0:02 Welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind, a production of iHeartRadio. Hey, welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind. My name is Robert Lamb. 0:16 And I am Joe McCormick, and we're back today with the second part in our series on the character of Merlin from Arthurian Legends. In the previous episode, we kicked things off by talking about the patchwork origins of the 0:29 Merlin figure, as well as the character's evolution across history and lack of a fixed form. And on that subject, we got a bit into discussing a major source that we've both been reading for these episodes, which is a book called The True History of Merlin the Magician from 0:46 Yale University Press 2012. by the medieval historian Anne Lawrence Mathers, who is a professor at the University of Reading. One major emphasis of this book is the way that Merlin was from, I think it was roughly the 12th to 1:01 the 16th centuries, thereabouts, accepted by nearly everyone as a real historical figure and one of great political and religious significance, even though he was, to be clear, a totally fictional character. 1:17 And a lot of the most influential Merlin traditions trace back to a pseudo-historical chronicle put together by a guy named Geoffrey of Monmouth in the 12th century, though there are pre-existing inputs on that as well. And so we're going to talk about some of those today. But in 1:34 this book, Lawrence Mathers is clearly very interested in these interactions between Merlin's fundamental fictionality and in some cases explicitly fictional treatments of And then in other cases, his assumed historicity. 1:49 And we talked about a few aspects of that in the last episode. Last time, we also did a segment called Merlin, the Magician's Greatest Hits, where we talked about some of his famous magical deeds. The hits we got into last time included Prophecy, of course, which was probably 2:06 Merlin's most important and defining supernatural power, the ability to see into the future. and interpret omens of things to come. 2:15 And we talked about specific predictions he gave as well, such as the vision of the red dragon and the white. 2:20 We also talked about Merlin's role in the fictional origins of Stonehenge, at least according to Geoffrey of Monmouth. Of course, the real Stonehenge was built in the Neolithic period between 4,000 and 5,000 years ago, so this origin story is 2:35 completely wrong. But in Geoffrey's telling of Stonehenge was stolen by Merlin and Uther Pendragon from a monument built by giants in Ireland and brought piece by piece to the Salisbury Plain and then recreated. So it says that the 2:54 form of Stonehenge that is created in southern England is the same form that it had when it was the giants dance on this mountain in Ireland. And in the story, we talked about how it seems to be implied that Merlin was able to bring the stones over by the 3:08 use of special mechanical and engineering knowledge. So it's never quite said like what tricks he used. And then last time, we also talked more about the interesting differences between our early sources on Merlin and did more of a deep 3:23 dive on Geoffrey of Monmouth. And we're back today to talk about more, starting, I think, with some traditions of some what you might call pre-Merlin Merlins, input Merlins. 3:33 Yeah, input Merlin, input Merlin. Well, what is this input Merlin? Basically, we're going to be talking about an earlier Welsh figure, a Celtic figure that is featured in Welsh sources that pre-existed the work of Geoffrey of Monmouth. Concerning a character 3:54 named Merthyn. Now, if you see a spelling of this, it's spelled M-Y-R-D-D-I-N, but the Welsh pronunciation is more like Merthyn. 4:04 There are going to be several Welsh names and terms that we'll refer to in this section, and I just want to add my sort of standard caveat. The Welsh language is a beautiful language. I'm going to do my best with it, but I do not necessarily have the 4:20 tongue for it. So I'll try and do it justice. 4:24 So I was reading, of course, we were reading about this topic in the work by Lawrence Mathers that we've mentioned already, The True History of Merlin the Magician. But I was also reading about this in From Merthyn to 4:36 Merlin and Back Again by Australian academic Stephen Knight, who I believe was based in Wales for quite a long time as well. He had written multiple books on a number of topics, including Arthurian legend. And both point out that The tale that we mentioned in the last episode 4:55 of this seer child and the twin dragons that are battling each other, this seems to be lifted in particular from the tales of Ambrosius Aurelanus. We mentioned this in the past episode as well. This is a 5th century 5:12 Romano-British war leader who fought against the Anglo-Saxons. So presumably an actual historic person. And this character is also employed in Geoffrey of Monmouth's history. but in an altered form with this one story taken away from him and then 5:26 applied to this new character of Merlin based on the character from Welsh tradition, Merthyn. And apparently the reason that there's a name change there from Merthyn to Merlin is this was done very much for French-minded Anglo-Normans who might 5:43 think it would sound too much like murder, which means excrement. 5:47 So you didn't want your important prophet's name to be poop. 5:53 That's great because it reminds me of the story about the name of Jaws 2 in French. Are you familiar with this one? 5:58 No, no. 6:00 Basically, it goes that when Jaws was released for French-speaking audiences or in France, it was put out under the name, I think, Le Dant de la Mer. I'm sorry if I'm saying that wrong, but it means the teeth of the sea in French. So it ends with de la mer. 6:15 But when they wanted to release it, you know, the second one, Jaws 2, it would be De La Mer Du, which I think it just like it sounded too much like the teeth of the poop. So they had to fiddle with that. 6:31 Yeah, there's things like that in international film titles all the time. And yeah, it makes sense that this is something that existed obviously before film as well, going way back. 6:40 Anytime you were translating one work from one language to another. 6:42 Yeah. 6:44 Uh, now speaking of Ambrosius Arlenus, some historians have considered the possibility that you could look upon him as an actual historic inspiration for the mythic King Arthur. Um, this whole, this is a whole area beyond the scope of these 6:59 episodes where we're mainly talking about Merlin. There's a whole, there's a whole wealth of, uh, of, of information out there where people are saying, well, maybe this is the, the, uh, possibility for the historic King Arthur. Um, We're not going 7:12 to get into all of that, but still, there is at least a notion out there that a single historic figure may have inspired both of these characters, Arthur and Merlin, at least to some faint degree. Now, coming back to the Welsh Merthyn here, as Knight explains it, there are 7:29 basically two formations of the character. The first one is as follows. We have a Cumbrian noble bard who fought in the Battle of Ard-d-Rydd in 573 C.E. And traumatized by the horrors of that engagement, you know, just the horrors of war, he goes mad and he flees into 7:48 the forest to live as a hermit. So he's a wild man of the woods. But as is often the case, this is, you know, very much a trope, as we'll discuss here. He's full of wisdom and he has prophetic abilities that emerge. Also, in some tellings, he takes on 8:04 the air of a trickster and even a stag riding revenger. 8:07 I believe the tale is that he leads a procession of animals that while riding a stag into his former wife's wedding, and then throws the stag's antlers at the groom, either impaling him or the antlers just pass through his body like bullets made out of bone. 8:27 Wow. 8:27 Yeah. But in general, here we have, again, the classic wise hermit, holy madman trope. which also certainly factors into larger Christian traditions. It goes back into antiquity and even to ancient Sumerian works. You know, Enkidu from the Epic 8:45 of Gilgamesh, after all, was not only a wild man, but an interpreter of dreams. 8:50 Yeah. So originally the sort of the antagonist of Gilgamesh, but then becomes his good friend. 8:56 Yeah. 8:56 Yeah. 8:58 So, yeah, this this version of Murthyn, is very much a prophet, but also a poet. I'm going to read just a little bit about him here. This is from the Black Book of Carmarthen, and it goes as follows. 9:18 Now Gwynedd, this would be the sister of Merthyn here, loves me not, nor welcomes me, and I am hated by Gwasog, Ruthric's ally. I have destroyed her son and daughter. 9:32 Death takes everyone. Why does he not welcome me? After Gwynthola, this would be his former lord, no lord revere me. 9:42 No sport delights me. No lover seeks me out. In the battle of Ardorith, my torque was gold. Today I am no treasure to a swan-like girl. So, you know, again, getting into this elegant idea of someone whose heroic past is now truly their past. They've fled from battle. They've 10:00 gone into the wilderness. But then there they become something more. 10:04 All the good times are past and gone. 10:06 Yeah. But like we've been saying, he becomes this prophet in the wilderness. He can see into the future and has insight regarding the Saxons and so forth. Here's another bit. 10:17 This is also collected in the Black Book of Carmarthen. 10:21 Rejoice to the Welsh, very great battles, quick swords defending, death to the Saxons on ashen spears and playing ball games with their heads. And I will speak the truth without a lie. A youth shall rise in the region of the South. 10:38 Playing ball games with their heads, huh? 10:40 Yes. I went down a small rabbit hole on this one. 10:46 Because I think some people read this or read things like this and they think, well, this is the origin of football. This is the origin of soccer. It started with playing with human heads. And I don't think that's exactly what we're supposed to draw from this. We were 11:02 talking about this the other day off mic. I think we all realize that if you were trying to play serious sporting games with human heads, you'd run into a lot of problems. Consistency. Head size, you know, far better to try and deal with some sort of a bladder 11:20 based actual ball for your sport. 11:23 I just I've never tried it, but I would think a head would not be bouncy enough. They could be too dense. 11:29 Yeah. 11:29 And it would also pretty quickly degrade over the course of playtime. Yeah. 11:34 Yeah. Occasionally you're going to get some teeth stuck in your foot. You're going to get your your boot stuck on a jawbone. There's all sorts of stuff that could go wrong. So, yeah. Celebrate with the severed heads for a little bit. Sure. But when it comes down to 11:47 serious sport, you're going to want to depend on some sort of a sheep's ladder. Yeah. 11:52 Maybe Saxon heads are different. 11:54 Yeah. So in this work, Knight discusses how Welsh poets would use Merthyn as a recurring figure to spout prophecies against different foreign princes and invasions, as well as prophesying future liberation from this and other forces. And this Welsh poet, 12:15 and prophet Merlin was, of course, known to Geoffrey of Monmouth. 12:18 And he latches onto it for his own literary historic transformation here, repurposing wealth prophecies and poetry for different cultural, political and pseudo historical purposes. 12:31 But to be clear, while there are obviously some points of inspiration, the Geoffrey Merlin character is so different from this one. it is often thought not really to be the same character. It's more kind of like you get 12:46 a derivation of the name and some little elements brought through, but that a lot of it is combining with these other characters, elements, or just fabrication of new stories. 12:57 Right, right. And there has certainly been, to my understanding, an effort over prior decades here to sort of reclaim the Welsh Merthyn and sort of separate this figure and his importance to Welsh culture, apart from what was made out of him and what became Merlin and takes on 13:16 this grand purpose in British history and then beyond British history into fantasy lore and so forth. But you know what's not in the Welsh sources, and this was pretty interesting to me, that is the idea that Merlin's parents have a demonic flair to them. The idea, as we 13:37 mentioned in the last episode, something that Geoffrey of Monmouth introduces, that the child Merlin, brought by the tyrant Vortigern for blood sacrifice upon the foundation of his stronghold, is the offspring of a mortal woman and an incubus, a shape-shifting 13:53 demon that, like the female counterpart, the succubus, seduces mortal men, and this leads to monstrous births. 14:01 Yes, and this demonic parentage will actually play a big role in the section I want to get into later in the episode also. 14:08 Yeah, yeah. It's really, I think, one of the more fascinating things about the character, especially when you get into Lawrence Mather's discussion about how he was viewed as an actual living person, an actual historic figure. What are we 14:23 to make of this? And yeah, as she discusses in her book, this is not in the Welsh tales of Merthyn and seems to be an embellishment of Geoffrey's, but based on what? Hmm. So we should point out that the idea of a demonic seducer is also one of 14:37 those things. It's very old. Dates back at least in written records to the Sumerian king list of 2400 BCE, which describes Gilgamesh's father as having been born of a Lilu demon, which Anne M. Cox in Sleep Paralysis and 14:54 Folklore 2015, the Royal Society of Medicine Journals describes as, quote, one of four succubi or vampire-like demons that Yeah. So the mere idea here is, again, quite old. And as Cox discusses it in this paper, it may well be 15:06 tied to universal human experience of parasomnia, you know, night terrors and so forth. So Lawrence Mathers, discussing this idea, this idea of these demon lovers being utilized here in the Merlin story by Geoffrey, points out that these are 15:38 going to become a major trend in medieval literature, but they hadn't really arrived yet in terms of popularity at the time of the history of the kings of Britain, raising the question of whether Geoffrey, in these widely read texts, again, 15:52 we mentioned how popular these were, how many copies there were, And then the prophecies of Merlin too, circulating sort of, you know, as a kind of pamphlet. There's this idea that they might have kickstarted the popularity of these demon lover stories to some extent. 16:08 Interesting. 16:10 So, you know, these stories, as she discusses, they were popular and they were generally considered very much in agreeance with Christian theology of the time. This alone is a really fascinating topic. I'd read about it before in some sources. 16:26 And we're not going to get into all the theological ins and outs here. But basically, demons could and did do just this, according to theologians and people in the know. 16:38 Though there were discussions about the rules of the thing, such as the whole duck feet issue. We've talked, I remember talking about this, Joe, that there was this idea that, okay, demons can take the form of attractive people and seduce 16:53 human beings. All right, sounds a little unfair. And so there's this whole train of discussion about, well, a righteous person would surely have the opportunity to see through the disguise. 17:06 And therefore, the disguise, the shape, the lovely shape that a demon takes on can never be 100% complete. There must be something missing. So the demon can take on the form of a beautiful woman, but it will have to have duck feet, something that will give the faithful 17:23 human a way out, a way to recognize that something's amiss here and I should not give in to this temptation. 17:29 Yeah, so that is a very interesting, it's kind of a just world rationalization. Like, well, in order for things to be fair, because we know God is just, it would have to be this way. But we do know that not everybody in the Middle Ages had that assumption, 17:43 that it would always be like that, especially because you can see counterexamples in some of the Merlin stories. Like, we will get into There are different renditions of how exactly this would have happened with Merlin's parentage, but in 17:57 the one I want to talk about later, essentially it's portrayed that Merlin's mother did nothing wrong. She is essentially just fully deceived or sexually assaulted by an incubus demon. 18:08 So it's not like she fell for something that she should have missed. It's just the demon comes over her as she sleeps. 18:16 Right, right. Yeah, and the duck feet thing in particular, I think I always latch onto it because... I can see so many problems with it. 18:23 Well, yeah, yeah. 18:24 But yeah, I mean, this is a whole area where there's all sorts of discussions back and forth. I mean, early on with discussions about, well, can demons actually take on physical bodies? And if so, what does that mean? 18:35 What powers do devils have in God's universe and so forth? 18:41 There's tons of ins and outs there. But I guess the basic is the thing to keep in mind here is that, okay, it's It's technically considered a reasonable understanding of the natural and unseen world that this can happen. 18:57 And I think we can acknowledge that it's an entertaining thing to have happen. This is some high drama for your stories. It also has roots certainly in a lot of prior beliefs and traditions. It has roots in antiquity. 19:12 We have so many examples of maybe not necessarily demons, but certainly otherworldly supernatural beings. that, um, that, that, uh, that impregnate a human woman and lead to some sort of miraculous birth. I mean, this is just part of storytelling, 19:27 you know, world over since time out of mind. 19:30 Yeah. It's throughout Greek mythology and so forth. 19:32 Yeah. And as we touched on in the last episode, it's also the story of Jesus Christ. Yes. So, um, so yeah, there's plenty, plenty of that to go around. Um, There's a book that I've discussed in the show before. 19:44 This really concerns a later age, but there's a book called Demon Lovers by Walter Stevenson. gets into a whole lot of this. That author ends up making the case that in later eras of failing faith, tales of, and 19:59 more importantly, forced confessions of sexual congress with demons serve to provide kind of like carnal proof of not only hell, because, oh, if you you know, laid with a, with a demon, then we know demons are real, but then they would, 20:12 there'd be this added level of demons are real. That means angels are real. And if angels are real, that means God is real. And if I'm living in an age where I feel like my, my faith is threatened and the whole, you know, religious framework of my universe 20:26 is threatened. Well here in a very like perverse and twisted and immoral and violent way, I have, you know, reached out and found proof that what I want to believe in is true. Hmm. Yeah. 20:38 So it's in the face of an emerging skepticism that the yearning for these types of stories becomes even stronger. 20:46 Yeah, yeah. And, you know, we may come back a little bit to this idea when we discuss the trajectory of Merlin through time. So Lawrence Mathers discusses the possible roots of incubi and succubi in the Old Testament and 20:59 Apocrypha concerning the Nephilim, the offspring of the sons of God and the daughters of men. This is, of course, a whole topic unto itself as well. But basically, sometimes this is held to interpret it as being fallen angels 21:14 or mythic human heroes. And why not pre-human giants of mythic Britain as well? 21:19 That's interesting. I just made a mental connection, which is that one of the big tellings, one of the big sources for The story of the Nephilim of these, you know, heavenly beings that see women of earth and want to come down and lie with them and, you know, produce 21:35 offspring with them. That comes from a book called First Enoch. 21:39 First Enoch also famously has this section known as the animal apocalypse, which is full of this wild symbolic imagery, the full of prophecy and prediction about sort of geopolitical events that are going to happen. But everything is symbolized 21:55 by weird animals. Which also reminds me of the prophecies of Merlin. So they're like multiple connections between Jeffrey's Merlin and the Book of Enoch. 22:06 What was the Merlin prophecy? The hedgehog will dig... Gather. 22:10 Its apples and hide in passages. And the fox, let's see, the snake will encircle London. It's that kind of stuff. 22:16 Yeah, yeah, yeah. With lots of room for interpretation. 22:19 Yeah. 22:30 Now, uh, another thing that, um, Lawrence Mathers points out is that in the history of the Kings of Britain, Jeffrey mostly presents pagan ideas in a, like almost a surprisingly neutral tone. Uh, despite the Christian church, the church's 22:43 position that pagan gods were at least false idols, if not actual demons themselves. Uh, but in, uh, despite this, like we mentioned Brutus, the mythic founder of Britain, um, It's described how he worships Diana when he arrives in Britain. 22:58 He makes blood offerings to her and is seemingly rewarded. 23:02 So at the very worst, it presents British paganism as superstition. 23:07 But it certainly also presented as a miraculous part of Britain's origins. You can definitely see this idea and you see this reflected in so many later tellings, especially I'm thinking of modern retellings of Arthurian legend, this idea of 23:23 of a time when the old gods are fading away and being replaced by the new god, but the old gods are given a reality and a power. Elsewhere in the book, various mythic and monstrous threats from classical sources are also reflected. There are, of course, the giants we've 23:40 mentioned several times. There are also sirens that pop up. 23:44 But mostly, she points out, Britain is a place of natural wonders. in this book. Even the dragons that we've mentioned, they only really attack each other. They're witnessed and they're marveled at and they're a puzzle to unravel, but nobody 24:00 actually has to fight them. Merlin's not called upon to throw fireballs at these two dragons. It's just something wondrous that is reflected upon and then it passes away from the world. Here's another interesting thing that she points out. 24:15 Ghosts and spirits are pretty rare in the book. and they only pop up within the Christian portion of the history. 24:23 So there are no pagan ghosts, but there are Christian ghosts, so I found that interesting as well. All right, now coming back to the idea of demon lovers, incubi and succubi, it does seem, it was definitely the case that there 24:35 were already discussions and writings about incubi and succubi in the medieval world. Geoffrey here is just taking those, utilizing them, and very much helping to popularize them in his work. 24:48 And not only this work, there's a later work, one that is, at the very least, widely attributed to him, titled The Life of Merlin, which also gets into the weeds of discussing the hierarchy of spirits, angels, and demons, 25:00 and how they interact with humans. And Lawrence Mathers points out that it also ends up getting a little bit science-y by discussing how air factors into all of this, and how it affects spirits and so forth, and the planets. 25:15 But correctly discusses, to a certain degree, that air makes it possible for human ears to perceive sound. That's true. 25:25 Yeah. 25:28 And then to come back at least briefly to the century-spanning period in which the mythic Merlin was considered real, this especially seems to decline in the 18th century, as does most serious consideration of the reality of magic. Sources 25:46 continue then at this point to hold on to the prophet Merlin, to the kingmaker Merlin, the proto-scientist Merlin, but the magician Merlin tends to bleed out of serious consideration of the past. He becomes more morally complex, more human 26:04 in our own understanding of him. I don't know how much of this we'll really get into, but you get into like the the tragic trajectory of merlin merlin as a figure who doesn't stand completely apart from human temptations 26:18 and passions and is certainly susceptible to seduction by nefarious forces or forces that are at least plotting against him yeah. 26:29 And that's a big part of like the end of merlin's story at least in some tellings it's like with vivianne and all that yeah he. 26:35 Ends up like trapped in a crystal cave or in a stone or in a tree. 26:40 Yeah. 26:41 Um, you know, perhaps a fate worse than death or some sort of a, uh, an unreal dreaming, a suspended animation. Um, and you know, he eventually becomes of course a purely legendary figure, but one that still holds immense transformative cultural meaning. 26:56 And I don't know, it's interesting to think about this, these different ideas, like holding this up to with this idea of, of, um, you know, waning faith and, um, and people trying to like grasp onto things that will help them hold onto that. And then thinking too about 27:12 an age in which, you know, we're, we're, we're not going to let go of Merlin. We're going to hold onto the idea of Merlin first as a historic person. 27:20 And then finally, if nothing else, just this legendary figure, but we have to let the magic side of him go away first. 27:26 Yeah. 27:27 And indeed in some of the stories, you know, he does just sort of like pass away in, in the history of the Kings of Britain. He just straight up, leaves. 27:36 We don't know. He's like, his part in the plot is done and we don't hear anything else from him. 27:40 But there are other, other tales where Merlin eventually is like, okay, I've done my part and now I have to like fade into obscurity. And he does that. 27:48 You went across the sea to, to Valinor, the land of the, or actually, you know, the way that the Disney sword in the stone movie handles, this is pretty good, which is that Merlin can time travel. So, you know, he just pops out of time and then who knows where he is. 28:02 Yeah. I mean, he is a figure out of time. Um, not to get too ahead of ourselves, but we're going to be talking about the film Excalibur, John Borman's Excalibur and Weird House. And there's a bit in that where Merlin comes back and it's discussed that he's like a dream. 28:19 And there's also a little bit, it feels a little Star Wars-y, the sort of like, you'll make me more powerful than you can possibly imagine. And so one wonders, you know, with a figure like Merlin, once they pass out of consideration as an actual historic being, Do they 28:35 in some degree become even more powerful? Because as a purely legendary and mythic figure, they're kind of like unshackled from reality. But then I guess also perhaps a little less unbound. Who knows what form it will take? 28:48 Yeah, there's more freedom. But I would guess at least to some audiences, less authority. Because the idea that he was real and that therefore maybe he derived some of his power from God was... somehow important to people in putting those prophecies on the line. 29:05 I'm willing to guess that the name of Merlin is not invoked in Parliament much these days. I would love to see it. 29:13 Well, do you want to do another one of the greatest hits? 29:16 Yeah, let's get into some of the wonder works here. 29:18 I'm going to be referring in this section to the Merlin tradition from a medieval author named Robert de Boron. 29:26 who was a French poet writing around the year 1200. 29:29 We don't know a whole lot about de Boron, but he sort of picked up where Geoffrey of Monmouth left off. 29:35 Or I think there actually may have been another intervening author that he was working with as well. but he was retelling and expanding on the stories of of arthur and especially merlin that we have already talked about as 29:49 we talked about last time in jeffrey's pseudo history merlin just disappears from the plot after orchestrating the birth of arthur so he is not around for arthur's life at all De Boron changes that in a poem known as Merlin, 30:04 written in Old French, the language Old French. Only part of the original poem is known today, so there are these fragmentary manuscripts, I think roughly 500 lines or so are still in existence. So major parts of the poem are lost, but its contents are thought to be generally 30:24 known from a popular prose retelling known as the Prose Merlin. 30:30 which somewhat confusingly may have also been written by de Boron, but the exact authorship is still debated. It may have had multiple authors, but this prose work is thought to be based, at least in part, on de Boron's Merlin poem. 30:45 So I'm going to be referring to that prose Merlin that is based on de Boron. Now, there are a lot of notable things about de Boron's additions to the legend. 30:55 For example, he introduces the motif of the sword and the stone. Not present at all in Jeffrey's story of Arthur. 31:02 But the one scene that I really wanted to talk about today is what I'm going to call baby Merlin attorney at law. 31:08 I love it. 31:11 So Dibberon takes on the idea mentioned really only as a possibility by Jeffrey of Monmouth that Merlin's powers come from the fact that his father was not a human, but a type of demon. I kind of wonder if we overstated that a little bit in the last episode, 31:28 because we were talking a lot about his father being a demon, but I think Jeffrey just like raises that as one possible explanation. 31:35 Yeah, it's not super explicit. It's more like, hey, some people say that this could be the reason. A lot of people are saying it, but it's not explicit. 31:46 But in DeBaron, it is explicit. It's totally explicit. In fact, you get, not only was Merlin's daddy a demon- His birth is part of a whole conspiracy of devils. The story begins in hell with the devils talking about how they want to create an antichrist that will cancel out 32:04 the salvation wrought by Christ on the cross. So Christ comes down, he harrows hell. The demons are like, I don't like this. We got to get him back. So we're going to make our own Christ, our own antichrist. 32:16 So this is their idea. And in in a sort of mockery of the birth of Christ, they say, we're going to have a demon impregnate an earth woman, and that will be our antichrist. So in the story, an incubus impregnates Merlin's mother, who is described as a good 32:33 and virtuous Christian woman while she sleeps. And the text describes how during her pregnancy, she, of course, is a morally righteous, faithful Christian, and so she prays to God for help. Then the text takes a weird twist. I'm going to read a couple passages. This is from the 32:51 Nigel Bryant translation of the prose Merlin. This was published in 2001. And so Bryant translates the narration as follows, quote, God had no wish to deprive the devil of what was rightfully his. And since the devil wanted the child 33:09 to inherit his power to know all things said and done in the past, he did indeed acquire that knowledge. 33:17 So God is saying like, well, OK, the devil's wanted the baby to have this power. So I'm going to let the baby have that power. But he's not going to otherwise just let the baby go according to the devil's plan because of the goodness of Merlin's mother. God 33:32 is going to intervene. And so he also says, I'm going to give this baby a chance to work on the side of good instead of evil. So not only is he going to get the power to, quote, know all things said and done and done in the past from his demonic father, I'm going to give him the 33:49 additional divine power to see into the future. And I'm going to give I think it's implied that he sort of tampers with Merlin's moral potential and says, like, I'm going to let him choose. So the text says, quote, So it was that the child inherited knowledge of things 34:09 passed from the enemy. And in addition, Knowledge of things to come was bequeathed to him from God. It was up to him which way he inclined. If he wished, he could answer the claims of both our Lord and of the devils. For a demon had made his body, 34:27 but our Lord had given him the spirit to hear and understand. Indeed, he had given more to him than to other men, because he would certainly be needing it. 34:38 It remained to be seen which way the child would lean. 34:41 So it's a vulgar comparison, but feels very Star Wars, you know, like which side of the force. He's going to be tempted by the dark side of the force, but he could be great and powerful on either side. 34:51 But then in this case, this is, I guess, kind of an exaggeration of discussions already present in Christian understanding of the body. But here his body is explicitly a product of hell. Yeah. Like his body is dark magic. 35:08 His body is charged with devil power. Yeah. And it's only but his spirit then has been made stronger to counteract that. 35:15 Yeah. So Merlin's mother gives birth and the baby is named Merlin. She names the baby after her own father. 35:23 And of course, this this gets her into trouble with the authorities. It's very, very sexually repressive and conservative time. 35:32 And she is an unmarried woman who gives birth to a child. So she is accused falsely of sexual impropriety and she is condemned to death. Merlin, who is still an infant at this time, will not stand up for this injustice. So he begins to speak and he becomes 35:52 his mother's lawyer in court, even though he is, yes, still a baby. So he's a baby and he's her lawyer. 36:00 Amazing. 36:01 So how is baby Merlin going to get his mother off the hook? This aspect makes the story even better because he, he doesn't just like out argue the judge on the facts of the case. He gets the judge to release her by revealing that the judge himself is 36:17 of illegitimate birth because the judge's mother had a secret affair with a wicked priest. And that priest is the judge's real father. So the judge's mother cheated on her husband with this priest. The priest is the judge's father. 36:34 And so it's like the best way to win in court. 36:37 He's putting the whole system on trial. 36:39 It's a risky strategy, right? I mean, I guess they didn't have mistrials back then. 36:45 No, this is not. It's not the kind of courtroom procedure we would recognize today. So after this revelation, the judge's mother, who is there in the room? Admits it. 36:55 She's like, you got me. And the judge says, again, this is the Nigel Bryant translation quote, this child is wise indeed saying, uh, he knew his father better than I knew mine. It would be wrong to put his mother to death without doing the same to my own 37:10 in the, in the name of God and love. And so that I may clear myself of blame in the eyes of these people. Tell me who is your father. 37:18 Remember the judge is having this back and forth with a baby. So baby Merlin replies, admitting that he is the son of a devil. He doesn't try to hide it. 37:27 He says, my father was a demon. But he explains through this that his mother was blameless. You know, it wasn't her choice. She was attacked by this demon. So he says the demon was a type of demon. He gives the taxonomy of the demons. He says it was 37:42 a type of demon called a Hequibides. And I looked this up and couldn't find anything about it. So I don't know if this was a broad definition. broadly known category. 37:51 As far as I can tell, not really. But he says the Hecubites are demons that inhabit the air. And he explains that our Lord, meaning the Christian God, has, as we heard earlier, granted him knowledge of things to come, but that his demonic father, quote, bequeathed to me the 38:10 power and intelligence to know everything that has been said and done. That's how I know all about the life your mother has led. So, obviously, the image of the baby Merlin lawyer is conceptually hilarious, but I think the 38:37 scene is interesting. It reveals something interesting about the theological worldview of the author and how The theology of the time interacts with beliefs about what sort of magic was possible. 38:52 So you could have a character who is understood by the author and the intended medieval audience as morally good. 39:00 As we've talked about in the last episode, Merlin does plenty of things that a modern audience would probably quibble with being morally good. But he's supposed to be understood as good by the readers at the time. And so 39:10 he's supposed to be good and allied with the Christian church. 39:13 And yet his father's a demon. And he inherits from his father that demonic power. And it sounds like what that demonic power amounts to is omniscience when it comes to events looking backward in time. He can know all things said or done before the present moment. But the 39:34 distinction is that Merlin can only rely on the power of the Christian God to be given information about the future. 39:42 And so the story makes that distinction multiple times. And I wonder like, what's so like, why is that distinction so important that like your demon DNA can give you unlimited knowledge about all things past and present, but prophecy about the future that can only come from God? 40:00 It's interesting, isn't it? Um, you know, it certainly seems to, uh, to, to work with, you know, various other stories we've heard about, you know, people, uh, you know, seeking out the guidance of demons, at least, you know, about things in the past, 40:14 but then also sometimes about things in the future. Um, I don't know. One's tempted to sort of analyze it and think of like sort of the negative aspects of looking back on the past, that obviously like Satan would be the Lord of ruminating on past displeasures. And then 40:34 maybe the Christian God is promising something about liberation in the future, certainly in liberation of the soul, but also maybe in like escape from the shackles of the past. 40:45 I don't know. But then again, that's a very, I think, sort of modern way of looking at things. 40:50 Well, in some ways, I think it relates to the apocalyptic Jewish worldview, which very much informs the, you know, sort of the background in which the New Testament emerges. 41:00 So like the origins of Christianity, I think most historians of Christianity would agree have a lot to do with apocalyptic Judaism. And a lot of what apocalyptic Judaism is, is that Yeah, the here and now is ruled by bad forces. Like the here and now things are bad 41:17 and it is a future. There is going to be a future reconciliation in which God and the power of God sets all things right. But that is yet to come. 41:27 Yeah, it's currently the devil's world, but it won't always be the devil's world. 41:31 Right. 41:31 It's currently the invader's world. But one day we're going to be liberated and it'll be a different world then. Yeah. 41:39 Yeah. 41:40 Now, coming back to just the idea, though, of Merlin the baby, I love this in part because we see this with other mythic and religious figures from different cultures. 41:50 I'm particularly reminded of the Hindu Krishna and how you have plenty of stories, of course, about the adult Krishna, but then there are all these stories about the young baby Krishna. And he's a bit of a trickster. He's not just a stoic child with this precocious air. that 42:10 acts like an adult. He also, you know, conducts some mischief. 42:13 I don't know if we have any mischief stories regarding the baby Merlin, but it seems like the kind of thing we might well have or could have possibly existed. 42:21 But you do see this trend with different figures. The idea that, like, well, what were they like as a baby? 42:26 Let's tell those stories. What were they like as a teenager? 42:29 We have to have those stories as well. Teen Jesus, right? 42:33 Well, I mean, people do want to feel that, you know, they're... 42:36 apocryphal works, uh, telling the life of Jesus when he was a young child, at least don't appear in the new Testament, but there are stories of like, uh, you know, Jesus striking another child dead or these kind of like 42:48 mischief working baby Jesus, uh, stories or, you know, doing miracles. 42:52 I think in one, he brings some, some clay pigeons to life or something. Yeah. 42:58 Yeah. And I mean, I guess there are ideas to convey through those stories. Surely. But also, just by having a tale about someone who is extraordinary as an adult, you want to know what they were like as a baby. 43:09 They couldn't have just been a normal baby, pooping their pants and acting irrationally. They had to have had something of the saint or the savior in them, even when they were just a toddler. And so, yeah, we want to hear those stories as well. 43:26 So Merlin was Matlock at nine months old. Yeah. Yes. 43:31 Oh, man. There's a whole sitcom here somewhere. 43:36 You know, I think a lot of parents out there are probably listening and thinking, I have a young child who is something of a lawyer. Now that urge to argue for justice, it's right there in the, you know, it's not fair. 43:51 Yeah. 43:54 But in this case, Merlin's right. So you got to hand it to baby Merlin. You know, it's not just like I didn't get my way. He's like, actually, he's standing up for the right thing. You know, I compared him to Matlock, but I've actually never seen Matlock. Is 44:06 Matlock a defense attorney or what does he do? 44:08 I think he's a defense attorney. I think I actually watched some parts of Matlock episodes back in the day because it was on television. But yeah, I don't know. 44:18 I think he's a defense attorney. That would make sense, right? 44:21 Yeah. 44:22 Yeah. 44:24 I guess that'd be a weird show if he was a prosecutor. He's just putting people away. Yeah. 44:29 Now, as you were telling the story, I was concerned when the judge was like, it would be wrong for me to put her to death without putting my own mother to death. And I was like, oh, my goodness. 44:37 Oh, no. 44:37 Is that how he's going to correct things? Is that how twisted the sense of justice here is? He's like, OK, fair is fair. We're going to stone both Merlin's mom and my mom to death. And then we're going to be fair. Everything will be fair this way. 44:51 Well, I didn't make notes on it, but I think the story does end a little tragically. It goes on to say, for the judge's mother and her priest lover. 44:58 I think the priest lover throws himself into a river or something. So some bad stuff happens there, but at least Merlin's mother is released. Yeah. 45:09 You know, in general, authoring a legend covers a lot of ground. There are many different works of literature in different languages that are bound up in all of this, but In general, it's pretty dramatic. It's pretty soap opera-y. 45:22 There's a lot of who's sleeping with who and who's betraying who and so forth. If you have any familiarity with the stories of King Arthur, you know this. Camelot is ultimately a tragedy. The rise of Camelot, but the fall of Camelot. The rise of King Arthur, but the 45:38 death of King Arthur. The rise of Merlin, the death of Merlin. That's one of the reasons that it has such staying power. 45:48 Well, Rob, here's the question we're faced with. I know after this episode, we're going to have a week of vaults because we're going to be out for a week. 45:57 But do we want to come back after that? I know that'd be kind of a gap, but do we want to come back and do a little bit more Merlin after that? Or are we going to move on to something else? 46:05 I don't know. It's kind of an open question because we could come back and do something else related to Merlin. 46:10 We could come back and do a a one-shot where we talk about something else related to Arthurian legend, yeah, it's all on the table. So I guess we'll just kind of leave it open, right? 46:20 Well, I just wanted to acknowledge, like, if we are leaving it here, we have to be clear that we have not exhausted the interesting things to talk about with Merlin. 46:28 We've just, like, this is as far as we could get before the break. 46:31 Yeah, yeah, we're not going to be here next week, but that doesn't mean that we've been sealed inside an oak tree somewhere. We will return. And we'll keep the discussion going in one form or another. And even if we don't do another Merlin episode, we would love to 46:44 hear from everyone out there. Like, what are your favorite Merlin stories? Who are your favorite Merlin actors? Your favorite literary works? Which Merlin did you grow up with? And indeed, what Merlin are you imagining in your head when we 46:57 speak at them? I'm very curious how it changes over the generations as well. Our youngest listener is like, who do you think of when you think of Merlin? So, yeah, keep all of that in mind. We'd like to remind everyone out there that Stuff to Blow Your Mind is 47:11 primarily a science and culture podcast with core episodes on Tuesdays and Thursdays, short form on Wednesdays, and on Fridays we set aside most serious concerns to just talk about a weird film on Weird House Cinema. And, yeah, if 47:22 everything goes according to plan, the next episode of Weird House will be Excalibur, so there will be more Merlin discussions in there for sure. 47:29 Huge thanks, as always, to our excellent audio producer, J.J. 47:32 Posway. 47:33 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Community discussion