0:00 You know, it's my phone. 0:01 I'm the one who should decide what software should run on my phone and even what operating system should be running my phone. 0:09 Hello, everybody, and welcome to Techlore Talks. 0:11 Today, I am joined for I think what's a first ever dual interview is what I'll call this, where I have Wessel from Novacustom, who makes open hardware from laptops and desktops and mini PCs and now also a phone. 0:24 And we also have Brian from iodéOS, which is an Android custom ROM. 0:29 And they pretty much collaborated to build this phone, which is the SHIFTphone, which comes pre-installed with iodéOS. 0:35 And I wanted to go ahead and ask them about it, as well as the overall direction of where the Android ecosystem is headed, some of the concerns around Google, the repairability aspect of the SHIFTphone and why that's an important thing to consider, as well as some fun side 0:49 tangents regarding geopolitical things and why public money, public code should probably be more considered and what the future of mobile devices look like. 0:58 This was a fun one to just get to know these projects a little bit better. 1:01 So I hope you guys enjoy it. 1:02 So basically, I've been with iodéOS two years. 1:05 It's been around for over five years now. 1:07 It's an alternative operating system for Android. 1:09 The idea is to focus on privacy and make it user friendly for as many people as possible. 1:14 And one of the interesting points of iodéOS is that it comes integrated with a tracker blocker and even a spam calls blocker. 1:21 So we try to filter out ads and third-party trackers from apps and basically focus on that just to give people the maximum amount of privacy with the minimum amount of effort. 1:30 It's more an operating system for the average person. 1:33 We want it to come with a working set of apps that are all open source. 1:37 It's also for people who really want to know all the privacy implications of every app they're installing. 1:42 you can also go inside the iodé blocker and look at and see what all the connections are. 1:47 We're also trying to support as many devices as possible. 1:50 We're currently supporting over 60 devices and support them even beyond end of life so that people don't just throw away a device when it's no longer supported by the manufacturer. 2:00 Yeah, so I'm Wessel Klesznerkeborg. 2:01 I'm the director of Novacustom and we supply laptops, mini PCs, and now also smartphones with a strong focus on privacy, security, and durability. 2:12 And for our laptops and computers, we supply them with the Dasharo coreboot firmware. 2:18 And we are highly focused on right-to-repair, which means that we have a guaranteed spare parts availability for at least seven years after the product's launch. 2:27 And we also have repair videos for basically every part of the device. 2:32 So newly introduced was the SHIFTphone 8.1, and we supply it pre-installed with iodéOS. 2:39 So we have a modular phone that is privacy focused. 2:43 Do you mind just quickly covering Shift, that company as well? 2:46 Because it feels like this is a bit of a collaboration between a lot of people with similar values. 2:50 So I'd love to hear a bit about that. 2:52 Shift is actually a German company. 2:54 So they are focusing on durability and sustainability. 2:58 They compensate their waste with their closing the loop program. 3:02 So there is indeed a cooperation between us and Shift. 3:05 And basically the cooperation is that we get the device from Shift and we sell them on our website as SHIFTphone 8.1, but with iodéOS pre-installed. 3:16 So you cannot get this phone pre-installed at Shift themselves. 3:20 But if you would like it to buy pre-installed, you either have to buy it from us or from the guys of iodéOS. 3:27 Basically, our added value is mainly the right to repair and the guaranteed availability for spare parts and, of course, the repair videos. 3:37 Very nice. 3:38 And has the SHIFTphone previously been supported, Brian, by you guys? 3:41 Or is that something that you added in light of this collaboration? 3:44 We base iodéOS on Lineage, on Lineage OS. 3:48 And when we saw that it was supported by Lineage, we got excited because that takes a lot of work. 3:54 We have supported phones without them being supported by Lineage, but there's a lot of previous work that has to be done. 4:00 And so we got excited because it's German hardware, you know, it's modular, it's got to focus on ecology, but also because it has physical kill switches. 4:09 So that was something that some, you know, some people actually really like the peace of mind that comes with the physical kill switch. 4:16 If you just want to, you know, completely remove your microphone, you can't. 4:20 Sometimes people actually have asked us to get the microphones pulled off the SoC. 4:24 So desoldered from that. 4:26 You know, we don't actually offer that service. 4:28 So we do. 4:28 Some people actually don't even want there to be a microphone. 4:31 You can just plug a USB-C microphone in or you can connect that way and then you can be completely sure. 4:36 And so the kill switch is a better option. 4:38 You don't actually have to go pulling your device apart and desoldering microphones. 4:43 I think I heard Wessel there just say they do that. 4:45 Yeah, so for even more peace of mind, we do deliver this phone without the camera, for example, or without the microphone. 4:53 It sounds like the main thing you're discussing is modularity. 4:56 Can you speak to why that modularity matters? 4:58 So, for example, I don't know if you remember it from back in the days when you had this Samsung phone that you can just easily take out the battery and place another battery in. 5:08 Those were cool times, right? 5:10 So when we decided to offer a phone, we went really looking into a phone that has these kind of things, not only the battery, but also, for example, another part that is getting broken quite easily is the screen, of course, screen display. 5:25 So how nice is it that you don't need to heat up the screen display to take the screen out? 5:32 With the SHIFTphone 8.1, you can just remove two screws at the bottom side and then remove the cap that is on the backside. 5:41 And there are a few more screws. 5:42 You take them out and then just like that, install a new one. 5:45 I think people really miss the repairability aspect of this. 5:48 I think that open hardware is going to be one of the most important things in the next 10 years. 5:52 Because without that open hardware, and especially with the direction that we see Google going, I think they're going to try to clamp down more and more, which leaks into software. 5:59 This is actually where we want to jump in. 6:01 We want to have the technology as open as possible. 6:04 So this is why, for example, we collaborate with the iodéOS for the operating system on the SHIFTphone, but also on the laptops and computers that we offer that we offer them with Dasharo coreboot open source firmware. 6:16 This is very important. 6:17 And I think other manufacturers should follow the same path. 6:20 Yeah. 6:21 Is it open hardware with Shift? 6:22 Like what's open? 6:23 It's not like 100% open hardware, but we have access to documentation like blueprints and so on. 6:30 But I'm not sure if this is publicly available. 6:33 It's also open in the sense of every part we offer spare parts. 6:37 So this availability is also important so that people when they have a problem with a specific part of the phone, that they can just buy a new part and use it in their phone. 6:46 Can you guys explain firmware end of life versus software out of life? 6:52 Which one you think is more important? 6:54 I guess it depends on your threat model. 6:56 I mean, if you're an activist, a lawyer, a judge, politician, any actor in civil society that's involved in human rights, because we've seen this NSO spyware used extensively against civil society people, and even corporations pay for it to use 7:12 against people that are organizing against corporations, you know, mining companies, petroleum companies have been buying access to this NSO spyware like Pegasus. 7:22 This is information that comes to us from Citizen Lab, a great organization studying spyware as part of Amnesty International, I believe. 7:28 And they would clearly recommend to you, do not run an end-of-life device. 7:33 Make sure that your device is up to date. 7:35 And they would probably also recommend that you run something with a secure enclave, like a Pixel or an iPhone, preferably with some sort of lockdown mode or a hardened operating system like GrapheneOS install. 7:46 If that is your threat model, definitely don't consider running an end of life device because you're likely to get attacked by very specific vulnerabilities that go straight to the baseband, that go straight to the firmware underlying the device way before the operating system. 8:01 One of the most unfortunate things about our hardware manufacturers is that they aren't producing open hardware. 8:07 There just isn't a market for it. 8:09 And as the whole market has been reduced to a few players, they've showed no interest in it. 8:14 And that's something I would really, really love to see the EU do if they actually do start working on their own hardware, because we just don't know if there are back doors built into Apple and Google Pixels. 8:27 We have very little way of knowing that. 8:29 So to return to the original question, if your threat model is surveillance capitalism, yes, you're probably better off with an end of life de-Google device. 8:38 I do have one thing to add, if I may. 8:40 So one of the things I think people should calculate into when buying a new device. 8:45 So a lot of people want to buy a new device and they think, oh, that's really expensive. 8:49 If you're a person who holds on to your devices, consider doing the equation of divide the price of the phone by how many years of security updates you will get. 8:59 And very often you will find that a phone like the Fairphone or the Shift and also the Google Pixel, even though they're more expensive, They're going to be much cheaper per year than an Oppo and a Xiaomi and these other crap devices who actually aren't even living up 9:16 to the EU's own standards of five years. 9:18 As of last year, phones are supposed to have five years of security updates, and they're not even living up to that. 9:24 And I would like to see that actually enforced. 9:26 I'm glad you brought that up because it's something that I, it's how I look at things when I buy hardware or really anything. 9:31 And it's also one of the reasons we chose the shift is because they offer those seven years. 9:36 You know, that's why we're happy about Fairphone as well. 9:39 And it's great that Novacustom is going to offer seven years as well of ensuring that there's parts. 9:43 And even the Google Pixel, you know, while they offer those seven years of software updates, I'm not sure you're going to find parts. 9:51 And I know, for example, when you go to try to buy a screen for a Google Pixel, my goodness, it's a serious, I mean, it's often more expensive than just buying the phone secondhand with a good screen. 10:02 Plus, I think it's kind of a gamble if you can make it on your own, if you're not a specialized person. 10:09 The adhesive, right? 10:11 Yeah, exactly. 10:11 That's the whole thing around repairability mainly. 10:14 Glue is like not so good for repairability, right? 10:18 So yeah, we offer the repair video so you can easily just do the same thing as we do in the video. 10:23 And this makes it very easy to replace your screen display. 10:27 For me, personally, I've done it a few times and I do it within, I think, less than 90 seconds. 10:34 Wow. 10:36 Your phone and your laptop don't stop connecting just because you stop using them. 10:39 They can still share your location and sync data in the background. 10:43 Those connections can help big tech and governments track you and give hackers a way in. 10:47 But that's why I like to use Faraday bags like SLNT. 10:49 SLNT makes Faraday bags that physically block wireless signals to and from your device. 10:55 If you want a physical guarantee that nothing can actually access your device, just slide your phone in, close the bag, and the connection stops. 11:04 There's no app, there's no settings, no subscription. 11:07 It's literally a physical bag that physically prevents any signals from leaving. 11:12 It's one of the simplest ways to take some control back over your privacy. 11:16 Check them out at SLNT.com slash Techlore. 11:19 That's SLNT.com slash Techlore. 11:22 And that code at checkout gets you 15% off and free shipping on any qualifying orders. 11:28 Now back to the video. 11:30 Bootloader unlocking, I don't know if this ever develops, but I know that Samsung started making some moves to make it harder to unlock their devices. 11:37 And I've seen people speculate online. 11:39 I haven't seen a mainstream attack against this, but people have just asked and posed the question, what happens if a country wants to essentially say, hey, OEMs, you have to lock down the bootloader, which would prevent anyone from installing any kind of alternative 11:53 operating system on their phone. 11:55 So an unlocked bootloader has two risks associated with it. 11:58 One is that you're much more susceptible to physical attacks. 12:01 So there's nothing preventing Cellebrite, which is a software that many police agencies and intelligence agencies around the world use, and very often just take your phone away from you at the border and plug it into one of these devices. 12:13 They can crack and install malware on your device in a question of minutes. 12:17 So it makes it more vulnerable to those sorts of physical attacks. 12:21 But it also means that every time your phone boots up, there isn't this process in which the operating system gets validated. 12:27 So this is one of the basic functions of the Android security model is the locking on the bootloader. 12:34 In the end, it just comes down to do you value ecology? 12:38 Do you value security? 12:39 Do you value privacy? 12:40 And which of those do you value more? 12:42 You know, I don't think there's any right decision. 12:44 As far as I know, every manufacturer is locking their devices. 12:47 You know, they are bootloader locked when they're sold. 12:50 And there's only maybe like 10 or 12 manufacturers who will let you bootload or unlock at this point. 12:56 Even some European manufacturers who would be great if we could support their devices. 13:00 Just some of these smaller manufacturers, we kind of wonder why don't they, you know, allow bootloader unlocking and relocking. 13:06 And it's a shame. 13:07 It would allow a lot of really good hardware to be improved by de-googling it. 13:13 So in terms of like bootloader relocking, then that has to be a real conscious choice. 13:17 But I think that they have made a conscious choice. 13:20 Most of the manufacturers have made a conscious choice to go in the other direction, to not allow bootloader unlocking even. 13:25 So it's nice that manufacturers like Volla and Shift and Fairphone are very clearly wanting to go in the other direction and are explicitly allowing bootloader relocking. 13:34 Motorola has now seems to be going in that direction. 13:38 What can the EU do? 13:39 let me say specifically is that we could encourage procurement requirements on de-Google devices. 13:44 You could say, look, if you want to buy for your municipality or your government Android devices, they must be de-Googled. 13:51 And it could just be that they have a version of AOSP, or they could be de-Googled with microG or whatever. 13:58 It's going to require regulation. 14:00 I think that it would be great if the antitrust laws actually led to settlements that went in to develop alternatives to anti to to the to the monopolies because we we actually don't get any of those funds it doesn't trickle down to the ecosystem 14:15 in any way and it would be great you know the same way that banks were forced to implement 2fa it would be great if banks were forced to require web access to their services just because people might not even have a cell phone go figure and of course research 14:29 and development you know funding needs to go in developing local chip design. 14:33 And another thing that we can do is we can encourage or force free software onto anything that gets funding, anything that gets procured or bought, you know, just require open standards, require open source. 14:46 Yes, definitely. 14:47 Those are all things that can happen that obviously we can't do that we need as the public to ask for and insist upon. 14:54 One of the problems here is that Facebook, Google, and these other companies are now the biggest lobbying force inside the EU, like bigger than big oil, bigger than big pharma, bigger than any other European company. 15:09 These companies have more lobbying power in Brussels than anyone else. 15:14 And that is kind of shocking. 15:15 I can only completely agree. 15:17 I mean, if you see what happens, that politicians get influenced by big tech, we'll say, hey, we have to protect our children. 15:26 But really, it's not about protecting children. 15:30 It's just about having more control so that the big tech companies and maybe even governments can manipulate us. 15:37 And that has to stop. 15:39 We really hope that politicians go with correct decisions to stop this. 15:44 Yeah. 15:44 Did you guys maybe have any starting points? 15:46 I know that this has been an ongoing thing and we've been doing a lot of coverage for it and it's been kind of hard to track Google's moves. 15:54 Yeah, the steps that they do right now clearly show what they want is to close down the operating system and that has to stop. 16:02 There's some fundamental problems with Google being a manufacturer of devices and also being the company supporting other people's devices. 16:11 So there's a fundamental conflict of interest there and it's such a big monopoly. 16:14 And so what they can do is they can release their software for their own devices and then delay other devices, software updates, so debilitating their security on other devices. 16:26 So these sorts of things are very worrisome. 16:29 You know, in terms of keep Android open, to some extent it affects F-Droid on regular stock Android and that just will cause some developers to abandon F-Droid, perhaps, you know? 16:39 And so that in itself is bad for the whole, I hesitate to use the term ecosystem since it's such a monoculture, but it's bad for the whole, you know, for all of Android. 16:48 So Google is based on Android open source project, and they've gradually been introducing proprietary parts that replace aspects of the Android open source project. 16:58 So, you know, for example, the eSIM integration into Android open source project is proprietary. 17:03 So it took a while before it could be developed. 17:05 So you have to replace the proprietary eSIM stack with one that's an open implementation. 17:10 And that's the tendency. 17:12 Yeah, it's been weird to see. 17:13 And I've been, you know, I hear mixed reports from everybody. 17:15 It seems like everyone has different opinions and experiences with their project and how it's impacted by decisions that Google makes. 17:22 But the AOSP one seems to be the very universal thing that everybody's saying, which is things that used to be givens that were just out of the box, done for us, and part of the open source ecosystem of AOSP. 17:34 But now it puts more pressure on all of you guys. 17:37 Do you share any of that bandwidth with other projects? 17:40 I know that there seems to be like, like lineage sometimes works on certain things, and then you're able to utilize that. 17:46 And it seems like some projects have stepped up overall to help supply some of that AOSP work. 17:51 So what does that collaboration look like behind the scenes? 17:54 When we can push things upstream to Lineage, we do so. 17:57 Our development team also works on Lineage sometimes. 18:01 The main collaboration that's forming is now like there's a conversation going on between all of the, well, not all, but almost all of the different custom ROMs about how to deal with Google Play Integrity, which is this monopolistic play by Google to make apps incompatible. 18:17 It's very much an Apple move. 18:19 It's just to kill any app that wants to seek security. 18:23 It shouldn't be considered security because they're willing to support, I think even back to Android 9, if I'm not mistaken, or maybe 11. 18:30 So they're willing to support really out-of-date hardware and say that it's safe while telling people that the SHIFTphone with iodéOS is like an unsafe device to run your banking app on. 18:40 So there's two aspects of it. 18:42 There's a hardware attestation and then the soft attestation. 18:46 We can get past some of these tests, but we just can't get past the hardware attestation. 18:51 And so if a developer has made the poor choice of choosing this security that Google promises, then their apps don't work on other people's devices. 19:00 People can go to uattest.net. 19:03 There's a small manufacturer called Volla who's been spearheading that coalition. 19:07 And there's a bunch of us who are considering joining it. 19:10 We're still discussing some of the technical details. 19:12 We're such a small part of the total number of people actually running an Android device that what's good for any of these custom ROMs or alternative Android OSs is good for the other ones as well, I believe. 19:24 Can I ask you a question, Wessel? 19:25 What's coming up in the future for your company? 19:27 What plans do you have? 19:28 Is there anything that you can tell us about what you've got planned? 19:31 Yeah, yeah. 19:32 So we are working on an AMD model, which is pretty cool. 19:35 I don't know exactly about the timeline, but definitely this is what we are working on right now. 19:41 And I'm very excited about this because it will come with AMD openSIL, which means that even more parts of the firmware will become open source. 19:49 Looking towards the future, you're offering seven years of hardware updates. 19:53 How is your business model sustainable? 19:55 How do we know as a consumer when we buy a device from you that you're going to be here seven years from now? 20:01 You mean how we assure that we have the spare parts available for this time? 20:06 Is that what you mean? 20:07 Exactly. 20:08 We are analyzing our sales from past years. 20:11 And then we say, okay, probably we need this percentage of all the stock that we have. 20:18 We probably will need this for spare parts. 20:20 So we have a part of our stock that we set apart to guarantee this availability. 20:26 And at the same time, we have contacts with Shift, but also for the laptops with our ODM provider to supply parts. 20:34 But this is only available for three years. 20:36 Within these three years, we can still get spare parts from the factory directly. 20:42 And after these three years, we still have our reserved stock that we are basically just, you know, screwing open to take the parts out of it and to use it in case you need it. 20:53 That's very cool. 20:54 What about you guys, Brian? 20:55 What's next for you guys? 20:56 There's a bunch of things. 20:57 So we've been working on iodéOS Premium. 20:59 We have two business models or two sources of income. 21:02 One is that aside from donations, we sell devices, but we also have premium subscribers. 21:06 We offer some benefits to people who subscribe. 21:09 Like, for example, we have a spam calls blocker that gets a daily update rather than a monthly update if you're a premium subscriber. 21:16 So we offer a little bit more to try to encourage people into this subscription model to try to make sure that we have a steady sort of income stream that will also help us be more financially. 21:25 stable. 21:26 And so we've been working on that. 21:27 We're hoping to develop Find My Device, as well as to continue developing our parental features, like we'd like to add time limits to. 21:35 So one of the things you can do with the iodé blocker is that you can set it up for a child and you can choose which apps they can and cannot install and also choose whether they have access to only Wi-Fi or whether they have access to cellular. 21:48 With each app, you can fine-grained choose whether it has access to a VPN, to a cellular, to Wi-Fi connection, things like that. 21:55 And one of the things that we like about our collaboration with Novacustom is that they decided that they wanted just to include premium by default on all their devices. 22:02 So that's really nice of them. 22:03 They're paying extra for that. 22:04 It's a nice collaboration. 22:05 We're very happy about that. 22:06 And it's also sort of interrupt you, but it's also kind of cool that we can just go to you and say, hey, we want this feature to be included. 22:13 We can pay your hours to include this into your OS. 22:17 So we benefit, you benefit, everyone benefits. 22:19 So that's also pretty nice about this cooperation. 22:22 Yeah. 22:23 I want to thank you guys both for being here. 22:25 Where can anyone find your projects if they want to learn more about each of you? 22:29 Just go to iode.tech. 22:31 You'll find information about our operating system, our shop, and things like that. 22:35 And our products and services are available on novacustom .com. 22:39 Awesome. 22:39 Thank you guys for your time. 22:40 Thanks a lot. 22:40 Thank you so much, Henry. 22:41 If you guys liked this interview and you want to see more, let me know any guests that you'd love to have on. 22:46 I have a lot of fun interviewing people and getting to know all these different projects. 22:49 So I also benefit a lot myself and I have fun doing it. 22:52 And I hope that it's also educational for any one of you who are listening in as well. 22:57 If you want to support our content, the best way to do it is to become a Techlorian down in a description. 23:01 I have a private Signal group just for those people so that we have a nice little tight knit community there. 23:05 Another perk you can get is I have my private RSS feed that I use to track hundreds of stories throughout the week. 23:10 And so if you want to just follow one RSS feed and keep up with all digital rights stuff, you can do that by becoming Thank you all who already support us. 23:17 We couldn't do this content without you. 23:19 And I'll see you next time on Techlore.
Community discussion