Show full transcript 0:44 After that, you'll hear my conversation 0:46 with Pennsylvania Governor, Josh Shapiro. 0:48 All right. Hello. Yeah. This isn't bull work on people. 1:01 Someone's wearing a woke built crystal shirt right there. Yeah. 1:08 What times we live in. Okay. The goal of our panel day is I have some of the smartest minds 1:13 and politics and we're going to break down what happened on Tuesday and what it means 1:17 going forward. It's there along the whole obviously you all know. We have Carlos Odeo 1:24 from ECHI's research, you probably know, 1:25 from many appearances on Ponte America. 1:28 Rebecca Katz, one of the best democratic strategists 1:30 who just helped elect many people, 1:32 including Gabriel Alcide, 1:33 and Gina Hanna-Hosen, Texas. 1:37 At Deesu D'Amici, who you may also know 1:38 from Ponte America, who has worked for every Democrat, 1:40 and he's the first person who told me 1:42 that Scott Coulomb could win in Mississippi. 1:44 All right, I just want to start, like, 1:51 we thought, in my head heading into Tuesday, 1:53 I had blue wave blue tsunami. We ended up with something bigger than that, right blew through most people's expectations 2:03 Just want to ask you to start with like what's one thing that was surprising to you and the results could be a race 2:08 Could be a voter trend could be something that worked 2:11 Okay 2:11 So in the voter trend anybody who is listening to me knows that I was saying guys in rural areas 2:16 Republicans are gonna do way less well than normal because the prices 2:21 and affordability issues were hitting them hardest. 2:24 That's where AI data centers are being built, 2:26 which they're very upset about. 2:27 What I didn't anticipate though, 2:30 is how many people in rural areas were still sifting 2:32 to the data, but it looks like 2:34 not only did a lot of them not show up, 2:35 a lot of them voted for Democrats. 2:43 I feel like I should give a data answer. 2:45 And there are so many surprising data points, 2:48 but I have to say the one thing 2:49 that really did surprise me was Gina, Hosa. 2:54 And it's because I did not allow myself 2:57 to believe she was going to win down to the wire I was saying 3:01 oh no no she's going to lose because I didn't want to jinx 3:04 her you're very welcome and but I but I will say and it's not 3:12 just in the sense of representation in the way that 3:15 we mean it from a very symbolic standpoint. It is how 3:18 meaningful something to believe it is to have that 3:21 person in that seat at this moment. 3:27 Now you're going to make me cry. 3:30 Thank you for all you did I think you did all the work 3:33 Wait, thank you Rebecca. All he did was say it was not say she was gonna win 3:37 The biggest surprise for me when I woke up on Wednesday morning having barely slept 3:47 Was realizing how many resumes we needed in democratic politics right now 3:53 We needed so many people to make sure that the people who won 3:56 Actually succeeded. So to me the most important takeaway is like we have to make sure these people do a good job 4:03 And we need that we need people who have been on this on the sidelines to come back into politics and get 4:09 Get the best out of these folks because a very competent staff matters 4:16 I'd say two two things one the size of the house majority 4:20 I think we all knew we were gonna take back the house but to get to maybe 260 4:25 265 seats never been seen even in the 2008 wave is crazy the other race that both surprised me and 4:32 Was a harbinger I think of things to come in Mississippi with South Carolina 4:35 Not just that any Andrews one 4:37 But to win by five in South Carolina, right? 4:40 We were all talking about the first presidential primary state was a red state. Well, not so much guys 4:46 Not only did she win, you know the race outright 4:49 But to win by a significant decisive margin suggests and suggested on on on Tuesday night that the winds the winds are changing down south 5:00 It's important to understand why we won how we won not just so that we can win again 5:07 but there's always this like narrative battle 5:10 that happens afterwards where everyone's fighting over 5:12 like what the exact reason was and every what you'd be shocked 5:15 to find out that all the people having that fight 5:18 have discovered that the reason we want is the exact thing 5:20 they believe their whole life. 5:22 And so like I want to like dig into the data 5:25 and what you guys saw on the ground about 5:27 what really happened so we can have like 5:28 a real fact-based conversation about it. 5:31 Eddie Sue, let's start like obviously 5:33 when you're winning states like Mississippi 5:34 and Texas by huge margins and South Carolina, 5:37 you're doing everything. 5:39 But how much of this do you think was, 5:43 what our voters turning out, 5:45 their voters not turning out, 5:47 how much was persuasion? 5:50 Obviously it was everything. 5:52 We'll see when the catalyst data and other things 5:53 come back, it is too early to tell. 5:56 My guess it is about two thirds turnout, 5:59 one third persuasion, roughly speaking, right? 6:01 That's, don't quote me on that. 6:02 Oh shit, I just said it in front of a room 6:04 of a thousand people. 6:06 But the turnout, I think, is both high turnout 6:09 in Democratic areas, but, as Sarah said before, 6:12 low turnout in Republican areas. 6:13 That's also something we should take 6:14 as a cautionary tale for 2028. 6:16 We can't count that that's necessarily 6:18 going to be the case in a presidential election. 6:20 But we saw increased turnout in Democratic base areas, 6:23 as I was talking about before. 6:24 Black voters in the South pissed off about Calais, 6:27 pissed off about the Trump administration. 6:28 Latino voters in the RGV pissed off 6:30 about what Trump is doing. 6:32 Latino voters, and all voters in Minnesota pissed off about Trump invading an Operation 6:36 Metro surge, you name it. So we had a surge, but we also did persuade, right? Latino voters, 6:41 I'm sure you'll talk about it, Carlos, swung hards we all know to Trump in 2024, and we erased that 6:46 and then some with young voters, young white voters, we swung it. So it was a little bit 6:52 of everything, obviously, we'll dig into the numbers, but I do think important to remember 6:56 However, what happened to 26, we don't need to forget it, 7:00 but we need to rethink what 28, 30 and beyond 7:03 will look like and not just count on it happening again. 7:07 So exactly all that, just some of the math on this, right? 7:10 So there's the turnout piece. 7:12 I think if the early estimates hold up, 7:13 this will be the least white electorate ever. 7:16 If you look at, you don't have to clap 7:17 for the least white. 7:19 You can clap for the next part, okay? 7:21 It's for diversity, but they didn't know 7:23 exactly how to express that. 7:24 diversity. But the next piece, the next piece is good, which is, if you look at, we already 7:31 have voter files back in Georgia or Texas. And the black share and Latino share of the 7:37 electorate grew over the presidential. Just to be clear, that's not normal. That doesn't 7:43 happen. It's usually the opposite. They drop, including some shocking statistics like young 7:49 Latinas, Latinas under the age of 30, turned out at a higher rate than young white women. 7:57 That also does not happen, right? 7:59 There is a massive structural turnout gap between white and Latino voters that was 8:04 still apparent, except among young Latinas who are, have emerged as one of the most 8:09 important blocks in the entire American electorate. 8:13 And young people, it was as young as about 2018. 8:15 Then you have the persuasion piece which is a lot of pissed off Trump voters, came out and crossed the aisle and voted for Democrats. 8:26 That's meaningful defection. And it cuts across the electorate. 8:31 I'm here with Jerry Mandarin. 8:33 Jerry Mandarin? Maybe. I would, you know, I would put gas prices and the war and the total betrayal of everything he ran on, higher on the list. 8:41 But sure. 8:43 But I do think with black voters in the south, Jerry Mandarin plays. 8:45 Yeah, I think there was a sense of the Voting Rights Act that the incredible spike in turnout among black voters was actually largely concentrated in the south. 8:54 But on the persuasion piece, just to say, not only young people turn out, the current estimate in the New York Times of youth support for Democrats is also the highest level of support we've seen for Democrats among young people basically ever. 9:08 But one of the reasons that that is happening is we had really exciting candidates this year. 9:13 Like it's never happened that there were so many people who are so fun to follow and to see what was happening on their campaign 9:20 And the other thing we had this cycle that we should never underestimate going forward is really good tickets 9:26 And nowhere is that better than in Texas because Talarigo and Gina and Bobby campaign together 9:33 They I mean I was with them in the Valley last week 9:36 8,000 people all excited to go vote if we can keep getting 9:41 really good candidates up and down the ticket. 9:44 Give everyone something to vote for. 9:47 They will keep coming back. 9:49 It's not just what we're voting against, 9:50 but it's getting excited and inspired to vote 9:53 for someone again. 9:53 Can you actually talk about that a little bit? 9:55 Because I heard Gina say after the election 9:57 that before she ran, she met with Beto at work 10:00 and he said, one person can't win Texas. 10:02 Two people can. 10:02 Just talk a little bit specifically about that logic there 10:05 and how those two campaigns work together. 10:07 I mean, well, first of all, 10:08 Right away, Zuda Talerico, who took on the first many hundreds of millions of dollars 10:12 in attacks, right? 10:14 And he was building something. 10:15 And remember, people would come for him and be polite for Gina, but then Gina was running 10:20 a different campaign. 10:21 Gina was also in many of the rural areas, going after folks who were upset about 10:25 the data centers. 10:26 She was going after MAGA moms who were upset because the schools in Texas just 10:32 are terrible. 10:33 There's over 150 school districts in Texas 10:37 with only four-day school weeks 10:39 because they just gutted that whole process 10:41 for habits, corruption, and vouchers. 10:44 So Gina had a whole campaign going that way. 10:47 And then you had other folks on the ticket 10:50 getting people excited, and one by one, 10:52 they were bringing more and more people in. 10:55 Like Gina was doing through the roof excitement 10:58 with older Latinas. 10:59 and James was getting so many folks off campuses 11:03 and getting a gauge. 11:05 When we went, we did a whole college tour, 11:08 thousands of kids were turning out 11:10 and they were very laser focused 11:12 on what they could do to make a difference. 11:14 So just having quality candidates up and down the ticket 11:18 makes a difference. 11:20 Woo! 11:22 Just to go back to you, Carlos, for one sec. 11:24 Actually, you know what, Sarah? 11:25 You did something that I find to be completely insane. 11:28 and that is that the morning after the election you held focus groups. You know 11:36 those could have waited till after lunch, right? I had to do John Stuart at 11 so I 11:41 needed I needed to know. As one does, yes. Talk you down a little bit 11:47 who that who was in those groups and what you heard in their reaction to 11:50 what happened. Yes we did two groups immediately and it wasn't after we 11:53 woke up it was just we just never went to sleep and we just kept 11:56 going and got the voters in there. And we did the group that was the most interesting was the 12:02 group of Republicans who had voted for Democrats because their vibe was very much like thou art 12:09 punished it. They just they were like why did I vote for him because I wanted to check on this 12:14 madness. It's insane what's going on. And I think that this was the part that I'm over 12:21 because I've been doing nothing but just like celebrating endlessly and doing interviews 12:25 where I'm just like, can't get out of my skin. 12:29 But as we really get through the data, 12:31 I will be interested to see how many people 12:35 who are Trump voters, who ultimately voted for Democrats, 12:38 because I think the number is gonna be shockingly high. 12:41 And just going back to my first point, 12:43 I was pretty confident sort of the bottom 12:46 was gonna fall out of the Republican vote. 12:47 Like I just thought it was gonna be way down. 12:50 But I am pretty sure that the persuasion effect, 12:53 You might be even if it's even if it's two to one in a midterm not just that because independence 12:59 Totally broke for Democrats. So that's there 13:01 But if you get those Republicans do what you have to to get a Josh Shapiro by what was he ultimately 24 points or something insane, right? 13:10 I mean to in South Carolina in Mississippi like you have to have Trump voters who have voted for the Democrat 13:16 And so I cannot wait to see what those numbers were but anyway, they said they wanted to check they were also 13:22 The thing about Republican voters, and this has been true in focus groups all along, 13:25 and this is why you should all listen to the focus group podcast, is that they were basically 13:30 saying at first it was the tariffs, and they were kind of like, oh, man. 13:36 And then the war, and then the data centers, like those were the three things. 13:42 And then in some of the specific places, though, voters in Ohio, that Vivek Ramaswamy 13:47 had like they thought it was downright evil and we did a 13:52 focus right and they were right. And so in to me though, 13:57 this is this election was about Trump. You know that the one 14:02 thing that the never Trumpers that we have wanted for 10 14:05 years and we have not gotten that we finally got was a thorough 14:09 repudiation of everything that Trump is, but but a bunch, but 14:14 along a bunch of different vectors. He is a failure as a 14:18 president. He was lying to people. He cannot lower your 14:21 prices on day one. He cannot end the war on day one. In fact, 14:24 he started a brand new war, which he said he wasn't going to 14:27 do, right? So, so there was that level of disappointment. He 14:30 didn't release the Epstein files. But also, he picked 14:34 Darlene Graham. He handpicked weird Lindsey Graham's 14:40 sister who has no political experience and the voters in 14:43 in South Carolina were like, 14:44 she doesn't have any political experience. 14:46 He also decided to run John Cornyn out of town 14:49 for being insufficiently pro-Trump, 14:51 even though John Cornyn was like, 14:52 here's my art of the deal, I'm reading it, 14:54 and someone took a picture of me reading it. 14:56 Please, I love you. 14:57 And he was like, no, you're done. 14:59 And then you get, so he's like, 15:00 I need a really corrupt person 15:01 who mirrors my corruption in Texas 15:03 and they put up the absolute worst candidate 15:05 that they could have possibly found in Texas, 15:07 not to take anything away from them. 15:08 Macken Paxson obviously sucked really hard. 15:10 And then if you even think about, if you even think about Georgia, when Donald Trump was 15:14 deciding to say that the 2020 election was stolen, what happened? 15:18 Democrats got two Senate seats in Georgia, and those are durable Senate seats now. 15:23 And then I'll say one last thing about what I think, you know, I talk a lot about how 15:31 there's this very scientific term now that I think is very important politics called 15:34 vibes. 15:35 And it goes back to something that Rebecca was just talking about. 15:38 And I talk about this. 15:39 There's a wonderful lady here. 15:40 She's got my book up front. 15:41 She's been showing it to me. 15:43 And I'll sign over there. 15:45 But one of the things I talk about in there 15:48 is how Democrats, if they want to build a community, 15:51 they have to be a community. 15:53 And this is true in a lot of ways 15:54 about how do you bring people in? 15:56 How do you get them excited? 15:57 And one of my favorite tickets this cycle 15:59 was actually a losing ticket, if it was the one in Florida. 16:03 And the reason that I liked it so much 16:05 is that it was like, what happens if you, 16:08 instead of the factional fight on Twitter, 16:09 You actually put a never-Trump Republican on the governor's side and you put a DSA black woman on 16:16 On as in the Senate candidate and then you run them together 16:19 And the thing is is that Florida to even come within three points with no investment 16:25 No investment had there been investment. I you know, but that is an interesting sort of 16:31 political science experiment right there and if you and you look at Georgia John 16:35 Ossoff and Keisha Lance Bottoms they put their arms around each other and they ran hard. They showed everybody in all of these states 16:42 We're doing this together and that drew so many more people in 16:52 Florida's my home state so it still breaks my heart, but I will say down ballad was it was fantastic. Yeah, totally 17:01 So I want to come back to Latino peace we talked about persuasion, you know, I think part of what 17:06 that had so many people skeptical 17:08 that what happened on Tuesday 17:09 would actually happen at the end of the day 17:11 is because we're so used to Trump doing things 17:13 and never paying the price. 17:16 Sarah rattling off all of the terrible things he did. 17:19 And then in the Trump era, it's so unreal 17:21 that there was no like cause and then effect, right? 17:24 And yet what we saw on Tuesday was 17:26 Trump had done bad things 17:28 and then there were consequences for them 17:29 and they were very, very big. 17:32 And the best case of that is among Latinos. 17:35 So Donald Trump had made these pretty historic gains 17:39 among Latinos over the course of his elections. 17:41 From 2016 to 2020 to 2024, 17:44 he kept Democratic support among Latinos kept dropping. 17:48 What we saw in 2026 is it circle all the way back 17:51 to around 2016 again. 17:53 And the thing is, there is a turnout dimension, 17:55 but we shouldn't really simplify voters 17:57 as turnout voters or persuasion voters. 17:59 Most of that trip back is because of defection. 18:02 at least around 15% of Latinos who had voted for Donald Trump 18:07 switched sides, right? 18:09 They walked back away from the vote that they had just made 18:12 because of what they felt were the broken promises 18:16 of Donald Trump. 18:17 And so the way you get that kind of movement 18:20 is that you combine turnout enthusiasm, 18:23 but also a lot of vote switching and new voters 18:26 and you plus those up and it equals a big ass kicking. 18:29 So here, so here's what I want to do. So after 2016, the Democratic Party just like imploded a 18:36 little bit and we all blamed each other and we said, you know, Bernie would have won. We should 18:40 have done it this way. And we never had an autopsy to figure out what happened. Now it's 10 years 18:45 later, a lot of people on the left, me included, think that Bernie's economic populism was the 18:52 way of the future and maybe we should have gotten a little bit more curious 10 years ago. 18:56 So, but here we are, right? 18:59 And I'm wondering if we couldn't do an audit when we lost. 19:02 What if we actually did an audit when we won? 19:05 And instead of having everyone have their group say, 19:08 this is why we won, we actually got some hard evidence. 19:11 We saw what worked, we learned from it, 19:14 and then we continue to win. 19:16 What, how does that sound? 19:17 Yeah! 19:27 Pate America is brought to you by Helix. 19:30 As we move into a new season, 19:31 set your home up for comfort and rest. 19:33 Whether you're upgrading your guest room for holiday visitors or just trying to catch 19:36 up on much needed sleep during sick season, a great mattress makes all the difference. 19:41 Helix Custom builds your mattress based on your sleep needs. 19:43 Just take the two-minute Helix sleep quiz to determine your best fit. 19:46 They deliver your mattress right to your door with free shipping in the US, and you can 19:50 rest easy with seamless returns and exchanges and a 365-night sleep trial, part of their 19:54 happy with Helix guarantee. 19:56 Helix is the most awarded mattress brand for a reason tested and reviewed by experts 20:01 It's like Forbes and Wired. 20:03 God, I love Helix mattresses. 20:05 In our house, here at Cricket, 20:08 Pete had been struggling with a sleep for months, 20:09 but he switched to Helix mattress, 20:11 made an immediate difference. 20:12 Even his Oro ring backs it up. 20:14 His overall sleep score improved, 20:16 showing more sleep, more REM, 20:17 and far fewer interruptions throughout the night. 20:19 I would love that. 20:21 Go to helixsleep.com slash cricket 20:23 and get up to 30% off your mattress. 20:25 That's helixsleep.com slash cricket 20:27 for up to 30% off helixsleep.com slash cricket. 20:30 This podcast is sponsored by Planned Parenthood Federation of America. 20:34 Obviously, we talk about politics a lot on the show, court decisions, bills in Congress, 20:38 fights in state legislatures. We cover it all. But for someone trying to get healthcare, 20:42 the stakes go beyond theory and debate. Politics can determine whether they can get care at all. 20:47 Lawmakers have been attacking reproductive rights and care for decades. Through it all, 20:51 the people at Planned Parenthood health centers keep showing up for patients. Every day, doctors, 20:55 nurses, staff, volunteers, they all help people get the services they need. 20:58 Roughly one in four people across the country have visited a Planned Parenthood Health Center for birth control, wellness exams, 21:04 STI testing and treatment, cancer screenings, gender-affirming care, abortion care, and so much more. 21:10 And the people providing that care show up day after day, and now they're asking you to join them. 21:14 Make a gift of any size at plannedparenthood.org 21:17 slash defend because they never stop showing up and neither should you. 21:24 I think we can kind of start the audit right now. 21:28 Adisu, as you were looking at the campaigns, 21:30 you were traveling the country with a lot of campaigns, 21:32 what did you see the party doing differently 21:36 in 2026 and within 24? 21:37 Like what lessons did we actually learn 21:39 or things that actually changed 21:40 or was it mostly just better environment? 21:44 I mean, I'm not gonna lie, 21:45 it was a lot of better environment, 21:46 but that's, I think that ended up reflecting 21:48 in our candidate. 21:49 So honestly, the answer is like discipline. 21:52 And I think when I say discipline, 21:54 I mean like message discipline about the president and his failures and what Carlos said is totally right. You guys all know this 22:00 I was involved in 2020. I was involved in 22. I was involved in 24 22:04 the one thing we could basically count on for all four years basically up until 2025 was that Trump's approval rating was basically gonna hover around 40 22:12 no matter what he did and 22:15 Because of the tariffs and because of the war we finally saw those numbers dipped to what everybody seeing in the public in the public 22:21 Yeah, what do we call that guys? 22:24 There you go. 22:26 Thank you, Sarah. 22:28 But I think our candidates saw that and stuck to it, 22:32 no matter what was happening on Twitter, 22:35 no matter what distractions the president was throwing 22:37 out there with his stupid renovation projects 22:39 or whatever it might be. 22:41 And I honestly, I think in the first resistance, 22:43 as I like to call it, the like capital F, capital R 22:45 back in 2017, 2018, I was a part of it. 22:48 Guilty. 22:51 We chased that, because honestly, I mean, I get it, right? 22:55 Like, I want to chase it, too, because it's stupid and dumb and hurting people. 23:00 But the candidates didn't chase it, the campaigns didn't chase it. 23:03 They were as disciplined as I've ever seen a diverse set of candidates 23:07 in a diverse set of states about the importance of lowering costs 23:10 and taking on corruption. 23:11 And I don't think that was some on high from Washington or the capital command. 23:18 It was people like Rebecca. 23:19 It was people like Carlos. 23:20 It was people like Seth Krasny. 23:22 It was people like Peyton Lewis in Minnesota, 23:25 like people who were the campaign managers who said, 23:27 we are not going to let this guy throw us off our game. 23:30 And the candidates and the campaigns did it. 23:32 And we saw the, we, we repped what we saw, 23:35 which was huge wins everywhere. 23:37 But we almost didn't win. 23:39 I want to just be clear. 23:40 There were a lot of people who really doubted 23:43 what could win this year. 23:45 And nowhere is that more clear. 23:47 Well, Michigan, for Abdul, who like was such an exciting candidate, there was headwinds 23:54 all the way. 23:54 That's a whole other subject. 23:56 But in Texas, we couldn't get anyone to believe in Gina. 23:59 And to me, like the opportunity of Texas was the biggest opportunity the Democrats have 24:08 had in forever. 24:10 And we got like the DGA is a perfect example of an institution that should have just 24:16 been really interested in saying how could we take Texas like back? How do we change the map? 24:23 But there's a whole thing about it like they said there's this many vote like we want this 24:28 many states and no state is better than any state. So we didn't have people who were excited 24:34 about investing in the possibility of Texas and that almost cost us the biggest prize we've ever 24:39 gotten. And so as we look forward we should keep thinking about how we build for the future 24:44 and not just how many races can I win this year, 24:47 but what does that mean for the future? 24:48 I mean, this is the constant challenge of the party 24:52 is everyone is on a short-term cycle 24:56 where they feel like they're measured by what happens 24:57 in that moment. 24:58 So the DGA is like, well, 25:00 I wanna win as many seats as I can now. 25:02 So where are the most easy six seats, 25:04 seven seats, eight seats I can win? 25:05 And not thinking about the fact 25:07 that after the 2030 census, 25:10 Texas is gonna have three, 25:12 maybe four more electoral votes 25:13 in California is going to have maybe three or four less electoral votes and there's no 25:16 why not yeah that's the point why isn't everybody thinking about like we have all these we have a 25:21 democratic national committee we have all these groups that are supposed to be thinking about 25:25 this all the time but no one in a position of power in this entire city made a bet on Gina 25:32 she had to do it all herself can I and this is when we are we're going to sit through the 25:38 data and we're going to be nerds about it but there's something ineffable that we should 25:42 put our arms around, which is that a psychological barrier 25:46 has been broken where the map is no longer locked in. 25:51 Like we've been living through an age of polarization 25:53 for you think, well, these things are impossible. 25:56 They can't happen. 25:57 And now, I don't know about you, 25:59 but I'm sitting around being like, 26:00 somebody should invest in Florida again. 26:02 Like we should start thinking about all these things. 26:06 And there's nothing to breed success, like success. 26:10 And that's why this idea of the right normally the autopsy the point is you're dead, right? 26:14 And instead if you're like what if you're like, I don't know what the word is when you're like, let's examine the aliveness of this 26:21 Let's see how you make it live harder and longer. I guess it's called like medical attention 26:25 But but we but but that is that I'm expensive under trump. Yeah, that's right. Uh, they'll cut healthcare 26:31 That's all they'll get's all they'll try to beat us 26:33 But that's psychological barrier being broken is like that's the story of what just happened 26:39 which is that offense now is something that everybody can sort of lean into because they see it can be done. 26:47 You know, Adisu brought up a message discipline, right? And individual campaigns were disciplined, 26:54 but I watched this video that More Perfect Union put out the other day, 26:58 where they had clips. And our candidates were as diverse as they could be, right? You have the 27:02 a pastor from Kansas, you have the Bernie endorsed candidate 27:06 in Michigan, you have the seminarian in Texas, 27:10 you have the pediatrician in South Carolina, they're everywhere. 27:13 But when you listen to what they were saying, 27:16 they were telling the same story 27:18 where they were talking about a economy 27:22 that was not working for people 27:23 and they were naming the villains in it. 27:26 And I just wanted, anyone here can reflect on what, 27:30 way how we got to that point, 27:31 We're all talking about whether you are an avowed person on the left or an avowed person in the middle. 27:37 Roy Cooper and Abdul Sayed were saying the same things a lot of the time. 27:41 Well, you can't lie to people about what they're seeing with their own eyes. 27:45 And they know that the system is rigged. They know that corporations are a big part of the 27:51 problem. You know, Bernie rallied against the millionaires and billionaires. Now we have 27:55 a trillionaire who had the biggest self-own of anyone on election day. Let's be clear. 28:01 But if you look at all of these speeches, 28:04 there is a post-partisan populism to them, right? 28:08 Like it wasn't about the red states and blue states anymore. 28:11 It was like, this is what we gotta get done for the people. 28:13 And that was exciting. 28:15 Like we need to learn from all of these governors 28:17 and newly elected senators 28:18 that they wanna get actual results for people. 28:22 And it's not about being a moderator progressive. 28:27 It's about getting results. 28:28 So like let's go help them. 28:29 I think the story starts a lot on January 20th, 2025, 28:33 when, you know, who got the front seat 28:35 to Trump's inauguration? 28:36 It wasn't even his own cabinet nominees. 28:38 It was Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos, right? 28:42 And voters aren't stupid. 28:44 Like, they saw Musk get a job in the White House, right? 28:48 Not to mention spend $200 million 28:50 against our candidates and- 28:51 Four hundred. 28:51 Sorry, whatever. 28:53 It's all wasted, right? 28:55 And so, voters aren't stupid, right? 28:56 And I think it was also an easy message to glob onto because whether you're from the left or the middle or frankly the right 29:03 I think that's part of the reason to Sarah's point 29:05 We got a lot of Republicans in some of these southern states 29:08 You don't like when your government is used as a plaything for rich people and it's a very easy message for to unite our party 29:16 And frankly, I would say to anybody who's listening who's here in Washington 29:19 It's something we better as well deliver on actually doing with the majority that we have in Congress 29:24 We got to take these people on hold them accountable 29:26 Regulate their industries and make sure they can't buy government 29:30 for the next two years and beyond but in 29:33 What part of the appeal of trump in 24? 29:36 We still have to talk about this 29:38 Is what's the america first? It was the sense of 29:42 Democrats are putting other people other priorities ahead of you 29:47 right 29:48 They're they want to just they they democrats want to fight about trans issues 29:53 Me donald trump going to lower the cost of living 29:56 They want to go do wars in Ukraine. 29:59 I, Donald Trump, am not going to have any new wars. 30:02 I'm going to put you first ahead of everything else. 30:04 And then he got into power and systematically squandered 30:08 every one of those opportunities. 30:11 The message is, why are AI data centers so unpopular? 30:15 Part of it is the uncertainty of AI, 30:17 but part of it is also a larger narrative 30:19 of I don't have control over my own life, 30:21 that there is a small, wealthy elite 30:23 who are making decisions about my future, 30:26 What my jobs are going to look like, what my community is going to look like, who decides whether they're going to put something in my neighborhood, and I'm going to have to pay higher utility prices to pay for it, even though I don't understand what it is. 30:36 This sense of not control, that there is a powerful elite that is making these decisions for me, and they are rejecting it strongly. 30:44 I think the, and that led to a consensus among Democrats. Yeah, all these factional fights like moderates, progressives, everybody was saying the same things. 30:51 It was very similar. 30:52 And by the way, the best America first message I heard in 2026 was from Abdul Sayed, who 30:58 has taken it back, who's understood the value of a liberal nationalism that is about saying, 31:03 yes, we need to take care of our people. 31:05 That is the priority of our government. 31:07 And it's important for Democrats now that they take power. 31:10 By the way, Democrats are still not popular. 31:12 They're not, right? 31:15 The need here now is not Biden gotten the power squandered the opportunity. 31:19 Trump got into power, squandered the opportunity. 31:21 Democrats cannot forget what got them elected 31:24 because voters can change their minds real quick, 31:27 as we just saw. 31:28 And I will say for Abdul, 31:31 he ran an unapologetic patriotic campaign, 31:34 and it got missed time and time again. 31:37 But you look at our placards, it was Michigan first. 31:39 It was spending our money in Michigan. 31:41 And I think that just got completely overlooked. 31:43 And people didn't want their tax dollars 31:45 being spent overseas. 31:46 They wanted them right there to invest in their schools 31:48 in hospitals. 31:51 You know, we brought, you know, people brought up Elon Musk in the $400 he 31:54 wasted, but one of the things that I think kept a lot of people like you 31:57 look at the fundamentals, look at the polling, you think this is a great 31:59 year for Democrats. The one thing that gave people pause, at least up until 32:02 like the last couple of weeks is we've never faced this much money before. 32:06 This is the greatest financial disparity in any in all these races 32:10 were just absolutely unbelievable. 32:12 And Rebecca, you both in Michigan and particularly in Texas, just 32:16 the spending disparity between what the Republicans are spending and your cancer will spend is 32:20 just like God smacking. How did you navigate that? How are you able to sort of close that 32:26 gap? 32:28 So it is daunting. Remember, Gina got into this race. Greg Abbott already had $100 million 32:34 before we even got into the race. So it was daunting. But I will say this is one 32:39 of the great lessons of Mayor Mamdani is to always be communicated, right? And 32:44 And if you look at some of these folks, we never got that kind of money, but we did build 32:50 our own following, right? 32:53 And Abdul was constant with the attention economy. 32:57 He knew how to grab some headlines. 32:59 He would go anywhere, whether it was Fox News, whether it was on his own channels, 33:03 and we were constantly producing content. 33:06 Gina was walking around the data centers giving her lives as she's talking about 33:11 what's happening. 33:12 And we were building and building and building a real following because in Texas the majority of voters were 33:20 Millennials and zoomers. That's what made up the majority of voters. So they weren't watching the evening news 33:25 They were watching what was on their feed 33:27 So we had to get on everyone's feet and it was it was an exhaustive amount of interviews and just going everywhere 33:35 But the candidates that won and that beat all the money they worked harder than anyone else and you just got out work them 33:45 This idea of the everything, everywhere, all at once, 33:48 communication strategy is so essential. 33:51 But also, to do that, it takes an enormous amount of energy, 33:56 which is why it's not just that the millennials 33:59 and the Zoomers turned out to vote, 34:01 those were also the candidates. 34:03 They were a bunch of millennials, 34:05 elder millennials, right? 34:06 They're all like, I saw somebody, Rachel Jan Faza, 34:09 who does a lot of, she does some 34:10 of the millennial focus group stuff, 34:11 so I follow her, put out the ages. 34:12 And it was like that moment when you watch like college football and you realize they're all way younger than you and it's really 34:20 Depressing and I was like seeing that they're all 39 and I was like my moments over. I'm too old like to run for anything 34:27 Because they're all 39 43 whatever and so the energy this is 34:31 In Texas everyone knows Texas a big expensive state to advertise in so what did they do? 34:37 They just went everywhere like with their feet. They showed up. Do you know why Angie Nixon beat? 34:42 Alex Vindman in pencil. I'm sorry in Florida for that primary is because he had more money 34:48 She had more energy and so like the energy from this has to be carried through but you can see that the 34:56 Generational change like you know everything is about how do we not just beat Magda 35:00 but like salt the earth with its ashes and make sure that it can never come back and like some of that is 35:07 Donald Trump is 80 fucking years old and 35:10 And Joe Biden was older than that. 35:13 And so like to have this new generation is to, 35:16 is to like bring in a new era. 35:19 And that's why it does have to sort of define itself 35:21 early of what it's gonna do. 35:24 And it does, because this is just one thing 35:26 I wanna make sure you understand. 35:27 We in this room, we are pumped. 35:30 We are so happy. 35:32 But we didn't win this election 35:33 because voters are pumped. 35:36 We did it because they're hurting. 35:37 And so the delivery of something for those people 35:40 has to be real. 35:42 Yeah, I couldn't agree more. 35:45 Like I've been trying to temper my own enthusiasm 35:47 with the realization that what Carlos said is true, 35:51 voters don't love Democrats. 35:52 And also they don't really expect us to deliver. 35:55 Doesn't mean we shouldn't try, 35:57 but they are cynical about our ability to make change, right? 36:01 They were cynical about Trump's ability to make change 36:03 and he did even worse than they thought. 36:04 But the I think we did have more advertising than they did 36:08 I think we had the best advertising campaign in the history of America and it was the gas prices as people were driving down the street every single day 36:16 We can't we can't count on that to be the case forever, but more importantly we have to we have to put together a 36:23 Specific strategy that is specific to an election this election 36:27 2026 was about Donald Trump. It was about the war. It was about the tariffs 36:31 it was about taking back our country. 36:33 We now have the reins. 36:34 20 to 28 is gonna have a whole different electorate. 36:36 We're gonna have a whole bunch of different candidates. 36:38 We're gonna have to think about a whole different strategy. 36:40 So we shouldn't, we can't over learn these lessons 36:43 even as we, in this room at least, 36:46 rightly celebrate what happened on Tuesday. 36:48 We also can't put our thumb on the scale of in primaries. 36:51 I think what they tried to do to Abdul 36:56 to take him out in the primary is like unconscionable. 36:58 We should just have let that play out 37:00 because there was a lot of damage that we didn't have we didn't have enough money as the establishment. 37:06 So we didn't get to inoculate ourselves against a lot of the attacks that came in and that took 37:10 you know the the michigan primary was in august. So we had a very short window to have to like 37:16 like reclaim our our narrative and that that was done by our own party. 37:21 And I just think that like you look at what happened in california 22 that's bakersfield 37:26 Randy Villegas, the DCCC spent against him 37:30 for another candidate because they thought he would lose. 37:33 Randy Villegas is one of the biggest over-performers 37:35 in the whole country. 37:36 I think he's going to win by like 33 or 35. 37:40 He brought in Birdie and AOC the last couple of weeks 37:43 of the election. 37:44 He's like, let's go and it energize people. 37:46 So there's not just one way to win 37:49 and we have to keep reminding ourselves that 37:51 because they keep saying what can't win. 37:54 We don't know what can win 37:56 because we've never tried something new and this election was the first time and it worked. 38:00 So we should just keep going. It's a very important point on both Abdul, Randy Viegas, 38:08 a bunch of other elections is and this is going to come into play in 2028, not just for 38:14 like the political establishment for everyone in this room is no one knows what electable means 38:20 and no one really knows what electable is going to be in 2028. So you can begin the 38:23 process with eyes wide open and look at every single candidate and allow them to prove themselves 38:29 over the course of time. And you can make judgments how they perform on a debate stage, 38:34 on podcasts, hopefully this podcast. But like just the 2026 should show us that anything is 38:44 possible. We should open to it because I often tell people as many of you are too young to 38:47 this, but in 2006, when Democrats bounced back from a terrible 38:54 loss and took the House and the Senate, winning places like 38:57 Virginia, which at the time seemed insane, if that had not 39:02 happened, no one would have nominated Barack Obama. That 39:05 would not have been a possibility. Let's get back 39:07 to the advertising for a second. Because yes, we were 39:10 outspent. We also spent as a party and truly ungodly sum 39:15 of money on advertising. And mostly, but not entirely linear television. You guys just anyone 39:23 up here talk a little bit about whether the value of that with the media mix should be 39:29 did we light a bunch of money on fire? Like just, you know, 39:33 Well, you have to pop, right? You have to no one just watches TV anymore, especially 39:41 not younger people. You always have another screen out. So if you're doing an ad, you have to do 39:47 something that makes people look up. And I think, you know, obviously I work at Fight, it's we make 39:53 ads. We've have always tried to make our ads pop and like say something a little bit different 39:58 because by the end of a campaign, you're just the viewers are running scared from ads. It's 40:04 just like ugly, like attack ad after attack ad, it doesn't work. So you have to find them 40:09 different places and then you have to kind of complement it and amplify your other messages. 40:14 You can't just be and avoid. But if you're like, whether it was in Michigan or in Texas, 40:19 people had hundreds of millions of dollars and it didn't work because you can't just like 40:23 yell at people with the same boring ads. You have to try new things and you have to put 40:27 your candidate in different kinds of situations so that people, you know, get interested in it. 40:32 We had, for Gina, we had the flock camera ad. We had data centers. We were, we were, 40:37 we had this ad about, you know, her pronouns 40:39 or mom, governor, mom Texan and soon to be governor, right? 40:44 Like we kept having to try to do new things 40:46 to get people's attention. 40:48 Yeah, I think ads, it's often like a mutually assured 40:51 destruction thing, right? 40:52 The Republicans were spending more than we were 40:56 and you fear and you probably are polling 40:58 and seeing whether or not they have an effect. 41:00 You know, the minute when we started talking 41:01 about Mississippi in earnest was, 41:04 for me, it was early October, late September 41:06 because in September was when the biannual democratic freakout happened about how much 41:12 money we were being outspent by. But when we got to the end of September, early October, 41:17 the numbers had moved. And I think that's because you can't convince people the sky is green, 41:22 right? And I think Republicans, they were, they were trying to convince people the sky was green 41:26 and people weren't buying it. And at that point, I said, okay, they can spend another 41:29 100, 200, 500 million dollars. But if all they continue to say is the sky is green or 41:34 or God forbid, we might wanna be nice to trans people. 41:37 Like that's not gonna resonate 41:38 when people have to go to the gas station every day 41:40 and pay four or $5 a gallon. 41:42 So advertising still works. 41:44 It has to be multi-channel. 41:46 It has to be, it cannot just be linear television. 41:48 It has to be digital. 41:49 It has to be organic, it has to be paid. 41:50 But you still have to advertise 41:51 because especially in a state like Texas or Florida, 41:54 there are too many voters. 41:56 But the world matters. 41:58 What you say really matters. 42:00 And the fact that we had a chorus of people 42:01 across the country in a multi-channel way 42:04 at a national level and a state level and a local level 42:07 basically all saying the same thing. 42:09 That's how you win massive waves. 42:12 You know, one other thing about, yeah. 42:14 One other thing about the spending this time though 42:18 is like, do you have to have something 42:22 to spend money to say? 42:23 And Republicans were like, okay, so we started a war 42:27 and everything's bad for you. 42:30 So we're gonna talk about trans people, 42:31 the whole time. And I mean, Darlene Graham literally just talked about trans people. That was all of 42:37 her advertising. And one of the things that Democrats figured out between 2024 and 2026 42:42 was how to talk about the trans issue, which was to basically say, 42:47 why are you talking about the trans issue? Can you afford eggs? And like that level of 42:52 discipline, right? Because, you know, in 2024, we all just remember Democrats were basically 42:57 like did you say trans excuse me I have to run and or I'm gonna say like definitely you should pay 43:04 for transitions for felons with tax dollars you know and like that was not popular and this time 43:12 democrats really did figure out and they had different messages for where they were like 43:17 some people were not happy like I was with Annie Andrews and you know I you could just 43:22 see she was like please don't ask me about trans stuff it's like really terrible here in South 43:26 Carolina and she had to take a position that I think a lot of Democrats might not have liked, 43:31 but everybody also understood she had to win in South Carolina. And this is one of the things 43:37 that I think Democrats coming out of 2024 are understanding that they have to be a little 43:41 more flexible with their candidates. The way they understood this about Barack Obama in 2008, 43:46 when Barack Obama wasn't for gay marriage, everybody knew like, he's for gay marriage, 43:51 Would you just let him get elected and like people sort of understand that about Democrats right now 43:56 Which is like they can't talk they're not the trans stuff is not good for them in South Carolina or Mississippi or whatever 44:02 Let them talk about affordability and do whatever they need to do to get elected because winners make policy and losers go home 44:12 Yes, I 44:15 I come back often so much of what we need to do I get asked all the time well 44:19 How do we what do we do with Latino voters? 44:20 How do we Latino voters back so much if it's not rocket science? 44:24 It really is it for any group of people you talk to them about the things that they care about 44:30 And you do it in a way with messengers and language that uh reflects them 44:37 And here's the thing though that's not just an ad we like to simplify campaigns down to an ad ads do work 44:42 By the way, like there's a lot of literature ads do work even now 44:45 They still work they tend to work at the end because the effects of it decay very quickly 44:49 So that's why you have a lot of spending at the end. 44:51 If you let one side do all the spending, 44:53 you're gonna get your ass kicked. 44:54 All these things are true, but that's the very end. 44:56 To your point, the issue environment 44:58 is everything in between. 45:00 And I think sometimes the wonkier, 45:02 more technocratic, democratic set think, 45:04 okay, well, the election's over, now let's talk policy. 45:08 When in reality, the policy choices you make, 45:11 the fights you decide to engage on or to pick 45:14 are all political. 45:17 You can't go legislate now 45:18 and think that voters don't hear voters understand what your priorities are based on what you do 45:24 year-round and so you can't get at the end and say like well i really care about the economy 45:28 but i spent the last year and a half talking about everything except the economy 45:32 it is about the consistency of doing this year-round positive america is brought to 45:45 you by trees.com if you're a regular listener to the show you've heard us talk about fast 45:49 growing trees but now they're trees.com the same trusted online nursery with a simpler name 45:54 Trees.com is America's largest online nursery 45:56 with thousands of plants and trees 45:58 and over three million happy customers. 46:00 They have all the plants your yard or home needs, 46:02 including fruit trees, privacy trees, 46:04 flowering trees, shrubs and house plants, 46:06 all grown with care and guaranteed to arrive healthy. 46:09 Whatever you're looking for, 46:10 Trees.com helps you find options 46:11 that actually work for your climate 46:13 and your space and your lifestyle. 46:15 Trees.com makes it easy to get your dream yard. 46:17 Just click, order and grow 46:18 and get healthy thriving plants delivered to your door. 46:20 They're alive and thrive guarantee promises 46:22 that your plants arrive happy and healthy. 46:24 No green thumb required, just quality plants you can count on. 46:27 Plus get ongoing support from trained plant experts 46:30 who can help you plan your landscape. 46:31 Choose the right plants and learn how to care for them 46:33 every step along the way. 46:35 We have a bunch of plants and trees 46:36 from trees.com here at Crooked HQ. 46:38 They arrived looking great. 46:40 They've been very easy to care for 46:41 thanks to the experts at trees.com. 46:43 And if you're looking for something for your home, 46:45 they can help you figure out what would work 46:46 in your backyard or your landscape. 46:48 What's easy to keep alive, how to keep it alive 46:51 if you're not good at that kind of thing. Right now, they have great deals on planting 46:54 essentials up to half off on select plants, and listeners to our show get 20% off their purchase 46:59 when they use the Code Crooked at checkout. That's an additional 20% off better plants and better 47:04 growing trees at Trees.com using the Code Crooked at checkout, Trees.com Code Crooked. 47:21 even embarrassing things from our youth that play on an endless loop the minute we lay 47:25 our heads down to sleep. That sounds very specific. It doesn't have to be like this. 47:28 Therapy can help you evict intrusive thoughts and reclaim that precious space in your brain. 47:33 Start the process today with BetterHelp. BetterHelp therapists are licensed, experienced professionals 47:37 such as psychologists, marriage and family therapists, social workers and counselors. 47:41 They have at least three years and 1,000 hours of hands-on experience and have the 47:45 required education, training, exams and practice. BetterHelp does the initial 47:48 matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals. 47:51 A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences in our 10 plus years 47:55 of experience. 47:56 An industry leading match fulfillment rate means we typically get it right the first 47:59 time. 48:00 If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a different therapist at any time from 48:03 their tailored recommendations with no hassle. 48:06 It's great to see a therapist and you might not think you need one, but you go and 48:10 you talk to someone and you just, you're going to feel better and what better way 48:13 to do it than from the comfort of your own home with better help. 48:15 BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many co-pays as low 48:21 as $15 for eligible members. 48:23 And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 10% 48:26 off your first month. 48:28 Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com slash PSA. 48:31 That's better H-E-L-P dot com slash PSA. 48:38 In 2018, we, a lot of people voted for Trump and they came around and voted for Democrats 48:43 in the midterms. 48:44 And then three quarters of those veterans turned around and voted for Trump again in 2020. 48:49 And so as you guys think, and this is a little bit different because it's not, 48:54 you know, it's going to be a different Republican, presumably. 48:59 And as you guys think about what Democrats need to do, both with the power we have, but also, 49:05 like, tactically, you know, message-wise strategically to lock in some of these gains 49:11 at least give our 2028 nominee the opportunity to build on them. 49:15 Do you guys have thoughts on things the party could be doing? 49:17 The most important thing is helping Texas succeed, 49:20 because if we can take Texas off the table in 2028, it's ballgame. 49:29 So, that's a good point. 49:31 What happened to me? 49:31 Again, you're not allowed to. 49:33 Are you going to argue, Edi Sue? 49:34 Oh, no, I honestly had thought of it. 49:36 I was like, yeah, that's a good point. 49:37 Yeah, that's a lot of electoral votes. 49:39 So I think that's really important. 49:41 But we also have to remember that presidential years 49:44 are different than midterms. 49:45 I think a lot of our nominees in 2020, 49:49 or a lot of our candidates, 49:50 tried to over-learn the lessons of 28 49:53 and outdo each other, 49:54 and they just, they weren't authentic to who they were. 49:57 And if we're gonna win in 28, 50:00 we also need candidates to figure out who they are 50:02 and what they're running on, 50:04 and then have other examples of what they've done. 50:07 And we just can't roll over now that we've got this. 50:09 It's not, they didn't all vote for Democrats. 50:13 They voted against Republicans in a lot of these races. 50:16 So for 28, we need them to want to vote for us, 50:19 and that is gonna be the big thing we gotta get done. 50:22 You said this backstage, 50:24 so I don't wanna steal too much of your thunder, but. 50:27 Did I say something smart? 50:27 You said something, another thing smart. 50:29 Okay. 50:31 But the messengers that we have coming in to the house, 50:35 are diverse in talent, in ability, in demography, 50:39 in every way, on both sides here in Washington, 50:43 in the governor's offices, et cetera. 50:45 Now, obviously the party is gonna be defined 50:48 by who our nominee ultimately is. 50:50 That's how it always has been. 50:51 But for the next year in particular, 50:52 in the next two years in general, 50:54 we have people not only who are talented 50:56 and able to communicate our message, 50:58 but like you were saying, 51:00 there are uniquely facile in this media environment, 51:04 the new media environment, right? 51:05 So whether it's an Abdul or a Talarico, 51:08 or that old guy whose name I'm forgetting, 51:10 Chuck in Western North Carolina, 51:12 who somehow won a house race, 51:13 who was like apparently great at TikTok. 51:15 If you haven't seen him, like, 51:17 I got lost in his TikTok feed one night 51:20 and like that I didn't go to bed till five. 51:22 It's incredibly endearing. 51:24 But we have all these people who are really, 51:26 really good at communicating a message. 51:27 We have to, our leaders here in DC, 51:29 our leaders at the state parties, et cetera, 51:31 even while we get lost in the presidential primary, 51:34 have to put those people forward. 51:35 And the way that DC communicates is not that different 51:39 than when Dan and I were on the Hill 20 years ago. 51:42 You know, they had their big caucus meeting, 51:43 they come out, they do a press conference, 51:45 and it's like, that's it. 51:47 We could have dozens of different members and senators 51:50 actually say, here's what's happening today. 51:53 Here's what we are doing. 51:54 Here's what we're trying to pass. 51:55 Here's who's not letting us pass this. 51:57 Go call them, go make a difference. 51:58 It's like, we can use the power of this to actually change. 52:03 We got to get into it. 52:04 Everyone has their own channel now. 52:05 I mean, we have media entities. 52:07 Millions, tens of millions. 52:08 Abdul is a media entity now. 52:10 James Tolerico is like bigger than NBC. 52:13 Like, you know, we've got media entities. 52:16 Let's use it. 52:17 Let's use it. 52:18 It gets us to 2028, which is going to matter. 52:23 Obviously, it matters in who we pick 52:25 and if we have to pick the right person. 52:26 That will define the brand. 52:27 But it's also worth knowing that at some point next year 52:30 that's going to become the dominant story for voters. 52:33 And maybe even sooner, like, like in 2006, right? 52:37 We win this historic victory. 52:37 Nancy Pelosi becomes the first female speaker of the House. 52:40 We have all these new people, John Tester coming, 52:43 all these new Democrats, we use them. 52:45 They get sworn in on January 3rd. 52:47 On January 13th, Barack Obama 52:48 announced he's running for president. 52:49 Two weeks later, Hillary Clinton 52:50 announced she's running for president. 52:51 No one ever sees the Hill ever again. 52:53 And so I don't think it'll be like that this time. 52:55 that was obviously like a Titanic once in a century 52:58 presidential primary, but at some point 53:00 when the debates start over the summer, 53:02 that's gonna become the face of the party. 53:05 And there's great risk in that. 53:07 And that was a great risk in 2019 53:10 because we talked about everything 53:12 other than the things people cared about. 53:14 If you guys sort of thought about 53:16 what advice you would give candidates 53:18 about not just how for them to win the primary, 53:21 but for the best face they could put forward 53:23 for the party, for whoever the eventual nominee is? 53:26 Just the one thing I'll say about this, 53:28 and it goes back to my community. 53:30 I don't know if there's a way to do this, 53:33 but it feels like there should be some kind of a non-aggression pact 53:38 that just kind of keeps people from like tearing each other's faces off. 53:42 Like, it's not like they shouldn't have a competition of ideas, 53:44 but it almost feels like this kind of success. 53:47 You could rewrite the way that you do the primary, 53:51 Which is to say a bunch of the Democrats say like hey 53:54 There's a bunch of different ideas out here. Let's go around and instead of just like letting 53:59 We don't have to do politics the way we used to do politics 54:01 You don't have to let NBC set you up for a debate into Sarah. Have you met Twitter? 54:08 Boy has Sarah met Twitter. What do you mean? Oh about tearing each other's face off 54:13 Incidentally, I do have a bit of a Twitter face ripping off problem myself. And so I I 54:18 I understand physician heal thyself on this, but I just, for the candidates, it does feel 54:24 like, like, let us rip the faces off and let the candidates say there is an opportunity for us to 54:30 all sit down and, like, debate these ideas in really good faith and not, like, destroy each other 54:35 over it so that they can move in to 2028 with not exactly a unified front, but with a sense 54:40 that this is a good faith effort to do something great for the American people and 54:44 and not just a factional fight. 54:46 And then the other thing I'll say 54:47 just because I wanted to mention this before, 54:50 there's gonna be a real tricky point here 54:52 on a couple of places. 54:54 One is, you guys may have heard 54:56 that not everybody's super psyched 54:58 about Hakeem Jeffries or Chuck Schumer 54:59 being the next leaders. 55:01 And okay, but also, do you guys wanna have 55:04 a big nasty fight as your first thing right out of the gate? 55:07 I'm not sure. 55:08 I'm, it's a question for the room. 55:10 I'm not sure. 55:12 And then the other tricky point 55:14 to think about in terms of governing is like, 55:16 what do you do on the accountability front? 55:18 Who do you hold accountable? 55:19 And how much of that is Trump? 55:20 And I've been a big proponent of not impeaching Trump 55:26 because I think you end up then with repolarizing 55:29 your audience or your voters 55:31 with a rally round Trump effect. 55:32 And instead, you should be focused on getting Trump 55:35 to 32% that Bush line that I love to talk about, 55:39 which is what they were shouting before. 55:41 because you want them to be an albatross around everywhere, 55:45 because this was the other thing 55:46 about the focus groups I did the morning after. 55:48 We asked them about 2028 and all of the Republicans 55:50 in those groups said our nominee cannot be somebody 55:54 who is associated with the Trump administration. 55:56 Now, right now, and that's good, right? 55:58 Right now they are separating Republicans 56:00 into MAGA Republicans and like whatever's left over now 56:05 that could be vaguely normal. 56:07 And Democrats can win some 56:09 of those vaguely normal people with this new generation of people. 56:12 And so Democrats still have to think about an offense strategy on Trump 56:16 to make sure he is deeply unpopular and do nothing to make him accidentally more popular. 56:26 I've made it this far without talking about immigration. 56:29 So let me just talk about immigration because it's important for multiple fronts. 56:32 One is this primary. I will say obviously immigration was an important factor in this 56:38 midterm, especially among Latino voters, it wasn't the main 56:42 factor. It wasn't the only factor. It was a factor among 56:45 many, but it was part of a much broader story about the 56:48 message that Trump was sending about and Republicans were 56:50 sending about who they care about, who they feel belongs, 56:53 who they fight for and who they don't. That was only 56:56 possible because Democrats got more disciplined on 56:59 immigration. All Americans, including Latinos, want order 57:03 at the border. You don't want to have a stupid 57:06 border fight. A lot of the stupid immigration policies came out of a primary in 2020 where 57:13 people were floating ideas, were racing to the left and so they were trying to find some way 57:16 to distinguish themselves and I think it's important throughout the primary to have voices 57:21 because the candidates themselves are not going to do it. Voices who are helping check and say 57:26 please guys let's think of the general election, let's think of how this is going to play, 57:29 let's think about this affects the democratic brand at any given moment. That said, 57:34 When Trump was elected, I thought, okay, he could do smart fascism, or he could do dumb 57:39 fascism. 57:40 If he did smart fascism, it would be like in major danger. 57:43 Obviously, we know what he chose. 57:45 Just look at Pete Hegses' caveman face. 57:49 And now the poster boy of dumb fascism is the chief of staff of the White House. 57:55 And he's not trying to help Republicans win. 57:58 So like from an electoral standpoint, great. 58:00 But he is there to check off other items on his agenda list. 58:03 And top of that is really cruel immigration policies. 58:07 And there were a lot of people who thought 58:09 that Democrats shouldn't push back 58:11 on what Trump was doing on immigration. 58:13 But once he started crossing that line, 58:15 it was an important turning point in his administration, 58:17 that first summer of 2025. 58:19 It was strategic. 58:20 It wasn't just taking the bait. 58:22 We weren't defending murderers being deported. 58:25 We were saying, no, you are going after 58:27 hardworking people in our communities. 58:30 And so, keeping that strategy while this is happening 58:33 and defending our communities, 58:35 we don't have to stay quiet in order to win elections. 58:38 I think that is one lesson from 2026, 58:39 at the same time that we're not absolved 58:41 from being strategic at all times. 58:44 Moral clarity is a good thing. 58:46 Moral clarity is a good thing. 58:48 I don't know what to say. 58:49 I mean, I think this primary is gonna be tough. 58:53 And, you know, in many ways, 58:55 at the 2019 primary, I agree. 58:56 I ran a campaign and I remember it well. 58:58 Well, it was not the best time I've ever had in my life, 59:03 but I do think we did a good job, 59:06 I think because Trump was president 59:08 and the unifying factor behind all of us was, 59:11 we can't let him get another term to not tear each other apart. 59:16 Then you have 2008 and 2016, 59:18 two primaries I also worked on 59:19 where that was not necessarily the case 59:21 for the entirety of the primary season. 59:24 I think this one is honestly more likely 59:25 to be like 2008 or 2016. 59:27 But I think that it'll go longer or that it'll be nasty that's there nasty or I just don't I just don't think there's much 59:34 We can do about that because honestly we have a 12-year boiling pot in our party that people in this room 59:40 I think are well aware of that basically we've we've kept the lid on 59:43 Because of the threat of Donald Trump and in many ways what happened on Tuesday in my opinion was the beginning of the end of 59:49 Trump and Trumpism, but what does the Democratic Party? Yeah, I know please God willing inshallah 59:55 but 59:56 But what does the Democratic Party look like 60:00 in 2027, eight and beyond is an open question. 60:04 And we have to have that debate in public. 60:06 I'm totally fine with it. 60:07 My in-treaty to anybody watching, listening, 60:10 ever hearing this, the candidates, 60:11 God, if they wanna listen to me is 60:13 we have to not go so far as to not be able 60:18 to come back together. 60:18 We can't let Humpty Dumpty break all the way. 60:21 And in many ways, I think that's about, 60:23 it's when things go from political to personal. 60:25 So it's when you start tearing human beings down for who they are or what their motives 60:29 might be, because I know that whatever candidate you don't support in the, or candidates you 60:34 don't support in the primary in 2028 are still going to be infinity times better than whatever 60:40 bullshit they put up on the other side. 60:42 And keeping that in the back of your mind when we're in the heat of battle in March 60:45 of 2028, it's going to be hard, but I think we could all do it. 60:49 I don't mind a messy primary. 60:51 I'm sorry. 60:52 I just, I think that's the way that we're going to get somebody good. 60:54 It's like when you're you're going through the playoffs and you're just winning a game every week 60:59 You get better and better for the Super Bowl like we got to do that too 61:04 2008 was one of the messiest primaries. I've ever seen and we got Barack Obama after it. So I'm I'm for it 61:09 You know, I just want to make sure I 61:12 In Michigan, especially the attacks were so personal and so hideous on Abdul 61:19 every day they caught him a terrorist or a jihadist. 61:22 It was just, it was so ugly. 61:25 So my wish going forward is that we can at least 61:28 keep it a lot less personal because I do think 61:31 we forget that some of these candidates are actually people 61:35 and when you're spending hundreds of millions of dollars 61:37 to attack them, it like it does something. 61:40 So I just, if we can keep it focused on policy 61:44 and have a lively discussion, 61:46 I think we'll be better at the end of the day. 61:47 Yeah, I I completely agree with that. I think like one of the big things that I think people are gonna have to try to avoid is just because you 61:54 Disagree on an issue that you were there for corrupt for your position like you can have 61:59 You can disagree on how you're gonna do universal health care 62:02 And it does it if you believe one thing you're not in the pocket of this person or the other person 62:06 I think that's a very important thing. I think the thing that people are 62:11 Most concerned about concerns me is whether we end up like what the 2019 campaign primary was not nasty 62:18 Mostly at all. I mean that the things people fought over were insanely stupid like whether you thought Elon Musk should be banned from Twitter or all those other things 62:27 but the 62:28 But it was the bidding the bidding each other into these very unpopular positions that actually didn't come back to haunt us for another four years 62:37 So that I think that's the big thing Carlos last question. I can't let you off the stage without having to defend the entire polling industry 62:44 if we if if 62:46 If this had been a disappointing night, 62:50 we would all, this entire panel would have known 62:52 why the polls were wrong. 62:54 Yeah. 62:54 Yet they were still wrong. 62:56 They were. 62:57 And so I'm sure your polls were perfect, 63:00 but just say a little bit about like how you're thinking 63:05 about what we need to do to get to more acronyms. 63:08 It's just cooler when they underestimate us 63:10 in the other side, but they're still wrong. 63:12 The polls are wrong. 63:13 We can say that. 63:14 polls underestimated Democrats in every Senate seat except Nebraska. The average of generic ballot 63:20 was D plus nine. The result was D plus 14. So yeah, wow, right? So yeah, individual pollsters, 63:30 polls were good. The forecasts were good. Actually, if you judge them as 63:35 forecast probabilistic forecasts, not in terms of what their like median guess was. 63:40 That's not what people do. People try to have it both ways. 63:42 But here's what I would say, Nate Silver says this, 63:46 all polls at this point are models. 63:49 There is not, we are not in the heyday 63:51 where we are getting a perfectly randomly sampled 63:56 slice of the electorate. 63:57 Response rates are so low. 63:59 We're using online methods 64:01 where you're doing like non probabilistic samples. 64:03 And so everything you're waiting very heavily 64:07 toward your expectations. 64:09 So what does that mean? 64:10 At ECHIS, our final Latino number was 63%, which would have been Biden levels, but that was the 64:16 waiting scheme we used. We published all the other waiting schemes that we could have looked at. 64:20 And if we had favored more, how people were telling us they were going to, whether people were 64:25 telling us their vote intent, whether they were going to vote or not, it would have been 65. 64:30 If we didn't wait on how people had voted in 2024, which we did do, 64:35 it would have gone up to 70%, which is probably about what the final result is. 64:38 which does get maybe to the idea that people were so worried about an overcorrection. 64:43 Yes. It's a defensible mechanism if you think that there are Republicans who aren't responding to 64:47 your polls disproportionately. But here's what I would say. It was wrong in 2026, 64:52 but if you tried to not wait on recall every cycle, you'd also be in trouble. 64:57 Waiting on recall helped in 22 and in 2024. So at the end of the day, what's happening is 65:02 you're betting, you're as a pollster, you're guessing. These are educated guesses, 65:07 But you're guessing and so the real message to consumers is don't use Poles as therapy 65:14 See like an actual therapist like your mood should not be connected to what the average is at any given point 65:20 But if it is I have a podcast for you all 65:26 Okay, I'm going into your bottom line 65:28 Yeah, but I'll say but like we should be transparent about what Poles actually can do which is like puncture our view 65:34 our own little views of the electorate, 65:36 but understand them as a range, 65:38 understand them as possibilities, 65:39 understand that we're all trying to better grok 65:43 what actually matters in elections, 65:45 but there's a lot of factors beyond those poll numbers. 65:48 And so you don't have to religiously wait 65:50 for the New York Times Sienna every few weeks. 65:52 Okay, we are at time. 65:54 So I wanna thank Sarah, Carlos, Rebecca and Hadesu. 65:57 These are some of the smartest people in politics 66:00 and I could talk to them for hours, 66:02 but we gotta get off the stage. 66:40 Thank you, everyone. 66:44 debt programs is over $20,000. 66:47 Stop juggling multiple payments and get one lower monthly payment. 66:50 Saving start the day you complete a 30-second assessment, checking your options is fast, 66:54 free, and won't impact your credit. 66:55 If you are carrying any balance on your credit cards, it's costing you money every single 66:59 day. 66:59 No minimum credit score required. 67:01 PDS is the top-rated company in the industry with thousands of 5-star reviews and an A-plus 67:06 rating on the BBB. 67:07 Get your free 30-second personalized assessment today 67:10 at pdsdebt.com slash crooked. 67:13 That's pdsdebt.com slash crooked. 67:22 This looks cool. 67:23 Not bad. 67:25 Welcome, everyone. 67:28 Governor, thank you for being here. 67:29 It's good to be here. 67:31 Congratulations on your reelection. 67:33 Thank you. 67:36 I saw that you just squeaked by. 67:39 It was a nail platter there. 67:40 Yeah, Democrats of course had an incredible Tuesday in Pennsylvania, but also Kansas, South Carolina, Texas, Mississippi. 67:52 What do you think Democrats in those red states and purple states did right that Democrats haven't done right in the past? 68:03 Well, first off, I think it is incredible that we are winning everywhere. 68:07 I mean, I want you to think about this on the state side of the top 10 states in America 68:13 size wise, nine of them are now represented by Democratic governors. 68:17 Wow. 68:18 It's amazing. 68:19 It's amazing. 68:20 From Texas, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New York, California, and so it shows we can win anywhere. 68:26 And I think for a long time politically, our party has had a 270 attitude. 68:32 And I think we got to look back at Clinton Obama, who are pushing 370 and that needs to be our attitude 68:38 We got to show up everywhere. We got to treat people with respect 68:42 We have to have policies that actually make their lives better and then we have to importantly 68:48 Show our results in Pennsylvania. We call that 68:52 GSD get stuff done and you know, I think it may sound corny to you 68:58 It may sound dorky to you, but when you actually get a permit in a day instead of a year, when 69:04 you actually see the effect of the infrastructure work you do, when you actually see a kid get 69:11 free breakfast or have a mental health counselor in their school, when you see the effect 69:17 of job creation, when you see as we did that we invested 60% more in helping push 69:24 young people into the building trades so they can learn a skill and go out and do the work 69:29 we need in America. 69:30 That's concrete stuff that matters. 69:33 And that is what I saw candidates in Texas and Mississippi and South Carolina and elsewhere 69:39 talking about concrete stuff to make people's lives better. 69:43 And now they gave us the keys to the car. 69:46 We got to drive it. 69:47 We got to drive it well. 69:47 And we got to drive it forward. 69:50 Well, so you will now have the chance to govern Pennsylvania with Democrats in control of the 69:56 state legislature. It was like so much of your success over the last four years has been the 70:05 ability to work with Republicans at times in the state Senate. You've appointed Republicans to 70:11 work in your administration. 70:13 Do you think it's possible for that style of bipartisan 70:18 governance to work on a national level with this 70:23 Republican Party now or even after Trump is gone? 70:27 Look, I'm always someone who believes you got to reach 70:31 across the aisle and try and work with them. 70:33 But I will just tell you, my experience in Pennsylvania 70:35 is while we got a whole lot of stuff done reaching 70:38 across the aisle. There were moments about a year ago where I tried to reach out across the aisle to 70:45 get stuff done and I was met with a rebuke. I reached out to every one of those Republican 70:52 members of Congress in Pennsylvania before that beautiful budget bill came up for a vote and I 70:57 said, hey, if you vote yes, to give a tax cut to the people at the very, very top who do not 71:03 needed. This is the number of people in your district who are about to lose 71:09 healthcare. This is the number of people in your district who are going to lose 71:12 SNAP. And I'm urging you to vote no. Some of them say oh governor don't worry 71:18 I'll never vote for that. And then these cowards went to DC the next week 71:22 and they voted for it. And that was a moment where I realized trying to 71:26 reach out and work with them was not possible. So I recruited four great 71:31 candidates to run for Congress and we beat their asses on Tuesday night because you got 71:37 to stand up for what's right and sometimes, sometimes achieving what's right is working 71:44 with them in the halls of power and other times it's using our politics to go make 71:49 change so you can deliver more for the American people. 71:54 When you look out at the country, do you think our political and economic systems need fundamental 72:03 change? Do you think like what do you think is the essential problem and challenge right now 72:10 with our political and economic systems in the country? You got an hour? I mean it's a 72:17 long answer and there's like it's you know there's I'll try it this way there's 72:21 there's a theory where Trump has obviously been awful maybe Trump goes away 72:27 and a Republican Party goes back to normal post Trump and there's also you 72:33 know what what we really need is Democrats in power and once we get 72:35 Democrats in power they'll deliver more and things will be better and then 72:38 some people say no we actually need fundamental economic and political 72:42 Look, there's no going back and there's no looking in the rear view more mirror. 72:49 We have to look forward. 72:50 We've got to have massive reform and real change in this country. 72:55 And these midterms give us the ability to begin the process of laying out what we 73:01 would change. 73:02 Obviously, a whole lot of it will be stopped by Trump. 73:04 But we have to be for concrete, fundamental, real change in our system. 73:10 It's not about tweaking. 73:11 It's not about working around the edges. 73:14 It's about real significant change. 73:16 Whether you're talking about how the government operates, 73:19 the bureaucracy, whether you're talking 73:21 about a broken healthcare system, 73:23 whether you're talking about a broken foreign policy system, 73:26 we have got to have real fundamental change. 73:28 That's what I've tried to do in Pennsylvania, 73:31 not nibble around the edges, but make wholesale change. 73:34 And I do think that is what America needs. 73:36 We cannot yearn for a day in the past. 73:40 we've got to build for a brighter future. 73:45 Obviously, the country's dissatisfaction with cost of living was the top issue in these midterms. 73:53 If you could get one big thing done nationally to bring down the cost of living, 73:59 to make life more affordable in America, what would it be? 74:02 Look, I can just tell you, I'm going to get to the one thing, 74:05 but I can just tell you from my experience in Pennsylvania, it is by far been the number one thing. 74:09 That's why we cut taxes 10 different times in Pennsylvania for people who are working, 74:15 struggling to get by, for families who are trying to afford child care, for seniors who 74:20 are trying to stay in their homes. These are progressive tax cuts that help put money in people's 74:25 pockets. We built more affordable housing. We controlled the cost of healthcare. Now, 74:32 in Pennsylvania, every time we put a dollar in somebody's pocket, the problem was Trump took 74:36 two bucks out the other side because this war of choice in Iran we had no business getting into 74:40 he's got our earthly idea how the hell to get out of because the tariffs that he clearly didn't 74:45 understand when you put a tariff on Canada we pay more in Pennsylvania and across America 74:50 and so I understand folks didn't necessarily feel it at the state level so what what do we 74:55 need to do at the federal level you got to bring down the cost of health care you got 75:00 to make sure that it is not just accessible but affordable and the best way this new Congress 75:06 can do that is by using every bit of leverage they have to stop these Medicaid cuts from 75:12 going into effect. They're going to harm so many people. 510,000 Pennsylvanians are 75:20 in the process of losing access to healthcare. That just drives up the cost for everybody. 75:25 I would love to see this new Congress come out of the gate and stop those cuts and 75:29 And hopefully use that as a way to begin to bring down the cost of health care. 75:33 There's a lot they need to do, but you asked for one, so that's one example. 75:38 Your team has a memo out today that includes, that talks about all of your electoral success 75:43 and what you've done to sort of, like you said, recruit the four excellent democratic 75:49 Congress people to be. 75:52 It also includes a chart comparing the performance of every gubernatorial and Senate candidate 75:58 in a competitive race, specifically among independent voters 76:01 and Republican voters. 76:03 Spoiler alert, you are ranked number one. 76:07 So it was a good memo, I guess, though. 76:09 Although you're smirking, so I can't wait 76:11 to hear what the question's going to be. 76:12 It's an interesting chart for someone 76:14 who is just focused on governing Pennsylvania, 76:16 and I'm wondering... 76:18 There's the smirk right there, I got it. 76:21 Am I right to assume the intention was to 76:24 Um, send a message about your potential strength as a 20, 28 presidential candidate. 76:30 First of all, I think what candidates were able to pull off in Kansas, in South 76:36 Carolina, in Texas, I mean, these guys ran incredible races and, and I couldn't 76:42 be more impressed with what they did. 76:44 And I'm excited to get to know them. 76:45 I'm excited to work with them. 76:46 And I think what they are showing, and I think what I showed in Pennsylvania 76:51 Pennsylvania is you got to build a big broad coalition in order to win have a mandate to get stuff done and to be able to deliver on people's hopes and also address their fears. 77:06 Look, I would also tell you that it doesn't matter if you voted for Trump or Harris in the last election in Pennsylvania, they're all dealing with higher prices. 77:16 It doesn't matter who you voted for in the past, you're disgusted by the corruption that 77:22 is not only enriching Trump and his spoiled kids, but it's meaning less money in your 77:27 own pocket. 77:28 And so what I tried to do in my state was speak to that, not in a judgmental way about who 77:33 they voted for in the past, but to try and show them a path forward where we could 77:37 actually speak to meeting their needs, to addressing their challenges and to making 77:42 their lives better. 77:43 And now the burden is on me and those other governors and the senators and members of Congress to go deliver for them 77:49 I would just know one other fact. I'm not sure if it's on that chart. I haven't read the memo, but I appreciate you reading the memo 77:55 Of course great 77:58 If you look we're gonna end up winning somewhere north of about 40 seats in the Congress United States 78:06 roughly 78:08 two-thirds about 60% of 78:10 of those wins are from districts that Donald Trump 78:14 won by eight points or more. 78:18 So you can look at the senators and the governors, 78:20 I think that tells an interesting story, 78:22 but go look at those members of Congress. 78:24 People like Paige Cognetti, who won in Scranton. 78:27 I love Paige. 78:28 Love Paige. 78:29 And that's a district Trump, 78:31 if memory serves me correct, 78:32 I think Trump won that by eight and a half for nine points 78:36 and we won that district this time. 78:38 It is imperative that those members of Congress are not one hit wonders 78:44 They got to come back and the way we get them to come back is by making sure the things they spoke to 78:50 Effectively in this election how to bring down costs how to end the war in Iran how to make sure that there is a check on 78:57 This corruption 78:58 They've got to be able to legislate effectively that way and show their constituents that they are going to deliver for them 79:05 And if we do that effectively, then we can build that durable majority and we should be thinking as a party about 79:12 370 not 270 and that's our path forward 79:18 Might you be one of the people thinking about 370 as a potential candidate, I was gonna try again, right? I'm thinking about 79:28 I'm thinking about right now 79:30 Now, governing with a Democratic trifecta for the first time since 1978 in Pennsylvania. 79:37 I was actually texting with Katie Hobbs last night in Arizona, great governor. 79:44 She got a trifecta for the first time I think since 1960 something. 79:47 So she beat me by a few years there, but I'm excited about that. 79:51 And I'm also, I think looking forward to making sure that as our party thinks 79:56 about the direction we want to go in, that we are focused on a party that is looking at doing 80:02 big things again. We're focused on significant reform, not rebuilding what is in the past, 80:08 but building something big for the future. And I think coming from the, you know, the 80:13 swingiest swing state in America, we got a little bit to say about that. And I definitely 80:17 intend to be part of that conversation about what our party looks like going forward. 80:21 Well, it says it you laid out a hundred day agenda first hundred day agenda 80:26 So that would that would definitely so you're gonna be there for that that would take you into the spring 80:31 I'm gonna be there for the whole thing the whole thing the whole term 80:36 I have to try yeah, all right, you're doing great 80:43 We talked on the last panel about 80:46 What the new Congress is gonna do 80:48 everyone was in agreement about, you know, 80:51 like what you said, doing everything possible 80:52 to reverse the Medicaid cuts, 80:55 to also reverse the cuts to ACA subsidies 80:58 or at least to try to extend the ACA subsidies 81:01 as we had before. 81:03 Pramila Jayapal and other progressives have said 81:06 that they really want the Democratic House 81:08 to vote on Medicare for All. 81:10 I know you helped elect Bob Brooks in Pennsylvania. 81:12 He campaigned on Medicare for All. 81:14 Do you think that's a good vote for Congress to take? 81:16 And how would you think about actually bringing down costs in the long term and building a healthcare system that everyone can count on? 81:25 Yeah, and look, I didn't hear the Congresswoman's comments, but look, they will decide what bills come up for a vote and the leadership will determine what the best way forward is. 81:36 I think what is clear is our healthcare system is completely broken, where President Obama did a great job of creating access, right? 81:45 Trump has rolled back so much of that access and has driven up costs over the last decade. 81:52 Part of the reason why costs have skyrocketed is because we've allowed too many middlemen 81:57 into the system who are just draining costs out of the system. We did some real reform on 82:03 PBMs, those pharmacy benefit managers that from my perspective have no business being 82:08 involved in our healthcare system. All they do is drive up prescription drug prices. 82:13 So, number one, we got to get these middlemen out of the system. 82:17 We've got to make sure that there is some sort of real competition in this private system 82:22 with call it a public option, call it a buy-in on Medicare, whatever you're going to call 82:27 it, there has to be real competition and there has to be access to that public option. 82:32 We also have to get back to some basics here. 82:35 If a doctor prescribes something, if a doctor says you need something, the damn insurance 82:39 companies can't stop it, okay? 82:41 like common sense stuff like that. 82:44 So I want to see Congress put all that in a bill, 82:48 call it whatever you want, put whatever label you want, 82:51 whatever slogan you want on it. 82:52 But we need to show as a party, 82:54 we are for fundamental reform that brings down prices, 82:57 gets rid of all the people getting rich off our system, 83:00 and instead make sure everybody's got access 83:02 and affordability across the board. 83:06 When I ask you about AI, 83:08 I since it could be the biggest issue 83:11 over the next year. 83:12 Without question. 83:12 It could be the issue in 2028. 83:15 Thanks to the issue, pardon me, right now. 83:17 I was gonna say right now. 83:18 I mean, so you've had a lot of experience with this. 83:20 You know, I know you announced a $20 billion 83:22 data center investment from Amazon last year. 83:25 You've more recently put a lot of restrictions 83:28 on data centers. 83:31 Like what do you think you underestimated 83:33 about what these projects would mean 83:35 for the communities getting them. 83:38 Look, I think there's kind of two 83:41 public policy conversations for now, 83:44 and there's probably gonna be five more 83:46 just over the course of the next six great months. 83:48 That's how quick it's moving. 83:49 The first thing is, 83:50 what does the infrastructure look like in America? 83:53 So in Pennsylvania, I put through an executive order 83:56 the strictest guardrails in the entire nation. 83:59 Number one, it says, if a local community 84:02 through their board of supervisors or whatever, 84:05 votes down a data center, it's dead on arrival. 84:08 They cannot do an end around to the Commonwealth 84:10 in Pennsylvania for our consideration, period. 84:14 If a local community wants it in their area, 84:19 they gotta do a few things before you even get 84:21 to the state. 84:22 You have to have local labor building it. 84:24 You have to have a local benefits agreement 84:26 where the companies are gonna invest millions 84:29 and millions of dollars in that local community. 84:31 And then you get to come to the state 84:33 where we have an even higher bar that you've got to get across. 84:37 You got to generate your own power and a significant amount of it has to be clean energy 84:41 and you have to pay 100% of your power costs so that there's no added cost to local consumers. 84:49 And then we've got very strict requirements on protecting air quality and water quality. 84:54 But the key to my executive order is the local communities are in charge. 84:59 We're not going to let these rogue developers run rough shot over communities. 85:02 we put a stop to that in Pennsylvania. 85:05 I mean, fun fact, since my executive order 85:07 went into effect, not a single data center project 85:11 has made its way to the Commonwealth 85:13 for our consideration, 85:14 because local communities have not embraced it. 85:17 So that's sort of conversation one, the infrastructure. 85:20 And I'd love to see at a national level 85:23 a mirror image of what I've done, 85:26 or mirror images at the opposite, I don't know. 85:28 Yeah. 85:29 The same thing of what we've done in Congress. 85:33 The other conversation is how to help regulate AI. 85:37 And to me, this is very simple. 85:39 They are making a product that could have some benefits for us, 85:43 could also have a lot of challenges. 85:46 I'm not a doomer, but I am a realist. 85:48 And I understand that there are very real challenges 85:52 as a result of this technology being 85:53 built without any oversight. 85:56 We don't let a pharmaceutical company 85:58 make a prescription and tell you it's good for you, go ahead and take it. 86:02 No, it's got to go to the FDA first for their approval, for their review. 86:06 We don't let like an airplane manufacturer build a plane, then you go fly to Detroit on it. 86:10 You've got to go through the FAA for their approval. 86:13 We need a similar federal initiative, a similar federal agency 86:18 to test these models before they go out. 86:21 And the reason we don't have that is because Donald Trump and his kids are getting rich 86:25 off of the fact that there is no regulation. 86:28 This goes back to the corruption 86:29 and why the corruption is so insidious. 86:32 Our lives are being compromised. 86:34 Our communities are being hurt 86:36 because Trump is looking to make a buck off this 86:38 as opposed to actually regulating it. 86:41 We need responsible regulation at the federal level. 86:44 And I believe we can still be China. 86:47 We can still move quickly and responsibly 86:49 with federal oversight. 86:51 So I think both conversations need to happen now and then we also have to have some really 86:57 serious conversations about the social effects of this, about the workforce effects of all this 87:03 and that's something hopefully we can start under this new Congress. 87:09 Do you think on the development of AI do you think we need to 87:14 slow it down, do you think we need to, 87:17 there's been proposals bandied about 87:20 on banning superintelligence, 87:23 this idea that, you know, 87:25 there's recursive self-improvement, 87:26 which is suddenly the AI is building the next AI 87:31 and you hear people at the companies, 87:34 including the people running the companies, 87:36 expressing some concern about that. 87:39 And so I think on one hand there's like regulation, 87:42 let's make sure there's guardrails, 87:43 But it's moving really fast and you do wonder if you at least need, I mean, you know, Dario and Modi called for, you know, 87:51 they called for a pause, right? And the development of superintelligence. Do you think that government needs to step in there? 87:57 Government has to step in there. I mean, it is insane to me that we are leaving it up to these CEOs 88:03 to determine whether or not they should proceed with something, that something's helpful for the world, harmful for the world. 88:09 You know, if you think about it, their job is to build these models. 88:14 Their job in some cases of the public companies is to deliver for their shareholders. 88:18 Their job is not to be the regulators. 88:22 We need regulators. 88:23 We need responsible adults in the room who are making sure this technology is developed in a way that doesn't harm the American people. 88:31 And the reason we don't have that is because Donald Trump continually stands in the way of regulation. 88:37 And I believe the reason he stands in the way of regulation 88:40 is because he's making a buck off this. 88:42 And that puts us all at risk. 88:44 I think this federal oversight needs to happen 88:47 not two years from now 88:49 when hopefully Democrats control the White House 88:51 but over the course of the next several months. 88:54 We cannot rely on the CEOs of these companies 88:57 to do what is in the best interests of America. 89:00 There has to be a regulatory environment 89:03 or regulatory structure to do that. 89:04 And I believe to the first part of your question, 89:07 you can do that and still move swiftly, still beat China, 89:12 still ensure that communist China is not dictating 89:14 the rules of AI, which I don't think anybody wants. 89:17 So we can do all this in a responsible way, 89:19 but it is going to require us 89:21 to build this oversight structure immediately. 89:26 You said in 2020 that the electoral college 89:29 should be abolished. 89:31 You now have a democratic legislature. 89:32 would you push to join the national popular vote compact, 89:38 which for people I don't know would award 89:41 the participating states electoral votes 89:44 to the national vote winner once enough states join. 89:47 And now that after Tuesday, 89:49 there are now enough democratic trifectas 89:53 to actually get to that point. 89:54 Yeah, look, I think the national popular vote makes sense. 89:57 My views on that have not changed. 90:00 I'll work with lawmakers to figure out what the right mechanism is for moving 90:04 forward on that. But look, we're the ultimate swing state in Pennsylvania. 90:09 We're the biggest swing state. We're proud of that role we play. I think 90:13 Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in a national popular vote. 90:18 And to me, the most important thing is that the will of the people is heard 90:22 and respected. And I think popular vote is a way to do that. 90:25 Yes. 90:27 I was going to say, because do you have any concern that it would reduce the role of Pennsylvania 90:33 in this? 90:34 Look, because we still have 13 million incredible people with diverse interests, diverse backgrounds. 90:39 And if you want to win a national election, you sure as hell better show up in Pennsylvania 90:43 and hear the people of our great Commonwealth. 90:46 You helped stop two ICE detention centers in Pennsylvania. 90:56 Two massive ones, by the way. 90:57 They wanted to house 9,000 human beings in Berkson School 91:02 County. I said, hell, no, we fought back. 91:05 We wanted we drove them out of Pennsylvania. 91:06 Yeah. 91:08 What what do you think should happen to ICE under the next Democratic 91:11 president? Reform it, rebuild it, replace it. 91:15 I actually think your question is too limited. 91:18 And I mean that respectfully, I think I was going to get to asylum 91:21 policies next, if you I mean. 91:24 And I think the entire Department of Homeland Security is broken. 91:29 I think it is outdated. 91:34 I think it was built in response to 9-11. 91:37 By the way, built by a friend and a predecessor, Governor Tom Ridge, you know, a patriotic 91:42 American, but it was built to deal with threats from 25 years ago. 91:46 And I think the threats are completely different now. 91:49 And I agree with Michael Cherdoff and Jay Johnson, one who served Obama, one who 91:55 serve Bush, the entire agency needs to be overhauled, ICE included. But I think we need to focus on the 92:02 threats that exist today. I think we need to build an immigration enforcement office or whatever 92:09 underneath that that is compassionate, that is focused on actual proper law enforcement 92:14 tactics. And I was former chief law enforcement officer in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania as 92:19 Attorney General for six years. I know what it takes to have a successful law enforcement agency. 92:26 It's not about the guns. It's not about the machinery or the weaponry. It's actually about 92:32 building trust with the community. And ICE has completely eliminated all trust with communities 92:38 across America, cannot continue to exist as it is. But I would say just focusing on 92:45 on overhauling whatever the word is, ice is too limited. 92:49 We need a complete overhaul of DHS, period. 92:55 You've called for an end to the around war. 92:58 Do you think Democrats should refuse to vote 93:01 for a funding bill that keeps funding the around war? 93:05 Absolutely, period. 93:07 I mean, you know, the senators 93:08 and the members of Congress up here, 93:10 they'll tell you what the mechanism is for which vote 93:12 or what have, they're not gonna get into that. 93:14 But the idea that we would give, Pete Hegseff, who is like an eight-year-old playing with toy 93:21 soldiers, completely incompetent, that we would give him money to continue to prosecute a failed war, 93:29 a war they had no business getting into. You'll remember the president never explained why we 93:34 were going into it. He has no earthly idea how to get out of it. And anyone in a 93:40 Freshman political science class were to tell you first thing they're going to do is shut down this trade of four moves and they had no plan for that. 93:47 I think this is a moment where our party needs to stand firm and use the power of the purse strings to stop them from going forward here. 93:59 And by the way, Magistrate, I think we can all agree. 94:03 No one here has any sympathy for the IRGC. 94:07 No one here wants Iran to have a nuclear weapon, but what is clear is that Donald Trump does not 94:13 have a plan to stop them from developing that nuclear technology, and he doesn't have a plan 94:18 to manage the crisis that he's created in the Middle East. 94:22 Some pretty interesting and rather sudden shifts on Israel from the Trump administration in the 94:28 last week. By the way, we made it 20 minutes before you asked me about Israel. That might 94:33 It might be a record here for me. 94:35 How about that? 94:36 Well, some news. 94:38 Trump announces on election day 94:40 that he's ending annual aid to Israel. 94:44 JD Vance posts a 600 word Twitter essay 94:48 about the election. 94:50 I didn't know that was possible 94:52 that you could put that in any words. 94:53 It's a very annoying shift now. 94:55 Now people think that we all wanna read 94:57 your thousand word tweets. 94:59 We don't. 95:00 JD Vance listed the need to change our relationship 95:03 with Israel is one of the top four reasons Republicans lost the midterms. Do you agree with that? 95:10 On the JD Vance thing? I mean, look, American people spoke very clearly. Stuff costs too much 95:17 and they're too damn corrupt in Washington and JD Vance wears both of that. I mean, I had to laugh 95:22 that Vance now is, he's trying to like brush the stink of Trump off of him with this, 95:29 I guess six hundred word tweet. It doesn't work that way. He made his bed. He's with Trump 95:36 He stuck with Trump and no matter how much he tries to distance himself from Trump and the failed policies and the corrupt 95:42 Actions, it's not going to work people were fed up look 95:47 I I traveled to communities that voted for Trump and Vance 95:52 Overwhelmingly I was in a county in Pennsylvania 95:54 yet. Trump advanced got 80% of the vote against Kamala Harris back in 2024. And you know what 96:01 those folks voted for? These are good and decent people, even though we've got differences of 96:05 opinion on who they voted for for present. They voted for lower costs. They voted for 96:10 an end of the wars. And they voted for, as Trump loves to, you know, say, to drain the swamp. 96:16 And what do they have? Higher costs, more wars, and far more corruption than existed 96:21 before Donald Trump got here and so they sold him a bill of goods and I think 96:25 folks voted in this election in a way that they instinctively understood that 96:31 what Trump and Vance promised them they've not only failed to deliver on 96:35 they've made those issues met worse or they've made matters worse and no matter 96:39 how many tweets Vance puts out he stuck Vance showed himself to be a 96:45 profoundly and pathetically weak human being when he sold his soul to 96:51 Donald Trump. And now he's stuck with the stink of Donald Trump on it. 96:57 I know, I know you said that we should change our military agreement with 97:02 Israel. What would your policy actually be? And where would it differ from what 97:07 Trump announced and what Trump is doing right now? 97:09 Yeah, I think what Trump and, you know, many members of Congress on the 97:14 left and the right have said is we should stop this military aid, the 97:19 subsidize aid. I agree with that. I also believe that America has a national security interest 97:26 for ourselves in having a stable Middle East that extends not just in Israel, but in what 97:33 I hope would be a Palestinian state and throughout the entire Arab world. And I think it is 97:40 important to make sure that nations have the ability to defend themselves against 97:46 to tax from rogue actors, from terrorist actors, but that is different from the military aid 97:51 that we have seen over, you know, over really decades now stretching back to your time service 97:58 in the White House. 97:59 Would you restrict weapons sales at all? 98:01 I think we sell weapons, America does, to lots of countries, and it's done in a way 98:07 where there are very strict requirements on those sales, what it can be used for, 98:12 How it can be used and should those nations violate the terms of the sales 98:17 They would no longer be permitted to purchase those weapons and I think Israel should be treated as other nations are 98:25 Last question very important question about the next administration 98:30 What do we do with the ballroom? 98:34 We first off I got a whole bunch of building trades from Philly 98:38 Who would love to show up with a hammer and a chisel and scrape that gold shit off the way 98:43 Get it off I mean are we keeping it? Are we tearing it down? 98:48 Are we turning it into a cheesecake factory? What I mean is nuts. I did think that was a funny line 98:53 Did you write that line? I I don't take credit for that kind of things 98:58 President writes all look there there is a serious point here 99:01 I mean whether it's the Kennedy Center whether it's the ballroom whether it's that reflecting pond or any of that stuff 99:05 There has to be congressional oversight of what this guy's doing, you know to our national monuments to our historic places 99:13 And so before they even build this thing, 99:15 I know they got sort of a scaffolding up or whatever. 99:19 Congress has to exert its power here 99:21 and it has to make sure that whatever is built there 99:24 is in keeping with, I think, our standards 99:27 and in keeping with something that is appropriate 99:30 for that venue. 99:31 Sounds good. 99:32 And the building trades are gonna go scrape 99:34 that shit off the walls in two years. 99:37 It is awful. 99:37 Governor Josh Buro. 99:38 Thanks everybody. 99:39 Thank you so much for joining Kirk and Com. 99:40 Thank you. 99:41 Appreciate it. 99:44 That's our show for today. Hope you enjoyed it. We'll be back in the feed on 99:47 Tuesday with two more conversations, a panel I led on the Democratic brand, and 99:52 love its interview with Senator Alyssa Slotkin. Then Dan and I will be back on 99:56 Friday with a brand new episode. Talk to everyone soon. 100:13 David Tolles, Mia Kellman, Ryan Young, and Naomi Single. 100:16 Our staff is probably unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.
Community discussion