0:00 Welcome to The Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:16 [music] 0:47 Welcome back to The Messy City Podcast. 0:49 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:50 I have returning champion Aaron Lubeck with me here today. 0:54 The beauty of this is I could just sit back now and say, Aaron, go. 0:59 I know, you know, we've done this once or twice already, but I remembered we sat down at CNU and maybe Savannah and just kind of shot the shit for a while. 1:08 And it was no real agenda, but I remembered it being a great conversation. 1:11 I hope the people who listened to it felt the same, but there's always so many interesting things. 1:17 And I love this format because, you know, in the world of Twitter and Instagram and TikTok, our world is sort of shaved into a never ending series of 30 second events. 1:29 But the joy of podcasting is you kind of get long form depth, which all of us are craving. 1:34 But, you know, sometimes you can deal with some of these issues that we deal with. 1:39 Yeah, this is the format to, you know, make real progress and have some fun. 1:43 Yeah, sometimes it's like, you know, you get on social media to just see, you know, how much shit the monkeys are throwing at each other. 1:51 And there's kind of entertainment value in that, but it has its utility, but I think, you know, what you're So why don't you tell everybody about your various... 2:20 Yeah, so I'm a designer and a builder. 2:23 Started as a restoration contractor and did historic restoration work really the first 10 years of my career. 2:29 Started a company called Trinity Design Build here in Durham, North Carolina, I think in 2003. 2:34 Strangely been gone from that company now longer than I was at it. 2:37 They just celebrated, I think their, yeah, 23rd anniversary, which was really exciting to see something you started have that sort of longevity and you're thriving. 2:46 But I wrote a book about our work that was sort of about the intersection of historic preservation movements with the green building movement. 2:54 About 2010, those were sort of novel ideas. 2:56 Both of them have a little bit more gray on the beard now. 3:00 But it was just interesting because both movements have a lot in common with long-term sustainability, but also like no shortage of conflict points, right? 3:07 Like an old house is not a... 3:09 That's your energy house and the house has more charm and all those things. 3:13 Anyway, I wrote that book about our work and that kind of set me on a different trajectory where I taught at Duke for four years at the Nicholas School for the Environment. 3:21 Really loved that experience and that set me on a little A little bit a different career trajectory to do more writing advocacy policy work, both locally and state level. 3:32 And privately, we still do a lot of design work. 3:36 My work now is more designing homes for other builders, more than building, but still do dabble and build things now and again. 3:43 And now that my youngest is pushed off to college, I have more brain space to go do that again. 3:48 So I'm hoping to ramp up the building again here in the near future. 3:52 Yeah. 3:53 And you have a great Substack called On Housing. 3:56 Also, you know, have Southern Urbanism that you do a lot of work with. 4:01 Yeah. 4:01 So it gives you a chance to do longer form stuff. 4:04 It does. 4:05 I've been, I hope I get into it today. 4:07 I know your work, you've been kind of at long-form journalism more than most people, and I think people are kind of getting into it and see the value of it. 4:15 I really could not be more bearish on traditional media at all and mostly bearish on social media for the reasons you mentioned before. 4:26 It's usually just shallow, and you can actually find truths sometimes there, but you can't change anybody's mind. 4:33 Like, nobody changed their mind ever on Facebook for anything, and they won't, so it's not good for that. 4:38 But I think as local journalism, the writings on the wall is like days are numbered and some are walking wounded and zombie companies. 4:47 What it's really going to be replaced by is a Substack revolution. 4:51 And that's, for the most part, people who are kind of in the Tom Sawyer economy doing it for the civic good of it or because they want to or they want to share their expertise. 5:02 But what's the biggest differentiator that nobody's talking about that exists on Substack and not in like your daily papers or your activist weeklies, it's first-person storytelling. 5:12 So you're not taking a journalist with 20 years experience or more likely, you know, a 25 year old a few years out of J school who might be really smart and might be really dedicated, but really doesn't know anything about the specific subject they're talking about 5:26 because they're not a restaurateur or they're not a musician or they're not a builder. 5:30 And so what we see on Substack are the people who are actually doing it. 5:34 And it's still messy. 5:35 There's still plenty of noise out there. 5:38 But there's some really good Substacks out there and people who are telling it not from an outside observer perspective, which can't have benefits, but from an insider's perspective. 5:47 This is what happened. 5:48 This is what I saw. 5:49 And it's actually really good content. 5:51 And I think we're going to see more of that. 5:53 I think we're on the tip of the iceberg of that revolution. 5:55 Yeah, yeah, I agree. 5:56 And, you know, it's a great way for people to monetize some things as well if you, you know, want to go that route. 6:02 I have found some incredible stuff on there just to your point. 6:06 There's a guy who has a, who's an affordable housing developer who writes, And it's really cool because he actually will break down the financials of his projects and 6:35 And you just don't really see much of that on other forums. 6:38 You never see it. 6:39 So is that Marlowe, by chance? 6:42 Stanfield, is that right? 6:44 You know the reference? 6:45 No. 6:46 That was the drug kingpin in the last three years of The Wire on HBO. 6:50 Oh, God. 6:51 There you go. 6:52 That's great. 6:53 At one time, I engaged with him, totally anonymous account. 6:56 I have no idea who he is, but clearly very active and very successful in affordable housing. 7:00 And I think I engaged with him to like, you know, I think we came up with a top 10 or 20 list of everything I know in real estate I learned from watching The Wire. 7:10 But he's a great writer and you're right. 7:13 I mean, that's actually the perfect example. 7:17 There is an assumption that when traditional journalism was well-funded, which was 30 years ago, the local paper in tiny, tiny little Durham had 325 people on staff. 7:30 Wow. 7:31 You know how many they have now? 7:33 Probably 20. 7:35 Zero. 7:36 Oh, they're even worse. 7:37 For a while, it had one. 7:40 But it's basically a shell paper. 7:41 So the editor there told me he had 325 people just 30 years ago. 7:46 Still, when they had that many people, there was, let's be honest, nobody was there to write the kind of detailed piece that Marlowe wrote because Marlowe's in the arena. 7:56 So it gets into this, you know, I know you just had Jeff Graham on one that you published. 8:01 His podcast, See You, and it's just super interesting, different, kind of wacky, kind of cerebral. 8:06 Jeff and Benz are so intelligent. 8:08 And they just, Jeff just interviewed Nassim Nicholas Talib, who's always sort of had some interesting things to say on urbanism and so forth. 8:16 But he wrote the book, Skin in the Game, which made me want to kind of re-go through my notes. 8:24 It's such an interesting thing for urbanism because the conventional wisdom is the people who are in the arena have to be out of policymaking. 8:31 And certainly Jane Jacobs kind of talked about this divide between commerce culture or commercial culture or guardian culture. 8:37 But there's... 8:38 I can kind of make the case for both arguments, but I do think... 9:07 Just having, you know, clearly the proof is that people inside the arena have knowledge that people outside just don't. 9:14 And it's showing up in Substack that's very, very new and it's going to be the way forward. 9:19 Well, and I think we have ample evidence at this point that the idea that you can have this kind of disconnected technical class or political class that doesn't have a vesting in some fashion is a complete myth. 9:32 I mean, people aren't wired that way. 9:35 We're interested in many things. 9:36 We have our hands on a lot of things. 9:38 You might go into politics and think that you're above the concern for everything else. 9:43 You're going to end up in the middle of it some way. 9:46 Either by intention or by error or whatever. 9:49 Yeah, and I think it's the people who pretend that they are Totally neutral and without motivation that are actually the most nefarious and villainous. 10:02 We see this in all of our towns. 10:03 It's the people who tattoo on their forehead how much they care about affordability are the ones undermining affordability the most. 10:10 I don't know if you've read it, but it's kind of relevant to the talk we were going to do and also of expertise and of Euclid. 10:17 Have you ever read Woodrow Wilson's The Science of Administration? 10:21 I have not. 10:22 I've seen reference to it. 10:23 I've never read it. 10:24 And it was written when he was very young and it sort of set the stage for his trajectory because I think it was in the 18, it's either 1887 or 1898, but long before he was president. 10:34 And he was sort of workshopping, you know, in fairness, I mean, cities were urbanizing, you know, industrial revolution, things were undeniably chaotic and there was sort of a desire to, you know, city beautiful, clean things up. 10:47 How do you, how do you manage this chaotic world? 10:49 But his thesis was pretty simply you go hire some guys from Yale and let them run your life. 10:58 Right, exactly. 10:59 That's what he said. 10:59 It was the birth really of this sort of technocratic elite. 11:01 Technocratic, which is really the baby of the progressive movement that he was so integral to. 11:06 This was the first 20 years of the last century, but really kind of accelerated during the Wilsonian administration. 11:13 It was really the first and maybe only sort of ivory tower administration in American history. 11:18 Yeah, right. 11:20 But yeah, he just thought you'd get smart people in a room and then the fatal flaw of that, because I think it's not inherently bad to get smart people in a room, right? 11:28 You have to be able to execute. 11:29 But most importantly, he presumed they would be neutral. 11:34 You could just hire people who were above the fray of politics and were above the fray of throwing knives and fighting at the bar, and they would just be good and make decisions in the interest of the people. 11:45 And I think that was overwhelmingly proven to be bullshit very quickly. 11:50 Kind of the only place where that belief still exists is often in the governing of cities, specifically planning, but I think it's been universally dismissed mid-century, last century, as a total failure. 12:04 Yeah, and yet we still continue on with the myth, at least in practice. 12:09 So that's actually a great tie-in to the piece that you wrote. 12:15 So your most recent piece on your blog, which was also, I guess, We posted on Strong Towns, was called Revisiting Euclid v. Ambler at 100. 12:27 And, you know, I read through this and I have to say, it was so interesting. 12:32 There was some great material in there that I had never discovered. 12:35 Yeah. 12:49 I wonder if you could talk a little bit about, you know, we talked about Euclid v. Amler before. 12:55 Euclid Amler was the place, the Supreme Court case that essentially established the local government's rights to do zoning. 13:02 Why don't you talk a little bit about the background of what 13:20 What was going on in America at that time that we had this case come before the Supreme Court? 13:28 And what specifically was the matter? 13:31 Yeah, so America was booming, particularly Rust Belt City. 13:34 Well, they weren't rusty yet, but the Great Lakes Cities. 13:38 This was the 1920s, mid-1920s, and a suburb of Cleveland, which was Euclid, Ohio, The Messy City. 14:01 And prededicate undeveloped land as residential only. 14:06 And at the time, whether it was the motivation or just sort of basic calculations, residential land was worth about a quarter of what commercial land was and ultimately wasn't what the development company bought it for or wanted to use it for. 14:17 So they litigated and said that that was unconstitutional. 14:21 I like to think of it in, you know, if we put ourselves at 1920s, And again, we're still at the edge of like the Industrial Revolution wasn't that old. 14:41 You know, people always like to use the kind of lazy argument, like, well, what if it's a nuclear factory? 14:46 Or what if it's like, you know, an iron smelter or whatever? 14:50 And clearly, like, one, there's not that many of them. 14:52 And two, those usually don't place themselves in the middle of a residential neighborhood anyway, because it doesn't make sense. 14:58 So, you know, American history, you bought land and you could do a farm or you could build some duplexes or you could build a church or a bar and there was no institution there to prevent you from doing that and largely things grew well. 15:13 And people created wealth and it wasn't either a environmental hazard or a social nuisance to do so. 15:19 So for a city, kind of bureaucrats, which were a very new thing, to say, no, you can't do that here. 15:25 We'd like you to do something totally different was sort of mind boggling. 15:29 And so Ambler sued. 15:31 They won in lower court cases. 15:34 And somebody on Twitter actually earlier today, Tim, said, I'm probably getting the pronunciation of that wrong, but he actually decided the lower court case was really kind of fire breathing. 15:48 Relative to the Euclid case, no dissent was filed, which is kind of odd for a Supreme Court case. 15:53 So the city won, essentially justifying them and everybody at the last hundred years' ability to just pre-zone land without any rationale or any deference to the owner. 16:05 But before that, it was Judge Westenhaver struck down the ordinance in 1924 and said that 16:15 He said zoning was illegal. 16:16 The purpose was to put all undeveloped property in a straitjacket. 16:20 That's for the American people in a straitjacket, which I thought was a great analogy. 16:24 And further, critically, identified the primary purpose of any such effort to pre-zone land would be segregation. 16:32 It's just inherently you're going to use it for that. 16:35 And Newton Baker, the last point I'll make on this so we can get into it, Newton Baker was the lawyer for Ambler in this, wrote some just beautiful sort of scathing critiques of how depressive zoning would be towards people, but also showed that... 16:58 As cities were deferential to their public boards, public boards would pull every trick in the book to prevent unwanted, undesirable people from their community. 17:08 Here's a trivia question for you. 17:10 So in 1920s Cleveland, what were the undesirables of the day that they were trying to minimize in their community? 17:20 1920s Cleveland, Irish or Jews, maybe? 17:26 Jews and Catholics. 17:27 Yeah, Jews and Catholics. 17:28 The way I've heard it before is more Italian than Irish, but Jews and Catholics. 17:32 So it often presumed to be race-based. 17:34 In this particular case, it was that. 17:37 And he goes into an example where literally a community board decided to turn down an orphanage, which in the modern day I would think of like you're above nobody who's going to turn down an orphanage. 17:50 This should sail through any rezoning easily like you're doing good work here. 17:54 And a community board turned it down because it was a Jewish group that still exists today, actually, in Cleveland. 18:00 But the rationale on record is they thought that the neighborhood would be worsened by Jewish children running around. 18:08 And so Baker was really prescient to point out these boards will descend into the worst of the worst of humanity and will inherently discriminate based upon the worst prejudices that are many of which are sort of like unpercolated or under 18:24 the skin but not talked about in the 1920s. 18:27 And I think he was incredibly right. 18:28 I mean, I think we see this in the modern day too, and it's still cloaked in a whole series of sort of subversive language. 18:36 But it was just amazing to see how the dissenters in this case predicted with remarkable accuracy how harmful the case would be towards the country moving forward. 18:48 Yeah, it reminds me a little bit of the conversation we were having with Vince and Jeff Graham about the Wilson v. Shaw decision, which was about the same era. 18:56 But also, you know, the presidential opinions and dissents leading up to Wilson v. 19:03 Shaw for 150 years were essentially that if the federal government got involved in infrastructure financing and provision, it would just eventually set the states and the cities all against each other in a terrible race to the bottom. 19:16 Which is true. 19:17 And which has happened. 19:18 And you get, you know, you get a lot of unproductive infrastructure as a result. 19:23 And, you know, because I'm, you're asking the many to pay for something that few will benefit from. 19:31 Concentrated benefits, dispersed costs. 19:34 And you kind of see that actually in Sutherland's rationale for the, actually I came from Sutherland or the lawyer for the, You have to build some houses instead of a factory. 19:42 That's not... 19:55 That's not worthy of court stepping in. 19:57 Is that really like unconstitutional? 19:59 It's just some houses. 20:00 People need houses. 20:01 So there's always this language of sort of incrementalism. 20:04 Even if it's wrong, it's so small, it doesn't matter. 20:06 And therefore, you shouldn't object to this. 20:09 And then it's creeping. 20:11 I mean, we've all seen it in our lives. 20:14 But that's the common language. 20:16 If people doing bad are either saying they're not doing bad or it's so minor, you should ignore it. 20:21 Yeah, I love some of the other quotes and work you have here from the attorney from Baker, who is the attorney for Ambler Realty. 20:29 And this is just so deeply connected to what we were talking about. 20:33 And it's fascinating to me here, too, because this is very, very new or young in the history of zoning ordinances. 20:42 I think there were still, at that time, precious few places that had really adopted any kind of a zoning ordinance. 20:48 And if we compared those zoning ordinance of that era to what we see today, we wouldn't even recognize them because they were so much smaller and simpler. 20:56 But still, there were not many. 20:58 And I love this paragraph that you quoted. 21:00 He said, the more experience I have with zoning audiences, the more satisfied I am that the whole theory is wrong. 21:06 Nobody knows enough or can know enough to zone a city. 21:09 As a matter of fact, cities do not grow and will not grow according to any plan, no matter how wise. 21:15 Their growth is a necessary resultant of economic forces and economic accidents, which nobody can foresee, which feels like could be the prelude to my website, The Messy City. 21:26 I love that. 21:27 That's also the prelude to Mike Tyson's great quote is everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth, right? 21:33 That's right. 21:34 And so we still see this today and certainly there's a narrow band of planner that I'm critical of. 21:41 I mean, so many of the most brilliant people I've met are land planners and are dedicated servants and I don't mean to broad brush that class in any way. 21:55 I totally forgot what I was going to say. 21:57 Oh, the idea that people can predict things fully and that things go exactly to plan and that plans will be carried out and things don't change, the economy doesn't change and jobs don't go away and the Yeah. 22:10 Yeah. 22:29 There's enthusiasm for new ideas to make things better. 22:33 And certainly at the margins, people could, I mean, the idea of selling happiness and city building as a science, it was pretty easy to sell because everything else had a doohickey that made your life better. 22:47 So it was great to see people who were critical of it that knew that, you know, the real world's messy and you can't predict this. 22:53 And this is actually going to cause a lot of harm by pretending that you can predict them because you can't. 23:00 Yeah. 23:01 There's this other great quote, which I can't resist, where he talks about, we have outgrown the civilization established by the Constitution and have surrendered private ownership of property into sort of communistic ownership and control. 23:16 That is a hell of a shot across the bow. 23:19 In an era, again, where actual Marxist-Leninist communism was on the rise worldwide in a very serious way, and he kind of tied those two together. 23:34 And so, you know, I know we can all get hyperbolic with the language and people might think that's hyperbolic today, but this was a real thing that was happening at that time. 23:43 There's an element of that happening again today, which we can pass on for the moment. 23:48 But I think it's just, it's fascinating how he tied those together. 23:55 And, you know, one of the things that I'm always mindful of is that this era, what we call the progressive era, Late 19th or early 20th century seems so far away now because there's really almost nobody alive who was even born in that era. 24:14 And yet, There was probably, you know, not an era where we more fundamentally transformed how the United States anyway operates as a country than that era. 24:27 And there's such a dramatic difference from how we operated for the first 150 years than what we changed with a lot of the Progressive Era reforms and especially the Wilsonian reforms when he was president. 24:41 And so there's so much today that we kind of take for granted, like this is just the way it is. 24:45 But the reality is a lot of this is about 100 years old. 24:48 And I'm not sure any of it was really meant to be an experiment that lasted this long. 24:55 I think that's right. 24:56 Yeah, I mean, I kind of get into it. 24:57 It's funny when I have a thesis that often gets some really interesting pushback on social media. 25:02 If I list off what, in my view, are the three worst Supreme Court decisions ever, you've got Plessy versus Ferguson. 25:11 Dred Scott will start there. 25:13 Black people are three-fifths of a person. 25:16 Bad decision. 25:17 Plessy versus Ferguson in 1898 said separate is fine as long as it's equal. 25:23 So it's like, oh no, black people can have schools too as long as they're similar, then there's nothing wrong with segregation. 25:29 And then Euclid. 25:30 And what's remarkable about that is Dred Scott effectively got overturned in seven years as the Civil War ended and the Emancipation Proclamation set all that motion. 25:40 Plessy lasted about 57, the numbers written in the article. 25:44 I can't remember what they are. 25:45 Brown versus Board of Education essentially said separate is inherently unequal and ended that. 25:50 But Euclid's on to its 100th year. 25:52 And it is interesting because I think Euclid is less clear how it's un-American. 25:58 It's a messier and it's sort of stuck in this language of it's not that big a deal. 26:03 You can, you know, cities should be deferential. 26:05 The courts should not step in because they should be deferential to their local governments and local governments can make Bad decisions that the idea, you know, doing something dumb is not inherently unconstitutional, basically. 26:18 Like there's a difference between dumb ideas and unconstitutional ideas. 26:22 And, you know, the argument was, and this is still very much dry. 26:26 And what we have Supreme Court today is that there's a deference to the legislators. 26:32 Like there's a very high standard or high bar to rule something unconstitutional. 26:37 And there's all sorts of writing that says there should be a lower bar. 26:40 I mean, it's pretty clear when Things are unconstitutional. 26:43 And courts should be throwing laws out a hell of a lot more often than they do. 26:48 And certainly they should have thrown out Euclid as, you know, Westover or whatever it was did before it got to the Supreme Court. 26:55 We've kind of gotten away from that. 26:56 But courts were sort of the last line of defense for keeping the basic American values of the Constitution and Which, at the end of the day, the most unique thing about the American experiment, particularly the first 150 years of it, was that concept of private property. 27:13 We take it a little bit for granted now, we think like, you know, you own a car, you own a guitar, you own a house, That's not that big a deal. 27:34 And you could essentially create the life for your family and collaboratively with your community without an overlord was unheard of in human history. 27:45 And that's really what the Euclid decision was about. 27:48 It was the most substantial whittling away of those principles in the history of the country. 27:53 Yeah, and for anybody who thinks that might sound even a little bit nutty, just try to build an outbuilding or a new garage or a new accessory building on your own property and see what all you have to go through in about 90% of cities 28:08 in the country and just how difficult that is to do simple things and what you run up against from a regulatory and a process standpoint. 28:17 Even in places that you might think that are very light on government interference, you'll be shocked at how strict the zoning ordinance is and how difficult it is to implement a lot of really basic change or something that you wish to do with your own property. 28:35 So, Aaron, one of the things I think we have to talk about when we talk about this, you know, because whenever there's a criticism of Euclid and the idea that maybe it should be overturned, people think, oh my God, you know, what does that even mean? 28:50 There's like, you know, are there no rules? 28:52 There's nothing for how cities would be built? 28:55 You know, what do you talk about or how do you answer people when you talk about what is a different kind of regulatory apparatus look like for cities? 29:04 Yeah, it's a great question. 29:06 And I know we're going to get into that question specifically at Southern Urbanism this fall. 29:12 I believe the Euclid case actually was passed down in October or November of 1926. 29:17 And so we're going to review it. 29:19 I repeat, we just published a five-part series on American land use at 250, which you can see at southernurbanism.org. 29:26 I'm blessed to work with incredible writers across the spectrum from different walks of life that Jaime Azurienta curated that. 29:33 You should have him on if you haven't already. 29:35 Anyway, one of the things, we're going to repeat that format to discuss what Euclid means and what do we do and how different angles at it to try to add some depth to the conversation. 29:47 Certainly there's a gradient of how It could be overturned and most likely it's going to be a slow whittling away of the sort of little technocratic rights that bureaucrats have to take personal property rights away. 30:03 And I think we're already seeing that through local and state zoning reform. 30:06 But there might not be a big bang event that overturns Euclid. 30:10 I do know the public interests legal groups, the two that are most well-known in this space are Institute for Justice and the Pacific Legal Foundation. 30:20 Both have an intense interest in this. 30:23 A guy to have on, and we'll probably... 30:25 Yeah. 30:25 Yeah. 30:26 Yeah. 30:26 Yeah. 30:26 Yeah. 30:50 So I think it'll go through groups like that. 30:53 As for what it would look like, my dream, which I'm sure is detached from reality, is somehow a court justifying that if your city was chartered before the Euclid case, then it was a taking. 31:08 This was just fundamentally un-American and you couldn't come in. 31:14 Yeah. 31:29 That said it had a zoning code and you bought into it. 31:32 Functionally, this might actually work really well for us urbanists because generally the cities chartered before 1926 are the old cities that it's the Kansas cities and Durham's and sort of are carving off. 31:45 The second and third ring suburbs to be say, hey, those are zoned, that's fine. 31:50 And I think it would allow for a bifurcation between urbanist and suburbanist lifestyles and philosophies and mindsets, which is fine. 31:59 We can both sit here in pejorative suburbs as much as we want while recognizing that most of America lives in the suburbs and they raise perfectly happy kids and they seem to be fine and it's just a choice. 32:09 It's not one I want, but that doesn't mean it's bad. 32:14 And so that would allow suburbs to be suburbs built to climax condition, never changing, separated uses, you know, big lawns, whatever. 32:23 And it would allow cities to get on with being cities that could be dynamic and never changing and kind of have that the New York vibe that has been New York since its beginning. 32:31 It's always under construction. 32:33 Because there's actually a lot of us that gravitates towards that and a lot of us that don't and would allow it to be those things. 32:38 It's interesting how it would work in sort of residential neighborhoods. 32:42 I think the easy answer, which I acknowledge is super messy, is it gets replaced with private covenants. 32:50 Retroactively doing those, messy. 32:54 Mm-hmm. 32:54 But I think we should have been doing that all along. 32:56 Yeah. 33:23 Look, in these districts, you can't build bigger than three stories. 33:27 And, you know, outside of that, knock yourself out. 33:30 Well, and worth noting, we've had a live running counter experiment for many, many years with Houston, Texas. 33:37 You know, it's actually the only city that's had public referendums on adopting zoning. 33:42 And it's been rejected multiple times. 33:45 And it doesn't have zoning, but it does have the ability, you know, a lot of neighborhoods do have those restrictive covenants. 33:51 And then city staff manages a lot of those covenants in the same way they might manage a land use document otherwise. 33:59 So, I mean, there is a counterexample out there of how that can work. 34:02 And interestingly enough, while Houston, maybe you love it, maybe you hate it, maybe you think it's beautiful, maybe you don't, it has been the one big city in the country that has been able to accommodate massive population growth and not become expensive. 34:17 That's right. 34:18 And actually, while boosting incredible culture of food and art, coming from a baseline where it had very little of it, it's probably the most accepting city in the country of immigrants with huge Latin American populations and Vietnamese populations. 34:33 It is funny because you can... 34:38 Yeah, I know. 34:53 We'll be in Santa Fe and Taos this fall. 34:56 But at the end of them, we kind of have an open call for like, hey, where should we go in the future? 35:00 And I think for maybe once or twice, I shouted out like, I want to go to Houston and just study it. 35:04 I want to see everything that's awful and wonderful about it and make our own judgments. 35:08 I don't pretend that everything there is great. 35:11 But it's funny, like in that room, you just hear the oxygen go out of it going like, oh, come on, man. 35:18 Nobody wants to go see Houston. 35:20 Yeah. 35:22 Well, you know what? 35:22 There's a lot to learn. 35:23 So the results speak for themselves. 35:25 Yeah. 35:26 So, yeah, anyway, I think it's important to have that. 35:28 I mean, it'll be interesting to see your series this fall on how we talk about that because I think it's hard for people to understand what a post is. 35:39 Zoning world might look like and how it could actually live in practice and how you could still accomplish goals that are of your concern now, but allow cities to change more dynamically. 35:54 Yeah, and I think the other thing we left out there, which I'm sure you're cerebral enough to be aware of, is like the form code approach, which is very much wrapped into new urbanism. 36:02 Most downtowns have gone through something like this already. 36:06 A lot of us have frustrations that form codes still tend to be Pretty complex and detailed. 36:13 There's not a ton of examples of people coming out with just a freaking simple form code. 36:18 But in principle, they should be like, this is the form, these are the rules for whatever the context is. 36:23 Build whatever you want. 36:24 You want to build a townhome or a school or a bar or Like whatever, but knock yourself out. 36:29 Within this forum, it's fine. 36:31 So I think that's another one. 36:32 It's easier to pull off in a downtown than an already existing residential district, but that in principle is a good precedent. 36:40 And so, yeah, there's already precedent. 36:42 I do think rather than a bang, there's no rules, there's no zoning, it'll be a slow whittling away and ultimately, eventually, somebody will come up with some ways to simplify zoning. 36:55 All the efforts I've seen in the last 10 years promise to do that and actually do the opposite. 37:00 And it's a funny thing because, you know, we all love to take shots at kind of overzealous staff and bureaucracies as we work through this. 37:09 But I think it's also, if you take a step back, it's fair to say that, you know, the staff in most cases did not really. 37:15 And really a lot of the mess that we have with zoning today, you can pin on politicians, activist groups, and oftentimes people reacting to the last project that everybody hated. 37:31 So there's some truth to that. 37:33 And I would add, I think planning consultants play a huge role in this. 37:39 There's an assumption that your local planners write your zoning codes. 37:42 And in nearly all the cases I've seen, the local staff hires an applicant. 37:46 It's sort of a traveling salesman briefcase model. 38:02 Some do it well, some don't do it, but it's not localized at all. 38:05 And it's remarkable looking at like parking mandates. 38:08 It's remarkable for a country that has however many thousands of municipalities. 38:14 We all ended up with like parking mandates that are largely similar through this phenomenon. 38:19 So I think so much of it comes from the consultants who do just a So bad, suburbanist, copy-paste job. 38:28 I think to that note, a lot of these places would probably be better off if their local planners wrote the damn thing. 38:34 At least they have the local knowledge. 38:35 They know the specifics of what didn't work. 38:37 They care. 38:38 It's that whole idea of being vested. 38:40 Somebody who comes from Albuquerque to Kansas City is just not going to care as much as the planner's been there for 20 years and really wants to see their city grow. 38:49 So I think that'll be part of it as well. 38:51 And then the only thing I'd push back there too, And I'm like, yeah. 39:14 So I kind of get that, but there's not a politician in America who came up with three parking spaces per bowling alley. 39:22 That's on you guys. 39:24 That one's you. 39:25 So I think it's more in staff than we might think. 39:28 Yeah. 39:30 Yeah, I mean, I guess I'm thinking about it more in the world of like, you know, affordable housing mandates and stuff like that, which really comes from the world of like the housing advocacy world and politics, which is we've got to take. 39:45 It's also an oxymoron, by the way. 39:46 Oh, I know. 40:08 I know. 40:09 Yeah, some of the language we come up with, kind of crazy. 40:12 So I've seen a lot of stuff like that, and it was not really like the staff was not beating the drum to do those things. 40:17 No doubt about it. 40:18 Some staff is. 40:18 There's no question that actually I think that I would say more than half of the planning staff I've engaged with, if we talked about that specific issue, I would say they would be defenders of inclusionary zoning for similar reasons. 40:32 I see a lot of staff who believe that all planning is political. 40:36 It's supposed to be politicized, which I think is categorically inaccurate. 40:40 Right. 40:54 That's what it's supposed to be. 40:55 And if those stay in their lanes, things work better. 40:58 But I also know that, you know, bureaucrats and staffers and planners are human and want to do good creative things and that can be incongruent. 41:07 The role of being technical staff, which can be boring, can be less soul-satisfying. 41:13 So people want to be creative with it. 41:15 I think ultimately, same goes back to Euclid. 41:18 This is all an effort to depoliticize housing because when it's politicized, we do dumb stuff. 41:24 And I don't know if it would be linked to an overturning of Euclid, but another series, actually, you'd be great to participate in this for Southern Urbanism. 41:33 I do think... 41:35 The profession of planning is going to be reconstructed. 41:39 And I think where it is right now is not what it's going to look like in five years and what it could look like and how it gets redone and how it could be rebuilt to be productive and helpful, but also Once you've written your 60th staff report on the height of a fence for 41:54 a project. 42:05 Yeah. 42:22 We'll rebirth it in the Olmsteadian tradition of this is actually a profession that was rooted in landscape architecture, not sociology reports, not surveys, not community engagement. 42:36 It's in the geometries of And in that sense, if you draw a hard line between the public realm and the private realm, and then those of us who are fixing not great triplexes like me and you, we're on that side of the line and the people who need to make our parks, 42:51 streets and utilities So I think if it can be rebuilt to just make our public realm amazing, we'd go back to what the profession was started as when Olmstead originated really in the early part of the 20th century. 43:16 Yeah, I've always thought there's a big difference between planning a design exercise primarily, which is a good thing and a very necessary thing, and micromanaging every aspect of a person's property. 43:31 Which is nothing but frustrating for everybody involved. 43:36 And I think you're onto something too. 43:38 And I think when we talk about that five-year timeline, whatever it is, there's no question that as AI accelerates, it's going to change the entire nature of a lot of people in compliance-related jobs. 43:54 So planning departments, codes departments, et cetera. 43:56 I can't imagine a future where all of that isn't automated through AI. 44:00 A lot of it, yeah. 44:02 And then that frees people up. 44:04 You know, the work, like in my city, the work that we really need to do, which we never do with our planning department, is like actual, honest to God, like neighborhood scale planning. 44:14 Yeah. 44:14 You know, let's look at the next 20 or 30 years and let's plan out those public spaces and, you know, let's look at the big issues and try to figure out what the next generation is going to look and feel like. 44:26 And then let's make sure we're pointed in the direction of accomplishing that on a neighborhood by neighborhood basis. 44:32 To your point, you wrote about this or talked about it on a podcast recently, but the ability, like nobody teaches the skills of how to manage the thing. 44:40 Like we talk about, hey, we can design it. 44:42 A few people know how to build it. 44:45 But then we don't know how to manage it. 44:46 I just watched with my daughter, the Pruitt-Igo myth, before she went off to college. 44:52 But that was the exact same problem with so many public projects. 44:56 You can design it, you can build it, but nobody ever, like it's all about the ribbon cutting and anything that happens after is an afterthought. 45:04 And if nobody's there to manage it, it's going to go to shit. 45:07 It's just going to. 45:08 And so, yeah, there's, I mean, there's a bigger need for that rebirthing because North Carolina is somewhat unique because it has a flagship planning school that's ranked really highly and generally nobody comes out of there knowing how to draw. 45:23 We sort of over-programmed that manager, sociological, community engagement, policy, research world while totally deprioritizing or dismissing the drawing world. 45:36 So people really don't have the skills to spatially think about, hey, in this neighborhood, this commercial district, how could we solve the parking? 45:43 What's the tree plan? 45:44 How would we deal with these power lines? 45:46 There's no technical ability to execute. 45:48 So one, it gets abandoned, but two, even when you can get through, like it takes years to do the reports and the policy and the advocacy and the politics to get to the point where you can finally hire somebody to do the drawing. 46:00 And at that point, it's just a process issue where you can't get anything done. 46:04 And you spend 10 years before you do a drawing that me and you could probably do over a lunch. 46:09 Like it's just, it's just ass backwards. 46:11 And so, but getting kids to draw again and spending, maybe it's an extra year in planning school, But this is a landscape architecture profession. 46:21 And it's a hill I'll die on. 46:24 Yeah, it's funny because the conversation here kind of ties together. 46:29 If I had a wish list for what a future regulatory apparatus might look like, it would be a much more like a pre-Euclid regulatory apparatus for building combined with our modern understanding of place management, 46:44 which has really evolved over the last probably 40 or 50 years and in a lot of places is incredibly effective. 46:50 Yeah. 46:51 Yeah, there's, I mean, Andres has talked about this really in the new urbanism because, again, I spent most of my career doing historic restoration, historic neighborhoods. 46:59 I live in a historic neighborhood. 47:01 There is no HOA. 47:03 Everybody seems to get along. 47:04 We have a nice park and nice streets. 47:06 In fairness, like our yards are like slightly more unkempt than, you know, ION or something. 47:13 But he says, and I subscribe to this, in the modern world, people expect modernization. 47:18 Right. 47:33 And so that would kind of subscribe to what you said. 47:39 Let's build in the old methods physically, even a lot of the software of how the amenities are programmed, but how it's managed has sort of new age financial needs and realities, but also expectations. 47:53 And certainly we should know how to manage a park better than we did a hundred years ago. 47:57 I'm not sure if we do or not, but Sometimes yes, sometimes no. 48:02 So I want to take a little diversion. 48:04 We've talked before about building codes and building code reform. 48:07 It just occurred to me in our opener when we were talking, one of the things I don't think we've ever talked about, that I imagine you have a lot of insight into our energy codes. 48:16 And this is a topic of interest of mine because... 48:21 My city is the only city in like a four-state area that adopted the 2021 IECCC code, which is an absolute train wreck of a code and has almost single-handedly pushed people out of our jurisdiction into neighboring jurisdictions who don't want to deal with it. 48:42 And as I had, you know, it's funny because it's been a few years, more than a few years now since I've had to, you know, stamp a drawing as an architect. 48:51 And when I was a younger architect, I was really into understanding the codes and doing all that work. 48:57 And I felt pretty knowledgeable about it, but I've been out of the loop for a little while. 49:01 So I started to dive deeper again and look at the IECCC, which did not even exist when I started designing buildings in the 90s. 49:12 And it's pretty remarkable how this code has evolved and become such a fixture in communities all over. 49:21 And yet it is really difficult. 49:24 It's extraordinarily difficult to deal with. 49:26 I imagine you must have had to deal with it in renovation scenarios earlier. 49:30 In addition to new construction? 49:31 It's a good question. 49:33 Partially because in restoration stuff, you're usually exempt depending on how much you're renovating. 49:40 You have some relief there. 49:42 And some of that was a long time ago, so I can't remember it. 49:46 Doing new construction, really the person to have on it is my design partner, Jen Truman, who runs CityBuilder and is the primary host for Yimbytown and Raleigh this fall. 49:57 So she'd be a great interview in the next month or two just to talk about that. 50:01 But nobody knows the building code better than her with possible exception of Derek Kronberg. 50:07 But she knows the 2021 and 2024 projects 50:13 I know our stock plans, we're starting to design eight inch walls, accounting for, it's two by six framing, but you're going to have to generally wrap the entire thing with continuous insulation. 50:27 There's There's long debates in southern states, like North Carolina, where there's a fight between the code councils, which are generally programmed with architects, and the architects usually specialize in $3 million homes, 50:42 so cost is not how much it costs, Michael, $10 million. 50:47 And the HBA who builds across the spectrum but is always fighting to make sure that building costs stay low. 50:55 And there was these fights of like, oh, the code improvements only add $3,000 to the home. 50:59 And HBA is saying like, no, it's $25,000. 51:02 And I'm not smart enough to really know which is right. 51:06 But it's more wood, it's more insulation, it's more details. 51:09 The continuous insulation is a bit of a pain in the ass to do. 51:12 It's specialist, you know, subs or specialty materials to do it well. 51:18 And there's, I mean, the main argument from people who do this, particularly in the affordable world, it's really, we're getting to the point of marginal benefit. 51:29 Like these houses complying with the, you know, 2000, whatever, 2012 code or whatever it was, 51:38 Are really not inefficient. 51:41 If you're in a decent sized house, you're paying $50 a month for all your utilities. 51:45 How much more are you going to squeeze out of the damn thing? 51:48 So I get it. 51:49 And I do think it's a challenge. 51:52 It's also interesting how many of these rules... 51:56 If the old homes are subject to them, make them non-viable before their time. 52:01 I saw that a little bit with historic restoration. 52:03 The EPA's rules for dealing with lead paint were like really strict in the later part of my historic history. 52:10 Yeah. 52:38 All these, you know, for those of us who really have a fascination with affordability and serving down market, something that adds five, 10, 20 grand at the cost of a house is objectionable. 52:49 Yeah, well, I mean, it's like anything. 52:50 There's never any clear-cut choices, no matter what somebody might think. 52:55 Everything's a trade-off. 52:57 And so there's the technical aspect, certainly of the energy codes, which, you know, takes some time to really dig into. 53:04 And it's always, you know, somebody listening might think, well, how can you possibly criticize energy efficiency? 53:09 That's good for everybody. 53:10 And it was true. 53:11 Of course, energy. 53:12 Energy efficiency is a good thing. 53:14 But, you know, there are cases where, you know, is the juice worth the squeeze on what you're requiring? 53:20 So there's a technical aspect. 53:22 There is a big picture aspect, which drives me a little crazy in that by far and away the most energy efficient buildings are existing older buildings. 53:31 And like a run-of-the-mill new construction house from 1995 is still vastly more energy efficient than a building built in 1915. 53:40 And so, but we direct all of our energy at the new building, which China is bizarre. 53:47 Yeah. 53:48 And then there's the third aspect, which our friend Steve Muzan's talked a lot about, which is just, you know, the breathability of buildings and, you know, sort of the concept of the original green, which is that, you know, 54:00 we used to design especially houses in such a manner that they were comfortable in all sorts of climatic conditions and still pretty energy efficient. 54:10 Obviously, before we had air conditioning and the technology we have today, but there's also a real trade-off that comes with making buildings so tight that you can end up with the sick building syndrome problem. 54:26 Yeah, well, it's funny because I've got a 1904 house that I live in and then built a 2020 house in the back where I work from. 54:33 And so I've got a little bit of both. 54:35 My favorite thing because they're both, well, the new one has a spray foamed rafters. 54:40 And then my old house has basically, you know, no insulation on the rafters. 54:44 So whenever there's snow on it, you can see the opposite part melts first from the two technologies, 54:51 even though they kind of look 54:51 the same. 54:53 Yeah, you know, either work. 54:55 I think it's really, like you say, it's trade-offs and like the idea that our historic homes should only have $30 a month in utilities or be held to the same standards misses all of the other benefits of having a home that's historic and is loved and is part of 55:09 a community and all of these things. 55:11 And so it's my quote that I kind of live by, I picked up at a Front Porch Republic conference a few years ago, is that the modern world destroys all that cannot be quantified. 55:23 So these energy codes and so much of the pursuit of perfection through zoning 55:32 or progressivism or policy or whatever assumes everything is a data point and it's quantifiable. 55:37 And this was sort of Wilsonian's flaw. 55:41 He's just like, oh, happiness is a problem. 55:43 People aren't happy. 55:44 We'll just give us the data and we'll get some guys from Yale and we'll figure out the solution. 55:49 It's a science, right? 55:50 And, you know, there are other things that matter about a historic home or building an affordable home or building a home in a community or proximity to work. 55:58 So it'll be interesting. 55:59 Again, Jen can talk about it much more coherently than I can. 56:02 She can talk about the fights to minimize it. 56:06 And I'm always sort of fascinated because North Carolina just split their building code into a commercial and residential code, largely because the commercial code had, I think legislature actually just threw a couple of the architects off of it 56:18 because they tended to be left-leaning and advocating for more expensive building. 56:23 But the residential code should be much more pinpoint onto these issues because building a duplex is different than building a skyscraper. 56:33 And we should see better building code reform when that panel starts in the next year or two. 56:40 Yeah. 56:41 Well, I don't want to leave without talking about Mel Brooks because you wrote a great piece recently about Mel Brooks on his 100th birthday. 56:51 Is that right? 56:52 It was his 100th birthday, I think in July, something like that. 56:55 Yeah. 56:56 Yeah. 56:57 The King of Satire. 56:58 And I meant at the time to send you a note on that. 57:02 And then I think I just, it's crazy. 57:04 I think you did. 57:05 I think you did at that point. 57:07 But that resonated so much. 57:10 Of course, I've been an enormous Mel Brooks fan. 57:14 And Blazing Saddles, one of the best movies of all time. 57:19 So this is fun to talk about. 57:22 There's obviously a point to it as well, which is, it was really great. 57:27 There was a lot of fun in an era where you could just make fun of each other. 57:32 And you could have biting satire and everybody made fun of everybody. 57:36 And there was a bit of that, that like, it was just okay. 57:38 And you're just like, lighten up a little bit. 57:40 Let's all make fun of each other. 57:41 And it's fine. 57:42 Yeah. 57:43 And we've lost a little bit of that. 57:45 And I think in your piece, you had a plea for like, can we please have more satire? 57:49 Right. 57:50 Let's go ahead and like make fun of people because it's good. 57:53 And we see that sort of in local politics where everything is so uptight. 57:55 Like we're all could benefit from an onion paper, I think at some point, like just they don't have to be good, like something that makes us chuckle. 58:02 Like, you know, life is messy. 58:03 Life is fun. 58:04 Like life is ridiculous. 58:06 I do think that some... 58:09 I don't know why screwball comedies went away is a question I'm sort of fascinated with because they're easy to produce. 58:17 They're dumb. 58:18 They're dumb inherently. 58:21 You have no need to make this highbrow or smart. 58:23 It's dumb. 58:24 They're not expensive with high-tech stuff going on. 58:28 These should be made all the time because there's always something to make fun of. 58:31 I do think... 58:34 Trump kind of killed satire. 58:36 I mean, I don't know if it will come back, but you can't make fun of somebody who sort of is a caricature of himself. 58:41 I think I talked about that in the article. 58:43 So it's harder. 58:45 It's sort of a defense mechanism for him. 58:49 But it's It made satire, I think, harder to pull off anywhere, but we should be trying. 58:54 I mean, it's just fun and it's a comic relief to a messy world that can be really frustrating at times. 59:00 And Mel Brooks was the best at it. 59:01 And at the end of the day, I had forgotten this for a guy who's seen Blazing Saddles 20 times, that it was really a story about corrupt development. 59:11 Yeah, exactly. 59:13 This is perfect. 59:15 That's right. 59:16 And the people fighting back, right? 59:18 And the good sheriff holding the good fight. 59:20 That's right. 59:21 That's right. 59:22 Cleavon Little, you know, his premier role before he died too young. 59:27 I can't name a single other thing that he was in, but I mean, he was so great in that that it was like, I have to go pull up his old catalog. 59:35 I hope he was entertaining his other films as well. 59:38 I mean, it's a crazy thing that a movie that's that old that I still quote all the time, you know, just random circumstances. 59:45 But yeah, there's a lot to, you know, everybody, wish everybody could just lighten up a little bit and take a joke and give a joke. 59:52 Yeah. 59:53 You know, why not? 59:54 I love it when people, you know, throw something at me. 59:57 That's funny. 59:58 And it was a lot more enjoyable when we could kind of give each other crap. 60:02 I feel like there's a way. 60:03 I printed it for one CNU, some dark or some blue trucker hats that said, make planning fun again. 60:13 Whether those have any validity or not, I do think as ridiculous as public meetings are, they might be the perfect platform for skit comedy and somebody to show up with a guitar. 60:24 The idea that... 60:28 But your 90-second talk over a rezoning or a zoning reform or whatever has any effect is just kind of ridiculous. 60:38 And frankly, you're probably more likely to have a lasting effect or at least be memorable. 60:42 There should be some burden on the public to be entertaining. 60:48 That's what it'll take to cut through the noise. 60:50 And again, it's one of the most obvious things to satirize because it's so ridiculous at face value. 60:58 It should be an arena that's ripe to remake the spirit of satire. 61:04 Well, I don't know about you, but I know anytime I go give public testimony, I'm always thinking about, is there a joke that I can lead with? 61:11 Oh, yeah. 61:12 And, you know, sometimes they land and sometimes they don't, but... 61:15 Well, I don't really do as much public testimony anymore, but just when giving a talk, I mean, less than a podcast, but just when giving a talk, I feel like if you're going to speak publicly and take any human's time, 61:27 whether it's 90 minutes or an hour, there's an obligation to entertain. 61:33 At least be memorable. 61:34 Otherwise, like... 61:35 What are we doing here? 61:37 You just want to be heard or you just want to listen to the sound of your own voice? 61:41 So I do think there should be sort of an expectation of time is valuable. 61:48 We're all on this rock for a limited amount of time. 61:52 Prepare and do some good. 61:54 Our friend Joe Minicozzi is really good at that aspect. 61:57 He is terrific about sort of comic timing within his presentations. 62:02 Every couple of minutes, there's a really good joke. 62:06 And that's a great format for people to learn from. 62:10 Aaron, thanks so much for doing this. 62:13 We hit an hour. 62:15 What is next for you and for all of your various endeavors? 62:19 Well, first off, I hope to be your Steve Martin on SNL and be the champion with the most visits. 62:25 I can come in one day with, I've been on The Messy City seven times. 62:28 There you go. 62:28 I have a trophy or something. 62:30 I'll build a trophy specifically for it in the back as long as I have the lead. 62:35 You know, what we're doing here locally, it's fun to get back into building. 62:39 Working with Jen Truman's been an absolute blessing. 62:41 Like her heart's just such in the right place. 62:42 And she reminds me of myself, 15 years younger. 62:45 Like she's got friends who are struggling for housing and she understands the pressures that are creating these stresses on young families. 62:53 And there's a policy side there and there's a media side and there's a training side, but there's also just the difficult work to design homes at the margins. 63:03 Vince Graham had the great quote of like, hey, I've been doing this 40 years and it has not gotten easier. 63:08 Like industries are supposed to get easier as they progress and this has gotten harder. 63:13 And so we're still, even though people are abandoning the pursuit of affordability because it's just... 63:17 Just like your people fight you every step of the way. 63:21 We're still there and working on that pursuit. 63:23 And I sort of love the debates of what you can do, what you can't do, what's difficult and helping clients that are trying to do good work, get that work done. 63:32 So that's been really fun. 63:34 Continuing the work with Southern Urbanism and the series and writing has been great. 63:39 Hopefully getting some beautiful things out of the ground. 63:43 Well, I look forward to seeing more, and I'm sure we'll catch up again soon. 63:49 There's still four or five months left in the year, so who knows? 63:52 Maybe we'll get you back on again. 63:53 That'd be great. 63:54 I'm here for you. 63:54 All right. 63:55 Aaron Lubbeck, thanks so much. 63:56 Appreciate your time. 63:57 Thanks, Kevin. 63:58 See ya. 64:00 Farewell, farewell, farewell, farewell, farewell, farewell, farewell. 64:13 Farewell. 64:14 Farewell. 64:16 Farewell. 64:16 Farewell. 64:17 Farewell. 64:20 Farewell. 64:22 Farewell. 64:24 Farewell.
Community discussion