0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there, welcome to The Dishcast. 0:32 And what a Dishcast it is. What a day it is. 0:34 What a week it is. 0:36 It's actually been a pretty brutal week for me. 0:39 We're going to give you a little TMI before we begin today's conversation. 0:43 I spent Monday and Tuesday of election week Either compulsively violently vomiting into a bucket or a toilet, followed by a day of close to a coma. 0:55 I was out for 13 hours. 0:58 I know that because my little ring tells me. 1:00 All of which is a yet another moment when the GLP side effects just completely knocked me over. 1:07 So I have actually finally come to the conclusion that I'm giving it up. 1:11 I'm not doing any more to Zepatide. 1:16 Almost two years, I've had now four huge, horrible episodes of Side Effects, one of which took me to the ER. 1:25 If I didn't know what I was going through yesterday or Monday, I would have gone to the ER. 1:30 That's how bad it is. 1:31 It's like a... 1:33 I counted it. 1:34 It's six and a half hours of vomiting until you have nothing to vomit left. 1:40 It's nothing to do with and you don't feel any better after you vomit. 1:43 Anyway, absolute horror. 1:45 So my week started pretty roughly, but I'm feeling better today and it's beautiful out here. 1:52 And I want to thank you after my quick TMI for subscribing because we really need you. 1:59 We need you especially now. 2:01 We don't do anything here. 2:03 We have to gin up extra money. 2:04 We don't do sponsorships, we Don'T Do Advertising, I'm Not Going To Sell You A Lawn Mower. 2:08 So please if you enjoy these conversations and we're trying to do really high quality in -depth ones Please support us and subscribe. 2:17 If you haven't then this will peter out very quickly just when it's getting good And if you have thank you so much for doing it. 2:26 We have some great people coming up. 2:27 We have Frank Fukuyama is coming on to talk about his memoir and his reflections on where we are in world politics and history. 2:35 Cynthia Burak, someone who went through and pioneered the study of gender studies and came out the other end feeling a lot worse for it. 2:44 Hamish McKenzie is coming on to talk about Substack and journalism. 2:48 Cyrus Habib is coming on to talk about why he left politics to become a Jesuit priest. 2:54 And then we have Graham Tomlin coming on to talk about Pascal and Nancy Sherman coming on to talk about Aristotle. 3:00 It's part of our series of some big thinkers. 3:03 But today I'm delighted to say that my guest is an old friend and an icon, really, of Washington journalism. 3:11 He will cavil at that. 3:13 I can already see him shuddering at the thought of being called an icon of anything. 3:17 But anyway, Michael Barone... 3:20 Has forgotten more about American politics than you and I will have learned in a lifetime. 3:24 He's a journalist and a historian. 3:27 He's currently the senior political analyst for the Washington Examiner. 3:31 He's the resident fellow emeritus at AEI. 3:35 Michael's brain is just a sponge. 3:45 Anyway, of all the people I thought 3:58 To talk about these elections, I thought, Michael, would be perfect. 4:01 And so, Michael, I'd just like to thank you so much for coming on and sharing your thoughts with us. 4:07 Well, thank you very much, Andrew. 4:09 I've been a reader and admirer of yours for various transmogrifications going back well over 30 years. I know. 4:18 I'm on to 40, I think. I know. 4:20 It's insane. 4:22 It's insane to think we're that old. 4:25 But we are. And I've... 4:27 Yeah, well, I've been following this and I have been... 4:32 Moving in my career from one job to another, I claim to be a recovering pollster. 4:40 I spent seven years as the vice president with Peter Hart. 4:44 He's a Democratic pollster. 4:46 My political journey has taken me somewhat to the right and wobbling around over a period of time. 4:54 So I have a certain sympathy with people who change parties. 4:58 After all, Winston Churchill did it twice. Ratted twice. 5:03 He did, as he said. 5:05 But I always think of you... 5:08 Very lucky to be a witness of these things from a young age, actually. 5:13 When did you first start being a sort of nerd about American politics? 5:18 When did You get the bug to understand the details of what was going on? 5:23 Well, you know, I was fortunate to grow up in the Detroit metropolitan area. 5:29 Detroit was then the number five city in the country. 5:34 It was the number one auto producer, number one. 5:39 We had the biggest factory in America. 5:42 We had produced the biggest aircraft factory during World War II. 5:47 We were proud that even as we were training children to duck under their little tables in case of atomic attack, that we were going to be a target. 6:00 They were going to go after Detroit, the arsenal of democracy. 6:03 So I thought I was growing up in an important place and is one small cog in a very large machine. 6:13 I mean, I lived, I spent my first conscious years in northwest Detroit in a little town. 6:19 Two-bedroom house, my two parents and one and then two sisters. 6:27 I learned early on, two blocks away, was the holding place for Ward 22 Precinct 221. 6:35 That 221 tells you that you're one small part of a very large unit in industrial America when we were used to being dragooned, when we had had a country that at the time of my birth had 16 million men in the military serving in a country of 130 million people. 6:59 The equivalent today would be a U.S. military of 40 million 7:04 That's a whole different world. 7:07 It is a whole different world. 7:10 And that's a world in which we thought about nuclear warfare. 7:16 We assumed that people my age would be called up to serve in the military and in a war. 7:22 They'd have world wars every 20 years. 7:27 It was going to be time. 7:29 So was that partly what motivated your interest? 7:33 Well, and also I started off in a public school that was, the student body was, as it happened, about a third Catholic, third Protestant, and a third Jewish. 7:46 And I thought, hey, this is America. 7:50 And I was aware of these things more than I suppose most kids were. 7:58 And I remember one time when my mother, I think, was going to meet Martha Griffiths, who was elected to the Democratic Congresswoman, turned over a district for the Democrats in the 1954 election. 8:12 And she made the comment to me that the Catholics usually voted Democratic and the Protestants mostly voted Republican. 8:20 And I thought to myself, why should that be so? 8:25 And I have been trying to ask and answer questions of that variety ever since, which is, I guess, about 70 years ago. 8:34 So I was interested in these things. 8:37 And we also had part of the great northward migration. 8:42 Metro Detroit in 1940, a few years before I was born, had 150,000 black people. 8:53 And 25 years later, In 1965, Metro Detroit had 600,000 black people. 9:03 That's a quadrupling of the population in a city that had 1,849,568 people in the 1950 census, of 9:14 which I was one. 9:16 I'm just pausing to note that that number came out of your brain. 9:22 Well, I mean, I made lists as a child for the U.S. 9:29 cities and population, so I copied all those digits down. 9:33 So that's the best way to remember anything, right? 9:36 1950 census, New York City, $7,891,900. 9:42 75, I think I may be wrong about the last two digits. 9:46 Los Angeles had passed Detroit and it was 1,970,357 and so forth. 9:55 You're undoubtedly aware of all these data. 9:59 I don't have them on the tip of my tongue the way you do. 10:02 But Michael, you're not disproving your chops as a super nerd. 10:08 But there's something that happens that you grew up just thinking, I want to master this. 10:13 You know, I think Nate Silver is a bit like that. 10:16 There were people who just, they just, as kids or as young adults, they're like, why is this happening? 10:21 And they just become obsessed and they follow very closely. 10:24 And of course, you're also... 10:26 You are also aware of this is America. 10:28 This is the history, the story of America. 10:31 Well, my parents were people who read, you know, I used to think they didn't read magazines very well. 10:38 Well, they had three young children. 10:40 And one thing I've learned in life is that the time when you read less, 10:47 My mother used to tell me to go out and play in the backyard, and I would sneak down the basement stairs where we kept our set of world book encyclopedias and study these numbers and page around in different pages to try to learn about history and the order of the kings 11:11 of England, of the United Kingdom and so forth naturally from 1066 on all those things you would want to know. 11:21 And I was always puzzled that none of the other kids seemed 11:27 to be interested in the census. Why wouldn't they be? 11:30 Well, it is fascinating, right? 11:33 Well, it's fascinating. 11:37 I also had a wide acquaintance in what was one of America's largest and most prominent metro areas. 11:48 We grew up in Detroit. 11:49 I used to say we lived in a neighborhood. 11:51 There were factory workers on either side of us. 11:55 I grew up in a neighborhood of factory workers, and my father made his living with his hands. 12:01 Now, that's not entirely a thing. 12:04 We moved to Bloomfield Township, which was a high-income suburb, when I was 11, and my father was a surgeon. 12:13 So, you know, it was—we lived—but I had—I entered private schools in a series— A place called Cranbrook and the Cranbrook Schools in Bloomfield Hills, Michigan, which your friend of mine, Michael Kinsley, 12:30 went to six years after me and a variety of other people that we've heard of. 12:36 And so I got to be classmates of the sons of auto company vice presidents and things like that. 12:46 So I had exposure. 12:48 To all levels of Metro Detroit. 12:52 And I can remember going with my father on weekends. 12:56 He would go to the hospital, Highland Park Hospital, where I was born, and look in on patients and we could do rounds. 13:07 And we would go through an area and he would say, that area of a square mile has changed from all white to To all black within the year, within 12 months. 13:22 Now, my parents always opposed racial discrimination and things. 13:27 They just thought it was just wrong and foolish. 13:32 And they disliked restrictions against Jews joining clubs and everything. 13:36 That was just foolishness. 13:39 And they didn't want to take any part in that. 13:48 So I was exposed to a whole bunch of- 13:50 Yeah, every class, every race, Republicans, Democrats. 13:54 Yeah, pretty much. 13:56 If you went to the Brightmoor neighborhood of Detroit or to Hazel Park, Madison Heights, and north side of Pontiac, people spoke with Kentucky accents a generation after their parents had left the Hill Country. Yeah. 14:12 Yeah, you've always been fascinated by also these ethnic lineages and how they alter and have affected history. 14:22 Constituencies and districts forever. 14:24 Tell me, and then you went to of course Harvard and Yale. Why not? 14:30 You did Yale Law. 14:31 You're obviously very bright. 14:33 But why did... Let me ask you two questions. 14:35 Why did you stick with being interested in politics and why did you lean more to the right as you grew older? 14:43 Well a couple things. 14:46 Why was I interested in politics? 14:48 I did precinct work for the Democratic Party with groups of friends in 1964. 14:56 The county chairman of the Democratic Party was then Sander Levin, who later spent 30 years in Congress, is still alive today at age 95. 15:06 And he sort of retired from public view, I think. 15:11 But it's so I got to know people on the ground, people who are enthusiastic for different parties and met a few conservatives at that time and had friendly enough relations with them. 15:25 I was puzzled, started with the Democratic Party in 1964 and took it downhill. 15:34 From winning, you know, 290 congressional districts, Lyndon Johnson left side, 61% of the vote. 15:43 And so I got in on the ground floor. 15:46 I was interested in politics, public affairs. 15:51 The Michigan I grew up in. 15:54 More than most states was a state that divided people along economic lines. 16:00 You were either with the union, the UAW. 16:03 In democratic politics, we just called it the union. 16:07 Everybody knew what you were talking. 16:10 Or you favored the management at the auto companies and things. 16:15 You know, there was a story that the 16:20 Two sisters, one married George Edwards, UAW organizer, later Detroit Police Commissioner, federal judge. 16:30 Appeals judge and the other married the son of Bunky Knudsen. 16:35 Bunky Knudsen, the son of William Knudsen, who had been president of General Motors, a dollar-a-year man for getting the U.S. 16:44 business involved in military effort in 1940, well before Pearl Harbor. 16:49 The two sisters didn't speak for 20 years. 16:54 They were on the other side of the fence, and I mixed with people on both sides of that fence. 17:01 So, continued to be interested in that, studied this sort of thing. 17:06 And when did you launch the Almanac? 17:09 When did that sort of come together? 17:11 The Almanac started after law school, but it owed something to the fact that I was on the staff of the Harvard Crimson, the newspaper, and At Harvard, and it was on the Law Journal, the Law Review at Yale Law School where I did a lot of writing. 17:32 In my secondary school grandbook we were assigned to at least 1 ,000 words of writing every weekend. 17:40 Well, it served you well as a colonist 17:42 all these years! Writing about this... 17:44 So I wrote about politics in the Harvard Crimson. 17:49 You can summon all this up online. 17:52 I wrote a piece called The New Snobbery about the new mirror of New York, John Lindsay in January 1966. 18:02 It's actually quite prescient. 18:05 With the idea of you've got a liberal coalition of support from black people and from upper income, high education whites. 18:16 And I thought, well, that's a coalition that... 18:20 It kind of ignores large numbers of people in between and doesn't seem to give them much respect. 18:28 Does that sound a little bit familiar the last decade or two? 18:31 It sounds the last 25 years, to be honest with you. 18:33 So I was spotting that issue in 1966, which is, what, 60 years ago? 18:41 I think that's called being right too soon, Michael. 18:46 After law school, I was a law clerk to a federal judge. 18:50 And my friend Grant Ujafusa, whom I met at the Crimson, had an idea that students rebelling against the May 1970 invasion of Cambodia invasion, He would write a guide to other students and give descriptions of every state, district, every senator, 19:16 every member of the House so that people would know who they had to lobby to do this. And it occurred to him after a while that a book of that nature, if it was written accurately, would be useful to a large number of people with different political views. 19:33 And I said, why did you call me? 19:36 When I was a law clerk to a federal judge in Detroit and said, would you be interested in working on this? 19:46 Well, I thought it would never come to anything. 19:48 But I said yes. 19:49 And I said, why did you call me? 19:52 And he said, well, he said When we first met at the Crimson, you always ask people, where are they from? 19:59 And he said he was from Worland, Wyoming. 20:02 And I said, oh, that's the western terminus of U.S. 16. 20:07 I happen to know had made a list of all the terminuses of the U.S. 20:13 double-digit highways in the country and so forth as it then was. 20:19 And he said he was so impressed. 20:21 He said no one at Harvard had ever heard of Worland and many had never heard of Wyoming. 20:28 Yeah. So he said, I knew that you were the person that should work on this book. 20:34 And all you have to do is write written descriptions of every state and congressional district. 20:40 And you can surely do that in a few months. 20:44 And it took more than that. 20:46 But the first issue came out in November 1971, which is what, what, 55 years ago. 20:56 And it turned out to be successful. 21:00 It was published by an eccentric publisher named Lovell Thompson in Boston. 21:05 It got mentioned in Time Magazine, and I think the New York Times sold out its printing. 21:14 And... 21:15 Well, for a long time, if you were working in political journalism, you had the latest almanac. 21:22 It was every two years, right? 21:27 It wasn't just the data. 21:29 It wasn't just the results. 21:31 It was the changing demographics. 21:34 It was a rich portrait of every individual district that was rich. 21:40 I mean, it was not just numbers. 21:42 It was not juste data. 21:45 It was also history and ethnicity and a cultural sensibility in those portraits of districts. Well, thank you. 21:54 That's what I... 21:56 One of my basic theories that I've caved through this business is That politics has more often divided Americans along lines of culture rather than economics. 22:10 This was contrary to my experience growing up in Michigan where economics was the real dividing line. 22:16 It was contrary to the teaching of the New Deal historians who really set a vision for America that still has a hold on people, in part because they're just beautiful writers. 22:30 And that Franklin Roosevelt in particular is an endlessly fascinating people and is, in my opinion, one of the people that saved Western civilization. 22:42 Mm-hmm. 22:44 And so forth. 22:45 It was, you know, but I thought the cultural aspects were more important. 22:51 I mean, people were not voting for George Wallace just because of, in 1968, presidential election as an independent candidate, 13.5% of Americans did. 23:04 And it would be extremely hard. 23:06 Just because of economics, they were part of a cultural vision. 23:10 They had a sense. 23:12 And one of the things they also had, when you sketched out maps of the counties that he carried, and obviously this was something I always liked to do, color-code it. 23:22 I used to color-code Democrats red and the Republicans blue as... 23:28 In line with European and British tradition. 23:31 But, of course, the networks decided to do it opposite ways. 23:35 So it's a little... That was 19... When did they... 23:37 It was 2000 that they really switched the red and blue, right? 23:41 That suddenly red was... Well, earlier than that. 23:43 No, by the 70s. 23:44 Oh, really? 23:45 By the 70's. Yeah. Huh. 23:47 So they were, well, I think part of it was that, remember, the journalists at that time and the people running the networks were mostly liberals. 23:55 They were familiar with the anti-communist, and they had, I think, a somewhat distorted view of the anti-communist views in the 1940s and 50s. 24:09 They pictured Joe McCarthy as a dominant figure of the age, which I think is an overstatement. 24:19 So they didn't want the Democrats to be red because people would think they were 24:23 communists. 24:25 Oh, I see. I see. 24:27 They switched it around. 24:28 So we're stuck with red states and blue states now being assigned to the inappropriate party, in my view. 24:36 But one lives with that. 24:38 Those crafty liberal elitists. 24:41 Well, this was... 24:42 No, I know, I know, I know. 24:43 I'm just kidding. 24:46 Anyway, let's get to the current situation. 24:48 I mean, I'm jumping right ahead. 24:51 13 points. 24:54 Is the margin in the popular vote, I understand, which I also understand is the biggest margin for any single party in the congressional election since 1976 or 74. 25:10 and 76 are almost identical. 25:12 Yeah, it's very close. 25:14 What did you... 25:16 When you heard, when you realized that what was your reaction? 25:23 Well, as I said, my lead piece for the Washington Examiner, which I spent much of today drafting, was the, it was more than a thumping, the term that George W. 25:37 Bush used to describe what happened to the Republicans in the 2006 off-year election 20 years ago. 25:46 Certain resemblances in this, but not necessarily a realignment. 25:52 I think it's, If you look at the numbers of seats for each candidate, each party, what you're looking at is sort of at the outer limits of what we've seen in this period of polarized partisan polarity that we've had. 26:14 A period of mostly and increasing straight, for most of the time, straight ticket voting. 26:21 An increase towards nationalizing of issues as opposed to people in the South voting Democratic because of the Civil War and so forth. 26:33 That was part of the politics that I was studying in the 1960s and 70s. 26:46 So I was just trying to think. 26:49 Since the 80s, say, have we ever, have we had, I mean, since Reagan, have we had an election, a congressional election, which seemed to really move the needle? 26:59 I guess 2010 was pretty close, right? 27:01 I mean, that was the Tea Party election. 27:03 No, we've had, well, we've had differences. 27:07 The period from 1952 to circa 1992, we had a period of almost entirely divided government. 27:17 The Republicans tended to win the presidency, and by a pretty significant margin, if you average those Elections from 1920 to 1988, you're looking at the Republicans outvoting the Democrats by something like 52 to 46 percent of the popular vote, averaging over 50. 27:44 Over 18 elections. 27:45 In the presidential votes. 27:47 In the presidential race, you have during that period, the Democrats control the House of Representatives in every single election. 27:56 They never have fewer than 243 votes, members of the House and so forth. 28:06 And they have They have, you know, so this. And since then. 28:12 From 1958 to 1992. 28:15 But in presidential elections, starting in 92, in House elections in 94, we get a change. 28:24 Two baby boomers are particular architects of that. 28:28 Bill Clinton, aided by the political philosopher James Carville, removes the Republican lock on the presidency. 28:39 Newt Gingrich, aided by all sorts of people, Dick Armey and Bob Walker and so forth. 28:47 Get rid of the Democratic lock on the House of Representatives two years later. 28:53 And since then, we've had results within a narrower partisan range. 29:01 So the Democrats have won four of seven presidential elections starting in 1992. 29:09 They've won them by a popular vote average of 49 to 46. 29:14 Hmm. 29:14 That's kind of a narrower range than we saw in the period from Eisenhower to Reagan and Reagan-Bush. 29:24 We have the Republicans winning the House of Representatives in 12 out of 16 elections starting 1994, but it's rather narrow range again. 29:38 Basically, Who gets more than... 29:40 243 was the minimum that the Democrats won from 58 to 92. 29:48 Republicans have exceeded that number only once in 2014. 29:54 Democrats have exceeded that only once in 2008. 30:00 They got 257 in the year that Barack Obama was elected president. 30:06 And the presidential levels, similarly... 30:10 In, I think, seven out of ten presidential elections from 52 to 88, the winner got more than 53 percent of the vote. 30:19 Nobody since then in presidential race has gotten more than 53 percent. 30:25 Barack Obama got 52.9, rounded off to 53, but... 30:31 A little bit below. 30:32 In that context. 30:34 This election is, with the Democrats winning something over 250 House seats, looks like the 257 that they won in 2008 after Bush's thumping in 2006 and then additional Democratic gains in the 2008 election year. 30:56 And that... 31:00 One of the things that we saw, we've seen seven of the nine presidential elections since 1992. 31:09 We have seen each party win trifectas, the presidency, majority of the Senate, majority of the House. 31:21 In six of those seven cases, they lost that trifecta in the next off-year election. 31:28 And that in the last two cases, their trifectas were based on very small majorities in the House for Joe Biden in 2020, for Donald Trump in 2024. 31:45 How much has gerrymandering played a role in this? 31:52 It seems that you can have big... 31:54 Numerical majorities, but the seats changing hands seem to get fewer and fewer as each election. 32:01 Am I right about that? 32:03 Well, you're more or less right about that. 32:06 Yeah, I think it's within pundits' distance. 32:13 No, one of the things that both parties did with this redistricting and the intersensal redistricting, As I call it, the district thing that you have to district to meet the equal population standard. 32:29 The Supreme Court said 1964, you have to do that after each census if you've got more than one district. 32:38 But Trump decided to do that one more time. 32:41 But we've had it additionally because basically the Republicans started to redistribute. 32:51 They had huge sort of what I call bacon strip redistricting in Illinois in particular. 32:58 They have these little bacon strip districts that started a particular ward in Chicago that has a heritage from one ethnic group or one family, Michael Madigan's ward or whatever. 33:11 And somebody then extending out into the suburbs and into the prairies and things. 33:18 And they practically eliminate Republican representation in the Illinois delegation. 33:26 The Republicans attempted to have done something like that in Texas, but less egregiously, replacing Democrats' quite egregious bacon stripping that was Done in which a federal judge continued in 1992 on the grounds 33:45 that people somehow had a constitutional right to continue to be represented by people with lots of seniority. 33:52 So you wouldn't want to give these Democrats un-seniority. 33:55 Unsafe districts under the Constitution. 34:00 That was one I never figured out. 34:04 Republicans redistricted on the basis of Donald Trump's gains in particular among working class Hispanic districts and so forth. 34:15 And that proved to be misleading. 34:19 The North Carolina redistricting process. 34:22 Which is done by the legislature. 34:25 Governor can't veto it. 34:27 North Carolina initially never had a governor's veto because in 1789, North Carolina disliked executive dominance 34:37 and so forth. 34:39 Only you would know that one, Michael. 34:42 Yeah, but I wasn't around for that one. 34:46 But the... 34:48 But what I'm trying to get at is the margin this time seems to be... 34:51 But they became dummy-mandered. 34:53 Right, the margin this time... 34:55 Right, dummy-mandered, that's a... 34:57 Yeah, the dummy manders, because they ended up losing seats that they intended to win. 35:04 If you go pig in redistricting, there's a chance you could become roast pork when segments of the electorate changed their view. 35:15 And you had the chairman of the House Republican Campaign Committee, Richard Hudson of North Carolina, was defeated. 35:24 I think that's happened since James Corman of the San Fernando Valley in Los Angeles was head of the Democrats campaign committee, was defeated in 1980. 35:41 I saw that both parties did though Was reduce the number of districts that were D plus two or R plus two and move them to districts that were D plus nine or R plus nine. 36:00 One of the stories of this election is that with those numbers based on the previous presidential election, Republicans were losing almost all districts that were less than R plus nine. 36:15 The difference from some previous elections are there are fewer districts that are R plus one to R plus nine. Right. 36:24 And that's probably going to be the modus operandi for the future, right? 36:30 I have disliked the way both parties have gone against trying to chop up Memphis, the black majority district in Memphis and in southern Alabama and Louisiana. 36:46 I think that's untoward. 36:48 The Democrats have done similar things to Republican Democrats. 36:53 Groups in the Central Valley of California and in Orange and Riverside County, Southern California. 37:04 But that's the way it's done at this point. 37:09 One thing J.D. Vance said just after the vote in a tweet was that before he'd heard this 13% margin possibility, but he'd also heard from his own internal pollsters that demographics look good for them. 37:24 That in fact, the demographics that they had, the number of men turning out, the number of the people that used to vote for Republicans were showing up. 37:34 And he was reassured by that until he realized they were showing up, yes, but they were showing up and voting for the Democrats. 37:40 What's the big demographic take you take from this election? 37:46 What has happened in the demography of politics in this country in the last two years? 37:52 It's been a big shift. 37:54 Well, there was, you know, I will give you one analysis that I led with in one of my recent mid-October columns in the Washington Examiner. 38:07 One of the most effective ads for Donald Trump in 2024 was photos of videotape of Kamala Harris assuring people Back in 2019, that she was for government payment of sex change operations for prison inmates. 38:26 And she had never wavered in this and was always for this very important issue and so forth. 38:35 And the tagline on the thing was, Kamala is for they, them. 38:41 President Trump is for you. 38:44 And he underlined that, I think, with that sort of marvelous visual of him at McDonald's in Lower Bucks County, Pennsylvania, marginal county, marginal suburban, marginal congressional district. 39:01 And he was at the Fry Station and the drive-thru windows serving people, conveying the idea that President Trump is serving you. 39:12 Well, what's he been doing the last couple of years? 39:16 The ballroom. 39:17 Those horrible, gaudy, golden things on the wall in the Oval Office. 39:27 I was going to suggest you get a few of those for the brick wall that you have there. 39:38 The whole business about the triumphal arch and everything. 39:43 The Trump family making money off various ventures that seem to some people to be pretty shady. 39:51 And then the day before the election, he's at the reflecting pool, which he tried to clean up. 39:58 And he explains this is important. 40:01 What happened to the guy at McDonald's? 40:04 He's staring at his image of himself in the reflecting pool like Narcissus. 40:13 And this is at odds with the idea that he's serving you. 40:20 And, you know, you get into substantive issues on this as well. 40:24 But basically, it was a sense that he has become part of the elite that he was supposed to oppose. 40:31 Well, that he's indulging himself. 40:34 L'état c'est moi. 40:38 The tariffs. 40:39 He's just about the only person in the country... 40:43 That thinks tariffs are a great policy. 40:47 Putting on my recovering pollster hat, there's no demand among the public for tariffs. 40:55 And certainly for a president that sits in his golden office adjusting the tariffs up and down and doubling the 50% tariff on Canada, putting on my Michigan hat, He's putting on tariffs on what has been a free trade agreement between the U.S. 41:20 and Canada supported by the Detroit Three Manufacturers and the UAW. 41:26 Going back to the auto parts agreement of 1965, that's 61 years ago. 41:34 And suddenly he's increasing the tariffs on that 50%. 41:38 And then he's wondering why... 41:40 Why Republicans are not carrying Michigan. 41:45 Right. Or the statement he put out, which I thought was kind of a truly staggering statement, which was about oil gas prices, saying, well, they tell me not to say this, but it's not so bad. 41:56 You have a little bit at the pump, but we're making a freaking fortune. 42:00 The oil companies in America in general are making a freaking fortune out of all of this. 42:05 Now that, I mean, at some point you're just like, has he lost... 42:09 Well, there's any reality. 42:12 There was an old statewide politician, Democrat from Orange County named Ken Kari, who in the 1970s said that he ran with the tagline and nothing else in it. 42:25 The oil company's worst enemy, Ken Koren. 42:30 I asked him what that had to do with the position of controller of the state of California going after the oil companies. 42:38 He said, well, basically nothing. 42:40 He said, but the oil companies are unpopular and I'm going to go after the oil companies. 42:47 Well, you know, he's taken the opposite advice of that. 42:50 And also, the politician says, It reminds me of when Fred Barnes, the reporter, the colleague of yours at the New Republic, I think at one time, Fred said that whenever Tony Blankley, Newt Gingrich's press secretary, 43:08 whenever Newt Gingrich said, Tony told me not to say this, but he said, then you know Newt is getting himself into trouble. 43:18 Well, that's what Trump has said. 43:20 But there's a... 43:22 And let's actually also go to the state shifts. 43:27 What was the state that most surprised you? 43:30 Hi there. 43:31 This is not the end of this podcast. 43:34 In fact, we're only just getting going. 43:38 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast info. 43:45 No extra charge. 43:46 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 43:57 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 44:02 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 44:07 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 44:15 It's very easy. 44:17 AndrewSullivan.substack.com is 50 bucks a year. 44:19 Great value for money. 44:21 You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 44:25 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 44:30 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 44:34 So all those questions you had in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 44:44 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 44:47 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 44:50 Join the debate. 44:52 Join the fun. 44:53 Subscribe.
Community discussion