23 disentangle all the red tape we've created and make it simpler to build the city again. 49:29 What our folks in our planning studio at Multi Studio always said was that we need to create... 49:35 guidelines, 49:36 regulations that encourage people and show people how to build the city we want 49:40 rather than make it a guessing game. 49:42 And we've made it far too much of a guessing game. 49:46 So the thing that's missing and that I appreciate that is pointed out in the Strong 49:57 Towns book is there's no economy, there's no market, there's no return on investment for doing starter housing. 50:08 I'm pretty confident that if you're just a little bit smart about where you place it, 50:13 that if you build smaller footprint starter housing, you would sell it. 50:20 And 50:23 The risk there is that something, again, 50:25 like municipal or philanthropic funding is going to have to underwrite that because 50:29 the market's not going to because there's no margin there. 50:32 You're just as well off to build a luxury home than you are to try and build 10 starter homes. 50:37 Yeah. 50:39 But because of that, nobody's building them. 50:40 And so there's no market because it's a self-fulfilling prophecy. 50:43 Well, look, there's no market there. 50:45 But if we built it, 50:46 I'm confident there are people who would like that alternative and would take it. 50:50 And that's one example. 50:52 My friend, Terrell Jolly, has been doing the right work for the last 10 years. 50:58 And it's still incredibly difficult for him to do things, either because of finance or because of regulations. 51:05 Um, but he's been rehabbing homes on the East side that, uh, are the closest thing we have to affordable housing as a model. 51:14 And we've not been able, he's not been able, nobody's been able to scale that. 51:19 And we need to be finding a way to scale that. 51:22 Cause it's, um, he's shown that you can create, uh, good quality housing at an affordable level. 51:30 Um, now, uh, We need to help people like Terrell do that, 51:35 and we need to find a lot more Terrells and just start working towards the 51:41 objective of building more housing. 51:43 A stat that I recognize in looking at the Casey Rising, 51:50 Casey Rising is a local initiative that is trying to help the city move forward by 51:54 comparing ourselves to cities we would aspire to be, not cities that would be easier for us to be, but cities that we'd like to be. 52:01 And if you look through the 10 different cities they've chosen, 52:08 you can figure out two things pretty quickly. 52:11 For one thing, they're on average 40% higher in population than Kansas City, Missouri. 52:18 The other thing, they're 40% smaller in footprint than Kansas City, Missouri. 52:24 So if we were just to match stats with the average of those 10 aspirin cities, 52:28 we would need to grow by two and a half times. 52:32 I just set a city of 1.25 million people to really fit out a healthy city and the 52:40 footprint we've chosen. 52:41 Right. 52:44 That's a long-term game. 52:45 I don't even know if that's necessary because I think we could find the balance 52:49 when we're less than that. 52:51 But we need to be trying to reinvest in areas, again, that have the best opportunity for return. 52:56 This housing-based strategy has a working title of 250 by 2050. 53:06 which means let's try and get 50,000 more people back to the central city over the 53:11 next 25 years. 53:13 To follow the school district's lead, 53:15 let's start reinvesting in housing again and rebuilding the neighborhoods, reinforcing the existing neighborhoods so we can support the school district and support communities and provide opportunities for people the way cities used to. 53:31 And it's, you know, like you said, it's the starting piece. 53:34 Housing's the lead. 53:35 But it's the lead to city building. 53:37 And we need to get back in the mode of city building. 53:39 I want to ask you one final question that might have a little bit of controversy to it, 53:45 just for fun. 53:46 More of a design question. 53:50 But our mutual friend, Aaron Lubeck, 53:54 has been poking at people recently on social media in the fun ways that he does. 53:58 I always appreciate the way he does it. 54:00 He shared a photo this week. 54:02 He's been poking at people about the notion of like that you have to have skyscrapers to have density and that, you know, the low rise or mid rise city is not sufficient. 54:14 So he shared a fun photo the other day of New York City of Manhattan. 54:19 from 1930 when there were very few skyscrapers or tall buildings and it actually 54:27 had more population than it does today. 54:35 So I'm, I'm not against tall buildings per se, but, I think we need to have big buildings. 54:40 I think we have good places for big buildings, especially if you have really wide streets. 54:47 Height is a good thing. 54:49 It helps create the sense of enclosure along a city street. 54:52 But it's interesting, 54:52 and I bring this up because there's this kind of thought process that happens a lot 54:57 in redevelopment. 54:59 that in order to get to those kinds of numbers that you talk about to have that 55:02 kind of redevelopment, well, what we really need are a bunch of 20, 30, 55:10 40 story buildings to house all the people that we need to house. 55:11 And I don't think you think that way, but I'm curious. 55:14 I don't know. 55:15 I'm interested in what your, what your take is on this. 55:19 Like how, how, how appropriate is the low rise city? 55:23 Because the low rise city is easier to build for, frankly. 55:26 Yeah. 55:28 we are a low rise city. 55:33 Um, the, um, 55:34 450,000 people that used to live here used to occupy all the buildings that are 55:38 still in many of our neighborhoods. 55:39 We've lost a lot of them, but, um, 55:42 There are plenty of neighborhoods around town that show you how you get 450,000 55:45 people in our original 60 square miles. 55:48 And they're at most three stories high. 55:54 So we don't even have to think about high rise buildings. 55:57 And frankly, they have their place, but they're not a lot different than the suburban model. 56:08 Part of what I think we're coming to realize is that cities are built to bring 56:15 people together to share and participate and engage and all those things. 56:19 Suburbs are built to get away. 56:22 And we've driven a lot of people away from our city. 56:27 And that doesn't bode well for social reasons, for political reasons, for financial reasons is what we're focused on today. 56:35 And it's not a lot different when you put people on an elevator and send them up to 56:39 the 13th floor or the 18th floor or whatever. 56:40 You know, 56:41 you've got an isolated community there that doesn't form the same kind of social fabric that our neighborhoods have always formed and used to be celebrated for how 56:52 they work. 56:54 So we just need to get back to building those places that really create community and create the kind of supportive Kansas City that we like to think we are. 57:08 Yeah. 57:08 All right. 57:08 architect, uh, Leon career used to, um, in, in his own way of describing it, uh, uh, 57:15 he would say that there should be no buildings taller than six stories because 57:18 that's about the limit at which people can walk upstairs. 57:22 And he, he felt like the, the, 57:24 the city that was really built around human beings uh is a lower scale city and that doesn't now when i say that that people might interpret that to mean that everybody has their own house on their own lot but it's really more about a height 57:42 of building uh issue so 57:44 You could say the same thing about every historic city ever built before the 1940s, 57:49 going back 1,000, 2,000 years. 57:49 They were all generally lower-scaled cities. 57:59 It's an interesting conversation. 58:00 It's another fun theoretical one because we're going to build big buildings and 58:03 we're going to build skyscrapers and that's fine. 58:06 But I think it's interesting how people get fixated on these ideas that it has to 58:11 mean tall buildings as the solution. 58:14 Yeah. 58:16 All right, Dennis, I suppose we should stop there. 58:20 That was a quick hour. 58:23 So I appreciate you coming on. 58:25 I'm really glad now that you are retired that you're more available. 58:30 And I hope to get you in here a little bit more often. 58:33 So I appreciate you doing this. 58:36 I appreciate the opportunity, Kevin. 58:37 We don't get together often enough. 58:38 So this is the way we do it. 58:39 I'm happy to do it. 58:40 All right. 58:41 Whatever it takes. 58:42 All right. 58:43 Thanks, Dennis Strait. 58:44 Appreciate it. 59:26 We'll be right back.
Community discussion