0:00 What is up, freaks? Welcome back to Rabbit Hole Recap. I'm your host, Marty Bent, with my co-host, Thomas Pacquia. 0:08 I'm calling in from Philadelphia. Thomas is at PubKey NYC. Big week since we last spoke. 0:15 Binance hacked. Midterm elections. More hacks. Privacy features. Banks going down. A lot to talk about this week, Thomas. 0:27 Yeah, every week, just deeper and deeper into being driven mentally ill by the algorithms. 0:35 My algorithm is pretty funny, though. 0:38 As far as my algo is concerned, I feel like Nick Fuentes was one of the biggest winners on Tuesday. 0:44 A lot of Fuentes memes are hitting. 0:47 Yeah. 0:47 So that's okay. 0:49 Yeah, yeah, a lot of Fuentes memes out there. 0:52 a lot of people blaming groypers who should you blame the groypers or the GOP obviously it's the groypers fault yeah what a ridiculous take that that one is they're just not even remotely close to being big enough to be spoilers this would take another decade 1:10 he is pretty popular he's super smart he's super funny I love the memes the memes are incredible but they're not spoilers and I really doubt a lot of them went out and actually voted down ballot democrat are we just going straight into fucking midterms uh we can i mean it's a big 1:28 impact i think we should cover the binance hack it feels like two months ago at this point but i think we should start their bitcoin podcast let's let's just jump into clark's dashboard get that 1:38 out of the way yeah then we'll talk about them so we can jump into it um current price of bitcoin 75,420 cuck bucks. 1:46 One cuck bucks is going to get you 1,326 sats. 1:49 We're at a $1.52 trillion market cap. 1:52 We're at block height 974,824. 1:56 Inching closer to the next halving. 1:59 We are currently 920 blocks away from the next difficulty adjustment. 2:07 Estimated to be a negative 3.3% adjustment. 2:10 Blocks will be coming in at 10 minutes and 20 seconds on average. 2:13 A little cooling off of the difficulty target after a hot run up into the right. 2:20 There are currently 3,847 transactions in Clark's Menpool. 2:23 And if I go over to Menpool, that space, I will see that there are, according to the instance that is being presented to me, 65,564 transactions. 2:37 Bees hot right now. 2:39 Five sats per v-byte to get into the next block. 2:41 Four sats. 2:41 You have a medium priority, low priority, two sats per V-byte. 2:45 So that is the state of the network. 2:47 Bitcoin down a bit, down a bit. 2:50 We had a gulag pump temporarily there after the midterms jumped up above 80, flirted with 81, and the markets got absolutely decimated yesterday, recovering a bit today. 3:04 Not a full recovery, but everybody's still digesting the news of the midterms and it's probably what people want to talk about. 3:13 Let's just stay topical midterms. 3:15 I'll throw it to you. 3:16 What was your take? 3:18 All right. 3:18 So we were just talking about the Groypers. 3:20 I asked my clankers. 3:22 There's no real reliable data. 3:24 You can figure it's about a million people that tuned into his show. 3:29 About a million three on X. 3:32 ADL identified 105 affiliated Instagram accounts. 3:36 That's about 1.4 million. 3:38 So let's just get rid of the idea that the Groypers were a major swing, a spoiler here. 3:45 I think that that's ridiculous. 3:46 And that's really kind of like a narrative that Nick himself has started to sort of like boost his clout, I suppose. 3:56 And that happened, Jonathan, when did that start? 4:00 Was that before 2024 election he started saying that? 4:04 Yes. 4:06 Yeah. 4:07 Yes. 4:07 Yeah. 4:07 So he started that before the Trump-Harris election. And certainly since then, his followership has grown quite a bit. But this was really about the Democrats absolutely trouncing this administration, a complete rejection of the Trump administration, affordability, war, immigration still, you know, an atrocious showing from this administration. 4:36 and it's just a rebuke. 4:39 There are issues that I have with it. 4:42 You know, I'd like to, we can get into some strange turnouts. 4:48 Some of the numbers coming out of Texas governor seems a bit strange. 4:52 Yeah, 2 million more voters compared to 2024. 4:56 I saw many people tweeting about the voter registrations that happened rather quickly in the last two years. 5:02 It was a convicted convict who got voted into the Texas state legislator. 5:06 even though she's a very odd outcome in Texas, particularly. 5:12 Al-Sayed posting, like, Obama-esque numbers strikes me as a little strange. 5:17 There was so much contested in that race. 5:20 You know, driving towards voter transparency and, you know, integrity of elections. 5:27 To be fair, they had everything in their corner to actually clean up a mess. 5:33 they had the white house the head of the senate the house um the save america act was woefully inefficient they just didn't get shit done so they really have nobody to blame about themselves 5:45 and we'll see we'll see what the democrats can do now that they get i don't know they don't they don't really have the whole ball right now um obviously uh trump's still in the white house 5:55 and he can just veto anything that they come out with it's going to be a shitty two years um but preparing for 2028 kind of starts today. 6:05 The thing that's probably the most relevant for Bitcoiners are, I think we're going to see a lot more moratoriums. 6:11 We were pulling for Bruce Blakeman. 6:13 We hosted Bruce Blakeman. 6:14 He got blowed out. 6:15 He didn't even win his home county. 6:19 And the moratoriums are here to stay. 6:23 I think they'll intensify. 6:25 Yeah. 6:25 And again, I think you're right to say that the results of the midterms on Tuesday were a complete rebuke, a repudiation of the GOP not wielding power and not following up on the promises of the 2024 election. And I want to preface this by 6:42 saying I'm not saying that there was election fraud that drove this broadly across the country, but the numbers out of Texas, Logan just had the tweet up and I'll read it. Gina Hinoza, who no one had ever heard of, got more votes than Kamala Harris 6:58 with 1.9 million new registered voters, 93 of which turned out to vote Democrat, which is 93% of which turned out to vote Democrat. 7:08 I think that may be a probabilistic impossibility, statistical impossibility. 7:14 But again, we're not going to lean into that too hard. 7:21 Just want to highlight that. 7:22 But to your point, moratoriums definitely on the table. 7:26 In Texas, Hynosa has come out and said that any data center that's been approved up to this point can continue to move forward. 7:38 It looks like they are going to, I think her posture on data centers is actually pretty pleasantly surprising in terms of, and I think it's very much aligned with. 7:50 Texas? 7:50 Yeah, with what everybody else was expecting, which is like, hey, we need to make sure you're not going to strain the grid. We need to make sure you're not going to increase residential electricity rates. And we need to make sure that you're reinvesting and we're collecting tax dollars to reinvest in the communities that you're going to be a part of. 8:09 Gavin Baker came out with some commentary and based off of those comments from Gnosis says, every data center, we should be good to go for all the compute needed or planned for 27 and 28. 8:23 So I think the scare of data centers in Texas particularly may be overblown. We'll see how that progresses. And again, the Texas state legislator, I think the Republicans still hold a majority there. And so you can see gridlock within the state. The question will be whether or 8:37 She'll use the executive power of the governor to stop that in Texas, across the rest of the country. 8:44 I think it's yet to be determined how the moratoriums will play out. 8:49 I think I agree with you. 8:51 Leaning towards they'll probably be less amenable to data center build-outs than we were just last week. 9:00 I think we have had a number of representatives and senators come out very emboldened by the results of Tuesday. 9:07 and say we need to slow down superintelligence. 9:09 We need to stop the data centers. 9:10 And so that will be a hot topic. 9:12 As it pertains to Bitcoin specifically, it looks like Elizabeth Warren will be back at the helm of the Banking and Finance Committee. 9:21 Senate Banking. 9:22 Senate Banking Committee. 9:23 And so you can expect- Maybe Sherrod Brown, but pick your poison. 9:27 They're both going to come after crypto and Bitcoin in particular. 9:33 One quick note though that you were getting at with the data centers. 9:37 Previously, I've been saying for the last couple of weeks that once the midterms are over, Democrats are going to really lighten up on the anti-data center rhetoric. 9:47 They need the corporate tax revenue. 9:49 Every state does. 9:50 Every state is fighting for this stuff. 9:52 What I think is going to be really difficult for them is to unring the bell. 9:56 They've worked a lot of their base up over this issue. 9:59 I can't imagine the DSA is actually going to soften it. 10:02 but moderate to more centrist Democrats that are now in power are certainly going to, you know, see the dollar signs and want to go capture them. 10:12 It creates a bit of an opportunity for Bitcoiners, for PubKey, for TFTC. 10:19 There's a real opportunity here to bring some of the domain expertise and what we experience through Bitcoin mining and help blunt some of the negative narratives that are gonna be pretty hard to unwind, even for Democrats. 10:37 But I do expect it to soften. 10:39 Not in every state. 10:41 New York is lost for a little bit longer and it's gonna get worse before it gets better. 10:48 But other states are definitely in play. 10:50 Yeah, I do wanna address a comment unrelated to what you were just describing in the YouTube chat. 10:55 people who continue to be purposely ignorant of Fuentes' impact are not providing useful analysis. 11:00 And I would agree. I should push back when you said earlier, maybe it wasn't people who self-identify as Groypers who had an effect on Tuesday's result. But I think undeniably, the viral nature of Fuentes' clips and the impact he has on... 11:15 I wasn't saying he wasn't impactful. I think he's incredibly impactful. I just don't think that cohort is swinging elections yet. 11:22 I don't know. If you look at it, the 18 to 29 demographic shifted 40 points to the left. And combined, Gen Z and millennials will be the biggest voting bloc heading into 2028. And so I think at this point, it is safe to say that they do have an impact. 11:41 um you know i think there are definitely a lot of disgruntled disenfranchised zoomers and younger millennials uh out there and even people i mean you're a bit older than me but uh people my age 11:55 i know i know uh a lot of people that i grew up with delayed marriage delayed family formation um yeah and particularly if you go like two or three younger than me it's even it's even worse 12:08 there. And so I do think there is validity to the impact that this voting bloc has on elections now and especially moving forward. It's certainly growing. And like I said, he is tremendously influential. I'm just not sure it's at the point where I haven't, 12:30 I've seen enough data or I have enough confidence that, you know, the Groypers are real spoilers at this point but we don't need to belabor it thanks for the super chat hey you can send us super chats 12:41 on youtube guys um let's get into it bitcoin related stuff binance literally i think an hour after we stopped recording last thursday the tweets started um started rolling out that large 12:55 amounts of bitcoin and other uh crypto assets or digital assets were were being swept off of Binance It was an ongoing situation for about 24 hours I think at the end of the day, $6.3 billion were stolen from Binance. 13:15 Largest heist in Bitcoin and crypto history, larger than Mt. Gox, larger than the cold card hack, larger than the cold card vulnerability was really hack. It was a deficiency in the random 13:28 number generator, but, um, largest, and I think broadly speaking, largest, highest generally ever, um, Binance largest exchange in the world. Uh, and there's a ton of nuance and details to this 13:44 case that highlights, um, many deficiencies, not only in Binance, but I think of the, uh, industry at large and so i'll just start with a sort of rapid fire list of things that i can recall from memory again it feels like that was two months ago at this point i'm sure binance is 14:02 happy this happened four days before the midterm elections in the united states but uh what we're being told we're being led to believe is that there was a devops engineer at binance who was successfully seduced by a North Korean spy who got access to his laptop that was able to 14:21 get control of their hot wallets and create transactions across many different chains that moved $6.3 billion worth of Bitcoin and other digital assets out of their hot wallets. 14:37 Specifically, there's an Ethereum tilled here with EIP 7702, which was implemented in May of last year that allowed the sort of, for lack of a better term, NCP-like functionality via a smart contract to move funds. 14:57 They exploited that. 14:59 They got access to the Bitcoin keys. 15:02 And I think some other interesting details. 15:05 They stole a bunch of stable coins, some of which they then immediately sent to Aave to take out loans to get ETH, which are unencumbered and impossible to freeze. 15:15 We had a number of billions of dollars worth of stable coins frozen by the issuers, Tether, USDC, and other. 15:22 I don't know if Coinbase got involved in it as well. 15:26 Binance looks like they're going to be able to fill the hole, the $6.3 billion hole. 15:31 It's probably not that large because the stablecoin issuers will simply burn the stolen stablecoins and reissue them to Binance and their users. 15:42 And so they probably have to cover like a $3 billion hole or something like that. 15:46 But yeah, I think this highlighted the nature of single point of failure risk that still exists in the industry. 15:54 And I'm certainly a black eye. 15:55 I think one positive silver lining. 15:58 uh again i think bitcoin's trading at right around where it was during the binance hack i think bitcoin only fell like five percent um which historically if this were to happen it would 16:09 mean the largest heist in the industry's history i would have expected at least a 10 20 correction it did not correct that hard yeah so trm and chain analysis uh have pretty high confidence this is a North Korean hacker, trader, trader, trader, trader. 16:31 Traitor, traitor. 16:33 Like a trader, like trading stocks. 16:37 A trader, like a Benedict Arnold. 16:40 Mm-hmm. 16:42 So about 2.8 billion out of the total. 16:48 Is that subtracted? 16:49 How are Circle and USDC, sorry, USDC and Tether dealing with this, the frozen stable coins? 16:59 From what I understand, I could be wrong if anybody in the comments has better knowledge of the process of how this works. 17:06 And I think there, again, there is some nuance with the stable coins that were sent to DeFi protocols like Aave. 17:12 But from what I understand, they can freeze the tokens and simply burn them and reissue new ones to the owner that had their stablecoins stolen from. 17:21 I'm pretty sure that's how it works. 17:23 Have they detailed how they're going to deal with this? 17:25 Like, how much of the Safu Fund do they actually have to use to cover? 17:31 I think the whole Safu Fund is being trained for this. 17:35 The 6-3? Because if they're getting reissued, if the stablecoins... 17:39 Right. It could be half of that. 17:41 I think it's about half. 17:42 I think half of it was stable coins. 17:43 All right, not that bad. 17:44 It's pretty cool. 17:46 What else do we have? 17:47 Fuck Binance. 17:49 Well, what do you think? 17:50 So there is the conspiratorial, like the 4D chess theory on this is that Binance was a critical part of the facilitation of economic activity in the cryptoverse for pariah countries like Iran and others. 18:08 And many people are saying that the Lazarus Group, North Korean story, is a front for Western intervention to take Binance under to wield economic power against the pariah states, if you will, which is an interesting theory. 18:26 Interesting theory. 18:29 It's impossible to tell. 18:31 I mean, a healthy Binance certainly helps with the penetration of the stable coins, right? 18:36 If you believe that Tether and USDC are really important for the proliferation of the U.S. dollar, penetrating into sanctioned countries and folks that it's a bridge to dollarization. 18:50 Then I would expect the U.S. government knows that and kind of likes having a Binance around, similar to having the tether and the circles of the world spread the strength of the dollar, excuse me, under the weather after New Orleans, the strength of the dollar further. 19:08 So, yeah, I don't know how to really square that with the conspiracy that it's for the pariah states. 19:19 You want the dollars to get into those, right? 19:28 I think you want them in the hands of the citizens of the pariah states, right? 19:36 Because you don't want the pariah states. 19:37 Yeah, sure. But you can't do both, right? They're going to have access to it. 19:41 You want control over it too. So I don't think this precludes the proliferation of stable coins. 19:49 I think you could see a new entrant to the market step in and fill that gap. 19:55 If the gap even emerges, who knows, maybe people still trust Binance after this. 19:59 Yeah. 20:00 I mean, I'm just saying that a healthy Binance greatly assists with the distribution of these things. 20:08 Hacking that up makes it a little bit more difficult. 20:10 It still exists. 20:11 It's not that big a deal. 20:12 We'll have like another exchange. 20:14 Binance is probably going to be completely fine throughout all of this. 20:18 But, you know, you have the transparency. 20:21 You have the visibility into where these things are going. 20:24 They just froze it, right? 20:25 The whole point of crypto. 20:27 It's like too funny. 20:29 But, you know, I think that at the end of the day, they're probably tacitly or, like, you know, supportive of a Binance out there. 20:40 Yeah. 20:41 But we'll see because... 20:43 Well, I mean, there's the other thing, too, because they took CZ behind the woodshed, sent him to jail, pardoned him, made him step down a CEO. 20:52 I mean, I think this happened. 20:54 Not the same exact thing, but, like, everybody gets a tap on the shoulder from the U.S. government at some point. 20:58 I think Tether did. I think Binance did. So to your point, maybe they are an implicit extension of the intelligence apparatus here in the United States. 21:09 Just depends on how much how much cooperation they get out of these entities. Right. 21:13 Like if they are sharing the internal information, if they are going to try and protect customers and run, I would say, a little bit more of a business that's aligned with privacy ethos and other things, then they're going to get a lot more taps on the shoulder. 21:29 This is only going to increase. 21:30 Sherrod Brown has got to be fucking furious at the crypto industry and what happens with support for Bernie Moreno. 21:37 And he had 63 million spent in opposition, and he still won. 21:43 Warren coming back and sending banking, they're looking at all this stuff. 21:47 And I think the activity of Binance and this particular hack is going to be scrutinized and it's going to be one of the poster childs that they're going to go after here as soon as they take control in January. 22:06 Yeah. 22:07 If you guys are on YouTube or you're on X, give us a like, subscribe. 22:12 If you're on X, retweet, share. 22:14 Let's blow this up. 22:15 Thanks for the super chat. 22:18 And it's funny, I wrote about it in the newsletter this week. 22:20 You had this happen. 22:22 I believe you had Mercado Bitcoin, which is big in Latin America, specifically Brazil, I believe. 22:29 They were hacked for, I believe, $40 million or maybe north of $100 million worth of Bitcoin. 22:36 And so the AI-enabled attacks continuing. 22:41 And then at the same time, and again, this is why it's murky, and I think it's a good opportunity for us to really reinforce first principles, understanding of Bitcoin, why we're here, 22:52 why we believe in Bitcoin, why we think it is important as we continue to transition into the digital age, you have these centralized third parties, whether it be Binance, whether it be Gold Card with their RNG bug, 23:04 or Bitcoin Mercado, and in the fiat banking system, there were three instances this week that I highlighted in the newsletter, one coming out of Paraguay, which is a Ueno bank, which was like a new fintech neobank in Paraguay that I believe was used by one-third of the country 23:28 as their main bank account. 23:31 They just completely shut down, completely cut off access to people's bank accounts. 23:38 And so there were riots. 23:39 The president of Paraguay resigned and was also impeached at the same time. 23:44 and you have a very serious situation unfolding in Paraguay where you have one third of the country that doesn't have access to their money. 23:52 So you have centralized third-party risk in the banking system in Paraguay. 23:56 Giannis, I forget how to pronounce his last name, he became very popular during the European credit crisis. 24:03 Giannis Mora, let me get this right so I don't sound like too much of an unintelligent, uninformed rube here um give me a second here uh tada yannis uh varofakis there we go he has i guess a non-profit um think tank or whatever 24:34 maybe dm25 they had their bank accounts uh frozen by the authorities i believe in greece or italy and then France also had a banking problem this week with Credit Mutuelle Arkea, which was subjected to a cyber attack that enabled fraudulent transactions, 24:55 forcing it to suspend some operations temporarily. 24:58 And so we have a tack on the incumbent fiat banking system as well. 25:01 And again, to reiterate, to bring this back to Bitcoin, this is why we Bitcoin, despite the chaotic nature of- The hardships. 25:10 over the last five months. 25:16 I think Bitcoin is being hardened right now and being able to self-custody appropriately money that is sovereign, that cannot be controlled, that cannot be shut down by central issuers or is not sitting in a honeypot of a central authority 25:32 or a centralized third party is very valuable. 25:37 And yes, Bitcoin has taken some lumps over the last five months, but I think the first principles approach to self custody is still very valid, particularly multi-sig, multi-vendor, multi-sig. 25:50 I think as these AI attacks increase, as we move forward into the future, 25:56 the value proposition of Bitcoin is gonna be very much understood by more and more people Yeah I think that right Let talk about the hardening process I think Cali had a tweet about developers getting a little burnt out Yeah Logan pull that up Wrote about that as well 26:14 this week. And I got a lot of people in my DMs, like stop being a core cuck. But I think this is a little bit of coming. I think it's important to highlight this stuff. But Cali, who is prolific 26:27 developer in Bitcoin, obviously the creator of the Cashew eCash protocol. He's worked on projects like BitChat. He's worked on a number of different projects that are freedom tech oriented 26:39 with a focus on Bitcoin. He tweeted on Monday, I know multiple people who basically quit working on Bitcoin because of how stressful it is to maintain software that handles money nowadays. 26:50 I tell them all the same thing. What do you think will happen if we all quit and become gardeners? 26:55 Were you just going to give up on the internet? 26:57 Do we just accept fiat as the end game? 26:59 Are we just going to let go of the dream of an internet that doesn't exploit your humanity and take away your rights to privacy and self-determination? 27:07 I know, fuck, it's hard. 27:09 But you're not alone. 27:10 We must fix this. 27:11 Nobody else is there to do the necessary work. 27:13 If we stop doing this, we're 100% doomed. 27:15 I can guarantee it. 27:16 But if we continue, we have a chance. 27:18 And I think this was a very potent and timely message from Calais. 27:24 Hug your developers. Find ways to support them. OpenStats. I'm very excited about LeBitcoin. 27:33 4 is getting close. We're going to have Eric Voskel come down to New York and probably DC to show the updates that are coming. Got to grow the ecosystem. It's not just core. 27:47 It's not just chain code, spiral, brink. We need more of these organizations and we need much more folks that are going to be in it for the long term. 27:59 Eric's no spring chicken. 28:01 He's been around for a long time. 28:02 I think he's very important. 28:03 But as the known developers or like the class that we have now ages on, doing this for decades, it's only natural that somebody's going to get burnt out. 28:15 So we need to continue to find ways to support new generations of developers that have a shared set of values for this project and devote their time and energy to making it a success. 28:30 Doesn't do it by itself. 28:33 Agreed. 28:34 But to that point too, the development work a lot of times is arguous, it's laborious, it's tedious, and often gets thankless. 28:44 And to Callie's point, Bitcoin is one of the most important projects in the world, undoubtedly. 28:51 And it does need maintenance. 28:53 It does need review. 28:54 It does need bug fixes, patches. 28:56 And I believe, I'll speak singularly here as an individual, I believe it does need some upgrades to make it easier to secure and make hacks less possible in the future. 29:11 Core has become a left-wing victimhood. 29:14 I don't know. 29:15 I don't agree with that. 29:17 And there's a diversity of thought within core. 29:21 Like a core capital, capital C core is a dedicated development team, but there's a lot of people that work on it with many, many different points of view. 29:29 Yes, there is a diversity of thought among people contributing to Bitcoin software in the core implementation. 29:40 Let me just send a tweet to get people in here. 29:43 We're solving the world's problems. 29:45 Get in here. 29:48 What do you guys think about stable coins on Bitcoin? 29:51 Not a good look when they freeze left and right. 29:54 I mean, there's a big difference. 29:55 If it's running, in my opinion, if it's running on the Bitcoin protocol in one form or another, I think there was also a push to tokenize stable coins on Lightning. 30:06 Tapas, taproot assets. 30:08 Yeah, there we go. 30:09 You can do it on the base chain. 30:10 You can do it on Lightning, whatever. 30:13 It's just using it as rails. 30:14 So it doesn't affect Bitcoin if Tether or USDC are going to freeze, you know, the representation of the token. 30:22 It doesn't matter if it's on Bitcoin, Solana, Tron, Ethereum, some motherfucking chain. 30:28 Yeah, and I think a concept that is underappreciated and hasn't gotten a lot of coverage in recent years, but I was very fond of and I have actually seen some activity in this space is the idea of stable channels on Lightning. 30:48 So instead of having a centralized stablecoin issuer like Tether or USDC, you basically create a quasi-stablecoin using Lightning channel management where I want to take away some price volatility risk of Bitcoin. 31:06 And so I decide, hey, I want to lock in $100 worth of Bitcoin on the Bitcoin network. Stable channels, the way it works there is you get like a quasi stable coin that can, I think with Tapas, be tokenized and moved along. 31:20 And the other side of that trade in the lightning channel is somebody going long or short Bitcoin. And so that's how you lock in the value, the stable value of Bitcoin. 31:31 So there is a way, a mechanism to create stablecoin-like features that are native to Bitcoin, and specifically Lightning via stable channels. 31:44 Whether or not that gains mass adoption and the UX around that can be developed to a point where it reaches parity with centralized stablecoin issuers is yet to be determined. 31:55 But there are ways to do stablecoin-like features on Bitcoin that are native to the protocol. 32:01 You brought something up that I wanted to... 32:08 Oh, and a lot of the comments are focused on Bitcoin Core, but I think Kale's comments on developers expand far beyond Bitcoin Core. 32:17 It's developers working on Lightning, developers working on apps, working on the ARC protocol. 32:21 I mean, everything. 32:22 BTC Pay server, I think we'll talk about it, had a large vulnerability. 32:27 And they've been under attack pretty aggressively over the last month. 32:30 specifically and so these are projects that yes um aren't like implementation protocol um projects they're they're applications on top of the protocol but i mean these these are very much needed products that we need on the market too and the developers of these projects are 32:51 getting burnout as well what's the latest on drive chain or uh e-cash fork so it launched October 29th. 33:01 It launched right after we recorded. 33:03 And I think to not much fanfare. 33:06 So. 33:07 Is it listed on any exchanges yet? 33:09 I doubt it. 33:11 I could be wrong. 33:12 Could be wrong. 33:13 I don't want Paul Stork to come in here and say, yeah, well, actually it is. 33:19 I don't know. 33:21 Actually? 33:22 Well, actually. 33:25 I like these projects. 33:26 I especially like the forks. 33:28 I think more experimentation is good. 33:31 I get a little tired of the Twitter discourse just over-rotating on these things. 33:38 Run the software, see how it does. 33:41 Yeah, if you've run eCache, how's it doing? 33:44 Let us know. 33:45 I honestly haven't heard much about it since we launched. 33:49 We have it on the list too. 33:51 I think another ramification of midterms, many people are saying, obviously, all right, The left's got the House and the Senate. 34:00 The subpoenas are coming. 34:02 The grifts, the fraud, the corruption is going to be unearthed. 34:06 And as it pertains to our neck of the woods, I think World Liberty Fi, Trump, Melania Quinn are going to be under very high scrutiny in the coming months. 34:17 And I have been saying it since Trump launched it the night of the inauguration or the night before the inauguration. 34:25 biggest cell phone own goal he could have possibly made um him and his family got linked in with grifters at world liberty fi uh and this is very this was very obviously a easy target that he put 34:43 on his back right out of the gate before he was even in order it's a shit show um it was it was sad to see that take shape. 34:53 Because you were in D.C. the night before the inauguration when it launched, right? 34:57 So my wife and I were actually getting a drink at the St. Regis Bar. 35:02 And Don Jr. was there with Brad Armstrong and a bunch of other people. 35:07 And it was just like, huh, that's weird. 35:09 And then that night at the Crypto Ball is when they launched it and everybody was freaking out because they couldn't plow in. They were at the Crypto Ball and didn't have access to their funds or whatever. 35:21 They're going to go after it. 35:22 And to be honest, like, yeah, I don't know. 35:25 God bless. 35:25 They should. 35:26 They should. 35:27 It was terrible. 35:29 It was a fucking goof for sure. 35:33 Senate banking and some of these other committees are going to get involved. 35:39 Throwing the baby out with the bathwater or whatever the phrase is, is obviously the concern and what Bitcoiners have dealt with, with one crypto disaster after another. 35:48 I'm very thankful for, you know, good friend of the pub, Richie Torres. He won his reelection representative from the Bronx. There's a decent chance that he'll, I forget which seat this would be, but the chair of the House Financial Service Committee. 36:07 You know, if he happens to get that, I have a high degree of confidence that he will be able to advocate and articulate that there is a gulf of difference between Bitcoin and these crypto scams. 36:20 The risk is the Senate's not really in a position to do that yet. 36:25 And we've lost a lot of champions. 36:27 You know, Lummis is no longer going back to Washington to fight the good fight. 36:31 and we have to identify sort of the next wave starting in January, the next wave of who will be a champion for Bitcoin and really rip it away from what is coming for crypto. 36:46 What is PubKey DC going to do to contribute to this? 36:49 You're in the middle of a swamp, brother. 36:51 Yeah, we're going to continue to do our thing. 36:54 DC is going to change a bit, right? 36:56 Like lots of staffers, lots of interns. 36:59 Offices are going to close. 37:00 new offices are going to open up. 37:02 We have been working really hard to be nonpartisan, bipartisan. 37:07 It's not so easy to get Democrats out, but a lot more people are coming in and we have... 37:12 You had Chuck Todd on election night. 37:14 We had Chuck Todd on election night doing an eight-hour live stream out of PubKey DC. 37:20 I had such FOMO missing that when I was down in New Orleans for a Galaxy event. 37:24 But it's incredible. 37:27 And, you know, free and open to the public, Bitcoin programming on a weekly basis. 37:32 The outreach is just a steady drumbeat. 37:35 And, you know, we're preaching the same stuff that we preach out of New York. 37:41 How can the freaks help? 37:43 I feel like there's going to be a desperate need for resources and reinforcement. 37:50 100%. 37:51 If you want to start a podcast, if you want to throw an event, start a podcast, you know, host some friends, bring friends that haven't really participated in these conversations, you know, spark their 38:02 curiosity, come through PubKey. And if you want to host events or get involved with some of the programming that we're throwing, you know where to find us. Drop me a DM, drop, you know, PubKey 38:12 Twitter handle a DM. But continuing the free and open nature, lighthearted, accessible is more important than ever, in my opinion. The stakes are getting higher and they are absolutely 38:24 coming for the Trump family and anything that they touched. And they made a lot of money on crypto, on these coins. So that's going to be a really important counter narrative that Bitcoiners, 38:37 I do think, need to focus on. Bitcoin might not care about politics from the protocol perspective, but politicians definitely care about Bitcoin and they can make the lives of Bitcoiners really awful. So get involved. 38:51 Get involved. 38:53 On to the next story. 38:55 I think we're going to be weaving in and out of the political implications. 38:59 Forever Forever but specifically on this episode But let divert our attention to an update on the Bull Bitcoin wallet which was announced yesterday 39:10 They now have PayJoin trading a novel approach to UTXO consolidation and privacy with automated collaborative transactions by default. 39:17 Francis teased this two years ago from his, so Francis Poulot, who is the fearless founder and CEO of BullBitcoin, one of the best Bitcoiners in the world. 39:29 I think BullBitcoin is one of the most cypherpunk companies in the world and they practice what they preach. 39:34 They want to bring self-custody, the ability to, so starting with the ability to acquire Bitcoin to self-custody Bitcoin, the way the exchange works is you're not allowed to hold Bitcoin on the exchange. 39:44 you buy and you send it to self-custody. They have a wallet and they were the first exchange, I believe, in the globe to implement PayJoin, which helps destroy the common input ownership heuristics used by chain surveillance firms to follow you around the Bitcoin blockchain. 40:03 Then to the high level explainer of how PayJoin works when you make a transaction instead of you bringing the only inputs to a transaction. The sender, you and the receiver, the person you're sending to Bitcoin, put up inputs in the transaction. You broadcast the transaction, 40:20 it gets included in a block. And once that happens, it's hard to determine who owns what outputs from that transaction on-chain. This ability to destroy those on-chain common ownership 40:34 heuristics increases with more Pajoin adoption. And so now Bull Wallet has Pajoin enabled as well. 40:44 I believe BullBitcoin is now the first Bitcoin exchange in the world to introduce Pajoin as a deposit and withdrawal option. I think Bull Wallet has already had this, but now for deposit and 40:54 withdrawal from the exchange, Pajoin is enabled too. And so this is a beautiful thing to see. I I think more exchanges need to implement PayJoin and the more that do it, the more privacy that every Bitcoiner gets, even if you're not involved in a transaction 41:10 that is using PayJoin. 41:11 Another added benefit of PayJoin transactions, it is actually like a transaction batching protocol as well that makes transaction batching much more efficient and helps you save on fees. 41:23 And so from a business perspective, if you're working on exchange, trying to make the case for implementing pay join, that is probably the good way to go, economic efficiency, particularly saving on fees because you're batching more efficiently. 41:37 So this is beautiful to see. 41:39 Beautiful thing. More. We need more of them. 41:44 Comments on BullBitcoin. 41:46 I've never heard you talk about BullBitcoin. 41:48 What are your thoughts on the company? 41:50 I've never used it. I've heard great things, but I can't call myself an expert because I actually haven't used the product. 41:58 I've used BullWallet. 41:59 I mean, it's not available to us in the United States yet. 42:04 Also a reminder, Francis reiterated, I think he gave an update on this. 42:09 They are fighting KYC AML laws in France that are getting very onerous. 42:16 And so BullBitcoin is suing the French government to preserve the privacy rights They're French users, and I think they're making some progress on that legal battle as well. 42:28 So shout out to the Bull Bitcoin team. 42:29 Shout out to Francis and everybody else doing God's work, trying to bring privacy and sovereignty to Bitcoiners everywhere. 42:40 Just saying that, France is in a messy situation. 42:44 I think a lot of people are starting to look at them as the catalyst if we are going into a global recession or depression or whatever. 42:50 where France is looking maybe the most vulnerable out of the bunch. 42:55 Why do you say that? 42:57 Debt's out of control. 42:59 They can't independently print their way out of it. 43:01 They'd need the help from the ECB. 43:04 But when you don't have the ability to turn on the money printer, but you can't stop the borrowing and the spending, or at least slow it down, they're not going to grow their way out of it. 43:16 With hostilities towards AI, I don't think Europe is in a position to lead there. 43:20 So it's gonna be a disaster. 43:23 You have these riots demanding more resources. 43:25 They're tapped right now. 43:27 So they need growth to fix the budget and the budget fixes are making growth harder and harder. 43:36 But fair amount of macro geopolitical commentators or think boys are increasingly looking at France as the problem child. 43:45 Yeah, the canary of the coal mine, the first domino to fall in the global economic recession. 43:49 Is that what you're saying? 43:50 Yeah, absolutely. And I mean, it's so intertwined. We'll have to bail them out. 43:54 Like everything will go to shit and we either end up in war or we'll see something that makes 2008 look like peanuts in terms of the amount of printing to bail out BNP Paraba, 44:08 interconnectivity between the banking system in France, but also sovereign debt makes this a global issue very quickly. 44:16 Yeah, and I guess this is a weave back into the political situation here in the United States. I mean, if the left holds power, I think especially through 2028, thinking about the effects on Bitcoin, I think there's going to be some natural friction. 44:33 friction. There's going to be countervailing forces, particularly in the US as it pertains to Bitcoin, one of which, one of those forces being the one you described earlier, which is Elizabeth 44:44 Warren and her goons, and Sherrod Brown and his goons really trying to attack the industry. But then you have the overwhelming socialist, progressive economic policies of the left that had the potential to get implemented with very aggressively here in the United States, 45:06 which bodes well for Bitcoin because they are highly inflationary, nonsensical, and people will be looking for an asset to flee to if the Democratic Socialists actually get a chance to implement their policies. 45:23 Yep. 45:24 We're seeing it here too. 45:25 I mean, we have it on the list, 45:26 But Governor Josh Shapiro here in the great Commonwealth of Pennsylvania came out the day after the midterm election and says his first action next January when his re-election, when his next term starts is going to be to raise the minimum wage here in Pennsylvania completely. 45:49 is a perfect example of an economically illiterate policy that the left is going to try to push here in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. We can expect higher prices, less job growth, because our governor is going to implement a higher minimum wage here. 46:08 Did he pick a target? Did he say what he's looking for? 15, 20? 46:14 I think it's 15 now, so maybe it gets bumped by 33% to 20. 46:20 He said half a million workers in Pennsylvania still make less than $15 an hour. 46:23 You can't live off that in 2026. 46:25 Now we're finally able to change that. 46:27 The very first bill I will sign into law with our new Democratic majority this January will be to raise our minimum wage and make sure every Pennsylvania worker has a livable wage. 46:36 It's long overdue. 46:37 to which I responded with a Thomas Sowell quote from his book, Basic Economics, A Citizen's Guide to the Economy. Unfortunately, the real minimum wage is always zero, regardless of the laws. 46:48 That is the wage that many workers receive in the wake of the creation or escalation of a government-mandated minimum wage because they lose their jobs or fail to find jobs when they enter the labor force, making it illegal to pay less that a given amount does not make a worker's 47:02 productivity worth that amount. And if it is not, that worker is unlikely to be employed. 47:07 um so yeah that's uh coming to the commonwealth of pennsylvania i expect higher prices next year well pub key philly's getting a little bit more expensive but we'll deal with it yeah well i mean this like and i i think there's been a 47:28 recurring theme on this show is really highlighting because we do have many people who agree with the left from an economic perspective. 47:39 We love our listeners who lean on the left side of the political spectrum here at Rabbit Hole Recap and TFTC. 47:48 And I think that's what's really hard about these conversations is that they are seeped in a kernel of truth, which is the cost of living has gotten exorbitantly high. 48:02 the affordability of housing, grocery bills are going up with the war in Iran, gas prices are going up, gas prices have an effect on everything. 48:11 Throughout the economy, the American worker, the American citizen, the common man, is feeling the pressures, the economic pressures of higher prices. 48:20 And that is legitimate. 48:22 And I think the policy that Governor Shapiro is putting forth here is not a solution to that problem. 48:30 It's actually doubling down on that problem. 48:31 we're in these problems because we have centralized forces and government and markets that are putting their thumb on the scale, making things more expensive. Obviously, central banking being the largest benefit or excuse me, the largest sort of contributor to that 48:50 affordability crisis, I would argue. And the solution isn't to double down and to try to to try to centrally plan the economy harder. 49:03 It's to give the free market the ability to solve these problems. 49:07 So we need less regulation. 49:08 We need sound money. 49:10 And that is why we Bitcoin. 49:11 I agree. 49:12 It is undeniable. 49:13 The unaffordability crisis is real. 49:15 It's getting worse. 49:16 It will continue to get worse. 49:18 It's not because of greedy corporations or anything like that. 49:23 It's because of centralized government and central banking putting their thumb on the scale. 49:27 and misallocating capital, printing money. 49:30 And that is the effect of, that is what is driving the affordability crisis. 49:35 So we need to get that through people's minds. 49:37 I agree. 49:38 You can try and grow your way out of it. 49:41 What we were just talking about in regards to France. 49:46 We're not going to grow our way out of it if everybody has a mining moratorium and hates Elon Musk, one of the largest employers in the country, building unbelievably innovative products and services, and he's so vehemently hated by huge sponsors. 50:03 Logan, go find the Scott Galloway clips that's been going around this week. 50:09 Galloway is a scumbag. 50:11 So is Kara Swisher. 50:13 He's a block away from here. 50:16 Completely unacceptable rhetoric. 50:20 It's kind of everywhere. 50:21 You have people working the polls wearing a Charlie Kirk t-shirt that says problem solved. 50:27 It's a bloodstained Charlie Kirk t-shirt. 50:30 Yeah, it's really disgusting stuff. 50:33 But if your Bitcoin thesis only survives when Democrats lose and Democrats are not in, you're already way too partisan. 50:43 And it's not going to be effective. 50:45 We need to really open up and communicate effectively with folks that are curious about this stuff. 50:52 Yeah, that's the one. 50:53 Look and play it. 50:54 We have begun believing through this ridiculous, unhealthy, and dangerous idolatry of innovators that they get to live by an entirely different standard. 51:04 Elon Musk is a traitor to the West. 51:07 We lined up the Rosenbergs against a wall. 51:11 This is a traitor to the West, and you should be held to the same standards as every other trader in the world. 51:19 Anyways. 51:21 Yeah, I mean... 51:23 And the applause. 51:24 The thing that pisses me off the most about that is the applause. 51:28 Yeah, I mean, it's... 51:31 It's very serious. 51:34 The hour is late in America. 51:38 Jonathan, can you help me with the charger? 51:40 The Marxist sort of cultural revolution vibe is rising. 51:44 These people feel emboldened right now. 51:46 This is Bolshevism. 51:48 If you have not read your history, go read through the history of what the Bolsheviks did and how abhorrent their crusade on a certain class of people was in Soviet Russia. 52:02 Go look at what happened in Spain. 52:04 in the early 20th century as well. 52:09 Like these things are, this is the type of rhetoric that leads to that Maoist China, similarly. 52:14 Like this rhetoric, it may just come off as simply uncouth and distasteful, but it is seeped in a murderous envy that is extremely dangerous. 52:25 Look what's happening in South Africa right now. 52:27 Look what happened to Rhodesia. 52:28 Like this is, and it's not isolated to just a few people. 52:32 I think this is a widely shared belief among the radical left. 52:37 And I wrote about it in today's newsletter too. 52:41 And if we're being honest, the rhetoric that's being used is particularly pointed at white people, white males specifically. 52:51 And they're trying to create an oppressor, oppressed, dynamic, paint the white successful businessman as the other and go after them. 53:01 And Scott Galloway is, I would say he's a traitor. 53:05 And he's completely economically illiterate as well. 53:11 But this is dangerous rhetoric that will lead to an increase in tensions and an increase in violence in the United States. 53:18 And when it comes to Elon Musk, I don't know. 53:21 We didn't get the full context of that clip, I imagine. 53:24 And he was referencing Elon's... 53:31 What happened with Starlink in Ukraine last month and calling him a traitor of the West. 53:40 And regardless of what you think of that situation, I think it's undeniable that Elon is... 53:45 I've been highly critical of Elon in the past, still am with some things, but I think it's undeniable. 53:50 He is the greatest innovator. 53:51 He is the most motivated entrepreneur that is living on the planet right now. 53:59 And this attempt to attack him is something that should be taken very seriously, because that would be catastrophic if they successfully... 54:10 I mean, it looks like he's going to be one of the people subpoenaed because of Doge once the Democrats get full control of the House and the Senate next year. 54:20 and this is how you stifle innovation. 54:23 This is how you set the chilling effect. 54:25 You go after the most successful man in the world and if they can go after the most successful man in the world with success, the chilling effect that will emanate from that is going to be extremely detrimental to the economy, society, and social cohesion at large. 54:45 Culture and community always wins. 54:47 That doesn't mean that the culture or the community is pretty. 54:52 Ugly ones with bad ideas, whether they're economic, you know, superior technology sometimes loses out simply because of culture and community. 55:01 Right now, they're in the driver's seat. 55:02 Right now, it's being celebrated talking like this. 55:05 But the pendulum of the Uniparty swings back. 55:11 Doge wasn't nearly effective enough. 55:13 Like, Doge was just starting to scratch the surface until the Uniparty machine really stamped it out. 55:19 I am thankful to Elon for at least being crazy enough to try. 55:28 But I went to NYU. 55:30 I wrote a master's thesis on Bitcoin merchant adoption back in 2013. 55:35 And I loved being at NYU, but I will never give them a fucking dollar while Galloway is still there. 55:41 Yeah. I mean, again, it's not isolated to Galloway. 55:44 Logan, pull up the clip of Gene Wu, who's the new majority leader of the Texas House of Representatives. 55:51 Very similar rhetoric. 55:53 Again, trying to paint the white man. 55:55 He came out and said, he was referencing Republicans here, but I think that was an about face, trying to create an oppressor dynamic here, which, again... 56:07 And it's not just Latinos. 56:08 It's not just Asians. 56:09 It's not just African Americans. 56:11 It's everybody. 56:12 It's everybody. 56:12 Right? 56:13 Our country and the forces that be, the powers that be, have spent tremendous time, effort, and money to make sure that those groups are never united, that they always see each other as enemies, as competitors, without ever realizing that they share one thing in common, that their oppressors all are the same. 56:39 right the oppression comes from one place and i always tell people the day the latino african american asian and other communities realize that they are that they share the same oppressor 56:53 is the day we start winning because we are the majority in this country now we are we we have the ability to take over this country and to do what is needed for everyone and to make things fair no comment oh are you muted 57:19 oh i i i was muted i was saying are we oppressors are we oppressors dude no comment it's just a fucking batshit crazy rhetoric Like, it is really popular right now. 57:34 Culture and community always wins. 57:36 And I've got one more for you. 57:37 I got one more for you. 57:38 We got a trifecta, Logan. 57:40 I'm not pissed off enough on a Friday. 57:41 You got to do something. 57:42 Well, this is, I mean, this is very close, very close to you as well. 57:46 This is happening underground in your city right now. 57:49 Oh, I saw this woman. 57:50 My take is that white people should stop having weddings. 57:53 100% agree. 57:54 There's no significance to their weddings. 57:57 Nothing has any meaning. 57:58 Like, there's no traditions. 58:00 It's always just we start with wagon wheel and we end with don't stop believing. 58:05 The tradition is that they're just getting married. 58:07 The tradition is, yeah, like there's a flower girl at white people weddings. 58:11 She's supposed to symbolize the bride as a child, which, ew. 58:17 Why are we doing that? 58:19 It's not good. It's not great. 58:21 I went to an Indian wedding with an elephant. 58:22 And that's kind of good for the economy. 58:24 Also, white people have like wedding parties more than other people. 58:27 than other people We don need to know who your eight best friends are And they don need to all wear the same color Like these women have a mortgage You can tell them to all wear green White people weddings are the wedding industrial complex It's like Valentine's Day. 58:41 It's fake. 58:41 Exactly. 58:42 And then they think that they can't be a homeowner because of Starbucks and avocado toast. 58:46 But no, it's your wedding. 58:47 Yeah, maybe you shouldn't have spent $100,000 on a stupid wedding. 58:51 Don't do the wedding. 58:52 So did you have an alternative solution for white people weddings? 58:55 that just have a vibe party, go upstate or something? 58:58 Just go to the courthouse. 58:59 Treat it like you're going to the DMV, right? 59:01 Like, we don't need to know that you got married. 59:06 Because then you're going to show us all these pictures of your kids in two years. 59:11 And then we're going to have to do this all over. 59:12 Maybe they should stop having babies, too. 59:14 Yes, to my next point. 59:17 Maybe they should stop having babies, too. 59:19 Never stop having babies. 59:21 It's disgusting. 59:22 And again, this is a demoralization campaign. 59:29 And that's the thing. It's like, do white people have culture? 59:32 I've been told we have no culture. 59:34 And she was saying one of the cultural tenets of white culture, if you will, the wedding, the celebration of a man and a woman coming together, becoming one's soul, and dedicating each other to themselves for the rest of their lives, to form a family, to do good things, 59:52 bringing their families together. 59:54 If you're Christian in a church, that's, it's tacky. 60:00 And I did, the most umbrage I took with that was the sense that all white people start with wag will and end with, don't stop believing. 60:08 Like, listen, we don't love that part of the weddings that do that either. My first dance. 60:14 Don't stop believing is a classic. 60:17 What's your wedding song? 60:18 Our wedding song is Cigarettes and Coffee by Otis Redding. 60:20 I think it's a beautiful wedding song. 60:21 It was Al Green, I think, was our dance. 60:26 It was at the Whaling Museum up in Nantucket. 60:29 I feel like there was a fair amount of culture at our wedding. 60:34 But what are you going to do? 60:37 Let's take a look at the birth rates by Bipartisan Gap. 60:43 So the best usable comparison, Institute for Family Study Analysis found 1.76 children per woman in the most Republican fifth of countries versus 1.37. 60:56 These are pretty low. 60:57 1.7, 1.8-ish versus 1.4-ish. 61:02 So conservatives are having more kids. 61:06 Just comparing the fertility rates there, they're having babies younger. 61:11 You know why there's symbolism? 61:12 people used to get married a lot younger. 61:16 When you're 40 years old and you have a mortgage, yeah, I agree. 61:19 It's a little long in the tooth for having like a big wedding. 61:22 Just go to the courthouse and get it done. 61:25 I agree there. 61:27 But yeah, I mean, long story short, we just watched three clips. 61:30 This rhetoric is rising. 61:31 These people are objectively insane. 61:33 They hate you. 61:35 And I think the time, again, the hour is late. 61:41 it is not the time to cower. 61:44 It is the time to stand up and fight for what you believe and fight for what you know to be true, to be virtuous, to be right, and to not cower and let these people try to tell you you have no culture and that you shouldn't have children. 61:58 It's in that you should be put against a wall and shot for being successful. 62:06 And that's the other thing. 62:07 People like Hassan and all the leftists who are saying that we need to empower the workers. 62:14 How many millionaires were made from the SpaceX IPO? 62:17 How many workers participated in the unleashing of wealth that happened when SpaceX went public? 62:26 I think there were 4,000 millionaires made. 62:30 We're talking about factory workers participating in that wealth creation. 62:35 That is the working class. 62:36 You do have the ability, workers do have the ability to participate in the wealth creation of the businesses that they work for. 62:44 It's called buying their shares and then doing your job to make sure the business becomes more profitable, more efficient. 62:50 And if you own a piece of the company, your wealth will go up commensurate with the work that you put in. 62:56 So it's complete propaganda and insanity and, most importantly, very dangerous. 63:07 Got a couple comments in the chat. 63:08 Trump's job was to dismantle conservatism. 63:12 He was the best advocate for communism. 63:15 If you're getting at the ineffectiveness of the administration coupled with how fucking angry he makes people, I would agree. 63:26 It's super counterproductive, and it's giving way too much oxygen to the DSA. 63:32 We're also looking at a collapse or a complete refactoring of the Republican Party. 63:36 Trump is still a generational... 63:38 Good. 63:40 Trump's a generational talent. 63:42 He completely refactored the Republican Party. 63:47 He effectively dismantled the DNC as well, which is now coalescing around centrist, left-leaning folks, and the DSA, far left. 64:00 That's going to happen on the Republican side too. 64:03 You have Thomas Massey and those folks. 64:06 You might see the Groypers continue to grow their ranks, but you're going to have a very, very different election coming up in two years for the next president because both of the parties are in disarray trying to figure out how do they deal with the more extreme factions that are growing in popularity. 64:27 Yeah. And listen, we're going to call balls and strikes here. I think obviously midterms were repudiation of the effectiveness to follow up on the policies promised in 2024. I have an episode dropping with EJ Antony from the Heritage Foundation tomorrow morning. 64:45 and he was calling balls and strikes on the economic policy. 64:49 So this is not to say that everything has been a failure on the economic policy side of things. 64:55 I think overall things have been moving in the right direction particularly from a perspective of deregulation The communication has been dog shit even around the wins The communication has been absolute dog shit around if you got a great justification for the war do a better job communicating it around affordability the plan the wins that he has had 65:16 Just get mired in the bullshit. 65:19 He's nasty to everybody and nobody really wants to deal with this deal with them that much anymore. 65:23 And they're going to come for him. 65:25 One thing that I was talking about down in New Orleans that I think is kind of funny is what's going to happen to the ballroom. 65:31 So the ballroom was self-funded, but a couple of folks that know a fair amount about how D.C. works are convinced the next Democrat president will tear down the ballroom. 65:44 What I think is really funny about that is they will need to use taxpayer dollars for the demolition where the construction of the ballroom was self-funded. 65:51 but we'll see if that ends up being the case. 65:56 And it's just petty. 65:57 It's just petty. 65:58 Of course. 65:59 Can we be productive? 66:00 Again, I do think we're getting into late stage empire where somebody gets power and you just go after the other. 66:08 I mean, the Republicans didn't do that. 66:09 I think they had a wide open lane to go after immigration fraud and things like that. 66:16 They certainly tried, but I don't think they were aggressive enough. 66:19 They didn't try. 66:20 Right. Congress is so fucked. The Republican Congress is so fucking feckless. It's like laughable. 66:27 Like the approach on the SAVE Act, on clarity, there are so many things to point to. 66:33 And like, it's unbelievable that we pay for these people. 66:37 Yeah. I mean, Curtis Yarvin, friend of the show, put it up, put it perfectly a year and a half ago. 66:45 The right cares about power the way a wine snob cares about alcohol. 66:48 The left cares about power the way an alcoholic cares about alcohol. 66:52 Guess who always wins? 66:53 But I see, I got a comment in the chat that I have to address. 66:59 It's going back to the wedding comments. 67:02 She honestly dropped good financial advice about the weddings. 67:05 No, like this is another part of like culture weddings, like families save up for weddings. 67:11 The family of the bride typically saves up over the course of the bride's life for a wedding to throw a big celebration of the joining of families. 67:21 Yes, they get expensive, but that is baked into the calculus of the ceremony of getting married. 67:29 Like, this is actually very culturally important that families practice the low-time preference view of preparing to hand their daughter over to her husband and throw a big celebration for that. 67:44 Like, that is culturally important. 67:46 And like, yes, it is expensive, but it is expensive for a reason. 67:51 It is supposed to be a big celebration. 67:52 So Jason Townsend, just want to push back on that. 67:57 It's not like good financial advice. 67:59 It's actually a tack on the cultural practice of weddings, which is very important. 68:06 All right, back to Bitcoin stuff. 68:08 You have it on the list here. 68:10 Samsung, apparently they're launching a stablecoin wallet for cross-border payments to Galaxy users. 68:21 So Samsung's USDC push tees up Bitcoin versus stablecoin. 68:28 So we'll see what this does. 68:30 But I think, broadly speaking, again, fundamental validation that this stuff isn't going anywhere. 68:35 You have one of the largest corporations in the world implementing stablecoin wallets. 68:42 So that's happening. 68:45 Any comments on this? 68:47 Real distribution. 68:48 No real self-custody properties, right? 68:52 We were just talking about the ability for stablecoins to freeze. 68:57 82 million phones. 68:59 How many actual customers is that? 69:00 What would be the subset of, if you assume of those phones, how many people will actually use it? 69:05 Turning on the text, great, but it requires people to actually understand the pros and cons. 69:13 Excuse me, I'm going to sneeze. 69:15 God bless you. 69:16 Maybe not. 69:17 Grapefruit. 69:20 You know, I think a lot about Square. 69:23 Square flips on great products and services, enabling every one of the terminals, not based in New York, to actually access these things. 69:36 What's adoption look like? 69:37 And the block team is doing a really great job getting out there, highlighting merchants that are using these things. 69:44 We can do that in DC. 69:46 We can't do it in New York. 69:48 And hosting educational events for merchants that might be curious about it. 69:55 With the stablecoin thing, I think it's actually a good thing. 69:57 However many people start to get familiar with some of these concepts, hopefully the learning doesn't stop there and they find their way to Bitcoin. 70:06 Yeah. 70:07 You know, C.S. Lewis, you know, he went a long way, but he didn't get to the Catholic Church. 70:13 He stopped just shy of that. 70:15 You got to get all the way to Bitcoin. 70:17 That's true. 70:18 That's true. 70:19 All right, moving on. 70:19 We got a few more topics here that we're going to cover. 70:22 And then I've got to go to a lunch date with my lady. 70:24 Oh. 70:25 We were up all night. 70:26 My wife thought our youngest swallowed a battery yesterday. 70:29 Oh, God. 70:30 With no, there was no batteries on them. 70:33 We were at a friend's house and he had like a croupy cough. 70:36 And for some reason, she got a bug in her mind that he swallowed a battery. 70:40 And so we were up all night. 70:42 That's awfully specific. 70:44 I know, I know. She's got like crazy. 70:46 She's like, she goes to worst case scenarios. 70:47 So we were up all night. 70:49 He said, honey, we'll go to lunch. 70:51 So we're going to do that. 70:52 Next up, Moscow is planning to launch Bitcoin trading at Guilafu. 70:59 new digital asset investment powers, with new digital asset investment powers. 71:04 So broader access. 71:07 And so I guess Bitcoin back on the nice list in Russia. 71:14 I think historically Russian citizens have been banned from accessing Bitcoin and other crypto assets. 71:20 Looks like they're turning it on. 71:22 It be interesting to see if this has an effect on the US and the Western world positioning towards Russia as it pertains to sanctions So I guess another signal of institutional adoption for lack of a better 71:37 term, coming out of Russia at this time. Sanctions. Yes. We mentioned it earlier. I mentioned it earlier, but BTCP server has had some critical vulnerabilities. And I think it's important for 71:51 us considering that we've talked about btc pay server for as long as it's been around here on this show there are new updates and it is important to understand with uh the security incident affected btc pay server 2.41 and earlier that simply updating the software 72:13 is not going to secure you from these vulnerabilities you actually need to spin up a fresh server and move your activity over to that. 72:23 I think there's some zero-day, unpatchable, the way I understand it, vulnerability with the existing, if you've spun up a BTC Pay server, been running it, even if you update the software, you are still vulnerable. 72:36 You need to spin up a fresh new server to be completely immune from this specific vulnerability. 72:43 and they have a guide to help you do that if you are running a BTC pay server. 72:56 We will link to that in the show notes. 72:58 Great project. 73:00 I know this is an example of something outside of core developers working on a project. 73:05 I think BTC pay server is one of the more active open source projects in the space and I know for a fact because a number of the developers, RockstarDev, Pavoldot, have come out and said that they are under immense amount of stress and a bit shell-shocked with what's going on. 73:23 I want to send our heartfelt, keep your head up, guys, out there. 73:32 That's why I'm going to send a heartfelt, keep your head up. 73:33 It's tough work. It's thankless work. 73:36 It's not going unnoticed. 73:38 Thank you for the work that you guys are doing on that protocol specifically. 73:41 Hear, hear. 73:42 that's what we got on the list anything else we should bring up before we wrap up here just looking through my notes i think that we kind of covered everything i don't know if you want to talk a little bit about calci what about holly market seemed to be legit and polling in 74:04 general um polling in general i admit i was a bit skeptical of the the blue wave just because i have learned and been conditioned in recent election cycles not to trust the polls because 74:14 they've been woefully atrocious yeah inaccurate but this time they were they were very accurate far more accurate this time around polymarket and calci um yeah i agree yeah what's going on what do you think do you think they come under intense scrutiny from yeah i think that that 74:34 intensifies. Hopefully we get an ethics bill, you know, making sure that politicians can't trade stocks and engage with Polymarket or CalShare protection markets in any way, shape or form when they're holding a public office. New York, New York continues to go after CalShare and 74:53 Polymarket. I think that they're sort of leading the charge, but I wouldn't be surprised to see a lot other, a lot more states join that. And if you have a couple of states, it's just going to get 75:01 kicked to the federal level at some point. But it's gambling. Caesars and DraftKings and FanDuel have basically taken over sports ball almost entirely. They're going to get increased regulatory 75:19 frameworks, but I don't think they get stamped out completely. But yeah, I think the attacks only intensified. Yeah. I got one more thing on the list. Logan, pull up this thread from physical superintelligence led by our dear friend, Matthew Pines, friend of the show, 75:40 been on TFTC many times, was at BPI, but has transitioned to solve some of the world's hardest problems as it pertains to physics specifically. And they announced today that they announced proof of the Aronson and Banas conjecture, 75:59 one of the central open problems in quantum complexity with major implications for quantum computing speed up. 76:05 Last month, PSI solved five longstanding problems in quantum information theory. 76:09 Now we resolve one of the most fundamental questions in quantum computing. 76:13 When can quantum computers be exponentially faster than classical ones by an exponential margin? 76:18 Scott Aronson and Andrus M. Banas had connected this question to a conjecture about polynomials. 76:25 If true, quantum computers are at most polynomial, polynomially faster than classical ones unless the input satisfies special conditions such as the exponential structure in Shor's algorithm. 76:39 PSI proved this conjecture is true that the bounded polynomials of low degree have influential variables. 76:45 The influence of a bit is the average change in a polynomial's value when the bit is flipped. 76:52 So they formalize and check the proof using Lean, a proof assistant language commonly used for machine verification of mathematical results. 76:59 The manuscript and the Lean formalization are public at this GitHub link, which we'll link to the show notes. 77:05 So I guess this is an advancement in quantum physics that Bitcoiners should be aware of. 77:12 Noted. 77:16 It's just going to keep breaking everything. 77:21 This has been fun. 77:22 We got to do the next one in person, I think. 77:25 Yeah, let's do it. 77:27 Well, you're coming up next week. 77:29 So we'll bank one in person next week. 77:31 That sounds great. 77:32 We got the Atlas Network event and a couple of other things. 77:37 It's gala season in New York. 77:39 Make sure your tuxedo's ready to go. 77:42 I got to put my tux on tomorrow for a wedding. 77:44 Just got it pressed. 77:45 We're good to go here. 77:47 Awesome. 77:48 Have a great lunch. 77:49 Peace and love, freaks. 77:50 Goodbye. 77:52 you
Community discussion