0:00 In a world full of lies and deception, it takes courage to speak the truth. In a nation held bent on its own destruction, it takes honor to seek a return to glory. Join us in cutting through the lies. Join us in cutting through the propaganda. Join us as we seek the truth 0:20 on cutting through the fog from the America Outloud Network. And here's your host, Wallace Garneau. 0:28 Ladies and gentlemen, it's another exciting adventure in cutting through the chaos on the America Out Loud Network, where we cut through the lies and the propaganda to bring you the Out Loud Truth. I'm your host, Wallace Garneau, and I want to talk to you today. I'm 0:44 going to base this on a Genesis story, so I guess I'll just start with the Genesis story and then get into it. You'll understand why starting with Genesis a little bit later. Genesis 4, 1 through 18 gives us a very interesting story. It says, Now 0:58 the man knew his wife Eve, and she conceived and bore Cain, saying, I have produced a man with the help of the Lord. 1:04 Next she bore his brother, Abel. Now Abel is a keeper of sheep, and Cain a tiller of the ground. In the course of time, Cain was brought to the Lord an offering of the fruit of the ground, and Abel, for his part, brought of the first flock the firstlings of his flock their fat 1:19 portions. And the Lord had regard for Abel and his offering, but for Cain and his offering he had no regard. So Cain was very angry and his countenance fell. The Lord said to Cain, Why are you angry? And why has your countenance fallen? If you do 1:33 well, will you not be accepted? And if you do not do well, sin is lurking at the door. Its desire is for you, but you must master it. Cain said to his brother Abel, Let's go out to the field. And when they were in the field, Cain rose up against his brother Abel and 1:48 killed him. Then the Lord said to Cain, Where is your brother Abel? He said, I do not know. Am I my brother's keeper? 1:56 Then the Lord said, What have you done? 1:58 Listen, your brother's blood is crying out to me from the ground. And now you are cursed from the ground, which has opened its mouth to receive your brother's blood from your hand. When you till the ground, it will no longer yield to you its strength. You 2:11 will be a fugitive and a wanderer of the earth. Cain said to the Lord, My punishment is greater than I can bear. Today you have driven me away from the soil, and I shall be hidden from your face. 2:21 I shall be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth, and anyone who meets me may kill me. Then the Lord said to him, Not so, whoever kills Cain will suffer sevenfold vengeance. And the Lord put a mark on Cain, so that no one who came upon him would kill him. Then Cain went 2:39 away from the presence of the Lord and settled in the land of Nod, east of Eden. Cain knew his wife, and she conceived and bore Enoch, and he built a city and named it Enoch after his son Enoch. 2:50 That's the story of Abel and Cain, you've all heard it before. At least most of you, I'm sure, have heard it before. But there are several things that immediately stand out to me in that story. The first is the difference between the offerings. The story says 3:05 Abel brought from the first slings of his flock, which are the firstborn. Abel also brings the fatty portions, which are generally considered the choicest cuts of meat. Abel then is giving God a sacrifice before taking for himself, and also giving God the best of what Abel 3:20 produces. God finds that to be an acceptable offering. 3:26 Genesis doesn't say specifically what was wrong with Cain's offering, but nor does it describe the fruit of the ground in any way that might represent first fruits, as later prescribed in the law of Moses. As a matter of fact, when Moses said to give 3:42 God the first fruits, Moses may very well have been referring back specifically to the fact that Cain did not do that. Whatever the case, though, God was not pleased with Cain's offering and warns Cain to master the sin hanging around him. The second thing that stands 4:00 out is that Abel is the secondborn. And though the story does not indicate that Cain thought himself superior to or more entitled than Abel, it was the custom that the firstborn inherits his father's position. God, however, overlooks the firstborn and provides favor to the 4:15 second, caring far more for the righteousness of the sacrifice, inferring also the righteousness of the person giving it, than for anything related to birthright. Cain killing Abel is the epicenter of the story. It is the ultimate betrayal, not only of Cain's younger brother, but 4:34 also of God. 4:36 For God told Cain to control his sin, and Cain instead gives into his sin, killing his brother, who happened to be a righteous man, out of spite. When God asks Cain where Abel is, Cain lies and says he does not know. Cain, as I said, asks, Am I my brother's keeper? Which is kind 4:52 of foolish, as God already knows the answer to his own question. It was asked, you know, it was it was asked rhetorically. God already knew exactly where Abel was. 5:02 Also at this point, Cain quite literally is his brother's keeper. By killing Abel, Cain kept Abel from living a full life. So, you know, it's it's another lie. Am I my brother's keeper? The answer to the question, which he's asking also rhetorically, is ironically, yeah, the 5:18 way you kind of are. You killed him and are now keeping him from being alive. 5:23 Uh God's punishment, of course, seems somewhat fitting. 5:26 He strips Cain of the ability to farm the soil and makes Cain a fugitive and wanderer of the earth. But he also marks Cain to prevent others from killing him. 5:37 Cain understands another portion of God's punishment. This is probably the one wise thing that Cain says in the entire exchange: that he will be hidden from God's presence. Well, sin, of course, separates us from God. That mark and the protection it bestows is the 5:54 third thing that stands out. See, God wants Cain punished. And murder, you know, are pretty significant crime. He killed his brother, and he killed a righteous brother. So uh he's punished, of course. But God punishes Cain directly and provides a warning for others not to 6:10 add to the punishment God has already provided. 6:13 So once God punishes you in a way that God feels is just, you've served your time. Other people are not supposed to punish you as well. So he protects Cain by putting a mark on him. What the mark of Cain is, it doesn't say, but there's a mark on Cain of some kind. Then 6:27 the last thing that uh stands out is that Cain founded a city after being told by God that Cain would wander. Now, in fairness to Cain, God did not forbid him from settling. He just told Cain that Cain would not do so, that he would wander. 6:44 We don't know what happens to Cain after that. I assume he did not stay in Enoch, but instead wandered, given that that's what God told him he would do. But the narrative, you know, it moves on to his descendants before going back to Adam and Eve, 6:58 who have Seth. There is incidentally a second Enoch that comes from Seth's line, and this Enoch, we are told, walks with God. This line eventually leads to Noah and to the re-establishment of humanity after the flood. 7:12 Lamech is the culmination of Cain's line, and Lamech, you know what he's known for, is boasting about killing a man. Cain's male line does not survive the flood. It's possible that Cain's bloodline does through uh through Enoch, or Seth's line, I should say, uh, 7:29 but if they did, they were wives, they were not the husbands. His male line, there is not a single male heir in the story uh from from uh Cain's line that would have survived the flood, because Noah didn't come through Cain's line. Uh 7:44 and there's up there's obviously a tremendous amount that we could unpack here, but there are several recurring themes. One is that we have agency. God called upon Cain to master his sin, not to succumb to it. The next is that though we have freedom, our freedom 8:02 has moral limits that relate to the respect for rights of others. In other words, you have the freedom to live your life, but you don't have the freedom to live your life in ways that harm others. Cain was not supposed to kill Abel because that violated 8:17 Abel's rights. In the same way, I am not allowed to do things that violate your rights. You're not allowed to do things that violate my rights. I always like to say that one person's rights end where another's begins. 8:30 Some people say that the right of my fist ends before it hits your face. Well, it's the same thing. I'm not allowed to hurt other people, and they're not allowed to hurt me. That is the primary purpose of government is to prevent us from hurting each other, which is a way of 8:45 actively protecting our rights. Uh somebody of the Libertarian Party, Libertarian Party's are more whack than I'm I'm not a member of the Libertarian Party. I do run the website, the Daily Libertarian.com, but I I started using that that URL before the Libertarian. 9:02 Libertarianism is a wide range of belief that goes all the way from constitutional conservatism, probably doesn't include constitutional conservative, but it rubs shoulders with it on one end, and then all the way to uh anarcho-capitalism on the 9:17 other end. Small L libertarians are very much in the constitutional conservative uh group. Uh they may differ from other constitutional conservatives in that they think that the state shouldn't have much, shouldn't be doing a whole lot more than the federal government. Uh 9:33 so you know you can do a tremendous amount if you're a state under the constitution. 9:38 So you can be a constitutionalist and still want to have very powerful individual states, the 50 states, as uh more of a libertarian side of that, uh you wouldn't want the state governments to be that big either, particularly in the state in which you live, which 9:52 for me is Michigan. So I would consider myself far more of a constitutional conservative side uh libertarian. I could easily go by constitutional conservative. No, there's no strict line that separates a constitutional conservative from a libertarian. There's just 10:07 a point after which somebody is clearly more into the constitutional conservative camp, and then there's a point where somebody is drifting more toward libertarianism, and I'm somewhere near that line. Uh whatever the case, though, libertarians would say, so the the the big 10:22 L libertarians would say that there is a uh a non-aggression principle, that you don't have the right to use aggression, to be the first to use aggression against anybody else. You can do it in self-defense, but you cannot initiate aggression against anybody else. And uh AND CAPS 10:40 believe that the government should not enforce that, that private individual individuals should support the non-aggression principle. But from a practical perspective, that just doesn't work. I mean, you spend your entire life, you know, doing little more 10:54 than protecting your property. We need government, I guess is what I'm saying. Government will always become excessive, it will always have a tendency to grow. Uh, but perfection is not for this world, and and we will forever uh wrestle with the fact that we need to 11:10 have an institution uh that is inherently going to want to become tyrannical. And so we have to find ways to to prevent government from becoming tyrannical while also uh respecting the fact that we need to have government. How you do that I I I don't know. But uh but 11:29 that's kind of what we have to do. 11:31 Um the the third thing, that was the second thing, I got a little long-winded there. The third thing is that punishment has just limits. 11:39 Just because somebody does something bad doesn't mean you can punish them for the rest of their life. 11:44 There's a limit to what is a just punishment. Now you can say the punishment must fit the crime, and accordingly, the more serious the crime, the more serious the punishment, but every punishment is going to have some kind of a just limit, and uh and 12:00 you shouldn't punish people beyond those just limits. 12:03 Uh finally, the actions of the father have a huge impact on his children who are not necessarily bound by the father's fate, but whose own start will be largely dictated by it. And if you're a parent, think about that. The bad things that you do 12:19 will be revisiting your children. Not if if if I drink too much, my children necessarily want to drink too much. It's not as direct as that. But if if I have habits and things in my life uh that that hurt me, they also hurt my family. 12:33 And they I'm not doing everything that I can then to advance my my children. Now, some people would say, well, what you're talking about that is not giving them privilege. Well, I think that a good parent does everything they can. You know, I don't consider it 12:44 privilege, I consider it good parenting. You should do everything you can to advance the interests of your children. That is good parenting, and that includes uh that includes, you know, trying to advantage them by by living a good life. 13:00 So, you know, that's that's how I think the sins of the father are visited on the children. I forget how many generations the Bible says, but it does seem to actually happen because it takes it can take several generations to dig out of the hole that the parents caused. So, 13:17 yeah, your children are going to be largely, their start will be largely dictated by by you. 13:23 That's how it works. Children start are largely dictated by their parents. Not fair necessarily, but that just is how the world works. Uh this basic morality, the basic morality that that that Genesis basically, you know, it starts with, with Adam and Eve, Cain and Abel, what 13:39 have you. Uh that sparked both the Judeo-Christian culture as well as the Judeo-Christian morality. 13:45 And uh it is our country slowly drifts away from those things, uh, we're seeing a split emerging within conservative circles in terms of how much power the government should have to uh to preserve those things. 14:00 We can't really talk about morality without also talking about sin. And and sin operates the same way shock comedy does, if you remember Andrew Dice Clay. Uh in that there's kind of a sweet spot where the sin is exciting without being so transgressive as to 14:18 move beyond something that somebody would actually be tempted to do. No, just as shock comedy, you know, it operates in exactly the same sweet spot where a statement is offensive, but not enough so to stop being funny. No, and you listen to Andrew Dice Clay, you 14:32 know, when he was when we were young, it was the shock of I can't believe he said that made us laugh. And uh, you know, it actually happens with shock comedy. 14:42 It's not so much that you find it funny as that it's so shocking that you don't know how to react. And one of the natural reactions to a situation like that is to laugh. Uh the problem for those to succumb to temptation is that the rush they feel in doing so requires the same 14:59 kind of escalation that shock comedy requires. 15:02 And shock comedians always eventually become so offensive as to turn off even their core audience, which is exactly what happened to Andrew Dice Clay. He's back now, he never entirely went away. I saw him in an interview once, and he said, You have 15:17 to understand, I'm not Andrew Dice Clay. I don't talk to my wife the way I talk on stage. I am Andy Clay. Andrew Dice Clay is different. He actually goes, at one point he went into a story about how he discovered the Dice Man, but that was a character he played. The Dice Man 15:33 was not who Andy Clay is. And when you when you when you see him in in, he's in he's in movies. He's in what with Lady Gaga about Once Upon a Star becoming whatever it is, becoming a star with that real popular song, that duet. I forget the name of 15:48 the movie, but he actually played Lady Gaga's father in that. So, you know, he's very, very different when he's not playing the Dice Man. Andy Clay and Andrew Dice Clay. The actor plays the part, but it's not really the same, you know, person. Uh, but that's 16:03 what Sin does. You know, consider uh, for example, a married man who who may begin just by exchanging flirtatious messages with a coworker. 16:11 You know, that's I don't want to say it's entirely harmless, but it's it's it's harmless enough. Um and at first the secrecy and the suggestion of it, you know, it's it's exciting. And that it provides enough excitement that the guy uh, you know, it's exciting. But 16:27 then as those exchanges start to become familiar, uh they need to become more intimate to recapture the same level of excitement. It's like a dopamine hit. And once you have had uh dopamine at a certain level from a certain activity, you need you need more 16:42 of the activity to get the same level of dopamine, I guess is what I'm saying. 16:46 Well, so those exchanges are soon going to become something more like sexting, which will eventually lead to an affair. A wife, of course, is more apt to forgive her husband if she finds out about the first few text messages and intervenes at the time before it 17:00 goes too far than she is to forgive her husband if it does develop into a full-blown affair. I think in some cases when somebody is doing things that lend toward affair, uh, they're probably best off if they get caught early because uh, you know, the wife 17:14 is far more apt to forgive you if she finds out about a few flirtatious messages than if she finds out that you've been, you know, having an affair with this person for like a year. I mean, just nature of the beast. The greater the transgression, the 17:26 more it's gonna separate you from your wife. 17:30 Uh that's just the way it is. I mean, it's I think that's how people behave. 17:34 And uh, the same thing is true in terms of sin, in that the the more we sin and the more sinful we become, you know, as the sin escalates, and it goes from a small sin to a slightly larger sin to a slightly larger sin to a slightly larger sin, and so on, you 17:51 know, so too we are becoming more and more separated from God as we move into that sin. Those who believe in possession, uh, in fact, they describe how it works in the exact same context I just used to describe sin, except that they attribute the sin 18:07 to an outside force. Temptation once followed becomes more extreme over time. Then comes obsession, infestation, possession, and finally subjugation. I'll give descriptions for each step. 18:21 That's not going to be because I believe in actual possession, but because the steps are illustrative of the process through which we can become captured by sin. 18:31 It starts out with extreme temptation, exploiting a person's desires and weaknesses to encourage wrongdoing. Next comes obsession. The temptation increasingly occupies the person's thoughts. Next comes infestation. 18:44 Evil gains a deeper foothold in the person's life. Next comes possession. The demon takes control of the host's body. Finally, subjugation, the culmination of it all. Domination with a demon claiming ownership of the person. I did a movie review that did a great 19:02 job of I forget what the movie was called. Nefarious, that was what the movie was called. If you haven't seen it, it's a great movie. Very few people, and it's really about uh a mass murderer and and a psychiatrist that has to determine whether or not 19:14 he's competent to be killed. And uh great movie. Uh and it goes through this very, very clearly. But that's actual possession. I mean, in the movie, there's an actual demon possessing this guy. It is actual possession. 19:28 And uh, you know, not everybody believes in actual possession. I I don't know that I believe in it. I guess I kind of do believe in the key in the concept of it, but I don't know that there's you don't need to have a demon. I mean, let's use the exact same list, but 19:41 I'll remove all reference to religion and we'll we'll see what it looks like with all religious connotations removed. Exact same things, we're just taking out the religious connotations. So we start still with extreme temptation, desire becomes powerful enough 19:54 to make wrongdoing deeply appealing. Then we go to obsession, thoughts increasingly revolve around satisfying those desires. Then we go to infestation. I'm using the same term, but I'm gonna take the person out. So these last three involve somebody else in the word, but in the 20:08 description, I'm going to take out that other person or that demon and just make it, you know, without another person, just just sit escalating. Uh so infestation then is the behavior becomes embedded in everyday habits and routines. Possession 20:22 becomes the compulsion, increasingly governs behavior despite efforts to resist. So at this point, it's like an addiction. You're addicted to the dopamine. 20:31 Finally, subjugation. Life becomes organized around serving the compulsion regardless of its consequences. 20:37 A sex addict, for example. 20:40 And uh just like that, remove religion out of those descriptions. We have the exact same steps, but now we're talking about psychology instead of religion. Why does that work so well? Well, because the Bible is a very old book. Even the part that we call 20:55 new is two thousand years old. It was written by ancient man in an attempt to explain the world around us and our relationship with it. It was an honest attempt to explain the world around us and our relationship in it. I'm a Christian, I believe that 21:10 it's actually God's word through men, but still inspired by God. I believe that. But you don't have to believe in God to see the wisdom in the Bible. It was an honest attempt to explain the world around us and our relationship to it, written over thousands 21:28 and thousands of years. Genesis goes back, nobody even knows how long. It would have been an oral history told around the campfire by the Israelite people, long, long, long before Moses wrote it down. We give Moses credit for writing the first five books of the 21:42 Bible, the Torah and Judaism. Um, but but Genesis, he he may have recorded it, but he didn't write the stories that are in Genesis. Those have been passed down for but possibly millennia before they were ever written down. 21:56 So these were stories that were, and these weren't told by historians either. The concept of history is a modern concept. These stories were not told by historians, and they didn't really have a concept of history in the way we do today. So they would have been 22:11 very, very concerned with making the stories easy to remember, and they would have been more concerned with preserving the morality of the time or of the message, the of a parable obviously teaches a lesson. They would have been more concerned with the lesson than with uh 22:25 with with literal truth. That is to them, that would have been a history because it's a history of their people, it's a history of the morality that they learned over time, it's a history of how you live with the world. It's hard-earned lessons. 22:38 And of course, of course, there's going to be wisdom in that. So, of course, the steps those who believe in literal possession observe are going to be the same steps that lead people to become overcome by sin to the degree that they then begin to 22:55 demand. In our case, what's happening in America today, they demand that the rest of society glorify their sinful behavior. We see that around us all over the place. People demanding that their sinful behavior not be called sin, but instead be glorified. 23:12 We also have the concept of repentance in the Bible. And here is how the American Heritage Dictionary defines the word repent. 23:22 To become a more moral or religious person as a result of remorse or contritions for one's sin. Contritions, it's not a plural, contrition for one's sin. Now, if you want to turn that into philosophy, or psychology, rather, just like I did with uh with the steps 23:36 of possession, all we have to do is remove one word and rephrase another. And then it becomes to become a more moral person as a result of remorse or contrition for one's moral errors. All we're doing is taking out the religion, and now again, you know, 23:51 it's it's psychology. Now I am a Christian. 23:54 I believe that repentance brings us closer to God. But one need not be religious to understand that acting in a positive way when we feel bad about something we did helps to make us better people by discouraging us from doing it again. But here's the thing 24:11 about repentance. It's personal. 24:14 Many people act as if nations need to repent, but nations have no ability to do so. Only individuals can repent. 24:24 Even when people support a nation doing something evil, repentance must come from those who support it. Nations can pay damages, as Germany did after World War II, actually, after both World Wars, they paid damages after World War I as well, which was part of the reason 24:38 we had World War II. Uh but they did that by taxing people. The nation didn't pay it, the people in the nation did. 24:47 I guess that's my point. So people can collectively feel remorse, but collectively feeling remorse is still remorse at an individual level, just with multiple multiple people feeling remorse at the same time. 25:01 The fact of the matter is that we have choices. We can sin or not. 25:06 If we sin, we can then repent or not. When people say that we're sinful creatures, that doesn't mean that we sin every time temptation comes knocking at the door. I think most of us do not. I think most of us are generally good people. But temptation 25:20 does not just knock at the door and oh, I guess nobody's home and leave. No, it might walk around your house and peer through the windows and then knock on the door again. And uh and then it does that again, and it does that again. We're tempted all the time in our lives. So 25:35 when people say that we can't that that we that that we are sinful people or that we cannot avoid sin, well, we can avoid it in individual circumstances and individual cases, but we can't do it consistently enough to live with God. We had to be 25:49 separated. Well, that's what happened to Adam and Evate from the apple. They committed sin, and having been having brought sin into their into their being, into their lives, they were no longer qualified to live in the garden directly with God. So they had to be 26:03 separated from the garden. It's the same thing here. We we could avoid sin you know in individual circumstances, individual cases, but we are not capable of avoiding sin all the time. 26:16 Sometimes temptation does get the better of us, and and that's true of all of us. 26:21 That's it's unfortunately one of the things that makes us human. Jesus is the only human being who has ever lived that could avoid committing sin in all circumstances, and Jesus, of course, was also God. So this is repentance is an individual thing 26:38 as sin is. We all have choices and we all make them as individuals, or we do not make them at all. Multiple people can do the same thing, and they may be encouraged by one another to do so. 26:51 If you sinned, I encourage you to repent. 26:54 Uh, and that may affect you. You may then decide, okay, you know, he's talking about cheating on his wife. I have been sending some text messages, I haven't. I'm gonna tell my wife and get her forgiveness before it goes too far. That would be a form 27:05 of repentance. But though I can encourage you to do it, I can't force you to do it. You have to make the individual choice to do that yourself. The interesting thing is, liberals used to believe in individual rights, just as most conservatives do. Over time, 27:20 however, modern liberalism is split further and further away from classical liberalism, which we now call conservatism, and they have done so over the question of collective guilt. Now, classical liberalism is not a phrase that I can find in my American Heritage Dictionary, but 27:38 it is in the Encyclopedia Britannica, which calls it an early form of liberalism. The political philosophical doctrine, which holds that the central problem of politics is the protection of individual freedom or liberty. The term classical liberalism may also 27:52 refer to actual political systems that instantiate classical liberal principles. The Encyclopedia Britannica goes on to say, and I'm going to read a couple of paragraphs, both classical liberalism, which was first articulated in England in the mid-17th century, and 28:05 modern liberalism, which was predominant in Western Europe, North America, and elsewhere for much of the 20th century, hold that government is necessary to prevent individuals from being harmed by others. 28:16 They also recognize that a necessary role of government is the provision of public services that prevent that private businesses are incapable of performing fairly or efficiently, such as law enforcement, education, health care, national security, and 28:29 sanitation. All forms of liberalism, however, seek to limit the powers of government because government itself can pose a threat to individual freedom. The problem that liberalism in general addresses then is that of devising a system that gives government 28:43 the power necessary to protect individual freedom, but also prevents those who govern from abusing that power. It continues. 28:59 Contemporary liberals in the classical tradition, the so-called neoclassical liberals or libertarians, answer that it is. Modern liberals, however, have insisted that the powers of government can promote as well as protect the freedom of the 29:14 individual. Indeed, according to modern liberalism, the chief task of government is to remove obstacles that prevent individuals from living freely or from fully realizing their potential. Obstacles such as poverty, disease, discrimination, and ignorance. That's the end of 29:28 the Encyclopedia Britannica quote. Now I agree with the Encyclopedia Britannica that there was a form of liberalism that dominated the 20th century. But though it was it was not the same as conservatism, of course it wasn't. They were separate parties, liberalism 29:46 and conservatism. But it was still within a classical liberal framework. We're talking about the 20th century, we're talking about your parents Democrats. 29:55 Modern liberalism, as defined by the Encyclopedia Britannica, involves a supposed freedom from want, in which the government assumes the power to provide. 30:05 And for the government to give something to one person, it must necessarily take it from someone else. Because the government doesn't actually have anything to give away. And with that, ladies and gentlemen, it is time for a word from our sponsors. You can reach our 30:20 sponsors directly by going to AmericaOutloud.news slash shop or by clicking the shop button at the top of the website. Don't go anywhere. We still have a lot to cover on the other side of the break. Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, are you ready? 30:36 Because your nose is about to witness the biggest breathing breakthrough on the earth. Introducing built on the 30:46 roll through your thing, 31:02 breathing power.com, 31:07 comfortable your nose, this is one of the greatest brain in the universe. Breathe better, live better. Your heart is the most crucial muscle in your body. Are you doing enough to keep it strong? Introducing the Wellness Company's 31:20 Breakthrough Healthy Heart formula, designed by Dr. Peter McCullough, now upgraded with taurine. This daily supplement supports cardiovascular health and works to protect cells against oxidative stress. Packed with D-ribose to boost heart function, taurine to help maintain 31:35 heart and muscular health, coenzyme Q10, and selenium citrate to help reduce risk of cardiac disease, and a vitamin B complex with L-carnitine for energy and muscle support. Endorsed by the wellness company's chief medical board, this formula is your 31:49 ally for heart health. Reclaim your health now at twc.health forward slash out loud and use code OutLoud for 20% off your first order plus free shipping. Are you tired of struggling with low energy? We get it. That's why we created organic energy juice. 32:05 In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle with low energy again. And it tastes amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low 32:18 energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. 32:21 If you're struggling with low energy, then buying organic energy juice is the right decision. With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. 32:34 That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. 32:40 Welcome to the secret completely updated license. 33:23 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back to Cutting Through the Chaos and the America Out Loud Network. 33:27 I'm your host, Wallace Garneau, and we have a lot to talk about, so we're gonna get right back into it. We're gonna talk about classical liberalism and modern liberalism at the break. I'm just gonna get right back into it from where I was there. 33:41 I said the last uh before the break, I said that I agree with the Encyclopedia Britannica that there was a form of liberalism that dominated the 20th century, but it was not the same as conservatism. However, it was still within a classical liberal framework. And then 33:55 I talked about modern liberalism uh having a supposed freedom from want, in which the government assumes the power to provide. And I said that for the government to give something to one person, it must first take it from someone else. This in turn creates the question 34:09 of who the government should take from and who the government should give to. And that opens the door for something very different, which is collective guilt. Collective repentance then becomes a call for reparations to cover the supposed collective 34:23 guilt. Now we like to say that white people had black people as slaves, which is why the idea that white people should pay black people reparations is in the public space. That's why so many people think that's the case. 34:36 But it's actually more accurate to say that some white people had some black people as slaves. We like to say that the nation allowed slavery, but it's more accurate to say that the specific states allowed slavery, not all of them, some specific states allowed slavery, whereas 34:53 other states did not. And the federal government really stayed out of it to the degree possible for the nation's first 72 years, which is when the Civil War started, going from the Constitution being being uh taking effect, not going back to 1776 but 1789. 35:08 Anyway, if guilt and repentance were collective, then someone could get repentance without taking any personal responsibility by apologizing for whatever group they are a part of. When white people apologize for their whiteness, they are doing precisely this. 35:23 It's performative but not meaningful, and they feel morally superior to other white people through their performance. 35:31 Collective guilt and collective repentance also leads to mob mentality, and I can think of no better illustration of possession, which we also talk about before the break, than what happens to individual people when they become part of a mob. The mob does not need a literal 35:47 demon to make this happen either. For all practical purposes, the mob is one. Over the past twenty-six years, modern liberalism has used collective guilt to try to limit opportunity for some on the assumption they can then provide opportunity for others. This is DEI. The best the 36:06 government can do in this capacity, however, is to give jobs to people who are unqualified and then to watch them fail. That's not to say that everyone who uses the term liberal to describe themselves follows this. It just means that the party as a group has 36:21 been moving in that direction, and those who do not follow it are increasingly finding themselves without a political home. When I talk about groups, by the way, I'm not talking about every individual in the group. I want that to be clear. I'm talking about the group 36:35 as a whole. Now I've often argued that what today constitutes modern liberalism was created in reaction to Richard Dawkins' book, The God Delusion, published in 2006. Dawkins argued that science is absolutely no explanation for free thought, and 36:49 that as such, free thought does not exist. 36:53 Dawkins asserted that there is no rational difference between believing in free thought and believing in God. The argument actually goes back further. It goes back to B. F. Skinner in 1971, but I don't think Skinner's Beyond Freedom and Dignity had the same effect on the national 37:08 discussion that Dawkins did. Dawkins' book spent 51 weeks in the New York Times bestseller list, and I think sometimes a repeat drives a concept deeper into the public conscience. Also, Skinner challenged autonomy, autonomous agency and free will, 37:23 but not all the way to the existence of free thought. So Dawkins, I think, taking that next logical step and saying that free thought does not exist, I think that matters. 37:31 Dawkins wrote that our brains are computers, driven by programming, DNA, and data, or lived experiences, and acting in entirely predictable ways upon those things. As Dawkins put it, we are mere meat machines that are sufficiently complicated to think 37:45 that we think, but actual free thought and free will are simply not possible under natural science and thus cannot exist outside of a purely religious context that Dawkins says any rational person should reject. This denial of agency gave 38:00 the fractured left something it had previously lacked. 38:03 An intellectual rationale to unify is disparited movements. 38:06 The Marxist could now say, well, the worker has no responsibility, clash position determines behavior. The Malthusian could say reproduction cannot be restrained, biology compels it. The Lenskyite could say truth is irrelevant, and people cannot be persuaded, only conditioned. 38:20 And the environmentalist could say humanity is inherently destructive, being programmed to consume. Now, before Dawkins, these ideas sat uneasily alongside one another, contradicting as often as they overlapped, but with 38:33 Dawkins, those contradictions began to dissolve. By declaring that free will is an illusion, he provided a common foundation on which each faction could claim scientific authority for its rejection of human responsibility. It was Dawkins' denial 38:48 of agency that split modern liberalism fully off from classical liberalism, whether he intended that or not. See, liberty requires agency, and the denial of agency then is a license for control. Now the post-liberal right arrives at the 39:04 question of agency from a different direction. Its concern is that people cannot exercise freedom responsibly without first learning how to do so. Families, religious institutions, and communities teach the obligations that make freedom possible. If those institutions collapse, 39:19 leaving people free will not restore their ability to govern themselves. Their argument is that a child does not arrive in the world understanding responsibility, and an adult does not automatically become responsible. We learn from others, and the institutions 39:33 surrounding us can encourage restraint or indulgence. The post-liberal believes that a society organized around individual liberty gradually undermines the authorities that teach restraint. Post-liberals want government to serve what they call the common good. Protecting 39:52 individual choice, they say, is insufficient if the choices society encourages leave people isolated, dependent, or incapable of fulfilling their obligations. 40:02 They argue that political authority is a duty to redirect people toward human flourishing through law and established custom. Individual freedom must be relegated within that purpose. A classical liberal like me can agree that freedom requires moral formation. 40:17 Recognizing that responsibility, however, does not to the classical liberal like me mean that the government should have the authority to, should have authority over the moral lives of its citizens. 40:28 I mean, looking back at Cain, God warned him and addressed his conduct and held him responsible for his choice. And Cain needed instruction, but instruction did not remove his responsibility. He could accept correction or reject it, and he rejected. The failure then was his. 40:46 A government can restrain a man from harming another, and it can punish him if he does commit harm. It can also protect the freedom of those who would teach him to live differently, but compelling outward obedience cannot by itself make someone repent. That still 41:02 requires the individual. Nor does giving political authority resolve the problem. Cain does not become able if the government acquires the power to enforce a moral code. He just tries harder not to get caught. Post-liberalism must explain 41:16 both how public authority will support moral formation and how that authority will be restrained when its holders become convinced that their wrongdoing serves a righteous purpose. Appealing to a shared moral order does not answer the question. Cain had 41:31 received moral instruction directly from God. 41:34 Denying agency can justify managing people as products of their circumstances. Affirming agency while giving institutions comprehensive authority to direct its exercise creates a different danger. The individual remains responsible for 41:47 choosing wealth while losing the freedom to make their own choices. Both bring us back to the same political question. What authority may one fallible person legitimately exercise over another? Classical liberalism places individual rights and responsibilities at the center. 42:04 Modern liberalism increasingly focuses on relationships between groups, while postliberalism emphasizes the moral order within which individuals live. Those priorities shape what each movement expects institutions to do. An institution charged 42:20 with protecting individual rights has a different mandate from one charged with correcting structural inequities or of cultivating a shared moral order. Each mandate also requires an answer to what happens when an individual's choices conflict with the institution's 42:34 purpose. Postliberalism affirms that people make meaningful choices, but it gives formative institutions a central role in teaching them to choose well. 42:44 That brings us to a question that is a little harder to answer. Where does moral formation end and coercive control begin? 42:52 Well, to follow these differences from philosophical primary season to the actual exercise of political power, we would need to ask four questions. 43:00 One, what should society look like? Two, what power should the government have? Three, how should government be structured? And four, who should control the government? Politically we tend to focus on two to four, but really question one is the critical one. 43:15 Question one being, what do we want society to look like? Now a classical liberal has an easy time with this question as they would deny that anyone has a right to decide what society should look like for anyone else. Society is the classical liberal, not a 43:29 single thing, but the conglomeration of everyone who happens to be in society. Each person has a right to decide for themselves how they will interact with the rest of society, making what society looks like a collective decision we may all make as a function of simply 43:46 living our lives. The classical liberal, what society looks like, is derived rather than determined. 43:52 Modern liberals necessarily reject this view. 43:56 Marxists, Malthusians, Alinskyites, and environmentalists all presuppose the right to define what society should look like, and then to mold society into that vision. These groups exist, in fact, out of the presumption that society left to its own devices does not look the 44:13 way they want it to and is thus broken. If we deny agency, then Elon Musk has not done anything personally to justify his wealth. He's just a meat machine reacting to DNA and lived experiences. I could take anyone else, and if they have similar enough DNA 44:28 and the same experiences, they will do exactly what Elon Musk has done. Exactly. Similarly, without agency, I have no reason to blame a criminal for the crimes they commit. They may be preordained by their DNA to commit crimes, they may be driven by lived experiences 44:43 to do so, or they may be driven by a combination of those things. But they have no more control over their behavior than a stone has over falling if I drop it. See what Dawkins gave was the justification for society to manage. The denial of agency 44:57 also explains the bizarre cultural paradoxes of the modern left. Queers for Palestine sees Palestinians as oppressed, which excuses them from all responsibility, even when they want to kill gay people. 45:09 With agency denied, the oppressed can never be guilty, no matter what they believe or what they do. They are simply reacting to their oppression, and there is something wrong with us, in this view, for allowing them to remain 45:23 oppressed. To the modern liberal, the Palestinians would not want to kill gay people if the Palestinians were not oppressed. Terrorism is not their fault, it's our fault for holding the terrorists down. If Dawkins is correct, we are meat 45:36 machines, it is possible to control humanity by controlling our inputs, including our lived experiences. The purpose of the media and everything else the public can see, hear, or experience in any way, it ceases to be about truth. 45:51 Without agency, the only purpose for information is to fill our heads with whatever data will optimize our behavior. The purpose of the media in this environment, it's not to inform the public, but to program it. The question of truth isn't even relevant. Now, 46:09 the elite don't see themselves as meat machines, though. Logically, they kind of have to view themselves along those lines, but there's a big difference between believing something on a logical basis and emotionally connecting with that belief. As 46:23 Jordan Peterson says, people act out their true beliefs, and the elite behave as if they believe in their own agency. It is just the rest of us that they seek to control. As the Encyclopedia Britannica says, liberalism in the 20th century began to move away 46:37 from negative rights and toward positive rights, removing obstacles such as poverty, disease, discrimination, and ignorance. Modern liberalism is the logical progression of this view: the belief that the government exists to provide freedom from want for 46:53 a public that lacks agency. For most of American history, both parties have been dominated by classical liberals who differed in whether they were more afraid of government controlling our culture and morality or of controlling our economic 47:06 freedom, but who still broadly believed in limited government and free markets, just at a different level of balance. The difference now is that the Democratic Party is increasingly controlled by those in the left who have expressly rejected classical 47:20 liberalism, leaving people like Bill Maher, Tulsi Gabbard, Bobby Kennedy Jr., and others without a political home. To the modern liberal, people are for the most part interchangeable. The differences between people can best be understood by 47:34 looking at the systems of privilege and oppression that they live within. Society can be optimized by reducing the differences between people, and the world can be optimized by reducing the differences between different societies. 47:48 Interestingly, this has created a mirror image within conservative circles, with some conservatives also breaking away from classical liberalism, wanting to use the powers of government to restore the morality and culture modern liberalism seeks to destroy. This is the 48:02 post-liberal movement that we've been talking about. Post-liberals view individualism as the cause of multiculturalism. And uh they see collective control over the institutions of power in order to enforce a post-Enlightenment Western 48:17 culture, really of their choosing. This moves us on to the second question: what powers should government have? Well, this too is very easy for a classical liberal answer. It should only have as much power as the government needs to protect the liberty of the people. For 48:32 both the modern liberal and the post-liberal, both of whom want to define what society should look like, limiting government to the power necessary to protect liberty is grossly insufficient. It is, in fact, the liberty of the people that 48:44 these groups believe gave us the broken society we currently have. And you hear this in their language. Post-liberal Patrick Dienon wrote in his book, Why Liberalism Failed. Liberalism has failed not because it fell short, but because it was 48:57 true to itself. It has failed because it has succeeded. Bertie Sanders said on the floor of the Senate, the economy is rigged, our campaign finance system is corrupt, and we are struggling to control climate change. The Democratic Socialists 49:10 of America says right on their website, capitalism is a system designed by the owning class to exploit the rest of us for their own profit. Alexandria Casio-Cortez can't leave her out. 49:19 She said in an episode of the Tightrope, our politics is so broken right now is because our relationships to one another as a society are really deeply broken. And uh against the dead consensus, a 2019 post-liberal manifesto, all of the authors, or several of 49:35 them, including Patrick Deanan, uh wrote, the fetishizing of autonomy paradoxically yielded the very tyranny that conservative conservatives, consensus conservatives claim most to detest. Now, I don't think many people can read something with language like the fetishizing of 49:50 autonomy paradoxically yielded. Uh, but Vice President J.D. Vance takes Patrick Deanan seriously. I would argue that modern liberalism's focus on multiculturalism, moral relativism are the reasons our societies become morally and culturally 50:06 fractured, and that the fastest way back to a unified nation is to return to classical liberalism. I would argue, in fact, that the classical liberal belief that each person should be free to live their lives however they wish, provided they allow everyone else to do the 50:20 same. I would argue that that carries an inherent moral compass within it, which we talked about earlier. One person's freedom ends where another's begins. Now you can pack a lot of morality into that one little rule. The fact of the matter is, sins that don't harm 50:35 others really can be left for God to judge. It's not my job to judge other people. My job is to live my life by God's moral rules, to repent when I fail, when I sin, and I leave judgment to Jesus. That's his job, not mine. I wouldn't want that job. So I can do 50:51 that. Uh the point is that where classical liberals see each individual as a moral agent with inherent rights and responsibilities, both the post-liberal and the modern liberal see the individual as something for society to control. And once people 51:03 are no longer seen as moral agents with inherent worth, they become either resources to be optimized or problems to be solved. Groups like the World Economic Forum and the Club of Rome, in fact, make this explicit with their degrowth rhetoric. Let's move on to our third 51:19 question. How should government be structured? Well, this question is much more easily answered by the modern liberal or the post-liberal. The Democratic Socialists of America calls for the Senate to be abolished, for the present Supreme Court to be 51:30 chosen by Congress and subordinate to Congress. Congress consists solely of the House of Representatives and would become a parliament. Parliament then would have whatever power parliament wants over both the states and the people. Not all modern liberals and 51:43 democratic socialists are democratic socialists, and theirs is the extreme view, but it is also where all of the energy on the political left is. So we should view this view as the direction the modern left is heading. 51:55 Now, post-liberals want the constitutional framework that we put in place, classical liberals put in place to control government, to limit government, but they want the limitations removed. They're okay with how the government is currently structured, but they want 52:08 to remove the limits that the Constitution places on it. This brings us to our final question: who should control government? The classical liberal answer is the people, the representatives exercising through representatives exercising the limited powers the people have 52:21 authorized. This is done not only to avoid the abuse of power, but also to avoid the concentration of power. Modern liberals and post-liberals faced a contradiction. They claim to govern on behalf of the people, but neither accepts the society the people have created. Both want 52:38 government to reshape society, which means overriding the choices of the people from whom they claim that their authority comes. A movement that supports democracy only when the public makes the desired choice necessarily places its agenda 52:52 above the consent of the governed. It must either accept that people are free to reject its vision or it must seek enough control over society to prevent rejection. To the degree that a movement rejects the agency of the people it governs, control, of course, becomes 53:08 an easy choice. Preserving our republic then requires more than putting the right people in office. 53:13 It requires limits that bind those people when they get there. And the public will defend those limits even when they obstruct some of our own personal political goals. We can disagree about society, which society should look like while recognizing one another's right to help 53:30 shape it. We can promote our beliefs, but it's build institutions around them and persuade others to join us. What we cannot claim is unlimited political authority to make everyone else conform. In other words, preserving our republic requires a lot less cane and a lot more 53:46 able. When people fail to build the society they want through their own efforts, an example, they can reconsider their conduct, or they can seek the power to compel others to produce the desired result. These are the same choices 53:57 Cain had, and like Cain, their disappointment becomes a justification for controlling someone else. The modern left and the post-liberal right offer different visions of society, but each must answer for the authority it claims over the people who 54:11 reject that vision. The sins of the father tend to be visited on the son, and Cain's story begins with his parents, Adam and Eve, who also faced a moral boundary, a temptation, and a choice. God had warned Adam that eating from the forbidden tree would bring 54:25 death. The serpent's first lie contradicted God. You will surely not die. The serpent then promised to benefit. Their eyes would be opened, they would become like God, knowing good and evil. 54:37 Sin then was presented as growth. The way things actually worked out was exactly as God had warned. Adam and Eve, now aware of good and evil, found that they could not always avoid the temptation of sin, and being sinful, they had to be expelled from 54:52 God's perfect garden. Being expelled from the garden also meant to be removed from the tree of life, and that meant they would eventually die. The promise that greater power will become safe once righteous people possess it requires us 55:04 to forget what Genesis teaches about those people. 55:07 They remain capable of temptation and self-deception. 55:11 Adam blamed Eve and implicitly God for giving her to him. Eve blamed the serpent. 55:16 Cain denied knowing where his brother was. Wrongdoing was followed by an effort to escape personal responsibility, and no office, institution, or declaration of moral purpose removes that human tendency. We cannot preserve our republic by pretending that liberty frees us from 55:34 moral obligations, nor can we preserve it by surrendering those obligations to people who promise to make us good. We have to exercise responsibility ourselves and accept limits in the power we wield over others, including when we believe our 55:48 purposes are righteous. The warning to Cain remains a warning to each of us. Sin desires to master us, and we must master it. 55:57 We cannot fulfill that obligation by powering by acquiring the power to master everyone else. No, we fulfill that obligation by acquiring the power to master ourselves and in doing so to master our desire for the sin lurking at our door. And just like that, ladies and 56:15 gentlemen, we're out of time, but that's okay. 56:17 I got through the whole thing. Uh, as always, thank you for tuning in. Please tell others you might be interested in Cutting Through the Chaos to listen in either on Saturday and Sunday at 9 a.m. Eastern Standard Time, Sunday at 10 p.m. Eastern Standard Time, or 56:30 on podcast whenever they have the time. And we will see you the same time and same place next week, where it will once again be time to get involved and to get loud on America Out Loud. 56:42 Loud.
Community discussion