0:00 [music] 0:27 Hello, hello, hello. 0:28 Welcome to another Dishcast. 0:31 It's our final one up here on the Cape. 0:35 It's kind of telling me to get the hell out of here. 0:38 We had this horrible Nor'easter all weekend and it's freezing cold and everyone's left. 0:42 But I'm still here. 0:45 Reading my books, walking my dog, smoking my weed. 0:48 So life is still carrying on, but we're going back to DC very shortly. 0:52 I want to thank you very much for subscribing. 0:55 You know, we're now podcast centric, although I will be writing every week a little bit, but not quite the big. 1:01 Thank you. 1:19 Kona Bear is coming on. 1:22 She is one of the best scholars on Augustine. 1:25 And as part of our series of podcasts on some great thinkers, especially Christian thinkers, we're going to talk about St. Augustine. 1:31 And a man, Cyrus Habib, a very interesting character who was involved in electoral politics in Washington State and has now become a Jesuit priest. 1:41 I'm going to talk to him. 1:43 About what his life is doing, where he's aiming, and why Christianity is still compelling someone with so many abilities and such a potential in the secular world. 1:54 But today, a wonderful writer, probably the best nonfiction writer in America, and one of my old friends, dear friend, Michael Lewis. 2:03 He is the author, bestselling, of many books, as you know, Liars, Poker, Moneyball, The Blind Side, and Flash Boys. 2:11 And he was on The Dish cast four years ago. 2:13 I can't believe it was four years ago, but it was. 2:15 Jesus Lord. 2:17 To discuss the premonition, a pandemic story. 2:19 And last year... Oh, it was last year. 2:21 See, I'm not completely crazy. 2:23 It's your third time, Michael, to discuss a collection of essays called Who is Government? 2:28 And this week, we're covering his new book, which is somewhat related to the last one, because there are some interesting character studies in it. 2:36 And it's called Blockers. 2:38 And it's about... 2:40 I think I want to make that point first, Michael, because when I first saw the title, I thought, oh, these are people trying to block the president's agenda illegitimately, right? 2:54 That's what it sounds a little bit like. 2:55 That's not what you're saying. 2:56 These are not people that try to block it. 2:58 It's people who tried to foil his acting illegally. 3:04 Am I right about that? 3:05 That's correct. 3:06 So the two million persons civil service takes an oath to the Constitution when they take their jobs. 3:12 And we've had for more than a century this nonpartisan civil service who is, you know, their job is to execute the president's policies with certain constraints. 3:23 And one of the constraints is you don't break the law. 3:27 You know what I want to do, Andrew? 3:29 We got to come clean with the audience a little bit. 3:31 So you were my editor at The New Republic for some years, right? 3:34 Yes. 3:35 And I got to say, this is completely true, that when I was working on this, I was thinking, what would Andrew make of this piece I Mm-hmm. 3:57 And one of these people in this book, in some way or other, came afoul of the Trump administration. 4:01 In some cases, quite subtly, like they just couldn't do their job anymore because of the incompetence of the person on top of them kind of thing. 4:10 But the frame of the book, I thought, was the idea I would have walked into your office with is I would have said, Andrew, this is different, the Trump administration this time from the last time. 4:19 And it's worthy of kind of like a series. 4:22 And it's different because of all of a sudden... 4:26 It isn't just neglect. 4:27 It's malicious. 4:28 It's a malicious attack on what's there. 4:31 Now, you may approve of that attack. 4:33 You may disapprove of that attack. 4:35 But it's going to change the changing the nature of the executive branch. 4:38 They're turning it from this nonpartisan. 4:41 And I'm proposing to you, Andrew, editor, that the way we do this, the clever way to do this... 5:04 We're going to paint a portrait of this change in the executive branch by what can no longer exist there. 5:11 It's going to be kind of a negative space portrait. 5:14 We're going to move through the government, the different sort of functions of the government, and see how it's changing itself. 5:21 By who gets, who has been there forever and done a great job, no longer belongs there. 5:28 It's like the way you might describe a new habitat after some great environmental catastrophe by what species gets. 5:36 No, no, no, no, please. 6:04 I started, and I can imagine you having, and I having a conversation about this beforehand, that I was sort of thinking in terms of the functions, in a very abstract way, the functions of government. 6:15 I wasn't thinking Department of Energy, Department of Commerce, Department of the Treasury. 6:19 I was thinking like the refereeing function or the public safety function, which is so much of government, or the data collection and dissemination function. 6:30 Or the science, the long-term scientific research, things that the market doesn't do that we've all kind of agreed the government needs to do, or most of us have agreed to this. 6:40 And then in each bucket, I went out and sort of cast... 6:45 The story. 6:45 It looked like the big short that way. 6:47 I had the abstract sort of idea of what was going on. 6:50 And then I went out and just found, and I was spoiled for choice. 6:53 In each sort of function of government, you could find people who'd been run out who were kind of shocking that they were run out. 7:00 And in some cases, they were explicitly blockers. 7:03 This is Elon Musk's term. 7:04 He said he told his muskrats in the middle of the 20-somethings to go out and find the blockers and get rid of them. 7:10 In some places, they were actually those people. 7:12 In some cases, they were physically those people, like physically trying to keep people out of buildings. 7:16 But in other cases, it was someone who had been engaged in some long-term kind of public safety project, say, who all of a sudden found his funding gone. 7:28 And he just couldn't do his job anymore. 7:33 So that's sort of the idea of the book. 7:36 And if I'd come to you with that idea a year and a half ago in your office at the New Republic, what would you have said? 7:44 I'm curious. 7:45 You could say it was a stupid idea. 7:46 No, I think it's important that it be established that That these people are not sort of trying to subvert the government. 7:57 Correct. 7:57 Correct. 7:58 That's an important point to make. 8:00 They're not. 8:00 They're actually trying to sustain government. 8:03 Yes. 8:03 The thing that you got from your last book is, and this is something I'd like you to sort of talk about a little bit, is that you actually look to the people who do government, not the politicians, the actual machinery of it, the people who actually make And not 8:24 used 8:28 against you as a weapon. 8:30 No, exactly. 8:31 And let's think about the first term with Trump, right? 8:34 Because he comes in wanting to do all these things the same way he did the second term. 8:38 But the second term, it seems to me, he has one thing in his head, and that is these people tried to get 8:43 me last time. 8:45 That's, I think, what's motivating him. 8:47 He's not thinking about politics. 8:48 He's thinking about, who is out to get me? 8:50 I want to get them. 8:52 I've got to get rid of them. 8:53 And that was really the point of vote and the point of the entire attempt to sort of purge the government of his enemies. 9:02 I don't think it's a sort of even coherent enough that he's trying to get people in to make sure certain policies are pursued. 9:09 Oh, no, no, no, no. 9:10 I think it's, who are my enemies now? 9:12 Who hurt me? 9:14 How can I hurt them back? 9:15 That is it. 9:16 Regardless of whatever the government is, he's not interested in what the government is doing. 9:21 So he may not be, but he's empowered people who do care. 9:26 So it's, I think Trump won. 9:29 I mean, very broadly, I think the story of Trump won is the dog caught the bus. 9:32 I mean, I don't think he ever expected to win. 9:34 And sort of like when the dog caught his bus, he doesn't really know what to do. 9:38 And I think that it was... 9:40 And I never felt like if I was elected president, 9:59 The first thing you wanted to know is, like, what is going on? 10:01 Like, you want a lay of the land. 10:03 And he told Chris Christie that, like, it's all dumb. 10:06 We can learn about it in an hour. 10:08 We don't need this transition team. 10:09 Get rid of them. 10:10 Cost money. 10:11 And if you, on the ground, and this is the book I wrote, The Fifth Risk, on the ground, what it looked like was... 10:18 Indifference, negligence, no particular agenda, like driftlessness, like what are we supposed to be doing was the kind of been the question. 10:28 And in this case, it was a full frontal assault. 10:32 And let's get rid of, let's subject these people to our rule. 10:40 Now, I agree. 10:41 Trump's motive is probably just like, Get rid of my enemies and stall my friends. 10:47 It's probably as simple as that in his mind. 10:51 But he managed to have doing the job people who had other agenda and who could drill down. 10:57 So Elon Musk, Elon Musk isn't that different from Trump in how little he seemed to know about the government when he came in. 11:04 But Elon Musk does have particular things he wants. 11:07 He wants control of NASA, for example. 11:10 And he has, I think, a model in his mind of how you reform anything. 11:17 I think it's the model that he solves. 11:19 They're the beginning. 11:20 They're the point of the spear. 11:38 And at one point, the footnote that my eyebrows went up the most was your footnote saying, you talked to about a dozen Doge staffers. 11:48 Now, these people I tried to find in Washington. 11:52 I wanted to know who the hell they were and whether they were genuine, what they thought they were doing, what Musk thought he was doing, and what I still, I'll be honest with you, don't understand. 12:05 I don't get it. 12:27 And it is actually a real problem across the government. 12:31 The government does not do well in periods of rapid technological change. 12:35 It's not designed to move quickly or anything like that. 12:38 And I thought there was at least a possibility there would be some constructive stuff So what they did instead was go in and they being the people who were really the most active were the 20-somethings who were living in essentially bunk beds in 12:54 the General Services Administration's building with Musk. 12:57 And they'd be given badges and passes to go wherever they kind of wanted to go and told that they would receive pardons. 13:02 So don't worry about anything that might be slightly sketchy. 13:06 And they went in and They attacked programs and they attacked people. 13:12 Get rid of people, get rid of programs. 13:14 Like, cut, cut, cut. 13:15 Now, from the global kind of point of view, it was strange because if you're going to look at the... 13:23 Musk said he was going to cut two... 13:25 He was interested, he said, in the deficit. 13:27 If you're going to cut $2 trillion, as he claimed to be wanting to do, out of a roughly $7 trillion deficit... 13:35 You have to address the Defense Department and entitlements. 13:38 It's like, I don't know what it is, three quarters? 13:40 We Google it, but of the budget. 13:42 Instead, they focused all of the energy in the narrow sliver of the ply that wasn't those things. 13:48 And they did it without talking to Congress. 13:50 And Congress is where the money gets allocated to these things. 13:54 So right from the start, it was going to fail because of the way they went about it. 13:59 Now, then how they go about it is so strange because... 14:03 They couldn't really just, they couldn't, what you or I would like to do or see someone do is go in and figure out like who's good, who's not doing their job and like prune the workforce of people who are just kind of showing up and instead they found They learned quickly. 14:19 They couldn't actually fire those people. 14:21 They were civil service protections for everybody but the young people, or the so-called probationary workers, people who had only been there 18 months, two years. 14:30 And it is, so who are those people? 14:32 Those are the And the government desperately needs young people coming in. 14:36 And there are people who have been brought on for some urgent specific task, like something that's immediate, of immediate concern. 14:43 So those people, they could fire illegally, but illegally Because the rules are that you can't fire them but for cause. 14:52 And what they did systematically across the administration was try to get someone who was some civil servant to sign a piece of paper saying, yes, we're firing the 20,000 probation We had three missionary workers in our enterprise for cause, and people did that. 15:08 So they got told, you know, people who are doing a great job, who are young, were told, you're getting fired because you're not doing your job well. 15:13 So that's how they got rid of people. 15:15 And it's a mad way to get rid of people. 15:18 Getting rid of the people who might be doing the most productive work. 15:21 That's right. 15:22 And keeping the people who might be doing the less or the least. 15:27 Right. 15:38 A 28-year-old into, say, the Department of Veterans Affairs with no, I mean, less knowledge of the Department of Veterans Affairs than you or I have, and that's probably not very much. 15:49 And they would say, give me a list of all the contracts that the VA has, like all the money the VA is paying out. 15:57 And it would be a file with 90,000 things in it. 16:01 Now, what are you going to do with that? 16:02 Especially if you don't know what any of them are. 16:04 What they would do is they'd be given a list of keywords like bias or gender or even woman. 16:11 And they'd plug in the keyword. 16:13 And if the contract came up having that title in it, they'd just slash it. 16:18 And now, I mean, it's like a 12 year old could do a better job. 16:23 But that suggests a motive. 16:25 That suggests a motive. 16:26 That suggests that they're trying to get rid of woke stuff in federal government, right? 16:30 So then I understand that. 16:32 Then I understand. 16:33 Yeah. 16:33 Yeah. 16:48 Yes, yes. 16:49 However brutally and dumbly enforced, whereas before I really couldn't because they haven't saved any money. 16:55 I mean, you look at it, there's no money saved at all. 16:59 So what the hell were they doing? 17:01 So let's do the accounting briefly because this is all ludicrous. 17:03 But basically right. 17:04 So he started, Musk started by saying he was going to take $2 trillion out of the $7 trillion deficit. 17:11 In the end, they claimed to have cut like $150 billion, but the New York Times did an audit of it. 17:18 Yeah. 17:36 They fired all these people they had to keep paying not to work. 17:39 And they also fired, got rid of people who they realized they had to bring back. 17:42 And there were all these costs for what they did. 17:44 And it's probably true that the costs over, and never mind the cost of like the government being screwed up in various ways the future. 17:51 But just those costs probably more than offset whatever the gains were. 17:56 So it does. 17:56 So from my point of view anyway, it seems really weird that it's an odd exercise. 18:01 What are they doing? 18:02 And why is anybody letting them do it? 18:05 It's hard to explain because it doesn't... 18:07 When if you were to ask Elon, if we were to sit him down, if we could, and say, what were you trying to do? 18:13 And obviously you massively failed, right? 18:16 So you must have some... 18:18 He's not a stupid person. 18:21 Right, so I just want to know, what does he think happened? 18:24 What is he trying to do? 18:26 I don't know. 18:27 Yeah, no, you always have to ask, try to see the world through the point of view of the person you think is doing something dumb. 18:34 And I think... 18:38 And what about the kids? 18:40 What did they think they were doing? 18:42 I could tell you what some of the kids told me. 18:44 A couple of the kids said they thought they couldn't make sense of it once they started to see what they – and that – not all of them, but I had – A couple of them say that they tried to sort of make sense of why they were going about it the way they were going about it. 18:59 And the only thing that made sense to them was Elon's business interests, that it was all a cover for getting a hold of NASA, that that's all he cared about. 19:08 And what was Doge? 19:09 It wasn't a formal relationship. 19:23 And so it was a rattle bag of characters who 19:38 Most of, I mean, some of them were older people who were kind of maybe Musk adjacent in the business world. 19:45 A few of them were obviously his associates at like SpaceX and other places. 19:49 But below that, the people who were the most energetic were kind of in their 20s and early 30s and mostly had not made their fortunes in the world. 19:59 A lot of had... 20:01 Chips on their shoulder. 20:02 I mean, it seemed to be that one pattern I detected was, it wasn't strong, but it was fake. 20:08 It was strong enough to hear it that I didn't get into Harvard because of affirmative action. 20:14 I ended up at University of Iowa and that was outrageous. 20:17 And I was the smartest person I knew every, every year. 20:20 And the world doesn't know how smart I am, but Elon sees how smart I am. 20:23 There was that kind of character and, and, you know, kind of Never played sports, played a lot of video games, was good at video games. 20:33 And smart, very smart. 20:35 I mean, it's not that they aren't smart. 20:36 But had not actually done the thing that they worshipped Elon Musk for, had not actually created a company that was worth a lot That they had been sort of programmers at some company. 20:48 So they hadn't made it themselves. 20:51 And those people really, I think, swallowed hook, line and sinker that what Elon Musk said, it's all waste, fraud, abuse, get these people. 20:58 A lot of them are, you know, passionate Ayn Randians. 21:01 You know, there's that strain. 21:04 And I think we forget what we were like when we were 25. 21:09 I mean, I don't know if I could have done this when I was 25, but I might have. 21:13 And I mean, it's like, who lets 25-year-olds in with the keys and gives them the keys to the Ferrari and says, go as fast as you want to go? 21:20 You know what it sounds like to me? 21:21 And I think this is maybe the best guess at Musk. 21:26 Musk has no understanding of politics, really, except the crudest sort of ex-directed right-wing critiques of big government, right? 21:34 He doesn't really think about it. 21:35 He just thinks they're all bad and wrong. 21:37 Right. 21:38 Let me get a hold of this. 21:39 I know how to do this. 21:41 Gets in there, fucks up massively, realizes he can't do anything without breaking the law, breaks the law, et cetera, et cetera, realizes he's not getting anywhere, then runs away. 21:51 That is, to my mind, the best... 21:53 The basic explanation of Musk just actually being a brilliant person, but knowing nothing about politics, nothing about the way government works, which any smart person knows is a whole different kettle of fish. 22:07 Can I raise another question about Elon Musk? 22:10 And that is just how well suited he is to take over any organization and reform it. 22:18 Now, he's a really good promoter of his businesses. 22:22 Superb. 22:22 He's obviously good with engineers, you know, when they're working on an urgent project and have to move fast and break things. 22:30 But Twitter, by all accounts, is a disaster. 22:33 I mean, he did the same sort of thing with Twitter, and that's a simple business compared to... 22:38 And he came in and he's hid his mess. 22:40 It's like revenues collapsed. 22:43 It's not as good as it was. 22:46 And he hid it by shoving it into SpaceX. 22:48 So we'll never know just how bad it was. 22:51 But I don't know how, Elon Musk at this stage of his life, how well suited he is to come in and really manage any existing thing. 22:58 But the government, it's not a business. 23:01 It's a peculiar operation. 23:03 And he, I think also, It's probably also true that when you are the richest man in the world, or even the 10th richest man in the world, that at some point you're just surrounded by people who suck up to you all the time. 23:14 You think your jokes are funnier than they are, you think your profound pronouncements are more profound than they are, that everybody is telling you all the time how great you are, and there's no check on it. 23:25 So he had no one telling him, like, you're an idiot, don't do this. 23:30 But did you get a sense... 23:32 I was reading this book that the Trump administration knew that a lot of what they wanted to do was against the law. 23:38 And therefore, they had to kind of target the law in a way. 23:42 Target the law. 23:44 It's funny you say this. 23:45 Yes. 23:45 Target. 23:46 They needed to soften the machine. 23:48 I think that's right. 23:49 There are all these checks. 23:52 In some ways, there are too many checks. 23:56 I mean, it's just, it is hard to get things done. 23:59 But they did, it is true that, oh, here's an example. 24:03 Let's take an example. 24:04 I have a character named Kathleen Walters. 24:08 She sits in the bucket. 24:09 If I was coming into your office to pitch the piece, I would say, Andrew, it's really interesting. 24:13 If you look at the, one of the things the government does that people don't pay that much attention to, it is a data collection machine like almost none on earth. 24:20 And we know about ourselves. 24:21 We know about ourselves. 24:22 This data is absolutely necessary for the country to function. 24:27 And there are two buckets within the data collection function. 24:32 One is data that we want to gather and let everybody know about, like economic statistics or climate statistics or agriculture statistics that people can take and do things with and draw a clearer view of the world that helps us all make decisions. 24:46 And there's data that's sensitive and should be kept private, like tax data, like health data, like that kind of stuff, census data. 24:55 And Kathleen Walters was the chief privacy officer at the IRS. 25:00 No one said anything. 25:01 No one had a bad word to say about her. 25:02 She's like done her job beautifully for a long time. 25:05 She'd only been privacy officer for maybe seven or eight years, but she'd done her job in the IRS for decades very well. 25:12 And she sits between your tax returns and the Trump operation. 25:16 Like if they want to weaponize your tax returns, she was the human being between you and them. 25:21 And Doge comes in. 25:24 A fantastic character, I have to say. 25:30 I enjoyed Gavin quite a lot. 25:33 A man in black. 25:33 A man in black who is really good at offending people. 25:37 And he comes in saying basically everybody's wasteful, fraudulent, or abusive. 25:42 Like he just comes in guns blazing and comes for her at some point. 25:47 But he, however, did not go after the tax information. 25:53 He just created chaos in the place and fear and enough commotion that it was more probable that when the Department of Homeland Security goes after the tax information, there's 7 million taxpayers. 26:08 And we've been talking about tax returns in a special database called the ITIN tax returns where it was a mechanism created in the 1990s to give undocumented workers a way to file taxes because they don't have social security numbers. 26:23 That's right. 26:45 It was maybe diabolically clever of Stephen Miller or whoever it was behind the DHS thing to encourage, I don't know if he did it, but if you were DHS and you were hoping to get the IRS lady who was in charge of privacy to break the law and really break the law, 27:05 it's like very clear, and hand over these tax returns or these addresses, then It makes a lot of sense to send a Gavin Clark and create chaos beforehand. 27:14 It sort of softens the operation up. 27:17 And so it's the extent to which all this is- 27:23 They did eventually. 27:24 She tried to prevent this, but they did eventually, after she quit, get those addresses and found those people and deported them. 27:34 I mean, that's what was going on. 27:36 She quit before she was fired. 27:38 This is wonderful. 27:39 So I will get to that. 27:41 But this is a wonderful moment. 27:43 This is kind of when I decide, yes, I'm going to write about Kathleen Walters as opposed to the six other people I could have written about. 27:49 She's this very straightforward, effectless, I mean, charming lady who is just doing her job. 27:57 And she gets a call saying, Gavin's in the building and he's looking for you. 28:01 He's coming for you. 28:02 And she finds this conference room. 28:05 And locks herself in in the dark until he just gets, you can hide in the IRS building, it's vast, until he goes away and then slips out thinking he's so ADHD he'll just forget about it in the morning kind of thing. 28:18 And I thought of that scene, this woman who's just trying to protect people's information from bad people. 28:25 Having to hide in her own building. 28:27 So she managed to keep the returns out of the hands of DHS for a while. 28:32 She locked herself in the room where the files could be located. 28:35 Was that what she did? 28:36 No, she locked herself in the room because if they located her, they were going to fire and put someone in place to just hand them over. 28:42 And so if they couldn't find her, he couldn't fire her, which is her idea. 28:46 And so what happens, but what happens is interesting. 28:48 So there was actually, when I started in on the story, it was kind of a mystery. 28:53 She knew that She knew that some of the returns had probably been pilfered or handed over, like thousands, but she didn't know if millions had been. 29:04 And actually, the question I had was, how would you know? 29:08 Unless someone from DHS comes out and says, yeah, we got these things. 29:12 Now, there is a lawsuit in which in the district court, in the D.C. 29:16 district court that has revealed it's been exposed that the IRS first, the Trump people in the IRS first lied and then I was giving a talk. 29:25 I can't remember. 29:39 I don't remember where. 29:40 Miami, Atlanta. 29:41 And it was to an association of people who owned apartment complexes. 29:46 And you'd be amazed how many people own large numbers of apartment complexes. 29:50 Like 8,000 people in the audience. 29:52 Maybe not that many. 29:53 4,000. 29:54 And the guy who I've never met, who is going to interview me on stage, meets me in the green room. 29:59 His name is Antonio Marquez. 30:02 And I say, what do you do? 30:03 He says, well, I own apartment complexes. 30:04 I said, what kind? 30:05 He says, well, through the South and Southwest, and it's largely low-income Latinos and a lot of undocumented in our apartment complexes. 30:14 And I started to say, have you had problems with ICE turning up on He goes, oh my God, how did you know? 30:20 Like, how did you know? 30:21 We've had in the last couple of months, all of a sudden they have the addresses and we don't know how. 30:27 And so he plugged me in to the world of people who house these people and they're all having this problem. 30:35 And the only answer is this. 30:36 I mean, this is what happened. 30:37 This is how they found the addresses. 30:40 But what's also fascinating about this because it makes it drama in a way. 30:43 There is physical... 30:45 And make sure your podcast is up to date with The Dishcast. 31:15 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 31:20 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 31:25 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 31:33 It's very easy. 31:35 Andrewsullivan.substack.com is 50 bucks a year. 31:37 Great value for money. 31:38 You also get with that the entire weekly dish every Friday. 31:43 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 31:48 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's dishcast. 31:51 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 32:02 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 32:05 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 32:08 Join the debate. 32:09 Join the fun. 32:11 Subscribe.
Community discussion