0:00 Now here's a highlight from Coast to Coast AM on iHeartRadio. 0:05 And welcome back to Coast to Coast. George Norrie with you, Craig Wheeler with us, astrophysicist, author, emeritus professor of astronomy at the University of Texas at Austin, a leading researcher in supernovas, black holes, astrobiology. Craig has authored hundreds of 0:20 scientific papers, several acclaimed books, including The Path to Singularity, exploring cosmic phenomena and the future of humanity. Greg, welcome. 0:29 How you been? I've been very good, George. 0:32 Thank you very much. 0:33 Looking forward to this. Did you hear what Avi Loeb, the astrophysicist out there at the University of Harvard, wants to build a telescope to see if he can monitor UFO activity? What do you think of that? 0:49 Well, that's probably a good idea at some level. Avi's a very smart guy and has some sort of radical ideas. 0:58 But if you want to understand anomalous phenomenon, what you do is study them. And now exactly what that telescope involves and how it's going to go about it, that might be a different question. But If there's unknown phenomenon, 1:15 then your whole scientific instinct is to get data and try to understand what's going on. 1:21 Do you think he'll be successful in constructing this? 1:25 Well, constructing is one thing. What he finds is something else. 1:31 I'm sorry, Jerry, I don't know enough about the particular project that he's proposed, what kind of telescope and how he wants to operate it. I will say that already. 1:43 We astronomers, just to speak for my community, have an immense number of ways of exploring the universe. Optical light that we see with our own eyeballs, infrared light, ultraviolet light, radio x-rays, gamma rays, cosmic rays, neutrinos, all sorts of 2:05 ways of probing the universe. And there's not a hint of anything out there. And you can't prove a negative that right now, if we look at what astronomers normally do, and they would love to find extraterrestrial life. There's just 2:26 not a whit of evidence in a traditional astronomy. So I don't know exactly what Abilob is proposing to do that's different than what we're already doing. A different focus, a different emphasis of this instrument, I guess. 2:41 How many other planets have we spotted out there, Craig, beyond our solar system? 2:45 Yeah, exoplanets. Of order, 6,000, I think the number is. 2:51 It's a lot of them. Once that was opened up, and it was opened up by doing particular astronomical techniques. 2:59 They used the same telescopes we've seen before, but used in a clever way to study indications of something orbiting around a nearby star. And once that technology was opened up, then it just blew up. It's been very exciting. Not my expertise, but very exciting. 3:17 Did they find like a light dipping in front of their star and they know something's going across it? 3:23 There's two ways of doing it. One is if you have a planet orbiting in a special way so that the Earth sees the shadow of the planet against the star. Then, yeah, you can see the dipping of the light of the star. 3:38 And the other is that if there's a planet going around the star, then they tend to both go in circular orbits around one another so that the planet is orbiting the star. But in some sense, in a subtle way, but observable, the star is orbiting the planet. And you 3:55 could see that motion. It's about as fast as a person walking. It's a very subtle effect, but people have gotten very good at teasing that out of the data as well. 4:06 Why do planets kind of rotate around their star? What causes that? 4:12 Basically, just gravity and just, you know, things in the universe rotate that born out of a chaotic Big Bang. 4:21 And there were swirls of stuff and a swirl is a rotation. And that just gets communicated to the galaxies that form and the stars that form in the galaxy. 4:31 So if you found something that absolutely did not rotate, that would be the remarkable thing. So the star, the central star rotates probably because they were born out of a cloud of gas that itself was rotating. So the central star rotates and the planets are born out of 4:52 the gas that is circulating around the star. and they form in those orbits going around the star. It was a fairly natural progression. 5:03 And, Craig, the rotation is always the same. Do any other planets in the systems out there ever go the other way? 5:10 To orbit the other way? 5:13 Like backwards? 5:15 Yeah, no, I understand what you're asking. You know, many of the planets, basically, yeah, most of the planets in our solar system not only orbit, all in the same direction, but they rotate in the same direction. But Uranus, I think, does not. And the speculation is it got hit by 5:34 some massive interaction very early on where the solar system was forming and still full of stuff and tilted it on its rotation axis. So there's some signs of things like that. But to see a star, I mean, a planet going in the opposite direction, no, we haven't. And 5:55 that makes sense in the picture of this so-called protostellar nebula, where the gas is all orbiting around the central star, even as it forms. And so the fragments formed at greater distances are going in the same sense. It makes a lot of sense. 6:14 What exactly, Craig, is an exoplanet? 6:18 It just means not one of the eight planets in our solar system. Giving credit for Pluto as being a dwarf planet, which is a controversial thing, but modestly well-established by now. 6:35 Are there many exoplanets out there? 6:38 Well, as I say, we've discovered something like 6,000, but those are around stars fairly nearby to use this dipping method or seeing the star shake method. to our whole Milky Way galaxy, is there are probably 10 billion planets 6:59 out there. We could only see them very near the sun, astronomically. 7:05 They're so far away in a human sort of way, but very near us astronomically. 7:10 What do you think is the most intriguing planet in our solar system? In our solar system? Besides good old planet Earth. 7:19 Well... Yeah, but that's an important exception because this one has life on it and we've not found life anywhere else. 7:28 This is dodging the question slightly, but my favorite planet is Saturn just because it's so gorgeous and it's got those rings around it. I've written a science fiction novel where I've threatened the existence of Saturn because it is 7:43 my favorite planet in some perverted way. I don't know. 7:47 Funny you say that. 7:50 They're all interesting in their own way, George. It's like asking, which is my favorite child? 7:56 I grew up in Detroit, and my father bought me a telescope for Christmas one year. And I went out on a cold, wintry night just to look at the stars and things like that. And I came across Saturn. 8:07 And like you say, that was the first time in my life I had ever seen it with the rings through a telescope. And it was like a painting that was out there. It was the most gorgeous thing I've ever seen. 8:21 Yep. 8:22 Yeah, that was kind of my experience, too. I was, what, 10 years old and living in Boulder, Colorado and hiking up into the foothills and ran across a guy with a small telescope. And why was I out in the evening? 8:38 I don't remember. But he pointed that telescope at Saturn. And, you know, there it is. It doesn't take a whole lot. 8:44 You can't. see it easily with the naked eye. It doesn't take much of a telescope to show those rings. 8:50 And yeah, they can really get to you. 8:53 And I know you're going to want some after hearing this. 8:55 This is an amazing story. We've got Stephen and Malachi Gregory in Nelson, New Zealand. I understand that Malachi, who's eight, almost nine years old now, was suffering with not just one or two warts, but I mean, a significant outbreak 9:09 of warts all over his body. So significant it impacted his ability to to really function. 9:14 Yeah, he was having trouble even holding a pencil to write. 9:17 It was Ty's book actually that got me thinking about it. 9:20 I'm not surprised. It is an amazing immunomodulator. And so I can see that it would work. 9:26 And so at what point did you see that there was actually improvement is really going to work? 9:31 Well, look, we really started to notice it around 12 weeks. 9:34 You can see these things actually getting smaller and smaller and then going down to the where they're just little red marks, the whole things are gone. And we're talking about one the size of a walnut. I thought, no way that's going to. 9:46 Wow. 9:47 It's just been miraculous to see him get into a pair of shoes. 9:51 Yes. 9:52 How wonderful. 9:53 It's great to see him so happy and confident. 9:55 Absolutely wonderful. 9:57 Our friends that have seen it, they're just blown away. 9:59 Ty, this is awesome. awesome. Yeah, this is awesome. 10:01 Another amazing story. 10:02 Why? 10:03 We're talking about carnivora. Call them to awaken your immune system and protect yourself now. 10:08 Call 1-866-836-8735. 10:12 That's 1-866-836-8735. Or visit carnivora.com. C-A-R-N-I-V-O-R-A. Carnivora.com. 10:23 Craig, I've got to ask you the question that I ask so many physicists when they come on the program and scientists. How did it all start? 10:34 Well. 10:35 I just don't get the Big Bang Theory. I don't understand it. 10:39 You don't get it. Yeah, well, nobody exactly gets it. 10:42 But we study very systematically all of the objects we can see, galaxies nearby and far away. And the whole ensemble of galaxies we study is moving away from us. 10:58 So the universe is expanding. And then more recently, we've discovered it's not only expanding, it's accelerating and If something's pushing on it, we can come back and talk about that. 11:10 But you wind that backwards with the best physics that we understand. And by that, I mean Einstein's theory and the quantum gravity, or not quantum gravity, but the quantum theory that we use all the time. The quantum theory 11:28 is in all modern electronics, for instance, run because... quantum mechanics works the way it does at the microscopic level, probabilistic level. It's all very bizarre stuff, but it's absolutely well tested. And gravity is well tested. We probe both 11:46 of them to see whether there's a breakdown somewhere. But you run that backwards with the best physics we know, and it's not just us, but quarks and exotic particles. 11:59 And what would the conditions be early in the universe? 12:02 And then as it expands out, they would form ordinary elements like helium and other elements. And then eventually form stars and galaxies. And that's a story we can talk about tonight, too. But you can go back with the physics we know now. You can go back to something 12:22 like a trillionth of a second after the Big Bang. 12:27 And everything kind of falls into place. Lots of details to be understood. But the picture where the universe expanded out of a very hot, dense state 13.8 billion years ago and has been expanding ever since just fits all the data we know and all the theory we know. Again, 12:51 people are constantly probing it to see whether there's some departures from that and haven't been obviously discovered at this point. 13:01 A lot of people trying. So I don't know what to do to get you over a conceptual hillock of some kind, George, but that's where the data points. Everything we study says that our universe started off very hot and compact and has been expanding for a long time, 13:22 but not forever. I mean, we can put a date on it, how long it took. So where it all started goes to before the Big Bang, and that we don't have the science to do. 13:34 That was my next question. What the heck happened before that? 13:38 No, that's an excellent question. But the fact that we don't know that doesn't mean the whole picture is wrong. 13:45 What it does mean is that at some point there are limits to the physics we know now. And again, that's basically the quantum theory and Einstein's theories. 13:57 My mother would bring God into the equation. Is she right? 14:02 I can't say that she's wrong, but it is not necessary in a modern physicist and astronomer's construction of how all this works. 14:18 I mean, something somewhere had to jumpstart all this, didn't it? 14:22 Yes. And we don't know what that jumpstart was. There's lots of theories about it, but there's no data that speaks to it. And again, our current theories, although we can take them back to a trillionth of a second, a long time ago, break down at that point. A 14:40 fundamental problem there is that as wonderful as they are, the quantum theory and Einstein's theory of gravity contradict one another if you go down to the tiniest scales. And that's where the Big Bang was born, in those tiniest scales. 14:59 So in some sense, we know that our predictive capability breaks down at that point. So until we have a new theory, and I almost misspoke myself and said quantum gravity a minute ago, but that's the current target, is to form a grander theory where Einstein is an approximation 15:19 at some level And the quantum theory is approximation at another level, but at this fundamental level, they're both parts of some bigger thing. The analogy to that is we now understand that Newton's theory of gravity, as successful as 15:37 it was, is an approximation to Einstein's theory. If you take Einstein and say, spread things out so gravity is fairly modest, then mathematically the Einstein's theory turns into Newton's theory. 15:52 Wonderful thing. 15:54 Was Einstein perplexed as well about these questions we're asking each other? 15:57 Oh, absolutely. He basically denied the strangeness of quantum theory. 16:05 And I'm afraid he was wrong about that. Quantum theory has now been tested. You know, the fact that we're building quantum computers now, We understand this physics well enough to engineer with it. And the quantum uncertainty, things jumping 16:26 around in a discrete way, is just the way nature works at a microscopic level. 16:36 See, I'm thinking too chronologically that there's got to be a beginning and an end. Maybe it's not that way. 16:43 I Right now, I think it's nulla contentere. I think we don't know in two ways, both at the beginning and the end. At the beginning, we run into this problem where the physics we need works at the level where our current gravity theory and quantum theory contradict one another. 17:09 So we need a better theory that embraces both of them and tells us what is going on at that conditions where our current theories contradict each other. And then once you buy, if you will, and most scientists do, astronomers do, that we've come out of a very hot, 17:30 dense condition. We call that the Big Bang. And you're asking about what happens at and before that, and we don't know. That's just true. But once you see what the universe is doing now... then you can predict what it might do in the future. And given that it's 17:47 accelerating outward, if something doesn't change, it'll accelerate forever. Stars will burn out. Particles will decay away. 17:57 New ones will crop up, right? 18:01 What's that? 18:02 New ones will crop up. 18:05 That will fade away. Again, this is literally true. And right now, we don't know enough to know whether it is. 18:10 And there are speculations of how it might turn around and recontract into a big crunch. And we wouldn't like that either. It's a trillion years from now. I wouldn't worry about it too much. 18:22 What would it take for us to get the answer to these questions? 18:28 I'm sorry. The tongue-in-cheek answer is more funding. Okay. No, there's very smart people thinking very deeply about these. String theory has come out of this, sort of the attempt to form a theory which would be grander than either 18:46 quantum theory or Einstein's theory, but would embrace both of them. 18:53 And mathematically, string theory does that. It's also very hard to test whether it's correct or not. But the theory... 19:02 accomplishes that it is a theory of quantum gravity at some level has quantum properties has gravity properties but then it predicts things like the universe doesn't just have three spatial dimensions it has 10 and they can be all some of them very tiny and some of them very 19:20 big which again there's no firm evidence that string theory per se is the active theory But it's an example of how we could have a theory invented in the minds of some very smart physicists that would give us a very different perspective on the universe. 19:43 Is it conceivable that we will never get the answer to that question? 19:49 Oh, it's conceivable. But, you know, we've only been asking these questions in their modern way for 100 years, because it was about 100 years ago when Einstein invented his theory and Bohr and Heisenberg and people like that invented 20:06 the quantum theory. And so those have developed over the last hundred years. We've learned how to make bombs out of them, for crying out loud. So, you know, give us another thousand years. This is a very young subject. 20:22 Give us another million years. The universe isn't going anywhere. 20:26 The sun's not going anywhere. The Earth's not going anywhere. 20:29 Listen to more Coast to Coast AM every weeknight at 1 a.m. Eastern and go to coasttocoastam.com for more.
Community discussion