0:00 Welcome to The Messy City Podcast, where we talk with the people who design, plan, build, develop, or even just think about how to create beautiful, successful, and humane cities and towns. 0:13 Let's learn from each other and create places we truly care about. 0:20 [music] 0:46 Welcome back to The Messy City Podcast. 0:48 This is Kevin Klinkenberg. 0:50 I am super excited for today's conversation, one that I had hoped to be able to land at some point. 0:58 And fortunately or unfortunately, I was able to land it because my guest Chris has had some health issues that have gotten more homebound. 1:08 But delighted to have Chris Arnotti on the show today. 1:12 Chris, thanks for joining me. 1:14 Thanks for having me. 1:15 Chris, for anybody who's not familiar, my first introduction to him was his book, Dignity. 1:24 Subtitle is Seeking Respect in Backrow America. 1:27 It's just a terrific book, a great read. 1:31 I think I read it in like two days. 1:34 And he has since migrated over to Substack, and he has a great Substack called Chris Arnotti Walks the World. 1:44 And there's an awful lot of his content that I find incredibly interesting. 1:51 And we'll get into some specific questions, but a couple of things that would stand out to me and I would just, you know, a quick compliment to Chris right off the top. 2:00 But I think you're just a terrific writer. 2:03 I mean, a really exceptional writer and your photography on the site is excellent as well. 2:09 He has a unique take where he takes these long walks in places all over the world. 2:17 But also beyond that, there's a level of discussion and topics that you get to that I really appreciate because it seems that you have a desire and interest to get into a lot of topics and discussions that maybe other people 2:34 You know, sort of my world, the professional world, what people call the urbanist world, quote unquote, have a reluctance to get into. 2:42 A lot of topics and areas of discussion that you are eager to write about. 2:49 And I really appreciate that. 2:50 So, Chris, I just start off by saying thanks so much for the work that you do. 2:55 And it's just really enjoyable to read. 2:58 Well, that's very flattering. 3:00 Thank you. 3:02 So there's a lot of places we could go. 3:05 I think I want to start off with something actually a little more lighthearted. 3:11 And Chris has traveled literally all over the world and walked a lot of places. 3:17 You are not a food writer, but you do occasionally work food into the conversation. 3:23 And I think you've written a little bit about this before, but I'm curious about, you know, one of the things that we talk about is like sometimes the lack of higher quality, like really cheap food in the United States. 3:35 But when you travel to other parts of the world, you find it almost ubiquitous, whether it's street food or whether it's, you know, food court situations, especially Asian food courts. 3:47 What's your impression about like the quality of food? 3:49 First of all, do you think that's like an accurate impression? 3:53 You know, America versus the rest of the world in terms of that quality of inexpensive food. 3:57 And why might it be different here? 4:00 Or what's your impression on that? 4:02 Yeah, you know, it's funny. 4:07 Some of the few viral posts I've written have been comparing, talking about food, talking about American food versus European food in particular. 4:15 The age-old question, you know, where is the best place to eat? 4:20 And honestly, I think, The U.S. just doesn't have the food culture that you find in the rest of the world. 4:28 You can eat, it's a bit more subtle than that. 4:32 You can eat the best of anything in the U.S., but it's not normally what people eat. 4:38 If you have a little bit of money, a little bit of desire, you can get the best cuisine in the world in the U.S. 4:44 You can get the best Japanese, you can get the best Thai, you can get the best French. 4:50 Because the quality of ingredients here is exceptional. 4:53 And there, you know, LA, for instance, and New York City have extraordinarily good food seeds. 5:00 But that's not what most people in the US do. 5:03 You know, the metric I say is like the quality of a food culture is, and I've lived this, is if you're stuck in a small town, you know, let's say you end up in a town of 4,000 people, 5,000 people. 5:20 And you have to spend the night there and you just go wander for a few blocks, five blocks. 5:27 What's available? 5:28 What's good? 5:29 And by that metric and by that metric, places like Japan, France, Italy are just exceptional. 5:38 Yes, you can get a bad meal in Japan. 5:40 Yes, you can get a bad meal in France, but it's kind of hard. 5:42 You kind of got to work at it. 5:45 Whereas the general level of Quality and care put into the food is just higher. 5:54 And, you know, that's a cultural effect, meaning people, the customers expect it. 5:59 And so that's what they get. 6:00 There's also some policy issues. 6:02 You know, it's when you go into places like Japan and you go into places like Italy, a lot of Vietnam is a perfect example. 6:12 They don't have the zoning we have here. 6:16 Food is not required to be in a certain part of the city. 6:19 It's everywhere. 6:20 So someone can sell, open up a restaurant in the bottom of their own. 6:25 And many people do that. 6:26 And so there's just a lot, the barrier to entry is much lower. 6:30 And so there's a lot more available. 6:31 Japan is another example of that, where you just, you're inundated. 6:36 Is that the word? 6:37 Inundated. 6:39 With options in terms of where you want to eat. 6:44 It's quick food, but it's not necessarily what we in the U.S. think of quick food. 6:50 It's high quality. 6:52 Usually the people who are cooking it are all, it's family run. 6:57 So there's kind of a, there's also an ambience there that makes it far less transactional than it feels in the U.S. Um, So I do think that in general, people eat a lot healthier outside of the U.S. Again, the quality of the ingredients, 7:15 the old farm to table thing that became kind of a marketing gimmick here in the U.S. 7:22 actually exists in a lot of the rest of the world. 7:24 I remember one particular time I walked from Marseille to Lyon. 7:30 I was going through fields and Some of the best meals I had were during that walk in places that were just, you know, you would not, no one's going to give it a review. 7:40 It was just a small little restaurant in a small little town. 7:43 But again, what was being served to me was often things I walked past during that walk. 7:50 And so there's just a level of care and attention that you just don't have in the U.S., 7:56 Yeah, it's interesting because like in my world and the sort of urban planning, architecture, design world, whatever you want to call it, there's always a lot of discussion and interest on, for example, the people fixate on Japan as an example and the culture of very, 8:12 very small businesses and how really cool that is for city living and how we lack a lot of that in American cities. 8:23 And it's interesting to think about, like you talk about, how much of that is culture and how much of it is policy and other interventions that enable it or don't enable it? 8:35 Yeah, you know, one of the things I, another thing I recently wrote about is, you know, people will, kind of policy people will just say, well, they have mixed, mixed, mixed zone, mixed use zoning. 8:46 So, you know, one of my favorite kind of, One of my favorite things is point out to people that Japan doesn't look like Totoro. 8:56 It doesn't look like Spear did away. 8:59 Japan is often, urban Japan is pretty ugly. 9:04 It's very utilitarian. 9:05 It's very crowded. 9:07 It's very boxy. 9:11 And it's everything cluttered. 9:12 It's all very... 9:14 But there is a sense of care still there. 9:19 And that's cultural. 9:20 And the mixed-use zoning... 9:22 It's part of what causes a kind of chaotic environment that allows you to basically be able to get food in any neighborhood you're in without having to walk too far. 9:32 But again, one of the things I've written about before, and this is a bigger issue, is there's a sense of public order in Japan. 9:40 And I think what I said is Americans' intolerance for mixed-use zoning is I think it's downstream of their fear of the chaotic environment that they see in public spaces that you just don't have in Japan. 9:59 People don't want to be next to restaurants. 10:01 They don't want to be next to bars because they associate those with chaos. 10:08 And that just doesn't happen in Japan. 10:10 People don't associate chaotic public spaces. 10:14 Public disorder with commercial establishments the way they do in the US. 10:20 Yeah, well, let's talk about that a little more because that is a theme that has interested me in a lot of your writings. 10:26 It's just sort of this discussion about disorder versus order in cities in particular and the impact of social trust on the various places that you go to. 10:39 I mean, it seems to be a bigger part of the discussion right now in the United States than probably it's been in a while for a variety of reasons. 10:48 It's something I encounter and have to deal with kind of on a daily basis in the day job that I'm doing now. 10:54 Um, where we manage public space. 10:58 Um, but, but it is an interesting aspect of, you know, with your perspective, having been in so many different countries and seeing such a wide variety of how people treat in our urban life. 11:09 Um, I wonder if you could talk a little bit more about the, the importance of that sort of social trust or the, the order disorder conversation. 11:17 Yeah. 11:17 I mean, you know, I, one of the things I, I'm a, I'm a huge advocate or, Not so much an advocate as a user of public transportation. 11:24 I famously, you know, part of my gimmick of my Substack is I don't drive when I go places. 11:32 I don't take cabs. 11:33 I don't take Ubers. 11:34 I think I've used an Uber once in my life. 11:36 It was called for me. 11:38 But, you know, I use buses. 11:40 I take buses from the airports. 11:41 I take trains and buses. 11:44 And I'm a huge bus fan. 11:45 And, you know, I do that in the U.S. as well. 11:48 And it's just not a very pleasant experience in the U.S. 11:51 You know, as I often write, I'm one of the few people who's on a public bus in the U.S. who's there by choice. 12:01 You know, I'm there because I choose to do it. 12:04 Most people are there because they are legally obliged to do it. 12:07 They're economically obliged to do it. 12:10 Or, you know, They don't have a friend who can drive them. 12:15 There's a pretty often dystopian scene. 12:18 When I write this, people say, well, you take the M60 bus in New York. 12:24 New York and Chicago and LA are slightly different. 12:29 But if you take a bus, I ride the buses wherever I go. 12:33 I ride the buses in Denver. 12:34 I ride the buses in Omaha, Nebraska. 12:36 I ride the buses in El Paso. 12:39 And it's a very different scene there where there are buses I would not let my daughters get on. 12:49 It's just unsafe. 12:51 I happen to know how to navigate it. 12:52 I've been doing it for 15, 20 years, so I don't feel unsafe. 12:56 But it's not a pleasant experience. 12:58 And I think until you make riding a bus a pleasant experience, you're just not going to get 13:09 The amount of writers with the critical mass you need for the system to work. 13:16 I often will fly home from Seoul to Chicago or New York City or LA and it's just... 13:26 Take the bus to the airport in Seoul or I take the bus from the airport in Chicago or Blue Line in Chicago. 13:35 And it's just an entirely different scene. 13:37 You know, it's especially jarring given the wealth differential. 13:41 We're the wealthiest country. 13:43 And there are times when I remember the last time I got on the Blue Line in Chicago, you know, 830 at night, whatever. 13:53 Some guy gets on and just lights up a joint. 13:57 Just, you know, just openly lights up a joint. 14:00 And it was funny as all the, the only other people on the train were, were, were, were, were airport employees. 14:10 And they all, we all got off the next stop and moved to the next, you know, I wasn't worried about the danger of this guy smoking job. 14:17 I was like, I had a kind of sweater on. 14:19 I didn't want to get smelling like marijuana. 14:22 And that was minor relative to what I've seen in the U.S. 14:27 And so there is an issue of, you know, people talk about, urbanists talk about the mixed-use density, high walkable cities, but the contingency for that needs to be a sense that people feel safe to walk. 14:45 You know, I'm a big guy. 14:46 I do it a lot, so I'm not particularly worried for myself. 14:49 But, you know, other people... 14:52 There are people like, again, I don't want my daughters or even my friends necessarily do some of the things I do. 15:00 Don't ride the bus at 11 o'clock in St. Louis like I do. 15:05 Yeah, it's interesting. 15:07 I was just having a similar conversation this morning because next year I have a daughter who will be in middle school. 15:16 The middle school is straight down a major street from our house. 15:19 It would be the easiest thing in the world for her to ride the bus to the school there and back. 15:24 And it would be a really cool thing to imagine her having that freedom, that freedom of movement to just go get on the bus, take it herself. 15:32 It's a straight shot. 15:33 It's an easy walk. 15:36 But the condition of our bus system and the people who are now riding it pervasively is not what it's like, I don't want her around that. 15:45 Yeah, they're roving homeless shelters. 15:48 That's what they are in a lot of the towns. 15:49 And again, I've written empathetically about the homeless issue. 15:54 It's not fair to anybody. 15:55 One of the things I've said in past pieces is I spent 10 years writing about addicts and homeless people. 16:04 And I've said, often there's a lot of mental issues going on. 16:09 And the last thing you want is to put them in a confined space with strangers. 16:13 And that's what's happening with using the buses as effectively shelters. 16:18 Because it's just begging for problems. 16:22 It's begging for misunderstandings. 16:24 It's begging for things to either harm them or then harm other people in both directions. 16:31 And so it's just, sorry people, and it's just idiotic policy. 16:37 And so I've gotten into this in the past. 16:41 We're going to talk about Should you charge on a bus? 16:44 Yes, you should definitely charge a fee for a bus entry. 16:47 One of my favorite things is some of the best public transportation systems are in ex-Soviet countries, Bulgaria, Romania, Uzbekistan, Romania, Bulgaria. 17:00 And the thing is, they have Fees. 17:04 And the thing was, even in the Soviet system, they had fees. 17:08 It was a small fee, but it was a fee. 17:09 And the reason they do it is because they knew that you needed a sense of ownership when you enter the system. 17:16 So that there's a sense of obligation to behave properly when on the bus or on the subway. 17:25 So I think that to me is one of the frustrations in the US. 17:29 The other, of course, is The U.S. is built for cars. 17:36 You talk about not wanting to let your daughter go down. 17:43 I walk across big cities. 17:48 I often stay at the Super 8 outside and you have an intersection and then I walk through the tangle of interstates along the little path that exists to get to the McDonald's up my way. 17:57 It's not pleasant. 17:59 It's not a pleasant thing and it's not necessarily safe. 18:02 I mean, I do it because that's what I do, but 18:09 we're a country that's built for cars. 18:12 And we often lay down sidewalks because we have to have sidewalks, but they end up being effectively hard to use and just basically titular talk. 18:24 Yeah, I want to ask one more thing on the bus question, too. 18:27 So I remember, I think you had one piece where you wrote quite a bit about your experience riding the bus in South American countries, and maybe it was in Ecuador. 18:36 I'm not sure, but there was one where I think it particularly struck you about the quality of the experience riding the bus or taking the bus as just a part of normal life in some of those countries. 18:49 Yeah, I mean, you know, Latin America has a good bus system. 18:54 It's been a while since... Last country I went to was Peru. 18:58 I haven't been to Argentina, but they actually have extraordinarily good bus systems. 19:03 And again, because there's a high level of... 19:06 There is a sense of respect when people get on the bus. 19:12 And I think that concept of... 19:16 If you were to smoke on the bus, the bus driver would toss you off. 19:19 You would be ejected immediately. 19:23 And the other citizens would as well. 19:26 So there is a certain level of understanding that you have to behave a certain way. 19:33 Yeah. 19:35 One of the things I wondered was in any of your work, did you ever come across any of the speeches or anything that former mayor Joe Riley of Charleston, South Carolina gave? 19:47 Joe was a longtime mayor. 19:49 I think he actually served as mayor for like 32 years or something. 19:52 Charleston, South Carolina. 19:53 Pretty remarkable guy, but really interesting in how he talked about like the purpose of a city and who it was for. 20:00 Is that anything you've come across? 20:02 I have not heard the name, but I've been to Charleston. 20:05 Yeah. 20:07 It's one of those, maybe a touch point when if you're sitting around board and search, find one of his old YouTube lectures. 20:14 So one of the things he talks about that I think there's like a crossover for is he pointedly talked about how the importance And 20:25 he often would sort of have that conversation built around somebody who was like born and raised in that city who never really went anywhere, never traveled anywhere, but felt like it was important as part of that day-to-day experience to just be able to encounter, you know, 20:42 something beautiful, a beautiful public space, a beautiful view, attractive buildings, whatever it was. 20:48 And it was sort of a cornerstone of what he tried to work on for a long, long time. 20:53 And it really, it occurred to me that that was, there was a bit of overlap in how you kind of think about the front row, back row conversation and how we often think about cities and, you know, the purpose, like who they're for, 21:08 who are we actually working for when those of us who plan cities or work on neighborhoods, you know, what we're doing. 21:14 Yeah, I mean, there's the whole question of, um, Some of my favorite cities are not necessarily pretty cities. 21:23 Asia famously has a very utilitarian approach to cities. 21:31 Yes, Seoul is particularly one of my favorite cities. 21:35 It's where I spend a lot of time. 21:37 And at an aesthetic level, it can be pretty jarring. 21:41 Pretty much an amalgamation of commercialization that just hits you. 21:47 And they don't have zoning either, so it's all in your face. 21:51 But they spend a lot of time thinking about public spaces and how they're used. 22:02 When I'm in Seoul, there's an old drainage ditch. 22:07 It was an old drainage river that runs through the south of Seoul. 22:11 It's been turned into a park. 22:13 It's down. 22:15 It's beneath. 22:16 Over it is a bunch of interstates, rail lines, like about a third of the walk. 22:25 It's my daily walk in Seoul. 22:26 It's an eight-mile walk along this. 22:29 They turned it into a river, and it's festooned along the walk with all sorts of... 22:36 Places where you can stop and do exercises and be able to use it. 22:42 And a lot of it is covered. 22:44 It's kind of underneath vaulted, underneath busy interstates and subway lines. 22:52 And what's amazing about it is every little space, they elevate every little space. 23:00 They turn it into... 23:02 Little art displays, lights, tables, benches. 23:09 It's so well thought of. 23:12 One thing I noted before is in this eight-mile walk, about a third of it covered, there's no smell of urine. 23:19 In the US, that place, because they actually have public bathrooms every mile or so. 23:26 Again, it's the care of the citizens. 23:29 The citizens care enough to take care. 23:34 They can have nice things because the people respect nice things. 23:38 And I think one of my concerns in the US is if you were to try to do that in Chicago or LA, it would quickly become a very, very different scene. 23:51 Yeah. 23:53 They do care despite the utilitarian approach. 23:58 They still have spaces in every neighborhood where they really do take care about the aesthetic so that everybody in the city, the wealthy and the poor, can kind of have a daily experience that elevates them. 24:16 One of the things that strikes me, I mean, you're a unique guy, highly educated professional guy. 24:25 You worked in the professional world for a number of years, and you kind of detached yourself from that to take this other journey. 24:33 Especially when you started working with addiction and the work that led to your book, Dignity. 24:39 And now this unique experience you have walking these very, very long walks all over the world. 24:46 How do you... 24:48 This probably could be a whole podcast, but how do you feel like that has changed you or your perceptions about the world or about how people live in cities? 24:57 I mean, this is a dramatic change in your life trajectory. 25:02 Yeah, I mean, you know, the thing about the, one of the most striking things about the, and this is true of almost any city, but it's particularly true in the U.S. 25:08 is, you know, every city is a confederate from their neighborhoods. 25:14 You can have very different experiences depending on where you live. 25:18 The U.S. 25:18 is a little bit more gated in that sense where you can live in one neighborhood and then five blocks, even six blocks away is an entirely different city, an entirely different experience. 25:30 And part of the reason I do the walking is you can't do that. 25:35 When you literally walk across the city, I walk 20 miles across L.A. from the airport to Downey through Compton. 25:47 You have to see it all. 25:49 You pass through neighborhood after neighborhood after neighborhood. 25:53 It gives you a real sense of how the city is for most people, not for just the people who live in those particular neighborhoods. 26:04 It's changed how I see ... 26:08 It's changed my perspective immensely because I feel like, unfortunately, so much of urban planning and urban policy has gotten a lot better than it used to be. 26:21 I think if I say, my standard talk is, if you want to know a city, walk across it and ride the bus. 26:29 I hope there's not that many people who are urban planners who don't ride buses. 26:35 You'd be surprised. 26:38 You've got to know the city. 26:41 Basically, I've The way I think about elites in general or urban planners is another example. 26:47 We're playing SimCity or SimCulture, like that video game. 26:53 You've got to know the Sims. 26:55 You've got to know the whole city. 27:00 If you're going to be a mayor of a city, you've got to ride the buses. 27:04 You just have to. 27:06 To know what your city is and what the people think and how they experience it. 27:13 You know, the experience of New York is a very, very different. 27:18 New York is too common an example, but like, you know, if you're in Chicago and you're only kind of in the north side and you've never been kind of south of Hyde Park and to kind of like, you know, Gary or 27:34 Or Hampton, you know, Hammond, sorry, Hammond. 27:40 You're going to have a very different experience. 27:44 You're going to think the city doesn't have problems. 27:48 The city has the problems it has. 27:52 You know, so I really do feel like, you know, it's a bit cliched at this point, but if you're going to kind of make policy for a city, you better ride the buses. 28:01 Yeah. 28:02 Yeah. 28:03 Yeah. 28:03 I mean, you'd probably be amazed how many people I've known that work for transit agencies that don't ride the buses. 28:10 So it's a funny deal. 28:14 What are some parts of the world or places that you have visited that have really surprised you for the better? 28:22 Better could mean anything more interesting, more lively, more who knows what, but someplace you went to that maybe you didn't have, maybe you weren't looking forward to as much, but really ended up surprising you. 28:34 I mean, Uzbekistan was one of the more recent ones where 28:41 Cash Kent, the capital, Was a pretty beautiful city. 28:48 And for transportation geeks, it has the most gorgeous subway stations in the world. 28:57 Like, you know, I knew that sometimes I can be pretty foolish in what I do. 29:02 And I kind of knew that Tashkent was in a desert. 29:10 But I really didn't, you know, so when I went out for like a 15-mile walk and realized I was getting heat exhaustion at night and dehydrated, it all made sense. 29:23 So in any case, the next few days when I was kind of way on my back, I took it easy and I just went from subway station to subway station and was just absolutely blown away by the beauty. 29:34 You want to talk about beauty. 29:35 The subway stations are absolutely magnificent. 29:37 Yeah. 29:38 But I think Central America, Central Asian aggregate, Mongolia, Tashkent, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, are places that I find are immensely fascinating. 29:51 And people talk about over-tourism. 29:53 They're not dealing with over-tourism. 29:57 Their places are just culturally fascinating, historically fascinating, and very rewarding as a tourist because you get to see a way of living that just is not Been corrupted by Hollywood or TV. 30:11 It's just kind of a more genuine way of living. 30:16 A more genuine sense of who they are. 30:18 A lot of problem with tourism in the modern world is people go to places where effectively the locals are performing for you, playing your role. 30:30 And that's not the case in Central Asia by any stretch. 30:33 But in general, I mean, Japan, I know everybody knows about Japan, but I think Japan is just, especially when you get outside of central Tokyo, Japan is just so rewarding a place to be a visitor in terms of what you can learn there, how beautiful it is, 30:59 how wonderful you realize when a culture really cares about everything. 31:07 Really cares about, you know, one of my favorite things to do is when I was, when I was, I put myself through college, I was a house painter. 31:20 I worked as a painter, painting at a local college, actually painting dorms in the summers. 31:28 And then there were two roles as a painter. 31:31 And one is you roll, you roll the wall. 31:33 This is before the modern equipment. 31:35 The other was called cutting. 31:37 You cut the floorboards. 31:38 You do the size line at the bottom of the floorboards and at corners. 31:43 So I'm very, I don't tell people that because I don't want anybody to ever, you know, get me to become their painter. 31:49 But I'm very attuned to painting. 31:51 And when I walk into a room, I kind of notice how, you know, quality of the painting. 31:57 And it's really fascinating to be in Japan where you go to come from someplace like China, which has relatively low quality. 32:06 And just see in Japan, how much care they put into absolutely everything, every small detail. 32:16 And you talk about the idea of elevating life through the aesthetics. 32:22 That sort of kind of precision and care really does elevate life and makes it really, really 32:28 wonderful experience. 32:31 You've also done something that, you know, very few like Americans focus on or certainly Americans like in the urban planning world, which is you've gone to a lot of African cities and walked them. 32:43 And, you know, I know you've written extensive pieces about your trips there, so they're on the site for anybody who wants to subscribe and read them. 32:51 But I wonder if you could talk a little bit about your takeaway about the difference and uniqueness of some of these very large African cities that you've walked through. 33:00 Yeah, one of the funny things about walking the world is, when you walk everywhere, is you think in a place like Africa, plenty of people walk, but they still think you're crazy. 33:12 As a white guy, they think I'm crazy for walking. 33:14 They think there's something wrong with me. 33:17 They'll come up to me and ask me, like, you need to walk. 33:19 Why don't you have a limo? 33:23 But, you know, it can be, it's hard. 33:26 They're hard cities. 33:28 Just the infrastructure is just, it's atrocious. 33:34 So you don't walk, you walk on the side of the road. 33:38 And the sidewalks have large holes in them. 33:41 And then there's just the issue of just literally traffic jams of people. 33:49 You find yourself unable to get through a certain position because there's just so many people carrying things and walking. 33:56 But, you know, I was hoping to go this summer again back to Africa, back to Uganda, which I absolutely love. 34:06 I had a negative experience in Senegal, a much more positive experience. 34:11 And Kinshasa and Uganda. 34:15 The people are just extraordinarily, you don't go for the infrastructure, you go for the people. 34:20 And people are just extraordinarily warm. 34:23 And you're just very welcoming. 34:25 And in that sense, when you see people making do with so little, 34:37 And building relatively rewarding lives, you know, fulfilling lives with so little, you know, it really does put things in perspective. 34:49 You know, when you, you know, when you see people, I remember there was a, I'm Catholic. 34:56 And so when I went to Uganda, I went, it was called the martyrs shrine in Uganda and outside of Kinshasa. 35:06 And on the plane, the day before, I always kind of think about my first walk. 35:10 And I'm like, oh, it's a 12-mile walk, a 13-mile walk to the center of the city where I was staying out to the martyr's shrine. 35:18 And I'm like, that's all I'll do. 35:19 That's going to be my first walk. 35:22 After five miles, I'm like, no way I'm going to do this. 35:24 This is impossible. 35:27 I was covered in mud. 35:32 I was walking on a small dirt trail with other people besides a very busy road with semis with no regulations, spewing tires and mud. 35:49 Eventually, I hopped onto a hack cab and I took the rest of the way to the murder shrine. 35:59 And, you know, I think I walked like seven miles out of the 12. 36:02 And I kind of felt like a hero. 36:04 Kind of was like patting myself on the back. 36:05 You know, like, I'm a hero. 36:06 I'm a hero. 36:07 Like, what a great guy. 36:08 And I look around. 36:10 I got there a little late after the service. 36:12 It was a Sunday. 36:14 And there was all these families spreading blankets. 36:18 It's a big complex. 36:19 It's about 200 acres. 36:22 And they're spreading blankets. 36:23 And they had their children on their backs. 36:27 And they had piles of food. 36:30 I started talking to some of them. 36:32 They had walked from the Congo. 36:33 They had walked 600 miles from the Congo. 36:36 Wow. 36:37 You know, like, to come to the shrine. 36:40 Yeah. 36:42 So I kind of, this sense of me being hero immediately. 36:49 But, you know, when you see people who can walk 600 miles, 36:55 you know, in those conditions, 36:59 It really does make you feel both very fortunate for what we have, but at the same time feel a little bit guilty. 37:09 A little bit guilty for not living a more holistic life. 37:15 Thinking of pilgrimage walks, it obviously immediately comes to mind the Camino Santiago. 37:21 Is that one you've done? 37:22 Is that too cliche? 37:23 I'm not a big 37:28 I like walks that are not intended as walks. 37:33 So I try to 37:37 kind of walk routes that kind of don't have the infrastructure set up for that and that I won't necessarily run into other people doing the same thing. 37:48 Because in general, I find those to be kind of walks that are advertised as walks and sold as walks and marketed as walks can kind of be a tunnel. 37:58 Where you don't really see much other than what they want you to see. 38:06 And so the lack of planning in some sense or the kind of chaotic nature to me is much more educational. 38:13 Because it forces me to deal with things that I didn't plan to deal with and see things I wouldn't necessarily have seen. 38:23 So the longer walks tend to be... 38:27 More through industrial regions than pilgrimages. 38:32 Yeah. 38:33 I have done nothing like your walks, but it's definitely my favorite moments in cities I'm not familiar with are just getting out and wandering around and getting a little bit lost. 38:44 Yeah. 38:44 I mean, I don't like to be lost per se. 38:50 Yeah. 38:52 But, you know... 38:55 I generally, when I do these kind of 150-mile walks where I carried everything in my pack, not in my back, I usually plan an overall route. 39:06 I kind of planned it for two days out, and then every two days I kind of readjust. 39:11 But, you know, 39:18 packaged walk just doesn't do it for me. 39:22 Yeah. 39:23 So one of the things, you know, highlighted with the African examples, you know, in Dignity and a lot of your other writings, you often will frankly talk about religious faith and your own Catholicism and you'll, you know, write about and discuss the topic of religion, 39:39 which I wanted to touch on that just because it's fascinating in a lot of like professional and elite discourse, like nobody talks about religion. 39:49 And it seems to be something that we studiously avoid. 39:52 And I'm curious, like, why you think that is? 39:58 Why is it important for you to write about it? 40:01 In Dignity, it was a common theme running through a lot of the work. 40:05 Yeah, I mean, for me, it was, you know, before I was a professional as a scientist, I got... 40:13 I did a physics PhD. 40:15 So at heart, I'm still a scientist in many ways. 40:19 And quite honestly, when I started getting out in the world and walking, I just encountered faith wherever I went. 40:27 And rather than say, well, 90% of the people have it wrong. 40:33 I have it right. 40:35 I started thinking a little bit more about what's going on here. 40:41 Why is every community walk into it? 40:43 Um, case so important. 40:45 And, um, in that sense, you know, I started not lecturing, but listening and, you know, they, they have actually convinced me that, that they, they were right. 40:55 And I was wrong. 40:57 No, I was never, uh, I was never a, um, kind of a, a scoldy atheist type. 41:04 Um, but, um, or a sanctimonious one, but I, I certainly felt like I had the answer and that religion was, um, It was something that we have moved beyond. 41:17 It's just my work 41:22 and actually just growing older and a little bit more humbler, I think, allowed me to... To me, I believe I'm not dogmatic about my faith. 41:32 I think philosophically, religion is right in terms of the big pictures. 41:37 I don't necessarily think it's right in terms of the day-to-day issues, but You know, to me, when my faith degree is more about humility, the idea that we don't have all the answers and there are answers that are unsolvable. 41:56 And that's where faith comes in. 41:59 But, you know, just seeing the faith, the intense faith, as in 42:07 Uganda or in Senegal, where there are mosques everywhere, 42:14 And in my work in the U.S. 42:18 and Hunts Point and Gary, Indiana and other places like that, and some in Alabama, you just realize how important faith is to people. 42:29 And so, you know, I think it holds a big component of being a human. 42:38 And I think to deny that is just... 42:42 Scientifically, at least, it's just counterfactual. 42:46 It's just not true. 42:46 I mean, faith is big. 42:50 But at a more emotional level, when you see how powerful it is to people, it's hard not to be moved by that. 42:59 Yeah, and you've written a lot about the need for humans to feel a part of something bigger. 43:06 I even wrote down, like, you're just one... 43:09 One little quote, a short quote here, said that human despair is no longer primarily a result of economic destitution, rather is due to a lack of functional and healthy communities. 43:21 And then you kind of talked as that went on about the corollary to this is about happiness and fulfillment. 43:27 And so much of this is a social need. 43:31 It's a social need, but also a need to feel a part of something bigger. 43:35 That could be bigger, more existential, or just bigger in terms of like more than just the individual. 43:41 And that's also kind of a common theme throughout a lot of what you are writing about is this tension and need between the individual and the social that we all have. 43:53 Yeah, I mean, you know, most sociobiology I'll ever get is that we're a social animal. 43:59 It's simple as that. 44:00 Like, you know, as Aristotle said, you know, No man can live alone. 44:06 The only people who can live alone is either a beast or a god or neither of those. 44:12 Community is huge. 44:15 The sense of being a valued member of community is, I think, ultimately what 44:23 people need that. 44:24 Without that, that's at the core of despair. 44:27 If you feel like you're not a respected member of something that's larger than yourself, Some people have a larger purpose than just here now. 44:39 I think that's extraordinarily important to people. 44:41 And when people lose that, then that's ultimately what I think is at the fundamental core of what's sparing that. 44:50 I know I saw that initially when I was working with heroin addicts throughout the US. 44:58 That's ultimately what they lacked was... 45:01 A sense of a purpose in the life that gave him a respected place in the community. 45:08 And when they don't have a functional community that gives them a role, they'll find a dysfunctional one. 45:17 And that's what drug houses are. 45:19 One of the things I've written about is I spend a lot more time than I like to admit not using. 45:25 I never used in trap houses and crack houses. 45:29 I ate one in the morning. 45:33 And they're very communal. 45:36 They operate as kind of, they're effectively similar to the old, they're like a dystopian version of the Cheers bar. 45:45 Like, you walk in, everybody knows your name. 45:49 So they preserve, they fill that role of giving people a sense of a community that understands them. 46:00 Yeah. 46:02 And another reason like homelessness can be so vexing because for a lot of people who are living on the street or living outside, they've created a community of other people around them and they're not necessarily in a hurry to try to detach themselves from that. 46:19 Right. 46:19 I mean, you know, famously, you know, by and large, most homeless live in camps and Again, they build communities there and social networks. 46:33 People don't like to be alone. 46:34 It's as simple as that. 46:36 Loneliness is a killer. 46:39 I just don't mean that in terms of physical loneliness. 46:41 I mean that in terms of... 46:47 When I was doing work in addiction, people would ask me for answers. 46:53 It's hard to come up with answers. 46:54 I mean, it's easier to describe a problem than it is to solve it, obviously, so I'm much more comfortable describing it. 47:00 But the degree I would try, I would say, the few cases I see of it working is people finding a community that's not about drugs. 47:12 For young men, it's often the military or it's sports. 47:18 And for others, it's the church. 47:22 Again, that is a community that is there to lift them higher and to give them a space. 47:33 Yeah. 47:35 What things, maybe seem a little bit random, but what is there about the United States that you find that you've come to appreciate more about? 47:46 After traveling so much, I'm curious, like, what your perceptions would have changed, especially maybe when you're out and about in a different part of the world. 47:53 What do you really appreciate about the U.S. that you might not have thought so before? 47:57 I think that one of the greatest features we have, first of all, I'm a huge fan of the U.S. 48:03 There's a reason I haven't moved. 48:05 I might have sounded pretty negative throughout this podcast, but, you know, there's a reason people want to live in the U.S. 48:14 It's effectively that 48:17 This may sound a little bit contrary to what I just said, but we allow people to remake themselves. 48:22 We give people five or six or seven different things. 48:26 In the rest of the world, often, you're slotted into a role very early, and you don't have a lot of opportunity to go elsewhere and to remake yourself. 48:38 In the US, you can remake yourself multiple times. 48:43 You can pivot your career. 48:45 You can change your image. 48:46 You can change your style. 48:48 You can change who you are. 48:49 People are like, oh, okay, we'll give you another chance. 48:52 And so I think that's immensely, that's an immense strength we have. 48:58 We don't basically take people and judge them and toss them aside and say, well, you're an engineer and you should always be an engineer or you're a engineer. 49:07 So there's a sense that you can kind of do what you want to do. 49:11 And again, we do reward. 49:14 We do reward hard work here. 49:15 I know it doesn't necessarily feel that way to a lot of people, but you can really come here or start off with very little in your pocket. 49:26 Generally, if you work hard and you play by the rules, you'll be rewarded by such. 49:34 The other thing is, and again, I think this may shock some, we're the least racist country in the world. 49:44 One of the things that maybe Canada is less, I don't know, but compared to Asia, compared to Europe, compared to Latin America, compared to Africa, we don't judge people necessarily, but just by their skin color or by what group they come from. 50:13 One of the things that you get used to if you spend time in Central Africa is they'll just call you Wuzungo, Wuzungo, Wuzungo. 50:20 That's basically, if you're white, you're a Wuzungo. 50:23 It basically means outsider. 50:25 Hey, Wuzungo, hey, Wuzungo. 50:29 You got money, come here, Wuzungo. 50:32 But I remember I made some friends in a bar in Kampala and 50:41 I went up to the bar and I started bringing back another person to the table. 50:45 And they said, no, you cannot bring that person here. 50:47 I said, why? 50:49 They're a member of a different tribe. 50:51 No, they're not allowed here. 50:53 I was like, you guys look exactly alike, but you speak the same language. 51:01 So there's an extraordinarily level of them. 51:06 Americans are much more understanding and much more open and much more accepting of different people than the rest of the boulevard. 51:13 And again, we're extraordinarily tolerant. 51:18 I think that gets lost in a lot of the political discourse. 51:21 But by comparison, we're extraordinarily tolerant. 51:24 Yeah, that's certainly, that's been my experience too. 51:28 Without as much traveling as you, but still a pretty fair amount. 51:34 A couple years ago, you got to give the keynote speech to the Strong Towns conference, which is a really interesting mix of people. 51:42 Obviously, that's not strictly like planning professionals or development professionals. 51:47 It's a lot of advocates, a lot of grassroots enthusiasm in that group. 51:53 What's it been like for you to find people in that world, people like myself, who gravitate towards your work and want to have you talk to us about urban planning? 52:03 All right. 52:04 I love that conference. 52:05 I actually feel, I misunderstood, you know, I knew who Strong Towns was. 52:13 I read, it's a Chuck, right? 52:18 And he's been very kind to me, but I didn't realize how grassroots you people are there. 52:24 So in some sense, I feel like the speech I gave was not necessarily to them, but to people who were not unlike them. 52:32 But yeah, you know, it's, I have an immense respect for, and I think I've said this, 52:38 were you there, by the way? 52:39 I actually was not at that one, which was kind of unfortunate. 52:43 But one of the times I was talking to a lot of people at the events after, it's a wonderful community, but speaking of communities, really well-intentive people, very knowledgeable. 52:54 I learned more about parking setbacks. 52:58 Very wonky group, yeah. 53:00 But I mean, those are good. 53:01 Those are important things. 53:02 I'm not a policy person. 53:04 So it was important to have that, to be reminded that policy really matters. 53:08 You know, the setback policies and parking space policies, they didn't matter. 53:14 But, you know, I think the care that people, you know, it was really, to me, it was really good to see that people can make a difference. 53:26 You know, you can really change. 53:30 You can really change the cities where it better. 53:33 Think where you live locally, I think is a very, very, very good cliche. 53:39 You know, if you want to change something, change it in your town and people can make a difference. 53:44 And I think that's wonderful. 53:47 So I know you've had some health issues crop up recently. 53:50 It looks like you might be stationary or at least home for a little while. 53:56 What's the prescription after that? 53:58 Or how long do you think you'll be homebound? 54:00 And then what's next on your radar for traveling? 54:03 If I can travel again, I have pulmonary embolism in the process of that 54:11 from a blood clot from the airplane. 54:13 So if you fly a lot, get up and move a lot. 54:17 Don't get blood clot. 54:19 But if I can travel before the year, I would like to go back. 54:24 My next trip plan was I was going to go to Korea, where I kind of, my second home. 54:30 And then I was going to do a, I was going to go down to southern Okinawa in Japan and then take ferries, work my way up over the course of two weeks up to Kyushu, basically island hopping. 54:43 I absolutely love I love Japan and I love everything about Japan. 54:49 But if I can't do that, which I don't think I'll be able to do, I kind of want to focus on the Bay Area and California. 54:55 I think California is one of my favorite states. 55:00 I think it's gotten a bad rap recently. 55:03 I just think it's absolutely gorgeous. 55:07 It's gifted with probably the most beautiful matron in the US. 55:13 And the Bay Area is just so fascinating when you just read about the history of it, going back to the Spanish missions. 55:22 But I want to walk from basically Berkeley down to San Jose along the East Coast through Oakland. 55:28 It's like a 70-mile walk through kind of... To me, it's a lot of the history of what... 55:36 I think the Bay Area is effectively what has made modern U.S. 55:40 in terms of I want to go on the east side, which is less high-techy and a little bit more of a spillover from what happened the high-tech industry with the immigrant communities and the World War II shipbuilding. 55:58 I want to focus on the Pacific Northwest basically for a month. 56:05 Certainly to Salinas Valley in California, north up to Seattle. 56:09 I think that's part of it. 56:10 That's one of the areas of the U.S. 56:11 I don't know very well. 56:13 Only ones. 56:14 And one of the things I like to do is when I'm in the U.S., I like to ride buses, ride home buses. 56:20 And I would like to do that basically from San Francisco up to Seattle through Oregon. 56:27 You did give a shout out to those of us in the Midwest. 56:30 I think when you were in Indiana recently, may have been Indiana, about the Midwest being... 56:35 You know, one of your favorite parts of the country just for a variety of reasons, but a lot of it had to do with the people you were encountering. 56:42 Yeah, you know, I was late to the Midwest, but I've been spending a lot of time in the last two years there. 56:50 I kind of got there by accident because Greyhound bus dropped me in Michigan City, Indiana. 56:55 And I kind of fell in love with the town. 56:58 It was just a very normal town and the best use of the word. 57:05 But I'm actually giving a talk at the Midwest Conference in November. 57:09 I'm really excited about it in Sioux Falls. 57:13 The thing about the Midwest I like is it still manufactures things. 57:20 It still makes things. 57:23 Yes, the de-industrialization gets hard, but it's bouncing back. 57:27 It still makes an immense amount. 57:30 Gary, Indiana, is still milk. 57:32 That's right. 57:34 And so does Michigan City, Indiana, has a steel mill. 57:39 And so I went up to, this year I went up to Duluth and fell in love with the city. 57:46 I went up to Saturday morning. 57:50 And I still fell in love with it. 57:52 But there's just, you know, people work hard. 57:54 They still manufacture things, which I think tethers people to reality in a way that is healthy. 58:03 But also, one of the things I found I really liked about the Midwest, and maybe I'm being a naive outsider, it's just not performative in the way the South is. 58:11 I grew up in the South. 58:13 And it's also not political in the way that the South is. 58:17 People in the Midwest are genuinely friendly. 58:21 The South is famously friendly, but that friendliness around election time gets kind of dicey. 58:30 And sometimes the friendliness can be performative, but in the Midwest, it's a genuine friendliness. 58:37 People just are friendly. 58:39 And the type of place where you break down on the side of the road, people just help you in a way that just... 58:46 There's very little cynicism in the Midwest. 58:49 And as someone who's been living last 30 years of Northeast, I 58:51 really appreciate that. 58:53 Yeah, it's funny. 58:55 So I lived in Savannah, Georgia for almost nine years, which I love. 58:59 Beautiful, beautiful city. 59:01 I remember one day getting my car fixed and talking to the guy who ran this little shop. 59:09 And he was talking about how he and his wife had taken a vacation. 59:12 I think they were actually driving around Iowa or something and their car broke down. 59:16 And how some, you know, farmer nearby, you know, found him, invited him in, cooked him dinner or whatever else. 59:23 And he was totally surprised. 59:26 And his comment was, you know, I'm from Georgia here. 59:29 Like, we would have taken everything you had. 59:33 He had a much more like dark take on like what would have happened. 59:39 In Southern Georgia. 59:42 When I was riding Dignity, I spent a lot of time driving around the country and then parking and walking. 59:48 But I ended up in Davenport. 59:51 My car broke down in a Walmart shopping closet in Davenport, Iowa. 59:57 It was five degrees. 59:59 It was nine at night. 60:02 And four people came and helped me. 60:05 And it was like a... 60:09 It sounded cliche. 60:10 It was like a Hispanic guy, a black guy, and a white guy. 60:15 And some other white woman talking to help me. 60:18 You know, I was suffering from too much help. 60:23 Yeah, definitely sounds like the beginning to a joke. 60:26 But it was, you know, it's just a wonderful, again, 60:32 it's not performative niceness. 60:33 It's genuine niceness. 60:35 Well, if you ever come back this way to the heart of the Midwest, to Kansas City or these surrounds, then we'll definitely walk with you for at least some portion of it. 60:47 One other funny little crossover we have is you have a great post that's still up. 60:51 It might be your pinned post on Substack that you called Why I Walk. 60:55 Um, which is also a book that I wrote about 10 years ago. 60:59 Uh, and it, I always think it's kind of funny. 61:02 Um, I, I would imagine your post probably has about a hundred X more readership than my little book sold, but, uh, so it goes. 61:10 So why do you, well, you know, it was funny when I wrote that book. 61:15 Um, you know, you kind of, I guess sometimes when you write things, you, you're, Writing for a certain audience or somebody you have in mind, I really had in mind like my own family. 61:26 And I was trying to, I was not trying to write a book for like professionals. 61:30 I was writing it more to explain to my own family who would constantly ask me like, why do you live in the city? 61:36 Why do you walk or what's this thing about like living in a walkable neighborhood? 61:40 Why do you care about that? 61:42 And so I kind of wanted to write a short book that was explanatory about my lifestyle choice, more or less. 61:51 And it was fun. 61:53 I really enjoyed writing it. 61:54 I enjoyed the act of publishing a book and all that, but it certainly was not a bestseller. 62:00 Do you still walk as much? 62:02 You know, I try. 62:04 It is horrible now that we've got two small children We are trapped in a very common American city situation where we are carting kids around all over the city all the time. 62:19 And so my walking and my biking has reduced a lot the last few years. 62:24 And my waistline is starting to show it, which I don't like. 62:28 But it's something I'm really eager to find a way back to. 62:32 Yeah, I wasn't 62:35 able to do these walks until... 62:37 I did my walks in New York City, sometimes pushing a stroller back there. 62:43 But I wasn't able to kind of walk 10 miles a day until the kids got above a certain age. 62:49 Yeah. 62:50 And then there's like anything, you know, once you get out of a habit, it's hard to restart a habit. 62:54 And, you know, breaking habits or creating new ones is always a challenge. 62:59 That's kind of why you try not to stop walking ever. 63:02 That's right. 63:03 Especially at our age when And then an injury, it just goes on forever. 63:10 Yeah, yeah, no kidding. 63:12 Well, Chris, I really appreciate your time and the connection here today. 63:17 Just, again, want to thank you for the work that you're doing and the writing. 63:21 And I'm super appreciative of the content that you put out and always find it enjoyable. 63:30 And highly recommend anybody from finding you on Substack at Chris Harnati Walks the World. 63:36 And hope at some point we can connect again in the future. 63:40 All right. 63:40 Well, thank you very much for having me. 63:42 Keep walking. 63:43 All right. 63:43 I'll try. 63:44 All right. 63:44 Thank you very much. 63:45 Take care, Chris. 63:46 Farewell. 63:49 Farewell. 63:50 [music] 64:09 Farewell, Farewell, Farewell, 64:14 [music]
Community discussion