0:02 Welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind, a production of iHeartRadio. 0:12 Hey, welcome to Stuff to Blow Your Mind. My name is Robert Lamb. 0:16 And I am Joe McCormick. And we're back with the second part of our discussion about this year's Ig Nobel Prizes. 0:23 If you're not familiar, the IgnoBells are given out once every year by a scientific humor magazine called the Annals of Improbable Research. You can read more about them at improbable.com. 0:34 And the mission statement of these prizes is to, quote, honor achievements that first make people laugh and then make them think. We at Stuff to Blow Your Mind are not affiliated with the IgnoBells in any way, but we usually give them some coverage every year. So most years 0:50 we release an episode or two covering some of the winners. 0:53 The timing's usually awkward for us because they typically have the prize ceremony in September. Around the same time, we're getting ready for our big slate of Halloween season episodes. 1:04 So like most years, this year we're only getting around to talking about the eggs now that we are into November. 1:11 But in the last episode, we already covered the 2026 Technology Prize, which was awarded for research into something called necroprinting. 1:19 Yeah. 1:20 A very, very interesting concept. A concept for using parts of dead mosquitoes as a mechanism in microscale 3D printing. 1:28 That's pretty sick. We talked about the Biomechanics Prize, which investigated the phenomenon of mouth-to-mouth kissing across different non-human animal species. 1:39 And it came up with a truly beautiful, moving scientific definition of kissing, which was, quote, non-agonistic interactions involving directed intraspecific oral-oral contact with some movement of the lips-slash-mouth parts and no food transfer. And finally, last time we talked 2:00 about the 2026 Chemistry Prize, which was given to researchers who looked into the nutritional value of cockroach milk. So we're back today to talk about more. And Rob, if you don't mind, I want to kick things off here with a very brief look at this year's Ig Nobel 2:15 Prize in Medicine. 2:17 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Let's get into this one, because this one, as we were chatting about before we recorded, is news you can use. 2:24 That's right. It has some advice for how to manage your body fluids correctly. So this was awarded posthumously to a Japanese medical doctor and researcher in the field of respiratory physiology named named Tokuji Uno. Uno was a professor 2:41 at Asahikawa Medical University in Hokkaido, and he passed away in 2022. But the paper that earned him this award was from all the way back in 1977. So this is one of those deep cuts that they pull out of the archives to give some recognition to. And the 2:58 paper was called, are you ready for this? How to Blow the Nose, an Aerodynamic Study of the Nose Blowing. 3:06 So do we need to be told how to blow our noses? Yes, we do. Just because you've done something a lot of times doesn't mean you're doing it the best possible way. 3:16 Yeah, this is one of those things I think about more and more in part. I think I thought about it more and more after I became a parent. But, you know, this is one of those things you learn as a kid by parents who you eventually learn had 3:29 a lot on their plate and maybe didn't have time to walk you through absolutely everything. So This is exactly the sort of thing you may be doing wrong because you've just been doing it without thinking about it. 3:41 Did you ever have to deal with a snot sucker or as it's called in our house, the snot snucker? 3:50 Yes. 3:51 Basically a machine that blows the child's nose for them. 3:53 Oh, it's a machine? 3:55 Well, it's a little like, it's a little squeezy. 3:57 Oh, okay. Squeezy, I know. 3:58 It's a very simple machine, a little squeezy, simple machine. 4:01 I was imagining there was some sort of like full blown device that you have to charge at night. And maybe there is, but yes, the squeezy I'm familiar with. 4:09 Okay. 4:10 Yeah. 4:11 For children who are not yet able or willing to blow noses of their own accord. Or I guess for adults, you know, whoever whoever cannot or will not blow their nose. 4:21 Yeah. After a certain point, it's no longer socially acceptable to ask a person of a certain age. Hey, do you need to blow that nose? Do you need a tissue? 4:29 I mean, I guess you can still ask if they need a tissue, but generally you're not allowed to really critique someone's technique. 4:36 Okay, so this article, the original was in Japanese, but I found a couple of write-ups, one in the Japan Times from September of this year by Spencer Landers and another on a site called Sora News 24 by Elliot Hale. 4:50 So putting these two summaries together, I got the gist of what the recommendations are. What did this researcher decide was the best way to blow your nose? It seems to me the most important of the recommendations is blow 5:04 each nostril separately. When you blow both of your nostrils at the same time, air tends to take the path of least resistance to escape. So you are not getting the most mucus clearance per blow. Nostrils are rarely clogged 5:20 the same amount. Usually one is clogged more than the other. 5:25 So the air is, if it's just finding the path of least resistance, it's actually mostly going where it is least needed. So instead, you should close one nostril at a time with your finger and blow the other and alternate them. And this will make sure both passages get 5:40 cleaned out. A lot of people probably figured this one out for themselves, but not everybody. 5:45 I don't know. 5:46 I'd say I myself, I probably most of the time do both nostrils at once. And now I'm going to change that behavior moving forward. 5:54 You know, this is one of those things where I honestly don't... I like to think that I'm doing it correctly, but... 6:01 generally when I'm engaging in nose blowing, it's, you know, it's such a fast sort of, okay, I got to do this. I got to get on with it. It's not something I'm really being present with. Uh, and however I'm doing it, I should be more present with it. Um, 6:15 and I'm not saying you could be, it could be a meditative practice though. It is interesting that, you know, alternate nostril breathing, um, is, is very much a meditative little technique people can use to sort of like, you know, 6:26 come down from mild anxiety and put yourself in the moment. 6:30 And while doing it, you can sometimes notice like, oh, yeah, this is a lot easier on one side than the other. 6:35 If you haven't done this before, you know, look up the technique online. But it's basically like, you know, close one nostril, you know, breathe in, breathe out and then go to the other one and so forth. 6:46 OK, so next recommendations in the paper blow powerfully. You know, that might be pretty obvious, but they say, you know, higher air velocity really does get the secretions discharged better. 6:57 So don't be afraid to give it a good blow. 7:00 Now, that can prove difficult in various social situations or if you don't want to make a lot of noise. 7:06 So I could see that being an issue where if you're trying to keep it down, you don't want to sound too disgusting, you don't have the privacy to really do a proper nose blow, then you might not be doing it effectively. 7:20 Third element here is to maximize clearance of not just the upper but also the lower airways. Start with a moderate breath in, moderate inhalation, and then try to do a long, steady exhalation through the nostril instead of just a short, intense burst. So try to stretch it out 7:40 over time. I think the idea from what I was reading is that that will clear deeper down in the airways, which, you know, clearing more of the mucus and buildup from down there could help prevent disease. 7:53 Hmm. 7:55 So that's all I've got on the nose blowing paper. 7:57 But I thought that this was the rare case where an Ig Nobel winning study really is probably going to make me change what I do going forward. 8:04 Yeah. 8:05 Yeah. 8:05 That's I mean, this is a good one to highlight because, of course, it involves blowing the nose, which is inherently funny. But, yeah, it's something that people are going to be doing a lot of, especially now that we're into the getting into 8:16 the colder months. So, yeah, take this knowledge with you next time you're blowing your nose. Take a moment to critique yourself. But be very sparing in critiquing your neighbor. 8:27 Oh, man, this is reminding me to get my flu shot. 8:30 I meant to do that a month ago, and now here we are, and it's going to be Thanksgiving soon, so I'm going to be doing that this week. 8:36 Yeah, make sure you time it with your Weird House selection so that you're watching just the right movie in case you get mild flu symptoms from the vaccine. Yeah. 8:46 Okay, but yeah, that's all I've got on nose blowing. 8:49 All right, I want to talk a bit here about the Soil Science Prize. Worth noting, they don't always have these, these prizes are often, the title is tailored to whatever is being honored a given year. And that is the case here. This is a, this is something that I 9:04 mentioned briefly in our last episode, because it was, we were talking about the sorts of things that get honored by the Ig Nobel's and how sometimes it's a serious study that just has something funny about it. Other times it's more of a tongue in cheek study, the publication 9:20 that they're honoring. And this one is more of a, citizen scientist initiative, an educational initiative. And yeah, this won the 2026 Ig Nobel Soil Science Prize, honoring a soil science citizen scientist initiative to raise awareness in Switzerland. And 9:39 then afterwards, it ends up spreading to like 25 additional countries about the importance of soil health. Launched in 2021, it entailed the burial and retrieval of identical pairs of cotton underpants and tea bags from soils ultimately around the world. 10:00 I don't think any of the in any of the experiments took place in the Americas, but still they made it to multiple continents besides the Americas. 10:10 Is it okay if I ask at this point, had the cotton underpants been worn or were these unworn new pairs of cotton underpants? 10:18 I believe these were new because it's essential for them to all be in the same state before they're buried. 10:24 Because that's ultimately what you're doing is you're using the underpants as a litmus test for soil health. Okay. So we're recording this particular episode on October the 34th and we're still dealing with the passing of yet another Halloween. 10:38 We're in a little bit of Denial, as always. And so out of desperation, I want to point out that this topic is also really key to zombie media. We talk about the different types of zombies we see in our zombie movies. And then what are those zombies wearing 10:53 when they emerge from the soil? What sort of state of decay are they in when they climb out of the soil? Oh, yeah. 10:59 So we've talked about wet zombies versus dry zombies, sort of mucus zombies versus flesh zombies versus soil zombies. Earthy zombies are very much a type, especially in certain Italian horror movies, the ones that really have the kind of 11:16 mud or clay themed zombies that almost feel more like emanations of the earth than remains of human bodies. 11:25 Yeah. Thinking about particularly like the Fulci zombie. And then the burial ground zombies, burial ground being a zombie picture from Italy that we discussed in Weird House in the past. 11:37 But those, yeah, those zombies have essentially become one with both the dirt and I guess their underwear. While on the other end of the spectrum, we see like the zombie trash in Return of the Living Dead. And she emerges from the grave without any underwear at all and 11:53 with very little signs of decay. Hmm. 11:56 Yeah. 11:57 So clearly more zombie-focused study is necessary, but let's go ahead and turn back to the prize-winning entry here. 12:03 Okay. 12:04 So the Ig Nobel's single out two different articles, a 2025 paper in science and a 2026 paper in plants, people, planet. 12:13 Lead author, Franz Binder and associates attended the ceremony to accept the award. And the project here was, again, all about soil health. So we've talked about soil on the show before, and We've gotten our hands dirty a little 12:27 bit with the topic. What does soil do? Well, healthy soil is, of course, a dynamic ecosystem. It's essentially alive. 12:37 And healthy soil does a lot of different things for us. 12:40 It supports plant growth. It filters and regulates our water in multiple ways. It stores carbon. It cycles nutrients. And in addition to that, we have microorganisms, fungi. Other organisms, insects and so forth, worms, you know, everything that crawls 13:00 in and out that helps decompose that waste that ends up on or in the soil, which I guess would include the zombies. And that's why some of these Italian zombies are coming out of the ground with like worms and insects crawling on them. Right. For real. Yeah. So 13:16 the science paper, the science publication in the journal Science here, throws out some key numbers that I wanted to feature here as well, because they point out that 95% of our food depends on soil, that soil harbors around 59% 13:32 of global biodiversity, and it's also the second largest carbon reservoir on Earth. And in addition to the decomposition, which we're about to get back to, a source of antibiotics as well. Soil helps suppress pathogens. So healthy soil is 13:47 good for just... healthy everything else, including healthy people. So if zombies were real, zombies would probably be a pretty good soil indicator. Like what sort of zombies are emerging from your soil? What state are they in? And, you know, 14:01 presumably a good Italian dirt zombie would be like, oh yeah, that's great. We have some really healthy soil here. While your Louisville, Kentucky trash zombie might raise some questions. But since we don't have zombies, the researchers here distributed cotton 14:19 underwear and teabags, quote, as proxies for soil biological activity and soil health. So, you know, underpants especially seemed like the way to go for a number of reasons, including just the novelty factor here, because, again, this is about 14:35 getting citizen scientists, regular people excited about soil health so that you can educate them about soil health. and get them doing something that is novel and fun, which is burying and then retrieving underpants from the earth, which was 14:50 so exciting that I was like, I want to do this now. I don't think they're actually doing this particular study anymore. They have something else that's coming up that I'll mention at the end of this, but it just sounds like a fun time. Let's get some underpants. Let's 15:06 bury them. Let's dig them back up. Everybody likes to Well, maybe not everyone, but there is a pleasure to be found in retrieving something from the earth and observing what state it's in. I'm not saying it's something disgusting, but 15:19 if you've ever been digging around in your own backyard and you find a stuffed animal from decades past, that sort of thing, that can be amusing. Yeah, yeah. 15:30 I thought for a second you were going to say there's a universal pleasure in burying underpants. 15:35 Well, maybe we're just not doing it enough. You know, we don't, I guess we don't have to. We tend to, we often throw these things away or we, you know, hopefully we're doing some sort of composting, but that's exactly what they're doing here is they're doing natural composting of 15:49 the cotton underpants. So the basic idea here is that the identical cotton underwears, along with the tea bags, which are also identical, are buried for a set period of time. 16:02 So you'll So all this stuff is buried. And then after 30 days, like half of the undies and teabags are removed from the earth. And then after 60 days, the rest are retrieved from the soil as well. And the idea here is that the state of underwear and 16:17 teabags will reveal how active and healthy the soil is based on the state of the organic matter's decomposition. Because that's, of course, key to all of this is that if you bury underwear in the soil, if everything's healthy down there, 16:32 you know, it's going to begin to break down. Yeah. 16:36 This is why we keep our active underwear in a drawer and not in the ground. That's right. If you're bearing your underwear every night, you're doing it wrong. Or you're engaging in activities that maybe should be questioned. So the way this would work then is that everything is 16:53 dug up, gets dried out, and then they would mail it back to AgroScope. This is the Swiss Agricultural Research Center. 17:00 And then it would undergo analysis. They were able to build out a data set of not only the Swiss soil health, but also essentially global soil health with some of these other far-flung locations like other places in Europe, Japan, 17:16 also in Africa. And not only is this, again, about the gathering of data, but it's also a way to reach new audiences and get them excited about something that might otherwise not seem exciting. 17:29 Hmm. 17:30 The science article in particular really breaks down the whole process, though, including the drying, the cleaning, and the visual analysis of the resurrected underwear. Like the idea is that, you know, how much of the underwear is still there is something 17:44 that can be figured out visually. And they actually have like a whole equation. There are actually multiple equations related to underwear breakdown in this paper that I'm not going to attempt to regurgitate here, but you can look them up. 17:57 This is a free article to access. But they write, quote, area loss was calculated relative to the area of new underpants and expressed as percentage decomposition. 18:09 OK, so they had a quantitative method of visual analysis, not just looking at them and getting a vibe like, yeah, pretty gross. 18:18 Yeah, because otherwise you're I mean, if they had not done that, I guess it would still would have been fun outreach. But the idea is like this was they determined the best way to get usable data out of this whole experiment. 18:30 Mm hmm. 18:31 So they point out that one of the biggest factors concerning like how healthy any given area studied here turned out to be was land use. They said, quote, land use was the most important predictor of decomposition processes, followed 18:47 by soil chemical parameters. Private gardens, the land use type with the highest levels of soil, organic carbon and nutrients exhibited the greatest biological activity. Whereas lawns showed the lowest with crop lands and grasslands falling in between. So, and 19:05 there's some, I guess, some good data here as well. 19:07 Like if you were going to do your own version of this for purely your own amusement, if you were to bury identical undies in your front yard, in your garden, and in your garden in the backyard, presumably, like you would probably see a difference between the two based on 19:24 just how active the soil is. 19:27 Now, I do kind of wonder how how does the differential land use manifest in these different soil conditions? Like they mentioned, the organic carbon and nutrients like is that going to be because of using like pre-prepared or nutrient filled soils in a garden? Or is it because of 19:46 what happens in a garden, the types of plants that grow there? Do you know that? 19:52 My understanding is that, yeah, a lot of it is going to be based on like, you know, what's going on in a basic background garden is you're probably having multiple different plants. There's more of an emphasis on having quality soil. You know, it's not going to be a 100% 20:07 like natural plant. like wild situation, but it's going to be better than like a monocrop situation. And it's going to be better than just like a tightly controlled lawn environment, obviously. 20:20 So it's just, it's just thriving a lot more, at least seasonally. Yeah. So yeah, I just thought it was a fun little idea. If you want to learn more about what they've been up to, you can go to soilproof.org. 20:33 There's a great deal more information, including a map of the sites. You can pull up like a a local map and then like a whole world map to show like where these studies were conducted. And again, I don't think the underpants program is still going on and they didn't, 20:51 I don't think they did anything in the Americas. But while that study is finished, they are, I believe, open to participants in the upcoming soil bodies effort. You know, do look into, I don't know exactly how wide, if they're really going for a global thing or if it's, 21:05 they're starting more regional or what, But they're exploring, quote, how different textiles break down in various types of soil. 21:12 And it's apparently going to have both a scientific and artistic approach. So it's going to be where fiber arts meets soil science meets rotting underwear in the ground. So check out their website to learn more about that if that interests you. 21:28 I'm curious what percentage of buried underpants never got dug up. 21:32 You know, you always have some drop off in experiments like people who begin but don't finish. 21:36 But yeah. Yeah, yeah. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but there was, I believe there was some drop off, you know, that's referenced in the totals. 21:47 Some of the undies are still out there. 21:49 Yeah, yeah. And since they're out of sync with the other undies, you know, they're not really going to tell us anything. 21:54 Yeah. Or they're still out there if the soil hasn't finished them. Okay, are you ready to talk about this year's Ig Nobel Peace Prize? 22:12 Yeah, yeah, this is always a fun category. I remember some past award winners for the Peace Prize, and there's usually some sort of satirical twist to everything. 22:23 Usually the Peace Prize is awarded to some kind of study that involves people behaving badly. 22:30 Yes. 22:31 So the prize this year was awarded to Jamie Arona Krems, Rebecca Honnell-Peters, Lorian Mary, Keela Williams, and Daniel Schneiser, quote, for documenting that we value friends who are vicious to people we dislike. So the prize-winning research appeared in a 22:50 paper published in the journal Evolution and Human Behavior in the year 2023. I dug up the full text of the paper and was quite pleased by the epigraph that they chose to put up top. It was about a resolution passed by the City Council of Philadelphia in 2018, 23:08 welcoming the Philadelphia Flyers, at the time, new mascot, Gritty. 23:13 You know Gritty, Rob. 23:15 The text of this resolution included the sentence, Gritty may be a hideous monster, but he is our hideous monster. Yeah. 23:25 So the authors begin by talking about the state of scientific research on the nature of friendship. And they note that the majority of research on the friend relationship is focused on what they call the dyad, meaning the direct 23:39 relationship between the friend and the self. Therefore, most of the research on how people want their friends to behave is really focused on how people want their friends to behave toward them. In other words, I want a friend who treats me well. And a large body of research 23:59 confirms exactly what we would suspect about this. The majority of people, of course, want friends who are kind to them, and they do not want friends who are cruel or vicious to them. Not a huge surprise. The study doesn't really go into this here, but it did raise this 24:16 an issue, a related issue for me. Obviously, very few people are going to actually prefer friends who are mean to them. But I started to wonder, what are the conditions that tend to make people tolerate friends that are mean to them? One example here is I think it's 24:33 a pretty common experience for people in, say, elementary school or middle school age. to have some friends who are just nasty to you most of the time. But for some reason, even though they're mean, like you'd still voluntarily spend time with them. My guess is that on average, 24:50 this kind of relationship gets less common as people get older and you kind of realize like, I don't have to hang out with this type of person. But yeah, I don't know. I'm just wondering like why, why in some cases do those friend relationships persist and not in others? 25:05 Yeah. 25:06 Yeah, I mean, I guess it gets complicated when you think about like larger friend groups, when you start thinking about social groups that maybe have some things in common with friend groups, but maybe are a little broader than that. And, 25:18 you know, makes us think of just sort of the 25:22 deeper dynamics of human social groups where like there is a survival incentive in sticking with the group. And is it worth potentially being kicked out of the group? you know, to voice your displeasure with your treatment by one of the people in that group. Yeah. So it gets a 25:43 little complicated, I guess. 25:44 I think that's right. 25:45 Yeah. 25:45 And I think that that'll interact with an idea that the authors will bring up in a minute. But so the authors mentioned in their intro that some what are called cooperative accounts of friendship predict that because we want friends who treat us well, we in general will seek 26:04 out friends who display high pro-sociality overall. In other words, we want our friends to be nice people, people who generally treat other people well, at least in part because that's a predictor of how they will treat us. But 26:19 the authors complicate this account by using what they call an embedded dyadic framework, which, quote, emphasizes that dyads, e.g. friend-pairs, exist embedded in wider and often densely interconnected social networks, 26:36 wherein one's friends inevitably interact with other people. So this is kind of what you were just saying, Rob. It's recognizing that you can't really study friendship just as a dyad in isolation. It's a relationship between two people that 26:51 also exists in relation to a bunch of other people. 26:54 Yeah. 26:56 And so you not only are you affected by the ways that your friends treat you directly, you're also affected by the way that your friends treat other people in your broader social circle. And by the way, other people 27:10 treat your friends. Those interactions affect you indirectly in complex ways. 27:16 And the author's right, quote, because one's friends also interact with other people, including one's rivals. we suggest that people might sometimes prefer friends who behave with greater monstrousness than brotherly love. And this would challenge accounts of friendship that 27:33 claim we are mainly looking for friends who are maximally pro-social overall. So why might we want friends to be good to us but bad to others versus friends who are just good to everyone, including us? Hypothetically, it could 27:50 be adaptive to value friends who are generally unprincipled but loyal to you. So you can think up lots of situations where this might be a benefit. Here's an example. 28:03 Like an enemy of yours says to your friend, I'll tell you something if you promise to keep it a secret. 28:10 They promise. And then the enemy tells them of some plan they have to do something nasty to you. So a friend there who keeps their promises and is perfectly trustworthy now cannot tell you what they know because they promise not to tell. In that situation, you actually want 28:27 a friend who will be untrustworthy to your enemy, who will break the promise and who will warn you. And you can imagine other scenarios like this. You want a friend who is kind and generous, but do people always want a friend who is just generally kind and generous. 28:45 What if that universal generosity means they end up giving more to others than they give to you, their friend? 28:53 Yeah. 28:53 Yeah. 28:54 I feel like there was, um, there was, there was a sitcom I was watching recently where that was, that was kind of like a wrinkle in a friend group where they realized, Oh, this guy's great. And he's a part of the, you know, they think he's just a 29:06 great friend, but then they start observing that, Oh, he's kind of, he's great to everybody. And maybe that makes my friendship a little less, um, less special. Yeah, totally. So, yeah, I could definitely see that being a factor here. 29:19 And I think there is some research showing that at least sometimes we do kind of feel that way, and maybe not always, but sometimes that is a reaction that can be provoked, that maybe we want people to treat us better than they treat other people, not the same, 29:33 not good to everybody equally. 29:35 Yeah. Otherwise, what are we doing here, right? Yeah. 29:39 So, first of all, the researchers found that if you don't specify who the behavior is directed toward people generally say they want their friends to treat people the same way that they want their friends to treat them you know so like I want my close friends to be 29:56 kind and trustworthy to me And I also want my friends to be kind and trustworthy to unspecified people. But they also found people on average want their close friends to treat them better than they would treat a hypothetical stranger. 30:11 So now if you give somebody a stranger to imagine, maybe don't treat them quite as good as you treat me. 30:18 We want special treatment from our friends. And sometimes, but not always, people, quote, prefer friends who are more vicious than pro-social, for instance, toward one's enemies. And specifically, the preference for viciousness over pro-sociality held in the U.S. samples, 30:41 but it did not reach significance in the India-based sample, which is interesting. And the authors note that that could be a genuine cultural or ecologically-based difference, or it could be a result of low statistical power in the India region. 30:54 in the India based results. So they weren't sure. So it feels like a contradiction that people would say, yeah, I want friends who treat people with kindness and trustworthiness and not viciousness, except maybe actually I do want them 31:07 to be vicious toward my rivals. Um, but it is not, this is not the only such contradiction in human relationships. 31:15 The authors highlight other documented examples of double standards in our preferences for friends and romantic partners. One example they cite that I thought was interesting is that people expect their friends to keep their secrets, but to tell them 31:32 other people's secrets. So you want a friend who is good at keeping secrets for you, but not from you. 31:40 And people become upset when this double standard is violated. 31:44 Like it's kind of not a fair expectation to have because it is self-contradictory, but we still do want it that way. 31:52 Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, you would be understandably upset if you found out that, uh, that, uh, that your, your friend was, uh, even, even if they were sharing someone else's secrets with you, that they were betraying your secrets. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Um, 32:06 in a similar way, it's like, you want a friend you can, you can talk smack with about other people, but you don't want your friend talking smack with other people about you. 32:13 Right. 32:14 Yeah. 32:14 And, um, and then that, you know, and then that you, you, you want a friend who's maybe a little bit, um, You know, it gets it gets a little bit mean in the things they say about the people that you're talking smack about. 32:25 Yeah, totally. The authors also point point to research by Shaw and co-authors from 2016, which showed something that I think most people know this at some level from experience. 32:38 They found that if a friend is having a dispute with other people. and you display neutrality in that dispute, it is very possible your friend will take this neutrality as active opposition. And this can make a lot of 32:54 situations in friend groups difficult. I think a classic example of this is like a romantic breakup within a friend group. 33:03 That can be really difficult if people are friends with both people in the relationship. And maybe neither of them, like, did anything actively awful that would end the friendship with the others. But the breakup is not exactly on good terms. 33:18 So people find themselves forced to pick sides if they want to remain friends with at least one person. Because just saying, like, I am neutral on this will often be seen as a betrayal by both parties. Like, if you're not willing to badmouth my ex with me, you're against me. 33:35 Yeah, yeah. 33:37 So I think this is an interesting finding, though I do want to emphasize that none of these experiments involved observations of like behavior on a task or practices in the real world. This research was based entirely on self-reported 33:52 preferences and answers about like hypothetical situations on a survey. 33:58 So what we have here is what people would consciously admit about what they're looking for in a friend. I have to wonder if people would demonstrate even larger revealed preferences for vicious allies in like experimental conditions where they 34:14 don't have to explicitly say it, where it's some kind of, you know, revealed preference through activities and in a test. 34:21 Of course, we don't know that's the case, but I would be curious and I would kind of suspect that. 34:26 Yeah, yeah. I wonder, too, if part of it is like, you know, the idea that like, oh, this friend's really vicious regarding my enemies. But they're really, but they're nice to me. And therefore, like, I know that that niceness is genuine or, and, you know, I guess with all 34:41 of this, we can imagine how easily these things can also bleed over into maybe slightly toxic areas as well. Oh, totally. 34:50 Yeah. I think, I mean, there's a lot of toxicity wrapped up in all this. Like, it's a thing I think a lot of people would probably realize, like you, that's why I was saying, you know, it's interesting that this result is just what people would admit on a survey. 35:06 I mean, a lot of people might really deep down kind of like to have a friend who would be mean to their enemies, but they wouldn't say that out loud. 35:14 They'd be like, well, I shouldn't say that, but that is kind of what I want. 35:18 Yeah, you might want it while also realizing that this could cause a lot of problems. Again, especially if it went beyond that person just is going to talk smack with you about this enemy. But if they're going to actively like, provokes that enemy, then maybe that's the whole 35:36 situation you really don't actually want in your life, but on some level you want it. 35:43 Another variation that is not directly tested in the paper, but which interests me, is about how this would affect the way we view actions themselves. Like, Again, the paper explores hypothetical behavior that is explicitly labeled as vicious or cruel. 36:03 But what I'm wondering is how would it affect our judgments about whether actions are vicious or cruel? In other words, I think if we witness somebody acting a certain way toward a friend or a neutral stranger, you might look at the behavior and say that is vicious. 36:21 But if you. 36:21 Saw the same person behaving the same way towards someone you perceive as an enemy, you might not even perceive the behavior as vicious to begin with. So you wouldn't even get to the point of saying, like, I will tolerate viciousness against my enemies. You might just say, like, 36:36 that's not vicious. You know, instead of looking like cruelty, it would look like your enemy getting what they have coming to them. 36:44 I have to admit, in all of this, I keep picturing the vicious behavior as being like an offhand sick burn. 36:52 as opposed to like actively clawing somebody's face. So I guess a lot of weight goes into how we're going to think about vicious behavior. 37:00 Yeah, yeah, that's true. Obviously, if you got into the details of specifying like acts of violence or stuff, I think that would probably provoke different responses than what I imagine most people are thinking about in the study, which 37:15 is probably, yeah, like, saying mean things about somebody or maybe like little bits of social sabotage. 37:22 Yeah, it's got to be to some level socially acceptable. 37:26 If it's not socially acceptable, I feel like it's surely crossing some line here. 37:31 Yeah. 37:32 So anyway, everybody listening right now, think about which of your friends are the most vicious and do you value this in them? 37:41 Yeah, or yeah, there's probably a lot to unpack there because too, I often think about Friendships is being like orbits, you know, and you have you have closer orbits and you have you have orbits that are a bit farther out and you need things to be in their right orbit. 37:56 It can be disastrous if the wrong cosmic body is in the wrong orbit. And therefore, perhaps like a vicious friend is somebody you want them. You want them, you know, several astronomical units out. You want them to protect protect 38:09 you from incoming bits of shrapnel, you know. But you don't want them like super close, right? And maybe if you were in close proximity to them too much, then it could maybe be a bit toxic. I don't know. 38:21 There's so many dynamics to potentially consider here. I would love, I guess, some good field reports on this, provided there's a kind of field reports we can actually share on the show. 38:30 The vicious friend planetary body can, I would say, emit a lot of radiation. 38:35 Yes. 38:35 So like being in their direct vicinity can have just secondary effects. 38:39 Yeah, you don't want that in your Goldilocks zone for sure. 38:42 Yeah. 38:43 But then you wonder, too, does the vicious friend have vicious friends? Does this just keep going? There's got to be a limit, right? Yeah. 39:00 I guess that's it for all of the ones we're going to do a deep dive on today. But I briefly did want to flag also the physics prize this year was the one about the splash-free urinal. So that one went to Randy Hurd. And it was, quote, for 39:19 theoretical and experimental attempts to design a splash-free urinal. This was research that was published in 2025. And I was just shocked that, like, there's like, still research going on about splash-free urinals. That's, like, not a solved problem. 39:34 Yeah, I guess so. I mean, you're still going to get some urine on you sometimes. Well, that may be... 39:41 You just haven't worked that out as a civilization yet. 39:44 I'm just... shocked that that wouldn't be something that, you know, where the optimal design was discovered like a hundred years ago, you know? 39:52 Hmm. I guess they're just a number. I'm just guessing here that they're just a number of factors in the fluid dynamics of, of peeing onto a surface like this, uh, with or without flowing water. And yeah, it's like, how do you account for all of that? 40:07 Yeah. 40:08 Well, uh, hats off to him. 40:10 Yeah. 40:10 Yeah. 40:11 Yeah. Somebody, somebody has got to work on the hard stuff. 40:14 Okay, well, that's all I've got for this year. And if you want to look up the other prize winners, we didn't cover everything. You can, again, go to improbable.com, and they list all of the winners. You can click through to them, read the papers, read the coverage, and 40:28 check it out. 40:29 Yeah, as is always the case, some are funnier on the surface level. And a lot of times that is what it's about. There's just some sort of an instinct to laugh based on what is being studied or how it is being studied. But then, you know, I think 40:46 generally in the ones that we tend to dive into, there's something deeper that's either, like, there's deeper comedy there, or there's something, you know, there's some serious science going on there that is, you know, deeply contemplated. 40:57 Yeah, it's not always, you know, the ones that are the funniest are not always the ones that are the most interesting to go deep on. 41:04 Yeah. 41:06 Maybe I'd give my personal prize this year for the one that's, like, the greatest peak of both actually very funny and Interesting to get into the details of. I thought that peak may have been the necroprinting one. Big thumbs up here. 41:19 Yeah, that one was good. I really like the underpants as well, though. And yeah, vicious friends blowing your nose. 41:26 It's a good crop. Good crop this year. All right, we're going to go ahead and close it out. But we'll just remind everyone that Stuff to Blow Your Mind is primarily a science and culture podcast with core episodes on Tuesdays and Thursdays and Weird House Cinema on Fridays. 41:39 let's see, wherever you're listening to this podcast, rate, review, subscribe. 41:43 That really helps us out. If you're watching as well on Netflix, that's where you get to watch the show in addition to listen to it, just make sure that you're giving us a couple of thumbs up and asking to be reminded about new episodes. 41:55 Huge thanks, as always, to our excellent audio producer, J.J. 41:58 Posway. 41:59 If you would like to get in touch with us with feedback on this episode or any other, to suggest a topic for the future, or just to say hello, you can email us at contact at stufftoblowyourmind.com. 42:17 Stuff to Blow Your Mind is a production of iHeartRadio. 42:20 For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app. Apple Podcasts are wherever you listen to your favorite shows. 42:40 Thank you.
Community discussion