Show full transcript 0:43 from anywhere. 0:44 If she's ever unsure, if she locked her door, she can check in the app, lock it 0:47 from there to give her peace of mind that her home is always secure. 0:50 She can even monitor the cameras from the app to check in with family or friends 0:53 as they arrive. 0:54 Yeah, that's right. 0:54 Our CEO is a woman. 0:56 Damn right. 0:57 We partner with SimplySafe. 0:58 To all of our listeners, the biggest savings of the year, 70% off your new system with 1:01 professional monitoring. 1:02 When you visit SimplySafe.com slash Crooked, that's SimplySafe.com slash Crooked, and when 1:06 you order, type in Podsave America, check out, it lets them know we sent you, and it 1:10 really helps the show. 1:10 So go to SimplySafe.com slash Crooked, SimplySafe, ahead of crime in real time. 1:15 CrookedCon is coming up right after the election, and we have just added a bunch 1:19 more great names to the lineup. 1:20 We got Governor J.B. 1:21 Pritzker coming. 1:22 Senator Chris Murphy and then over from the house side, Ilhan Obar, Robert Garcia, Sarah Jacobs, Jamie Raskin, Sarah McBride. 1:29 We also have Carlos Eduardo Espina, Simone Sanders Townsend, Eugene Daniels, David Pakman, Jessica Tarluff, Heather McGee, 1:36 and then all the other people that we've announced on the website, plus more to come. Great list. 1:40 Check out the full lineup and get tickets right now at CrookedCon.com. We'd love to see you there. That's CrookedCon.com. 1:46 Welcome 2:07 to Pod Save America. I'm Tommy Vitor. It is only two days until the midterms. Two days 2:13 until election day. And we are all just refreshing those polling sites as fast as we possibly can 2:18 to deal with our anxiety to see what's going to happen, to figure out what the numbers tell us. 2:24 So I brought in an expert today. We are going to talk with CNN's chief data analyst, Harry Enten. 2:30 You can find him on CNN. He does hilarious and really informative bits with John Berman 2:35 on CNN on TV, you can also find him on the Inton scale on CNN All Access and Harry does 2:42 exclusive data coverage for CNN on YouTube. We spoke on Friday. We broke down the kind of 2:48 broader mood music of the electorate and what he's seeing in polling. We talked about the 2:52 odds of Democrat taking the house. We walked through all the Senate races to see what the 2:57 Democratic chances are in each. We also talked about some concerns about polling and response 3:03 and whether pollsters are getting enough Republicans on the phone to get accurate samples. 3:09 It was a great conversation. I think you're really going to enjoy it. 3:12 But also, on the midterm night, you don't have to go it alone 3:16 because to celebrate, to commiserate, to do both, Alex Wagner is going to do a live stream. 3:22 She's going to be joined by a bunch of your favorite cricket hosts, including me, Stacy Abrams, Aaron Ryan, 3:27 Dan Pfeiffer, love it, Favro, everybody. 3:30 It's all happening on the Pod Save America YouTube channel 3:33 on Tuesday, November 3rd at 9 p.m. Eastern, 6 p.m. Pacific. 3:38 So come check it out. 3:39 Subscribe to Pod Save America on YouTube 3:41 so you don't miss it. 3:42 Now, here's Harry. 3:43 Harry Ensign is the chief data analyst for CNN, 3:46 but he's so much more than just the numbers guy. 3:48 He gives you the data with pizzazz, 3:50 usually with my friend, John Berman. 3:52 I love the kind of routine you guys have with Harry. 3:55 Great to see you, buddy. 3:55 Ah, you know what, anything to help brighten people's mornings with a little bit of numbers. 4:01 You get both your vegetables, but you get a little dessert as well. 4:04 We'll see about the dessert. 4:06 For those just listening and not watching on YouTube, by the way, subscribe to Pod Save 4:09 America on YouTube. 4:10 What are you doing? 4:11 We're trying to build a progressive counterweight to all the right-wing crap on YouTube. 4:14 Harry's got like a beautiful mind background with lots of graphs and charts and numbers. 4:19 I assume it's all just nonsense here you made up, but it looks cool. 4:23 You know what? 4:23 any comparison to Russell Crowe I will take. Yeah, well, you do look like a young Russell Crowe. 4:27 You also seem to be Donald Trump's favorite TV personality or CNN personality. He said, 4:33 this is a quote, the best person on CNN is pollster Harry Enten. Is that because he thinks 4:38 you're hot and have a great ass? Oh my God. Look, I can't comment on other people's backsides. 4:46 I'm about what's up here. I'm pointing to my head. I'm not as much as what is on my back. 4:52 But, you know, maybe he watches, you know, in that case, he would be of the same opinion 4:57 as my mother, that is, I'm a good-looking young Jewish boy. 5:00 Okay, so let's get to the polls, not the ones, anyway. 5:04 Big picture, historically speaking, one of the iron rules of politics is that the party 5:10 in power loses seats in the midterms. 5:12 There are some exceptions, but most of the time the president gets punished in the 5:17 midterms, especially when his approval rating is low and 5:21 Donald Trump's approval rating is quite low. Set the table 5:24 for us. What is the historical average in terms of the hit the 5:28 party in power takes? And how do you think Trump's current 5:30 approval rating impacts the likely outcome here kind of just 5:34 big picture? 5:35 Yeah, okay. So, you know, you sort of teed it off there if 5:38 I didn't believe three midterm elections since the civil 5:42 war in which the White House party did not, in fact, lose 5:45 seats in the House. 34 with FDR was one, Bill Clinton 1998 is two, and George W. Bush in 2002 5:54 coming off a 9-11 is three. It would be highly unusual for the White House party not to lose at 6:01 least some seats going into a midterm election. To add that to the fact that there are only 6:10 two presidents, by my count, besides Donald Trump, who had a sub minus 15 point net approval 6:17 rating, that's approval rating minus disapprovering, only two others besides Donald Trump, who 6:21 had a sub 15 minus 15 point net approval rating, those being Harry S. Truman going 6:27 into the 46th midterm, and George W. Bush going into the 2006 midterm. And in both 6:33 of those cases, their parties didn't just lose seats, they got absolutely shellacked. 6:38 And they didn't just lose the U.S. House, they lost the U.S. Senate as well. 6:44 So, yes, you don't say. 6:46 In both of those cases, the opposition party ended up with north of 230 House seats. 6:53 And so I think a lot of people have been, at least a few months ago, thinking about 6:58 those redistricting efforts that the Republicans have been doing, thinking about how polarized 7:03 or politics are, and being like, this may just be a midterm, yes, Democrats may gain 7:08 the House majority, but they won't, quote-unquote, blow it out, but the historical comparisons 7:15 that we have to this midterm in terms of the President's unpopularity suggest that 7:22 it's quite the possibility that Democrats don't just take back the House, but take 7:27 it back rather easily, at least according to how unpopular Donald John Trump is. 7:31 I want to walk through some specifics on the house and then go through some specific Senate races 7:36 But first I need to just unload my anxiety on you like you're my therapist 7:40 the thing that keeps me up at night is 7:43 Polling error and response bias. I think this right up from a recent New York Times poll of Minnesota summarizes. Well 7:49 I'm just gonna read this to you guys 7:51 So they they have Peggy Flanigan the Democrat in Minnesota defeating Michelle Tafoya the Republican by 54 240 7:58 This is one of the biggest outliers we've ever published. 8:02 No non-partisan poll of the race has shown Ms. Flanagan by up more than 4 percentage 8:07 points since Labor Day. 8:08 If the polls or our polls wind up underestimating Republican strength this year, we may look 8:13 back and say this was the canary in the coal mine, something like the 2026 equivalent 8:17 of the seltzer poll showing Kamala Harris ahead in neighboring Iowa in 2024. 8:22 In hindsight, and even at the time, that result was clearly a warning sign that 8:26 pollsters were struggling to reach white working-class voters rather than any indication 8:30 of democratic strength. 8:32 There are good reasons such a warning might come from Minnesota, unlike every other state 8:35 we pulled the cycle. 8:36 Minnesota doesn't have party registration or partisan primary participation on the voter 8:40 file. 8:41 As a consequence, we have fewer tools to correct non-response bias. 8:46 There was a similar article in the Washington Post Friday that talked about the problem 8:50 of contacting Republicans in Kansas, Harry, do you want to talk me down from the 8:55 or is it appropriate that I'm kind of sitting up there? 8:58 How do you think about this problem? 8:59 Look, I don't think any of us should be on ledges. 9:02 I'm a big believer at the end of the day. 9:05 We'll wake up on Wednesday morning 9:06 and hopefully nobody anywhere has jumped off of anything. 9:11 But what I would say is this, 9:12 look, we know that in the Trump era, 9:16 especially in states that Donald Trump won 9:18 in the prior presidential election, 9:20 there has been an underestimation 9:23 of Republican strength. 9:24 it's been four points on average in close Senate races. That is Senate races in which the polling 9:29 average before election day was within five points. You all of a sudden take that and you put it across 9:36 the Senate map. And if let's say it happened in all the states, then Republicans don't just 9:41 hold on to the United States Senate. They hold on with ease. Of course, that said, that said, 9:48 this is like, I feel like this is the season where I say, but or however, couching everything, 9:55 just so I still have a job come Thursday morning. No, it's because there are many different 10:01 pathways you can take. And I would also say that in 2022, the last midterm that we had, 10:07 in fact, what you saw was that in 100% of the races in which they were the close Senate 10:14 races, right? Five points on either side. The Democrats outperformed their final polling 10:19 in all of them. Holsters have been trying to attack this problem of underestimating Republicans. 10:25 The question is, has all that work actually paid off or not? And if you had the answer, 10:33 I had that answer. I can assure you, I wouldn't be here with you right now. I would probably 10:39 be on some idler living somewhere because then I would be all-knowing in the future 10:44 and I would be in a much better place than having a NHL Playoff Beard, you might say, 10:50 or in this case, the lead up to election Playoff Beard. 10:53 Yeah, you just be on Cal, she betting on races and walking away with a lot of money. 10:57 Okay. 10:58 So that's the anxiety. 10:59 Those are the things that we're uncertain about. 11:01 The reason I'm nervous, some of the kind of things in the ether why Democrats 11:04 I think have PTSD or not, and are not as hopeful 11:07 as the data might suggest they could or should be. 11:10 But let's start with the House of Representatives. 11:12 The Cook Political Report says, 11:14 the most likely outcome at this point 11:16 is that Democrats flip between 12 and 25 seats, 11:19 resulting in Democrats holding 227 to 240 house seats 11:24 in the 2027, when 2027 starts the new term. 11:28 Does that sound right to you? 11:29 And is there a broader range 11:30 that you're kind of thinking about, 11:32 about kind of like the Hopium to Doomer range? 11:34 Sure. 11:35 So I do think that that sounds broadly 11:38 as a good starting point. 11:39 And one of the things I think is so interesting, right, 11:42 is right now, if you look at the Cook Political Report, 11:45 or you look at Sabados, Crystal Bull, or what have you, 11:48 you will see that Democrats reach a majority 11:51 just by combining the lean, likely, 11:54 and solid categories for them. 11:57 They don't need any of the toss-up races. 11:59 That is highly unusual. 12:01 That has not generally been the case. 12:04 So for me, right now, I almost think at this point, 12:09 at this point, assuming we know what we're talking about 12:11 and Tuesday may come and go, 12:13 and it turns out there was something missed, 12:16 the 225 sort of almost feels much more like a floor 12:19 than it does like a ceiling. 12:22 If you look at the people who obviously do this 12:25 mathematically and it builds statistical models, 12:27 they are all north of 230 as the most likely outcome, 12:31 And I did a YouTube exclusive, this is one of the most fun things in our era of being 12:38 able to reach people in different mediums, is I went on, I was like the chance of a 12:44 blowout and I defined a blowout as 230 or north has been rising and that is absolutely 12:50 the case. 12:51 So I think that that's fine, the 227 or 240 or 230 or whatever the exact number 12:56 was that you said, I think that's perfectly fine, I think that's a nice middle ground. 12:59 But I really would not be surprised by North of 240. 13:03 You know, there was sort of this analogy that was, you know, done in terms of if Democrats 13:09 get North of, let's say, a nine or a 10 point popular vote victory, which some of the generic 13:16 ballot polling or some of the National House polling certainly suggests is plausible. 13:21 You really could end up, if you're able to stretch it out, it's not like you go 13:25 from, okay, you know, we, if we are the Democrats, we wouldn't buy nine. 13:29 or Democrats win by 9, and then it becomes, you know, we gain three seats versus if we 13:37 go from winning by 9 to winning by 10 or 11, it becomes you may win 10 more seats or 12 13:45 more seats, you know, it just, you get this sort of deluge as Republicans had, you know, 13:50 when they did the redistricting either mid-decade or at the end of the last census cycle 13:55 where they tried to essentially say, oh, we'd never get that high, but the levy 13:59 may in fact be breached. So that's certainly plausible on the Hopium side. And I can go 14:03 through the potential worst case scenario for Democrats, but I have been speaking for 14:08 a long time and my TV mind is going, shut up, shut up, shut up, shut up, shut up. 14:12 We'll stick with the Hopium on this one. But so we got some political junkies listening 14:15 to this show. They are going to be, you know, refreshing the CNN website, the second 14:21 polls close in a lot of these states. What are some bellwether districts you 14:25 are watching and why and what can they tell us kind of early on maybe some east coast districts 14:31 or eastern time zone districts that might help us sort of have a signal about where 14:35 the night is going. 14:36 I mean, look, when the polls closed at six in Kentucky, Kentucky six, I think is the 14:40 number one, right? 14:41 This is the district around Lexington, Ben Chandler back in the day, who is in 14:47 the lineage of happy Chandler for the baseball fans who are out there, who of course 14:52 was the commissioner when Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier, had been a long time 14:57 rep there. That is a Trump district. Trump won that district rather easily, but has some 15:02 ancestral Democrat ties to it. There has been some data to indicate that the Democrat there 15:10 can in fact may do very well, but truthfully doesn't even need to win there. If that race 15:14 is close, I think is an indication. In Indiana, Victoria Sparks' district, the number of which 15:22 is escaping me right now. That's another indicator, right? That race is close. I'm not saying 15:28 that Democrats are going to necessarily flip either of them, but I think those are sort 15:32 of two places you can sort of start off with. Beyond that, you know, I am going to be 15:38 interested at 7 p.m., you know, how does Don Davis do in North Carolina? Obviously, 15:44 there have been some redistricting done there, and I'm interested to see if not 15:48 Not only if he holds his seat, but whether he does significantly better. 15:53 Beyond that, you know, Florida I'm interested in the Latino districts. 15:59 Donald Trump made a lot of gains with Latino voters back in 2024. 16:05 And putting aside, look, I don't, as we discussed, I don't think that one or two house seats 16:11 are going to make or break a majority for Democrats. 16:13 But Latino voters are very, very, very, very, very, very important to James Tallarico and 16:18 his hopes to become the first U.S. Senator as a Democrat elected from Texas since 1988. 16:25 So getting some early signals on the Latino vote in and around Orlando, down in the 16:30 Miami-Dade area, I think I'll be interested in that as well. 16:34 Okay. 16:35 That's good. 16:36 It's helpful stuff to watch. 16:43 Pot Save America is brought to you by Wild Alaskan Company. 16:47 The difference between low and high quality seafood is enormous. 16:51 It's also one of those things that's tough to accurately assess for yourself in the grocery 16:54 store. 16:55 Wild Alaskan Company offers the best way to get wild cut, high quality seafood delivered 16:59 to your door on your schedule. 17:02 Each Wild Alaskan box comes with individually portioned fillets, they're vacuum sealed, 17:06 they're easy to prep and grade for any meal, no matter how quick or elevated. 17:10 All the fish is quick-frozen, fresh from the Alaskan waters, 17:13 which helps lock in its freshness, texture, flavor, 17:15 and key nutrients, like omega-3s. 17:17 It's fish you can trust with no GMOs, antibiotics, 17:20 or other additives. 17:21 Every order supports sustainable harvesting practices 17:24 in Alaskan fishermen whose history is tied 17:26 to the region and to the practice. 17:28 We've had a bunch of wild Alaskan in my house. 17:30 I made some really good salmon a couple times. 17:32 We made just some, like, whitefish tacos. 17:35 There's a million options. 17:36 It tastes delicious. 17:37 It's easy to cook, like, in the pan 17:39 are just in the oven. And we highly recommend it. Wild Alaskan Company is so confident their fish 17:44 is the best that they offer you 100% satisfaction and money back guarantee so you can try your first 17:48 box risk-free. Go to wildalaskan.com slash crooked for $35 off your first order of a premium 17:56 Wild Cod seafood. That's wildalaskan.com slash crooked for $35 off your first order. 18:03 Thanks to Wild Alaskan Company for sponsoring this episode. 18:05 But, Path of America is brought to you by Hymns. 18:09 Confidence is showing up ready, 18:10 not second-guessing yourself in the moments 18:12 that matter most. 18:13 Getting support for your sexual health 18:15 should be straightforward and stress-free. 18:17 With Hymns, you can access customized plans 18:19 designed around your unique needs 18:21 all without leaving the comfort of your couch. 18:23 Just answer a few questions and you'll be connected 18:25 with a licensed provider to get started. 18:27 No awkward pharmacy visits or waiting in line. 18:29 If prescribed your treatment ships 18:31 discretely to your door, 18:32 CY 8 in 10 Hymns customers said 18:34 They were able to satisfy their partner in bed with HIMS. It's not about managing a condition or treating a symptom 18:39 It's about having the sex life you actually want. Step into the bedroom with real confidence knowing you're fully prepared. 18:46 Be prepared, be strong, be confident, be HIM, ready to be HIM. 18:49 Visit HIMS.com slash Crooked to get personalized affordable care for weight loss, sex, testosterone, and more. 18:56 That's H-I-M-S dot com slash Crooked HIMS.com slash Crooked 19:00 Prescription products require an online consultation with a licensed health care provider, 19:03 who will determine if prescription is appropriate. 19:06 Restrictions apply. Individual results may vary. 19:08 Based on a survey of HIMS customers, see HIMS.com for full details. 19:14 So the Cook Political Report says the range of outcomes in the Senate, 19:18 they believe, is Democrats netting two to six seats. We need four for the majority. 19:23 North Carolina seems like a done deal. Georgia seems like a done deal. 19:27 Or Democrats lose those states. We got big, big problems. 19:30 So we're just going to set those aside and skip them. 19:31 Let's start with Texas though. 19:33 You just mentioned James Tallarico. 19:35 The latest CNN poll has Tallarico up six points 19:38 over Ken Paxton. 19:40 Nate Silver's polling average has Tallarico up 3%. 19:44 What is the data telling you about Texas 19:47 and what do you think Tallarico needs to win here? 19:50 Well, what's like the secret sauce? 19:51 Okay, so let me take it from the other side. 19:54 If I'm let's say a Republican, I'm saying, 19:56 okay guys, we gotta hold this seat. 19:58 we know that historically we have done very well in Texas. 20:04 What we just need to do is turn out Republican voters 20:08 and get Chem Paxton to essentially equal 20:11 what Greg Abbott has historically done. 20:14 And that would be enough even if we lose independence. 20:17 That's our plan. 20:18 Here's the problem. 20:19 The problem is manyfold. 20:21 First off, the problem is if you look at, 20:23 I believe the last Fox News poll, 20:25 James Tallarico is getting nearly 30% of non-Maga Republicans. 20:31 That is a huge, huge number, and potentially you combine that with the fact that he's winning 20:37 independence by 20, 30, 33, 34 points, depending on which poll you're exactly looking at. 20:44 After Donald Trump won independence in Texas by a point, that's a problem. 20:49 And then we spoke about Latino voters. 20:52 There's polling that shows James Tellerico 30-40 points with Latino voters potentially in Texas. 20:59 Donald Trump carried the Latino vote in Texas by 10 points according to the exit polls. You don't 21:04 have to be a mathematical genius to know that those two numbers don't sound anything alike. Now, 21:11 here's the question. The question, of course, is I think, again, a lot of the listeners on 21:17 here, if you are a Democrat you are worried about, can I trust the polls? Well, here's what 21:22 But I would say, first off, there has not been any example since Lloyd Benson was elected 21:27 in 1988 of a Democrat polling as well as James Talorico is right now. 21:33 Two, on that same sort of line of thinking, Beto O'Rourke actually outperformed his 21:39 final polls back in 2018. 21:42 So this to me is one of those weird states where if I was skeptical of the polling, 21:47 I'm skeptical of it everywhere insofar as the elections are so tight and even small differences 21:54 in the polls can make a difference. But in terms of the list of states where I am the most skeptical 21:59 of the polling, Texas is actually in the middle of the group or down near the bottom. I actually 22:03 believe those polls. Now the race is tight enough that a four-point switcheroo makes all 22:07 the difference. But I look at those polls, that to me seems like a real deal, especially 22:13 especially considering that Ken Paxton is the least popular GOP nominee for the Senate 22:19 in Texas this entire century. 22:20 Yeah. 22:21 I mean, this is an interesting state because it's a combination of factors like, Talarico 22:24 is good, Paxton is historically awful. 22:28 The demographics, as you mentioned, are important here. 22:30 I mean, there's a huge Latino vote in Texas. 22:32 We've seen a big shift there nationally. 22:34 Trump's approval rating is down. 22:35 Awful. 22:36 Yeah. 22:37 I think I trust the polling. 22:39 I feel bullish on Texas and trust the polling in Texas in part because what I 22:43 I'm hearing privately from campaigns tracks with what I'm seeing publicly in public polls, 22:50 which is Talarico up by a bit, Gina Hosa maybe having a chance to pull out that governor's 22:55 race. When I hear you say that Talarico is pulling, what was it, 30% of non-magical Republicans, 23:00 that makes me wince and worried about response bias because those seem like the kinds of 23:04 Republicans who might answer a poll, whereas Trump fans just won't. 23:09 But we'll see. 23:10 We'll see. We'll see. I mean, look, 23:12 Kempax is still doing very well with MAGA Republicans. 23:16 You know, obviously that's sort of in some ways or many ways or is is a 23:20 self-selecting group in, but we'll see. We'll see. We'll know soon enough. 23:24 We'll soon enough. All right. Turn to Michigan to a full disclosure. 23:27 I have been an Abdul. Also, I had supporter since the primary. 23:30 He's a friend. We did a show with him here at Crooked Media. 23:32 So we're very biased. I think he's an incredibly talented communicator. 23:36 I think the polling average has him up almost four points over 23:40 Mike Rogers. But I'm very anxious about the narrative in the closing week, like Trump's 23:44 out there calling Abdul a jihadist. He's questioning his loyalty to America. Haley Stevens, 23:50 the woman Abdul defeated in the primary, and her husband have made these kind of high-profile 23:55 comments that I find quite unhelpful. I know the campaign wants to be focused on the economy, 24:00 because that's what voters really care about. This stuff is not focused on the economy, 24:05 but like, I don't know how important is the closing couple weeks to you? 24:09 How much of this do you think is like Twitter noise versus like what voters are really going 24:12 to vote on? What do the numbers say here? Okay, so this to me is one of the most interesting 24:18 races in so far as I don't think that the narrative matches with the polling data is 24:24 showing us. So we had to see an end poll that had, else I add up seven, okay? 24:31 Okay. After just after the primary, Fox had a poll that had them tied. I'm sorry, did 24:37 not have them tied. You can see my playoff beard is sort of also emblematic of my lack 24:43 of sleep. Had Mike Rogers up by four. Obviously, if you look at the average, you look at those 24:49 two pollsters, there's been a clear shift. You look at the average pollsters, also been 24:53 a shift. When you look, for instance, at the issue of Israel, I think a lot of 24:59 folks, some in the media, some in this sort of the, you know, the, the, the, the chattering 25:06 class you might say have thought that that issue would work for Mike Rogers in the general 25:11 election, the way that it seemed to work for El Sayed in the primary. 25:14 Here's the thing is voters who say that Israel's their top policy or say it's, you know, 25:19 an extremely important, their vote, they're more likely to support El Sayed. 25:22 Right. 25:22 El Sayed's favorables are higher than Mike Rogers' favorables. 25:25 I'm like, I'm looking at the polling and what I hear in one case doesn't necessarily 25:29 match up with what the polling is suggesting. 25:31 That doesn't mean, you know, in the primary, the very limited polling that came out and 25:36 it wasn't necessarily the highest equality polling, did overestimate outside. 25:40 It's possible, it's possible, anything is possible. 25:44 But in terms of what I see as the narrative out there versus what the polling data is 25:49 saying to me, I'm not sure there's a state in which the two of them are further 25:52 they're apart than the Wolverine State. 25:56 Yeah, I noticed that too. 25:58 You were formerly the CEO of Wedgwood Polling, right? 26:01 Yes, that's exactly right. 26:02 Yes, I was- 26:03 Polling from those faking numbers? 26:05 Yes, that's exactly who I was. 26:08 I can, you know, it's one of these things. 26:10 It's so funny. 26:12 We're, a decade ago, nine years ago, 26:14 I guess I should count it as nine. 26:16 Don't make it further along than it needs to be, Harry. 26:19 Right, yes. 26:19 A decade ago, I wrote an article, 26:21 So for 538, which is where I was formally employed with a very similar thing. 26:27 And it's one of these issues that I think we sort of have going on right now. 26:32 And as AI has sort of taken things, et cetera, I'm not going to be surprised if we, I'd 26:39 be very surprised if we don't see more attempts at the Wedgewoods. 26:43 Yeah. 26:43 It's too easy to just make up numbers, post them on the internet, get a bunch of people 26:46 to share them and get it out into the ether long before companies like The New York Times 26:53 or CNN or 538 have a chance, 538 RIP have a chance to vet the pollster in the polling 26:59 and kind of dispense with it when it's fake. Let's turn to Alaska. I was feeling bullish 27:05 about Alaska. Mary Paltola has overperformed a lot in past elections. She is up nearly 27:11 four points in the polling average, but then The New York Times came along. Huge 27:15 conservative bias over there. I've always said it. 27:17 Yes, of course. That's always what they've been accused of. 27:20 Always with the narrative about the times. 27:22 They ran this big story about efforts by Democrats to recruit another guy named Dan Sullivan 27:28 to run in this race and siphon votes away from Senator Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent. 27:34 Harry, is there any data that can help us assess the impact of this story? 27:38 And how much stock do you put in the idea of October surprises generally 27:43 in a cycle like this, where the broader story 27:46 is the economy and inflation and gas prices. 27:49 And that cake seems pretty baked, especially in Alaska, 27:52 where I think you're talking like $8 a gallon. 27:54 Yeah, look, there are a few things going on. 27:57 First off, Mary Patola has absolutely outperformed 28:01 sort of the baseline that we've seen. 28:03 You know, she won a house seat in 2022, for example. 28:06 Now granted, Sarah Palin wasn't necessarily 28:08 the strongest of candidates I've ever seen, 28:10 but she's still won one. 28:11 That being said, look, Alaska has elected one Democratic Senator in the 21st century, 28:19 and that was marked baggage in 2008, and his opponent had literally just been convicted 28:23 in a federal trial in Ted Stevens. 28:26 If you take that away, the last time that Democrats won a United States Senate race 28:31 in the great state of Alaska, and it happens to also be the last time they won in a 28:35 midterm, was Mike Ravel in 1974. 28:39 before. Gravel, who I think to this audience is probably better known for running for president 28:45 in 2008 and then also sort of in 2020 and skipping stones along a pond. 28:51 Through Iraq. 28:52 Through Iraq, yes. This to me is a tough state to win if you're a Democrat. Now, the fundamentals 28:59 are there. I guess the question is, does this go beyond the bounds? One of the things 29:07 I think we've learned the Trump era is that what we thought with the norms might not have 29:12 been the norms and you can break norms and be fine. 29:16 Is this the norm? 29:18 Is this go beyond the normal bounds? 29:20 Does this go beyond the normal bounds? 29:22 I don't know the answer to that question. 29:24 That being said, I laughed to myself in so far as what are we doing if I'm a Democrat, 29:31 I'm asking myself, what are we doing, what are, and you know, as I go, what are 29:36 you doing? 29:36 And for another reason, this is a ranked choice voting state. 29:40 It's so stupid. 29:41 It's so stupid. 29:42 It's like, I don't know. 29:43 Yeah, like the ranked choice voting piece of it 29:45 is relevant for listeners just because 29:46 it means it seems less likely 29:48 that having another Dan Sullivan on the ballot 29:50 is gonna actually impact the vote. 29:52 But the effort to recruit this guy 29:55 seems so goddamn ham-handed. 29:57 And then you have this former Mary Pizola campaign manager 30:00 who decided to go unburden herself to the New York Times 30:04 and then try to take it all back. 30:05 Like that's a thing you can do just like I retract to my quotes and she was gonna do a wrongful termination suit to the 30:11 Campaign it's like seems like you were rightly terminated if you were going to unburden yourself about you know all that like anyway 30:17 It was just so stupid and messy and foolish and I was like we don't need to do this guys 30:22 Like I feel like this is obviously not helping her win right now. No, no 30:27 And so look the other question that I kind of have is because the polling from there has been so limited 30:34 I don't even know if we'll be able to measure it. 30:37 I'm sure there'll be some questions, 30:39 if some good pollsters will put on their questionnaires, 30:41 but it's gonna be difficult to even measure 30:42 the exact effect on it. 30:45 At this point, you look at the prediction markets, 30:47 we'll get some final polling, 30:49 I'm sure in the last few days, 30:51 my baseline is maybe you take a point or two off of Potola, 30:55 but I don't know if that's the right baseline or not. 30:58 And even if it is, it might not be enough 31:00 to change the race if the pre-polling, pre-this week 31:05 polling, it was right on with the result, 31:08 it may get Sullivan a little bit tighter, 31:10 but it may not even be enough. 31:11 Yeah, yeah, we'll see. 31:19 Pod Save America is brought to you by Stamps.com. 31:22 We could all use a few more hours, even minutes 31:24 in the day for ourselves. 31:26 Skip your trip to the post office 31:27 and stop letting mailing steal your precious little time 31:30 with Stamps.com. 31:31 With Stamps.com, you can print postage and shipping 31:33 labels from your computer or phone 24-7 31:36 with up to 90% off UPS, USPS, FedEx and more, no lines, no trips, no waiting, get everything 31:42 done in minutes and even schedule free pickups so carriers come right to you. 31:46 Whether you're sending letters, contracts, important legal documents or packages, 31:49 Stamps.com makes mailing simple for businesses of all sizes, including multi-location offices. 31:54 You can even send certified mail with proof of delivery right from your desk. 31:58 We've been using Stamps.com for years here at Quick Media. 32:01 It was a really great way to send merchandise or just kind of like day-to-day business mail 32:06 You'll save a ton of time. 32:08 Who wants the drive to the post office? 32:09 Literally no one. 32:10 Go to stamps.com. 32:11 If mailing has taken more time and more money than it should, 32:14 try stamps.com for free for four weeks 32:16 and get a welcome kit. 32:17 Go to stamps.com slash PSA to get this offer today. 32:21 That's S-T-A-M-P-S dot com slash PSA. 32:24 Stamps.com slash PSA. 32:26 Taxes and fees apply. 32:28 Potsafe America is brought to you by AG1. 32:30 November is when the end of the year chaos 32:32 starts to pick up speed. 32:33 That means a packed social calendar, 32:35 occasionally questionable food choices and long nights. 32:38 Your routine and some of your health goals 32:39 might be starting to fall by the wayside. 32:42 That's where AG1 shines. 32:43 When life gets overwhelming and your routine suffers, 32:46 AG1 keeps things simple. 32:47 One scoop in cold water every morning before anything else. 32:50 One scoop covers what a giant handful 32:52 of separate supplements would. 32:54 75 plus ingredients, vitamins, minerals, 32:56 adaptogens, pre and probiotics, and superfoods. 32:59 No cabinet full of bottles. 33:01 No figuring out what to take and when, 33:02 just a no-brainer streamlined part of your routine. And it's not just marketing. AG1 is back by four 33:07 separate gold standard clinical trials. This is not them just doing one study in-house. It is four 33:12 independent studies with key nutrient levels that improved within months with consistent use. 33:18 And here's something new. AG1 Pro, same daily drink now with a performance and recovery layer 33:23 built in. Five grams of crevatallus, a premium German-made creatine monohydrate with one of 33:28 of the most steady compounds in sports science, 33:30 plus CAHMB for muscle protection 33:33 and zinc carnicine for gut support. 33:35 Next gen is the foundation. 33:37 Pro adds what your body needs to recover. 33:39 I'm a big AG1 fan. 33:40 I was for a long time before they were sponsor. 33:42 I like to just put it in a morning smoothie. 33:45 You blend it up with whatever you're having, 33:47 a little protein powder, banana, 33:48 whatever it is, peanut butter. 33:49 It tastes great. 33:50 Actually adds a lot to it. 33:51 It's a nice little flavor. 33:52 Or if you don't feel like eating that that day, 33:54 throw it in water, chug it down. 33:56 It's great. 33:57 It's easy, it tastes good, and it's a great way to get all the nutrients you need. 34:02 For a limited time, visit drinkag1.com slash crooked and get a free immune support bundle, 34:08 including Omega 3 fish oil and vitamin D3 plus K2 with your first subscription of AG1 34:13 Next Gen or AG1 Pro. 34:15 That's drinkag1.com slash crooked. 34:21 All right. 34:21 So people feel pretty bullish about Ohio, which is surprising to me because Trump won 34:26 the state by 11 points in 2024. JD Vance won pretty overwhelming in 2022. I think he got 53% 34:33 of the vote. Want to buy six, I think. Yeah, Trump got 53% in 2020. So it's been a pretty 34:38 conservative state. Although Sherrod Brown has been a winning Democrat. He's had the 34:44 secret sauce to win in Ohio, many, many cycles. So right now, Nate's polling average has it 34:51 at 48% for Sherrod Brown. 34:54 John Hustad is at 45%. 34:56 This is another state where I worry about a polling miss. 35:00 But what do you think of Sherrod Brown's chances 35:01 against John Hustad's fat, juicy, thick, thick dumper? 35:08 I mean, let me tell you, 35:10 I will never be able to think of John Hustad 35:12 the same way ever again after Donald Trump. 35:16 The way that he's talked about Hustad's backside 35:18 and the way that he's spoken about 35:20 Ken Paxton and his personal appearance. I have to say, Trump does know how to make a line that 35:25 makes you remember it automatically. Can you model the value of being kind of caked up, 35:30 having like a badonga dunk? Yeah, I mean, let me tell you, we do have data that indicates that 35:34 taller presidential candidates do better. Maybe we should be doing some research into how their 35:39 backsides actually project electoral chances. Something for 2028, yeah. That's right, 35:44 that's something for 2020. We're always building towards the future. Look, 35:48 Look, if I'm a Republican in that state, I say, look, we have won every statewide race 35:53 recently. 35:54 We have had. 35:55 We've been underestimated in the polling. 35:57 That is absolutely the case. 36:00 And so I look and I say, maybe this is happening again, and that's something to hang our 36:06 hats on. 36:07 That being said, look, who said it is an appointed incumbent? 36:11 And there is a massive difference between being appointed and being elected. 36:16 There are anecdotes out there that suggest that some of the voters in that state of Ohio, 36:21 the Buckeye state, the great Buckeye state, actually still think that Sherrod Brown is 36:25 the incumbent there. 36:26 And he has gone on the ballot and won in Senate races in Ohio time and in timeout. 36:32 He did it in Trump's first midterm election. 36:35 I will say that Ohio is one of those states where, again, if I were ranking the list, 36:41 I would put Ohio closer to the top of the list 36:44 of where I'm the most skeptical of the polling data. 36:47 Interesting, okay. 36:47 And that is in part because it's a state 36:49 with a lot of white working class voters as a state, 36:52 where we looked at the polling in 2020 36:54 and Joe Biden and Donald Trump are pretty gosh darn close. 36:58 And then Trump blew them out. 37:01 You look at the polling in 2022 37:02 and while Bernie Moreno did seem to pull away 37:05 from Sherrod Brown near the end, 37:08 a lot of the polling middle of month of October, 37:11 I don't think Bernie, Bernie Moreno actually even popped a polling lead into like late October. 37:15 I think it was like the 15th, the 20th, at least in terms of the polling that I was looking at. 37:20 So that's a race where, look, Sherrod Brown has run before, has done well, AI plays in that state 37:28 in a way that I don't think it plays as much in other states. And Brown has made a big deal 37:32 about the data centers there. And it shows up in the polling data. But it's certainly a 37:38 state where I am, I still think Sherrod Brown's more likely to win than not, but it's certainly 37:44 the state where I'm the most sort of eyes, eyes need to be wide open about the potential 37:49 for appalling this. 37:50 Interesting. 37:50 Okay. 37:51 Yeah. 37:51 Well, Sherrod is snatched. 37:52 So we'll see if that factors in. 37:54 Main is what I'm anxious about. 37:56 Obviously, the process for going from Graham Plattener to Troy Jackson was not ideal. 38:03 It took Troy Jackson a while to get going as a candidate, I think. 38:08 He was off the trail for a while, he had to raise a lot of money quickly. 38:12 Susan Collins is a historic over-performer in her elections. 38:16 The current polling average in Maine has jacked in up 2.5 points, 38:20 but I also feel like we're not seeing the time of quality data out of Maine. 38:23 What is your take on Maine? 38:24 And can you just remind people of the way Susan Collins has overperformed the polls in the past 38:30 or overperformed, you know, other elections in her state? 38:33 Well, first off, both on both of those are the case, the last three election cycles. 38:37 So this is dating back 2020, 2014, 2008. 38:41 She's outperformed her polls and not just by a little bit, but I think in each of those 38:45 cases it was at least five points, if not double digits, which was the case in 2020. 38:51 So she definitely has a history of doing so. 38:55 And more than that, she's obviously outperformed the partisan baseline, right? 38:59 right? Donald Trump lost in Maine rather easily or hard for him, and Joe Biden won rather 39:05 easily in 2020. And then Susan Collins walked to reelection, beating her polls very easily. 39:12 So that is all the case. Here's the thing about Maine that I do think is interesting, 39:17 which is even in those polls, those years in which the polling showed that Susan Collins 39:22 was trailing, it was Sarah Gideon back in 2020, she was still better liked than 39:28 not in the polling. That is, her favorable was higher than her unfavorable. That's not 39:33 the case this year. Her net favorable rating, net favorability rating, I think in our CNN poll 39:38 was like minus 10, minus 11, minus 12 somewhere in that neighborhood. So this may be a different 39:44 climate than we're used to seeing. And our CNN poll, again, we categorize as no clear leader. 39:51 I think it was something like 49, 45, Jackson, something in that range. It was four points 39:56 are separating them either way. Yeah, I get it. Your skepticism, again, based upon the 40:03 fact that Susan Collins has outperformed the polling and seems to pull a rabbit out of the 40:08 hat each time. But I almost am like, it kind of makes a lot of sense, right? We're getting 40:16 more polarized than ever before. Donald Trump is really, really unpopular in Maine. She 40:23 really hasn't run in a tough year since 2008. And that was when the correlation, that was 40:30 the same year in which, you know, Mark Pryor was running basically unopposed. I think maybe 40:34 there's a Green Party candidate running in Arkansas. That's just a delight time ago. 40:39 So I get your skepticism, but kind of also makes sense to me. 40:43 Okay. Okay. And my more fun to banter with than John Berman, your partner in crime 40:46 on CNN. I've known John for a long time. He's a very funny guy, but he has to 40:49 play the straight man on TV. I was wondering why, let him, let him lose. 40:52 I am a fan when you can get Johnny B to go a little loose Johnny B 40:57 You know he was a Hastings putting this guy back up back in his Harvard days 41:01 He's a very funny guy and what the hell does that? Oh, is that like a club thing? Yes. It's a club thing 41:07 I dare anyone in the audience to 41:10 Look him up from his hasty putting days. I think it I John probably hates me for it 41:15 But I think it I think it's a perfect, you know 41:18 So it really encapsulates John of how he's honestly one of the smartest guys that I know, 41:23 and he's also one of the kindest guys that I know, he's also one of the funniest guys 41:27 that I know. 41:27 He's very funny. 41:28 Does that mean there's like a photo of him like singing in his underwear somewhere? 41:30 Is that what we're digging up? 41:33 I can't say. 41:34 Okay. 41:34 You might have to Google that out. 41:36 I'll figure that out. 41:36 It was probably on a fun saver. 41:37 So we'll work on that. 41:39 Iowa, looks too close for me. 41:41 Don't like it. 41:42 Polling average has Josh Turrick, head of Ashley Hinson by less than a point. 41:45 Both candidates are at 46. 41:47 I hate polls, they're at 46 or 47, 41:51 because I feel like they always cut against us at the end. 41:53 There's a libertarian in the race 41:55 who could siphon some votes away from the Republican. 41:59 I don't know how impactful that would be, 42:00 but it's always a good thing for Democrats 42:01 when your win number is like 49 and not 50. 42:06 The Democrats I talked to are a little worried 42:10 about Iowa. 42:11 The best news I've heard from someone very in the know 42:13 is that Josh and Hinton are tied. 42:16 Republicans seem a little more bullish. 42:18 What is the number, what is the data telling you on Iowa? 42:21 It's not the 51st seat if I'm a Democrat. 42:24 That's what it's telling me. 42:26 I think Democrats could win there. 42:27 I think Josh Church could win there. 42:29 But it's not the race that, you know, 42:31 if Democrats win Iowa, they are winning other states first 42:34 to get them the majority in the United States Senate. 42:37 I think the bigger story out of Iowa, to be honest with you, 42:41 is what's happening in that gubernatorial race, right? 42:44 With Rob saying, and I think that that somebody is, 42:47 I sort of project out of my own head and I go, 42:49 there's someone who might be running for president one day. 42:52 He's one of, look, Josh Church has run a, 42:54 it seems to be a good campaign. 42:55 Ashley Henson actually in terms of the Republican campaigns 42:57 has run one of the better ones as well. 43:00 I look at that race and I say, 43:03 would it surprise me if Josh Church went? 43:05 No, it wouldn't surprise me, 43:06 but it's also the race where if I were a Democrat, 43:09 proud. I would be more worried about that race in terms of the close race I'm looking 43:13 at than any other for no other reason. We talk about polling misses. I was home to the greatest 43:19 polling miss, I think, in the last decade in terms of most notable. 43:24 Got it. Rob's going to hate us for mentioning him as a presidential candidate. The only 43:27 time I think Rob's ever sent me a gruff text was when I mentioned him as a 20-28 43:31 or he's just like, dude, come on. This is not going to happen. I don't want that. 43:34 Speaking of these governor's races, there are a bunch of states where these targeted 43:39 Senate races and targeted governor's races. Gina Inajosa in Texas, Amy Acton is running against 43:45 Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio, where Vivek is just, you know, in the gutter. Rob Sands in Iowa that 43:52 you just mentioned. To what degree do you think we should expect governor and senate races to 43:58 be correlated? How much vote switching should we expect these days? What do you think? 44:03 It's certainly the highest, look, Phil Scott, although there is some polling to suggest that 44:10 Phil Scott may lose in Vermont, Republican governor of Vermont, but I think it's the 44:14 favorite in that race. 44:15 That gives you an idea, right? 44:16 That still there are states that vote one way for federal races and then in a statewide 44:24 race can vote a completely other way. 44:27 It's more than you used to expect, but I wouldn't be surprised by, you know, 44:31 of Split Vertex Texas, as an example, 44:33 where I wouldn't be surprised by Split Vertex. 44:36 I wouldn't be surprised that even Kansas, 44:38 I wouldn't be surprised of it in Iowa. 44:41 I wouldn't be shocked by it in Ohio, 44:44 although I think they'll probably both go dem. 44:47 So I think that there could be, there could be some. 44:50 That people still are willing to split their ticket. 44:54 We saw it in 2022. 44:56 We saw it in 2024, granted, 44:59 you know, the Republican candidate for governor in North Carolina in 2024 was not exactly the 45:06 strongest candidate I have ever seen, but we saw it there as well. 45:16 Pud Save America is brought to you by Mint Mobile. Groceries are up, gas is up, rent is up, 45:20 your wireless bill also up. It seems everyone is finding new ways to squeeze more out of you, 45:25 everyone except for Mint Mobile. While other carriers keep finding new ways to charge you 45:29 more, Mint Mobile has kept plans starting at just 15 bucks a month. Stop overpaying for 45:33 wireless just because that's how it's always been. Mint exists purely to fix that. All 45:38 plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 45:41 5G network. You can even bring your current phone and your number. Ditch overpriced wireless 45:46 with Mint Mobile. It's so easy. Sign up online and get three months of premium wireless 45:50 service for $15 a month. For a new wireless plan starting at $15 a month, go to mintmobile.com 45:55 slash Cricut. That's mintmobile.com slash Cricut. Cut your wireless bill to $15 45:59 bucks a month at MintMobile.com slash Crooked. $45 upfront payment required equivalent to 46:04 $15 per month. New customers on first three month plan only. Taxes and fees. Extra C Mint 46:09 Mobile for details. 46:11 Corrupting our democracy works best when we forget that we, the people, are in charge. 46:17 I'm Stacey Abrams, voting rights advocate and host of Assembly Required. In my podcast, 46:23 I'm talking with some of the sharpest minds in politics and in civic activism to help us figure out how to fight authoritarianism and win 46:32 Mike podcast doesn't just diagnose problems 46:35 We give actionable steps to help you feel a little more connected and a lot more empowered to make change in your communities 46:42 So check out my podcast assembly required new episodes drop every Tuesday on YouTube or wherever you get your podcast 46:49 All right, let's talk about some of the kind of best case scenario for Democrats, stretch 47:03 Senate race states. 47:04 So we got Kansas, South Carolina, where the New York Times has it tied, Nebraska, Florida, 47:11 Mississippi. 47:13 Can you rank some of those in terms of like likelihood of Democrats actually being able 47:18 to win there and talk about what you're seeing in the data? 47:20 I mean, I think Kansas is the one that's most likely to flip. 47:24 You know, for a few reasons. 47:26 number one, the polling that we see out of there. I mean, there have been multiple polls 47:31 now either showing a tie, a nominal advantage for Hamilton, or in the case of that Washington 47:36 post-polo, you mentioned the write-up at the top about it. They seem to be skeptical 47:44 of their own data. 47:45 Yeah, they're really struggling to get Republicans on the phone, essentially is 47:49 the problem. 47:50 Correct. That being said, fool me once, shame on you, or fool me twice, shame 47:55 on me for, you know, etc. Correct. You just see that data and you speak to Republicans 48:01 and they don't think Roger Marshall has run a good campaign. Yeah. And Adam Hamilton is 48:06 well-known, you know, you know, pastor, etc. Fits the right profile in that state. Seems 48:14 to be more popular than that. Roger Marshall, the least popular Republican Senate nominee 48:17 in Kansas is laying a campaign this century for sure. You haven't seen polling like 48:22 this, and I looked it up, this late in a campaign for a Democrat in 30-plus years, I was able 48:29 to get all the way back to Sam Brownback's first one. I couldn't get any data further 48:32 back than that. 48:33 So I look at that data and I go, yes, and then I will also just know, put the polling 48:38 aside for a second. I was interested in sort of Kansas' let's say journey in the 48:46 last few presidential elections, and sort of if you were to rank it out, which states 48:50 are the most Republican versus the national vote. Kansas used to re-rank like 9th or 10th, 48:56 and now it's closer to 18th or 19th. It has actually shifted to the left, 49:01 even as it's still been voting for Republican for presidents. One way to put it is Texas 49:06 went Republican, voted for Donald Trump by 13 points in 2024. Kansas went for Donald Trump by 16. 49:15 Yes, 16 is slightly bigger than 13, but it ain't that much of a difference between the two 49:19 of them. What about South Carolina? Do you buy that like Darlene Graham is 49:23 obviously a terrible candidate. You know, she had one of the worst debate 49:27 performances I've ever seen where she was kind of like, I don't do foreign 49:30 policy. I could imagine a world where voters aren't thrilled to watch, you 49:37 know, a Senate seat be treated like an heirloom that gets passed down in the 49:43 family from Lindy Graham to her. But like, what do you make of those 49:46 numbers? I mean, look, we've now seen a number of polls that show a close. But South Carolina 49:52 is a very racially polarized state. It's one of those things, you know, when I think of Mississippi 49:57 or Louisiana, you know, your South Carolinas, when you look at the polls, you see it's 50:04 a racially polarized state. It tends to mean the state is very inelastic. Ergo, you know, 50:08 the results are always within sort of a certain range. I see a Democrat getting to 45, 46, 50:14 47% of the vote. The question is, can you really get to 50% and that to me, look, I 50:21 think any Andrews has run a good campaign. But again, is it possible? Sure. I don't think 50:27 I would have imagined that we would have gotten a race that was a tie this late in 50:31 the campaign, but it's, I think you're right. It's definitely one of those stretch 50:35 states. 50:36 So the last three states that I mentioned are Nebraska, Florida and Mississippi. 50:40 We had this horrible Supreme Court decision, 50:43 the Calais decision, 50:44 which sort of further gutted the Voting Rights Act. 50:47 There seems to be some evidence 50:48 that that decision is driving significant black turnout, 50:53 especially in southern states. 50:55 Can you talk about what we're seeing in the early vote data 50:58 and whether it gives you any hope in these states 51:00 or should give me hope in these states? 51:02 Yeah, I mean, the only thing I ever hope for 51:03 is a Buffalo Bill Super Bowl. 51:05 I'm gonna be honest with you. 51:06 This could be your year. 51:07 This could be this the offense is absolutely tremendous. Yeah led by Josh Allen 51:13 The defense is a train wreck. Yeah, my Patriots beat your ass, too 51:16 Yes, I I recall that it's it's it's one of those I'm gonna quickly side sidetrack and then get back in the path 51:24 It's like Josh Allen has like one of the best records ever for when his defense gives up 30 or more points 51:30 He has won the majority of those games. I think which is insane. It's insane 51:35 We'll see, I hope spring's eternal. 51:37 I'll be up there for Thanksgiving. 51:39 We'll see what happens. 51:39 Nice new stadium, congrats. 51:40 It looks beautiful. 51:41 Thank you, thank you so much. 51:42 The taxpayer money very well. 51:44 I would love to throw you through a table sometime, 51:46 which is a nice thing for someone in Buffalo. 51:48 That's what they do in Buffalo, 51:49 you just air elbow drop a table. 51:51 We'll make it happen. 51:54 So look, when I look at the early vote data, 51:58 it's definitely the case that I see 52:00 that black turnout is up significantly. 52:01 And obviously, if you're going to do well in a state like South Carolina if you're a Democrat, 52:07 you need the black turnout to be sky high. 52:10 Same thing for Mississippi, same thing for Louisiana, which is now sort of being bandied 52:15 about a little bit more than I think we would have thought. 52:20 Again, these are not close to toss-up races necessarily, but on a very good night for 52:23 Democrats it could go high. 52:26 I would say, in all honesty, when I think about the black turnout being up, yes, 52:31 Yes, it's probably, it is certainly helpful in South Carolina, but I think I think actually 52:37 two states and two races where I think it could be particularly helpful are at least 52:41 two states and three races, maybe. 52:43 I think of Georgia governor, Keisha Lance Bottoms, trying to become the first black 52:48 governor of Georgia, first female governor of Georgia. 52:52 And John Ossoff obviously has been winning there rather easily in the polls, but you 52:56 know, will Lance Bottoms come along with him? 53:00 I also think of Texas, which actually has a significant black population as well. 53:05 It shouldn't be undervalued there. 53:08 And I think of Talarico, yes, but I also think of the governor's race as well. 53:13 So look, Democrats don't lose when black turnout goes higher and certainly their early 53:19 vote data. 53:20 And the way I often see it is when a group of voters believe that their rights to 53:27 representation or voting is trying to be taken away from them, 53:32 which I think many black voters and certainly many 53:34 Democrats feel is the case, then they tend to turn out in 53:37 higher numbers. And certainly the early vote is, um, let's 53:42 say in line with that. 53:43 So over my years in politics, I have learned not to pay a lot 53:48 of attention to early vote, not to pay a lot of attention to 53:51 the first round of exit polls, because they tend to be 53:55 misleading or at least revised and off and break my heart, but is there anything you're 54:02 seeing in early vote numbers so far that kind of affirms what you've seen in polling or 54:08 tells you a story that you find interesting? 54:10 I think for the most part, early vote is one of those experiences where you can see 54:15 what you want to say. 54:17 I think you could go to Nevada and obviously John Ralston has done the stuff out there 54:22 and we have a very long baseline. 54:23 I think you could say that it is good for Democrats. 54:26 But overall, if I'm being honest, 54:29 maybe I'm just not smart enough 54:30 to understand the early vote data like some people are. 54:33 I doubt that. 54:35 I tend to be like, 54:37 this is just one of many things. 54:40 There's nothing, another way to put it 54:42 is there's been nothing inconsistent 54:44 with what I see in the polling, 54:46 with what I see in the early vote data. 54:47 Just for listeners, the hard thing to know is like, 54:49 okay, you see this early vote data, 54:51 it's heavily democratic. 54:53 Is that a sign of more democratic votes to come 54:56 or are Democrats just voting early 54:58 and we're kind of cannibalizing our election day vote 55:00 because Donald Trump's voter is correct 55:03 if I'm wrong, Harry. 55:04 I mean, Donald Trump likes to vote early by mail himself, 55:06 so does his family, 55:07 but Donald Trump voters tend to vote on election day 55:10 and they come out in droves 55:11 and that's when we end up losing. 55:13 That has at least since COVID been the case, right? 55:16 This is one of these things. 55:17 One of my favorite little historical anecdotes 55:20 is the reason that George Bush won the state of Florida in the 2000 election was because he won 55:25 the absentee vote. Al Gore actually won the in-person election day vote in Florida in 2000. So what is 55:31 now might not necessarily be of what used to be. But no, that for the most part is correct. The 55:37 one thing I will point out is that I do think the percentage of people voting by mail will be 55:42 down this year. And that is in part because Democrats are worried with all these new 55:49 rules that have been put into place in certain states with some talk about the USPS and mail 55:54 voting that they will, in fact, say, you know what, why risk it? 55:59 Let's go vote in person, whether that be early election day, that kind of makes it also difficult 56:04 to understand, which is, you know, the votes on election day count just as much as the 56:09 early vote does, and in the midterm election, especially turnout is the name of the game. 56:15 And so we don't know if the people who are sitting out now 56:18 are gonna show up on election day 56:20 or they're just gonna sit out altogether. 56:23 Yeah, good point. 56:24 Okay, so anyone who is alive in 2020 knows 56:26 that election night is no longer a thing. 56:30 The counting can take days. 56:32 I know this is an especially acute challenge for you 56:34 because there's a scenario where some hire up at CNN 56:38 gets handcuffs, chains you to a desk, 56:40 you don't get to go home for three, maybe four, 56:42 maybe five days. 56:43 is when do you think we'll have a good sense 56:45 of which direction things are heading? 56:48 Like what are the key timing inflection points 56:50 for you as you're watching these results? 56:52 Yeah, I'll tell you this much, 56:54 which is maybe this is a bit of a surprise. 56:57 Look at the polling data is right. 57:00 That is, assuming there is in some last minute 57:03 October surprise in every state 57:05 and assuming that the polling now 57:07 is what the polling is a Monday, et cetera, 57:12 then to me, I look at it and I go, 57:17 this may actually be a quote unquote early night. 57:20 That is it won't last days. 57:22 It last days if we're reliant on Alaska 57:25 or it's a very tight race in Maine 57:28 where the vote can sometimes take a little bit of a while 57:31 and a kite can go into Wednesday, et cetera. 57:35 Obviously Alaska with its rank choice voting, 57:38 it's relatively slow to count to the other states, 57:41 and the ranked-choice voting could take a while. 57:44 I think, if I am a person who's looking at this, 57:48 I think 2, 3 a.m., we should, 57:52 we will very likely know what is going on. 57:56 Unless Michigan, we sometimes get those vote drops in 57:59 from Detroit, that could be the last thing we're looking at. 58:02 But most of the states, they count relatively quickly. 58:06 And more than that, we will know, you know, 58:09 we'll get an early idea in Ohio, 58:11 we will get an early idea in North Carolina, right? 58:14 We will get these early indicators, 58:16 which will tend to suggest to us what exactly, 58:20 which way the tide is going. 58:23 I will note, I'll admit, 58:25 I haven't really watched Kansas election nights 58:28 all that closely. 58:29 Nor have I, nor have I, but I'm excited to try. 58:31 Final question for you. 58:32 So we talked at the top about some of the challenges 58:34 is with response bias and pollsters reaching people, right? 58:38 They're both seem to be like more polling than ever before, 58:41 but also this crisis with people not answering their phones 58:45 and maybe now not answering online surveys. 58:48 But at the same time, we have all this new data, 58:50 there's prediction markets and Calci 58:52 and poly market all this stuff. 58:53 So as we roll through this election into 2028, 58:57 how are you thinking about the health 58:58 of the kind of polling industry and data analytics 59:01 and how do you think it's gonna evolve 59:03 as we get closer to, you know, 59:05 maybe the most consequential election 59:07 of our lifetimes in 2008. 59:09 Yes, every, excuse me. 59:11 They all are. 59:11 They all are. 59:12 They're all the most consequential election. 59:14 I've only been hearing that now forever. 59:16 Although granted, I really wonder if in like 1996, 59:19 you know, they were like, 59:20 oh yeah, this is the most consequential election ever 59:22 between Bob Dole and Bill Clinton, 59:24 which had like no voter turnout. 59:26 I'm fairly sure most people are like, eh, whatever. 59:28 I think there's a whole Simpsons about that, 59:30 by the way. 59:32 Look, I think of it in a few ways. 59:35 One, which is, if you look at the horse race polling, 59:38 it actually hasn't become less accurate over time, really. 59:42 Yes, 2020, it was a big error, historically speaking, 59:45 but 2024 actually was perfectly fine. 59:48 What has happened is that the races 59:51 have just simply become significantly closer. 59:54 Every national presidential election, 59:57 the national popular vote has been within single digits 59:59 since 1988. That is the longest such stretch since we started counting the popular vote 60:05 really on a nationwide scale back in 1824. So as long as we keep getting close elections, 60:12 I think a skeptical eye towards the polling is worthwhile. And I'll also note, I'm going 60:17 to be interested to see once assuming Trump does not try to run for a third term and 60:21 isn't on the ballot, whether or not those biases still exist. That being said, I 60:26 tend to take a sort of worldview of this is I look at all of the data, I look at the 60:31 all of that, I look at the polling data, I look at the prediction market data, I look 60:34 at the registration data, I look at the national indicators, I'm of the belief 60:38 the more data that you have in there the better and then you can sort of 60:43 weight up and weight down what you don't think is worthwhile. 60:47 In terms of the polls themselves and the individual polls, yeah, I think I'm 60:50 going to take a skeptical eye if I go to the website and the persons 60:54 and the people who are supposedly running the polls 60:56 don't have pictures or maybe not names. 60:58 I think that's generally a pretty good idea. 61:02 But look, it's sort of the wild west, 61:05 but I welcome people if they want to try and go and poll, 61:08 but you know what? 61:09 I deserve the right to then say, you know what? 61:12 I got to be honest, I don't necessarily think 61:15 that the individual who has no experience of this 61:17 and isn't willing to show their face, 61:20 I'm not going to use their data. 61:21 Should I do a little DIY polling myself? 61:22 I'll just call a bunch of people, 61:24 just ask them questions randomly. 61:25 You know, you can certainly try.
Community discussion