0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there. 0:29 Welcome to the DishCast. 0:31 It's a really fun one for me. 0:32 I'm happy. 0:33 I'm back in the studio in Washington, D.C. 0:36 with the team all back together, Chris Bodine, my trusted confidant, colleague, co-creator, and impresario of the entire Dish experience, and Seltsuk Karawalan. 0:48 I got it right. 0:49 I think Karawalan. 0:50 That's right. 0:51 Who is our producer, a swishing board, In D.C., a fantastic operation, a fantastic human being. 0:58 So grateful for his support and work all these years. 1:01 And last but not least, we have Truman, the Pit-Pom, the Pitbull Pomeranian, a splendid little thing who's actually today, because it's really hot in D.C., a little tired from the long walk here and should be quite quiet today with any luck. 1:18 I want to thank you, first of all, for subscribing. 1:22 We have some amazing guests coming up. 1:25 We have just to discuss the midterms after they happen. 1:51 We're bringing back Michael Barone, one of the smartest and wisest people about American politics, knows more than almost anyone who's retired but still very much watching the game. 2:02 Francis Fukuyama is coming on to talk about his memoir and especially the impact of The End of History. 2:11 The book that was grotesquely misunderstood, misread. 2:14 Well, actually not misread, just no one read it and everyone talked about it. 2:18 It's actually an absolutely quite splendid book, I think. 2:21 Hamish McKenzie, the great man who founded Substack, is coming on to talk about it. 2:25 We're going to talk about Substack and journalism. 2:27 Cynthia Burak is coming on to talk about how gender studies has essentially destroyed the university. 2:34 And we have some great spiritual broadcasts. 2:37 We're going to have one entirely devoted to Pascal. 2:40 And we're going to have one entirely devoted to Augustine. 2:44 And we have Cyrus Habib coming on. 2:46 He is a very smart young politician out west who decided to become a Jesuit priest. 2:53 And the story that he tells himself is a story that I think is worth hearing. 2:57 Unfortunately, Sean Ealing, our friend who was supposed to come up this week and we were going to talk about Nietzsche and Camille, got derailed by the hurricane. 3:04 And I love Sean so much, I really want to do it in person. 3:07 So we're going to delay that until we can do it in person. 3:10 But today... 3:12 An old, old friend. 3:13 We've known each other since our 20s, when we were both slightly different characters. 3:18 Not really. 3:19 Chris Caldwell is a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute, a contributing editor of the Claremont Review of Books, a contributing writer for the New York Times, and a member of the editorial committee of the French Quarterly, Coltaire. 3:32 He's back now for the fourth time because I can never get enough of Christopher. 3:38 I... 3:39 Heads up. 3:40 I think he's the most intelligent, sane, and well-read conservative thinker writing in America today. 3:50 And it's always a privilege and a pleasure to have you back. 3:53 Well, I'm delighted to be in your company again, Andrew. 3:56 Thank you. 3:57 Since we last spoke... 4:00 A certain war has broken out. 4:02 What didn't break out was obviously purposely initiated by the president and the prime minister of Israel. 4:10 When I heard inkling this was about to happen, I was somewhat in disbelief and then wrote a piece before it happened saying, for fuck's sake, don't do this. 4:21 And I don't know quite how it came about. 4:23 Perhaps we'll find out. 4:24 But to me, it was A watershed moment in not just the second term of Trump, but in the entire project post-2016 of reconstituting American right. 4:34 Tell me your thoughts about that particular event. 4:37 Yes, I absolutely agree. 4:39 And I wrote an article in The Spectator in the immediate aftermath of our decision to go to war called The End of Trumpism. 4:50 I think it really... 4:52 It does a couple of things. 4:54 One is, it is an outright broken promise to the most loyal part of his electorate. 5:05 You know, Trump has always made a lot of people nervous, including a lot of people who supported and voted for him. 5:13 But he seemed to be disinclined to use the most extensive and unchallengeable powers in the arsenal of an American executive, which is the military side of things, where the president can pretty much do what he wants. 5:29 That's suddenly off the table. 5:32 There's a final thing that has worked more slowly, and that is... 5:37 I think that it's sort of in a way that Trump surely did not understand. 5:42 It's kind of broken faith with his old economic agenda. 5:46 As I think we've discussed on this show before, Trumpism as a, let's say, Trumponomics, if we can call it that, has its strengths and its weaknesses. 5:57 Trump's economy in his first term grew more slowly than the economy of Bush or Obama before him. 6:05 But Because of certain elements of it, like the protectionism and the tight border and the limited immigration, the gains of it were better spread. 6:18 And so in a way that's kind of invisible to the pundit. 6:21 Recent legal immigrants. 6:23 Yes, yes. 6:51 Well, legal or, you know, yeah, I mean, they have to be legal to vote in theory at least. 6:56 And so that, I think, was a terrible breaking of faith with his electorate. 7:02 And it's landed him in hot water because he's got no credit for it among the people who didn't like him to begin with. 7:07 But he's getting questions from... 7:10 I agree. 7:14 When you look at the first term, I kept waiting for a couple of things. 7:18 One for him to launch a war, which he didn't. 7:21 The other was to use a crisis like COVID to put the military on the streets or do some kind of controlling thing. 7:30 And neither of those things happened. 7:31 And in fact, he did seem quite consistent. 7:35 But obviously Trump is not an ideologue. 7:38 He does not have any set of principles. 7:43 He's a character. 7:44 And each decision he makes in foreign policy tends to be dependent on... 7:50 The last person he spoke with and his own sense of himself in history or whatever. 7:56 And I think that's what happened, right? 7:57 I mean, they told him you could be the great savior of the Middle East. 8:02 You could bring about a democratic revolution in Iran, get rid of the nuclear problem, reestablish the Abraham Accords and basically bring sunshine and happiness everywhere. 8:14 And the CIA in that meeting said, It did describe that scenario. 8:19 It was farcical. 8:21 But he still went ahead with it. 8:22 Why? 8:22 Because he has no sense, it turns out, of his own base. 8:27 No base, no sense of that. 8:31 Instead, it was all about him. 8:33 And so we know all of that now in that first term was a kind of accident. 8:37 It was a way to get himself into power as opposed to a new set of priorities for the Republican Party. 8:44 Well, yes, that's a very... 8:45 This is a very... 8:49 Let's talk about that in a second. 8:51 I mean, in terms of the way he did get into war, and I think that the key document when we think about this is that particular news story done by Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan about the meeting in Washington last, I guess it was last February, in which... 9:15 You know, Benjamin Netanyahu was visiting from Israel and he put the head of Mossad on video and there was a large discussion and there was an attempt to persuade the United States to launch this war. 9:30 And it's very interesting. 9:32 It was very heavily sourced. 9:35 And I think that all of the people in that room were very eager to tell The New York Times as quickly as they could. 9:42 I wasn't for this. 9:44 But what's really striking is this appeal that you describe. 9:49 You know, Mr. President, you're going to be the greatest. 9:52 Everyone is going to. 9:53 Everyone is going to love you. 9:55 And I think that he was made... 9:56 He was made vulnerable to this appeal from Netanyahu, certainly. 10:01 He was made vulnerable to this appeal by the seeming success, at least on Trump's own terms, of the raid on Venezuela. 10:11 But, you know. 10:11 An interesting irony is that this way of appealing to someone to get them to do something, you're going to be the best. 10:19 Everyone's going to love you. 10:21 Don't be like him. 10:22 Everyone's going to hate him. 10:24 He's a loser. 10:25 You know, that kind of thing. 10:26 Much like the way Trump appealed to his own electorate. 10:30 You know, Russia is laughing at who's laughing at China. 10:33 They're laughing at us. 10:34 They're feeling sorry for us, you know, and and it goes to show like so many things in the in Trump's behavior that appear mystifying at first. 10:45 They're actually there's a kind of simplicity to them, you know, almost an integrity to them. 10:50 That is sort of the way he. 10:52 He views the world. 10:56 If you like me, I'll like you. 10:58 If you suck up to me, I'll do good things for you. 11:01 That also, of course, his own complete obliviousness to usual standards and norms means also we've also seen something that we didn't quite see to this extent in any way in the first term, which is corruption of quite staggering proportions. 11:18 Billions of dollars in crypto bullshit. 11:20 Favors dispensed. 11:23 The Democrats, if they win in November, are going to have an embarrassment of riches in terms of investigation. 11:31 But doesn't that also, when you combine it with that ballroom and that arch and the absolute obsession with gilding, literally gilding the White House to make it look like a sort of Gilded Age campaign, Brothel, as George Will put it. 11:50 That just sends a completely different message than the first term. 11:54 It sends a completely different message than we are here for the forgotten man, the forgotten working class. 12:01 We remember you. 12:03 We're serving you. 12:05 It turns out, no, he's only ever served himself. 12:08 Well, I don't think that there's been any kind of pivot. 12:11 I just think that there's been a, I think Trump I'm not sure that there's an inconsistency in Trump's behavior between the first and the second term, but a couple of things have happened. 12:23 One is Trump was really, I think that Trump was at least somewhat surprised by his victory in 2016. 12:34 And even had he not been surprised, there was a great shortage of Right. 12:39 So you had a situation where you could not he could not. 13:03 The only way the government could keep running was with the people who had been there before Trump. 13:08 And sometime in the interregnum, if we can call it that, sometime during the Biden administration, a lot of people around Trump and sympathetic to Trump really came to understand Trump. 13:23 How the levers of power in the government worked and where you could shut down the alarm systems that would keep you from utterly transforming the executive branch. 13:38 And so... 13:43 By the way, that's not necessarily a bad thing. 13:47 I mean, there is an argument to be made that when the public votes for an executive, it should get a whole new executive branch. 13:55 There is something democratic about that, and there is something legitimate about that wish. 14:02 The way I always put it is that, look, civil services resist change. 14:07 Wherever the administration comes in, there's always friction. 14:11 But there's a hitch. 14:12 But there's a hitch. 14:13 And the hitch is that we have a constitution that was drafted before the French Revolution, which means that its idea of the executive is a monarchical one. 14:26 The American presidency is not like the prime minister's office in a European country. 14:34 It's got great prerogatives. 14:36 And so if you are going to go back... 14:39 To the old system that doesn't have checks and balances built into the executive branch, you need a man of real character. 14:50 And what happened is we, in Donald Trump's second term, we reformed the executive branch so that it can really be operated properly only by a person of George Washington's character, which is at some distance from the situation we're in now. 15:10 So what you're saying is that on the second term, he actually had a plan to control the executive branch and Doge was the first attempt or are we talking about? 15:21 Oh, well, that's interesting. 15:22 I don't know that Doge was the – I think that he had aspirations to make the – Right. 15:49 Unbelievable ideological energy that can really only be compared to Roosevelt's brain trust in the first term starting in March of 1933. 16:00 They really did an extraordinary job. 16:04 Russell Vogt, we're talking about. 16:05 Yes, I think Russell Vogt and Stephen Miller 16:08 would be the two. 16:10 But you would think that the best way to control... 16:13 The executive branch is to appoint really competent and knowledgeable agency chiefs who know their departments and can wrestle them to the ground. 16:23 In fact, he just picked TV hosts and people who looked good on television who had no ability to control their departments whatsoever, except in rather disruptive and counterproductive ways. 16:34 Well, I totally hear what you're saying, but I think that there's also a sociological problem, which is that there's a kind of a culture of being the manager of a government department. 16:50 And it's kind of like the culture of being a public interest lawyer or the head of a foundation or something. 17:00 All of the people who provide expertise to the government, they tend to have been educated in, you know, in similar ways. 17:10 And so they have a culture of their own, which is really resistant to, you know, to, there's a kind of esprit de corps among the bureaucracy that actually has to be broken if an executive is to get it under his control. 17:29 So there's something tragic about this, too. 17:31 Right. 17:32 But the tragedy is presumably that the vote decided we're not just going to make them realize we are now in charge. 17:39 We want to traumatize, shock, disorient them. 17:46 The Musk experiment, which looks, in retrospect, completely weird and irrational. 17:51 It didn't really save any money. 17:53 It just destroyed certain parts of the government that were indeed... 17:58 I take that point entirely. 17:59 But of course, this thuggish attempt to get rid of every inspector general, to put in... 18:17 Idiots, the head of these agencies, unable to really manage them. 18:20 It seems to just be that policy ends in disaster, 18:25 right? 18:27 I don't think we should take the actual name of the effort. 18:33 I think that Department of Government Efficiency was chosen more for the acronym it produced, which was DOGE, you know, which is both the Venetian word for a ruler and the name for a cryptocurrency. 18:49 That's the first time I've heard that. 18:50 The DOGE of Venice? 18:51 Yeah. 18:51 Well, I know. 18:52 I have to. 18:53 But I've never put it together. 18:55 So it was one of Musk's just sort of late night wacky kind of thing. 18:59 But it's not. 19:00 I don't think it's efficiency, I don't think was the real goal of it, although it's an easy it's easier to get. 19:09 It's easier to get such a thing up and running if you profess that it is. 19:14 But I think that it does appear now that the main goal of it was to purge these agencies of unlike-minded people, perhaps with some effectiveness. 19:26 I mean, very interestingly, you see... 19:31 Since the re-election of Donald Trump in 2024, there have been almost no victories of progressive and liberal parties in Latin America. 19:46 All of the elections have been won by conservative parties, you know, most recently in Brazil, at least in the first round. 19:55 And so this has led a lot of people around Trump to crow. 20:01 It was necessary to root out American bias in USAID because it was actually constraining Latin American countries to elect people of a left-leaning. 20:14 That's also the first time I've heard that, which is interesting. 20:17 But we're now almost two years in. 20:22 Let's take the first real question, which is, Spawned by the Iran War, which is the party then has to decide, are we going to support this or are we going to define ourselves in opposition to this? 20:35 And you see Vance clearly taking from the very get-go, as you point out in that Swan Haberman piece, I did not fully approve of this. 20:45 I did due diligence on this. 20:47 At the meeting that they described, he was not present, I think. 20:51 Really? 20:51 Yes. 20:52 He was not present at one of the major bilateral meetings about the Iran war. 20:58 By his own design. 21:01 I don't know if it was by his own. 21:02 I don't know. 21:03 Rubio, who, of course, would seem the most... 21:07 I don't know. 21:09 He's both... 21:10 Classically, we have to think of pre-Trump Rubio, which is kind of... 21:14 I think of Rubio as a classic neoconservative interventionist, human rights defender, a big opponent of the Cuba regime. 21:23 As he is still. 21:24 As he is still, clearly. 21:27 But he clearly realized that, well, since the Iran War with Vance and the forming of a definite non-interventionist wing in the wake of Trump... 21:39 He has to charge another course. 21:42 Now, we had his speech last week in Athens, which I don't know whether, which apparently Nate Hockman ghost wrote, I was told. 21:50 I haven't heard it. 21:50 Did you read that speech? 21:51 No, I haven't. 21:52 Oh. 21:53 It was a very strange speech, Christopher. 21:55 I mean, part of it was great. 21:57 I mean, part of it was, let's defend the West. 21:58 Let's not be ashamed of the West. 22:00 But then he kept defying the West in terms of what he called thumos, this, this, this, which of course- Which is a favorite theme of- Yes, it is. 22:10 And I think it was, I think, well, Fukuyama subsequently wrote an elegant correction of what, of what, how Vance was interpreting it. 22:20 But it seems, I mean, Rubio was interpreting it, but it seems to me he's trying to re... 22:30 Well, 22:36 now we seem to be, this is a slightly different subject than the Iran War. 22:43 But we're talking about the future of a Republican foreign policy. 22:47 And obviously, because Trump has turned out to be so weird and incoherent, We now have a question mark, which is, and the debate the next year will presumably affect the candidate's position in 28. 22:59 What is the Republican foreign policy position going to be? 23:02 Are we going to stick with this more skeptical, non-interventionism, no endless wars? 23:07 Or are we going to not do that? 23:11 Well, there's, I mean, the Republicans had settled quite comfortably into being a semi-pacifist You know what I mean? 23:24 Very distrustful of, you know, not isolationist, but distrustful of grand schemes for improvement of the human rights. 23:36 And now Trump has so strangely drawn them into a... 23:41 Into a compromising position in this. 23:44 It's sort of, there's something, you know, there's a sort of a hypocrisy of it, you know, and it's the difference between a, you know, like a, let's say a telegram. 23:55 Well, well, but you know, I mean, Republicans... 24:22 Have maintained their brand, you know, even as they become semi-isolationist, they've maintained their brand as being the party of the tough, the military, you know, the fighting man. 24:35 And Americans kind of like that. 24:37 Whether it's warranted or not for Republicans to have that reputation, they have it and it's important to them. 24:44 It's rather similar to Democrats maintaining their reputation as a party of the working class after they've become the party of rich neighborhoods in big cities. 24:59 But Republicans are going to have to... 25:00 So Republicans cannot simply say, okay, we're going to go back to before Trump. 25:04 They have to win the war first. 25:07 And winning the war is a very complicated situation. 25:12 And the road to military victory leads through global depression. 25:19 And that's the terrible... 25:22 And it seems right now, I mean, Trump is trying to, you know, talk his way into people viewing this in a sunny way, but it's from what you read in the... 25:37 You know, in the business newspapers, the number of ships struck in the Strait of Hormuz reached record highs this week. 25:48 The compensation for freight companies carrying freight through the Strait of Hormuz is also at record highs. 25:57 Insurance rates are rising. 25:58 And so... We also have the Houthis making other avenues for oil harder and harder. 26:03 In the Bab al-Mandeb, yeah. 26:05 Right. 26:05 And... 26:07 But at the same time, you also had spin last week that, in fact, we were beginning to get more oil out of the Middle East. 26:16 It just wasn't the right oil. 26:17 It wasn't refined. 26:18 It was hard to get to market. 26:21 But what this means, nonetheless, is that there's no end in sight to very high oil prices, to very high energy prices. 26:28 And after a while, surely even this economy can't quite sustain the growth it wants to sustain. 26:35 Yes, absolutely. 26:36 This is the point that I was trying to make when I described the Iran War as a kind of an economic betrayal of the base. 26:45 Now, in the second term, as in the first, the tight The 26:54 tightening of the border and the reduction of the size of the workforce for lower earners should be helping working class people and it probably is. 27:06 But all those gains have been undone by the high price of gas and diesel and by inflation, which according to this week's numbers is close to 4%. 27:18 Yeah. 27:19 And the thing is that most people had this horrible inflation under Biden, hated it. 27:25 In some ways, correctly associated Trump before COVID with relatively good times for working people. 27:32 And now, of course, we're where we are. 27:35 And he was elected. 27:37 I think gas is up 34%. 28:02 Yes, but you know, Trump has a, I think that I'm sure that Trump sees this, but he clearly has some sort of theory that 28:33 Of how you talk to people about things to put things in a good light. 28:37 And Chris Lehman, the nation's bureau chief in Washington, thinks the real source of this is Norman Vincent Peale. 28:48 The Power of Positive Thinking. 28:49 Yeah. 28:50 Who was, I believe, presided at Trump's first wedding. 28:53 I mean, so he has a real idea that you don't always talk happy. 28:59 No weakness, always great news. 29:02 Just carry on, hide everything, lie about anything bad, and it'll all work out in the end. 29:07 That's the basic view. 29:08 And of course, life is a little bit more complicated than that. 29:13 But where are they going to go? 29:14 I mean... 29:16 Is Vance going to be, let's nail down this new conservatism, this tariff-friendly, non-interventionist, socially conservative 29:28 vision? 29:29 Or are we going to go with global power, Thumos, more interventionism, Marco Rubio, etc., etc. 29:37 ? 29:38 Well, I think that Vance has actually a quite coherent ideology. 29:44 He's a very smart guy. 29:48 It's clear to, I think, most viewers, most watchers of politics that he feels a certain repugnance from some of the unpopular elements, repugnance to some of the unpopular elements. 30:04 ...Elements in what Trump is doing. 30:07 Nonetheless, I think if you look at Vance as the representative of the first wave populism and Rubio as the representative of maybe a recrudescent neoconservatism... 30:21 I think they're both personally going to be somewhat tainted by this, by whatever happens, by the war and whatever. 30:31 I think that this has got to be hashed out anew probably for Republicans. 30:37 Interesting. 30:40 You look at why did Democrats really thrive between, let's say, 2006 and 2016? 30:47 I mean, they just ran the table. 30:49 They made all the domestic policy. 30:52 It was like a one-party state in terms of parties having an impact on the way Americans acted. 31:00 And the problem was the Iraq War, which was George Bush's war. 31:06 And We have men fighting and dying over there still as the 2006 elections were taking place. 31:15 And Republicans had to stick with the president. 31:17 And it's worth noting the first Republican to get elected afterwards denounced the Iraq War. 31:22 So it had that long term and impact. 31:25 So that's what I'm this is what I'm saying. 31:27 Right. 31:27 The Democrats, the absolutely pivotal person in all of this, I think, is is Howard Dean. 31:34 The Howard Dean candidacy of, you know, of 2004 was really a major moment of of. 31:42 And then it 31:51 just sort of created the landslide of 2006. 31:53 And then suddenly the Democrats had the perfect candidate, not because Obama is a perfect person, but because he happened to be far enough from Washington that he never had to make the vote in favor of the Iraq war that all the Right. 32:10 Right. 32:10 Right. 32:11 Right. 32:29 Right. 32:30 And then no one in the Republican Party could say it until someone from outside the Republican Party said it. 32:39 And it was significant enough to not just to win the Republican nomination in 2016, but actually to drive the neoconservatives out of the Republican Party. 32:50 And so when you have to fess up, you know, When you have to fess up to a mistake, it's very – I mean, it used to be that the United States didn't have a lot of lost wars to sort of like hand out accountability for, but now we have a 33:09 – The other fascinating part of this, it seems to me, in the debate that's happened since the Iran war and it's still raging on – Yeah. 33:39 Obviously, because of the way, in part, because of the way Israel is definitely, let's put it, was integral to the beginning of this war. 33:48 If they hadn't decided to do that assassination and had that intelligence, it would – It wouldn't have happened when it happened. 33:56 So you can actually say, without being some paranoid conspiracy theorist, Israel persuaded the president, didn't force the president, but persuaded the president to go to war. 34:06 Now, that also puts the destruction of that sort of republicism in the hands of Israel, which, of course, is Groyper a sort of frenzy about that. 34:18 And you have Nick Fuentes, Just repeating verbatim what Jonathan Swann and Mike Abramson and says, see? 34:27 Yeah. 34:27 I think, yes, this is a, the Iran war is a terrible crisis for Israel because Israel is dependent in so many ways, you know, in terms of money, in terms of blocking votes in the UN, and in terms of morale on the United States. 34:47 And intelligence. 34:48 Yeah, and intelligence. 34:50 I do think we should remember that the Republican support for Israel is pretty solid still, that the real concentration of... 35:05 Second thoughts about Israel is in the Democratic Party. 35:08 The Democratic Party is becoming an unambiguously anti-Israel. 35:12 I don't want to say unambiguously. 35:14 Chuck Schumer is not exactly anti-Israel. 35:17 No, no, no. 35:17 But it's becoming particularly the younger generation. 35:20 And particularly, I think, when you see the way their congressional delegation will look after the coming midterms. 35:28 The Democratic Party is... 35:31 But the younger generation of Republicans are also really strikingly anti-Israel for the first time that I've ever seen. 35:39 Yeah, I think that's probably right. 35:42 And what people like Rod Dreher say when they come to D.C. 35:46 and they talk to the younger staffers... 35:48 Is that this younger generation really are sort of Nick Fuentes' acolytes in some ways? 35:55 I, you know, I don't know. 35:58 I don't, you know, I don't really know. 35:59 I don't know either. 36:00 I don't know what's on Nick Fuentes' show. 36:03 Have you ever watched? 36:06 I watched his interview with Tucker. 36:09 You've 36:11 got to watch him perform because it seems to me without understanding that subculture, it's hard to understand the various pressures within the Republican Party. 36:24 And rather than like Father Coughlin in a way to talk about, or Rush Limbaugh, these are all very different characters, but they're talented. 36:34 At what they do. 36:34 He is an extraordinarily talented broadcaster. 36:38 You'd say he's more like Father Coughlin than like Rush Limbaugh. 36:42 He never really trafficked any of this. 36:44 I'm just saying in terms of his technique. 36:46 His ability to speak to people. 36:48 He's brilliant. 36:48 He's very – in the way that Trump is a brilliant demagogue, Fuentes is a brilliant propagandist. 36:55 It's entertaining. 36:56 He doesn't take himself seriously. 37:00 He's a very powerful voice. 37:02 And I just – I want more people to listen, not because I want them to be persuaded. 37:07 Because when he can say things like, you've got Jabotinsky, we've got Hitler, you just realize – For God's sake. 37:13 But at the same time, there's something real here. 37:17 Well, I think that... 37:21 What's real is, I mean, I still think it's important to say that the penetration of anti-Israel feeling is much, much less on the right than it is on the left. 37:37 And I also think that there's a, you know, in both cases, there's a sense of a double standard. 37:43 Hi there. 37:45 This is not the end of this podcast. 37:48 In fact, we're only just getting going. 37:51 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast in full. 37:59 No extra charge. 38:00 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 38:10 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 38:16 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 38:21 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 38:28 It's very easy. 38:31 AndrewSullivan.substack.com is 50 bucks a year. 38:33 Great value for money. 38:34 You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 38:38 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 38:43 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 38:47 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 38:58 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 39:00 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 39:03 Join the debate. 39:05 Join the fun. 39:07 Subscribe.
Community discussion