0:00 Welcome to the Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:47 Welcome back to the Messy City Podcast. 0:48 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:51 My man, Alan Branch, on the line here today. 0:54 Mayor Alan Branch. 0:55 How about that? 0:57 You forgot honorable. 0:58 Oh, that's right. 1:00 The honorable. 1:00 Or is it just the honorable, Alan Branch? 1:02 Which one do you prefer, sir? 1:06 I told my dad, I said, he said, Alan, my water pressure's out at my house. 1:09 I said, it's not Alan, it's Mayor Branch. 1:13 I like to keep it very formal around our family. 1:15 Well, you probably should. 1:16 Or, you know, you might just go to Sir Branch or try to get knighted or something like that. 1:21 So I was really excited to have Alan on the show. 1:25 I've been wanting to chat for a while because he has a cool story related to doing 1:31 small incremental development in Panama City, Florida. 1:35 But then he just like went and took things to another level and decided to run for 1:38 mayor and won. 1:40 So it just seems like we've got a lot to talk about. 1:43 And I'm really glad you could join me today, Alan. 1:45 Thanks for doing this. 1:47 Thanks for having me. 1:48 So what I really do want to start with is I think your whole story about doing 1:55 small development in the town you grew up in is really cool. 1:59 And I first became aware of you, I think, by seeing some of the videos that you created, which were really impressive, that just told a little bit of the story. 2:07 But I wonder if you could talk about, like, what was your background? 2:09 So you grew up, you're, what, second, third generation in Panama City? 2:13 How's that? 2:15 Yeah. 2:15 Yeah. 2:16 My grandparents moved here in the 40s, actually in restaurants and car washes in the late 40s, early 50s. 2:25 And my grandfather was just one of these entrepreneurs that was ahead of his time. 2:31 I never met him. 2:32 He died in the early 60s. 2:33 But the restaurants he created, they were in Pensacola, Columbus, Georgia. 2:39 panama city tallahassee he had car washes in panama city in columbus georgia and this is before car washes could get money it wasn't really a thing and he was a pretty bad um not a dad a lot of men in the 40s took advantage of their situations 2:58 he passed away in a car wreck and um but i grew up in my 3:02 um mom and dad really running the car washes and uh grew up in entrepreneurship in the chaos entrepreneurship uh we don't really have hobbies in our family we talk about business and for thanksgiving we talk about pnls and employees and hiring and 3:18 firing and all that sort of stuff and then my background's in software i build software companies i can write software and design software but i'm much better at 3:25 building an organization And I sold a couple of software companies, 2016-ish, and just was looking to put money somewhere. 3:35 And it led me into real estate. 3:37 I started studying real estate, knew nothing about it, and just kind of want to make small mistakes, not big mistakes. 3:45 And that led me into C-Metal Housing, Inc. 3:48 Dev stuff, you know, total validation. 3:52 So it's interesting because I think there's a couple things that I think about. 3:57 We'll talk about the development stuff. 3:58 But I think when a lot of people think about Panama City, Florida, if you're not familiar with Panama City, Florida, you don't really think of it as a place that people live. 4:08 You know, or certainly live for like multiple generations. 4:12 So what what's that experience like growing up in a place that I know I'm well 4:17 aware that like Panama City Beach is the spring break destination. 4:21 But a lot of people may not know that and talk about that relationship to being 4:24 such a kind of a famous or infamous destination. 4:28 Well, it's very similar with Pensacola. 4:30 Pensacola has a Pensacola beach and a Pensacola. 4:34 Almost the same topography in that the beach is on the Gulf of Mexico. 4:38 And the city, really the county, well, Pensacola and Pensacola Beach are the same municipality, but we're actually separate cities. 4:46 But topography-wise, people go to the Gulf for their vacation, and the town is really located on the back. 4:56 And if you really think about when towns were created, you couldn't live on the beach because you couldn't grow crops. 5:02 So unless you just ate fish, you'd starve to that. 5:06 It was like even seaside, that whole area, the rest of here, 5:10 was not a place you wouldn't survive because the ground is sand and you can't grow 5:15 crops. 5:16 So if you were, when the towns were created, that wasn't a thing out there. 5:20 But growing up in Powell City, you know, most of the people made their living off of tourism. 5:26 and servicing tourism, my family car washes in restaurants. 5:29 The last one of the restaurants is actually closing because of DOT, DOT expansion next year. 5:37 My family has years of entrepreneurship in this town. 5:40 So then you became interested and you're like, I got to, I want to do something with the real estate. 5:44 How did you find out about or get connected to this world of incremental developers 5:49 and small developers, all that? 5:51 You know, I don't remember the Genesis story. 5:54 One of my strengths is surrounding myself with really smart people. 5:58 And my partner in the breweries that we own, I've known since high school, he was actually a city planner. 6:04 He's an AICP. 6:06 And I don't know if he told me about CRA, Florida, and Ocean Springs, and all the other places, but somehow it led me to you know, Incremo Development Alliance, Monty Anderson, you know, Bernice and stuff and Buffalo, the whole, the whole gang of just, 6:23 and then even realizing that new urbanism from seaside area on the street. 6:30 And so I don't know. 6:31 And my, 6:32 my sort of skillset and software is in the people of the company and even designing 6:39 software is very similar to architecture in that it's, a digital world that you're kind of steering people through, very much like architecture, very much like the design of a restaurant. 6:51 It's like, what do you see when you walk in? 6:53 How do you feel when you exit? 6:55 It's all those kind of things. 6:56 So it lends itself a lot to it. 6:58 And then I grew up, my dad and mom are like famous car washers. 7:03 Like my dad and his friend invented the car wash model. 7:08 You ride through the car, you vacuum yourself. 7:10 That was created backwards and kind of lost it. 7:13 And my dad was the International Car Wash Association president. 7:17 So he's like a legit famous car washer, one of the biggest associations in the world, biggest trade show in the world. 7:24 And I grew up just tagging along for the trade show, 7:26 tagging along and going to car wash tours and talking about debt service and curb 7:30 cuts and signs and traffic counts. 7:33 And so I thought it was normal that a 12-year-old asked what your labor rates were. 7:38 You know, we had cost requisition costs. 7:40 And I think that was normal. 7:42 That was a little bit of a little... 7:44 kid. 7:44 But yeah, you know, it all just kind of led itself to this. 7:48 And we had some money after selling a software company. 7:51 And when I started studying failure in real estate, it was around people making big jumps. 7:56 They would jump to a really big project. 7:59 And so our first project was renovating a quadplex. 8:03 It was like $80,000 to buy it. 8:05 It was a bad part of town. 8:06 We paid about $40,000 in cash in it. 8:09 And it's hard to make, you know, you don't sink yourself If you have a couple of million bucks, my $120,000 project, you sink yourself and jumping into a big, sexy project. 8:24 And so I like to make little mistakes along the way and learn and then just study other people. 8:29 Yeah. 8:30 So I'm curious about that. 8:33 So that first one, that fourplex deal, you know, 8:36 one of the issues that people have had doing sort of cash deals or doing things 8:39 like that in bad parts of town is then on the backside, Canada praise. 8:44 And did you have issues with that coming out? 8:47 I would assume at some point you maybe refinanced out of it to a, to a permanent loan. 8:51 Yeah. 8:52 It was like, we bought it. 8:54 $40 a square foot. 8:56 It was like $45 or $50 a square foot. 8:57 The rents were like $600 per unit or something. 9:01 And now it's like $1,000 and $1,200 a unit. 9:03 We refiled all our money a few years ago. 9:06 But then I even studied sort of rehab. 9:09 That sort of failure when you refile your money, you take out too much money. 9:14 And then the AC break, you lose one unit before you know it. 9:20 So I like to study failures. 9:22 Yeah. 9:24 and not just success, but failures as well. 9:26 So then where did, 9:27 where did you go from that after kind of looking at the fourplex and what, 9:30 what was the next endeavor for you? 9:31 And at this point, was this like a full-time thing for you? 9:34 Were you still working or how'd that work? 9:36 Yeah, I, I am a glutton for punishment. 9:38 And, uh, and so I always work a couple of jobs. 9:41 No, 9:42 we were still building software companies at the time doing consulting work after 9:47 we sold a couple of companies. 9:49 And we bought a little house after that. 9:50 So I learned about wholesaling. 9:52 I had a woman approach me and she said, I got to help you in a contract. 9:55 I'll assign the contract to you for $20,000. 9:59 Had no idea what that meant. 10:01 Asked a friend of mine who was in commercial real estate what that meant. 10:04 And he walked me through that. 10:06 So just along the way, I keep collecting knowledge. 10:09 We still own that house. 10:10 And I think we bought it for $40,000, $20,000 signing fee for like 40 grand or something like that. 10:17 Yeah. 10:19 That is definitely starting small. 10:21 I think you would make Monty and everybody proud by thinking about doing those 10:25 little steps first. 10:26 Well, you know, people forget all the practice, right? 10:30 Like people, you see people hit home runs in sports, but you forget about how many times they show up to the gym. 10:36 coming out this long and so you have to also develop a palate like chefs that don't taste lots of dishes don't develop a palate what tastes good so a lot of those 10:46 little steps um aren't sexy and cool and they're not big wins, but there's the practice you need to make to hit the home run later. 10:55 Yeah. 10:56 Yeah. 10:56 And it's kind of, and it's helping you build a habit and of, you know, doing deals, 11:01 making deals so that eventually you're ready for bigger things down the road. 11:05 Yeah. 11:06 So talk to me then. 11:08 And so where, 11:09 at what point did like the big commercial renovations start to come into play and 11:13 the bigger projects that you were looking at? 11:15 Yeah, once we got a couple little projects done, I just started looking at Panama City as a whole. 11:19 I had considered moving some money to a different city, but just started studying Panama City. 11:25 And I noticed our downtown was $10 a square foot for like brick buildings. 11:31 And I thought, that's weird. 11:34 Why can't I buy a metal building in the worst part of town for $70? 11:38 And I can't buy a building downtown for 10. 11:41 That's what led me to downtown and other comparables. 11:47 And then I saw the failures of those downtowns that revived themselves came from a 11:52 local push, came from dirt spaces. 11:56 And then I had a friend, Tim Whaler, who's the partner of the breweries now. 12:00 He loves brew beer. 12:02 And I thought, well, we can take this out. 12:04 The building that I'm in right now is my home. 12:06 It's right behind one of our breweries. 12:08 We bought this building for 10 bucks a square foot. 12:11 And, you know, we put a bunch of money into it, like, you know, 60 bucks a square foot or something. 12:17 But, yeah, I just knew it was a market. 12:19 It was a confidence issue. 12:21 Money follows confidence. 12:23 And you need a competent person to sort of change. 12:26 More than real estate, it's a culture change. 12:30 You know, people would say on Facebook, When they talked about a news story about revitalizing downtown in 2016, people would say, bulldoze the place. 12:39 I was like, why are they so grateful towards this area town that's done nothing to them? 12:45 And so I just saw that it was partial marketing, bringing art to third space. 12:51 I was an art major in college, so I kind of like the arts. 12:56 And kind of pushed forward about 2016. 13:01 Yeah. 13:04 And before we get to the hurricane story, 13:07 talk a little bit about what are some of the other things that you learned? 13:10 So you're like studying failure from, from other downtowns of the cities. 13:14 What were some of the other things that you saw that you either wanted to emulate 13:18 or not emulate as you're working in Panama city? 13:20 I, you know, I think it's easy in life to think that your problems are unique. 13:26 And, and, they're very rarely any person or city have a unique problem. 13:33 And I saw that the common story of library downtown is, you know, that's where the town's created, that's where the house goes, that's where all the commerce is, the mall comes in, rips the commerce out, privatized parking, it's lawyers buy the buildings, 13:48 long-term companies hold onto properties, rents drop, confidence drops, you can't afford to replace anything because the rent's so low, it's a poor landlord. 13:57 And it's a downward spiral. 13:59 And so every robotic story is super, super similar. 14:03 It's like the exact same story. 14:06 You know, you get rid of parking, you add buildings, do pop-up stuff. 14:10 All the better block stuff is super interesting. 14:13 Yeah, it's all the exact same story. 14:16 Yeah. 14:16 All right. 14:17 So now let's talk about the hurricane and the impact that that had on not just your 14:23 town, but you personally. 14:25 That was a big deal. 14:29 Just to frame the whole thing, it was a Category 5 hurricane that came out as a Category 2, like 36 hours before it hit us. 14:37 Category 2 is like bad thunderstorm. 14:40 Category 5 is like you're all dead. 14:43 And so we all woke up that morning and like, oh my God, this thing's, it was a Category 4. 14:49 And we're like, oh, too late to leave. 14:51 You get stuck on the interstate. 14:53 And then it came through, it removed 80% of the trees we have in our county. 14:56 That's a fact from the government. 14:58 Like we, there's 80% of the trees are gone. 15:01 But for a blighted area that needed the turnover, right? 15:08 It was a moment where people who had been thinking about retiring, I'm going to retire in three years, four years, five years, I'm going to retire now. 15:16 I'm thinking about opening the business. 15:18 I'm going to open it. 15:19 It was a galvanism at the moment. 15:21 It was terrible. 15:23 would never want to go here. 15:25 But it was the best thing that's ever happened to us because it forced, it concentrated 10 years of decisions in the six months. 15:32 Wow. 15:33 So people who were thinking about leaving left, 15:36 people who wanted to make money moved here because they saw a lot of people who 15:40 could make money. 15:40 A surge of construction and insurance money, people were moving here. 15:46 And it was basically a 30-mile-long tornado. 15:49 And it was a Category 3 by the time it hit Georgia. 15:53 So it blew through us, one of the strongest storms we ever had in the United States. 15:57 And our school system had $400 million in damage to it. 16:01 We didn't have running over for three weeks. 16:03 We're a city, so we have lift stations, lift sewer over. 16:07 And we have 112 lift stations. 16:08 Only two of them worked. 16:09 Wow. 16:10 Wow. 16:17 Yeah, I mean, that's incredible. 16:19 I mean, so on the one hand, you've got the physical devastation of the storm itself, but then that's a fascinating thing to think about, that it really was this galvanizing moment. 16:29 How did that impact the projects that you wanted to take on and do? 16:33 Did everything kind of just go on pause for a little bit while you're cleaning up, 16:37 or did it spur you and your friends into doing more quickly? 16:44 Yes, all of the above. 16:47 disruption of your entire life. 16:50 Highly don't recommend going through a category five hurricane or any natural disaster. 16:54 And every natural, every city after natural disasters have the exact same story as well. 16:59 I had a FEMA consultant tell me every, so after a hurricane, you have resurgence of community pride. 17:06 And then you have a bell curve in a year. 17:09 And for politicians, if you get elected before the natural disaster, you get elected after that as well within two years. 17:16 Within year two, three, four, the community starts, enthusiasm drops. 17:21 Every city thinks they should recover faster than they should. 17:24 But you can't because no city is sitting on enough money to rebuild itself. 17:29 You don't have that. 17:30 So you borrow a whole bunch of money in the hopes that FEMA gives you your money. 17:35 And then you never rebuild that. 17:38 And then people start saying, oh, the politicians are stealing money. 17:41 And enthusiasm drops. 17:43 You're anti-politician. 17:45 People get elected. 17:45 You're rabble-rousers. 17:46 And you sit in anger near three to five. 17:50 And then positivity springs back. 17:52 So the bell curve. 17:54 But for us, you know, I was 44 now. 17:58 And a lot of my friends... 18:02 sort of we're in through a chapter of life where this was no longer our parents' 18:05 town, but it was our town now. 18:07 You start feeling now, like, oh, this is a bad place, and now my dad's retired, right? 18:12 It's my turn. 18:13 And it was sort of a, if not now, then when, if not us, then who? 18:20 And so you had people, money on the sidelines, who now said it's the time now to invest. 18:27 And they want to invest in meaningful things, not just highest rates, We were desperate for, you know, a beacon of hope. 18:36 Yeah. 18:37 Yeah. 18:38 I mean, it's, God, it's crazy. 18:40 I've been around, you know, a few hurricanes, a few places that have been devastated by tornadoes. 18:46 You know, 18:46 I participated in some of the new urban charrettes that happened in New Orleans 18:51 after Katrina and Rita. 18:53 And I mean, what you describe is so true. 18:55 Like there was this amazing energy afterwards that galvanized people to be creative 19:00 and want to do cool things. 19:02 But now when you go back to a lot of those places, even years later, there's not been a whole lot of activity, not been a whole lot of reconstruction. 19:12 It seems like in most places that experience a natural disaster. 19:17 And I don't know, 19:17 some of that might just be a function of the age we're in where just things move 19:20 really, really slowly. 19:24 FEMA is necessary, needed, but also very hard to work with. 19:28 And so the common story that you'll see is cities go borrow a whole bunch of money, 19:32 and then you have to cash flow that interest. 19:35 Like right now, our little town, 38,000 people, 19:38 has $8.5 million of just interest on loans for projects that we're getting done. 19:42 And our whole property tax take is $18 million. 19:47 So you've injected $8.5 million into a tiny little budget, and so now things are tight. 19:53 And you can misconstrued that of we're broke. 19:56 Well, we're not broke. 19:57 We're just on a loan that we're waiting to get out of projects and then FEMA will pay us back. 20:01 And in two years, we will have that go back to our normal budget. 20:06 But that can get misconstrued. 20:07 And so I think I never really thought about how government is an organization where 20:14 it's very fluid as opposed to a business. 20:19 Imagine having a pizza restaurant. 20:22 where the ownership is new every two years. 20:26 And the pendulum is swinging. 20:28 We're going pizzas. 20:29 We're not going pizzas. 20:30 We're going pizzas. 20:31 And your customers don't trust you. 20:35 And it's a part-time job. 20:37 It's the first time they've ever done the job before as an elected official. 20:40 And so you have people that are running a pizza restaurant who've never worked in a 20:44 pizza restaurant before. 20:45 So it's all new. 20:47 It's very unusual, quite clumsy organization. 20:50 Messy city is a great name. 20:51 I'd call it clumsy city. 20:56 Oh, gee. 20:56 So, all right. 20:57 So let's talk about what projects did you immediately start working on then in that 21:01 period after the hurricane, before you started really get involved in local politics? 21:07 Well, that was six years ago. 21:12 And so I, It became clear in that, I mean, Victor Dover told me, cities don't revitalize themselves because of the city. 21:21 They do it in spite of the city. 21:24 And that's a quote. 21:25 And so it became very evident that Facebook and sort of community pressure to 21:34 change became a very powerful tool. 21:37 Um, and I had to be a very kind, sneaky wheel, selected officials here, uh, to get changed. 21:44 Uh, I mean, skateboarding was around town. 21:46 Murals were illegal. 21:48 Brewers were illegal. 21:49 Bodies were illegal. 21:50 Seating was illegal. 21:51 Everything was illegal. 21:53 And, uh, and so we had to change all those things. 21:56 And, um, but we immediately started the brewery. 21:59 Um, I had bought the building for the brewery across from my house. 22:02 Uh, history class is the name of the brewery. 22:04 Uh, it tells the stories of our community. 22:06 And, uh, We immediately start on that, along with my own roof of my house. 22:12 And every property I own was torn apart. 22:16 I didn't have a small friend that had a roof on my house. 22:18 Everyone had a roof. 22:20 I had a roof, standing seam metal that took the roof off. 22:25 Right. 22:25 This is a brand new roof. 22:27 Yeah. 22:28 So yeah, 22:29 so it wasn't like immediately after buying properties because people started just 22:34 selling their properties. 22:36 And they're getting big, especially big cash out from insurance. 22:39 And they can sell the property at cheap enough that we can afford to remodel on it. 22:42 So we were buying properties. 22:43 We bought about $2.5 million in properties at like 30 bucks a square foot. 22:47 Wow. 22:48 Which gives you the ability to rent it. 22:51 And we rehab it. 22:54 We bought a historic registry. 22:55 It's a wedding tree now. 22:58 We're on commercial buildings. 23:00 And so we were just buying it if we could. 23:01 And some with partners, some with ourselves. 23:05 How hard was it to find labor in that period, construction labor? 23:09 Very hard. 23:10 And I know everybody this time. 23:14 No contractors were doing any favors or, hey, buddy, I've known you for two years. 23:20 Get my roof on. 23:21 The best analogy I can tell you would be if you watch an Easter egg hunt, 23:27 and you watch a kid with a basket and the basket's full of eggs and they just keep 23:32 trying to pick up eggs. 23:33 Yeah. 23:34 They keep dropping the eggs as they're picking up eggs. 23:36 That's every architect and contractor in this town. 23:40 Yeah. 23:41 They had more work than the handle. 23:43 And so, yeah, it was tough. 23:45 We were doing a lot of labor ourselves. 23:46 I have my own handyman, Aaron. 23:49 He's worked for me for four years doing projects and stuff. 23:52 And he was helpful. 23:53 My brother-in-law moved to town to help. 23:56 And so, yeah, we just did it all on weekends and nights. 24:00 I even, on history class, per Florida State Statute, you can pull owner permits on commercial property. 24:07 So you have to own them outright. 24:08 It has to be in your personal land. 24:09 You can't lift them for a year. 24:11 And then you have to pull all your stuff from your license. 24:14 And so I pulled my own license, my own permits on history class. 24:17 Interesting. 24:17 Because I couldn't give you one. 24:19 Yeah. 24:20 So, all right. 24:21 So at some point this translates into you getting more and more and more involved 24:24 in just like local politics and city politics. 24:26 How, uh, talk a little bit about that. 24:28 Obviously you're already like lobbying for change for different, uh, policy change. 24:34 Well, I think anyone who, um, especially restaurants, I think it was a special place in people's hearts for restaurant owners. 24:41 Yeah. 24:42 like serving people. 24:43 Although I don't work there. 24:44 I've built software companies. 24:46 Um, but I think anyone who becomes known in the town, especially vocal, you get the, Oh, you should run for mayor. 24:54 Um, So I got that for a long time. 24:56 I said, no, no way. 24:58 That's a terrible job. 25:00 But so much of my life, 25:01 there's an incremental involvement at Wyatt's video that's called Somebody Auto. 25:05 That should be tacked across my forehead, which is just like, hey, no one else can do this. 25:10 I also realized just in studying cities, talking to other cities, I knew more about how cities work than the previous mayor. 25:23 and a lot of prisoners. 25:25 And I was constantly bringing them up, like, hey, this is what they're doing. 25:27 Why don't you do this? 25:29 And kind of became influential behind the scenes. 25:33 So it was like, I'm already getting complaints for everything as a person that's not elected. 25:38 And so might as well go for the whole deal. 25:41 So when did you actually decide then to run? 25:45 I actually announced the day the previous mayor got elected. 25:48 OK. 25:49 Yeah. 25:49 So to your term, the previous mayor 25:53 Two years is short, yeah. 25:54 Two years is very short. 25:56 And the previous mayor was a very nice person, but had no idea how cities work. 26:03 Former orthopedic surgeon, 81 years old. 26:05 Couldn't tell you how the lead permit works. 26:07 Couldn't tell you what a CRA stands for, but just had all the answers. 26:11 And he had not done the homework to disperse the position in life. 26:21 So then you had a two year long campaign to work on. 26:23 Yeah. 26:25 And so let's talk a little bit about that because there's probably people who 26:29 listen, uh, anybody in this world, you, you just run across city politics. 26:34 It's just that it's the nature of anybody who's in development or planning. 26:37 You can't escape it. 26:38 There's just some, almost all development these days has some discretionary element to it. 26:44 uh unfortunately and so you end up dealing with a lot of city politics plus getting to know just all the city departments state issues etc etc uh so talk a little bit about just the process of what it was like to run for mayor first of all and what 26:59 were some of the things that you talked about with people as issues why very few 27:06 people asked me why um 27:10 Most people have seen me enough to know why and also know my track record of stuff downtown. 27:19 Our downtown now is thriving unbelievably. 27:24 It's a place that people take. 27:26 I watched a person get engaged the other day, like 50 hours a year. 27:30 And so that didn't happen five years ago. 27:33 Uh, and I get a lot of credit for a lot of things I didn't do. 27:36 Uh, and so just cause I'm such a loud, large person. 27:40 Um, but the campaign is the most gut wrenching, terrible experience you could ever go through in your entire life. 27:47 Uh, it's, uh, it's the worst thing. 27:50 Um, 27:51 in that you are a punching bag, even still this, 27:53 this is a customer position and you're a punching bag for a lot of people. 27:57 Yeah. 27:58 Uh, but a campaign is basically, um, 28:04 half truth slung at you, manipulation of the truth. 28:10 Thankfully, my family has such an incredible reputation here. 28:13 It was very hard for people to ruin my family's reputation, which was an attempt by the previous mayor. 28:20 Just like he said, I'm in the cartel. 28:23 That was his deadline. 28:25 Alan is in the deep state cartel. 28:26 He said it over 100 times. 28:28 Wow. 28:29 100 times. 28:30 So my friends are printing T-shirts. 28:32 Deep State Cartel. 28:35 And I'm at a Kiwanis meeting where there's a debate. 28:38 And in the room is like my Latin teacher from high school. 28:43 You know, it's friends of my parents. 28:44 And this is a man who's saying, Alan's in a cartel. 28:47 And everyone's moaning and groaning. 28:49 And I'm like, my family owns car washes and soft hamburgers. 28:53 You know me. 28:55 I'm not in a cartel. 28:57 But it's exhausting defending your reputation. 29:00 It's exhausting. 29:01 yeah yeah i can see that and especially was there a bunch of that on social media as well that you had to deal with oh yeah they sent out like hit letters on me uh it was just it wasn't very nice and that actually really backfired on that campaign 29:14 because i think in a small town people see you and they see you at the grocery store right they see you at the baseball park and they're like i don't know i don't 29:22 think alan so it I think that, I don't think the dirtiness of the campaign, that's how the campaign affected me more than just emotionally. 29:32 I think it actually backfired on them, but emotionally. 29:35 So tactic-wise, like what all did you have to do, like on a week-to-week basis? 29:40 Are you knocking on doors? 29:43 Are you going to breakfast and lunches and all that sort of stuff? 29:46 Yeah, the campaigning is... 29:49 A little town like ours, we spent $100,000 in the campaign. 29:53 There's 38,000 people in the whole town. 29:56 And my opponent spent 70. 29:58 And so even raising $100,000 is a lot of work. 30:02 But it was 14 hours a day. 30:04 And what's funny is the last two weeks, the ball's already rolled. 30:08 The ad buys have been made. 30:11 The most of the work is actually months and months in advance. 30:14 And so I went out immediately in the fall before the past spring. 30:19 I went on his complete donor list and started having meetings with all his leaders 30:23 from the previous campaign and just picking off his donors. 30:28 But yeah, it was fundraisers. 30:29 It was like seven debates. 30:31 Wow. 30:34 We did trash pickups. 30:36 I walk around down every morning and pick up trash in my little trash bucket. 30:40 So every Saturday we had trash pickups and we would talk about Panama City and I 30:43 had trash buckets with the city logo on it and I gave them away. 30:46 You know, I have video resources with our businesses. 30:52 So I had like the campaign and put it highlighting nonprofits like, hey, this is an awesome nonprofit. 30:57 They're looking for volunteers. 30:58 So it was more community-oriented and less media-oriented. 31:01 Yeah. 31:03 Yeah, it was a lot of work. 31:05 Yeah. 31:05 So for what period of time would you say that was a full-time job? 31:09 Oh, my gosh. 31:10 I'd say it really ended up January 15th through April 22nd. 31:14 Okay. 31:15 Yeah. 31:16 But it was mostly meetings and getting the groundwork laid October, November, December. 31:23 And then you have a lull around the holidays, and it really picks up much earlier than you think. 31:29 And campaigning is a weird process, too, where you're going to all your friends and saying, I need money. 31:34 And I need help, but don't talk to me. 31:36 I have to meet with people who don't like me. 31:40 You're meeting all day, not people who like you, who are skeptical of you. 31:43 And that's exhausting. 31:45 It's like everyone's skeptical. 31:47 Everyone's questioning you. 31:49 Um, and that's, that's not really a fun day. 31:52 Yeah. 31:52 It's like the worst kind of dating experience day after day after day. 31:55 Yeah. 31:56 I actually really liked knocking on doors. 31:58 Um, That actually wasn't a fun experience. 32:00 I had a few doors slammed on and people that cussed at me, but overwhelmingly people were really excited to just say hello and meet. 32:07 And I just dropped off a business card and said, Hey, you got a question? 32:09 Email me. 32:10 I know you're probably cooking dinner or you're cutting the grass. 32:15 It's Saturday. 32:16 I don't want to interrupt you. 32:16 Here's my business. 32:18 And no one would call. 32:19 It wasn't bad to have a whole conversation right at the door. 32:25 Yeah. 32:26 So I want to talk about some of the things you're doing or you hope to do, 32:29 but I'm curious now because you mentioned this being a two-year term. 32:34 Are you already having to think about being in campaign mode for the next election? 32:39 Yeah, we can change it to a four-year term through an ordinance, and we're looking at doing that. 32:43 Okay. 32:43 Because the commissioners are a four-year term and the mayor's a two-year term. 32:46 We are a weak mayor, so I'm basically a city commissioner that runs the city meetings. 32:50 Okay. 32:50 And you get blamed for everything and you have authority over nothing. 32:53 Right. 32:54 And, uh, and so, but you, you're, you're a fuel, you're. 32:58 you know, your power, I don't want the right word to say, it really comes in running the meeting and steering conversation. 33:04 And then your words seem to impact people more as the mayor than the commissioners. 33:09 It doesn't make any sense, but it just seems important. 33:11 Yeah. 33:12 Yeah. 33:12 We have a weak mayor system here too, although they have added some powers to it over time, 33:16 like the ability to appoint people to other commissions and committees and stuff 33:21 like that. 33:22 But yeah, by and large, the mayor is kind of another citywide council person. 33:26 Yeah. 33:26 We're doing a charter review right now. 33:27 We have a charter review committee. 33:30 Yeah. 33:31 So then talk about what, 33:32 what are some of the things that you hope to bring to the table or what are, 33:35 what are you already working on in the mayor's office? 33:39 Yeah. 33:39 Um, it's, it's crazy. 33:42 Um, 33:45 how much of a customer support job this is. 33:48 People want to unpack their days on you, want to demand that, oh, I need you to come here right now. 33:54 I don't care if it's Saturday at 10 o'clock at night, those kind of things. 33:59 And I knew that would happen. 34:00 I didn't know to what extent. 34:03 I made no big campaign promises either. 34:06 I basically said, I own businesses. 34:08 I know how this works. 34:10 But I didn't say, I'm going to do this and this. 34:12 I'm going to get you a stadium. 34:13 No. 34:15 And so the campaign promises I made were really related similarly to a business. 34:20 Like, we're going to ask for feedback. 34:22 We're going to listen to feedback on how to improve permitting, all the things. 34:26 We're going to bring customer service to City Hall. 34:29 And so in the past 120 days, 34:32 every city email address has a link in the email signature to a feedback form. 34:36 And the link is, you know, give us feedback. 34:39 Can we do something better? 34:40 Let us know. 34:42 We're doing a quarterly video. 34:44 We have $150 million infrastructure project happening. 34:48 And so roads are torn up everywhere. 34:50 And people are going, well, why is my road not getting torn up? 34:52 And we were never telling anybody what we're working on. 34:55 Let's just make a video once a quarter. 34:57 The city manager going through a chart, a map of the city saying, this has been engineered. 35:01 This hasn't. 35:02 This is funded. 35:03 This hasn't. 35:04 This is why this road's not getting repaired. 35:06 This one's getting repaired because, and bringing some clarity into that, those decisions. 35:12 And so I've already met a lot of the campaign promises and I kind of insinuated that. 35:17 The millage is staying the same, so we're not raising the millage this year. 35:21 But just bringing some of that to City Hall is all I really made. 35:27 Yeah, I didn't make any promises. 35:29 Just a friendlier city government, one that you can understand better. 35:32 We have no meetings now. 35:34 We have a town hall meeting on Saturday mornings where there's no agenda. 35:38 You just can come talk. 35:39 Wow. 35:41 So we've actually removed open public non-agenda items, 35:45 comments out of our commission meetings and put those into a town hall meeting once 35:50 a month. 35:51 That's cool. 35:52 Well, you can still comment on agenda items. 35:55 You just can't come complain about. 35:57 Right. 35:57 That's not on the agenda. 35:58 Right. 35:59 But Saturdays, it's donuts and coffee. 36:02 We're in shorts and t-shirts and it's casual conversation. 36:05 And you get, I mean, People were very skeptical about that. 36:09 That was the first thing I did was I changed the meetings. 36:11 We have virtual meetings. 36:12 We have Zoom meetings where we're just discussing ideas earlier. 36:16 So if we're talking about how does CRA work? 36:20 What are the CRA products? 36:21 We have a whole two hour virtual meeting on the CRA. 36:25 How does it work? 36:25 What are we working on? 36:27 And so you get a lot more dialogue when you're elected officials now. 36:29 It's all on YouTube. 36:31 There's hours and hours of us talking because even as someone who paid attention to 36:34 local politics, I couldn't understand how an idea was worked and formed. 36:41 It would just magically appear. 36:43 And then as a citizen, you'd be like, wait, it's a final reading. 36:45 What's happening? 36:46 And you'd rush down and they're all pissed off and you have no idea something's about to happen. 36:50 You couldn't even tell where the idea came from. 36:52 Did it come from the staff? 36:53 Did it come from a certain person? 36:55 Where did this thing come from? 36:57 And so now you can track the story of, Why are we doing this thing? 37:02 Well, 37:02 it started a year ago in a virtual meeting where this commissioner brought up this 37:05 issue, or in this town hall meeting, this citizen said this, and here's the conversation. 37:11 So it's a lot more, the board, I think, 37:13 is a lot more casual in that you get long discussion recorded that aren't in a 37:18 traditional meeting where everyone's in suits, sitting in sort of this. 37:24 It's also weird being on the dais. 37:26 It's like a straight line. 37:27 It's not conducive to the conversation. 37:29 If we were having a conversation, we'd sit at a round table and look at each other. 37:33 And so, yeah, we just expanded all those things and made it feel a little familiar. 37:38 On the doors of City Hall, it has feedback. 37:41 Did you have a good experience? 37:42 Scan this QR code. 37:43 Tell us what we do better. 37:45 We want to iterate on mistakes and get better. 37:50 And when someone does a great job, we want to reward them and celebrate them. 37:53 That's brilliant. 37:54 I love that. 37:55 And I mean, 37:56 it feels to me like those are the not very sexy sort of things that actually really 38:01 help build trust in a community. 38:03 Yeah. 38:05 Well, you know, as someone who was really paying attention. 38:09 I've watched every meeting on YouTube. 38:11 I've attended every meeting for the past eight years, planning board meetings, CRA meetings, city meetings, but then watched every meeting going back to 15 years. 38:18 I couldn't really tell you what was going on and why people were doing certain things. 38:22 And I was at everything. 38:25 And so I just wanted, when people take care of parenting, as an elected official, what they mean is you talk like this. 38:34 hey, here's what I can do. 38:35 And you might hear a bad idea from the official, right? 38:40 But what makes it really hard, especially with a weak mayor, is your city manager controls the city, even behind the scenes. 38:47 If you're not having open discussion, big debate, where you're building a consensus of an idea, your city manager behind the scenes can steer and whip loads. 38:57 And you're never going like, well, who thinks it's a bad idea? 39:00 The commissioner's like, the commissioner thinks it's a bad idea. 39:03 We have, Florida has this sunshine. 39:06 We can't, we cannot, 39:07 any of the city commissioners cannot talk to each other about things they're going 39:10 to vote on. 39:11 Other states, you just can't meet the forum. 39:14 But we have like the strictest forum here. 39:16 And so it's a very inefficient way. 39:19 You know, if you, 39:20 your family and my family are planning on vacation and you can only talk to the 39:23 travel agent, And I'll go, why does Kevin want to go to California? 39:27 We want to go to Colorado. 39:28 And he's like, well, I can't really tell you why Kevin thinks that way. 39:32 That's a very bad way to plan a vacation. 39:35 Right? 39:36 you want to have more discussion openly like this and say well here's what you think versus behind the city managers trying to get people together and build consensus you want to build consensus ultimately yeah yeah that's what we're doing 39:49 yeah it makes a lot of sense so what about then the policy world locally related to development to incremental development are there opportunities that that you've 39:58 seen where you're hoping you could make some change yeah 40:02 So we have, Inc. 40:04 Dev is starting tonight, actually. 40:05 So I go from here, there's a reception for EDA, and then I go to Inc. 40:09 Dev has their opening sort of commencement speech thing, and then we go to workshops, hopefully, this fall. 40:16 So we're bringing that in. 40:16 That was an idea I gave City Hall two and a half years ago. 40:23 And we're just now getting here. 40:26 Bernice from... 40:29 Buffalo has reached out to me as well saying, hey, let's talk about how we can make this more friendly. 40:33 I want to do a pattern book for ADDs and missing middle housing that I'm working on. 40:38 I just haven't gotten enough time to get there. 40:40 We're currently in budget season. 40:42 And being elected in April is sort of like 30% budget season. 40:45 So I found myself in budget season. 40:48 And so that's been my main focus. 40:50 But pattern books related to missing middle housing is the next step for me. 40:54 CRAs. 40:56 I think we were going to spend some money in some cute ways, but not effective ways. 41:00 So we've strengthened some grants. 41:02 We also have lots of city properties that need to get on the tax roll. 41:07 And so we've developed a plan that would be SPARK. 41:10 Every company has an acronym for it. 41:13 And the catchier it is, the better it is. 41:15 Of course, yeah. 41:16 And so we have a bunch 41:18 that we're hoping to sort of piggyback on the IncDev workshops this fall and start releasing those either really cheap or free to people who get through the IncDev 41:29 courses and then pair them up with banks. 41:32 We're already talking to five friends that run banks here, and so we're already talking about how do we get to pair them up. 41:37 And so that's the story we're hoping to tell in December is IncDev came to town. 41:43 We just now are seeing that. 41:45 People went through it and they're building their first projects using city 41:48 properties that we've acquired over the past 30 years. 41:50 Wow. 41:51 That's really cool. 41:53 So I know you, you mentioned Victor, uh, Dover earlier. 41:56 I know Dover Cole did a big, uh, downtown plan for you as well. 42:00 I wonder if you could talk about the impact of that and, and how you begin to implement a plan like that. 42:05 And I say that with like the greater respect. 42:08 I love Victor and their work. 42:09 I think they do. 42:10 There's some of the best planners in the whole country. 42:13 Uh, so talk about what that means for you all. 42:17 Yeah, that whole team, um, 42:20 are amazing people and i don't know especially after the hurricane they're like half city planners half mental health counselors because everyone needs mental health counseling after a hurricane like that um and victor has been just for me 42:39 someone who just offers words of encouragement um but we did a whole main street uh 42:44 streetscape uh where we 42:47 Parallel parking, wider sidewalks, street streams, big plaza in the middle. 42:53 And it still is very controversial in this town because we do have a lot of roads 42:57 that are still bottom holes and sinkholes. 42:59 And then we have this one road that's fantastic. 43:01 And so some people still are happy about it, but overwhelmingly it's got a lot of confidence in the area. 43:11 Pushing for people, spaces for people, not for cars. 43:14 And then 43:15 I've also found that consultants like Gover Cole are not just giving you the idea, but oftentimes the person where if you have less than strong-willed officials, 43:30 you can point to people like, oh, they told me to do this. 43:34 They take all the information. 43:37 But he's been amazing. 43:38 I still keep in touch with him. 43:40 I think they're coming back in time history, so. 43:42 Okay. 43:43 And so thinking about the hurricane and we're kind of, I guess, smack dab in hurricane season right now, 43:51 how do you all think about future hurricanes and protecting yourself potentially, 43:57 or how do you deal with the possibility of that? 44:00 And just how do you prepare as a community, having been through a really devastating one? 44:06 You certainly now... 44:08 like when people build with ICF block, which my dad did, he rebuilt his home ICF block, which is like styrofoam with poured concrete in it. 44:16 Yeah. 44:17 That's now sexy and cool. 44:19 Cool to build the concrete. 44:21 Yeah. 44:22 And so you definitely see a lot more of that. 44:25 We've talked about even having grants for people that use, you know, stronger products, non-wood products. 44:34 But certainly, you know, as, as, 44:36 sea levels rise and as more hurricanes come it's becoming more and more popular to talk about how strong your building is not what it looks like how long it will be here i really been thinking about building codes and and i think you know 100 years 44:50 ago when you built something for yourself and your great grandchildren like a generational home a generational farm and farm is something that monty anderson john anderson they all talk about your farm right when it's your farm you want it 45:04 to last generational 45:06 And building code for something I think will invent it when people start selling stuff. 45:10 Because then you have to tell them to something else. 45:13 But when it's your great-great-kids, you want to be around for longer. 45:16 And so you just hear more conversation about like, oh, well, what kind of framing methods do you use? 45:21 Or what do you use for this? 45:22 And it's now becoming cooler to build things that last longer. 45:25 I haven't seen as many green roofs that I was hoping to see and things like that. 45:30 We did a big bio swell behind history class where the rain goes into like a little 45:34 rock swell and we absorb all the rainwater off the roof. 45:38 That's becoming cool now. 45:39 It's like, oh, what do you do with your rainwater? 45:41 Can you reduce your stormwater through interesting techniques? 45:44 That kind of stuff's cool now. 45:47 And just one other sort of tangential thing I'm just curious about. 45:51 So you're right there, like you mentioned before, 45:55 kind of in the shadow of some of the most famous new urbanist communities in the 45:59 whole country with Seaside, Rosemary Beach, Alice Beach, everything right down the street. 46:05 Has that had any impact on Panama City? 46:09 Or I would assume everybody knows about it. 46:11 Some people probably go there occasionally. 46:13 What's that like? 46:16 Yeah. 46:17 I wouldn't say everybody. 46:17 I'd say the well-studied architects or builders or real estate people understand 46:23 how crazy that is, that it's right down the street. 46:26 Everyone else just, most people just like it. 46:29 They don't know why. 46:30 I don't know why this feels good. 46:32 I don't know why I feel safe on this corner. 46:35 And that's been interesting to dig into, you know, you start all the strong town stuff. 46:41 Anyone talk about road signs and it's so much psychology. 46:47 And that's kind of hard to quantify. 46:49 The space between the buildings are interesting. 46:51 I had this whole conversation with a group in this historic area of Panama City, 46:55 and they were hung up that this developer wanted five stories. 46:59 Oh, I can't believe they want five stories. 47:00 Five stories. 47:01 Four, not five. 47:02 Four, not five. 47:04 I said, I'll give you a two-point development. 47:07 It'll be self-dorage building. 47:09 Not a single window. 47:10 Do you want that on your waterfront? 47:11 They're like, oh, God, no. 47:12 And I'm like, well, okay, so function matters. 47:15 The space between things matters. 47:17 Don't get hung up on a number. 47:19 And I think that's what, you know, Seaside really showed us. 47:23 And the retention part on Seaside is the answer here. 47:26 I love telling you that. 47:28 Oh, you know, that's the retention part. 47:30 So there's a lot of lessons there. 47:31 The temporary building on the south side of the road. 47:34 That's a story, too. 47:35 People don't realize that. 47:36 We're looking at a simple ordinance for one of our districts that needs a spark. 47:41 It's where the historically black area town is, and DOT ripped through their main street. 47:47 It's now an interstatement, a four-lane highway with a median. 47:50 And all the lots are smaller, 47:52 so we're looking at doing two gray ordinance for buildings like that there to get 47:55 some buildings back. 47:56 Interesting. 47:58 So, yeah, there's a lot of lessons to learn from everybody. 48:00 Yeah. 48:01 So what's next then for you besides the mayoral work? 48:05 Are you able to actually continue any kind of real estate work or development work 48:10 as your mayor? 48:12 Yes. 48:14 Well, my role diminishes. 48:18 So I still do software stuff about 32 hours a week. 48:23 And real estate, we're doing a $9 million condo project, like two blocks from here. 48:28 We are opening a liquor bar. 48:31 across the street in two weeks. 48:33 We're doing a prep kitchen and we'll cross the street over here and we're doing 48:37 plans for that right now. 48:38 But it's not me that's keeping the projects. 48:41 It's partners that are, you know, 48:44 we all kind of came up in the same time with history class and some of the first 48:48 projects. 48:49 So now the third or fourth projects are much easier. 48:51 Like we understand grief traps now. 48:52 We understand how to get problems. 48:54 We understand development orders more. 48:56 And so I don't think it's quite as burdensome as it should be, but we're still no projects. 49:02 It's just not me leaving. 49:02 My wife's running up on projects for me. 49:04 Oh, cool. 49:05 Cool. 49:05 All right. 49:06 Well, Alan, 49:07 if anybody wants to follow what you're doing or get in touch with you or ask you 49:11 questions, what's the best way for people to track you down? 49:15 Facebook. 49:15 I put a lot of stuff on Facebook and Instagram. 49:17 Just Alan Branch on Facebook, A-L-L-A-N. 49:20 And then my email address is my name, alanbranch at gmail.com. 49:23 That's easy enough. 49:24 You and me were lucky that way. 49:33 Well, there aren't too many Kevin Klinkenberg, so I'm lucky in that regard. 49:38 That's right. 49:39 I think all the others are in the Netherlands. 49:42 Alan, this is really, really great. 49:44 I appreciate the time for doing this. 49:46 I think this is an awesome example of, I mean, so many different things, but I especially love, you know, 49:52 the story of somebody who loves the place that they're in and really takes on the 49:56 work to try to improve it in any number of ways. 49:59 And it's funny how those paths lead you in so many directions. 50:03 I have to remind myself that meaningful work is not supposed to be easy. 50:07 Yeah, that's true. 50:09 That's right. 50:10 And eventually you'll have the scars to show it. 50:13 The hairline, my hairline's gone. 50:15 It's a very brown beard, very brown thick hair, not so much anymore. 50:18 That's right. 50:19 All right. 50:20 Well, thanks again. 50:20 I appreciate it. 50:21 And we'll all be interested to see how you're doing and look forward to your 50:26 re-election in about a year and a half. 50:27 So, all right. 50:29 See you. 51:07 Farewell, farewell, farewell
Community discussion