0:00 [music] 0:28 Hi there! 0:29 Welcome to the new season of The Dishcast. 0:33 I think of seasons that way because I like a good summer break, as you all know, and I'm really grateful for you all for allowing us to have those weeks away from the world. 0:43 I did my usual. 0:45 I went out to the dunes, the tidal pools, I biked. 0:50 I sat in the pools. 0:53 I smoked a bunch of weed. 0:54 I hung out with friends and I played a lot with my dog and took him all over the place and just stayed here and did not really read the papers and stayed off for the most part social media. 1:08 And I have to say, it feels great at the end of it. 1:12 I didn't realize, well, I do realize, but I think, you know, those of us that do this For a living, they've been writing and thinking about our politics and culture, especially in the era of Trump. 1:24 If you do that for a decade, eventually your brain begins to really calcify in ways that are not pleasant. 1:34 And I think having, and I'll say this as plainly as I can, having someone with mental illness as your president kind of spreads. 1:42 It's like Every time you have a mentally ill person in a family, everyone in the family becomes a little mentally ill, unfortunately. 1:51 I don't mean this to stigmatize. 1:52 I've been in that family myself. 1:53 I know what this is. 1:55 And it's important to get some... 2:00 And I'm 2:06 so grateful for you guys allowing me to have those three weeks away and to decompress and to come back in the fall with more energy and a little bit calmer, I think. 2:19 Perspective is so important. 2:21 The cliché touch grass It's a good one, but I just jump into a pool. 2:27 Look at the sky. 2:28 All the rest of it. 2:29 So after my little hippie sermon, we have some amazing guests coming up, and I want to thank you again for subscribing. 2:37 Emily Eakin is coming on soon to talk about French postmodernism. 2:42 We're going to go over all those people that have helped create our modern world. 2:46 Jake Weisberg, my old, old, old friend, has written a terrific polemic against all of those who have appeased Donald Trump. 2:54 It's called Profiles in Cowardice, and it's coming out this month. 2:59 And Ariana Huffington is coming on. 3:01 And we're going to talk about life and love and the soul and how you survive in an internet era and keep your sensibility and your equanimity intact. 3:12 But today... 3:13 Someone I've come across simply by reading the pieces. 3:16 And I read a few of them and then I was like, God, that was good. 3:19 And then look to see who was the reporter. 3:21 And then over the last couple of years, even more amazing stuff. 3:24 Anyway, I posted a note the other day on notes pointing to a terrific piece about new drugs in Estonia. 3:33 Anyway, Azam Ahmed is a An international investigative reporter for the New York Times now. 3:40 He used to be the Times bureau chief in Afghanistan as well as Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean. 3:46 He won a Pulitzer last year for work on the U.S. intervention in Afghanistan. 3:52 He's also the author of Fear is Just a Word, A Missing Daughter, A Violent Cartel and A Mother's Quest for Vengeance. 4:01 And... 4:03 He's also won the George Polk Award. 4:06 He won the Mike Kelly Award. 4:07 James Foley 4:11 Medill Medal for Courage in Journalism and Overseas Press Club Award. 4:17 I knew Mike Kelly pretty well, so it's good to know you got his prize. 4:21 He was the kind of crazy-ass motherfucker that would go into any place, however dangerous, and was able just to write what he saw in a way that was... 4:33 Really amazing. 4:34 I was lucky enough I edited his pieces coming in from the first Gulf War. 4:39 No, from the Iraq War, 2003. 4:42 And they came in like, the prose came in just staggeringly good. 4:49 And one of those people like Michael Lewis, you don't really need to edit very much. 4:53 You just need to get out of the way. 4:55 But anyway, that... 4:56 Attention to detail, that eye. 4:59 That's what my guest today has, I think. 5:02 And I hope you can look him up. 5:05 Look up the pieces he's been writing. 5:07 Look up that really terrific book. 5:08 Azam, thank you so much for coming on The Discast. 5:12 Thank you so much for having me. 5:14 You're welcome. 5:14 Let me ask you, first of all, who were your parents? 5:18 And how did they bring you up? 5:20 And where did they bring you up? 5:23 All right. 5:23 My parents both were born in Pakistan. 5:26 They migrated to the U.S. not too long before I was born. 5:29 I'm the third of four kids. 5:32 And they raised me in Danville, Virginia, which is a small town right on the border with North Carolina, kind of dead center of Virginia. 5:42 What did they do? 5:44 My father's a doctor and my mother had, you know, as a good South Asian would, multiple degrees. 5:51 But she raised us. 5:54 And what kind of doctor was your dad? 5:56 He was a cardiologist. 5:58 So a heart doctor in the South was good for business, I guess. 6:04 You had a relationship with Paula Deen at some vague level. 6:11 I'm just curious. 6:13 This is probably the amazing thing about America, isn't it? 6:16 These are two Pakistanis in Danville, Virginia, bringing up kids. 6:22 What was that like? 6:24 How did you encounter that? 6:26 What is it like to grow up in that context? 6:29 When would this be, the 80s? 6:31 Yeah, yeah, I was born in 1982. 6:32 You know, it's a great question because you would think, especially in the hyper-politicized era we're in now, that it would be very fraught growing up a Pakistani in southern Virginia. 6:45 You know, it was a tobacco town. 6:47 Danville was known as a tobacco town. 6:50 And yet it was... 6:52 You know, we were the only for a long time, the only Pakistani family in town. 6:56 And so the kind of the nastier parts of racism didn't take hold because we were sort of a novelty. 7:02 My father was a doctor. 7:04 There was there was privilege there. 7:06 I mean, obviously, I came to realize that the limitations of being a South Asian post 9-11 in particular. 7:14 But it was this interesting era where, you know, we we I went to a rough public school. 7:20 You know, it was a You know, I think half of the school population was on free or reduced lunch, which is sort of a metric of the poverty rate. 7:29 And yet I got along with everybody, had no problems, was friends with people across the racial divides. 7:36 Again, it was a curious kind of anomalous experience, I'd say. 7:42 I mean, I'm not sure anomalous. 7:43 I mean, it's really remarkable how successful often... 7:48 And to do it at the pace and scale that the U.S. 7:50 has been doing over the last 50 years, I think it's a bloody miracle the place hasn't completely exploded. 7:58 And it's precisely, I think, those... 8:15 Very basic taking people as human beings in these communities that you might not associate with great levels of enlightenment that nonetheless make it work somehow. 8:25 Yeah, I think that's right. 8:26 I think it's easy to lose sight amid the contemporary political acrimony and the charged accusations on both sides. 8:34 But yeah, I mean, I think our story is, you're right, it's not anomalous so much as it is a surprising narrative to hear out loud maybe. 8:43 That's not the narrative you often hear. 8:45 Yeah, people don't talk about it. 8:47 It's funny, whenever I've talked to people on here from similar backgrounds, they say very similar things to you. 8:52 It makes me, cheers me up, to be honest. 8:54 And I tend to think that the prevailing discourse distorts a much calmer, kinder reality underneath in many, many places. 9:03 So was your school half white, half black? 9:07 How was it? 9:08 It was pretty even. 9:12 And how did you fit into that all? 9:15 It was interesting. 9:15 So my high school, it was a big high school, it was a few thousand kids. 9:20 It was about 60% black, 40% white, and then there was me. 9:24 And it was, again, it was this strange sort of everything was fine. 9:28 I had friends, you know, black friends, white friends. 9:32 I didn't, yeah, I sometimes think back on it. 9:36 It wasn't that it was utopian by any means. 9:40 But in terms of the charged, it wasn't until I got older that I felt the real racism of being South Asian or Muslim in the world. 9:50 At that time, it was fine. 9:52 I was having fun. 9:53 People were pretty open-hearted and open-minded. 9:57 If they might ask an unintentionally rude question like, what is a Muslim? 10:03 You'd explain it to them and they'd be like, oh, that's kind of like Christianity and that was it. 10:07 Yeah. 10:09 I'm a big fan of asking, what is this? 10:11 What is that? 10:12 And not taking offense and answering the question. 10:15 One of my favorite things about was a dude that sat down and did ask a tranny anything. 10:22 Just like, come on, offend me, ask me. 10:24 I'll explain what it's like. 10:26 And I honestly think that's the best way to go. 10:29 Get conversations you often find you have more in common with people when you actually just talk about shit in a very real way. 10:35 But anyway, when did you first think about maybe becoming a journalist or traveling writer? 10:43 I think, I mean, I was a reader from a very young age. 10:46 I mean, one of those kids who sought refuge in mostly novels. 10:50 I actually didn't read that much news when I was a kid. 10:54 Nonfiction, I mean, nonfiction interested me, but not nearly as much as literary fiction. 10:59 So a lot of my time was spent reading, investing in that. 11:02 And it was like a sanctuary. 11:04 Which authors most thrilled you or appealed to you? 11:09 I mean, Toni Morrison affected me. 11:13 I mean, a lot of the books you start reading when you're young, Gabriel, Garcia Marquez, Toni Morrison, on the nonfiction side, Joan Didion, but then also the greats, the Dostoevskis, you know, the... 11:27 Robert Penwarrens. 11:28 I loved All the Kingsmen. 11:30 I thought it was such a brilliant, beautiful, stark portrayal of politics. 11:35 Faulkner, obviously. 11:36 I mean, I could go on and on. 11:37 I love Faulkner. 11:39 It's interesting because I think having a background in reading literary fiction and 11:45 then going into nonfiction is kind of refreshing. 11:49 And maybe it's why the stuff you write It feels like a bit of a novel sometimes. 11:53 It feels more alive than most of the stuff you read in The Times. 11:59 I think that balance between fiction and nonfiction, which is one I have not sustained, is incredibly important. 12:06 Yeah, it's almost like it's like food for the soul, right? 12:10 You're reading these things. 12:11 You read these often target, you know, reports or pieces that are, you know, they're like information injections, right? 12:20 You're just, you're getting your shot of what you need to know. 12:23 And then you're taking it, you're thinking about it. 12:25 But the You know, you said something interesting. 12:28 You said, you know, it cheers me up when I hear these stories about integration and assimilation in the same way that when I read a novel, I feel so much more gratified about the human experience. 12:40 So much more seen, the complexity, the nuance, the character development, the charity that a great writer has for their characters, no matter how bad they are. 12:51 It can be really hard to feel and find that in nonfiction. 12:55 And especially today when everything feels so fucking stark and heavy. 13:01 And cartoonish. 13:02 And cartoonish, yeah. 13:04 That's the depth that you get of understanding human nature and other people. 13:09 The ability to get a step outside of yourself is, I think, important for democratic life. 13:16 Otherwise, you're just representing yourself and hating others as cartoons, which is what we see on social media. 13:22 Essentially, that's where we are. 13:24 And it's not restricted to one side or the other. 13:27 It's everywhere. 13:28 Yeah, I think the one advice you can give to a young person is read fiction, good fiction. 13:34 I mean, try and read fiction because it does more for you than you realize. 13:39 Totally. 13:40 It works at a different level. 13:42 It does. 13:42 Yeah. 13:44 It also helps you live because you become more aware of subtle interactions of other people. 13:48 You're aware of the unknowability of other people. 13:51 Absolutely. 13:52 So anyway, then you go to UVA. 13:55 Take us from there. 13:58 UVA, it was, I mean, I grew up in Virginia. 14:02 It was a good deal, but it was a good school. 14:08 UVA was, I made a lot of good friends there. 14:12 It was a beautiful campus. 14:14 It was a very Southern culture still, which didn't bother me. 14:20 I grew up in Danville. 14:21 But it was, like a lot of American campuses, I guess, quite divided along social, racial lines. 14:28 And for me, it was... 14:29 A bit surprising because in high school, I just sort of passed between lines seamlessly, you know, could be genuine all across the board. 14:39 It took a bit more work at university because those lines were a bit more hardened. 14:43 You know, everybody sort of retrenches behind their lines and stays there. 14:48 And, you know, someone who might have been more fluid in where they hung out, who they hung out with, race, religion, creed, Tended to sort of find comfort and sanctuary behind their own lines. 14:59 So that was an interesting human experience. 15:02 It didn't really affect the education of it. 15:04 I wasn't a particularly good student. 15:07 I was good at what I was interested in. 15:10 If I was interested in something, English literature, you know, mostly writing. 15:16 But, you know, if it was something like, you know, oh my God, like macroeconomics, microeconomics, I would, I was the kind of student My mother hated this, but no matter what I did, I could do nothing and I'd get a B. 15:34 But I'd probably have to work a bit for an A, and I just sort of thought, why the fuck would I do more to get an A when I could get a B and kind of skip class and not do too much? 15:43 So I didn't have the best habits for studying and at least doing... 15:49 I don't know. 15:50 A friend of mine once said he always felt like university and school was a bit of a game. 15:54 You know, I'm just trying to get a good enough grade to get to the next phase. 15:58 And I don't think that was the right approach, but that was how I saw it at the time. 16:02 I think part of that was, you know, going to a not great high school in Danville, Virginia, where it was quite easy to get an A. I don't think I really... 16:10 I didn't appreciate the academic pursuit. 16:15 I always appreciated the intellectual pursuit, but the academic was a bit... 16:18 And, yeah. 16:38 How did reporting sort of first pop up in your mind as something you might be interested in? 16:44 I mean, why, for example, did you not try becoming a fiction writer, given your love of fiction? 16:49 It's interesting. 16:50 I did initially think about applying to places like the Iowa Writers' Workshop, one of the prestigious creative writing workshops. 17:01 And I had a good writing teacher who told me, you know, prose... 17:06 I think that prose can be perfected. 17:30 And it kind of became a way that I thought about it. 17:33 I mean, I've written short stories. 17:35 I've had some published at Granta. 17:38 But it hasn't been... 17:41 Yeah, I guess I've spent a lot of time on the journalism because it's so... 17:46 It's a bit like what you said about taking that three-week break. 17:49 When you're in the mix, it feels so utterly important. 17:53 And we are in these kind of cataclysmic times where these seismic changes are happening and these things are, they feel so vital that it's hard to extract, extricate yourself from that when you're in the middle of it. 18:06 Or you have a job where your job is go out, find the thing that should be calling everyone's attention, and then spend a lot of time thinking about it and writing about it. 18:15 There's a real allure to that. 18:16 And so I think I'll get back to your question, but for me, there was a bit of an inversion. 18:21 Can I bring a more literary sensibility to the urgency of today versus can I bring the urgency of the day into literature? 18:32 But one of the reasons I think nonfiction and newspapering in particular, but, you know, magazine, nonfiction writing in general appealed to me was you... 18:46 You know, you as a child of an immigrant, you're always looking at the world and trying to assess it through other people's eyes. 18:53 You know, one of the things I became quite good at was understanding how to make other people comfortable, but also understanding the nuance of their position, because I was always kind of in these micro ways adjudicating my own. 19:05 I'd go into a room, I'd be like, you know, microcalculation, see how people are feeling, see how I'm being received, remain myself while also being conscientious of how other people feel. 19:17 And when I think you have that by birth or sort of, you know, that is the birthright of the immigrant, it is a really handy tool when you're traveling the world or anywhere really to try and understand people on their terms. 19:32 Yeah, I mean, well, you weren't an immigrant. 19:35 You were born here. 19:36 No, you know what I mean. 19:38 Yes, I do, but as slightly other... 19:44 And myself as a gay man, as it were, God, I hate saying that, but you are immediately confronted with something as a kid. 19:53 Like, I'm not like the others. 19:54 So you start looking and observing. 19:57 And what do they do that I do? 20:00 And so you inevitably become a slightly more heightened observer of the world. 20:03 You just do. 20:04 Yeah. 20:05 You want to survive and you also want to thrive. 20:08 So you also want to figure out how it works. 20:11 And you have to learn that because it doesn't come naturally to you because you're not the majority. 20:16 And I think in some ways I'm grateful because you could go through life if you're in a big group of people. 20:24 You don't have to question anything. 20:26 You're not forced to re-examine all your assumptions. 20:28 Where if you're slightly off, you have to constantly negotiate. 20:32 It gives you this great wellspring of empathy, which I think, 20:36 you know, to one of your earlier points is the thing that is most lacking in the discourse today. 20:41 This sense of, okay, I see you. 20:44 I can understand you on your terms. 20:45 I don't think it, you know, you give people the benefit of the doubt that maybe you didn't always get. 20:50 And as you said, you know, because you're constantly kind of attuned to how people see you and you not feeling like you're a part of this mainstream community, Yeah. 21:01 It gives you a sense of, it's almost empowering in that you can go into a situation and be like, no matter what it is I'm confronting, I've probably seen it or felt it. 21:10 And at the very least I can like humanize it or I can find a way to identify with it or find something decent out of it. 21:17 It makes you more charitable, I guess is what I'm saying. 21:20 Well, it gives you the opportunity to be more charitable. 21:22 Yeah, maybe it doesn't make you more 21:24 charitable. 21:26 But yes, you're also aware of the vulnerabilities of people in ways that you might otherwise not be. 21:35 And that analytic skill, and also the skill to go to completely alien places and see the human dynamics in a totally different cultural context, which requires translation, but also requires... 21:49 A sort of human knowledge, a sense of what human beings are and feeling when they're uncomfortable or when they're confident or when they're bullshitting you. 21:59 Those things, which must come incredibly handy to a reporter, are important. 22:06 I want to talk about, you know, your first major, I guess, assignment after you did a little stint to, you entered Chicago, the Chicago Post. 22:15 Tribune, yes, the Chicago Tribune. 22:18 And then you went to the New York Times business section for a bit. 22:20 It's kind of interesting. 22:23 You were telling me how you hated all that math. 22:26 And then they went, and I don't know why they did that, but they sent you to Afghanistan. 22:30 So tell me about that. 22:31 How did that happen? 22:33 And it wasn't surely, oh, we got the South Asian guy here. 22:36 Let's send him over there. 22:39 What was it? 22:40 No, no, no. 22:41 Actually, you know, quite the contrary. 22:43 I was asking to go to Warzone from pretty much the moment they hired me. 22:49 I thought and think war correspondence is some of the most vitally important work you can do. 22:54 I mean, the stakes... 22:56 There's no metaphor for the stakes. 23:18 With war, it wasn't like that, you know, although I was to later learn it was a bit like that. 23:23 Because by the time, you know, I got hired at the Times in my, you know, like 28, I think. 23:29 And so, you know, coming from the Chicago Tribune, which at the time was struggling, shrinking, I was happy to have a new job. 23:37 And at first I was very... 23:40 Yeah, I wouldn't say disappointed, but I was like, I don't know anyone on Wall Street. 23:45 That's not who I grew up with. 23:46 I don't have family that is making a lot of money on Wall Street. 23:49 I don't know anything about it. 23:51 It was actually after I got hired, my boss was like, so we're thinking about having you cover hedge funds. 23:59 And I was like... 24:00 What's a hedge fund? 24:01 And he looked at me with this paralyzed look like, oh, we just fucked up. 24:05 Why did we hire this guy? 24:06 He doesn't know what a hedge fund is. 24:08 And I could see it in his face. 24:09 And I was like, okay, I got to turn this around. 24:11 I was like, no, but really, what is a hedge fund? 24:13 When you think about it, he was like, no, no, totally. 24:16 Is it a fee structure? 24:17 Is it an investing model? 24:19 But the truth is, I had no idea what a hedge fund was when he said I was going to be covering that. 24:23 That's good for you. 24:24 That was a good bullshit pivot there. 24:27 But I found that job. 24:28 What really is a hedge fund? 24:30 Yeah, I got philosophical. 24:33 It reminds me of my immigration interview. 24:36 They asked me in the test, the civics test they give you at the end of your immigration interview. 24:40 So they have a bunch of questions. 24:43 They said, what's the rule of law? 24:46 And I was like, well, I guess you could see it derived probably, you know, from somewhere from Hobbes and Locke onwards. 24:52 And then it sort of becomes established as this. 24:54 And they looked, this man looked at me as if I was out of my mind. 24:57 And he said, no, no, the answer is you obey the rule of law. 25:02 Well, yes, you do that. 25:04 Anyway, he forgave me. 25:05 I nearly failed. 25:07 He's like, who's Hobbes? 25:09 You mean Calvin and Hobbes? 25:13 Where were we? 25:14 You're going to Afghanistan? 25:15 Oh, we were talking about going to Afghanistan. 25:16 Yeah, after the response. 25:18 I was going to say something about covering business. 25:22 I mean, we can gloss over it, but the one thing that I found so immensely useful... 25:29 It was like a boot camp for both writing concisely and then searching for that extra thing. 25:37 It's so hard to write about finance. 25:39 It's so hard to write about markets and business deals. 25:42 And you have to find a way to dramatize it and also to connect it with people. 25:46 And on top of that, if you're doing the investigative work, You have extraordinarily well-funded people on the other side who, if you fuck anything up, are going to pounce on you and make your life miserable and point out every single incorrect thing that you say. 26:01 So it made me cautious. 26:02 It made me more creative within the framework of how do I write about what could otherwise be a very mundane story of a guy sitting behind a desk clicking a button. 26:12 And I valued that. 26:13 It also made me... 26:14 It helped refine a different kind of sourcing because... 26:17 I didn't know people on Wall Street and all of a sudden I'm with all these suits who are, you know, using these verbal pyrotechnics about, you know, asset backed securities and like, you know, internal repo operations. 26:29 And I'm like, I have no idea what these people are talking about. 26:32 So you learn to mask a little bit and you're like kind of getting in there and then you grasp it. 26:36 But you also learn, at least I learned, some people can go into a Wall Street kind of dynamic. 26:44 It's just source. 26:45 They can make friends. 26:46 They can, you know, play up to people and people will give them stories. 26:50 I learned something about myself, which was if somebody liked me and thought of me genuine and we got along, they were going to leak to me. 26:59 Or they were going to be like, who's this fucking asshole who like, you know, thinks he's better than us or, you know, who doesn't understand our world or doesn't care about us. 27:07 He's like on a crusade against, you know, insider trading or whatever it is. 27:11 And that was really, it was useful for me to know that I think this was more when I was doing more investigative work. 27:36 Just befriending people and getting to know them and getting them to trust you, regardless of any ulterior motive to begin with. 27:43 And once you establish that trust, then you just kind of slowly pummel them for info. 27:48 Yeah, exactly. 27:49 You slowly start to abuse that friendship. 27:51 Yes. 27:51 This is why Janet Malcolm had a point. 27:54 Never trust a journalist. 27:56 No, never do. 27:58 So that helped you going into another completely alien place. 28:01 It helped me, even though it was, yeah, it was like 28:03 something I... 28:05 Finance is something I absolutely didn't want to do. 28:06 But if they told me from the moment they hired me, you're going to Afghanistan, I'd have been stoked. 28:10 I'd have been so happy because that is what I wanted to do. 28:14 So, you know, it was a two year stint covering finance, which again, I wound up not only loving, but finding extraordinarily instrumental in like my development as a writer and a journalist. 28:26 And then, yeah, I kind of I went to Afghanistan when it was sort of at the apogee of global interest. 28:33 You know, it was like post-Obama surge, you know, the drunken night was done, the hangover had passed, and there was just sort of this sense of like, what's happening here? 28:43 And nobody wanted to write about it or read about it. 28:46 So they were looking for, you know, young flesh to throw at that war. 28:50 And I raised my hand, I was like, I'd be happy to. 28:53 And I, yeah, I remember getting there. 28:56 And having a conversation with the time security advisor about what to do, what not to do. 29:02 And really finding it a transformative assignment, place, moment in my life. 29:12 You know, you go to these countries and they've been written about so much. 29:16 And you think, what else could you possibly say? 29:18 What else is there to do here? 29:21 Like readers are tired of it. 29:22 You don't want to hear about another suicide bombing or another Taliban attack. 29:27 Another U.S. promise that like, you know, victory is just around the corner. 29:30 It was all like sort of like it was at the point where everything just seemed like, speaking of cartoonish, like a caricature of itself. 29:38 And I found that my time as a Metro reporter in Chicago was immensely useful because... 29:45 I thought like, what do I want to read out of Afghanistan? 29:48 What's interesting to me? 29:49 You know, like the bigger, more well-known correspondents are doing the heavy news or doing the big politics story. 29:54 And so the first, I think the first front page story I had, and again, front page doesn't mean anything, but it's a rubric of how, what kind of esteem the Times itself held it in. 30:05 So the first story I had that ran out front. 30:09 I was looking through a local newspaper, and I saw a blurb that said this young woman had committed suicide by eating rat poison, and that a few hours later, her sister had died in the exact same way. 30:24 And I thought, two sisters dying from eating rat poison in the north of the country, which is, you know, ostensibly the more liberal part of the country in Afghanistan. 30:34 And I just, something was like, you got to fly up there, something... 30:37 Something is happening that's interesting. 30:38 There's a story there. 30:40 So I flew up, met the family, talked to them, and it turned into this just like heartbreaking, but to me, very illuminating story. 30:49 So basically it was these sisters. 30:51 There was the older sister who was a bit of a scold and the younger sister who was a bit of a rebel. 30:55 They were living in post-war Afghanistan where they were still Afghan women. 31:00 And even before the Taliban, during the peak of the U.S.-backed Afghan government, it was not an easy place to be a woman. 31:08 And the young girl had fallen in love with a boy. 31:11 And, you know, she's seeing these things coming in online or the Internet. 31:17 She's watching movies. 31:18 There's this whole world that she knows is out there now. 31:22 And she just goes for it. 31:24 And her older sister... 31:25 Finds out, condemns her, you know, really scolds her, gets her in trouble. 31:32 And the young girl, basically in this sort of plea for help, cry of desperation, takes rat poison and dies. 31:41 And then the older sister, realizing what she's done, how far she's pushed her younger sister out of shame, does the same thing. 31:49 Ugh. 31:52 And it turned into this story that was even more complicated than that because the younger sister had actually taken rat poison not to try and kill herself, but to frighten her parents and to frighten her family into giving her freedom 32:05 by giving them the sense that I will kill myself. 32:08 Because on her deathbed, I was talking to the doctor who was there and he said, yeah, she said, I didn't mean to do this. 32:13 She's sort of like, as her father's there beside her sobbing, like, why did this happen? 32:19 And it just was, it was just a parable of, 32:21 Of the cross currents of a local culture with global culture as these things become more accessible, as war has sort of swept in these new ideologies and these new sensibilities of freedom. 32:35 And society hasn't yet caught up to those. 32:38 These women were trapped in those cross currents. 32:41 But also they were two cross currents as well. 32:45 The humans are complicated. 32:48 You could have a sister as stymied as her sister, but she will then attempt to restore order and stigmatize in the same way. 32:58 And then the second suicide, my God, those parents must be... 33:04 What precisely was the younger sister looking for? 33:08 I mean, she had a boyfriend. 33:09 Why wasn't that enough? 33:11 What more did she want that her sister thought was illicit? 33:14 Was it that she was accessing the internet, that she wanted to travel? 33:17 Or what was it about the boyfriend that triggered this response? 33:22 I should qualify the nature of a... 33:25 An Afghan boyfriend in that context. 33:28 It's like a boy she liked who liked her. 33:30 You know, they maybe held hands. 33:32 There was nothing. 33:33 Yeah, okay. 33:33 It was an infatuation. 33:34 Yeah, it was just an interest. 33:36 And all she wanted was a margin of freedom. 33:39 It was a little bit of self-determination. 33:42 What would that have meant 33:44 in reality? 33:45 To choose to marry a 33:46 person like that? 33:47 Yeah, it could have been choosing to marry a person. 33:49 It could have been her parents entertaining her thoughts about who she should marry. 33:54 It could be like, I don't want to wear a big flowing dress. 33:59 I want to wear jeans. 34:00 I want to listen to the music I want to listen to. 34:02 I want to watch films. 34:04 You know, a modicum of freedom is... 34:09 Yeah, I mean, you'd be disheartened to know how little it is for a woman in Afghanistan. 34:16 Never mind today. 34:16 And that was even when the U.S. was in there. 34:20 God knows what it's like today. 34:21 Yeah, I mean, it's always been a... 34:24 It was a conservative country then, and it remains one, though it's become kind of draconianly conservative. 34:32 Yeah, and culture matters. 34:33 The idea that... 34:35 I mean, one of the things that one tries to understand in retrospect about what we did there... 34:40 I mean, part of me wants to say, well, we had to do something, didn't we? 34:44 I mean, that's where 9-11 came from. 34:47 That was the people harboring... 34:50 The terrorists, obviously, we had to do something to find them and get rid of them. 34:54 It took a while. 34:55 They ended up in Pakistan, of course, in the ironies of these things. 34:59 But that irony suggests how little we understood what was going on, how little we understand of other places, how completely alien they are to us, and how hard it is to exist in a place, let alone govern it, when you have no idea really what it is. 35:17 Yeah, I couldn't agree more. 35:19 I think the interesting thing about post 9-11 decision to enter Afghanistan, you know, go in, you bomb a country, you respond to, you know, one of the greatest attacks on American soil in modern history. 35:36 And then you stick around, you stay past the expiration date and you sort of set a new one, which is nation building. 35:45 On the one hand, that is a moral position. 35:49 We're not just going to come in and break it. 35:50 We're going to do the Colin Powell thing where we own it, right? 35:52 We're going to try and rebuild this place. 35:57 And it set us down this tremendously treacherous, problematic, and ultimately disastrous path. 36:04 But it started with an idea of we're not just going to go in, bomb it, install some corrupt Northern Alliance guys, and then leave. 36:13 So, yeah, I mean, did we have to do something? 36:18 I mean, I don't feel qualified to answer that. 36:21 Do you have to respond to these sorts of provocations? 36:24 Because, again, think about where 9-11 was and where we are today and what these kinds of terroristic, violent incidents engendered. 36:37 I mean, you know, I know we're going to talk about this, but like you could bookend Israel-Palestine with U.S. 36:43 Afghanistan, like a horrific, terrifying, traumatizing terrorist attack that then elicits such a staggeringly big and violent response that is seismic in the way that it changes the world that we live in, in the way that we think about things. 37:02 I don't think we've still reckoned with the ways in which the global world on terror has changed our nation and the world. 37:09 Even as it's kind of like, does anybody even talk about that anymore? 37:12 I mean, it's such a thing of the past. 37:14 I remember when I was pitching this Afghan project, everybody was like, huh, so you want to write about Afghanistan? 37:23 You know, it was like nobody even, you know, it was like a joke. 37:26 You come back from Afghanistan and people wouldn't ask you what it was like. 37:29 They'd be like, we're still there. 37:31 Thank you. 37:32 One of the stories that you really helped uncover was a classic one, really, of misunderstanding or good intentions. 37:42 In trying to defeat the Taliban in the north, we funded militias that seemed to be the most effective anti-Taliban bunch of people, rather the way that we actually funded the Mujahideen to help get rid of the Soviet Union in the 1970s. 37:58 The same well-meant support for How did that story, how did, first of all, how did you come up with that story? 38:06 And secondly, why did we not 38:26 Hi there. 38:27 This is not the end of this podcast. 38:29 In fact, we're only just getting going. 38:56 If you're a paid subscriber and are hearing this, it means you haven't yet signed up for the package to get our podcast in full. 39:03 No extra charge. 39:05 Just go to andrewsullivan.substack.com forward slash listen, L-I-S-T-E-N, and make sure your podcast is up to date with the Dishcast. 39:15 You'll be able to add it to your Dishcast feed and never hear this message again and go back to exactly what you've been doing. 39:21 And I'd like to thank you too for contributing for so long. 39:25 If you're hearing this message and you haven't yet subscribed and want to listen to the rest of the podcast, then just subscribe. 39:33 It's very easy. 39:35 AndrewSullivan.softfact.com is 50 bucks a year. 39:38 Great value for money. 39:39 You also get with that the entire Weekly Dish every Friday. 39:43 Not just my weekly column, but also all the comments and dissents on that column. 39:48 You also have a full discussion of the previous week's Dishcast. 39:52 So all those questions you have in your mind can be answered or you can hear and read readers debating what we talked about, sometimes calling me to account. 40:03 Andrewsullivan.substack.com. 40:05 Subscribe and get the whole thing. 40:08 Join the debate. 40:10 Join the fun. 40:11 Subscribe.
Community discussion