0:11 To secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our austerity. This is the Constitution Study of the American Network. With your host, Paul Engel. 0:30 It seems almost everyone is worried about flock safety and other automatic license plate readers. I hate to tell you this, but there's a lot more to be concerned about when it comes to your rights protected by the Fourth Amendment. Hello there, everyday Americans, Paul Engel 0:45 here with the Constitution Study, where we read and study the Constitution. Teach Rising Generation Be Free. Glad you could join me today. You know, I've I've talked about it many times, and I well, I guess I've got to talk about it again. You know, when we 0:58 talk about any sort of security camera, any sort of surveillance type scenario, we have to make a distinguish between public and private. A lot of people are complaining that these automatic license plate readers and all sorts of other things are they're an invasion of privacy. 1:14 Well, in order for there to be privacy, you must do something in private, right? It kind of the same root word, right? Private privacy. What you do in public is not private. You do not have a right to privacy for acts you commit in public, which brings you to one area where I 1:32 differ with a lot of people who are concerned about uh these these ALPRs. They're worried about the cameras. I'm not so worried about the cameras, I'm worried with how that data is used and how it's secured. You know, when when you talk about because you talk 1:48 about the Fourth Amendment, right? They say, well, it's a violation of the Fourth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment does not protect your right to privacy, at least not directly. What does it say? That you can be you you will be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures. 2:02 It doesn't say you'll be secure from being recorded in public, from being identified. And you know, think about it. If we were to ban flock cameras, well, then you'd also have to ban your little doorbell camera, uh, unless it was set up so it only 2:17 viewed on your property, uh, your security cameras, your um uh the security cameras that many businesses use, uh body cams on on law enforcement, you have to get rid of those. 2:29 There are so many things that are out there that are that are uh uh recording you, but it's that data and how it is used that's a problem. See, in order for government to search, there must be a good reason, right? You'll be secure. If 2:45 it's unreasonable, they can't search. There must be a good reason. Now, how do you define a good reason? Well, generally, the well, first of all, the constitution gives you one good reason. That's called a warrant, right? And why? Because that warrant must be based on 3:01 probable cause, it must be supported by oath or affirmation, and it must specifically identify where things are to be searched or who or what is to be seized. So, in other words, if a government actor wants to search a uh uh information about you 3:17 in this database, they should get a warrant. 3:20 They should have probable cause supported by oath or affirmation. Now, the other situation which has actually been created by courts that makes a search regional is what's called an exigent circumstance, or think of urgent. It's something that really 3:34 you can't wait for. Um you can't wait for someone to get a warrant. The classic example is you know, smoke billowing out of a home or someone's crying for help. Um, the police don't have to wait to get a warrant to enter. 3:48 They've got an urgent circumstance. The courts have expanded that urgent circumstance to the belief that uh evidence may be destroyed, but again, there's got to be some reasonable article of suspicion that's actually going to happen. So when 4:02 you're talking about searching uh any sort of ailptor, any sort of security system, right? You should have either um a warrant or you should have an exigent circumstance, a reason why waiting for a warrant would not be reasonable. 4:19 For a security camera, the example might be well, hey, um we just had a report of a kidnapping. And uh, you know, we've got a description of the vehicle, we've got the license plate. How about we search the database and try and find where this car 4:34 is because they are a credible sub uh suspect in the kidnapping of a child? Hey, that are that is exigent, that is urgent. 4:42 I don't have a problem with that as long as it's limited to these exit circumstances or there's a warrant. Right? So I uh that that's my opinion from a constitutional standpoint about uh of how to deal with all of these security cameras, right? Not just the 4:57 flock cameras, not all the ALPRs, all the security cameras, all the facial recognition, all of these, these, these databases. But as they point out, there's actually so much more that we really have to be concerned with. 5:12 For example, the FBI this year put out a solicitation for bids uh to get uh what's called indefinite delivery, indefinite quantity contracts to purchase data from these commercial license plate readers. They want to get a subscription to have unlimited access to this 5:34 data. Now, the FBI made their objective fairly simple, fairly straightforward. They want to evaluate and manage threats to personal safety, property, and law enforcement. The FBI requires professional service firms that can provide license plate readers 5:53 for tracking subjects on roads and highways over the U.S. and its territories. Meaning, well, the federal government wants to be able to track people, but here's the concerns that I have. 6:04 They want to manage threats to personal safety. 6:07 That is not a role of the FBI. 6:09 Federal government has no role in your personal safety. They want to manage threats to property. 6:15 Again, the only property the FBI has legitimate reasons to be concerned is federal property and law enforcement. Well, why why why focus on law enforcement? Why should law enforcement be, you know, oh well, we have stressed law enforcement? Now again, should 6:33 the FBI have access to this data? Well, if they get a warrant, yeah, I don't have a problem with the FIG. But let me ask you, who really thinks the FBI is going to be using warrants to get access to this data? Because the bid require that contractors not only encrypt FBI queries 6:50 and the search results, but they delete the search criteria afterward. They may only retain a record that the FBI conducted a search and its timestamp, not what they actually searched for. And that was the not the legal basis of this search. Meaning the FBI 7:09 wants their searches to be untraceable and unauditable. Now, listen, if you are going to follow the I'm going to flip the script on law enforcement. If you're not doing anything wrong, why do you want not want it traced? Why do you not want it recorded? 7:23 Why do you not want it auditable if you're doing nothing wrong? Now, that doesn't work against a human being, a citizen, because we have rights. The FBI is an entity, it's a government entity. It has no rights, it has duties that we give it. 7:40 And one of those duties is listen, everything you do needs to be auditable. 7:47 Everything the government does must be auditable. That's you know, call it a sunshine law. Because what they're saying is, you know what they're trying to do? They're trying to get, they appear to be trying to get around FOIA requests. So imagine this. 8:01 Imagine the FBI targets you. We've never seen the FBI uh target uh political operatives, have we? I've talked about this before. Right? The FBI used the Pfizer, uh the section 702, the we can spy on you section. Uh the 702 says that that they can spy 8:22 on foreign entities, but if they're in communication with U.S. citizens, they can do like three hops. And and this is the spying section, the one that Congress refuses to fix and courts refuse to recognize goes far beyond the constitutional limits. Well, they're using it to 8:40 spy not just on criminals or people with alleged criminals or people where they've got probable cause supported by author affirmation. Apparently, this being used to spy on political opponents. 8:53 Remember, the FBI is being accused of uh of using this Russia-gate Russia agent to surveil law-abiding political opponents using, well, other means. You think that they're going to get access to ALPR data? They're not going to use that. 9:14 Uh, the FBI has been accused of you uh of spying on the communication of members of Congress, all of whom happen to be Republicans at the time, uh, journalists, state court judges, and other uh examples of a persistent and widespread abuse of Pfizer in order to spy on political 9:33 opponents. Do you really think that uh once you hand them access to ALPRs, records that, by the way, will be that they they do not want audible, they want no real trace of what they're searching for left. Okay, yes, we searched, and here's when we searched. We have no idea what 9:52 you search for. Do you really think that's not gonna be abused? Why do they want this to be unsearchable? 10:01 I mean, are the American people really like Charlie Brown kicking the football? You know the FBI is gonna spy on political opponents. You know they're going to use this uh uh to do illegal searches. You know they've done it in the past, time and time and 10:16 time. But this time, honestly, promise we're not going to do it. 10:21 Really? What reason do we have to trust that the FBI will not spy on political opponents, uh political activists? How about just people who they disagree with? 10:34 Why do you have to have this information secret? 10:38 And remember, the FBI is only empowered to enforce federal law. In fact, federal laws that follow the Constitution, which means a lot of the things they're talking about are not federal law, not legitimately federal law. So you're not you got the FBI given tools to basically 10:59 allow them to become our own secret police, nationwide coverage, untraceable searches, uh um, you know, uh, where's the the the audit trail to make sure that, oh, by the way, they have a warrant or a reasonable article of suspicion to do the 11:14 search, they've got some exit and circumstances. None of that. They don't want that. This, ladies and gentlemen, is set this sets them up to become their own secret police. 11:26 And uh, before you say, Well, you know, this president wouldn't use that, 11:32 just imagine that power in the hands of a political enemy. 11:38 Imagine every Republican imagine that this is in the hands of a Kamala Harris-run FBI. 11:45 And for all you Democrats out there, just imagine what happens if the Trump administration gets access to this type of data. 11:52 If you would not put this power in your in your enemy's hands, why would you put it in the hands of a friend that will one day become an enemy? 12:01 Because guaranteed, sooner or later the other political party is going to win a presidential election. 12:08 And the FBI, which is part of the executive branch, will be run by someone who dislikes you. You want to put this type of power in their hand? Now, as I said, there's more to be worried about than just these flock cameras. I mean, I talk about uh the the facial recognition. I did 12:26 a whole story on uh um a guy who in Florida who was accused and and charged with a crime based on flawed facial recognition content, um, and and the the the law enforcement not only ignoring exculpatory evidence, but leaving it out of their 12:51 their warrant application. And all that evidence got thrown out in an evidentiary hearing when it got exposed, just how bad law well, FBI's a law enforcer. What happens when it's the FBI that's doing it? What happens when we we've talked about um you know people 13:07 who were who flew into DC on uh on or around January 6, 2021, suddenly entered a secret no fly list, or not a no-fly list, say hey, let's track them with uh air marshals list. 13:21 Imagine that. Imagine you show up for a demonstration or an event, and the FBI says, ooh, this could be, you could be seditious. 13:30 So we're gonna track you. We got your license plate number now because we've got all that data, and we're gonna track you all across the country to figure out if you are a danger. Just because, well, you showed up at an event. 13:45 Is that really that far-fetched? Am I really that far out on a limb on this idea? Or does that just seem like something that the FBI has done in the past and will most likely do again? 13:59 Believe it or not, there's somebody that has a pretty good idea on how to deal with this, and that person is Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez. I know, shocking, but there's something that she's done that I actually agree with. But before I get to that, I need to take 14:20 a break. Now, it wasn't all that long ago that the federal government wanted to spy on you in other ways. They wanted to know whether or not you'd been vaccinated, they wanted to track your contacts, they wanted to know who you interacted with, they wanted a 14:34 lot of that data. And that that was it was all illegal, but they tried really, really hard to get it. The other thing they tried to do is get you to put gene therapy in your arm. They called it a vaccine, it wasn't legally a vaccine, but they called it one, and it's caused 14:48 a lot of problems, right? Long COVID, vaccine injury, uh uh uh shedding. Right? There are people that are really because I know somebody who literally they had to quit a job because of long COVID. They just couldn't do the job anymore. So, what are we 15:03 to do? Well, our friends at the wellness company have come up with a product called spike support. It's designed to block and dissolve the spike protein, the inflammatory, the toxic part of COVID-19. 15:17 The very thing that this fake mRNA vaccine taught your body to make, and that they lied through their teeth about. 15:26 The great part is if you're worried about the the spike protein, if you're worried about uh uh you took the vaccine or you had COVID and you're worried about long COVID, you're just worried about shedding this product again, it's designed to block and dissolve that protein. 15:38 Now, again, I'm not a doctor, I'm not uh I don't play one on TV. I don't understand all of this stuff. I do know that this has been backed by documentary research, and there are people on the chief medical board of the wellness companies that understand 15:54 this and explain it, and they've vetted this product. So if you want to find out more, whether for you, a friend, or a family member, head to americaoutloud.shop and click on the spike support panel. Do your own research. I want you to be an 16:11 informed consumer. I want you to understand what this will and will not do, and I want you to understand the possible side effects of it. And when you've done that and you've decided to give it a try, well, use the code OutLoud at checkout and you'll 16:25 get 20% off of your order. So if you're looking for a way to protect yourself or to deal with the after effect of this spike protein, this crazy thing that went from a what appears to be a lab-created, um, lab-enhanced virus into something that the the governments were 16:46 trying to get people to shoot in their arms. Well, head to americaoutloud.shop, click on the spike support panel, do your own research, right? 16:54 Be that informed consumer. And when you decide to buy, use that code out loud to get 20% off of your order. Don't sit around waiting for the government to come up with a solution to all this nonsense. They're the ones that created this problem. Find out 17:09 for yourself by heading to AmericaOutloud.shop, click on the spike support panel. Do your research, do your due diligence. And then don't forget, use that code out loud at checkout to get 20% off of your order. 17:30 Are you tired of struggling with low energy? 17:33 We get it. That's why we created organic energy juice. In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle with low energy again. And it tastes amazing. 17:44 And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy juice is the right 17:57 decision. With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. Successful weight loss is 18:11 about changing the gut brain relationship with food. 18:14 I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. 18:16 If you don't like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepatide RX. This doctor designed solution works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. Terzepatide helps with food portion reduction and satiety while changing how the brain 18:34 responds to engineered sugars and unhealthy fats. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. Visit Twc.health slash Outloud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. I'm Doug 18:52 Evans, author of the Sprout Book. I want to share something that's powerful. You can grow your own food right on your kitchen countertop. 19:01 Sprouting is an ancient method that turns ordinary seeds into living vegetables in just three to five days. No soil, no sunshine, no fertilizer. Just seeds, water. For under a dollar a serving, you can grow nutrient-dense packed greens anywhere city apartments, dorm rooms, 19:20 off-the-grid cabins. In a time when food prices are rising, sprouting gives you control, abundance, and peace of mind. Join the Self Reliance Revolution. 19:30 Go to thesproutingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code Out Loud for an exclusive offer. 20:30 But flock is not the only risk to your privacy, or more accurately, to your Fourth Amendment protected rights. The first segment I talked about Flock and the fact that the FBI wants unfettered and unauditable access to these ALPRs, these automatic license plate readers. 20:46 They want the keys of the kingdom and they don't want anybody to know what they're doing with it, which is a problem. Which is why I'm looking at this bill. And again, this bill was sponsored by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. I guess this is this is uh the the 21:04 proof that uh even a blind squirrel can find it on occasionally. She's proposed a bill called the Ban Flock Act. A lot of people going, ooh, this is great, sounds great, right off the beginning. Um, and again, uh I uh uh AOC, I'm like, hmm. So I read the bill. I actually done a 21:23 whole article on the bill. Uh, and it reads in part, except as provided in subsection B and C, the head of any federal agency and any federal official in an official capacity, and any person acting on behalf of the federal government may not acquire, possess, 21:38 access, or use in the United States an automatic license plate reader or captured plate data. Right? Meaning what the FBI is trying to do would be illegal would not be allowed under this act. No federal government agency would uh be allowed to 21:55 access automatic license plate readers. That not to have not to own them, not to possess them, not to use them, not to use the data, not to have access. All of that stuff I talked about in the first segment with the FBI would become moot if this bill becomes law. Now, I want 22:15 you to point out, yes, this is AOC. 22:17 This is crazy on legs. This is a a Marxist, socialist Democrat that uh I'm sure a lot of people on this program have no affection for. But will you let that cloud your judgment as you look and say, wait a second, maybe this is a good idea? Now, I'm not 22:37 saying there are not loopholes that that we may be concerned. Uh, there's one loophole that says you can use ALPRs to collect tolls. 22:45 Uh, that would not be be covered under this. Um, my main issue with this bill is the extortion portion of it. See, under section five, um, except as provided in subsection C and D, no federal funds may be obligated or expended directly to or directly 23:05 or indirectly to purchase, acquire. I have no problem with that. They're basically saying, listen, federal funds may not be used to purchase, acquire, lease, install, do anything uh with these automatic license plate readers to contract for their data. 23:18 That would basically, again, kill the FBI, the other part of killing the FBI uh scenario. 23:25 But the problem is, comes under such uh section four. Um, basically it says uh no federal financial assistance administered, awarded, allocated, transferred, or otherwise made available by the Department of Justice, Department of Transportation, Department of Health 23:39 and Human Services, Department of Housing and Urban Development, or Department of Homeland Security may be obligated, awarded, distributed, or otherwise provided directly or indirectly to a state or unit of local government, unless the state or unit of local 23:52 government has in effect a law or binding policy that prohibits the use of automatic license plate readers by its agencies, officials, employees, contractors, persons acting on behalf or other in the same to greater extent as prohibiting applied by 24:04 the federal government uh government under Section 3A. 24:06 Basically says, listen, if the states don't follow along with this, you don't get any money for anything regarding from these the DOJ, DOT, HHS, DHS, uh, yeah, DHS, um, HUD. 24:22 In other words, this is the this is the extortion part of the federal bribe. Right? 24:27 They bribe states with this money and then they threaten, do this, or else we're gonna move that. That's the problem I have with this law. That, by the way, is the only real problem I have with this law is the extortion part in section four. 24:40 I don't have a problem with saying you can't use our federal funds for this. I have a problem that says either you you do what we do or you're not getting any funds from these agencies. And um that that's the one problem. Other than that, this is a again, to me, a pretty 24:57 good law. And it is uh uh something I I think you should take a look at and you should talk to your representatives about, not simply, you know, and tell them, don't simply hold, you know, go say, well, it's AOC, we have to ignore it. No. 25:10 No. Look at the law, look at this bill. It's not law yet, right? Look at this bill and see whether this to me makes a lot of sense. If you're concerned about your Fourth Amendment rights, and you're concerned about the federal government, specifically the FBI, 25:26 trying to get access to data, secret access to data, this bill would prevent that from happening. And just because it's been sponsored by uh proposed by AOC doesn't mean we should write it off as a bad idea. Like I said, even a blind squirrel can find a nut every so 25:45 often. And since we've even talked about the FBI, I need to bring this up because, again, it shows me the you know the FBI is just as corrupt as any other government agency, right? It has good people and bad people, but again, politics becomes a large 26:02 part of how they do business. At least according, in this case, according to the New York Times, they reported that the FBI has had evidence that Elon Omar likely married her brother in order for him to obtain a green card. They've had this evidence for over 10 years. 26:21 Right? That's three administrations Trump, the first Trump administration, the Biden administration, and now the second Trump administration. They've had this information since 2016, and they haven't done anything with it until now. 26:37 Now, according to the New York Times report, um, the main reason the case stalled was because prosecutors looked at the crime and said, Well, listen, it is a felony, but there's a five-year statute of limitations on that crime, and we've passed that. So we can no 26:54 longer prosecute Ms. Omar for that particular incident. Which again brings in the question. Then why, uh just you know, weeks before the midterm elections, did the FBI suddenly search Ms. 27:10 Omar's Washington, D.C. residence, um uh and and and talk about these the the these uh um uh immigration fraud allegations, including that she married her brother in order to get him legal status in the country. 27:28 In other words, you're telling me that the FBI may have initiated or restarted or re refired an investigation just before an election against a political opponent of the current administration? I'm shocked, shocked to find out that that could happen. I can't 27:50 say that with a straight face. 27:52 Now, the way I look at it is uh the you the statute, I have I have some issues with the statute of limitations, but that's the law. And if the statute of limitations has expired, then this whole criminal case involving her marrying her brother should be packed up, it's done with. 28:16 There's nothing we can do. Does that mean it shouldn't be brought out politically? Well, that's a whole nother issue. But the FBI is not supposed to be, the Department of Homeland Security is not supposed to be a political entity, meaning they're not supposed to be doing 28:30 political investigations, they're supposed to be doing criminal investigations. 28:36 So what appears to be happening here is yet another example of the Department of Justice um being used as a as a political arm under the guise of criminal investigations. Now it was wrong when it was done against Donald Trump. It was it's just as wrong if it's done against Ms. 28:56 Elon Omar, even though I disagree with her vehemently. 29:01 The law is supposed to be the law, and the the federal government and its agencies are not supposed to be above the law, they are supposed to be subject to the law. 29:12 So I I I asked you, as we're as everyone is focused right now on not just ALPR, but specifically on Flock, what is driving this hype? What is driving this anger? What is driving this dare I say irrational fear of cameras that have been part of public life for decades? 29:35 Cameras are nothing new. 29:38 Government actors violating the law to infringe on our rights is nothing new. 29:44 Ways of spying on people is not new. 29:47 The tools may change, but the underlying actions have not. So I have to wonder what is driving this fear of flock cameras, this irrational hatred of flock cameras. Because, like any tool, it can be used for good, it can be used for evil. The very same flock 30:08 camera the people are up in arms of the people are actually tearing down, stealing that uh place they're putting moratoriums on. The very same ALPRs that um Mrs. Cajun Cortez wants to ban from federal use could just as easily be used, again, as I point out, to find a a kidnap 30:30 victim. Or to find a as a victim of some other scenario. Imagine uh uh imagine you have a an a family member with Alzheimer's and they get in their car and they drive away and they get lost. 30:46 Wouldn't you want a tool like a license plate reader that can look and say, oh, we spotted the car here and here and here, so we can help find them. 30:56 The the concern I have, I mean, I'll go back to the Spider-Man, or actually Spider-Man's uncle, who said, with great power comes great responsibility. Well, governments hold great power, and because of that, they have a great responsibility, specifically a 31:13 responsibility to follow the law, a responsibility to uh um to to do what the law requires. And when we use our when our fear of of abuse overrides the possibilities, then we may end up shooting ourselves in the foot. So if we're concerned, and again, 31:38 I have concerns about ALPRs, I have concerns about all of these this buying stuff, and I'm you know, I'm very security-minded. Let's make sure we're we're focusing on the right thing. 31:49 Right? The the the cameras are less the issue, it's how that data is collected and how that data is used. 31:58 It could be used for good, it could be used for evil. Let's enable it to be used for good while not only setting up laws, but punishing those who violate the laws that use it for evil. The same scenario we're talking with uh Elon Omar, the very same laws that 32:16 say, listen, you know, uh uh if you marry someone, if you marry a foreigner, they should get a green card. They should become a permanent resident. They're not automatically a citizen, they become a permanent resident. The fact that it appears 32:32 that Ms. Omar may have violated that law doesn't mean the law itself is invalid. It means that uh um, well, either nobody investigated, or as some may say, they investigated too late. They found the information too late based on the law. 32:51 You think of all the things that can be used to spine. Everyone here I'll I'll I'll you know, if I were a betting man, I bet at this moment you have a tracking device either in your hand or on your person. A cell phone, especially a smartphone. Now that data is being collected 33:08 about you, but how is that data accessed? 33:12 If you got a cell phone, the phone company, your your wireless provider knows roughly where you are as long as that cell phone is on. Why? Because it's pinging a tower to say, hey, I'm here, route my calls this way. Hey, I'm here, route my internet connections this way. And that 33:34 is data. But what happens when government actors start searching that data for things without problem without without a warrant, without a reasonable, uh uh articulable suspicion of a crime? That's the problem. And I just want to think about this. Think of all the time and effort 33:51 and energy that is being put into the camera, is time, effort, and energy that is not being put into the search, into the data, into making sure the data is secure, into making sure that the data is only accessed properly, and more importantly, probably to 34:08 me most important of all, making sure when government actors violate the law and illegally and unreasonably access this data, they are punished. 34:21 That to me is a big problem. And I'm gonna talk a bit more about that in the next segment, because to me, these laws mean absolutely nothing if people are not held accountable, if they're not punished when they violate the laws. But that's something, like I said, I don't get 34:38 that. I have to take a break before I get to that. Uh, before I do, though, you know, I want to remind you that uh wireless companies, I just mentioned that, right? They've got a lot of data. And uh many of those wireless companies, do you 34:51 know who they're supporting? Are they supporting organizations that want these unwarranted searches, that maybe you know don't believe in in the republic or in your rights, they want to deprive you of your rights under the first, second, fourth, fifth, fourteenth. 35:08 Are they see? I switched to Patriot Mobile years ago, not because they're America's only Christian conservative wallets provider. They are. That's great. 35:18 That's not why I switched. I didn't switch because their customer support is 100% US based. 35:25 It is. And I'll tell you, it's nice to pick up a phone and call somebody and actually talk to a person who speaks and understands English natively. Very nice. 35:34 That's not why I joined them. 35:36 I joined them not only because they believe what I believe in protecting our rights, they're willing to put their money where their mouth is. They support organizations that are fighting for your freedom of religion, freedom of speech, uh, freedom of assembly, freedom uh to 35:54 petition, your right to not be subject to unreasonable searches and seizures, to not be deprived due process. They also, by the way, support the sanctity of life, our veterans, and our first responders. So if those all sound like good ideas, join me at Patreon Mobile, get 36:11 free activation with the offer code Constitution. Just go to patriotmobile.com slash constitution and find a plan that works for you. By the way, if you happen to be one of those veterans, those first responders, maybe just a family with multiple lines, you are eligible for a 36:25 discount, making it even better to join us here at Patreon Mobile. Find out more at patriotmobile.comslash constitution. Find that plan and discount that works for you, and don't forget, use the code Constitution at checkout to get free activation. Then you can use your cell 36:41 phone to support The Constitution Study and similar organizations that are truly fighting to defend and assert your rights.news. 36:52 Why? We live in the information age. It's amazing the access to information we have. At our fingertips, we have pretty much the sum of human knowledge. But where do you get to go to go? Where do you go to find out what's going on? What is the news? I'm looking for a place that 37:08 I can trust and verify. I trust them because I've verified them. One of those places I go to every day is AmericaOut Loud.news. 37:16 Why? Because I've verified what they're saying and I found it trustworthy. But it's more important than that. I yes, I want you to join me at AmericaOut Loud.news. It's a great source. But do like I do. Share that information. Read the stories, read the articles, 37:31 and then share them. Sure, I've got a website and I've got some social media, but you can share them. You can share them with your friends, your family, your neighbors, civic groups, um, organizations you're part of. 37:43 Listen to the podcast, watch the videos, share them as well. You'll be surprised how often someone will tell you, oh, I didn't know about that. I never heard about that. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is the point. Because when you share the news that the corporate 37:58 media and the people in power don't want out in the open, you're not just sharing the news, ladies and gentlemen. You're hoping to secure the blessings of liberty for all of us. 38:11 Have you been looking for a healthy snack on the globe, although the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar? Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy, savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients. 38:25 Beer bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein, and they're low temperature dried for a unique crunch. Most energy bars are based on chocolate or fruit or held together with syrups or sweeteners. But bear bars 38:39 are a simple and delicious combination of veggies, nuts, and seeds. It's a perfect snack for hikes, workouts, or busy mums and dads. To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get a special offer just for listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com 38:55 forward slash out loud. Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, are you ready? Because your nose is about to witness the biggest breathing breakthrough on blue breakthrough. 39:21 No drove, no rebound, unstoppable daily breathing power. Go to clear.com right now. That's it.com before your nose misses out on the greatest spray in the universe. 39:35 Clear, breathe better, live better. Feeling run down, foggy, or constantly drained? Your body might be lacking the support it needs at the cellular level. Recharge from the Wellness Company is a doctor-formulated supplement designed to restore your energy, 39:50 focus, and immune function. It features the first ever combination of methylene blue and urolithin A. 39:57 Clinically studied ingredients that support mitochondrial health, boost cellular repair, and enhance cognitive performance. With added NAD3, COQ10, and PQQ, recharge is the daily solution for deep lasting energy, not just a temporary boost. Visit TWC.health forward slash outlout 40:18 and use code Outloud for 20% off your first order. Power up your body and mind with recharge. 40:43 Now, I've talked about flock cameras, I've talked about uh the FBI, Department of Justice. I gotta go back because it's a new week, which means there's a new story about Jack Smith, the former special counsel that apparently was used to spy on the political 40:59 opponents of the Biden administration. Now, according to documents obtained by the New York Post, whose report I'm looking at, uh, Mr. 41:09 Smith and his team obtained draft fundraising emails and donor information from hundreds of supporters of President Trump following the 2020 election. 41:22 The records show that they were gathering information about potential donors to Trump's um Make America Great Again PAC. Uh the Make America Great Again committee. And uh so again, they got fundraising emails, they got uh uh um donor information, and if 41:41 you contributed, apparently they got that as well. 41:46 Now, apparently, this is all again, this is all collected up, hoovered up as part of the Arctic Frost probe into um the allegations that Donald Trump tried to overturn the 2020 election. 42:00 Now, according to Senator Cruz, um, he claims that the the the Smith's team gathered up information on well over 300 Texans for doing nothing more than exercising their constitutional right to participate in the political process. 42:16 Now, again, this is just another example of Arctic frost and the uh abuse of power. But I want you to notice this has nothing to do with license plate readers. This was emails that were collected and other data. In fact, federal investigators 42:32 attempted to get call logs and metadata from Mr. Cruz's cell phone from their provider, um, which the provider denied. ATT. Now, again, this to me is an important point. I want to, from a constitutional standpoint. See, when you sign up for a cell phone plan, 42:50 your cell phone provider needs information. They keep the call logs, they need they need to know where you are. This is how they bill you for what you use. They don't necessarily listen to the call, but they know when the call is placed and and 43:04 where it's being placed from. And most wireless providers, one of the reasons why I go to Patreon Mobile, most wireless providers, when they get a request from federal investigators, will more than happily turn over that data. And it's just uh just just wireless providers. Think 43:20 of Google. Do you use Google apps? You know, uh Google Maps, Google Docs, uh, Google Drive. Do you use any of those things? Well, all your communications with Google, Google keeps track of. They log it. And if they're asked, they hand over the data. Especially 43:37 if you've got an Android phone, they got a lot of data about you. By the way, Apple does the same thing with iPhone. 43:43 Um I've seen them to be a little less re uh a little more reticent in simply handing over data to f to investigators. 43:51 But again, this is this is life in the 21st century. Now, well, ATT didn't turn over Mr. Cruz's data. Apparently, Verizon, well, they turned over records for other lawmakers. 44:04 And um, well, uh again, we have this this where's your data? Where's that reasonable search? In other words, Mr. Smith he can search for data, but doesn't he have to have a reasonable articulable suspicion of an actual crime? 44:20 That's what would make a search reasonable, and or at least reasonable article suspicion or probable cause, neither of which did Mr. Smith actually had. He had an investigation to complete. Now, what's interesting is the the the some of 44:35 the members of Congress who who, especially those who had their data collected, how they responded to it. For example, back in uh September, uh Representative Jim Jordan posted on, I think he posted this on X, uh he said, members of Congress communications are protected 44:51 under the speech or debate clause. Jack Smith knows this, but he ignored the Constitution to spy on Republicans. Uh, Mr. Jordan, that isn't exactly what it says. 45:02 Article 1, section 6 of the Constitution that says uh for any speech or debate in either house, they, being the senators and representatives, shall not be questioned in any other place. 45:13 It doesn't say that their that their communication is secure, that it's exempt from search, it's that it cannot be questioned. Again, we have another member of the House who took an oath to support the Constitution who doesn't actually know what the 45:28 Constitution says. In fact, I'll go you a step farther. When the members of Congress use government-owned devices for their communications, it is required to be uh categorized, logged, and made available under the Freedom of Information Act. So, no, this is not a violation of the 45:50 speech and debate clause, Mr. Jordan. It is a violation of the Fourth Amendment because there was not a reasonable, there was not a good reason for the search. But again, I want to point out, look at all the other methods they have. 46:03 They've got your emails, they've got your phone logs, they've got your your internet searches and access, they've got all the apps that we use, which collect data about us. Uh, all of that information is available. And that's just the 21st century stuff. This type of 46:19 spying has been going on long before we had this the internet and this type of technology. They there was they the FBI uh the reports that they were spying on um the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, um, that they may have been spying on the Kennedys, 46:36 that they've been spying on people. And again, there may be investigations and good reasons. And the problem you have is is this search or seizure reasonable? I don't care what tool is used to violate that. I care is the search or seizure reasonable. 46:56 But here's the other thing I want you to consider. So you've got the government collecting all this data, some of it legal, some of it not. What happens to all that data? Now, again, I spent 30 years IT in IT. I'm familiar with data security and 47:10 how to keep data secure both at rest and in flight. Uh, I've worked on a lot of systems, I worked in a lot of data centers where this was seriously uh an issue, which means when this report came out, this one I saw at the Epoch Times, that an internal database 47:25 identifying more than 41,000 DHS employees apparently was hacked. They got access to it. 47:34 It was actually, according to the group, published online. 47:39 Now, of course, I look at these and say my first question is, well, how do they access the data? That's again, I worked in IT. That's that's how I think. Um, okay, uh this is an and they say it is an internal database, meaning this database 47:52 should not have been accessible over the internet. 47:55 There should have been plenty of firewalls in place that would prevent this act this data from getting access to the uh uh anyone on the internet, which kind of leads me to suspect there could be an inside job, intentionally or otherwise. Meaning either 48:11 somebody with access to the database intentionally gathered the data and sent it to someone to that was part of these these these hacktivists, or they were compromised through a social uh hack, meaning um somebody clicked on a link, they got 48:29 an email, they went to a website, malware was installed, and that's how the activists got access to this data. Uh again, it it it is bad uh data security to have confidential data accessible to a system that might be accessible outside, right? Uh, I the again, there's a lot 48:50 of security way protocols, there's a lot of ways to help secure this data, and some or not all of them apparently were not followed. Now, again, that assumes that this wasn't an somebody, an activist themselves, getting this data, right? You that that is a whole 49:07 personnel issue, which again, that's a whole other issue. But this is also a personnel issue because you got a 41,000 employees, and their data is now available online, including potentially um compromising uh uh security operations, things that they're working on. According to 49:28 the hacktivist, they've they've got data including emails, phone numbers, field offices, work-related information from um not from uh customs and border patrol, federal protective services, uh DHS headquarters, uh information, uh 49:44 customs enforcement, homeland security investigations, they got access to a lot of this data. Um and uh a group calling themselves Department of Peace has allegedly got access to the data, sent copies to uh other groups, uh, the to uh distributed denial of secrets, um 50:03 and uh a which is another activist group. 50:06 And again, think about this. Imagine all the data the federal government collects. How well is it being secured? You have now the FBI wants access to even more data. 50:19 How well is the FBI going to be at securing that data, right? Because now they want unfettered, untraceable access to automatic license plate readers, which they then, well, what happens if there's a data breach at the FBI? There have been data breaches at the 50:35 past. They they not only do they want access to this data, could it be could that that data access be compromised? And the fact that the that the auditing of the data is non-ex all but non-existent, meaning you gotta have people performing all sorts 50:52 of of queries through the FBI system that the FBI all they know that a search happened, they know when the search happened, but they may not know what was being searched for, they may not know there's a problem. 51:04 Just another reason to uh uh not to be careful what we trust government actors with. 51:11 They are our employees, they are to work for us, um, they're not to dictate and over us. And that, well, to me, that's part of the problem, is we've become so dependent on government doing for us what we should be doing for ourselves that we're frequently 51:26 willing to compromise our security, our rights, and yes, our privacy, or at least privacy, uh at least restricted access to information about us, all with the promise of, well, we'll just keep you safe. And of course, that's why the FBI says they want access 51:43 to all these automatic license plate readers. It's why they, you know, all the Department of Justice, all these agencies, they want access to data. They want stuff. They always promise to keep us safe. It's the same reason Alexandria Casio-Cortez wants her banned flock act, is to 51:59 keep you safe. And um, while I appreciate when government helps, ultimately, it's my responsibility to keep me and my family safe. 52:09 It's a responsibility I take fairly seriously. So uh, yes, my concerns about flock, I've noted, I've said it multiple times, right? It's I'm not as concerned about the cameras, I'm concerned about the data. Because those cameras could be quite useful. 52:26 The same reason, you know, you might put uh security cameras on your property, you you know, you've got those there in case something bad happens. Is it really any different when the government does the same thing in public? 52:39 Remember, public is not private. You have no privacy in public, that is public. 52:45 But how that data is used by the government, they have a responsibility. The same way, you know, if you um if you have cameras on your property and you collect data on your property and you use it in a f in a manner that violates the law, you can be held responsible. You can 53:02 be held accountable. Too often I see government actors are not held accountable. Or say, well, you know, we were doing we were doing it in good faith. That's what the courts like to say. Well, you know, I sure they violated the law, but they were acting 53:15 in good faith. That's questionable to begin with. But I have to wonder, is good faith good enough for you to hand over your rights? Now, you know, uh uh this deals a lot with again, we talk we're talking about the Fourth Amendment, we're talking about 53:30 other concepts under the Constitution, as I've already shown, that a lot of people don't truly understand. Uh, you know, as a representative of Jordan, who apparently doesn't understand what the speech and debate clause says. Now, uh I frequently 53:43 get asked when I go to events, uh, by the way, I just got invited to uh a keynote the uh Constitution Party's uh national conference this coming May in Tampa, Florida. So I hope I'll see you there, you know, uh if you're attending. But one of the things I'm being asked to 54:00 talk about is this idea of privacy. And a lot of people have a lot of ideas that have nothing to do with the actual language of the Constitution. And one of the things I get asked a lot when I go to these events is, well, what should I do next? And the answer is 54:15 almost always, well, it depends. Because it does. I don't know what you've studied so far. I don't know what your goals are, so I don't know yet what your next step should be. It's why I created the Constitution Study Wizard. It's a tool to 54:29 help you weed through some of those things. 54:31 Go to Constitution Study.com slash wizard. 54:34 It does ask for your name and email address. Why? Because the system's going to email you suggestions. You answer questions like, uh, you know, when was the last time you read the Constitution? Uh, have you read any of the other documents, like the Federalist or Anti-Federalist 54:48 papers? Um, have uh what are your goals? 54:51 What do you want to do with this information? And based on those answers, the system's gonna generate some emails with suggestions. They're just suggestions, they're not the law, you can follow them or not, you know. And by the way, I look at each and every 55:04 entry because I might have something specific that I might want to add. Again, find it all at constitutionstudy.comslash wizard. What's the worst that happens? All right, you fill out the form, you get some suggestions, and you don't particularly 55:17 like them. Oh well, you've spent a few minutes of your time. That's it. However, you might get an idea that you hadn't thought of, a suggestion of something to try that uh well, you hadn't thought of, and maybe it sends you down the road to becoming 55:30 a better constitutional scholar. So again, find out more at constitutionstudy.com slash wizard, fill out the Constitution Study Wizard, and uh see if it gives you some ideas on ways to improve your study. By the way, I hope your study includes coming back here 55:45 for the Constitution Study every weekday at 4 p.m. Eastern Time on America Out Loud Talk Radio, heard on the iHeartRadio Network. Now you can listen on our media player. We've also got apps for Apple, Android, and Alexa, so there are plenty of ways to listen. Of 55:59 course, all of the episodes go to podcasts a day or two after they're heard on the radio, which means you get to listen in your favorite podcast app. Do me a favor though, subscribe to the podcast. Leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts. It helps the 56:13 algorithm share the Constitution Study with more people. 56:16 The more people that see us, the more people that are likely to click the link and join us here for the Constitution Study. 56:22 Now you can find all the links you need at the homepage at AmericaOutloud.news. But please share those links. Share this program. Let other people know what you're listening to and why. And it's by sharing this content, by sharing this information, that you help 56:38 secure the blessings of liberty to everyone who calls this great nation. 56:42 nation home.
Community discussion