0:02 Welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind, a production of iHeartRadio. Hey, welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind. My name is Robert Land. 0:16 And I am Joe McCormick. And on today's episode, we're going to be kicking off an investigation of the character Merlin. Merlin, the magician of Arthurian legend fame. Rob, this was your pick. 0:29 What got you interested in Merlin? Why were you thinking about this guy? 0:32 You know, just something about the the autumnal world. You know, it just feels like the right time for Merlin to reemerge from his imprisonment. I don't know. I guess one of the things about Merlin is that he's one of 0:45 these sort of towering figures that certainly within the Western canon that you may not think about him every day. 0:52 But he's never that far from anything you're into. Part of this is like the huge cultural shadow that he casts. 1:00 The other, I think, is also the fact that in addition to this, he's public domain. So he can show up anywhere. Anybody can do a Merlin adaptation, right? Merlin can show up in any comic book at any time. 1:10 And when he does, he carries that weight. He's not like a deep cut. Like he actually brings something. It's like having Dracula show up in something, right? Yeah. 1:19 Huge. Oh, it's him energy. 1:20 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And like Dracula, Merlin, just the name Merlin, is going to summon an image in your mind. As we're talking about him now, there is undeniably some sort of shape emerging in your head. What does it look like? 1:38 Is it an old, white-bearded man in astrological robes? Or is it something different? As we'll get into, is it something like a child of prophecy? Is it a wild man of the Welsh woods? Is it the son of a demon? You know, it's in all likelihood any variation 1:55 or any merging of the different film and TV adaptation or illustration takes on what Merlin looks like. But the interesting thing is the title of the series indicates there have been many faces of Merlin over the ages, even if they've all sort of coalesced into a single universal 2:13 image that we're enjoying today. Yeah. 2:16 You know, I tend to associate, well, first of all, I tend to associate Merlin with with his animated form in the Disney sword in the stone movie, which I watched a lot when I was little. Um, so I think he's got kind of blue robes in that and 2:30 a hat with the long white beard, but also he's very funny in, in that version. Uh, also I think of Merlin as almost your, your prototype wizard, very much like Gandalf, uh, you know, with the, the, the hat and the staff. And that's probably a historical, but, uh, 2:48 he comes in right in the bullseye of the wizard archetype. 2:51 Yeah, absolutely. I think it's a very strong argument to be made that Merlin still is the leading wizard trope, uh, the kind of epitome of Western wizardry, even, um, rivaled really only by Gandalf, I would argue. Um, and, and 3:07 Gandalf to be clear, not directly based on Merlin, despite perhaps some superficial resemblances. Um, And yeah, he continues to enjoy a lot of this reach again because Merlin, unlike Gandalf, is public domain. Anybody can use him. But also just 3:23 very important, as we'll discuss, within the history of British legend and lore. We think of him as a nearly all-powerful magic user and seer who orchestrates the rise of King Arthur, the architect of Camelot in terms of its 3:40 grandeur and power and significance. And, you know, we tend to see him as dressed in outlandish astrological robes and probably prone to comedic missteps as well as acts of wonder. 3:52 You mentioned that Disney film from 1963, The Sword in the Stone. That, I think, was probably also my first impression of Merlin and probably one that's still in there somewhere anytime I think of him. Very entertaining film. Great 4:09 wizard battle. And of course, this film was based on the work of T.H. White, who lived 1906 through 1964. 4:17 His collected work, The Once and Future King. This is a highly influential work. Not only has it influenced this direct adaptation that so many of us are familiar with, but just in general was a popular retelling of Arthurian legend for 20th century audiences. 4:35 You know, it's good that you bring up how influential T.H. 4:37 White is early on, because the thing about that is it's a 20th century source. So it has no claim to being like, you know, the original Merlin or anything like that. It's very recent and yet it's still very influential in the popular understanding of the character. And I 4:53 think that illustrates something that actually goes way back into, you know, the Merlin tradition. This is a character that does not really have a fixed form that changes a lot over time. And in some ways, it would be hard to select an origin point for Merlin. Maybe the 5:09 closest you could come is a figure that we're going to talk about, the 12th century author Geoffrey of Monmouth. 5:16 But even Geoffrey is creating his Merlin in some sense out of fabrications, but then also out of combining elements from existing characters in folklore and literature. 5:27 Yeah. Yeah. This is, this is an important point. Yeah. That, um, this is often the case with myth and legend, you know, like sometimes there'll be a very important, uh, early text and, and there, there are those here. And then there are 5:39 of course cases where someone comes along and they, they retell everything and that becomes kind of like the canonical source. Um, and it, it is important to stress here as well is that just as there's no true historical Arthur, uh, 5:53 King Arthur, uh, there was also no true historical Merlin. Um, as we'll discuss, this did not stop people from believing Merlin to be a real historical person from roughly the 12th through 16th centuries. As real as King Arthur, as 6:09 real as William the Conqueror, as real as Jesus and all the saints and whoever happens to be the current king. 6:15 As Anne Lawrence Mathers points out in her book, The True History of Merlin the Magician, one of my main sources that I'll keep coming back to, for nearly five centuries, he was presented as Among other things, historical proof of magic. 6:30 And we'll get more into that in part two. But this is just another, I think, fascinating wrinkle about this figure is that, yeah, there have been so many faces to him. And sometimes that face was just considered, oh, yeah, yeah, he was real. He's part of our history. 6:45 Yeah, that is a really good point, Rob. And this is a big thing that, as you said, Anne Lawrence Mathers focuses on in this book. You recommended this book and I started reading it too. So a big focus is like separating these different strands of the understanding of Merlin. 7:00 Like in one sense, he is an explicitly fictional character treated as such by some of these later authors. But for a long time, people just thought Merlin was real, even though he was not. There is no historical Merlin, at least not in the sense, you know, you can 7:15 always make the case, well, maybe there was some character that inspired. But in no real sense was there a historical Merlin. And yet for a long time, people thought there was. 7:25 Yeah, yeah. So I'm looking forward to getting back into that. 7:28 But yeah, there's so many additional wrinkles to consider. Anne Lawrence Mathers points out that the version of Merlin that we have today, like the mainstream version, the T.H. White version, is it's essentially been more or less the same with 7:44 variation for for centuries. But you look back and you find like if you go back far enough, you find very little comedy with Merlin. Like we think of the T.H. 7:55 White version and we think of the Disney version. And we tend to think of him as maybe a little bit bumbling, a little bit comedic, but also capable of wonder. 8:05 But many of the older sources, like he is a figure of terrifying power, like he is someone to be afraid of to a very large degree. And I was curious, I was like, well, when did we first start injecting or, you know, as far back as we can tell, when 8:20 did we start injecting comedy into our Merlin narratives? And it looks like at least as early as 1622, there was a comedy titled The Birth of Merlin. And that's maybe that seems to be a key early surviving account. 8:34 of a humorous Merlin depiction. But I don't know, not to say that Merlin can't be funny and terrifying. I think sometimes different works manage to walk that line. But yeah, definitely you look back in these older works and he is a terrifying figure. 8:54 Some of the earliest sources are I think, to 21st century readers unintentionally funny. 8:59 Yes, definitely. There's that. Yes. Yeah. 9:02 And we'll talk about some things in that vein in just a minute. In fact, are you ready to do some greatest hits? 9:08 Yeah, let's let's jump into the greatest hits. It's good to be reminded of exactly who we're dealing with before we get back into like the root of of the legend. 9:16 All right. So I'm not going to tell the entire story of Merlin right here. I'm not even going to try to do that. Instead, I figured, Throughout this series, it would be good to do this thing called Merlin the Magician's Greatest Hits, where each time we just zoom 9:29 in on a few of Merlin's great feats of magic and notable deeds. So we're going to do two big ones here. Caveat, of course, that there are, as we were just talking about, many different presentations of Merlin. And we will continue to explore these differences as we go on, 9:46 but very quickly... You've got like the Welsh character Myrddin, usually spelled M-Y-R-D-D-I-N, who is a sort of wild man of the woods turned prophet. And then you also have the Myrddin. of Arthurian legend, which is basically a synthetic 10:03 creation of a 12th century author named Geoffrey of Monmouth, which combines stuff from pre-existing Welsh and British characters like the Merthyn I just mentioned, but also a character named Ambrosius, who's kind of a boy prophet character. And then also, 10:21 Jeffrey just seemed... The Jeffrey version has original stuff that Jeffrey made up. And then you've got the rationalized, pseudo-historical character of later chroniclers. People would be writing about Merlin thinking he was a real historical figure. And then you 10:36 also have the Merlin of openly fictional storytelling, like the French Arthurian romances and everything that would follow down the pages. 10:45 So. 10:46 we should always keep in mind the differences between these characters. 10:49 In some cases, they're huge differences to the point where it's reasonable to ask if they should be thought of as the same character at all, especially with these earlier Welsh and British traditions from before Geoffrey. But putting that 11:02 aside for a minute and lumping all the Merlins together into a kind of all Merlin, I think we should look at a few of the chart toppers. And the ones I want to look at are Prophecy and Stonehenge. 11:14 So one of the oldest and most important traditions of Merlin's power is foreknowledge and the eye of prophecy. He is depicted as a man who could see into the future and who could discern the meaning of omens. There are lots of prophecies attributed to Merlin, but to give 11:35 you a flavor, one of the most famous is the story of Vortigern's Tower and the Vision of the Red Dragon and the White. This is told in multiple sources, but I'm going to focus on the telling by Geoffrey of Monmouth. So in this story, Vortigern, the King of 11:52 the Britons, witnesses two dragons emerge from a pool that has been drained of its water. The backstory is that he has the pool drained because it keeps making a tower fall over. So he's, okay, we drain the water out and then coming out of the pool, There are 12:11 two dragons, one red and one white. The dragons start to fight. They tear into each other, with the white dragon first gaining the upper hand and driving the red dragon back. And then the red dragon counterattacks, and it prevails for a time. And we're told that they fight 12:27 on bitterly. And then Vortigern, the king, orders the prophet Merlin to tell him what the battle between the dragons means. 12:36 So Merlin begins to weep and he goes into a trance and he explains that the red dragon symbolizes the Celtic Britons, while the white dragon represents the Saxons, the Anglo-Saxons. 12:50 And the fight shows that the Saxons who have been invited over to Britain are going to conquer and subjugate the native Britons, such that, according to the translation by Lewis Thorpe, quote, the mountains and valleys shall be leveled. 13:05 And the streams in its valleys shall run with blood. 13:09 And then it goes on to mention the bad things the Saxons are going to do. Apart from just leveling the topography, apparently they're going to destroy all the churches. 13:17 There's a big emphasis in the story that the Saxons are desecrating the Christian tradition. So they're going to destroy all the churches and they're going to ruin the country's religion. 13:28 But then, just like the Red Dragon... it says that the Britons are going to come back and they will overthrow their oppressors and, quote, the boar of Cornwall shall bring relief from these invaders, for it will trample their 13:42 necks beneath its feet. And yes, that boar was Albert Einstein. 13:47 In a way, that boar is going to be King Arthur, or is commonly interpreted as King Arthur. 13:53 Yeah, and we'll return to the importance of Geoffrey of Monmouth's treatment of this story here in just a bit. 14:01 Just for flavor, I wanted to mention a random smattering of Merlin's other prophecies about the future history of Britain. 14:08 I found a good collection of these on a blog post on medievalist.net by an author named Catherine Walton. So Walton has pulled these in translation. 14:18 Here's one. 14:19 The lion of justice shall come next, and at its roar the towers of Gaul shall shake and the island dragons tremble. In the days of this lion, gold shall be squeezed from the lily flower and the nettle and silver shall flow from the hoof of the lowing cattle. 14:37 So that's evocative. Then we get another one. This one is in the days of the fox, a snake shall be born and this will bring death to human beings. 14:47 It will encircle London with its long tail and devour all those who pass by. And I really like this next one. the hedgehog will hide its apples inside Winchester and will construct hidden passages in the earth. Seems to 15:03 be something mischievous about that one. The hedgehog's going to hide its apples and make tunnels or hidden passages. So it is worth noting that the Merlin tradition tells that he gave many prophecies about the future, both specified and unspecified. 15:21 So some accounts of Merlin say directly quote a bunch of oracles of the future, like the ones I just read. 15:27 And then they also include lines like, and he gave many other prophecies and the people were amazed. So he predicted many other things and we are not told what those other predictions are, which of course is a very tempting opportunity for later writers to come in and add 15:46 further specified predictions. So this opened door about other unspecified predictions as well as the vague symbolic predictions about foxes and lions and snakes and stuff. These things have made Merlin a very popular ex post facto mouthpiece for whatever 16:06 later authors wanted to express with the authority of a wizard behind them. So people in later centuries who wanted to advance political or religious propaganda or other tendentious points of view could either attribute new prophecies to Merlin, like, 16:24 oh yeah, this is one of those ones Jeffrey didn't spell out, or interpret the existing prophecies that are specified in the text in ways that are favorable to their cause. Like, you see, I am the lion of justice foretold by Merlin, 16:38 therefore you should back my claim to the throne. So of all of Merlin's supernatural deeds, I would say prophecy is is the most important and the most defining. Early on, Merlin, you could say, is more prophet than magician. 16:55 Absolutely. And the sole reason that Geoffrey of Monmouth is assembling him and presenting him in his history is because of the prophecy powers. And he He has this role that is ultimately as important a prophet as anything in 17:15 the Old Testament to the British people, again, for centuries. So, yeah, really prophet first, everything else comes later. Yeah. 17:25 But again, because of all this, the vagueness in the prophecies and the unspecified prophecies, there's just all this room to use Merlin to your advantage, you know, to appeal to Merlin and say, aha, this prophecy serves my agenda. 17:38 Yeah. And a vague prophecy is always going to have the most staying power. Yeah. You get too specific and then, well, then it's wrong. Or you're going to have to really do a lot of gymnastics to make it work again. Yeah. 17:51 It's like Nostradamus. 17:52 Yeah. 17:53 All those vague things. It makes me think of that scene in The Sopranos. You know, Quasimodo predicted this. Yeah. 18:10 So prophecy may be Merlin's most important and defining power, especially in these early stories. But it is not his only feat of strength, not his only great work of wonder. 18:22 Another one I want to talk about is Stonehenge. So this will be another story coming from the Geoffrey of Monmouth telling. Merlin apparently conceptualized and oversaw the construction of of Stonehenge, or based on the details of the story, 18:40 you might better characterize it as he oversaw the theft of Stonehenge. So the story goes like this, and the quotes I'm going to read here are coming from the 1906 edition edited by J.H. Iles. So in the story, before the time of King Arthur, Arthur's uncle, Aurelius, has 19:00 defeated the Saxon invaders and Aurelius restores Britain to its former glory. He puts the churches back up and everything's good now. At the beginning of this episode, he wants to build a monument in Salisbury and dedicate it to the memory of a host of British nobles who were 19:19 viciously murdered by the now defeated Saxon chieftain Hengist. The situation was Hengist invited them to a peace conference under false pretenses, and then had all of his soldiers hide weapons in their clothes. Then they pulled out the weapons 19:34 and murdered these unarmed British leaders. So they're all dead now, and Aurelius is mourning the dead nobles and wants a monument to their memory. So Aurelius summons Merlin. Merlin is known as the Prophet of Vortigern, and he wants advice 19:49 on this project. Like, what should I do to build a monument? Actually, the first thing he does when Merlin arrives is he says, like, hey, Merlin, do some prophecies for me. You know, like, entertain me. And Merlin scolds him here, scolds the king, saying it is wrong to 20:04 prophesy for entertainment. He can only do it when it's really important, when there is the greatest necessity. And he says he fears that the spirit that tells him the future will fall silent if he speaks prophecy in vain. So, like, you've got to be careful not to use it wrong. 20:21 But moving on to the business at hand, Aurelius asks Merlin about this monument. Hey, how can we build a really good monument? And Merlin says, if what you want is a really good monument, what you have to do is go to a mountain in Ireland called Lannister. Kilaraus. 20:36 I hope I'm saying that right. It's K-I-L-L-A-R-A-U-S. Kilaraus. And you have to go to this mountain because on that mountain there lies a ring of stones known as the Giant's Dance, made, quote, of a vast magnitude and wonderful quality. 20:53 The stones are, of course, huge stones, wonderful quality stones. 20:58 And Merlin says if you bring those stones over here and make your monument out of them, they will stand forever. 21:05 At this point, Aurelius laughs at Merlin and he says, we do have stones here in Britain. Why would we need to go to Ireland for stones? And Merlin says, these are really good stones. Quote, they are mystical stones and of a medicinal virtue. The giants of old brought 21:21 them from the farthest coast of Africa and placed them in Ireland while they inhabited that country. Their design in this was to make baths in them when they should be taken with any illness. For their method was to wash the stones and put their sick into the water, 21:38 which infallibly cured them. With the like success, they cured wounds also, adding only the application of some herbs. There is not a stone there which has not some healing virtue. 21:49 So I'd never heard that before. But Merlin's saying the stones that are not yet Stonehenge, they're over here in Ireland right now, brought from Africa by giants, put there by giants, and the giants use them as medicine. 22:03 Yeah. And at first I thought the argument here was that the giants were making like a big hot tub. 22:08 Yeah. 22:08 But there's something a little more complicated going on with the treatment of their sickness and all. Yeah. 22:15 It sounds like they're saying they put the stones into the bath or they wash the stones with water and then the water maybe helps. 22:22 Yeah. Yeah. And I don't know if by they're sick they mean illness or like. Vomit. Yeah. 22:28 I think I think that means like the ill giants. 22:31 OK. All right. But they're sick. Not like I guess I'm thinking in terms of like British slang for vomit. Yeah. 22:37 Probably not that. 22:38 And bits of sick. Yeah. 22:39 Yeah. 22:40 So Merlin convinces Aurelius that we must steal these stones from the Irish and we've got to take an army because the Irish might fight back and we have to defeat them in order to take the stones home. So the king appoints his brother, Uther Pendragon, and Merlin himself 22:57 to head up the expedition. They take an army of 15,000 men to the mountain in Ireland. At that time, we're told the king in Ireland was a brave youth named Gilomanius. And when he heard the Britons were coming for his stones, he made jest of them, made jest 23:12 of the British, saying, quote, No wonder a cowardly race of people were able to make so great a devastation in the island of Britain. When the Britons are such brutes and fools. So I think there he's saying, like, no wonder they got beaten by the Saxons, even though 23:26 the Saxons are wimps. Because, you know, they're just so confused. 23:31 They're trying to take my stones. Quote, was ever the like folly heard of? What are the stones of Ireland better than those of Britain that our kingdom must be put to this disturbance for them? I think making a reasonable point. But again, Merlin says, no, these are the 23:46 best stones. You've got to get these stones. So Gilimanius raises his own army to fight the British and prevent the theft of the giant's dance. Uther attacks, routes the Irish, and forces Gilimanius to run away. So the British go 24:00 to the mountain, Killeraus, and they find the giant's dance, and all the warriors stare at the stones in amazement. 24:06 And then Merlin is like, okay, this will be funny. 24:08 Go ahead, try and take down the stones. Quote, at this word, they all set to their engines with one accord and attempted the removing of the giant's dance. Some prepared cables, others small ropes, others ladders for the work, but all to no purpose. Merlin laughed now at their 24:25 vain efforts and then began his own contrivances. When he had placed in order the engines that were necessary, he took down the stones with an incredible facility and gave directions for carrying them to the ships and placing them therein. 24:42 So only Merlin knows how to take down the stones by some special method. which you would be tempted to assume is magical in nature because Merlin's a magician, right? 24:53 But the way I read this text, it sounds like Jeffrey is saying Merlin had special mechanical or engineering knowledge that would make taking down and transporting these huge rocks possible. 25:06 So this raises the question, what kind of wizard is Merlin? 25:10 Is there some element of not fantasy, but science fiction to him? 25:14 Yeah, this is an important point because I think of the many faces of Merlin. One is that of a kind of proto-scientist. Part of it is in the fact that, yes, Merlin seems to know his way around the unseen world, but he is also a kingmaker in this world. He's 25:32 a manipulator of politics and he's an empire builder in this world and therefore has natural command of natural forces as well as unnatural command. And yeah, this becomes, I think, an important part of his legacy in different tellings. And 25:49 certainly by the time you reach the Elizabethan era and you have a figure like John Dee, who is kind of held up at the time and in retrospect is kind of a real world Merlin, someone who has occult interests and maybe even supposed magical powers, but is also 26:07 very much engaged in politics and empire buildings. and in proto-scientific understanding of the world. 26:15 Yeah, I think that's a great point. And it kind of highlights how really before the Enlightenment, there was much less of a mental distinction between practical scientific engineering and mechanical knowledge and magical or astrological knowledge. I mean, they 26:34 were all just kind of knowledge about the world. So you were much more likely before the Enlightenment to have people thinking that these are both equally valid things to explore. Right, yeah. 26:45 We see this, of course, in alchemy, where you have basically scientific principles and a chemical understanding limited of the natural world combined with all of these additional magical and occultist ideas. And it's all just kind of like, all 27:01 kind of reaching for the same thing, but without this clear division that we think about today. 27:05 Anyway, coming back to the story, Merlin and company bring the stones by ship back to a plane in Britain where Aurelius wants the monument. And after Aurelius takes care of some affairs of church and state, they have the stones put up. It says in the same arrangement as 27:22 they were found at the mountain in Ireland, the mountain of Killer House, quote, and thereby gave a manifest proof of the prevalence of art above strength. Art there meaning strength. 27:33 something more like skill or knowledge. So such showing that, uh, skill or knowledge is more powerful than brute strength. 27:41 Yeah. Like, like the artful Dodger. It's not that he knows how to paint. Yeah. 27:46 Uh, so of course we should note that this is not in any way, the real origin of Stonehenge, uh, characters like Merlin and Uther Pendragon are fictional of course, but if they had lived, uh, the story would place 27:59 them in legendary history sometime in like the fifth century, uh, Meanwhile, we know from all kinds of physical evidence that Stonehenge is much, much older than that. It was built in stages, so not all at once, but in stages over more 28:14 than a thousand years beginning in the Neolithic period, so roughly 3000 BCE. And the largest stones were put in place sometime around 2500 BCE, so thousands of years before this Merlin story would have taken place. On the other hand, 28:30 one thing the real Stonehenge does have in common with this fictional history is that the huge rocks, the megaliths, did have to travel across great distances. We know that the blue stones of Stonehenge were transported all the way 28:44 from not Ireland, but from Wales. And this would have been a massive and incredibly costly effort with the technology available at the time. But As far as we know, done without magic, done with just, you know, human strength 28:58 and cleverness and ingenuity. People using tools like ropes and maybe wooden rollers and sledges and probably floating the stones for certain parts of the journey. So, yeah, just done by cleverness and the work of human hands. 29:14 Yeah, pretty amazing. And, of course, Stonehenge itself is an amazing site. If you ever get the chance to see it, definitely check it out. don't be tempted to skip it just because it feels too touristy. I mean, it is touristy. 29:26 A lot of people come to see it, but its importance is much deeper than that. It's worth experiencing. 29:33 It's very cool. But as a story convention, I want to come back to this ambiguity about how to take Merlin's engines for moving the stones. So again, he's often described as a wizard or magician, but it seems like the story is implying his occult knowledge is of a 29:51 physical nature about mechanics and engineering and And it does remind me of these other works you can read from the Middle Ages in which some writers compare the engineering feats of the past, like the engineering and architecture feats 30:06 of the Roman Empire, to a kind of sorcery or to the work of superhuman creatures. One example is the old English poem The Ruin. This is by an unknown author. 30:16 It's preserved in a 10th century manuscript, I think called the Exeter Manuscript or something like that. I believe this poem was a favorite of J.R.R. Tolkien's, but it begins with the lines describing a Roman-era ruin that is often 30:30 thought to be somewhere in the ruins of Bath. Quote, This masonry is wondrous. Fates broke it. Courtyard pavements were smashed. 30:39 The work of giants is decaying. And to be clear, I think the work of giants here is a literary device. 30:46 It's not a claim by the poet that these buildings in Roman Britain were destroyed. literally built by magical creatures. 30:54 But you can see what the author is getting at with this sense of awe at what a past civilization could build and how to the author, it seems so far away as to be separated by a kind of magical barrier. However, we know that engineering and architectural texts 31:10 and knowledge from the Roman world were not completely lost in the past dark age thinking used to assume, you know, a lot of these texts and some of this knowledge did survive, though they were not widely accessible. But privileged, 31:27 educated people with access to the right reading material would realize that there were things you could do. There are engines and artifices constructible by human hands that can simulate the work of giants and do things that seem magical. 31:42 All you need is the knowledge of how to do it. 31:45 And this is what Jeffrey again calls the prevalence of art over strength. So, of course, Jeffrey's Merlin is magical. 31:52 He's said to be the son of a demon and he sees the future. But maybe he is also special because he has this practical scientific and mechanical knowledge that is mostly unknown to his contemporaries. And you could likely think of as something coming from civilizations past. So I 32:10 was thinking of him as like a man out of time in both directions. He sees the future. But he also knows the wisdom of the ancients. 32:18 And it makes sense that this is the sort of figure that would be championed by a learned, literate cleric like Geoffrey of Monmouth. 32:27 Yeah, so that is interesting. But then also, I just wanted to mention one last time how funny it is to me that Merlin suggests that Britain's national monument here should be straight up stolen from another nation. It seems kind of funny on its face. Like, I guess this 32:43 did not seem obviously funny to readers at the time. 32:46 Yeah, I don't know, kind of prophetic in its own way, right? 32:49 Well, yeah, but I don't know. Like, that just seems like so obviously full of irony that it's hard to imagine it would not have been noticeable as funny even to medieval readers. 33:00 Wow. All right, well, let's get a little more into Geoffrey of Monmouth here. I want to do a quick reminder about the timeline here, because this is important. We basically go from prehistoric Britain to Roman Britain, and then 33:24 to what's called sub-Roman Britain, and then to Anglo-Saxon Britain, and then to Norman Britain. And Norman Britain is where we find ourselves in this discussion. And again, Merlin first emerges as a fictional character in the 12th century, as 33:40 a creation of this Welsh Christian cleric, Geoffrey of Monmouth, who lived 1095 through 1155 in the history of the Kings of Britain. And this is a very important work. 33:51 We're not gonna be able to do like real justice to just how important it was, but we're gonna try and just hit the basics here. This work served as a kind of cultural glue for a time of division and great uncertainty for the British a time known as 34:08 the Anarchy, a civil war between the English and Normans following the death of Henry I's son, William. This would be the grandson of William the Conqueror, and it basically fought between the supporters of two different cousins. And it's 34:23 a time of great uncertainty in general for the Anglo-Norman aristocracy, and something is needed other than the Anglo-Saxon past to sort of ground the sense of British identity. There's also like, you know, there's filling in a gap that seems to 34:39 be missing in the written histories as well. There are a lot of ins and outs here. I think it's important to think of this work, again, not as what we would think of today as like a true history, but as kind of a pseudo history, a sort of 34:53 a mythic history, a legendary history that is serving a very important cultural and political purpose at the time. 35:01 Yeah. So it is something meant to be taken as true history, but involves a lot of synthesizing of fictional sources and straight-up new fabrication. Yeah, yeah. 35:14 And so that's where Jeffreys' The History of the Kings of Britain comes in. Beginning in the aftermath of the Trojan War with Brutus of Troy, the entirely fabricated founder of Britain, though pre-existing from the 9th century history of 35:29 the Britons by Welsh monk Nemeus. So this was not a creation of Jeffreys, but one that he's employing again here. 35:37 There's absolutely no evidence that this was real either, that this was a real person. But this is an idea that served to root British identity in antiquity. And this sort of thing, I think, is pretty common throughout certainly the medieval world. 35:52 Of course, I can't be sure that this is the reason Geoffrey is doing this, but it seems to me to be establishing clear parallels with classical literature, namely the Aeneid. So, of course, in the Aeneid, you have the founding of Rome by people who from Troy. They come from Troy 36:07 and become the, you know, the lineage that founds Rome. 36:09 And so you get a similar thing here. It's like, well, we're kind of like Rome, you know, Britain was also founded by people coming from Troy. 36:15 Yeah. 36:16 Yeah. 36:16 And so he did, he discusses how Brutus arrives in the British Isles, defeats the primordial giants that are living there at the time, and then establishes a rule that eventually shatters into different kingdoms. 36:28 Hmm. 36:30 And from here, the history goes in a number of different directions. So we get the history of the mythical King Lear. This is very much the King Lear that Shakespeare would later retell. And I think many of us know mostly from the works of Shakespeare now. He eventually 36:45 reaches the Roman era. And then in book seven, the text turns to the prophecies of Merlin before getting into the wars of Uther Pendragon, his son Arthur, the conquest of Northern Europe, the defeat of resurgent Roman forces, the 37:00 rise of the evil nephew Mordred, and the resulting battle that ends in Mordred's death and Arthur's mortal wounding. And of course, it's off to Avalon at that point. And then this history ends in the decline and final loss of supreme British rule to the Anglo-Saxons in the 7th 37:16 century CE, thus setting up the legitimization of Norman British rule as a kind of restoration, which of course comes hot and heavy in 1066 AD. We even get an angelic prophecy suggesting that this is the case. So again, a lot of this work is about also pointing out like, okay, 37:36 you know that whole deal with the Saxons? That was an interruption. They were tearing down churches. It was a bad time. But the Normans, in their conquest, they were able to restore things. And this is a legitimization of what they are and what they are doing. 37:54 So, This Merlin is not just used by later authors looking back for their own rhetorical purposes, but even in Jeffrey's original usage, this seems to be trying to make political and religious points. 38:09 Yes, yes, I believe so. And it's interesting when you get into the prophecies of Merlin section, Jeffrey wrote and distributed a pamphlet ahead of the history. So it actually like slightly predates the publication of the history. according to him, 38:23 due to popular demand. He's talking about how just people were crazy for it. And it seems- People do love prophecy. 38:30 People do love prophecies- Still. Yeah, today as ever, and at the time they were very popular. Lawrence Mathers points out that the prophecies of Merlin were perhaps more popular than the histories themselves. And if this was the case, 38:45 it's saying something given the high number of surviving copies of the history. which suggests that it had a very high readership or at least ownership at the time. So the idea that the prophecies of Merlin were even more popular, 39:01 even more widespread, that's saying something. Anyway, we get this account. 39:07 We've already touched on some of this. But yeah, after the collapse of Roman Britain, we have this tyrant, Vortigern, and he's forced to flee into Wales, tries to build this stronghold. Tower keeps collapsing. What's going on here? Some 39:20 sort of foundation issue. some sort of dragons running about. 39:25 He asked his magicians, what can I do? And they're like, well, you probably need a foundation sacrifice. We need a, uh, the blood of a boy with no father, no human father. 39:33 And so they eventually hear about this boy with no human father in Southeast Wales. They collect this strange boy. And, um, and this is of course going to be, uh, our, our Merlin character, right? But not the Merlin with the long white beard that we know of now, but this boy, 39:52 this perhaps scared boy even of prophecy. We don't even know that he's prophetic yet, but he has some sort of strange history. It's suggested that his father was perhaps not human at all, but in fact an incubus, a demon that had seduced his mortal mother. And therefore, by 40:12 his very parentage, is a being with a foot in both worlds. 40:17 There's an interesting point that Lawrence Mathers mentions, I think this is in the introduction to the book, where she says the fact that Merlin had a demonic father allows him to, at the same time, sort of be a Christian, be a character understood by the audience as good, but 40:37 to also have access to demonic powers, like these powers of foresight and stuff that people would often assume you had to do something wicked in order to get that knowledge. 40:48 Like you had to consult a demon, but he maybe doesn't have to consult a demon. He's got more intrinsic powers because of his parentage. 40:56 Yeah, and this is kind of a complicated, like theologically complicated topic, right? And she gets into this in the book where he is in many ways an antichrist. We have this child that has no human father, much like Jesus Christ. except his father is not God, but a 41:14 seductive demon. And therefore his powers would seem to come from hell, but yet he's using them for good, or at least the good of the British people. And how do you couch that? And how do you interpret that? 41:27 And how do you weigh that out, given the theology and the demonology of the time? Because there were, as we've discussed a little bit on the show before, there were very strict ideas, according to certain theologians, governing exactly 41:41 what demons were, what they could be, what powers they definitely had, and what powers they absolutely did not have. 41:48 And I would say, in general, they had more powers than we tend to attribute them today. But yeah, there was discussion about exactly how Merlin's alleged powers factored into all of this. So at any rate, as we discussed earlier, 42:04 basically the strange boy manifests these powers of prophecy. and tells the tyrant what this means. The red dragon represents the Britons, the white dragons, the Saxons. The boy's life is spared. He's not actually sacrificed as a foundation sacrifice 42:21 for this tower. Now, an interesting point here that Lawrence Mathers raises, again, this gets into just how important Merlin was and the degree to which he was accepted as being a real person. She points out that the 12th 42:38 century theologian, this was William of Newborough, famous critic of Geoffrey of Monmouth, accused him of just fabricating all sorts of stuff in his history, which, to be clear, he did. 42:49 Despite all of this, she points out that he was largely accepting of the character Merlin. He basically just had a problem with, we touched on this already, the idea of how did these demon-derived powers work and what sort 43:02 of theological objections would there be to them working. He also had some issues with the accuracy of some of the prophecies. But as the author points out here, Jeffrey essentially establishes Merlin as a prophet on par with anything 43:16 in the Holy Bible, and the questions of fabrication are not directly leveled at the figure of Merlin. 43:24 That's funny. So William is on the right track with his criticism, but does not go nearly far enough. 43:30 Right, right. Again, just suggest the power and staying power of Merlin as a figure in British lore and British identity. Now, worth stressing that in Geoffrey of Monmouth's work, Merlin orchestrates the birth of King Arthur through magic and his tutelage 43:49 of Uther Pendragon. But he then exits the histories and never meets Arthur at all. So this idea that Merlin is like an adult Merlin friend, teacher, or advisor to even a child Arthur, much less an adult Arthur. This all comes much later in medieval romance and so forth. 44:11 Certainly we get the construction of Stonehenge and everything, but yeah, he's gone before Arthur even shows up. So this is all stuff that's going to be added much later on. 44:21 That's interesting. Even the early stuff in Arthur's life, like in Geoffrey, Merlin doesn't orchestrate the sword and the stone or anything like that. 44:31 Yeah, that's right. I mean, maybe there's some argument to be made that he has set things in motion, so he is responsible, but he's not peeking around in the woods in the background or anything like that. 44:40 One funny thing I remember in Lawrence Mathers mentioning in her book is that there, of course, was no widely accepted tomb or grave of Merlin like there were for some of these other characters even some of these fictional characters but that that wasn't really a huge obstacle to 45:00 believing him to be a historical figure because again he's got these magic powers maybe he just disappeared like or maybe he maybe he still exists somehow because he has this magical aura around him there is not as much need for the normal kinds of proofs you would have. 45:15 Yeah, yeah. Again, he always had a foot in the other world, in the unseen world, and therefore it makes sense that he could vanish into it and come back out of it. And that's exactly the sort of stories that are told later on, and we'll get into some 45:29 of those. All right, well, at this point, I think we're going to break and we're going to come back. 45:34 In the next episode, we're going to, for starters, get into the Welsh traditions that Geoffrey of Monmouth latched onto and sort of recreated in his work. So we will get into the Welsh Merlin character in that episode. We'll 45:51 talk about some other Merlin-related topics, other faces of Merlin. And, oh, also worth noting that the current plan, plans are always subject to change, but this coming Weird House Cinema is going to be on the film Excalibur. So we'll get 46:08 to discuss that. In that, at least to a limited degree, we'll talk about its depiction of Merlin and how it matches up with these different trends and these different faces of the famous magician. 46:18 I've never seen it before. I'm very excited to watch it for the first time. And I've got my eclipse glasses to wear while we put it on. 46:26 Excellent. Yeah, it's loaded with Merlin. Merlin is one of the things that does best. All right, just a reminder to everyone that Stuff to Blow Your Mind is primarily a science and culture podcast with four episodes on Tuesdays 46:37 and Thursdays, short-form episode on Wednesday, and then on Fridays we set aside most serious concerns and just talk about a weird film on Weird House Cinema. Wherever you are listening to us or if you are watching us on Netflix, 46:48 we just ask that you rate, review, subscribe, click a couple of thumbs up, ask to be reminded about new episodes on Netflix, give us some stars and a nice review elsewhere. These things help keep the show alive. 47:01 Huge thanks, as always, to our excellent audio producer, J.J. Posway. 47:05 If you would like to get in touch with us with feedback on this episode or any other, to suggest a topic for the future, or just to say hi, you can email us at contact at stufftoblowyourmind.com. 47:14 Thank you. 47:22 Stuff to Blow Your Mind is a production of iHeartRadio. 47:25 For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app. Apple Podcasts are wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Community discussion