0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there. 0:28 Welcome to another DishCast. 0:31 It's a beautiful, beautiful fall in Washington, D.C. 0:36 I want to thank you for subscribing, first of all. 0:40 If you haven't subscribed, please do. 0:42 We have no ads. 0:43 We have no sponsors. 0:45 It's just you, me, and a guest. 0:48 That simplicity is entirely dependent upon your generosity, so please subscribe. 0:53 If you haven't, this conversation will be Badly truncated in ways that will frustrate you deeply. 1:00 So get ahead of it and subscribe now. 1:03 We have some amazing guests coming up. 1:06 We have Cyrus Habib who's coming in talking about how he left politics to become a Jesuit priest. 1:14 Peter J. Williams on why the Gospels are probably more accurate than you might imagine. 1:21 Graham Tomlin is coming in to speak about. 1:23 Pascal and Nancy Sherman is coming on to talk about Aristotle. 1:29 Big, deep themes as promised, but we also have Michael Barone coming on to talk about the midterms. 1:36 We will go over it in great detail. 1:38 We have Francis Fukuyama coming in to talk about his memoir and the end of history and what's happening in the world. 1:43 And Hamish McKenzie, one of the founders of Substack, good friend of The Dish, is coming in to talk about what's happened to journalism and why Substack matters. 1:55 But this week... 1:56 A subject that's always been dear to my heart. 1:58 And to be honest with you, one of the impulses is I'm working on this memoir, as you know. 2:04 And why not read the OG spiritual memoir, the spiritual memoir that really defined the genre? 2:11 And it turns out, of course, I'm talking about Augustine's Confessions. 2:15 Well, there's a new book. 2:16 And my guest today is Catherine Konibare, and she's a philologist with a particular focus on Augustine of Hippo. 2:24 Hippo is the bishopric of which Augustine was bishop. 2:28 She's both the Leslie Clark Professor in the Humanities and a professor of Greek, Latin, and Classical Studies at Bryn Mawr College. 2:37 She's the author of many books, but this one, which we'll talk about, looks at Augustine from a slightly, slightly, from a fresh angle, the African, thinking of him as someone Who really should be thought of as someone from 2:51 the north coast of Africa looking at the Roman Empire as opposed to the Roman Empire looking from Rome out to the provinces. 3:01 And the book actually has this lovely map of the Mediterranean but upside down. 3:05 So you just begin to see how really the Mediterranean was not quite what we think it is. 3:12 And we tend to ignore the entire Roman... 3:17 Thank you so much for coming. 3:20 Thank you so much for having me, Andrew. 3:22 It's such a pleasure to be here. 3:23 Tell me, where do you grow up and who were your parents? 3:25 What did they do? 3:38 I had a peripatetic childhood, but the core of it was actually spent in Oxford. 3:43 We moved there when I was six and away when I was 13. 3:47 And the reason for the wandering is that my father was an orthopedic surgeon and he was moving up the ranks of surgical practice. 3:57 And he actually got his final job in Canterbury. 4:00 So that's where they settled in the end. 4:03 And that's where my parents still are. 4:05 Yeah. 4:06 And what brought you into the idea of studying ancient languages? 4:10 It's not something that the average schoolgirl would think of doing. 4:13 So what was the first peak of your interest in this whole area? 4:18 This is a strange question to have to answer honestly. 4:25 I was brought up In a very intellectually old-fashioned household that held that if you were bright, the highest possible achievement would be to read classics at Oxford. 4:41 That's what my grandfather did. 4:43 He was... 4:45 I think rather idolized by my grandmother, who incidentally also had a degree from Oxford, and my mother, who also had a degree from Oxford, but he was held up as the model. 4:56 And that was what I was expected to do. 4:58 So though I actually loved the study of Latin and Greek and their literature and philosophy, I was also... 5:10 Channeled towards it in very particular ways. 5:14 And in some ways, my entire career has been rethinking that challenging, but from the very strong base of a superb training in Latin and Greek, which I got from high school onwards. 5:28 High school, Latin and Greek. 5:30 And Greek. 5:31 Greek at a grammar school in Canterbury. 5:34 When I was 14, I started Greek. 5:36 And that was remarkable. 5:37 Then I changed school for the last two years to continue studying Greek. 5:42 So were you more a Greek scholar than a Latin scholar? 5:45 Yes. 5:46 When I left Oxford, I would say my Greek was actually better than my Latin, but I had become fascinated by late antique and medieval Latin and specifically by what happened to the Latin language and the classical tropes and genres when Christianity hit it. 6:08 Well, that's how I configured it at the time. 6:11 I was so intrigued by the new energy that Hmm. 6:14 Hmm. 6:15 Hmm. 6:28 People sort of don't realize or don't always fully grok that Christianity was a late entrance into Roman, certainly the Greek civilization, but Roman civilization as well. 6:39 So how did it change philology? 6:42 How did it change language? 6:43 Was it a way in which they used different words or was it they transformed the kind of tropes that they would use? 6:50 Was it just the energy behind it? 6:52 All of that. 6:54 So, yes, certainly the scope of certain words change. 6:59 Once you're developing a vocabulary for Christianity, to some degree, you're building on the pre-existing vocabulary. 7:09 A really simple example, pater or father. 7:15 No longer necessarily means just your biological father. 7:19 It can also mean the father in heaven. 7:21 Caelum, heaven or sky in classical Latin, starts to have this composite meaning in Christianity, more like what we mean by heaven today. 7:35 So you start to get these double meanings and this greater emphasis. 7:38 Exactly. 7:39 And it's in that context that this character shows up. 7:43 Yeah. 7:45 When did you first stumble across Augustine actually in your work? 7:51 I backed into the study of Augustine. 7:55 It's always a good way to do 7:55 it. 7:57 Because he's terrifying. 7:59 Because it's such a vast oeuvre. 8:04 There are five million words, five million words of his writing that survive. 8:09 That's incredible. 8:10 And then there's... 8:13 Vast amounts of scholarship on him. 8:17 And you can start that scholarship where you like. 8:21 I mean, you can start it with Petrarch if you like. 8:23 So, you know, huge scholarly production. 8:27 And nothing from my undergraduate degree had prepared me to work on him. 8:33 So I avoided him. 8:36 But I began working on a dissertation, on a doctoral dissertation. 8:42 I discovered that the only letters for which the response survived was the correspondence with Augustine. 8:47 At that stage, actually, I had a baby. 9:04 And while the baby slept, I sat down and I read all of Augustine's letters. 9:10 So that was my way into him. 9:12 It wasn't through the confessions. 9:13 It wasn't through the city of God. 9:15 It was this very diverse, personal, large corpus of letters that's getting on for 400 years. 9:24 Well, let's put him in some context to start with. 9:26 Who is this person? 9:27 And when was he born? 9:28 And what was the world like when he entered into consciousness? 9:49 So he was born in the middle of the 4th century, 354 CE. 9:54 And he was the son of a small landowner and town councillor in Roman North Africa. 10:04 He was born in a place called Thagasti, which is now Souk Aras in modern Algeria. 10:11 It's about 80 or 90 kilometers inland from the coast of Algeria. 10:18 A relatively small, humble, Romanized town in the foothills of the Atlas Mountains, quite a How long have they been occupying it? 10:58 Well, they obliterated Carthage, their age-old enemy, in 146 BCE. 11:08 And when we say obliterated... 11:10 They did a Gaza, basically. 11:13 When I think of Gaza, I think of Carthage, in terms of they just obliterated it. 11:17 Interesting. 11:18 Yes. 11:19 I mean, that makes it very real. 11:22 And that is essentially what happened. 11:25 The Romans had been fighting the Carthaginians for many years, and they wanted to make Carthage uninhabitable. 11:34 But 150 years later... 11:38 The Emperor Augustus resettled it and it became again a powerful, thriving city, a major center of education and culture, a major center of trade. 11:52 But a Roman city. 11:53 But a Roman city, precisely. 11:56 When Augustine grew up, would he think of himself as a Roman or as an inhabitant of Thagaste or as a North African or as an African? 12:07 What would he have learned to be his identity as he grew up? 12:13 This, of course, is the fundamental question for a book called Augustine the African. 12:18 Mm-hmm. 12:19 He would certainly have thought of himself as Roman. 12:22 He was acculturated to be Roman. 12:24 His native language was Latin, and he learned the same Latin texts as any... 12:33 There are places where he seems to identify with African as a category. 12:54 Which does exist in Latin. 12:56 Yeah, Africanus. 12:58 So when he meant Africa, he would mean North Africa, essentially. 13:03 Precisely. 13:03 He would mean the geographical region that I just outlined. 13:07 But in general... 13:10 Identities were more regional than that. 13:13 So I think he was very closely identified with that corner, sort of eastern corner of Numidia, western edge of what was called Africa Proconsularis. 13:23 So it's very local. 13:24 Sort of near Tunisia today. 13:26 Exactly. 13:26 Right, right. 13:28 And he would have spoken Latin? 13:31 He would have spoken Latin, yes. 13:33 Punic was also a language that was spoken then. 13:37 Obviously, that must have been stigmatized after the Punic Wars, as we call them. 13:42 Well, don't forget, it's we who call them that. 13:44 Right. 13:45 Yes. 13:45 I'm sorry. 13:46 Punic. 13:47 I don't know whether it was stigmatized. 13:49 It persisted in... 13:52 Amazing ways. 13:53 In general, regional languages collapsed under the Roman Empire, under the pressure of Latin. 13:59 North Africa defiantly preserved its languages, not just Punic, but Berber and some other local languages of which we have no trace, but only references. 14:11 So people around Augustine would have been speaking Punic. 14:15 His nurses may have spoken Punic. 14:18 We know he refers to them that he had nurses. 14:22 But he doesn't seem to have learned the language. 14:26 He seems to be pretty monoglot. 14:30 And he hates Greek. 14:31 And he hated Greek. 14:34 I just love that. 14:37 I mean, there are many people who lived at this time, and we know lots about them. 14:41 But we don't know that they hated Greek. 14:45 This is why he's a one-off, really. 14:48 Why he sort of springs... 14:52 Out of somewhere very different. 14:54 I mean, no one's like him. 14:56 Exactly. 14:57 No, he's so emotionally open. 15:00 I think that's part of what makes him feel so modern. 15:04 But the remarkable thing about him also is he doesn't just say, oh, I hate Greek. 15:12 Oh, it was so hard. 15:14 What that leads him into is a reflection on how difficult it is to learn a second language and how even if you love what that second language can give you access to. 15:27 So he loved stories. 15:29 He would have loved to read Homer, but he never became comfortable with Greek. 15:34 And that was a source of embarrassment to him. 15:36 But it also... 15:38 Opened the door to him thinking about language and the different things that languages could do. 15:45 And this is, you see him all the time. 15:47 He's just always asking the second question, right? 15:51 Exactly. 15:51 He's always like, he's not just saying, I hate Greece. 15:53 He's like, why do I hate Greece? 15:54 Why is that interesting? 15:55 He subjects... 15:58 The experience of everyday life to a series of unending sort of questions. 16:01 He's obviously from the very beginning super curious about the world. 16:06 Now, the first thing that he sort of really gloms onto, which I never really fully understood, and I'm not sure I still understand it, Manichaeanism, that is this very popular at the time doctrine about the world. 16:23 Can you... 16:24 I mean, obviously, let's not get lost in mannequinism. 16:28 But if you could sum it up in a couple of sentences, we think of it, I think, as this splitting of the world into two good and evil, these two forces that exist that are constantly at battle with each other. 16:40 And obviously, that's not compatible with what Christianity says. 16:47 Why was it popular and what did it actually argue? 16:51 And the point is that they're not just forces. 16:53 They're actually material objects. 16:56 There are seeds of light. 16:59 Entrapped in dark matter in the world. 17:03 And the object of Manichaeans is to release those seeds of light so that ultimately the forces of light will prevail. 17:12 Now, this is extraordinary, obviously. 17:14 Why Manichaeism attracted Augustine was because he had become preoccupied with the And he thought that Manichaeism would provide an answer to that. 17:29 It also had a creation story that he found appealing. 17:34 But above all, he liked the notion initially that we could attribute evil to actual dark matter in 17:45 the world. 17:46 Yet there's this belief that a sort of materialism, that everything, that there's nothing other than matter. 17:53 Exactly. 17:54 Yes. 17:55 Which, of course, is very hostile, very alien to the Christian. 17:58 Where did this come from? 17:59 Was there an original thinker? 18:01 Yes. 18:02 The original thinker was called Mani. 18:04 He grew up in the third century in what's now Iran. 18:11 And Manichaeism was incredibly successful, I think partly because of this rather simplistic answer to something that bothered people who thought about the world, but partly because wherever it went, it It went in the disguise of the local religion. 18:31 So Manichaeans in Augustine's area of North Africa just called themselves Christians or true Christians, and they had Christ as part of their worldview. 18:43 So it looks a bit like Christianity. 18:46 When they moved towards China, they incorporated Buddha. 18:51 They had Buddha as part of their worldview. 18:53 So it's a chameleon thing. 18:55 But it does have at its base this fundamental, as you say, materialist dualism. 19:05 At the same time, we know from the Confessions that Augustine was obsessed with the physical world. 19:15 I know that this is, we might not get it over with, but I mean, the one thing that strikes you with the Confessions, this man had a real, he's both... 19:24 Very sexually active and extremely sexually ambivalent about it, right? 19:29 I mean, am I getting this right? 19:31 I mean, he... 19:33 We have the famous moment where he's embarrassed or kind of embarrassed by his dad in the baths. 19:38 He obviously gets a boner of some kind or I don't know what happened, but he's kind of ashamed of it. 19:44 His dad is proud. 19:45 I think he's mortified because his father rushes home and says, look, we're going to have grandchildren. 19:52 He's like 14 at the time. 19:54 So I think it's as simple as that. 19:57 Really? 19:57 It was just like, oh, shit, this is happening to me. 20:01 Exactly. 20:03 But then there's this sense that this is obviously something that drags you down into filth and muck and animalistic stuff. 20:13 But despite that feeling, he's in a relationship, an actual relationship with someone whose name we don't know for 14 years. 20:22 He's... 20:26 He's, how should we put it, he's bedding this young woman. 20:30 And they seem to have a really, actually, this is not a completely utilitarian, there was a real affection and love between these. 20:39 So how did that, how common was that in those days? 20:42 He wasn't married, but he had a live-in partner. 20:47 Now that's a whole stack of questions. 20:50 I know, I know, I know, sorry. 20:53 To start with the body... 20:56 Don't forget that he's writing the confessions from which we know about all this when he's just been ordained as a bishop. 21:07 There's all sorts of reasons now to distance himself from sex. 21:13 And indeed, I don't know whether you've noticed this, it goes by quite fast, but in book 10 of the Confessions, he's talking about the different ways in which he can still be tempted. 21:28 And there's a So, he is still very much a sexual being. 21:53 But he also needs to some degree to distance himself from that because he has committed himself to celibacy. 22:02 He actually didn't have to. 22:04 At this stage in Christian development, bishops could be married, but he had come to feel that sex was really a distraction from what he should be doing as a dedicated Christian, which gets us back to your question about this I agree with you. 22:23 I think there's every reason to suppose that 22:50 He was devoted to her. 22:52 I personally think that one of the reasons we don't know her name is because when they separated, she would have gone back to their hometown And everyone who was reading the first draft of the Confessions would have known exactly who she was. 23:10 And he's giving her a bit of protection, a bit of privacy, having had this, if he's to believe, terrible breakup. 23:20 At least he doesn't have to drag her through it all over again for centuries. 23:26 Right. 23:27 Right. 23:28 And he took another lover in... 23:43 That was something that conferred legitimate legal status. 23:46 It wasn't the same as marriage, but it was a formal and formally recognized relationship. 23:50 Domestic partnership. 23:52 Domestic partnership. 23:53 There's so much here that is contemporary in ways. 23:56 And then... 24:13 His mom and dad, who are, we really don't know much about his father, right? 24:18 He's a Roman. 24:19 His mother, we know a hell of a lot about. 24:22 He was a mama's boy. 24:23 He was devoted to his mother. 24:26 And the passages and the confessions about her are among the most moving ever written about her mother, because he's aware of how much he pained her, how much distress he caused her, because she too, well, she, unlike him at the time, had had a full... 24:42 Full-blown conversion to Christianity. 24:45 Tell us about Monica. 24:46 That's her name, Saint Monica. 24:48 We Catholics are obliged to call her. 24:52 She clearly had her own mind and had a serious faith that she tried 25:01 endlessly to get her son to appreciate. 25:04 Tell us a little about her. 25:06 Yes. 25:08 Monika is a Berber or Amazigh name, so it's thought that she was herself Amazigh. 25:17 So she is a native North African. 25:21 His father may have been too, we just don't know. 25:25 And you're right, she was a force. 25:27 And we see that actually not so much in the Confessions as in some works that were written while she was still alive. 25:37 He wrote a set of philosophical dialogues. 25:41 In which she actually plays a role. 25:43 And you can see she is down to earth. 25:46 She's no nonsense. 25:47 But she's also really quite smart. 25:49 She has, or at least he portrays her as having, the art of getting to the heart of things. 25:56 And I think we see that going on in the Confessions too, which was written after her death. 26:02 And indeed, her death is described very movingly in the Confessions. 26:08 You wouldn't know from the confessions that Augustine had a brother. 26:15 He really is a mama's boy. 26:16 It's like Proust writing his brother out of the narrative. 26:21 It's all about her trying to lead him to Christianity. 26:27 When he comes across the great Bishop Ambrose in Milan, the person who ultimately is responsible for his conversion and who baptizes him, Ambrose doesn't give Augustine the time of day, but he's really impressed with Monica. 26:45 And he tells Augustine how lucky he is to have a mother like that. 26:49 Right. 26:50 And she's there forever as this incredibly powerful superego, really. 26:55 I mean, telling him the right thing to do. 26:59 And he reveres her for that in the end, right? 27:01 I mean, he loved her before that. 27:03 He loved her when they were at odds. 27:05 I think he did. 27:06 And again, one has to make allowances for the... 27:09 Retrojection for the fact that he's looking back. 27:14 But I think she was an extraordinary presence in his life. 27:19 I think these writings while she was alive were true. 27:21 There's a wonderful moment much later on, decades after she died, when he says he's writing actually to my man Paul Linus of Nola about the care of the dead. 27:35 And he says, I know for sure people don't come back from the beyond because if they did, my mother would be there every night. 27:45 Yes, she would never let go of him. 27:46 Right. 27:47 She loved him also quite passionately. 27:49 She followed him to Italy. 27:52 She picked herself up and went all the way to Milan and Rome, right? 27:58 Which is astonishing if you think about it. 28:00 Now, one of the reasons I wanted that map put on the front, first, as you already alluded, north and south are inverted. 28:08 Right. 28:09 But second, it shows how close... 28:14 She took it all. 28:40 So she was still trying to push him. 28:41 Exactly. 29:03 No, at the stage that he went from... She was on his case. 29:08 She was on his case. 29:09 Yeah, she wasn't letting him go. 29:11 No, at the stage he went from North Africa, specifically from Carthage, modern Tunis, to Italy. 29:17 He was still an ambitious young man making his way in the world, actually through his skills in Latin, through his skills in rhetoric. 29:25 And he ended up with a post at the Imperial Court. 29:27 That's why he was in Milan, because the Imperial Court was in Milan at the time. 29:32 So let's talk about his talent, because... 29:35 He became known because he was a very good speaker. 29:38 I mean, that's primarily it, right? 29:40 I mean, he gave talks. 29:43 Exactly. 29:43 What was he giving talks about? 29:45 He may have hated Greek, but he was spectacularly gifted in Latin. 29:50 He was teaching. 29:50 He was teaching other young men rhetoric. 29:56 I suspect philosophy as well, given those philosophical dialogues. 30:01 And he... 30:02 He would have been giving show speeches once he was at the imperial court. 30:08 It was his job to produce speeches in praise of the emperor, formal speeches. 30:13 He carried on teaching there as well. 30:16 And for ambitious young provincial Romans, skill in rhetoric was the passport to 30:29 better life. 30:29 Right. 30:30 To higher social class 30:32 and to more money. 30:33 So this young man is on the make and he's succeeding with his own talents and skills. 30:41 But then he starts reading Platonists and he begins to move towards an idea that things can exist in an entirely spiritual zone as opposed to – in other words, his materialism begins to waver or begins to be challenged. 31:00 Yes. 31:01 It was clearly a huge moment for him when he really immersed in the works of Plato and the Neoplatonists writing much more recently to Augustine's time, in particular, I think, the works of Plotinus, because he finally understood how something divine could be purely spiritual. 31:27 And once he had internalized that belief... 31:30 Then his days as a Manichean were numbered because there was no place for a truly spiritual belief in a Manichean world system. 31:43 What strikes me is that he's genuinely trying to figure out the truth of the world. 31:51 That's what he's doing. 31:52 Exactly. 31:53 He's genuinely, and you find this in the Confessions, which is sort of Forgive me, it's the work I'm most familiar with. 32:02 But he will talk about why he believed such a thing and why he came not to believe it. 32:08 And then what were his motives in not believing? 32:10 I mean, he's amazingly able to turn over everything that is going on in his fertile brain. 32:18 But it's all driven by the desire for something bigger, something the ultimate truth of the world. 32:25 Yes. 32:25 I love that you refer to his fertile brain. 32:28 I think that's exactly right. 32:30 And he is always thinking and always questioning. 32:36 And I've been talking about framing the confessions in the moment in which they were written. 32:40 But that impulse to question and to search and to ask the next question again is Continues throughout his life in The City of God, his other best known works. 32:57 It can actually be quite hard to read because he's so aware all the time of character. 33:05 So in the Latin, at any rate, you get these enormous branching sentences where he starts off with two possibilities. 33:13 And then he realizes that actually one of them can be subdivided, that if people ask the opposite questions, and then the other one can be too. 33:21 And so it goes. 33:22 And the next thing you know, this sentence has lasted half a page and branched 33:30 Across all these different possibilities of interrogation. 33:34 It's fascinating. 33:35 And he's almost obsessed with not letting anything open question unresolved. 33:42 So in the last part of his life, when he's furiously denouncing Pelagianism, he's engaged in a final sort of... 33:50 He is manic. 33:52 I mean, it's... And again, these arguments are taking place... Maybe explain this. 33:57 It's not... 33:58 This is not blog tweets. 34:00 This is not competing across the internet. 34:03 But they are writing stuff that is then read out loud. 34:09 And every single point that Julian has made, he has to refute. 34:15 And then Julian comes back and refutes every single thing he did. 34:18 And he goes back and it goes on forever and ever. 34:21 It's like an LLM, this thing. 34:23 Yeah. 34:24 That's right. 34:25 And it is large. 34:26 And it only stops with Augustine's death. 34:29 Yes, we could refer to it as pamphlet warfare, except that these pamphlets are the sides of bricks. 34:35 They're enormous, the way they go to and fro. 34:39 And Augustine does try to refute every single point. 34:44 That's because he really does think not just Julian's immortal life is on the line, but everyone who's convinced by Julian being his principal opponent in this anti-Pelagian warfare. 35:05 The fundamental question about original sin and the power of God's grace is what they're fighting over. 35:14 And if I may correct you, Andrew, you said earlier, Augustine likes to have things closed down. 35:22 You know, he likes an answer. 35:23 Yeah. 35:25 I actually disagree with that. 35:27 In general, he doesn't. 35:30 He thinks questioning is healthy. 35:31 He wants to carry on, and his relationship to the divine is asymptotic. 35:37 He knows he can carry on and on and on asking questions, and it will get him closer to the divine, but it will never quite get him there. 35:44 But for the anti-Pelagianism battle, you're absolutely right. 35:50 And he thinks this is truly a matter of life and death, and he does want to close off possibilities. 35:56 That, I would say, is atypical. 36:00 For him. 36:00 For him. 36:01 In other words. 36:01 Exactly. 36:02 Yes. 36:02 Not for most people. 36:03 No, what I meant, I misspoke. 36:07 I think he just was never satisfied with an answer, needed to penetrate further and further. 36:12 Yes. 36:12 That's sort of what I meant. 36:13 And there's no point in which he's like, okay, that's it for the day. 36:16 Right. 36:18 And when I think about what did he do every day, and I try to imagine, let's think of him in his later part of life when he's converted, he's preaching. 36:27 What was his day like? 36:28 He must have spent hours just writing and thinking. 36:32 I mean, he was a public intellectual, really. 36:35 It is an absolute mystery how he managed to produce so much. 36:42 So he would have preached pretty much every day. 36:47 He would have held what they call Audientiae Episcopalis, a bishop's audience. 36:54 Pretty much every day, people would come to him with problems, with things that needed judging, resolving. 37:01 That's part of his job. 37:03 He would have had to move among his parishes, checking up on people. 37:09 He maintained A vigorous correspondence. 37:14 And he wrote these enormous works. 37:18 The City of God is in 22 books. 37:22 His work on the Trinity is in 15 books. 37:25 The Confessions is in 13 books. 37:28 And those actually pale into insignificance compared with what he composed against the Manichaeans and against the Pelagians and against the local North African church, all of which 37:45 were polemical and somewhat repetitive, has to be said, treatises. 37:51 Most of his writing, notwithstanding those iconic texts, Botticelli images where he always has a book in one hand and a pen in the other and he can't even stop writing to have his portrait taken. 38:07 He would mostly have dictated what he wrote. 38:10 But even so, there he is in his monastery with monks around him taking dictation. 38:17 To me, it's even more extraordinary. 38:19 Where did he find the energy and how did he keep his train of thought? 38:22 Right. 38:24 We lose our train of thought here in a podcast. 38:27 He's doing this for hours and hours, days and days and months, years and years and years. 38:31 And he's composing major books alongside each other. 38:34 De Trinitate, sorry, On the Trinity and The City of God are composed over the same span of time. 38:42 They're complementary works. 38:45 They're both unbelievably complex, ambitious works. 38:48 How did he do it? 38:49 I don't know. 38:50 How did he do it? 38:50 You tell me. 38:52 He was a genius of some kind, some strange genius. 38:55 A genius is... 38:58 Such an overused and imprecise word. 39:02 But yes, I would use it of Augustine for that intellectual energy, for that originality, for precisely the way he kept his train of thought, whether it was in battle or in constructive theology, in creating ideas that we're still living 39:19 and working with. 39:20 Yeah. 39:20 And the other thing that strikes me that you might not think of a saint doing is He is brutal. 39:27 He is a lacerating snarky. 39:30 He can be vicious. 39:31 Hi there. 39:33 This is not the end of this podcast. 39:36 In fact, we're only just getting going. 39:39 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast in full. 39:47 No extra charge. 39:48 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 39:58 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 40:04 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 40:09 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 40:16 It's very easy. 40:19 AndrewSullivan.substack.com is 50 bucks a year. 40:21 Great value for money. 40:22 You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 40:26 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 40:31 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 40:35 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 40:46 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 40:48 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 40:51 Join the debate. 40:53 Join the fun. 40:54 Subscribe.
Community discussion