0:07 Mainstream media has betrayed our trust. Rather than tell us the whole story about the important issues of the day, they tell us only what they want us to hear. Your hosts, Tom Harris and Todd Royal, will bring you The Other Side of The Story. 0:27 The scientific method is one of humanity's greatest achievements because it provides a reliable way to separate fact from belief, evidence from opinion, and knowledge from superstition. For most of human history, people explain natural events through myths, tradition, 0:43 authority, or religious interpretation. 0:46 Disease, earthquakes, eclipses, and other phenomena were often attributed to supernatural forces. 0:53 The scientific method transformed this understanding by requiring observations, testable hypotheses, experiments, and independent verification. 1:02 Ideas could no longer be accepted simply because they were widely believed or promoted by powerful individuals. Instead, claims had to be supported by evidence that others could examine and reproduce. This commitment to evidence 1:18 makes the scientific method essential in court cases involving scientific or technical issues. Whether the subject is DNA analysis, forensic evidence, medical causation, environmental impacts, or product safety, legal decisions should rest on objective, 1:34 verifiable facts rather than speculation, ideology, or emotional persuasion. Courts exist to deliver truth and deliver justice. When scientific questions arise, the scientific method provides the most dependable framework for evaluating 1:50 competing claims and reaching fair, rational, and evidence-based conclusions. But this ideal is now being violated by the National Academy of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine itself in their How the Science Works chapter of the reference manual on scientific evidence. In 2:09 today's episode, I'm going to be speaking about this with Dr. Sharon Camp. She's the senior education advisor for the CO2 Coalition at CO2coalition.org. She is also the writer of the CO2 Learning Center lesson plans. The CO2 Coalition is a very important Arlington, 2:27 Virginia-based 501c3 nonprofit group. Dr. Camp has a bachelor's degree in geology from the University of Georgia and a PhD in analytical chemistry from Georgia Tech. 2:39 She's worked in industry for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and as an advanced placement environmental science teacher. Dr. Camp was certified to teach grades 9 to 12 in the state of Georgia and has 20 years of experience as teaching as a science teacher. Before 2:56 her recent retirement, she taught high school advanced placement environmental science for 15 years. 3:02 She was a reader, which is a grader, for the yearly national AP Environmental Science Exam for 9 years. So she's a great person on the show to talk about education, science, and what's really going on with this how science works chapter. So welcome to the 3:20 show, Sharon. Thank you, Tom. I appreciate it. 3:23 I'm glad to have the opportunity to talk to you. Yeah, that's great. So could you tell our listening audience about the CO2 coalition? 3:31 Some people may not yet be familiar with you. Oh dear. That's a shame because we're we're a wonderful organization. We were established uh in 2015, uh, and our surviving founding member is Will Hepper. 3:46 And he brought us about to help us share with educators, leaders, policymakers, everybody that can make a difference about how important carbon dioxide is as far as its positive contributions, not only to our lives, but to the economy. And so things that we like to point out 4:08 are we wish to have informed and dispassionate discussions about climate change. We want to make people aware of humans' role in the climate system and most especially the limitations of climate models and the consequences of the mandated reductions in CO2 emissions. So 4:31 nobody could call you folks a climate change denier organization. Well, um, yeah, they I mean they could. They wouldn't be accurate, but they could. We've got members from all over the world, over 200 members, uh most of whom are PhD scientists. We have economists, 4:49 we have energy specialists, we have engineers, but the the bulk of our organization is all people with high education and professional backgrounds. And our emphasis is on the data, it's not on modeling. In fact, that's one of the big things, the alarms that we want to 5:06 call to everybody's attention is the emphasis on modeling and taking it away from actual experimentation and measurements of empirical data. Yeah, yeah, exactly. And what's the URL for your coalition? 5:23 CO2coalition.org.org, okay. Good. We'll link to it in the podcast when it goes up on Monday. Now, eight months ago, you wrote an article. It was titled Muddling the Judiciary's Understanding of Science. You wrote that for what's up with that. And it criticized a chapter in the 5:41 reference manual on scientific evidence. In particular, the chapter is called How Science Work. And I was just um checking the web last night, and it's still there. So, I mean, can you tell us first of all what both of these things are, the chapter and the 5:55 reference manual, and how they're intended to be used? Well, the reference manual was written by members of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. This is their fourth edition. 6:07 So it's it's not a new publication. And the purpose of this is to help judges in making decisions about different scientific topics. Actually, it was written for the federal judicial center, which is established by Congress. And the purpose of it was to, according to them, 6:29 support the efficient and effective administration of federal courts through research and continuing education of judges and court employees and its separate status within the judicial branch, its missions, its specialized expertise, enable 6:46 it to encourage critical and careful examination of waves to improve judicial administration according to them. That's part of the actual manual. And essentially it's it's there to help judges with, as I said, scientific topics. The people that are on this panel are judges 7:09 and professors, policy fellows, the authors of this particular section on how science works. One of them has a PhD in philosophy. The other one has a PhD in integrative biology. I tried to look up what integrative biology was because I hadn't clued what that was. Um, it I know 7:31 that it is a major that's offered through Berkeley, University of California Berkeley. 7:38 And I am not sure if anybody else has this particular major. I went online to see what kind of courses they offered, and it was close to a hundred that ranged everywhere from educational techniques to you know some hard science courses, but not it was it's sort of 7:58 like getting a PhD in in science education, where the emphasis is on education and and not so much on the the deep and heavy science. Uh, I kind of got the impression that that's what the integrative biology was. Like they they don't go deeper in any one topic other than 8:17 just maybe a quarter or two. And then it looked as if the students themselves get to decide and design their own curriculum, is kind of what I uh interpreted. Uh, the person that has a degree in integrative biology actually works with paleontological museum at 8:35 Berkeley, at mostly in their education department. 8:38 So none of these people have got what I would consider a hard science degree. Oh, that's not so good. Maybe then maybe they're not familiar with the scientific method. Well, it kind of looks that way uh when you read what they what they put. And so 8:55 they wrote this guide that is supposed to explain to judges how science works, uh, with a preface from uh Justice Elena Kagan. 9:04 So that's that's kind of the background about what this document is and and what its purpose is. Yeah. So let's take a step back. And can you explain what the scientific method actually is before we actually look at whether or not the how science works chapter 9:18 actually reflects the scientific method? Well, okay, that's you know, that's very good. Um, the scientific method, pretty much every adult has been at least told what the scientific method was. There are a few that actually use it on a regular basis, 9:36 like I don't know, automobile mechanics will use a scientific method all the time to solve problems within the engine of a car. So it's it's not something that's just only used by scientists, but the traditional steps are you uh start with your background 9:53 research and then you come up with a testable hypothesis. So testable means that you can either refute it and say, yeah, well, this was this was like totally off the wall, or maybe you could support it and say, well, yeah, it looks 10:08 like I'm headed in the right direction. Hypothesis is simply an educated guess. It's a fancy word for an educated guess. And you then you go about designing an experiment, which in my experience as a grad student was the hardest part of the whole scientific 10:24 method. That could take like months to get everything just right. And then once you finally got your experiment all set up, you collect data, and then from that you draw a conclusion, you go back to your hypothesis and say, yeah, this hypothesis was supported or no, 10:39 you know, we're way off base, and then you communicate the results verbally, written, journals, whatever. And so the the scientific method is usually going to be some kind of variation of this, because not all questions lend themselves easily 10:58 to performing experiments in a lab. But that doesn't mean that you can't use the scientific method still to come up with answers to a hypothesis, and and that's essentially it. So, you know, we can go into definitions of the scientific terms, which which I hope to 11:14 be able to do with you. But that's that is essentially the scientific method in in a nutshell. Yeah, for sure. So it's evidence-based. 11:22 I mean, you're you're not just taking consensus or you know, politically correct points of view and assuming they're right. You're looking at the evidence, and it may be contrary to your hypothesis. That's exactly right. Yeah. It's all evidence-based. Yeah. So why is the how 11:38 science works chapter in particular not a reflection of how the scientific method is supposed to work? Well, let's start with their definitions of of the major scientific terms that everybody has heard, but probably has a slight misunderstanding of what they are. Okay. Um 11:57 so a hypothesis, I as I said, it's an educated guess, is what it is. 12:03 And so what they define it as being is a potential explanation for a natural phenomenon, regardless of the extent to which the explanation has been investigated or the amount of evidence supporting it or refuting it, which is uh a whole lot of mumbo jumbo, because 12:27 essentially what you have to do is develop a testable hypothesis, which means that you can simply write a question that is easily answered. And that's what testable means. There is a hypothesis, a type of hypothesis called a null hypothesis, which 12:45 means basically that whatever variables you introduce are going to have absolutely no effect on the system. That's the easiest to disprove, because if you have any kind of effect, then you've supported your hypothesis. They define a theory as being a 13:02 concise, coherent, and predictive explanation for a broad range of natural phenomena that integrates and makes sense of many hypotheses. There's nowhere in this definition at all that says anything about empirical data. It doesn't say anything about it being well 13:24 substantiated by a large body of evidence that has been rigorously tested through the scientific method. They just, you know, they just say, oh, it's a predictive explanation for a lot of stuff. That's that's essentially their definition. Uh, then we get down to scientific law. A 13:42 law is a statement that describes or predict a range of natural phenomena based on repeated experiments or observations. Examples of laws that everybody you're familiar with probably would be Newton's laws of motion. Let's say. 14:48 Um, which which might help with airborne diseases, but what about all the waterborne diseases, right? You know, as soon as they were they were able to demonstrate that diseases can be transmitted through water, polluted water, like this whole thing had to had to be 15:03 tossed out the window. That's a theory you don't hear about anymore because the germ theory did a much better job of explaining what was going on. So they define a law as being an often mathematical statement of the relationship among observable 15:19 phenomena, which doesn't say anything about repeated experiments, observation, rigorous testing, nothing. So they're already kind of loosey-goosey with their definitions. 15:31 Yeah, it's interesting. I know science is a search for truth, but uh I wanted to bring up something that we've we've discussed in other programs with with other guests, and that is that, you know, Al Gore says an inconvenient truth when he talks about climate change. 15:46 But you know, there's a professor I took a course from online, Professor Goldman from Lehigh University in Chicago. He's actually uh a philosopher. 15:55 He has a PhD in philosophy, although his undergraduate degree was a Bachelor of Physics. And he he actually says this, and maybe you can take this apart and tell me if you think it makes sense. He said that in science, unlike chess or you know, things 16:09 where we make up the rules, there is no such thing as truth, or at least we don't have it. He said basically, what people think about science is based on their interpretation of the data that they happen to have. And of course, interpretations can vary even 16:25 with the same data, and different scientists can have different data. I mean, surely it's it's not truth, it's just their opinions based on their observations to this point. Well, I'm gonna push back a little bit, okay? Yeah, yeah, I hope so. Um, the first thing you have to do is 16:42 is understand what empirical data is, right? 16:46 And it again, observations. We could make it really, really easy, like saying the sky is blue. And if if somebody wants to come up and say, Well, you know, my truth is that the sky is actually pink and you just perceive it as blue, like, where 17:03 is your evidence to support that? There is there is a scientific definition for blue, it has to do with the wavelength, the specific frequency of light. Okay, it is a it is a defined range in color. Take a look at the rainbow. Each one of 17:20 those represents a the whole rainbow represents a range in frequency of visible light that you can see, and this spectrum goes way, way, way long and way, way, way, way short. But the only part that you can see is the visible part, and blue is defined 17:40 specifically as a range of wavelengths of light. 17:44 Okay. So if you just want to say, well, my interpretation and my truth is that it's a different color, it's like, well, what if I get a spectrometer out and measure the actual wavelength and demonstrate to you that it's a blue? Is that going to change 17:58 your mind about your truth? This is the problem that I have with a statement like that. Well, also, I mean, I suppose there's a difference between what's practical in the real world and what is theoretically, you know, the case. Because um, you know, what you have 18:14 to deal with some truths in the world, otherwise you can't function. 18:18 That's true. Yeah, yeah, exactly. If you slam into a wall, you're gonna get injured, right? 18:24 Yeah, yeah, yeah. You can hardly say, well, it's it's your interpretation of the pain in your body. Exactly. Yeah, I see. 18:31 And you can see, you know, it's interesting because the whole postmodern movement with critical theory and all that, they say everything is based on your interpretation of your truth. And and that gets kind of dangerous if you're in a spacesuit and say, well, my truth is 18:44 that I don't need a spacesuit. You go outside, you go outside and you find out pretty quickly that there is a truth with respect to that. Yeah, exactly. And it's not the one you wanted. Yeah, so now you're right that the How Science Works chapter includes 19:00 an over-reliance on the unproven assumptions of computer models and the acceptance of consensus as proof, even when they're contradicted by empirical evidence. Can you say more about that? Because that sounds like something out of Alice in Wonderland. 19:16 Okay, so let's talk about what a what a scientific model is. There are actually two types of models. The first type of model is something that you can comprehend, maybe touch, feel, that helps you to understand a complicated system that you don't have the ability to actually 19:38 see. A great example that of that is the model of an atom, right? It really depends on what level of physics you're at as to how complicated you want your model to be. Most kids are taught this the simplest model, which is you got a nucleus 19:55 that's made of protons and neutrons, and then you have electrons that circle it. That's that is a model. It's a it's an attempt to help you understand a structure that you cannot touch, see or feel. But then there's the other kind of model, and that's the 20:08 predictive model. That's like a weather model where you put in you put in data and it spits out your prediction as to what the weather is going to be. So all of us have experience with that. And sometimes it's really it's pretty accurate, especially when there's 20:23 going to be no change in the weather, right? And then other times it might be really inaccurate. Uh, and the and the kind of detail that determines their accuracy depends on the kind of detail they want to give you. So, for example, they say, 20:39 Well, you know, it's gonna snow, but it doesn't start until one o'clock in the afternoon. 20:44 And you look out at nine in the morning, it's snowing, right? They blew it. They they got the snow part right, but they missed the time frame. This is a predictive model. And in the what house science works section, they put a tremendous amount of emphasis and importance on 21:02 predictive models. This is their definition. 21:06 A model is a mathematical representation of a hypothesized mechanism and interactions within a system that can be used to investigate the impact of parameter changes on predicted system outcomes, and they include it as a model as a form of scientific knowledge. So 21:28 if you made it through all that mumbo jumbo, hopefully the first thing you noticed is that they use the word hypothesize, a mathematical representation of hypothesized mechanism. Hypothesis, remember, is an educated guess. It doesn't have the same strength as 21:45 a theory. Or a law. Right, exactly. It's it is it's still an educated guess. Okay. 21:53 And then they use that to predict system outcomes, even though what they're using all their math models are guesses anyway. And then they have the audacity to say it's a form of scientific knowledge, which is a red herring right there. Okay. 22:14 And so you can you can assume that these hypotheses were not supported by rigorous testing, they weren't supported by the scientific method, they weren't, they weren't tested by observations. Essentially, they start on assumptions. 22:30 And the first assumption, of course, that they start with is that increase in carbon dioxide causes increases in temperature. When there's a whole lot of evidence to support the fact that this is not necessarily the case, but we can go into that later. Um, and 22:48 then the other thing that they say is that the fact that there is room for improvement in the process of science doesn't necessitate a distrust of the hypotheses that have gained widespread acceptance in the scientific community about which consensus has been achieved. So 23:09 let's let's put that in in you know plain English. It really doesn't matter whether or not this hypothesis is accurate. There are a whole bunch of people that seem to believe that it's right because of consensus, and because there's a lot of consensus that 23:27 we don't need to distrust this hypothesis, even though we haven't been able to prove it through experimentation and data collecting and empirical data. 23:36 That's what they're saying. It's basically just trust us because the consensus knows what's best. Yeah, you pointed out in your article that about Wegman who talked about continental drift, and the consensus said, no, no, that's not true. And 23:49 it wasn't until after he was dead that they realized that, oh, he's right. Yeah, exactly. 23:54 You know, because they dug and they found more evidence. And a geology is also a great example of how you can learn stuff about the history of the earth without setting up an experiment, per se. 24:11 Geologists can't set up an experiment. How do you set up an experiment to explain all of the different movements of plates on the planet? I mean, you know, you can you can sort of kind of come up with stuff, but you can't actually do an experiment 24:27 that that proves that. And in fact, the model of the earth and and how the tectonic plates move has changed even over the last 20 years or so. They have a completely different explanation now. It used to be they thought it was all due 24:42 to convection currents in the mantle, and they've found out since then that there aren't really any convection currents in the mantle. So they believe it all is driven by changes in density. Uh, completely different model, completely 24:54 different. They didn't do any experiments to do this necessarily, but they did have uh special imaging techniques that allowed them to see the structure inside the earth, primarily through earthquake waves and such, that demonstrated that you 25:09 know there really aren't any convection currents going on. So, you know, what is going on? 25:14 So it it you don't have to have an experiment, which is the other thing that they point out. It's like, well, the scientific method is too constructive and it isn't necessary because it promotes linear thinking and not everything can be performed with a with an 25:28 experiment. And the answer is, yeah, but that doesn't make the scientific method wrong because you you come up with a hypothesis, you collect as much data as you can, even if it's not through experimentation, and then you decide whether or not these observations support your 25:45 hypothesis. So that's right. That's the key. 25:49 If you have you have to have empirical evidence to either support or contradict it, or it isn't really following the scientific method at all. Exactly. And consensus doesn't count. If it's science, it's not consensus. If it's consensus, it's 26:03 not science. Thank you, Michael Crichton. Yeah, well, you might remember the quote from Albert Einstein when they had a hundred scientists who disagree with Einstein, the book that was published shortly after his theory of relativity came out 26:15 when he was still in Germany, and they asked him about it, and he said, Why 100? If I was wrong, one would be enough. 26:24 Which I thought was quite quite poetic. Yeah. 26:26 It almost makes you wonder, you know, just before we go for the break, one quick question. It makes you wonder if they designed this How Science Works chapter so that it could be used to support the climate alarmist point of view, because I mean it's based 26:39 on hypothesis and computer models, not you know, not supported by empirical evidence. Do you think they had that perhaps in mind when they wrote this chapter? Well, I don't like to speak to anybody's frame of mind when I don't even know these people, but 26:57 the fact of the matter is that they took a perfectly good section on how science works that was in the third version of this judicial manual written by an experimental physicist, a PhD physicist from Caltech. And they took it and they replaced 27:18 it with this nonsense. So, what was their motivation? Uh, you'll have to ask them. Let's just say that they came up with a grossly inferior product compared to what they had before. Yeah, it just makes me suspicious, though, because that's the kind 27:35 of argument that's used to support the climate alarm. Anyway, our guest is my guest today is Dr. Sharon Camp. She's the senior education advisor for the CO2 Coalition. You can check them out on the web at co2coalition.org. We'll be right back after the 27:51 break. Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, are you ready? Because your nose is about to witness the buildings, breathing breakthrough on planet earth. 28:02 Built on food, fuel body volatile, rolls three or four.com. 28:27 Before your nose, this is not on the brightest brain in the universe. Brain's better, live better. Successful weight loss is about changing the gut-brain relationship with food. I'm Dr. Kelly Victory with the Wellness Company. If you don't 28:41 like needles, you'll love oral dissolving terzepitide RX. Works by targeting the GLP1 and GIP receptors that influence appetite and metabolism. And unlike injections, these are fast absorbing sublingual tablets placed under the tongue, paired with an energy boost of B6 and B12. 28:59 Visit Twc.health slash OutLoud and use code OutLoud for an exclusive discount. Are you tired of struggling with low energy? We get it. That's why we created organic energy juice. In just one minute, you'll have clean, natural energy all day and never struggle with 29:16 low energy again. And it tastes amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants that make you crash. You shouldn't have to struggle with low energy, and with organic energy juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low energy, then 29:29 buying organic energy juice is the right decision. 29:32 With our double your money back guarantee, there is zero risk to try it. Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out loud. In a world of rising prices, you can still grow abundance. I'm Doug 29:49 Evans, author of the national bestseller, the Sprout Book. Sprouts grow in three to five days without soil, sunshine, or fertilizer on your kitchen countertop for under a dollar a serving. 30:01 Take control of your food and your future. 30:04 Visit thesingcompany.com slash out loud and use the code OutLoud for an exclusive offer. Grow food, not fear. Are you looking for healthy snacks, but you've had enough of all the sweet sugary energy bars? Good news. There's a new bar to try that's 30:19 savory, crunchy, and packed with goodness. Bear bars are based on just six simple natural ingredients: a certified organic veggie nut and seed bar that's low temp dried, never baked or fried. 30:30 Bear bars are plant-based, gluten-free, and loaded with nutrients and protein. Head over to bear bar.com forward slash out loud and get the exclusive discount just for America Outloud listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud. 30:44 I challenge you to find a great, great voice, a deep bench of experience dedicated to life. 31:12 So I'm back with Dr. Sharon Camp. She's the senior education advisor for the CO2 Coalition that you can check out on the web at CO2coalition.org. She also writes CO2 Learning Center lesson plans. So, Sharon, I was hoping we could switch over 31:28 to talking about the actual science of climate change. And I wonder, is this undue regard for models and consensus is that typical of the climate alarmist argument? Uh pretty much. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You know, they'll make absolutely absurd statements like the 31:47 oceans are boiling, right? Oh, yeah, that's right. 31:51 There will be no more snow by 2020, or just completely totally absurd statements. And they've been doing this for over 40 years. 32:00 None of their predictions have come true, even the ones that are based on the models. 32:05 In fact, the models have been running too hot for a long time. And they finally, finally, I say they, I think it's the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the IPCC, that after 40 years has finally admitted the fact that their worst-case 32:22 scenarios were like not even plausible. 32:26 They just took them off the record because they they were so absurd. And so this is where they come from. They don't have any hard evidence. One, to show that any kind of dramatic rise in temperature is caused by carbon dioxide. How far do you want to go? Oh, I don't know. 32:45 How about uh 500 million years? Will that work for you? You know, we could go back a little bit further if you want, but 500 million is where we have really good data to show that the CO2 went up and down and up and down and the temperature varied. And they didn't they didn't 33:01 do it together at the same time in sync. So you can go way back and see that there's literally no strong correlation between the two. Yeah, I get the impression that's why geologists are rarely interviewed by the media because because they would look at 33:16 today's changes and they say, Oh, that's nothing in comparison with what's happened throughout geologic history. 33:22 Yeah, I mean, pretty much. Let's just, you know, let's just look at the the ice ages, for example, you know, they which we are which we are in. Did you know that there are at least 60 different episodes of glaciers expanding and retreating in the last 10 to 20,000 33:40 years? 60. Wow. Yeah, yeah. And in certain areas, they have records of it of them expanding and contracting at least 60 years. 33:48 Uh so 60 times. 33:51 60 times in how many million years? No, no, no, thousands, 20, 10 to 20,000. Oh, I see. So they have like little mini glaciations where it advances, comes back, advances, comes back. Yeah, glaciers are incredibly dynamic. 34:06 They grow, they expand, which is like not what you want to happen because there are stories of during, you know, the earliest part of the little ice ages of the glaciers coming and and uh destroying towns and villages, sort of like you know, a 34:23 lava flow, you can't stop it. Um, and then then there are other places like in Alaska where the glaciers have retreated to the point where they show these giant tree trunks that clearly was a forest that had been destroyed by the glacier, and now the glacier 34:37 retreats. You see the remains of no, it's interesting. I just want to go back to that because I don't think very many people realize they seem to most people seem to think that there's one big mass of glaciation and then it retreats, and that's it. But 34:51 you're saying within that time frame, thousands of years, not millions, thousands of years, there's little many advances in it and retreats, 60 of them, you said. Yeah, that in fact, uh, there's a lot of that evidence that shows up in in southwestern Canada and 35:07 northwestern Washington, the northern part of the state of Washington. There have been all kinds of sediment studies that have demonstrated that. That's that's really interesting. Yeah, so Tim Ball was showing, you know, the c historical climatologist, he was 35:21 showing trees, fossilized tree trunks in areas that are now, you know, they they're basically way too far north for it, the tree line. 35:29 And so, I mean, it shows that you know, we had warm periods in the past, no question about it. Right. Now, the the position of the CO2 coalition is that the current rise in CO2 is causing a very gentle warming, which is beneficial for the growth of crops, for the 35:50 for the greening of the planet, for the reduction of desertification around the earth, and that there is a small correlation there. 35:58 But also, our physicists will point out that there is a saturation point uh above which it doesn't matter how much more CO2 you add, there is no increased warming. 36:11 Like it's its primary effect occurs at small concentrations, but the greater the concentration, the less of an effect it has on warming. So we don't deny that there is a correlation. We just don't believe that you're gonna have out-of-control runaway 36:31 climate doom if the if the carbon dioxide levels get higher. In fact, in geologic history, they've been over 2,000 parts per million several times in the history of the planet. So it and that's when plants like thrived. They are happiest when 36:51 you've got levels of between 800 and 1200 parts per million. And so when you have these levels of very high carbon dioxide, the plants, the plants pretty much explode in growth. 37:02 Did you know that there is a minimum amount of carbon dioxide below which the plants will die? Yeah, exactly. What is it around 150? Yeah, I I think it's uh between 120 and 150. I don't remember what the exact number is, but it it's right there. 37:18 So plants will grow. Well, I know it's it's plant fertilizer, right? Somehow these people forgot their carbon cycle and photosynthesis, sodasynthesis, and the fact that we all life forms on our planet are carbon-based, and that carbon comes from carbon dioxide. 37:38 All of that, um, but yeah, as you increase the levels of carbon dioxide, you see increased greening of the planet. And what's even more interesting is that we have compared data showing increasing carbon dioxide with crop yield, and found in, I think we've done about 37:58 six or seven states now. And in every single state, as you increase the levels of carbon dioxide, you increase the crop yield. There is a direct correlation between the two of those, whereas you won't see it with temperature at all. Well, and that's interesting. Just to 38:14 go back to those numbers, 800 to 1200 that plants really like in parts per million. 38:19 I should just underline the fact that today we're only a little over 400. So that would suggest, and uh, and I know 800 and 1200 is not dangerous to humans at all. What that would suggest that we should hope that it increases to that kind of 38:32 level. You betcha. That's one of the things, yeah. That's one of the things we're trying to explain. The the the interesting fact is that greenhouses will pump carbon dioxide into their greenhouses to make to increase the strength and the growth of their 38:48 plants in the greenhouse. Yeah. So would would they pump in up to 800 parts per million into a greenhouse? Uh I think it depends on the greenhouse and the plant. 39:01 But yeah, they can they can get up that high. Yeah, exactly. Now I'm gonna read to you some quotes from the How Science Works chapter and ask you to comment on it. The first one is the chapter says that science cannot, in quote, disprove hypotheses. I mean, what do you think 39:19 of that statement? It sounds like it doesn't make any sense. Well, I mean, it's totally false, completely and totally false. Of course, you can disprove a hypothesis. That's that's the whole purpose of coming up with a null null hypothesis. It's easy to disprove. Okay, it can 39:36 support a hypothesis, you can't prove it, but you can support it. One of my brother's favorite examples is the black swan. 39:44 Okay, so you've seen all you've ever seen in your whole life is a white swan, and so you come up with with a law, or or we could just make it a hypothesis. We don't even have to go to law, we could just start with hypothesis. 39:58 Your hypothesis is all swans are white, every single swan you've ever seen in your whole life is white, right? And then you see a black swan. What happens to your hypothesis? It's wrong, it's wrong, exactly. You know, so as long as you keep seeing white swans, your hypothesis 40:20 is supported. But as soon as you find that that one black swan, then you realize that your hypothesis is false. And you if you're a an honest scientist, you toss it out the window and start all over again. The whole yeah, the whole purpose of 40:36 a hypothesis is it's an educated guess, right? 40:39 So your guess is either on target, you got a good guess, let's keep going, or it's completely wrong. Start all over again from scratch. 40:49 It's interesting. So so I mean, you're hoping your car mechanic he actually is able to disprove hypothesis as he tests the part of your engine to find out what's really happening after he thinks something is happening, he gets in and tests it to see if it 41:02 really is happening. So it's the scientific method, obviously, should be employed throughout our lives. Yeah, it's pretty much everywhere. Yeah. Now they're right. 41:10 Now read this quote, it's a bit long, but tell me what you think of this. 41:14 They say, quote, in the context of testing hypotheses, the term prediction refers to a logical consequence of a hypothesis, not necessarily what will happen in the future. Huh. 41:26 They gave a new definition, yeah, for the word prediction. Because, you know, there are a lot of people that'll do that these days. 41:33 They'll take a word and change the definition, and that's essentially exactly what they did right there. Prediction by everybody's measure is what you think is going to happen in the future. And then to say, well, not necessarily, is it's a you know, 41:48 it indicates either your ignorance or your intent to mislead. One of the two, because prediction to everybody means what's going to happen in the future. Yeah, yeah. It's almost like they're defining a new kind of language the way they do in postmodern postmodern theory. 42:05 You know, I heard that there's even now postmodern engineering, if you can believe that. I mean, it sounds like it's a good way to have your bridges fall down. Now, you you write about the yeah, you're right about the importance of testing, observation, and experimentation. 42:20 All three can be disproven, of course, but do the writers of the chat of the chapter, do they actually acknowledge that? Um not really. No. I don't think there's nowhere, anywhere in this how science works things that they talk about testing, um, 42:38 collecting empirical data. In fact, they they at the very beginning, they start off discrediting the scientific method. That's like the very first thing they do right out the gate, hence their emphasis on modeling, because we're supposed to believe 42:50 that you can take these hypotheses, which aren't necessarily a prediction of the future, and then use them to predict the future, and have no way to support that they're even accurate. This is what this is what they think science is. Yeah, it's it's like Alice 43:09 in Wonderland. And you're here's a quote from your article. I was hoping you could you could talk a little bit about it because it sounds ridiculous and dangerous, even you say, quote, the authors support, quote, using consensus as 43:21 a defense against evidence that challenges a popular narrative. Like, what that consensus doesn't prove anything. 43:31 No, consensus doesn't prove anything, but that's that I mean that's what they throw in your face. The National Science Teaching Association is a perfect example of that. 43:43 They have a NSTA statement on climate change. If you want a real good entertainment, you should sit down and read their statement. Oh, okay. Because essentially what they said is this is not open for discussion, we're going with a consensus. And if you don't 43:59 agree with a consensus, then you're wrong. Yeah, you're in the wrong field. You're you know, you're wrong. It's like, well, it's a good thing that not all scientists feel that way because the one guy who stands up and says, no, this this ain't right, this doesn't 44:13 make any sense, is the one that makes the new discoveries, right? Exactly. It's not the people that accept the consensus when it when it's poorly defined and has no evidence. They're not the guys that come up with a new with a new understanding and 44:31 learning. They're you know, they're the ones that go along for the ride and we stagnate. 44:36 Yeah, well, it's interesting. Einstein, you know, I I visited his office in Princeton. I don't know if you've ever been there, but they've kept it to you know, the with his blackboard, it still has his writing on it, it's kind of exciting. And um apparently he 44:49 had a picture of Ein of uh Newton on his wall. He was a real fan of Newton, but of course, he showed that there are cases where Newton's laws don't work, and he, of course, questioned the consensus. And it's funny because he would say to himself, 45:02 apparently, according to his autobiography, he'd say, Please forgive me, Sir Isaac, because of course he didn't agree with the great Isaac Newton on some things. So you're right. I mean, it was Einstein that was, you know, the the oddball, but he was he turned out to 45:16 be right. So now you say in some places that these how science works chapter is actually self-contradictory. Can you give us some examples of that? Yeah. Okay. 45:28 So uh if there's an example that they use over and over and over in this document, is if these are the only two scientists who ever carried out any kind of experiment. Um, and they're the two scientists who study the concentration of chlorofluorocarbons in the atmosphere and 45:47 associated them with the destruction of ozone. Okay. 45:51 And so they talk about here they're going to test a hypothesis. Remember that before we didn't have to test a hypothesis, but these guys are great because they did. And their hypothesis is what happens when the concentration of 46:04 these chlorofluorocarbons in the atmosphere increases. 46:08 This requires accurate measurements of the levels of CFCs. And then other scientists incorporated these ideas into their models and they made predictions about what was going to be observed. And so the point being that predictions seem to be important in 46:27 supporting a hypothesis, but then they say in another part of the same document, in the text of context of testing hypotheses, again, the term prediction refers to a logical consequence of a hypothesis, not necessarily what will happen in the future. They they make a 46:44 big deal about saying, oh, well, they came up with this hypothesis and they made predictions and they were all correct, and isn't that wonderful? And then they say, but you know, uh prediction isn't really a logical consequence, so you know it's not necessarily what's going to 46:58 happen in the future. So which is it? 47:01 Yeah, it it it's almost like they're trying to finesse the whole argument. In doing so, they've they've destroyed their argument. Pretty much, yeah. 47:10 Yeah, here's an here's another example. Uh, they state the hypotheses are judged according to the specific evidence relevant to them, and scientists are expected to give up a previously accepted hypothesis if new evidence or interpretations 47:25 warrant it. Okay, we're good with that so far. That makes that's what you're expected to do, right? But then at the same time, they also say but the fact that there's room for improvement in the process of science doesn't mean that you have to distrust the 47:40 hypotheses if they've gained wide acceptance about which consensus has been achieved. Okay. So it's like, okay, so you give up a hypothesis if you don't have the evidence to support it, unless it has consensus, in which case it's okay that that there's nothing to support it. Like 48:04 the whole town thinks this woman is a witch, so we're gonna burn her at the stake, and that's a good enough argument. The whole town thinks it. Exactly. You know, same idea. So two perfect examples of contradiction within this document. Yeah. 48:20 It it's sort of embarrassing for the National Academy of Science, Engineering and Medicine, isn't it, that they would ever have published this in the first place? Well, let's just say that we have issues with them as well. 48:33 We've written letters and all kinds of stuff. 48:35 Uh, of course, it's gotten nowhere. But yeah, we we're not necessarily in agreement with a lot of what they say. Yeah. So so at this point, is the chapter correctable? You know, is it like a minor tuning, or and I think I know the answer to 48:49 this question, but or should it be deleted and they go back to the original version? 48:54 Yeah, they should go back. It's like there's surprisingly little science in their document, and they clearly have no clue how science works. So I I don't think I think it should just be tossed and go back to the one that was written previously. But see, the one that was 49:12 written previously, they didn't have the emphasis on consensus in modeling because this guy is a physicist, right? Yeah, you know, and so he he wasn't he wasn't involved in this climate change debate nonsense. And consensus is only consensus when you can provide 49:30 evidence to support your argument, and as soon as somebody else provides evidence that refutes your argument, then you've lost the contest. Yeah, you know, according to them, if you've got consensus, it's science. So have you seen have have have they have 49:45 they budged at all? Like have they given any indication that they might pull that chapter completely? Uh it's one person who's responsible for that. And as far as I know, no. 49:56 Yeah, they pulled out the whole climate change thing. So I guess this was their this was how they agreed. It's like, okay, so we'll pull this other one, but we want to leave the how science works part. Uh-huh. 50:10 So it was made maybe a political deal, a deal. That I think, I think they dealt. That was that's just uh that's just a guess uh hypothesis on my part. Well, we're gonna have to re rename the National Academy of Sciences to the National Academy of 50:24 Pseudoscience. Because it really is it is a kind of pseudoscience, isn't it? Well, yeah, uh there really is no science in the how science works chapter at all. Yeah. Yeah. So getting back to the CO2 coalition, you know, I find that your website is really fun 50:40 to explore. And one of the fun things that you do is you make it easy for children to learn, don't you? So, I mean, can you tell us a little about that? Because you've got a science learning center. 50:50 Is that what it's called? Yeah, it's called the CO2 Learning Center. So um we are constantly coming up with products for the the target age right now is K through eight. Um part of the reason for that is that they have not been fully indoctrinated. That usually 51:12 occurs mostly in high school, although I understand it's you know starting earlier and earlier. Um, and of course, the the people who are the most open to our products are the homeschoolers because the public schools, again, I read you about 51:28 the ninth the national science teachers statement. 51:31 And we even took our uh our materials to one of the conferences and were told by the teachers that even though they agree with them, that there's no way that their administration would let them use it. But in the meantime, you have uh all these materials 51:45 for parents and for teachers, and everything that we have is free because we're a nonprofit. And a lot of the people who contribute to our organization do so because they are the most excited about the education center, the learning center. So we have a 52:03 group of five books that are all written as graphic novels that are totally free, that come with free lesson plans, which are downloadable online. And in fact, if you wanted a PDF version of the book, you can get that for free also. But the you can get hard copies of the 52:21 book simply by writing to our executive director, and she will get it in the works and send them to you for free. No should be hanging or anything. Yeah, we'll we'll include her and name and address in the in the write-up. Um, well, yeah, one book 52:33 I have here, which is quite fun. I leave it out on my coffee table for all of our friends when they come over. 52:38 Oh, look at this. They pick it up and they scroll through it. It's uh Chloe the clownface. Chloe. Yeah, can you tell us about that little book? Because, you know, that to me is first of all, it's beautiful. 52:49 But secondly, uh it's amazing how many people look at it and they smile and they look through it. Yeah, Chloe. Chloe is the first in what we call our sleep well series. We have also published uh Freddy the Fruit Bat, and we've published uh, we just came out with Polly the 53:07 Polar Bear. We're in the process of coming out with Holly the Holstein, and each one of them I call their mythbuster books. So they're written in simple language. The illustrations by our illustrator, Tiago Hellinger out of Brazil, are just absolutely stunningly 53:26 beautiful. He does a fabulous job of the illustrations, and each one of them tackles a myth and then uses science to shatter the myth. So Chloe is about uh the myth being the death of the Great Barrier Reef, which actually in and measured in 2024 had the the most 53:48 increase of growth of any time in its history that it had been measured for like over 30 years. Um the second one, Freddie the Fruit Bat, is about the the big uh lie that the Maldives are going to be sinking into the ocean because of sea level rise. And then we explain that not 54:07 only is that not happening, but why it's not happening. Um, the third book, which is Polly the Polar Bear, has to do with polar bears, which are you know the poster child for climate change. Their population has tripled in my lifetime from about 10,000 to 54:23 30,000. And the reason for that has to do with the with uh passage of the marine mammal protection act, which makes them all protected and you can't hunt them anymore. And if they're coming at you and trying to attack you and kill you, you do have 54:38 permission to shoot them. That's good, yeah. 54:42 And there are a lot of people, especially up in in Greenland, that will walk around with like giant guns, shotguns and whatnot, yeah, to protect people because the polar bears, polar bears are vicious, vicious animals and terribly frightening. But you know, 54:59 they're they're making a comeback. So that that's what Polly is about. Now, Holly the Holstein is about the methane myth that methane is causing you know increased climate change because it's a greenhouse gas. And actually, there are a couple of scientists that 55:18 use data from Australia to demonstrate that, given everything we know about methane and it's you know 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide and so on and so forth, that the amount of change in temperature, if Australia were to get rid of all of their sheep, 55:39 would be something that would be so small you couldn't even measure it with a thermometer, much less notice it. Yeah. So that's a that's another myth that we're uh that we're shattering. And and it's part of the sleep well series. That makes sense because I guess 55:54 anxiety about climate change is a is a serious thing, isn't it? About among children. It's a serious thing about child, yeah, for children. 56:02 You can't tell little kids, you know, your world is gonna burn up within your lifetime. 56:06 You can't tell them that and expect them not to be anxious about everything, you know. 56:11 And the irony of it is that they teach them all this stuff in school and then they complain about the anxiety in our children. It's like, well, yeah, you're doing it, you know. Stop it. Yeah. So people can get that if they go to the website, 56:23 CO2coalition.org, right? Yeah, they're all free. 56:26 Everything is free. Yeah, that's great. Well, my guest today has been Dr. Sharon Camp. She's the senior education advisor for the CO2 Coalition. 56:34 And she's one of the writers, she's the writer of the CO2 Learning Center lesson plans right now. So that's really something that people have got to check out, especially the homeschoolers. 56:43 So thanks so much for being my guest today, Sharon. It's been my pleasure, Tom. Thank you for having me. I appreciate it. Okay, well, this is Tom Harris, my guest, Dr. 56:52 Sharon Camp, signing out from The Other Side of The Story.
Community discussion