0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there. 0:28 Welcome to our new season of 2026. 0:31 We're covering all topics under the sun. 0:35 I want to thank you for subscribing. 0:39 Really deeply, deeply grateful. 0:41 We need you more than ever. 0:42 If you haven't subscribed, please do. 0:45 We don't have any ads. 0:46 We have no sponsorships. 0:48 It's a really pure podcast. 0:50 This is just to you, paid by you. 0:55 No other people involved whatsoever. 0:57 I will not try and sell you a lawnmower in the next hour and a half, I promise you. 1:01 So please do. 1:02 We have some really fantastic guests coming up. 1:05 We're moving a little bit away this season from contemporary events, partly because I'm sick of them. 1:11 And I think I've said all I really have to say about them. 1:15 And we'll pick up again with the Political Day podcast. 1:18 And in that respect, my guest today has written a book about 1:41 The most influential school of thought, really, in the West since the Second World War. 1:47 A school of thought that started in France, migrated to America and became something somewhat different. 1:55 And the writers involved in this are really extraordinarily difficult to read. 2:00 And so one is rather thrilled for the idea someone else will read them for us and help explain them to us. 2:07 And that's what Emily E. Aiken has done. 2:09 She's a senior editor for the New York Times Book Review. 2:12 She's worked as a senior editor at The New Yorker, an ideas reporter for The New York Times, a fashion features writer at Vogue, and a deputy editor at Lingua Franca magazine, a new book, this book. 2:23 It's called The Frenchman, which is a great title, or My Life in Theory. 2:28 Welcome, bienvenue. 2:31 Thank you so much, Andrew. 2:33 Emily, what a terrific book this was. 2:35 I mean, it's a handful and a lot of complicated ideas to deal with. 2:41 So let me tell you, let me ask you first of all, tell me about your parents. 2:45 What did they do for a living and how did they affect your trajectory in life, do you think? 2:51 Absolutely. 2:52 This is a good way in. 2:53 I was primed to fall for French theory for many reasons, but a central one being that I come from a family of Francophiles. 3:03 My father was a professor of American literature at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana. 3:11 He's retired now, but he was and is a lifelong Francophile. 3:16 In fact, I have a photo of him early on in my book, sitting in his Parisian garret in 1960 in full existentialist regalia, the black turtleneck and the black framed glasses, holding an issue of Combat, the leftist newspaper, with the shocked headline, Albert Camus est mort. 3:36 On the sudden unexpected death of Albert Camus. 3:39 And Camus, of course, was a serious contributor to combat in the Second World War. 3:44 Absolutely. 3:45 Absolutely. 3:46 And part of the whole existentialist movement until he had a falling out with Jean-Paul Sartre. 3:50 And so I inherited this love of French and France in part because every time my father had a sabbatical, he would take us to Europe, twice to Paris. 4:01 And so some of my earliest memories are of living I was in Paris, actually during the structuralist heyday in the 70s, being in nursery school at the Maternelle, and my mother being late to pick me up because Claude Levi-Strauss's lecture had run over. 4:21 Claude Lévi-Strauss, of course, being the father of structuralist thought, the man who brought structuralist theory to France. 4:28 My parents were oligog, reading all the structuralist books in French. 4:32 And so that really primed me, I think, to be receptive to French theory. 4:39 And yes, absolutely. 4:41 Well, that's a quite extraordinary story. 4:44 You basically had no choice but to get through these people. 4:47 If you're going to shake off your mom and dad at some point, you have to go through what your mom and dad were reading, even in the original French. 4:53 And by the way, of course, I think some of these books do read better in the French. 4:58 There's a kind of beauty and clarity to the French language, structure to it, that is much more – make some of these works more accessible to me anyway. 5:08 I think that's absolutely true. 5:10 And of course, having had this exposure to French early on, I continued to take French classes and was interested in French in my senior year. 5:20 I spent in Rennes in Brittany on a program program. 5:23 Partly just to get out of landlocked Indiana. 5:26 I sort of had enough of the Midwest and the small town. 5:30 But when I got to college, I took French literature classes. 5:33 And French departments were the portal through which theory entered American campuses, at least initially. 5:41 And so I was... 5:42 I did French literature as well. 5:44 But my special subjects were Montaigne and Pascal. 5:48 So slightly different... 5:51 You were a more classically oriented student. 5:54 The revelation for me, the class that just blew my mind was a class, I think it was the spring of my sophomore year on experimental French literature. 6:03 It was 20th century. 6:04 We read Georges Bataille's Pornographic novel, novella, L'histoire de l'oeil, The Story of the Eye, which Susan Sontag says is one of the best pornographic novels of the 20th century. 6:16 We read Marguerite Ross, we read Alain Robbrier, Nathalie Sorote, Monique Vittig, a kind of militant lesbian novelist. 6:25 It was all very exciting and new, and it went hand-in-hand with theory. 6:29 Yeah. 6:30 What exactly blew your mind in that class? 6:32 What was the idea that struck you as sort of mind-blowing? 6:37 I think I had been brought up, first of all, I went to a fairly generic, big public high school in the Midwest and had never read experimental literature really of any kind. 6:52 And the idea that one could This was shocking and new and exciting for me. 6:56 Something thrilling was happening below the surface. 6:58 And that really is what theory offered, a kind of access to these hidden layers of meaning. 7:03 And so, you know, I had been nurtured on the realist novel. 7:21 And of course, the theorists were saying realism is sort of an illusion and a fiction. 7:26 Look at all the manipulations and omissions and contradictions sort of simmering beneath the surface. 7:34 So as a way of looking at texts in a completely new and exciting way that would, in your view, uncover some hidden themes, some hidden meanings that Then you get into the twist that even the author wasn't intending to produce. 7:49 You've put it in your introduction rather well, actually, about what the structuralists were about, and especially in contrast with the existentialists. 8:00 This is, I think, a really beautiful way of putting it. 8:03 Where the existentialists promoted a humanist creed with, at its heart, a heroic individual imposing meaning on a senseless world, The structuralists ditch the idea of the human altogether, replacing it with a vision of language as an all-powerful impersonal system 8:22 whose formative effects on our lives have been poorly understood and routinely underestimated. 8:30 There was little room, you go on, for physical existence. 8:34 No, the Frenchman said, language is all there is. 8:38 Well, that, of course, is a really aggressive and interesting idea, but 9:00 But the first time you think about it, you think, well, no, obviously not. 9:05 Yes, you can play with text and text are within a con. 9:09 But no, there is something of it. 9:10 There is reality. 9:11 There is the world we live in. 9:13 Tell us why that commonsensical objection to this, which is that, come on, it's not everything. 9:21 It can be a lot, but it's not everything. 9:24 Tell us how they would respond to that objection. 9:29 May I say that first I want to respond to the question from my perspective and just say that I was very compelled by this question. 9:37 I wanted to understand how did language rise to the fore? 9:42 What happened to This did not seem obvious or explicable to me, the transition from the humanist self of existentialism after World War to this impersonal subject being manipulated by language, by assistance. 9:59 So 10:04 I think my first response to the question is to kind of see a larger historical context for this development, which on the surface of it just seems so improbable and extraordinary. 10:16 Don't you agree? 10:18 Yes, I find these ideas preposterous, to be honest with you. 10:21 I mean, at least they're fun to a point, at which point they seem to me to collapse under their own weight. 10:29 So the question for me was what happened in France in the 60s, actually beginning in the late 50s is when Levi-Strauss brought structuralism to France. 10:39 That the word became dominant and omnipotent. 10:45 And I really began to understand this as partly a function of large-scale historical development so that... 10:53 You know, France, after World War II, experienced a period of enormous economic growth. 10:58 The French call it Les Tentes Glorieuses. 11:02 The economy grew at an average of more than 6% a year for a lot of that, those three decades. 11:08 But then gradually... 11:10 And France retreated from the world stage and the world seemed to be carved up between these enormous superpowers, the capitalist, imperialist United States, the communist Soviet Union, and France's role was severely diminished. 11:24 And the idea that he... 11:27 That began to seem more and more of an illusion. 11:31 France was engaged in these sort of battles with its colonies in Africa. 11:36 These were deeply bloody battles. 11:38 The Algerians, a lot of thinkers on the left, were for Algerian independence, but it was coming at huge, huge human costs. 11:47 And so this idea of the world, the existential world liberated by the individual in charge of history, 11:58 The nation state, obviously, is a separate thing. 12:03 To infer from a single nation state's declining relevance in a world governed by two great superpowers does not seem to me to tell you anything about the role of language or the 12:20 The irrelevance of the individual human being. 12:24 It might have created a mood of helplessness, right? 12:27 But what's the other link? 12:29 What's the other link? 12:35 Okay. 12:49 And Reggie Debray's memoir tracks this perfectly. 12:52 He says, you know, in the age of the society of the spectacle, you know, history 13:05 And so I do think that there were these cues historically that set the stage for a receptivity to language. 13:09 This is how I understand it. 13:23 And the language, the recourse language, the way of explaining the helplessness is of the French or of indeed any viewpoint outside this Cold War clash. 13:36 Yes. 13:37 So, of course, the philosophers I write about were writing from a perspective of descendants, from a long line of thinkers, many of them German, who were struggling with these very profound, difficult ideas. 13:51 The foundational idea is being, truth, reality, the self. 13:57 And so you get to a point where you have a thinker like Derrida saying, you know, there is actually no escape from what he called the 14:10 Heidegger tried his best. 14:12 He coined neologisms to talk about this idea of being, right? 14:16 Being in the world and being in language. 14:20 But the next wave I think the thinkers applied a kind of rigorous scrutiny to those contentions and found that, in fact, there is no escaping language, that language really is this powerful structure. 14:34 And so you have this sense of systems. 14:36 The world being more and more a product of kind of these impersonal forces combined with a sense that philosophy had come to a dead end. 14:47 Metaphysics was really rooted and stuck in language. 14:51 And I think that combination leads to an idea of a linguistic system that actually structures the human and a kind of anti-humanist philosophy of language, which is what structuralism is. 15:03 Right. 15:04 Here's what I don't quite understand. 15:07 Maybe you can help me understand it better. 15:09 What does a metaphysical trap mean? 15:12 What does that mean, actually, in plain English? 15:15 Why is the average person walking around on the street today or listening to this podcast, why are they in a metaphysical trap that they don't really even appreciate or understand? 15:26 Yeah. 15:28 Which is roughly what these people are arguing. 15:30 Even if true, why should I think about it? 15:33 There's a beautiful essay that gets at this by Derrida called White Mythology. 15:38 And the subtitle is something like The Role of Metaphor and Philosophy, where he's contemplating the idea that all of language is metaphoric. 15:49 And the image that runs thematically through the piece is this image of a coin with the face of the coin rubbed off. 15:58 So words that have been in circulation so much that we no longer can see the face. 16:03 We don't think of words like the and and as being metaphoric. 16:07 Metaphors are supposed to be ideas that we deliberately 16:19 We say, you know, a rose stands for love. 16:22 But Derrida in this essay points out that all language is metaphoric in the sense that it stands in for something. 16:30 And this is philosophy's fundamental and to him very moving, ultimately, predicament that how do we get at these foundational concepts when we're doomed to talk about them metaphorically? 16:43 Truth is just a metaphor for a concept, right, that we can't access except through speech, through writing, through words. 16:52 And that's what he means by the metaphysical enclosure. 16:55 There's no escaping the metaphysical enclosure. 16:58 Deconstruction, we can talk about later, was his gesture toward that, but he conceded there is no escape. 17:05 Even deconstruction cannot escape it. 17:08 They're not life outside of language. 17:12 Derrida would say, of course, there's life outside of language. 17:15 All these philosophers were. 17:17 But language, we can't access it directly, right? 17:21 The idea then, and I think they would probably not concede it even now, is Is that language structures even our unconscious. 17:31 So all perception is structured by language, is mediated by language. 17:36 Doesn't mean there isn't something called reality or truth, but these ideas are fragile and because they are fundamentally inaccessible outside the discourse that you and I are engaged in right now, right? 17:52 Yeah. 17:53 I guess. 17:56 I find if you actually, and you talk about this a little bit as you became sort of subsumed in these ideas, that you kept living as if you were living meta-narratives. 18:08 You weren't actually living an actual life, that what we see to be real in our lives, you kept just getting displaced a little bit and seeing it as simply a narrative. 18:20 And the trouble with Narratives and discourses, seems to me, is that they're very plastic. 18:26 You can make them up, you can adjust them, in which there is no reality underlying it whatsoever. 18:35 How do you reconnect these discourses to anything called underlying reality if all that exists are discourses? 18:45 Well, I mean, that is the struggle, Andrew. 18:47 You've put your finger on it. 18:48 I mean, that's why universalist ideas that we've inherited from the Enlightenment, ideas about sort of justice and equality are constantly being contested, right? 19:01 We can't, as a species, seem to agree on what these concepts mean. 19:06 And the... 19:07 The takeaway of these French thinkers is really to understand why these concepts should be contested, why they are, because, right, we have no objective foundation on which to erect a single truth. 19:24 I think we do. 19:25 It's available to everyone. 19:27 I want to cite something that I just read that I think is apropos from a book of essays by Emily Wilson, who, of course, may be right now the most famous classicist in the world, thanks to her translation of the Odyssey and to her viral stories. 19:41 And she says, you know, language is no neutral tool by which we represent the world. 19:59 That's, of course, a direct thought inherited from the French thinkers. 20:04 And she goes on to say, language writes us, but we can still change the world by changing our words. 20:12 And I really like that because I... 20:14 I think right there is a sort of pivy distillation of the sort of paradox we're talking about. 20:20 Language may write us in the sense that it's much more powerful than most of us want to admit, right? 20:26 We don't go about our daily lives thinking about how we're victims of language or language just controlling our thoughts. 20:32 Because maybe we're not. 20:34 But that's another question. 20:36 Well... 20:36 I mean, I'm still grappling with this idea of reality. 20:39 It seems to be language... 20:41 Is an attempt to represent reality, right? 20:45 It's to say, I see a stone, I see a flower. 20:48 I'm using that word to point to something that's real. 20:52 And you're telling me, no, none of this is real. 20:55 No. 20:56 No, I'm not. 20:58 We can't know that it's real. 21:00 But I'm pointing out something that where do those, why do I understand what you mean when you say, I see a rock out the window, right? 21:08 It's how is meaning produced? 21:10 And this is what's fascinating. 21:11 Fascinating is that the structuralists said it's not that each name, each item, each noun names corresponds to a thing in the world, right? 21:21 It's actually meaning exists because of the way words differ from. 21:26 Meaning is, language is a hermetic system. 21:30 It's a closed system in which meaning accrues to a word because of how it's differentiated from other words. 21:38 And that's really quite fascinating. 21:40 Well, that's one way of putting it. 21:41 You could say it's also defined by pointing to something in reality that we've all seen in reality. 21:47 We sort of know it exists in reality, and therefore we can agree that this word applies to it and use it in a reasonable way to actually have meaning. 21:56 A conversation. 21:57 You take that away, you can't have a real conversation. 22:02 Well, we're not taking it away, we're just pointing out the French thinkers. 22:06 It's interesting how I'm now sort of inhabiting their policies. 22:11 Please 22:12 do for a while. 22:13 I'm trying to understand them better. 22:16 So language for the structuralist is this vast impersonal system. 22:21 It's not referential. 22:23 Language doesn't refer to anything outside itself. 22:26 It's relational. 22:28 I just don't say that. 22:30 It just doesn't make any sense to me. 22:33 We could call a rock a lamp or a table. 22:36 I mean, it's utterly arbitrary that these particular letters, these signifiers, correspond to this concept or signified. 22:45 That, in fact, is the legacy of a Swiss linguist named Ferdinand de Saussure, who taught at the beginning of the 20th century and whose ideas about language, which I don't think are debated really by linguists, were picked up by the structure. 23:00 And put at the center of structuralist theory. 23:04 So the idea that language is a sort of scrim over the world doesn't mean the world doesn't exist. 23:09 It just means we are doomed to talk about it in words. 23:14 It's the only option we have. 23:16 And what does that mean? 23:17 Well, these French thinkers wanted to give that paradox a kind of very rigorous scrutiny. 23:24 And some of them did this more effectively than others. 23:27 Yeah. 23:27 When painters paint reality or a musician composes something, these don't have words, but they are reflecting reality as they see it. 23:38 So why does that not make an exception to this idea of languages controlling absolutely everything? 23:46 I think that they would say that actually painting what we see in painting, we don't just see our brains compute and translate images within the painting. 23:56 We might say, oh, those are series of red and blue stars. 24:01 If it's an abstract painting or if it's Velázquez Las Meninas, which Foucault writes brilliantly about, we could describe the royal family that's depicted in the painting, the painter, the easel, the mirror at the back of the painting, right? 24:17 Our brains are already processing an image linguistically, I think is what they would say. 24:23 You're getting very technical with me, Andrew. 24:25 Yeah. 24:25 Well, I'm just trying to get at what these bloody people are talking about, which is a struggle at times because the language is obviously at some point deliberately obscurantist in a way. 24:41 But yeah, so you have this lovely, this sort of exciting idea in a way that the discourse is everything and therefore we need to interrogate the discourse. 24:50 We need to unpack everything in the discourse, unveil everything that might be conceivably hidden in the discourse. 24:57 And the question then becomes what then? 24:59 When you've deconstructed everything, What is left but a kind of nihilism? 25:05 Is that a fair criticism of this approach? 25:09 I mean, there was an interesting point when you mentioned you're talking to a fellow student and you talk about what books he's read in theory. 25:17 He said, oh, I don't actually read books. 25:18 I just read theory. 25:20 And I personally... 25:24 Can see his point. 25:25 If there's only discourse, only theory, then it's really irrelevant whether you're picking up Edgar Allan Poe or whether you're picking up Shakespeare or whether you're picking up the latest lyrics from Lil Nas X. 25:37 You know, it's all discourse. 25:41 Well, it matters utterly, actually. 25:43 The French philosophers really, and again, I'm lumping together men who were very, very different and don't even deserve to be lumped under a single label. 25:55 This is true. 25:57 Many of them passed through a structuralist phase. 25:59 Derrida and Paul Daman were mostly post-structuralists, in other words, critics of structuralist dogma as they saw it. 26:07 But what most of them were doing, particularly Derrida's, We're reading the Western philosophical tradition extremely closely, very, very rigorously to point out places where metaphysical claims about just the foundational concepts we've been discussing. 26:26 Truth, reality, the self were problematic because assumed rather than proven. 26:33 And the idea of deconstruction is to sort of always look at a text. 26:39 There's always a text that's being deconstructed. 26:41 You don't just deconstruct. 26:45 Theory had an object. 26:47 That was my understanding. 26:48 And it was a rigorous way of reading. 26:51 That was the point. 26:52 That's what Derrida was up to. 26:54 Now, in the United States... 26:56 Suddenly that idea, there was a kind of a concept creep where the whole world became subject to deconstruction and the word itself became increasingly meaningless. 27:05 I mean, we could deconstruct a building, a TV show, a cartoon, an advertiser. 27:11 It began to seem sort of meaningless. 27:15 And of course, was fodder for pundits on the right who said, what is this? 27:19 This is just sort of saying that there's no meaning. 27:23 Language is meaningless. 27:24 It's endlessly unstable. 27:26 And that's what right-wing pundits did through many bestsellers beginning in the late 80s. 27:32 Well, I think calling Alan Bloom a right-wing pundit is a little unfair, 27:36 don't you? 27:37 I didn't cite any names, and I will distinguish. 27:41 Alan Bloom was a serious classicist. 27:43 His book was the first of the books that critiqued some of these European thinkers. 27:49 And he did blame them for importing a kind of nihilism to America by suggesting that... 27:58 Foundational ideas were relative, right? 28:00 That we couldn't really get at truth. 28:02 Truth was relative. 28:03 Your truth and my truth, what do we even mean when we use these words? 28:08 And so, yes, I want to say, yes, the charge of nihilism is somewhat fair to be put at the doorstep of the French thinkers, but not wholesale nihilism, because they were really looking at the Western philosophical tradition for a kind of, So metaphysical missteps, if you will. 28:32 But the one thing you would find, let's say you would take a text, like, in other words, we do it properly, take a passage of Jane Austen and deconstruct it. 28:44 One of the things that is not going on there in deconstructing it is asking myself, what was Jane Austen trying to convey here, right? 28:52 Now that just strikes me as someone who writes for a living and reads for a living, just to break a very fundamental relationship between writer and reader, to essentially abolish the writer altogether. 29:09 And the reader then becomes as much the author as the actual author in a way. 29:13 And you talk about this explicitly at some point. 29:16 And that removes anybody's capacity, individual capacity, to offer their own take on the world. 29:28 And to be taken as valuable because they have done it and their individual choice of words, their individual concepts of plot, their individual elaboration of character. 29:41 This is why we want to read a And Jane Austen was trying to do something when she wrote the book. 29:48 She didn't just write a text and say, well, here you are. 29:50 This text is now over to you, Roland Barthes. 29:53 Right. 29:54 Okay. 29:55 She had an idea. 29:56 So what happens to that relationship? 29:58 I trust we have in an author. 30:00 That's very interesting. 30:01 It makes me think of a comment by an alt-right influencer named Mike Soranovic, who told a reporter for The New Yorker. 30:10 Soranovic, you mean? 30:11 Cernovich, I think you mean. 30:12 Cernovich. 30:13 Okay, Mike Cernovich, who told a reporter. 30:17 Totally fascist. 30:18 Anyway, go on. 30:19 Who told a reporter for The New Yorker, you know, what if Walter Cronkite turned out to have made up all his broadcasts? 30:28 You know, how would we know? 30:29 His broadcast dominated a whole period of American news broadcasts. 30:34 You know, this is what the French thinkers have taught us. 30:38 We need alternative narratives. 30:40 We need alternative facts. 30:42 I bet you didn't have me pegged as someone who read Lacan. 30:45 He says something like this in The New Yorker. 30:48 And I think this is what you're getting at, that like is one of the takeaways of these thinkers that anything goes, any interpretation. 30:56 If I don't like what this consensus around this text is, I can offer my own completely different one. 31:03 I think the French thinkers would be appalled. 31:05 Again, they never intended most of them for their work to be used in these overtly political ways. 31:11 They were doing close readings of the canon, actually, not a news broadcast. 31:18 Right. 31:19 Right. 31:19 Right. 31:34 And as much as it's all narratives, we can say certain things. 31:37 We can talk about the deep state. 31:40 We can come up with invisible forces that are behind. 31:44 And our discourse is as good as anybody's discourse. 31:48 And we're just going to be more successful at getting it across. 31:50 At that point, we've lost all contact with reality and certainly with anything that can work in a democracy. 31:59 I think it comes down to being able to hold two contradictory thoughts in one's head and believe both, that Derrida and his colleagues would certainly say murder is wrong, inequality is real, poverty exists, all of these facts about the world. 32:20 He talked about the fact that he never wrote about science. 32:24 There was a whole science scandal that we could get And Derrida was implicated in that because a physicist named Alan Sokol submitted a parody article, a kind of nonsense piece using French theory to suggest things like pi had no basis in reality or were endlessly unstable. 32:45 There was no gravitational constant. 32:46 It was relative. 32:48 And then he exposed this parody as a fake after it had been published to the great embarrassment of the editors in a leading theory journal. 32:57 And Derrida was interviewed and was very defensive about this. 33:00 And he says, you know, I never write about science. 33:03 I mean, he would say he believes in science. 33:05 So this idea that you 33:07 can do... 33:09 You can do a rigorous reading of sort of the Western philosophical canon and show where metaphysicians in a long line to Heidegger have made missteps and believe that there are fundamental and unchangeable facts about the world. 33:25 Both can be true is what I think you would hear them say. 33:29 That's not satisfying to you. 33:31 No, it isn't. 33:33 The facts always, at least maybe I'm wrong about this, but they always end up being kind of left-oriented, the facts. 33:42 Why are all these people seemingly leftist? 33:45 I mean, what is there in it? 33:49 Is it because if discourse is all there is, if we change the discourse, we can change the entire world, and that's our only hope? 33:59 Is that the argument? 34:01 Well, I think, again, they, being the French thinkers, we have to place them within their historical context. 34:08 One of the main ideas for motives for me writing this book was to sort of restore the human to the anti-humanist. 34:16 So to put these men's ideas, I don't think ideas just come out of nowhere, right? 34:20 I think they come from embodied experience. 34:24 All of these men, Without exception, were alive during World War II, had very difficult experiences during World War II, saw what fascism did in Europe, and were horrified. 34:37 To be a French intellectual in the 40s, 50s, and 60s was to be mostly, overwhelmingly, the French intellectuals were men of the left, right? 34:48 So these are men who came up steeped in a leftism and were... 34:54 Gravitated toward philosophy. 34:56 And this, Andrew, may be a side conversation. 34:58 What is it about French intellectual life that makes thinkers prone to the sort of philosophical trajectory? 35:06 It's one of the few countries I can think of in the West where philosophers... 35:09 Philosophers routinely hold state positions. 35:13 Emmanuel Macron studied philosophy. 35:17 He didn't get into the École Normale, but he did his degree in philosophy. 35:21 And so there's a really tight connection between philosophy and politics. 35:25 There always has been. 35:26 So again, I think it's the particulars of the kind of French culture that may be our explanation here. 35:35 And yet they also... 35:37 Almost to a person. 35:40 They were quite fond of Mao and what was going on in China. 35:44 In other words, they seemed to – where on earth in their discourse did they find support for what was a cultural revolution that killed millions of people that was one of the most hideous – Despotic, crazy tyrannies ever to have existed on the earth. 36:02 And these people horrified by Nazism were nonetheless embracing Maoism. 36:07 And of course, not to throw in an insult, but then famously Foucault embraced the Iranian revolution as well. 36:13 So one can say that their political judgment does not seem terribly solid, at least it seems to me. 36:22 Right, right. 36:23 Since when should theorists, you know, be held to, what shall I say? 36:29 Since when a theorist had the last word on politics? 36:32 I mean, in our own country, we have, you know, Francis Fukuyama predicting the end of I think that's fair. 36:38 But I think these problems exist. 36:39 The connection between abstract philosophy and philosophical 36:52 But the news from China was never that bad. 36:54 Even though it was horrifying. 37:21 I'm trying to think of which one really remained kind of, you know, Maoist. 37:25 And I think Bard had a Maoist phase. 37:27 Derrida did not. 37:29 And Paul Dumont did not. 37:31 And Foucault, his partner was a Maoist for sure. 37:36 Right. 37:37 You're right about the Iranian Revolution. 37:39 He saw that as a kind of anti-Western, in a very romantic way, as a kind of genuine, authentic expression of anti-Western political idealism. 37:49 And he was very wrong about how that unfolded. 37:53 Let me suggest something to you from thinking about the historical period that they're in, the Trente Glorieuses. 38:01 Right. 38:03 In some ways, you can see this as a failure. 38:05 But in other ways, what's a failure about it? 38:08 I mean, the French are more prosperous than ever. 38:11 They're a free country. 38:14 They've had three decades of solid growth. 38:17 It's hard to see that as some massive crisis of the country. 38:23 And in some ways, I sort of see some of these... 38:26 Movements as really desperate attempts to deny the success of bourgeois liberal democracy that's happening around them. 38:36 That they simply cannot tolerate this level of contentment and happiness. 38:42 These intellectuals, that's a terrible fate to end up as these happy, contented television watching consumers. 38:49 Pause them. 38:50 But it's what people wanted. 38:52 It's what they're currently begging to come back. 38:56 Look, you're right. 38:58 Bourgeois was an epithet. 38:59 It probably still is in France. 39:01 And for all of them, exposing kind of the mystifications of bourgeois ideology was a primary concern. 39:07 I say for all of them. 39:09 I mean, we are really conflating a whole spectrum of attitudes toward politics. 39:14 I mean, Foucault... 39:15 Foucault was the most, in the 70s, was the most activist of them all. 39:20 Derrida, not at all, right? 39:23 He didn't use the word bourgeois or ideology or really embraced politics until deconstruction was accused of being apolitical. 39:32 And in the 80s, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, he started writing about the legacy of Marxism and ethics in a much more focused and concentrated way. 39:43 And so he felt pressure, I think, to be more political. 39:46 And so you're right. 39:47 I mean, these men come out of a kind of a left-wing milieu. 39:51 The critique of literature and language is a critique of bourgeois ideology. 39:57 This is what is being exposed, right? 39:59 This is where language is complicit with power in insidious ways. 40:03 And that even though people... 40:05 Even people may think they're happy, they're not. 40:08 At least that's the idea. 40:10 And of course, to some extent, let's talk, because you do this in the book in a way that probably some theorists find disreputable in a way, but you talk about these people's lives, these actual human lives. 40:21 They are a very screwed up bunch of men, it seems to me. 40:24 Now let's go through them. 40:27 Althusser got on top of his wife, put two fingers into her throat, and slowly strangled her to death. 40:36 And then calls up his fellow friends and says, Oh my God, I just strangled my wife. 40:39 Why did I do this? 40:41 What discourse created this? 40:43 Right? 40:43 Now that's Althusser. 40:44 Foucault was... 40:46 Wait, 40:47 may I interject? 40:48 Yes, please. 40:49 Defend each of these music. 40:52 I don't think that's quite fair, of course. 40:54 Hi there. 40:56 This is not the end of this podcast. 40:59 In fact, we're only just getting going. 41:02 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this... 41:05 It means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast info. 41:09 No extra charge. 41:11 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 41:21 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 41:27 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 41:31 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 41:39 It's very easy. 41:41 AndrewSullivan.substack.com is 50 bucks a year. 41:44 Great value for money. 41:45 You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 41:49 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 41:54 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 41:58 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 42:09 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 42:11 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 42:14 Join the debate. 42:16 Join the fun. 42:17 Subscribe.
Community discussion