0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there. 0:29 Welcome to another exciting, riveting, accelerating edition of The Dishcast. 0:37 It is an absolutely lovely fall here. 0:39 I thought I'd just share that with you. 0:41 I'm still kind of a little buoyed by last week in an unaccountably good mood. 0:48 I have a good stoner friend of mine just crashing overnight, which is always fun. 0:52 So we sat there and We got high and watched Mobland, which is, I don't know whether any of you guys out there are watching Mobland, but I have become obsessed with this show. 1:01 It's absurd. 1:03 It's an absolutely ridiculous, silly, North London gangster show. 1:07 Guy Ritchie sort of... 1:10 And it has these incredibly campy old Irish characters in it. 1:15 Pierce Brosnan, for God's sake, playing this old Irish gangster. 1:18 And his wife, Helen Mirren. 1:20 Just like this extraordinary old hag. That's what she's playing. 1:25 You know, she's proof that, you know, the one thing the Irish can never give up are their grudges. 1:30 And she's a vicious, nasty person. 1:32 And then, of course, in the middle of this is Tom Hardy. 1:37 You know, and I could just... 1:39 Watch him sit still for like a few hours. 1:41 But he plays this fixer, the guy who really gets everything done. 1:46 His name is Harry D'Souza. 1:48 And he talks like this. 1:49 He's very gentle in a way he talks to you. 1:53 And he asks you, would you please do this for me? 1:56 Or if you don't, I'll just break your fucking legs. 1:59 And maybe break your arms as well. 2:02 But if you do, it'll be all right. We'll have a good time. 2:05 All right, yeah? 2:06 He literally does not change his affect or tone at any point in the 2:13 show apart 2:15 from, and I just watched him orchestrate the hanging of a man. 2:20 And it's just, I mean, anyway, it's ridiculous. 2:23 And completely compulsive TV. 2:26 It's on Paramount+. 2:27 I'm not being paid for this. 2:29 Which brings me to my usual pitch, which is I am not being paid by anybody else to do this except by you. 2:38 And if you don't pay, I won't do it. That's as simple as that. 2:41 And this has always been the principle behind this very simple model. 2:46 And so please subscribe. 2:48 If you haven't subscribed, this will cut off at a point where you really don't want it to, because that's Bowden's explicit instructions for the cliffhanger. 2:58 But do, it's fun. 2:59 And it is about the revival of Independent media. 3:05 We're 3:07 six and a half years. 3:09 How many years are we in now, Chris? 3:11 Six and a half? 3:13 Seems like only yesterday we started, but it's because of you. 3:17 And you know who you are, and we're really grateful. 3:20 I don't want to say that every week, but we really, really are grateful. 3:22 We have some great guests coming up. 3:26 We have Cynthia Burak, who's this really remarkable pioneer of gender studies who ended up being chewed up and spat out by it. 3:33 And she's done some chewing up and spitting out herself and she comes on the show to talk about it. We have Cyrus Habib, a really fascinating man who... 3:44 Very, very successful young politician, road scholar, who's becoming a Jesuit priest. 3:49 And we talk about his journey. 3:51 We have Anna Hutchinson and Paul Garcia Ryan, who's talking about therapy for kids with gender dysphoria. 3:59 How do we help them if we're not going to mutilate them or put them on blockers? 4:04 How do we actually make sure this population is taken care of? 4:08 And they have this amazing organization called Therapy First, which is really about talk therapy with kids. 4:15 And I think one of the great weaknesses that my side of this debate has had is that we've been very good at saying no, that we haven't been better at saying what we can actually positively do to help kids who are going through this, who don't need to make irreversible decisions, 4:32 let alone before they've gone through puberty. 4:34 We have Peter J. 4:35 Williams is coming on to write about the historical authenticity of the Gospels. 4:39 We have Graham Tolman coming in to talk about Blaise Pascal, Nancy Sherman on Aristotle. 4:45 I mean, where else are you going to get this, guys? 4:47 This is who we are. 4:49 We are The Dish. 4:51 We've always been The Dish. 4:53 We're 26 years old this year, and thank you. 4:57 This week, I'm saying a lot of this media stuff because of our guest this week, who's... 5:04 Who has pioneered the platform you are now part of. 5:10 And The Dish has benefited so enormously from. 5:14 And in fact, I think it would be impossible for me to conceive of a career in the last few years without Substack. 5:23 Even though, as we will get into, I was capable of doing this without Substack. 5:28 But with Substack, all the better. 5:31 Hamish McKenzie. 5:32 He's one of the co-founders of The Bloody Thing and its chief writing officer. 5:38 He's a former reporter. This is what's interesting. 5:40 He's a former reporter to actually be a writer, reporter for the tech blog Panda Daily and a former lead writer for Tesla. 5:47 He's a fucking propagandist for Elon. 5:49 And he's the author of Insane Mode, How Elon Musk's Tesla Sparked an Electric Revolution to End the Age of Oil. 5:58 Needed an editor on that subtitle. 6:01 And his new book, Mercifully, is not quite so long. 6:04 It's How to Save the Media. 6:07 Hamish, how nice to see you. How are you? I'm great. 6:09 Thanks very much for having me on the Dishcast. You're so welcome. 6:13 It's been a long, strange trip, has it not? 6:15 It's been a long, strange trip. 6:18 You especially have had a very strange trip. 6:19 I want you to take us briefly, tell us a little bit about who you are. 6:23 You grew up in the distant Antipodes? 6:28 That's what we call them, yeah. 6:31 Is that right? Did we used to call them that, the Antipodes? 6:33 Yes, yes, and the colonies, yes. 6:36 Anyway, the place we always used to look down on, even as a Bulgarian British citizen, New Zealand. 6:45 You know, these weird two islands, the most tedious and beautiful place on Earth. 6:52 Yeah. 6:55 So tell us about this tedious beauty. 6:58 This tedious beauty. 7:00 What was it like? What is your mum and dad to? 7:03 My mum is a teacher. 7:05 She focused on Maori culture. 7:07 It's the indigenous people of New Zealand and Maori language. 7:10 And my father was an atmospheric physicist. They're both still around. 7:14 They're just retired. 7:15 And he studied ultraviolet radiation and worked on the ozone layer stuff around the Montreal Protocol time. 7:23 And I grew up in a small town called Alexandra in the south of New Zealand because that's close to where the observatory he worked at was, where they had to have clean lines of sight to the sky, to the stars. 7:34 And that was a great place to grow up. 7:37 Yeah, tedious is an interesting choice of words. 7:39 It's a sedate and calm place, New Zealand, but full of dramatic natural beauty. 7:45 Yes, it's the Shire. 7:47 There's a good reason Peter Jackson picked it, right? 7:50 Because there is definite Shire there. Lots of Shire. 7:53 There's also everything else. 7:55 I mean, that's the staggering thing. 7:58 But tell me about that town. What was school like? 8:01 What was it like to grow up in New Zealand in the, what was it, the 1980s, 8:06 1990s? 8:08 It's a town of 5,000 people. 8:09 It mostly exists to serve the farmers who live around it. 8:13 I went to primary school there and then I went through high school there and the culture is oriented around rugby and hardening up and wearing your shorts for as long as you can into the depths of the winter, 8:24 which would get quite cold there, minus 10 degrees at its coldest in the winter, Celsius. 8:29 And binge drinking problems. 8:33 All the males have emotional suppression issues and so they drink to let it out. 8:39 They drink to meet women and... 8:42 Then that leads to violence. 8:44 So there's quite a celebrated fighting culture at the pie cart after a night out at the pub. 8:49 That's very... Let me... Forgive me. That's Britain, Ireland. Yeah, yeah. 8:53 We inherited that from you guys. 8:55 It's an entirely cultural creation. 9:00 It's amazing what men do to themselves in those countries. 9:02 But there is... And it has gotten better, I think, don't you think? 9:06 But... 9:08 Yeah, God, I remember rugby games in the winter where I literally could not undo the buttons in the locker room afterwards because my hands were frozen. 9:22 I could not literally move myself. 9:25 And if they could get a rugby ball smashing into your head at the same time as you were close to being petrified, literally petrified, so much the better. 9:38 Yeah, there wasn't much to do in that town. 9:40 So we played a lot of sports and rugby was one of them and getting tackled onto the frosty grass on a Saturday morning by some... 9:47 Farm kid three times my size was one of the rites of passages. 9:51 But it was a good childhood. 9:53 It was a good place to grow up. 9:55 And then you all get into a communal bath afterwards. 9:59 We didn't have that in our changing rooms. 10:01 Maybe I'm missing out on something there. 10:02 No, you were. 10:05 I'm just fantasizing. I didn't go into one of those baths, but they definitely, that was one of the things that rugby clubs did. 10:11 They all beat the crap out of each other, get into a big bath together, then get shit-faced together, fight each other, and fuck women. 10:20 That was basic. We had a lot of that. 10:22 We didn't have the communal bath, so we were missing out. 10:23 But, you know, poorer country. 10:25 But you weren't, from what you're saying, it sounds you weren't completely compatible with this culture. 10:31 I was a little bit, I grew up, you know, I did well at the bins drinking part. 10:34 I did well at the play sports part, but then I did stand a little bit aside on being a little bit more arts oriented and a little bit more intellectual oriented. 10:44 But I didn't fully figure that out until I got to university in Dunedin, New Zealand, Otago University and started to make friends with people who gave a shit about academics and intellectual achievement. 10:57 Tell me about that university. 10:58 Where is it and what kind of people does it attract? We don't know anything. 11:01 It's just genuine questions. 11:04 We don't know what these weird, strange Antipodean cultures are like. 11:09 Yeah, it's very archaic and obscure. 11:14 Otago University in Dunedin is a great university because New Zealand only has seven universities, basically, and so it attracts quite high talent of academics from around the world because academic jobs are in short supply. 11:29 But the culture of Dunedin, it's two and a half hours drive from where I grew up. 11:32 It's on the coast. It's in a gothic old city that was started by Scotsmen. 11:38 For a while, I was Hamish McKenzie living on Dundas Street in Dunedin, which is about as Scottish as you can get. 11:43 I ran one of them. 11:44 That's pretty relevant. 11:49 I just always find it amazing that this exists on the other side of the world. 11:52 You couldn't get a place more alien to where it came from and plop, there it is, able to reconstitute itself almost instantly. 12:01 Yeah, so Dunedin as An inversion of Edinburgh means the same thing. 12:06 And they just took the grid of streets from Edinburgh and plonked it onto this hilly, random bit of land in the south of New Zealand. 12:13 And so you get these incredibly steep streets in some part of them. 12:16 One of them is the steepest street in the world. 12:20 And some students, because it's a student-dominated city, it revolves around the university. 12:25 Some students take out wheelie bins down there and race them down the streets. 12:29 Very hazardous. And people have died doing that. 12:32 And that gives it a little bit of an indication of what the culture is there because it's a student culture very heavily. 12:38 Okay, it's changed a little bit in the last 25 years since I've been there, but very heavily revolves around the socializing aspect, revolves around binge drinking, getting out in the streets, going to famously in those days, 12:52 students were known for setting couches on fire at the terraces of rugby games or cricket games. 12:57 But it's also a very bohemian culture there as well. 13:00 There's lots of great indie music, underground culture and arts. 13:03 It has its own French festival. 13:04 It's a really cool city. 13:07 So if you think of an American equivalent, it would be something like, I don't know, somewhere in the Pacific Northwest? 13:13 Yeah, I don't know the scores very well. 13:15 Charlottesville reminded me of Dineen quite a bit, Virginia. 13:19 So at what point did you... 13:22 Think, I want to conquer the world. 13:27 When did you start thinking beyond New Zealand, beyond where you were? 13:33 I imagine there were people in your high school that didn't, aren't doing what you were doing. 13:39 When did that first, when did that ambition really begin to perk up in your brain? 13:44 I've never had the ambition to conquer the world. 13:47 And I haven't had the ambition to become like a... 13:50 Startup founder, this all happened by accident. 13:52 I didn't have the ambition or the belief that I could ever end up in a situation where Elon Musk would go hire me, someone like Elon Musk would hire me. 14:00 I had the ambition to be a journalist. 14:03 And apart from the ego reasons of doing journalism, which is it's nice to see your name in print, that kind of thing, I saw it as a good vehicle for helping people and helping people at scale because... 14:18 Writing is powerful and it can change minds and it can influence how people think and it can tell important stories that need to be told. 14:25 So I always set off on the course of being a journalist. 14:29 I thought that was the greatest possible job you could have. 14:31 I actually still think it's the best possible job. 14:34 But one thing lends to another and I end up helping to start this company. 14:40 Well, let's go through that period from college to where you got that, because you did start being a reporter. 14:46 I mean, you did it the hard way. 14:48 You stuck out on your own. 14:49 You're trying to figure out how to do this. 14:52 Tell us about what that was like, being a young journalist, where you were, when you were. 14:56 Because the Internet was sort of breaking on the horizon, if not... 14:59 Yeah, I guess I started a little bit before the internet came in and changed everything about the media economy. 15:07 And I decided in high school that I wanted to be a journalist, but I'd already committed to going to Otago University where they didn't have a journalism program. 15:16 So I did an English degree and volunteered at the student magazine. 15:21 And over the years, I rose up the ranks of the student magazine to become the editor. 15:25 And then I finished being the editor there. 15:27 I did my... 15:29 One year has been the editor, which is common, and decided I want to go see the world a little bit, which is another common thing for New Zealanders to do because it's at the bottom of the planet. 15:38 And I struck on the idea of going to Canada, and I thought I could go to Canada and do my post-grad degree in journalism. 15:44 So that's what I did. Went to the University of Western Ontario in London, Ontario, based on a one-line email from a journalism professor in New Zealand who purported to know something about journalism schools in Canada, but turns out he didn't know anything. 15:57 And so... 15:59 So I applied to that school, got into it, did a great year there. 16:02 And then went and worked in magazines in Hong Kong. 16:05 Okay, hold on. 16:06 You say that like it's nothing. 16:08 Then you went to Hong Kong, right? 16:10 Why? 16:12 One of the reasons was that there was a former girlfriend I had unfinished business with. 16:19 Thank you. 16:20 And another reason was, this is 2006, and China was really on the rise. 16:24 And two years before the Beijing Games, and I had... 16:28 I wanted to be a big serious foreign correspondent slash political journalist and China was the biggest story. 16:34 And I thought I could go to Hong Kong, which is booming at the moment, learn Chinese, spend a lot of time in China and report on this story for international publications. 16:45 And that's not quite how it worked out. 16:48 It sounds a little ambitious. 16:50 So what actually happened? I ended up working for Entertainment Magazine. 16:53 So I went over it with a month's worth of money and I thought if I run out of money I can just go back to New Zealand and figure out something. 17:00 But I got a job at a freebie entertainment magazine. 17:03 And then after four months there, I translated that into a job for a trade magazine, writing about the digital marketing industry in Asia, which was an important time for me because that introduced me to Facebook and Twitter and WeChat, which is China's big consumer app. 17:18 It's the biggest in the world, probably the most important consumer app in the world. 17:22 And I got a quick education in the tech industry. 17:26 But then Time Out Magazine was starting in Hong Kong. 17:28 My friend was the editor and he asked me to come and help launch Time Out Hong Kong, you know, just related to Time Out London, Time Out New York. And so I got a job. 17:36 My first role was music editor and online editor. 17:40 So that was, you know, still relatively early days of the internet before timeout was crushed by mobile apps. 17:45 But that was a super thing, super fun thing to do in my 20s. 17:49 Yeah, that's the absolute ideal journalism job in the 20s. 17:52 You do a sort of, you work for a magazine that also covers nightlife, which is basically fun. 17:57 Yeah, yeah. All that stuff too. 18:00 And then, yeah, no, that was the genre that was really a way of life for lots of people. 18:05 It just disappeared overnight. Kind of, yeah. 18:08 With Craigslist and all the rest of it. 18:10 Yeah, yeah, being a Listine's Bible is not so, not such. 18:14 So how did you end up working for You Know Who? 18:18 So skip forward a couple of years. 18:19 I moved to the States with my girlfriend who's an American. 18:23 She's now my wife and we have two children together. 18:26 Her name's Steph. 18:27 And we went to Austin first because we wanted to live in a cool city. 18:32 And then she went to law school. So we moved to Baltimore. 18:34 And I was a freelance journalist. 18:35 I came over as a freelancer because that was one way I could figure out how to get a visa in the US and make money. 18:41 And... 18:45 I wrote a piece about how the future of magazines could look a lot more like Spotify to platformatize journalism and let you follow independent individual journalists or individual stories or magazines. 18:57 And it turns out some things about that idea were a bit muddled and not great, not as good as Substack. 19:03 But I wrote that piece and offered it to this publication called Pando Daily, which was writing about startups and technology companies. 19:10 And Elon had read some of the work that I've 19:15 And a publisher at Faber & Faber in London was also reading some of the stuff and had read some of the things I'd written about Elon and got in contact with me to see if I'd be interested in trying to do a book about Elon and would he cooperate on such a thing. 19:30 So I said, well, sounds amazing. 19:33 Let me try. 19:34 And I got in touch with Elon. 19:36 Long story short, he said, I don't know about the book, but I like your work. 19:40 Would you be interested in coming to work at a place like Tesla? 19:44 And so, yeah, I said yes after a while. 19:47 I tried to convince him to do the book with me for a bit longer and then gave up on that and decided to join the company because it's such an interesting opportunity. 19:55 What do you know about Elon Musk that would be good for the people listening to this podcast to know? 20:00 Because, I mean, I've never been in a room with him and I tend to, you know, you tend to judge on public statements. 20:08 But knowing someone and working for them and interacting with them gives you a whole different... 20:13 Tell us, like, is the way that he's evolved, could you have seen it back then? 20:20 I'm not sure if I could have imagined this exaggerated sort of extreme expression of his character, but the fundamentals of that character were present. 20:32 I don't think Twitter has helped him. 20:34 Like before he bought it, I think that thing has been bad for bringing out some of the less helpful aspects of his character. 20:42 But he can be extremely charming. 20:45 I think he is sincere in his beliefs for wanting to help the world and change the world and give humanity a backup plan. 20:54 By condemning hundreds of thousands of children to death. 20:59 Yeah, that was an interesting way of going. 21:02 Sorry, tens of thousands. 21:04 But yes, the idea that he's a naive person trying to change the world for the better, I... 21:10 I guess we've lost that version of Elon. 21:12 Well, I think he probably has his own way of rationalizing those kinds of things to himself. I'm sure he does. 21:17 But I think He's sincere in His belief that humanity needs a backup plan and that's why We need to go and colonize Mars if we're too vulnerable to things. 21:25 That's obviously insane. That's an obviously insane view. 21:28 We can't possibly colonize Mars anytime. 21:30 Who would on earth ever want... 21:32 I mean, this is the kind of view that a 14-year-old boy has. 21:35 I do think it's my... 21:37 I think his politics is basically that of the 14-year-old boy who just read Ayn Rand for the first time and is just this absolute moronic teenager. 21:46 I do think there are aspects of him that reflect the idealism of a teenage boy. 21:53 I don't... And I... 21:55 think that Elon has done some things that we would consider crazy. 21:59 Like the idea of launching a rocket, bringing it back to Earth and catching it with a pair of tongs is kind of crazy. 22:06 Saggering. And getting the world to move to electric transportation when the entire automotive industry was invested in the opposite is a massive achievement. And so I don't know. I would say... 22:19 Even as you spent all this money for a president designed to stop exactly that process. 22:24 It's very interesting. 22:25 It's very interesting how these things have happened in the later years and the choices you've made, and I'm not going to endorse them. 22:31 But I do want to endorse a more complicated view of the man. 22:35 And that caricature, caricature, can you say that word for me? 22:39 Caricature, right? 22:41 Painting a caricature of him is unhelpful to the mission of defeating him if that's what your mission is. 22:48 I don't want to defeat him. 22:49 I just want him to stop harming people in the world. 22:53 I think he should get off Twitter. I think that would be helpful. 22:54 I think that media system has been damaging to a lot of people, including him. 23:01 Yeah. 23:03 And eventually you do write the book about Elon. 23:06 Yeah, I wrote this book about how Tesla has catalyzed this transition to electric transport. 23:12 A pretty puffy book. 23:13 I mean, not a takedown. 23:15 And he went completely bananas. 23:17 Yeah, the first version of the book that I wanted to write was going to draw on my experiences at the company, what I saw there, what makes this company so remarkable. 23:26 But the principle he objected to, the principle that an employee, a former employee would write a book drawing on their experiences, he didn't want that to happen. 23:34 So he came down on me with a ton of bricks, sent the lawyers after me. 23:37 Because other people in the future might? Yes. 23:40 He had this control of his own information that he wants to keep total? 23:48 That's the way I read it. 23:49 You know, lots of CEOs would say that they wouldn't want their former employees to write a book about what the company was like from the inside. 23:55 Right. 23:57 So he really came after me with his lawyers aggressively and it was a difficult time to get through as an independent writer at that time. 24:06 Yeah, I mean, you are trying to publish a book by yourself and the richest man on earth is determined to throw everything against you. 24:13 But you did end up publishing it. 24:15 Yeah, he might have been the 10th richest man at that time. 24:18 I did end up publishing the book 24:19 and I wrote it in a way to avoid these legal pressure questions. 24:23 I wrote it in a way as if I had never actually worked at the company and wrote it as a reporter. 24:28 Yeah, right, right, which is an easy thing to do. 24:31 But that to me is a pretty good character point. 24:36 That you still went ahead and did that fucking book, even though he did all he could to stop you, even though he fired you presumably at some point, right? 24:43 Actually, I chose to leave the company. 24:45 I had three bosses. 24:46 I was only there a year and a quarter. 24:48 I had three bosses at that time because the head of communications at Tesla's most cursed job. 24:52 And the last one was going to, they were going to lay me off and clean house and set up a new team. 24:57 But then they changed their mind and asked me to stay. 24:59 But I got excited about leaving in the meantime to go write this book. 25:02 So I did leave on my own volition. 25:05 So then you were looking at a career in independent freelance journalism. 25:10 And what was the environment then? 25:12 And that's presumably when you started hearing and thinking about the possibility of getting your own readers to support you. 25:21 Tell us about that process. 25:22 Yeah, so I'd finished writing that book around 2017. 25:25 And while I was writing the book, to pay the bills, I took a part-time job working for Kik, which is a big messaging app, which is kind of like WeChat in China. 25:34 And there I met Chris Best and Jaraj Sethi, who are my co-founders at Substack. 25:40 And so when I'd finished the book, Chris had also stepped away from working at Kik after about nine years. 25:45 He was one of the co-founders there. 25:48 And we were friends. 25:50 And he shared this essay with me for my feedback that he had written about the problem with the media these days, because there was a lot of finger pointing at that stage because a lot of people were upset that Donald Trump had just been elected and they were looking 26:03 for people to blame. 26:05 And Chris's thesis in this piece was, it wasn't just like shadowy billionaires corrupting the earth or the politicians weren't doing a good enough job. 26:15 It was that The media culture we were living in was unduly affected by the incentives of social media, which put us into these performative battles online. 26:26 And even the mainstream media had to play by those rules because the social media companies were getting all the attention and sort of determining the game. 26:36 And he sent that essay to me for my feedback and I said, this is all true and right and smart, but people in the media know that these are the problems, they just don't know what to do about them. 26:47 Maybe you should include a couple of paragraphs suggesting an alternative, like what would be a better way? 26:53 And he didn't actually get around to finishing the essay, but he did get into deep conversations with me about like what would be a better system with the basic insight that if you made the audiences, the customers, instead of the advertisers or the social media algorithms, 27:09 then you could get different cultural outcomes and Well, 27:14 when the internet tried advertising, which it did for a good decade or so, one became aware of the paradox that essentially these things were for advertisers, not readers, and that if you were getting something for free... 27:30 You weren't, actually. 27:31 You were the product. 27:34 And then finding ways technologically to maximize that just led to what we're talking about. 27:41 But at the same time, of course, you also had the collapse of the revenue model because advertising was also fleeing the old print. 27:49 And so you had this moment in the media where things are really in flux. 27:54 I'm just thinking about The basic idea that the internet, let's go back to the beginnings of the internet. 28:00 The internet gave anybody suddenly the ability with, you know, from the very late 90s onwards to write something and put it up on the web. 28:12 It's as simple as that. 28:14 I remember as a writer in the late 90s, let's talk about this process, how it all happened, because this is kind of interesting in the process. 28:20 Yeah. 28:24 I realized that I could write something This is what I realized. 28:30 I could read the New York Times at midnight when they put the whole thing up once a day. 28:34 And they finally started to bring this out. 28:38 It's not that long ago, but it seems like I'm talking about the Middle Ages. 28:44 Slate, if you remember, the first online magazine, originally came out once a week. 28:51 And you could print it out. 28:55 I remember because... 28:58 People used to ask, can you print that out for me? 28:59 And I was like, no, no, I can't print it out for you. 29:02 That's the whole point, you idiot. 29:04 But from my point of view, boy, as a writer who had spent, you know, I mean, had a really, I'm blessed career in mainstream journalism. 29:12 I was very acutely aware of all the subtle pressures that prevent you from writing what you really believe. 29:18 Yeah. 29:21 And also just the ability to get out there quickly. 29:24 You know, people forget you had paper, you had print, you had machines. 29:29 There was literally shit you had to move physically around. 29:33 I mean, I remember when I first worked at the day, my first job, and I sound like I'm 95, but really not that long ago. 29:41 I walked into, it's just an amazing story, really. 29:44 So let's just spend some time thinking about this story because it's just... 29:48 An incredible one. 29:50 As an intern, I worked at the Daily Telegraph, which was actually on the old Fleet Street before Thatcher really broke the print unions and enabled the media to sort of reconstitute itself. 30:03 It's based on... You can read Scoop. 30:07 It's in War's book. It's that building. 30:09 It's that very building. 30:12 And at the very basement of the building, these giant, massive... 30:17 Steel, iron, like printing presses that were, you put bits of metal into these fucking things. 30:28 And they had learned how to do this for like the last, I don't know, 100 years, 20, I don't know how many years they've been doing this bloody thing. 30:34 And of course, it was incredibly hard, the art of actually putting bits of metal to match, I mean, Jesus, it's, you know, it's a, So they paid an enormous amount of money and there was like 10 of them worked for millions of dollars a year. 30:48 And the minute they said we're going to strike, everything shut down. 30:50 I mean, the whole thing was bonkers. 30:53 And then I would write an editorial and I would go home and I'd get on the train the next morning and I would see these people reading the paper. What a feeling. 31:02 What a feeling. 31:04 But that was a physical thing. 31:06 That was a hugely physical thing. 31:08 And suddenly this thing slipped out of our physical hands. 31:12 And sometime in the 1990s, we realized this is all ethereal. 31:16 So what do we do with this? 31:18 What do we do with this? 31:20 And that was just, for me, it was all experimentation. 31:26 I asked a friend of mine who knew tech stuff because I didn't. And I still don't. 31:30 I'm still a fucking moron. 31:31 Otherwise, I'd be a much richer man. 31:33 But anyway, I never understood the tech. 31:36 And perhaps underlying this conversation is a thread of incredible envy. 31:42 But anyway, I'm beating around the bush here. 31:46 But yeah, so... 31:48 It comes out at midnight. 31:49 I can write that Maureen Dowd is full of shit at 1230 a.m. And I can put it up there and people read my telling them Maureen Dowd's column is full of shit that day before they read Maureen Dowd. 32:03 And my inspiration, of course, is Matt Drudge. 32:07 I want to just take a moment. 32:09 Who excoriated, no one ever writes about him. 32:13 He's not in your book. 32:14 He's not in any of the other books. 32:16 He is a complete, of course, this is everything he always wanted. 32:19 But he did this. 32:21 He fucking did this. 32:24 He saw box office returns in the office of a Hollywood agency. 32:31 And he was able to put them online before anybody else by stealing them from the mailroom. 32:38 And he did the dress. 32:40 He did the fucking dress. 32:41 This is so before anybody else. 32:44 All by himself. 32:45 And he was earning a fortune. 32:48 So I'm amazed the drudges are in your book. 32:51 Yeah, that's it. 32:52 An independent person who started making money. 32:57 Real money in the 90s by this astonishing independence. 33:02 You know what I should do? 33:02 I've started a companion Substack for the book and I can put new material up on that Substack that can supplement the stuff that's in the book. 33:11 You can do an entire history of the internet in this book. 33:13 I understand that. 33:14 But in terms of independent media earning money by doing their own thing, take a moment of silence for the great Matt Drudge. 33:23 I'm not saying this because he put my piece on the front page this week. 33:27 But by the by, anyway, I'm just, and then you kind of, yeah, and then, so what do you do? 33:34 But that's just the thing. 33:36 That's a little scribb. 33:38 So I'm like, okay, can I put all my articles up there? 33:40 Put all your articles up. 33:42 And then you begin to realize that something happens in the, oh, I could do it twice a day. 33:48 I could do it three times a day. 33:51 This has cursed you deep down. 33:53 And then the other thing that happens, and then I say, okay, I need a technical platform to do this. 34:00 So that was when blogger.com comes along, right? 34:04 Blogger.com, which is the first. Evan Williams. 34:07 Yeah. Okay, you know more about this. 34:09 Well, he's the guy who later went on to co-found Twitter and then Medium. 34:13 There you go. Okay. 34:16 It meant that someone who was an idiot like me, someone who didn't know a software from pajamas, basically, could put his piece up there and it'd be fine. 34:26 And so we were up and running. 34:27 And then it was just... 34:29 Playtime. It's like, let's try this. Let's try that. 34:32 Let's try the other. 34:34 And you find out certain things about the medium that is completely new to you. 34:38 For example, and this is what happens in social media immediately. 34:42 I know I'm talking too much. 34:44 I'm loving this. Keep going. 34:45 I hope it's okay to have a conversation about it. 34:47 But as I said, I wrote a piece. 34:52 Fifteen minutes later, I get a couple of emails. 34:56 One is from North Dakota and one is from New Zealand. Yeah, New Zealand. 34:59 I just will never forget that moment. 35:02 Fuck me. Jesus Christ. 35:04 That was probably you, actually. Probably you. 35:06 You're an early dish head. 35:10 And... 35:12 That was another thing. Whoa, the interaction here is different than anything else. 35:16 That's where the view from your window comes from. 35:20 Let's talk to each other. 35:21 Let's create a community. 35:23 And the other thing you mentioned that was interesting at the time is that when we put these regular publications online, the other thing that happened was that you noticed, oh, Mike Kinsley gets 25% of our traffic this week. 35:42 You never knew that before. 35:44 You never knew who was reading what within a magazine. 35:46 You put out 40 pieces a week. 35:49 You realize, ex-source, the editor, you kind of know. 35:53 You sort of have your gut. 35:54 But suddenly then, the disintermediation happens. 35:59 Suddenly the staples of the magazine come undone. 36:02 The papers fly away. 36:04 The individual writers start to have this presence. 36:07 So then you began to think, well, what is a magazine anymore? 36:10 What is it? 36:11 And the truth is, They don't exist anymore in any real way, magazines, in the way they did. 36:18 The Atlantic is no longer a magazine. 36:20 Whatever it is, it's not a magazine. 36:23 It has a print compendium of articles that have been online. 36:27 Yes, it does. 36:29 And it has that sort of gesture. 36:32 But, you know, magazines by their very nature were defined by what they didn't publish. 36:40 You know, there was very limited space. Mm-hmm. 36:42 So to get in them was an achievement. 36:46 The internet has no limits. 36:48 So it immediately completely changed that entire dynamic. 36:52 And then it became what you did publish and as much as you could publish. 36:56 And that's the other thing you realize is I realized that, well, people like this when it's kind of fast moving, addictive, fun. 37:04 Yeah. 37:06 It took off after 9-11, then it went through the strategy of the Iraq War. 37:11 These emotional, polarizing moments then galvanized these independent voices. 37:19 But again, even then, the monetization of it is utterly opaque and no one really knows. 37:27 So tell me, when did the first blog ask for donation subscriptions to support itself? 37:35 When did the first one, well, people 37:37 have done it in small ways over the years, but a lot of the problem was this infrastructure change came before the business model came to support that infrastructure change. 37:49 So what actually happened with a lot of the early bloggers, which you're a part of the class of, is that their business model ended up being go get a job at a mainstream media outlet. 38:01 Which kind of defeated the purpose ultimately of blogging, which was to create this new wave of energy and a new generation of voices. 38:10 But... 38:11 You were one of the early standard bearers and models for what an audience-supported publication could look like with The Dish when you introduced paid subscriptions. 38:21 And I remember writing about it when I was at Pando Daily. 38:23 So I was paying close attention because I think you started with TinyPass, which is this plugin that you could use to collect subscriptions from people. 38:30 I think you were charging... 38:32 $20 a year or something like that. 38:34 1999, I think we did. 38:37 A screaming bargain for the volume of work that you put out and the perspective that you brought in, the quality of that perspective and then the various voices that you had publishing in their operation and I watched it really closely 38:49 and I noticed that when you wound it down It didn't seem to be because it was financially not viable. 38:57 It seemed to be a financial success, at least a modest financial success, which was very hard for a print-focused media operation born in the 2010s. 39:06 Well, your one was born in the early 2000s, I guess. 39:11 But at that stage... Just FYI, I launched Donations in 2002. 39:18 Wow, okay. Well, I didn't realize that. 39:20 I had, yeah. 39:22 So I had an income from The Dish from 2002 onwards. 39:29 And I lost two thirds of it when I turned against the war. 39:33 That's how I knew. 39:34 And it was the most rudimentary. 39:36 It was police sent us some money. 39:39 So I actually have, for example, a cash check from Lynn Cheney. 39:43 Wow. 39:45 To The Dish. You were receiving paper money, like checks in the mail. 39:49 Paper money. Yes. 39:51 Checks in the mail. 39:53 And so that... 39:55 Because we didn't, things weren't automated sort of, I mean, they probably were, but we weren't on top of it. 40:00 And we were just like, well, look, because I used to, believe it or not, this has taken me really back, but I knew Don Rumsfeld back in the day, before the war and after the war. 40:09 And he would, whenever he met me, He would say, is that making any money yet? 40:14 How do you make any money? How do you make any money? 40:16 And I'm like, you wait, you wait, you wait. 40:19 We got the donations now. 40:22 But yes, I kept one foot in the mainstream because that kept my... 40:26 But I was earning money from independent blogging from 2002 onwards. 40:32 And 2005, I went to Time. 40:36 2005, you went to Time. 40:37 But 2012-ish, I think you introduced this paywall, the subscription option. Yes. 40:41 And it seemed to work financially, but the reason you gave, I read it, I remember what you said when you gave it up, was that it was an exhaustion issue. 40:51 You had to churn out stuff all 40:54 the time. 40:55 My organizational managerial skills was not up to the expansion and scale, and I'm just not good The thing about the product was that it was so much me, I couldn't delegate it to anybody else. 41:07 That became a problem with independent blogs is that it wasn't you. 41:12 So there was no what if you're sick? 41:14 What if you need a vacation? 41:15 And there's this constant demand for attention. 41:19 And so at that point We went, well, let these fucking media companies figure this out. 41:25 They came to me and said, well, you seem to be understanding this. 41:27 And my point from the get-go was, no, no, no, no, you're not going to do this and pay me a salary. 41:33 Because you're not buying a right, you're buying an audience. 41:36 And not only that, I want at the end of the year, I want my salary to go up in proportion to the number of people, in proportion to the audience. 41:46 And they were like, yeah, yeah, yeah, sure, sure, sure, sure. 41:49 A year goes at time. 41:50 And I'm like, so what's my salary next year? 41:52 And they were like, and I'm like, you don't get it, do you? So I quit. 41:56 I just said, I'm out. 41:58 And then the Atlantic came and offered me this deal. 42:01 Then the Beast came and said, we're going to do it with advertising. 42:03 We're going to raise, we're going to do advertising. 42:05 So we'll give you a cut of the advertising. 42:08 So that I thought was fine, but then they couldn't raise any advertising money. 42:11 So at that point, I know this is 2013. 42:16 I know this works. 42:20 I know it's valuable. 42:22 I know that no one in the mainstream media can actually realize its value. 42:27 And if we could get people to pay, but how do we do that? 42:30 Is there any way to get a... We went to these various companies. 42:33 It cost us fortune. 42:34 Remember we went to... What's that asshole's name? 42:37 Something... 42:39 Yes, you know who I'm talking about. 42:42 Anyway, they nearly fucking took us to the cleaners, but we ducked out. 42:46 We found this little company, Tiny Pass, that we have this gizmo we can stick on. 42:52 And that's when we heard from Obama, who said, this little dog keeps popping up. 42:58 I can't read anymore. 43:00 How do I get the subscription? 43:01 Anyway, that's how we did it. 43:04 So you asked me before how many people were collecting money online for their blogging from the audience. 43:10 And the truth is not that many. 43:11 You were doing it. 43:13 You figured out various ways of doing it. 43:15 And not that many people were because the internet and the media were still defaulting to advertising as the model. 43:22 And in fact, people weren't even at that time when you launched your thing, people weren't that accustomed to paying for content online. 43:29 Like Spotify and Netflix popularized that. 43:32 Before that, people were untrustworthy, untrusting of the idea of paying for content online. 43:38 But then... 43:39 That's a separate question for, am I going to pay a particular writer or artist or creator or publisher who I trust? 43:46 And it took Patreon to unlock that piece. 43:49 Patreon was the forerunner in setting the expectation that it's reasonable to send money to a creator or an artist who you really believe in. 43:57 And so that was a little cultural unlock. 43:59 And so all this had to happen basically before something like Substack could come along and Yeah, and to 44:13 have the technology in place to make that happen. 44:16 I mean, the infrastructure like Stripe. 44:18 Yeah, Stripe, a huge deal, yeah. 44:20 And just mechanically doing it. 44:23 But the proof of principle was there, I think. 44:27 It was there, Except, of course... There was... 44:29 I mean, I'm not really a good test because I already had a big presence in mainstream media visibility. 44:36 But other people who didn't came from nowhere. 44:38 I mean, Drudge was obviously the most obvious example. 44:41 He still is enormous. 44:42 Yeah, Ben Thompson did this as well. 44:45 Working out of his spare bedroom in Taipei where he lived – As a former business analyst guy who worked in tech companies, had no reputation in the media, no audience existing in the media, he built up from scratch a blog that he calls Stratechery, 45:01 where he'd analyze the business models of tech companies. 45:04 He'd write these big weekly blog posts, and he'd give anyone the option to pay $100 a year to get three more posts per week from him that could be delivered by email. 45:15 And that is the basic model that we took for Substack and Substack. 45:20 So Ben Thompson had done it. You had done it. 45:22 Another guy called Luke Timmerman was doing it in biotech. I.F. 45:26 Stone did it in the 60s and 70s. He did. 45:29 Let's take a tip of the hat to I.F. 45:31 Stone as well as Matt Drudge. 45:32 Yeah, maybe he's a precursor to the Drudge even. 45:34 Yeah, he was printing out those issues and taking them to the mailbox himself and proofreading them himself and his wife is helping. 45:41 And he made a living doing that. 45:43 But it was just very, very hard. 45:44 Can you make an analogy to the pamphleteering era too where everybody was publishing themselves? 45:50 Yeah I think these are like technological infrastructure change happens and then there's a business model that arises to fit it and that coupling of the infrastructure in the business model then has a cultural effect. 46:02 And so in the pamphleting era, it became easier. 46:05 The Gutenberg press allowed people to print their own pamphlets and then they would make money from them by selling individual issues in coffee shops or on the streets. 46:15 And with that business model. 46:17 Sensationalism really paid well. 46:19 And pamphlets were often sensationalist and or proselytizing. 46:23 It was a lot like the culture of social media today where the way to get ahead is to shout loudly and perform for maximum attention in a busy attention marketplace. 46:37 But the thing that ended the era of pamphlets essentially, which is hundreds of years long era, was not only the arrival of the steam powered printing press, which is not dissimilar to what you had in the basement of the Daily Calligraph, 46:50 but a business model that supported reputation because reputation became much more important as the industrial revolution was taking hold and people had to make bets on the markets and had to hold governments to account and And so the model 47:08 that supported reputation was subscriptions. 47:10 And that's the dominant model that the early newspapers settled on. 47:15 And these things became much more reliable. 47:18 These newspaper, these media objects became much more reliable, much more trustworthy. 47:22 People got ahead by living up to the reputation that they needed to preserve. 47:27 And that is what ended the age of pamphlets, not because the printing press itself came along, but the business model that fit it came along. 47:37 And that's a very interesting analogy to that because I felt myself the shift in incentives. 47:45 There's a very different shift if all you want is to get the viral post, the one viral post. 47:51 And especially if the other thing the pamphleteers often were the same, they were anonymous. 47:55 So if you really want to just completely rile people and make money out of, you stay anonymous and then you have these moments. 48:01 But if you want this to continue through time, if you want to actually develop a relationship with Then there has to be a point at which that person's subscription comes up again to renew. 48:12 And have you earned the trust in that year to be renewed? 48:16 And that then shifts the incentives quite dramatically. 48:21 Yeah, exactly. And it gives the audience some agency. 48:24 It gives the audience a little bit of a say in the culture that they want to live in. 48:28 Whereas before, if you're just buying a pamphlet and you're on the other end of a sensationalist tail, you're kind of like a dumb consumer. 48:37 And so the newspaper model was preferable, but it was still limited by the infrastructure of its time, which has only changed since the arrival of the internet. 48:48 Yeah. I'm thinking of the first critique of all of this was that how do we know? 48:53 There are no standards here. 48:55 Bullshit can come out. 48:57 Lies and truth have no difference. 48:59 There's no way to determine. People were panicked. 49:02 We don't have Walter Rokornkei to tell us. 49:03 I mean, there's no question that the first decades of this And what we had to say, what we said in response I guess to that question was a completely legitimate question and has in some ways been borne out. 49:13 I mean there's no question that the first decades of this technology have led to crazy theories, conspiracy theories, radical movement, all of the above based upon misinformation etc but You can't live in a different world, so you have to establish trust. 49:32 You have to establish reliability. 49:34 You have to establish. 49:36 And the only thing you have, of course, unlike the pamphleteas, is that you have an instant reaction from readers. 49:41 Instant. 49:42 You make an error, they will tell you within 45 seconds. 49:45 If you haven't fixed it within 60 seconds, they want to know why. 49:49 So you suddenly have this massive accountability question where you are accountable. 49:53 And when you fuck up, If you don't acknowledge it, they will notice. 49:59 Yeah, except I think that that piece got complicated by the arrival of and success of things like Twitter, where the current thing becomes a thing that everyone's obsessing about in a particular moment. 50:14 And your incentive as the publisher in this system is to create the maximum noise, get the maximum attention, be the most scandalous. 50:22 And then if you're wrong, it doesn't really matter a few days later because people have moved on to the next thing and you jump in and play the game again. 50:29 And so we've been stuck in this kind of chaos environment where the infrastructure has changed. 50:35 And it's amazing infrastructure. 50:36 The internet is an incredible enabler of new things. 50:40 You can publish and be seen globally instantly and potentially amass a huge audience and find your people around the world. 50:48 But it's been wedded to an incentive system that is producing really bad cultural outcomes. 50:55 And the incentive system is... You can see it on Twitter. 50:58 It's how can I get the maximum amount of attention in a moment on a timeline in a noisy attention market? 51:05 So Substack was a sort of, from that essay that Chris sort of wrote, was what if we became an instrument for... 51:16 For universalizing this principle. 51:17 In other words, make it easy for any writer. 51:19 And that's what you really do. 51:21 And I think the fact that you were a journalist is kind of important in all this because you have always been able to see it from the point of view of the actual writer. 51:29 And so the writer, as you know, many of us are, we're not techie. 51:34 You haven't mastered. 51:35 And not business people. 51:38 And not business, terrible business people. 51:39 So we have both those points. 51:41 And so what you basically said is that We'll be that for you. 51:45 We'll be that for you. 51:46 And we'll charge you just a small percentage. 51:49 And don't you worry about a thing. 51:54 And for someone like me, that sounds like an absolute dream. 51:58 That sounds like, my God, that's all I ever wanted was just to write and then pay what I'm worth. 52:04 That's all I want. 52:06 And I know I'm worth more than you motherfuckers are. 52:09 And you demonstrated that. You showed up. 52:12 Yeah, no, it was fucking amazing when that happened. 52:15 So, but then the other thing that happens is that you're also in a cultural climate in which the forces of censorship on both sides, the atmosphere in which it is okay to say what you think becomes dramatically cloudier in the mid-20-teens. 52:34 Yeah. And Do you think Substack would have had its breakout if it hadn't gotten so tough for people to say what they think in the mainstream media? 52:48 What I think is that this model, this direct relationships model where the audience has agency and the writer or creator gets to make money from a smaller but devoted audience through subscriptions, that would have succeeded regardless because I think it's one 53:05 of the great Substack, Substack, Substack, Substack, Substack, Substack, got the fortunate opportunity to be a leader in that model. 53:14 But the reason that model was born, the reason we started Substack was in response to this suboptimal model of social media which has all these externalities associated with Including Social media mobs and censorship campaigns and performative outrage, 53:37 etc. And so I would say that having the negative consequences of the social media model be so visible was a helpful precursor to giving birth to this direct relationships model. 53:53 Because when it arrived, there was sort of relief from readers, at least. 53:58 Yeah, in the early days. This is insane. 53:59 This doesn't feel like I'm suddenly... Yeah. 54:03 In the early days, it was like writers were surprised that they could make money from paid subscription newsletters. 54:08 No one really believed that that was going to be a financially viable thing. 54:11 Those are the very earliest days because we started in 2017 54:14 before the social media mobs really got into gear. 54:16 I mean, Gamergate had happened. 54:18 There'd been a few things. 54:19 But they really got into gear around the start of the pandemic and maybe leading up to the pandemic a lot. And you felt the heat of that. 54:27 Could free you, free the writers from that censorship pressure and I think that really did help accelerate the appreciation for Substack and the appreciation for this particular direct relationships model. 54:45 Yeah, When did we first, when did you first get in touch with me? 54:48 I was trying to remember the other day. 54:49 2018, as early as 2018. 54:51 Yeah, we were talking all along and I was like, and I remember you explaining the idea to me and I'm like, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. 54:58 I mean, as I remember, I was super enthusiastic, but I'm like, at that point, I hadn't understood. 55:03 I had always associated with As this sort of every 20 minutes post, I had created a sort of Twitter avola letter and I was trying to do it all myself with seven other kids helping me which was fantastic. 55:19 But nonetheless, it just wasn't sustainable. 55:22 Yeah, I think you knew very well that what The Daily Dish was and what The Daily Dish looked like and how that could succeed but you hadn't yet realized that there could be such a thing as The Weekly Dish and that could be just as viable. It's unbelievable. 55:36 It took a really nice dose of mushrooms in the tidal ports at Provincetown for me to one day, could we have been talking about it? 55:46 And I'm like, I'm not ready. I can't go back to blogging. 55:48 I can't go back to blogging. 55:50 And then it was like, oh, God, the Red Guard is coming down the corridor, slowly taking office after office. 55:58 And there was only a matter of time before. 56:00 And you know what? 56:04 The main thing that out. 56:08 Oh we could try to do it the other things that Substack did for me, it gave me back my readers. How so? 56:17 It gave me back. 56:19 Well, we had such an amazing community at The Daily Dish. 56:23 We had like, you know... 56:25 As you say, we had so many people smartly interacting, and we didn't allow comments. 56:31 We had this wonderful dissent feature where we would edit and write and curate really good criticism of me, and I missed them. 56:43 And we'd spent, you know, 16 years... 56:49 Building this relationship. 56:51 And suddenly I left. 56:53 I quit. 56:56 God, the emails that day were really remarkable. 56:59 It was like an emotional relationship. 57:01 And so finding them again, asking them again, come on. 57:05 What did that feel like? 57:07 Unbelievable. 57:09 It felt like... 57:10 My whole life made sense again. I got really depressed. 57:13 I was writing and it wasn't bad and the column was fine and I was doing work that I really enjoyed but I felt like I spent so much time building something and walked away and now suddenly these wonderful people from the Antipodes have given it back to me. 57:30 Chris and Jaraj are from Canada. 57:32 I'm sure you have a huge readership in the Antipodes as well. 57:35 I'm the only Antipodean in the technological infrastructure. 57:37 I'm just joshing your leg. 57:39 But... 57:41 And that reminded me that the joy of this medium, you know, again, which is you don't get as much with the magazine. 57:47 I published a weekly magazine. 57:48 I know what that's like. 57:50 You don't get the warmth. 57:51 I mean, we did get, please cancel my subscription, you know, every week, but not this. 57:58 And the thing is that there's something about this... 58:04 This medium that is, I used to call it mass intimacy, that people you really get to live with. 58:11 You're going through life's events. 58:12 You're going through history together. 58:15 You remember, and even though it's a weird thing, you know, you're just, you're a point of reference for them. 58:22 And so that was an amazing blessing that you, I mean, I just thank you for doing this and making it possible. 58:29 And the fact that then when And so I was going to move, if you remember. 58:33 And then they're basically not on my timing or theirs. 58:36 And I had to jump immediately. 58:38 But we already set it up so that we already had a relationship. 58:41 We already knew what we were going to do. 58:42 We had your escape vehicle idling. 58:44 You had my escape pod sitting there ready to go. 58:47 And I told Boden, we're getting in it. 58:50 Get ready to take off. 58:52 Fuck these fucking woke motherfuckers. 58:54 Hi there. 58:55 This is not the end of this podcast. 58:58 In fact, we're only just getting going. 59:02 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast in full. 59:09 No extra charge. 59:10 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 59:21 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 59:26 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 59:31 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 59:39 It's very easy, andrewsullivan.softfact.com is 50 bucks a year. 59:43 Great value for money, and you also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 59:49 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 59:54 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 59:57 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 60:08 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 60:11 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 60:14 Join the debate. 60:15 Join the fun. 60:17 Subscribe.
Community discussion