Sarah Nagel and the Brooklyn Morgue Mystery

In the summer of 1879, Sarah Nagel’s body was pulled from Brooklyn’s East River, sparking one of the most baffling cases of mistaken identity in 19th-century America. Friends, acquaintances, and a close benefactor wept over her remains at the city morgue, positively identifying the corpse down to her clothing, facial features, and forehead scar—only for a routine coroner's inquest to derail into absolute disbelief when Sarah Nagel walked into the room. In this episode of Southern Ghost Stories, Allen Sircy unearths a bizarre New York mystery where certain death collided with an unbelievable twist, leaving an anonymous soul lost forever beneath the soil.

Be sure to like, subscribe and leave a review!

Check out Allen's books on Amazon!
https://amzn.to/3HEf2u9

Got a question or comment? Hit us up on our socials!

Instagram
https://www.instagram.com/southernghoststories/
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/southernghoststoriesonline

Follow Allen on X
https://x.com/ATOAllen

Use code SAVE10 for 10% off your order over at https://monstercitymadhouse.com