Show full transcript 0:25 speaking through the camera 0:26 to stop an intruder in their tracks 0:27 and calling for urgent 911 dispatch 0:29 batch when it's needed the most. 0:31 Our CEO, Lucinda, has a simply safe system. 0:33 She said the app is really easy to use. 0:35 It allows her to arm and disarm the system directly 0:37 from her phone, from anywhere. 0:39 If she's ever unsure if she's locked your door, 0:41 she can check on the app and then lock it 0:43 from wherever she is, giving her a peace of mind 0:45 and that her home is always secure. 0:46 She can even monitor the camera 0:48 from the app to check in with her family and friends 0:50 as they arrive at her house. 0:52 We partnered with Simply Safe to offer our listeners 0:54 the biggest savings of the year. 0:56 70% off your new system with professional monitoring. 0:58 When you visit SimplySafe.com slash Crooked, 1:02 that's SimplySafe.com slash Crooked, 1:03 and when you order, type in PodSafe America at checkout. 1:06 It lets them know we sent you, and it really helps the show. 1:09 SimplySafe, ahead of crime in real time. 1:28 and a stylishly modern grand 1:30 Hyatt. With over 45 restaurants, 1:33 bars, and lounges, Baja Mar 1:34 serves up delicious dining from 1:36 world-renowned chefs, like Daniel 1:38 Balloud and Marcus Samuelson. 1:40 Nightlife venues like the new 1:41 Jean-Baptiste Jazz Club and the 1:43 Caribbean's most luxurious casino. 1:46 At Baja Mar, you'll find every 1:47 pleasure under the sun and one of 1:49 the kind experiences for the 1:50 entire family, like Baja Bay, 1:52 our 15-acre lush tropical 1:54 water park, interactive wildlife experiences, including our daily flamingo parade, world class golf, 2:00 tennis, spa, and so much more. Visit Bahamar.com today and discover a vacation destination where 2:07 memories are made for a lifetime. Bahamar, life spectacular. This is Martha Stewart. 2:13 Have you ever started a new tradition? Here's a hint. Do it with Lennox. This year, Lennox 2:20 will make the holiday something truly special. 2:23 How exciting it is every year to unbox all of our favorite decor and smile at the memories. 2:29 The Lenox Spice Village is the perfect holiday gift for someone you love, including yourself. 2:35 Calling back to the originals from 1989, now you can share the memories and the flavors 2:41 of the season. 2:43 It's a charming collection of hand-painted houses. 2:45 Imagine ginger from a Georgian townhouse or pepper from your Swiss chalet. 2:51 Lennox has brought timeless beauty and quality to tables and homes for generations. 2:56 Baking together, sharing recipes, decorating, suddenly simple pleasures become part of your 3:02 holiday story forever. 3:04 With Lennox, collect those moments every year or treat your favorite someone. 3:09 Remember, when you give a gift that lasts beyond the holidays, it's an amazing feeling. 3:16 When you give Lennox, you just might start a new tradition. 3:19 Discover the full collection at Lennox.com slash Spice Village. 3:46 Welcome to Plot Save America. 3:48 I'm John Favreau. 3:48 I'm John Lovett. 3:49 I'm Tommy Vitore. 3:50 Big show today. 3:51 Rachel Maddow stops by the studio to talk to Lovett, and Chris Van Hollen talks 3:55 to Tommy about his challenge to Chuck Schumer. 3:57 Stick around for both of those interviews later in the episode. 4:00 Before that, we'll talk about all the Trump administration's excuses for the country's 4:04 air traffic control system crashing on Friday, which briefly overshadowed the political 4:08 fallout from NVIDIA's sex, spies, and chip scandal, which we'll also talk about now 4:13 that Trump is off to China, great timing, and we'll dig in a bit more to the race 4:17 for Senate Majority Leader and how it's playing out among Democrats. 4:21 But first, we just want to give a shout-out to our friend Stacey Abrams, who hosts 4:25 the fantastic show Assembly Required here at Crooked. 4:28 We mentioned last week that so much of the success we saw happen in Georgia in the election was built on the tireless work of Stacey and other organizers who believed in a blue or south when not many people did. 4:41 She talks about that work and the lessons she learned on assembly required each week with some of the smartest minds on the left. 4:46 So if you haven't, go check out the show on YouTube or wherever you listen to podcasts. 4:51 Alright guys, let's get to the news. A faulty router in Arkansas was apparently enough to 4:56 take down our air traffic control system for several hours. On Friday afternoon, famously 5:01 a quiet time of the week to travel, the FAA had to issue a rare ground stop for the 5:06 entire country. I believe it's the third time in history it's done that. That led 5:12 to thousands of flight cancellations and delays that we are still dealing with 5:16 today. Fortunately, our MMA fighter turned Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen 5:23 was quick to assure everyone that this was, quote, not another 9-11. Thank you. Good quote. 5:28 While our real world road rules contestant turned transportation secretary Sean Duffy 5:33 calmed nerves by warning that it may happen again unless Congress gives him another $50 5:38 billion for upgrades on top of the $12.5 billion they gave him more than a year ago, 5:43 which he hasn't fully spent yet. 5:46 As for Trump, that guy's been around long enough 5:48 to know that you never become the face 5:50 of a customer service disaster. 5:52 So he hid from the cameras until Monday morning 5:55 as he left the White House for China. 5:57 Here's what he had to say about the whole mess. 5:59 What you saw on Friday was very, very old equipment 6:02 that had a heart attack. 6:04 I hate to blame anybody, 6:05 but the Biden administration hooked up 6:06 a lot of copper into glass. 6:09 And copper, if you know anything 6:10 about electrical engineering. You cannot hook up copper in the last minute. 6:16 Judge ruined the system. He totally ruined it. 6:22 I don't think any responsibility. They did a great job. 6:25 Perfect. 6:26 Secretary Duffy, they acted incredibly. Everybody was safe. 6:31 So do we know what he heard that he turned into? 6:35 You can't plug copper into glass. 6:36 Is it the wires into fiber optic? 6:38 Yeah, like T1s into fiber optics. 6:40 Is that what we think it was about? 6:42 The old system was based on copper 6:44 and the new system is based on fiber 6:46 and so they're going around updating 6:48 like one system at a time all over the country. 6:52 They're changing them from copper to fiber. 6:54 Gotta go back to the gold team. 6:55 No idea where the glass came from 6:57 and I don't think, 6:58 I don't think that is necessarily a real explanation 7:02 or one that shows any kind of knowledge of the situation. 7:05 But we do have Sean Duffy taking another swing at an explanation on the Sunday shows. 7:11 Let's listen. 7:12 One of the problems I have is I need more money to build a new telecom network. 7:17 I need new software. 7:18 But we're doing the right thing by way of the American people by fixing this really, 7:24 really old system that was left to us. 7:26 But respectfully, the American people have put a lot of money into infrastructure upgrades. 7:32 If the White House has allowed for reprogramming of funds, 7:36 why do you keep saying Congress is stopping you 7:38 from spending the money they're giving you? 7:40 So, first off, there was a lot of money 7:43 that was given to the F.A. in the past, 7:44 and I can't answer for other secretaries 7:46 or other F.A. administrators. 7:48 A lot of money was given, not a lot of work was done. 7:51 Do you feel you also owe an apology 7:52 to the American people this happened on your watch? 7:56 Well, listen, it happened on my watch, 7:58 but we have to be clear. 8:00 I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or the DOT in decades, 8:06 but I can't apologize for what was what was passed off to us. 8:10 The FBI now has the router CNN is reporting so I don't know what they're looking into. 8:15 But I think it was a mistake to let Arkansas have internet. 8:17 That's probably where we went wrong. 8:18 Yeah. 8:18 Well, clearly it's it's not great internet. 8:21 What do you guys make of the administration's explanation? 8:23 nation, the response so far. 8:27 And are you excited for your next flights? 8:29 Trump was president before, right? 8:31 For like four years? 8:32 That's right. 8:33 And then we're like two years into this one? 8:34 Mm-hmm, yep. 8:35 But no responsibility for anything that happened 8:36 in that time frame. 8:37 No, in fact, there's a clip going around 8:39 of Sean Duffy at the cabinet meeting in July of 2025 8:42 saying, thanks to, right when the Trump's 8:45 big beautiful bill passed, he said, 8:47 thanks to this $12.5 billion for upgrades 8:51 to aviation in the bill within a year and a half, 8:56 two years, this whole system will be brand new 8:59 and we'll have built out an entire new system. 9:01 That's great, that's exciting. 9:02 So when you said I can't speak to past secretaries 9:05 and past administrators, we're just asking him 9:07 to speak to the money you got a year and a half ago. 9:10 Yeah, there's so many dogs that aren't barking. 9:12 Like let's say this all happened, right? 9:14 And Sean Duffy got up there 9:16 and he said something like we've been working 9:19 really hard and moving very quickly to update a creaking system that actually 9:24 had needed refurbishment for decades. It was neglected by both parties for a 9:30 long time, Democrats and Republicans. We are balancing moving quickly because the 9:35 system needs to be changed with the challenges that come with this kind of 9:39 an upgrade. And it turns out that in this case there was a mistake, there was 9:44 an error, and as much as we are trying diligently to do this as 9:47 Responsibly as possible when things go wrong, that's on us, and I just want to apologize to everyone whose trips were disrupted 9:53 Just know we are moving as swiftly as we can to have the best system going forward and this administration takes that responsibility seriously 10:02 What happens if they say something like that? Do people like does like why is it like it's weakness? 10:07 It's weakness right as you can't say anything 10:09 So then you have Mark Wayne Mullen who gets to go up there knowing he can't really be blamed saying well 10:13 There was an upgrade to some systems and those systems failed 10:16 And then you have to have Sean Duffy come up to the podium say well actually it was the old copper wires 10:19 It was the old couple. It wasn't the new stuff. It was the old stuff. It was the Buddha judge shit 10:23 It was that gay Buddha judge shit that he left behind not me not me right and then Donald Trump right because he can't take any kind 10:30 Of responsibility and doesn't have a conception of leadership that acknowledges that human beings make mistakes and that he can 10:36 Be a good leader while understanding things go wrong 10:40 There's it's all so brittle and so fragile 10:43 So they'll have to get up there and spin and lie and then in an emergency you can't trust anything they fucking say 10:48 Well, that seems to be the the larger issue here is that like even if their explanations seem credible 10:55 You can't trust them on anything and like to your point. Love it 10:58 I mean, you know with the answer you just gave you trying out to be the new transportation secretary. I see 11:05 The the questions they still haven't answered her like okay, so you're upgrading the system 11:09 system, why are you upgrading the system even in Arkansas where there's an in some remote 11:14 corner of Arkansas where there's not a lot of air traffic on a Friday afternoon and like, 11:19 what is the problem with the system where there's a risk every time you upgrade a different 11:23 part of the system that the old system is going to go haywire and cause a fucking national 11:28 ground stop? 11:28 Like what? 11:29 Yeah, that seems like a real problem. 11:30 Those questions should be answered. 11:32 And Duffy says, right, he said he can't or won't guarantee this won't happen 11:35 again, but also he needs all this money. 11:37 Well, okay, so that means we're just at risk in perpetuity going forward and and John Thune said that they've only spent 11:42 4 billion of the 12 and a half billion that Congress passed so 8 billion is just quote sitting around 11:47 I'm not gonna pretend to understand like these systems will have to know how much money they need 11:51 But Sean Duffy, I believe you were a member of Congress Mark Wayne Mullen 11:55 You were a senator like two weeks ago 11:56 I feel I bet you have some contacts in your phone for people you could call if you really need this money 12:01 appropriated. Also imagine if Donald Trump cared about rebuilding like critical infrastructure 12:06 as much as he cares about building a ballroom for himself or monuments to himself. 12:10 Well, I mean, John Thune was the, he's not only the Republican leader in the Senate, 12:15 he chaired the committee that oversees aviation. So when he said like, yeah, 12:21 we passed the 12.5 billion, only 4 billion has been spent, and then 8 billion sitting around, 12:26 like that's not some lib criticizing Trump, it's John Thune. 12:30 Well, also, even before you get to whether they need more money or not, one of the problems, 12:36 at least some internal reports have found is there's a risk that they are moving too 12:40 quickly, right? 12:41 Like, even if they do need more money, like, you're, you're potentially trying to get 12:45 this done. 12:46 In part, you know, he's been bragging about how quickly he's been able to move to 12:48 get these things done. 12:49 And there's a risk, right? 12:51 Like, what should be coming next is, like, the system is fucked up and old. 12:56 It's been true for a while. 12:57 Like this is, we've had this, the last, what, the last, uh, stop, uh, ground stop was, uh, 13:03 uh, three or four years, three years ago, 2023 or 2025, 2023. 13:07 Uh, and again, it is because the system is old and it doesn't have a lot of redundancies 13:10 when you're upgrading a very complicated, very important system that doesn't have a 13:13 lot of redundancies. 13:14 Like there are going to be challenges. 13:15 What are the lessons from this? 13:17 What are the ways you can prevent this from happening again? 13:19 Right. 13:19 Like who's talking to the contractor that was responsible, that's been responsible 13:22 for this system for a long time. 13:24 Right. 13:24 Like was it Alice Wong? 13:25 Right. 13:26 Was it Alice Wong and the pool guy who did the fountain thing? Oh, yeah, was it the you had the Olympian? 13:31 No, I probably cut it all out of the canoe or was it someone related to Bill Clinton, Arkansas? 13:37 Look, I gladly pay 50 billion to not die in the plane crash 13:41 I would just like to know that they really need it for sure 13:44 Was what do we know about why this led to the ground stop was that? 13:49 Was that a precaution that was necessary? Was it something that they were they overreacting in part? 13:55 I'm not suggesting this, but like, was it an overreaction in part because of fears about AI and other kinds of systems and cyberattacks, right? 14:01 Like, there's just, there's a lot that we should be needing to learn now, 14:04 but it's impossible to trust what they say because it's so much more about their egos, their fears of Trump, 14:08 their concern of being blamed rather than actually getting to the bottom of it. 14:11 And look, the AI stuff has now come up a couple times, and I do not think this is, 14:17 people are conspiracy-mongering by at least asking these questions because if it was just the FAA thing, it'd be one issue. 14:23 We've had, last week, Microsoft Outlook went down. 14:27 There was an outage nationwide, everywhere, 14:30 that they couldn't figure out. 14:31 They said, well, it's like a technology bug or something. 14:34 Then this, doesn't have to do with AI, 14:36 not cyber attack that we know of yet, right? 14:38 The airline thing. 14:40 JP Morgan Chase today has a software bug 14:43 that then like spread to customers in their bank 14:45 and other banks as well. 14:47 People couldn't get out their deposits for a while. 14:48 They said, it's a software bug. 14:50 And then like United Airlines, right? 14:52 as we started recording was reporting another system-wide outage today and it's like whether 14:56 this whether these are all just a coincidence or not like say let's say it is just a coincidence like 15:01 the whole concern with AI and the rapid development of AI is that this shit's gonna be much easier 15:07 for individual actors to do to take down like entire systems like this which is just you know 15:13 and we're dealing with administration that just has no interest in regulating it whatsoever 15:18 However, it seems bad. 15:19 So Trump is in Asia this week with the stop in the Philippines 15:22 and then China, where he'll be meeting with his good pals 15:25 Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin about nuclear weapons. 15:28 Unclear if Trump will talk to Xi about whether mega-speed 15:31 executive Alice Wong was in fact working as a spy 15:34 for the Chinese Communist Party when she began an affair 15:36 with Nvidia CEO Jensen Wong, Trump's friend and donor 15:39 who resigned over a scandal that has rattled 15:41 the AI industry, the stock market, 15:44 and national security officials. 15:45 On Monday, Howard Lutnick's Commerce Department finally closed a loophole that allowed China to gain access to AI chips without sending a spy to sleep with any U.S. chip makers. 15:55 And it appears that there's a top-down effort to reinstate Wong, led by David Sacks and Elon Musk. 16:02 But it looks like it's not going to happen, at least according to sources on Nvidia's board. 16:08 But that's not stopping Trump from weighing in with his own take. 16:22 I don't know that she is a spy. Usually what happens with that is that any woman coming 16:29 to the country that's a beautiful woman that comes from China, they say she's a spy. I 16:34 don't know that she was a spy at all. I mean, I really don't. 16:38 So I looked at his couple lessons, one more important than the other. He's talking 16:42 about his wife. What do you guys make of the rush to save Wong by people like Elon and 16:48 Saks and the All-In pod who've been trying to argue that this was Saks arguing that the 16:53 spy narrative is already falling apart? 16:56 But the thing that's really interesting about David Saks is he tweets like, show 17:00 Biden is still president and he's not the A.I. czar or former A.I. czar for the 17:04 Trump administration. I mean like I don't know if Alice Wong was like a ministry 17:07 of state security staffer or what the intelligence says, but like David Saks's question 17:12 should be to Marco Rubio, so why did you brief Donald Trump on this intelligence if it is wrong? 17:17 And I also think that, like, focusing on this question of whether she was a quote-unquote spy 17:20 kind of misses the point, because clearly, Megaspeed, her company, was built to circumvent US export 17:27 controls, and that is what is happening here. Like, the New York Times sent reporters to 17:29 Megaspeed's office, there were like two people there, they said their bosses were all in 17:33 China, their clients were all in China, and the NVIDIA gear was in boxes, because it was 17:36 going to get smuggled to somewhere else, like this, so that is what's happening here. And I think 17:40 what Elon and David Sacks and the Jensen Wong fanboy should be worried about is whether 17:46 Wong was facilitating like a witting accomplice to that kind of smuggling activity. 17:51 That's real legal trouble for him. 17:53 And then second, let's say that she was just like a fixer. 17:56 That's the other thing that's been floated for like companies trying to do illicit 17:59 activities in China. 18:01 Let's talk about who this person was. 18:02 She worked for Chinese state media, then she moved to Singapore and she changed 18:06 her name. 18:07 She decides to pivot late in life to become an AI company CEO soon after she's one of the largest buyers of NVIDIA chips in all of Asia 18:15 She has relationships with Huawei this big Chinese telecom 18:19 Company that state backed that is like every blinking red light possible if you're an Intel analyst 18:24 And then she just happens to start dating the most important person in the entire field of AI and Chinese entities used her 18:30 To get all this access to chips like the bad thing happened whether or not she's like a spy 18:34 And so like if Jensen Wong is the CEO of Lockheed Martin or Boeing, he's supposed to report 18:39 contacts like this if you have a national security clearance. 18:43 Failure to do so means you could lose your clearance, you lose your job, maybe even get 18:46 prosecuted if you lie about it. 18:48 But like AI lives in this weird space, like it's a commercial product, but it's also 18:51 a national security priority, there's not the same rules. 18:54 And so like the real question I have is like, why wasn't Jensen Wong given a defensive 18:57 briefing about all of this intelligence if it existed? 18:59 Yeah, the other it's like there's like the NVIDIA piece of this and 19:03 Another group of people that seem should have taken some interest in where these ships going are the NVIDIA board and 19:08 The people that the the compliance officials that work in NVIDIA is a big company said they kind of hit it right 19:15 Because they wanted to sell the chips right well and and whether they thought they were 19:19 participating something that violated the spirit of the law or 19:22 What was obviously violating the letter of the law regardless? It doesn't really matter 19:28 whether or not Alice Huang was a spy, in part because this was Jensen Huang's ideology 19:34 before he met this person. He has a philosophical, he has a belief that he wants the U.S. in 19:39 part because it's maybe his sincere conviction also with benefits as company, that he believes 19:44 that we should dominate the manufacturer of these chips, that that's how we win this 19:47 and that includes being the supplier because it reduces the pressure for other companies 19:53 to develop their own competing chips. Fine, that's his philosophical view. 19:56 The problem here is not that there is a powerful CEO who has this view. 20:01 It is that he had such a close relationship with the president of the United States and the administration that it is not clear 20:07 whether U.S. 20:09 Interest or Nvidia's interest or the personal views of the CEO of that company were winning the day, right? 20:14 Because Donald Trump was clearly 20:16 very 20:17 highly influenced by Jensen Wong. Obviously, I don't think we would say Donald Trump is the most sophisticated 20:22 tech 20:23 a person, right? I don't think he knows a lot about how these chips work. He's relying 20:28 on these people. 20:29 They don't use copper. 20:29 He's finding out that Jensen Wong may be having this relationship. He's insisting that 20:34 Jensen Wong board the plane in Alaska because he's such a good friend. So this guy has 20:38 Trump's ear. It's incredibly influential. And the end result may have been that our 20:41 national security was put at risk, and now they're trying to put the horse back 20:45 in the barn, but the chips have already been sold. So to me, that's the issue, 20:48 right? Regardless of whether this person was a spy, Donald Trump was ensorcelled 20:52 by Jensen Huang. 20:54 Yeah, I mean, this guy, 20:55 whether it's for pure financial reasons, 20:58 or because he just, 21:00 and you know, when you listen to his series of interviews, 21:03 he did a couple of months ago, 21:04 he was on Azure Show and others. 21:06 He just like doesn't think that AI poses a great risk, 21:09 doesn't seem to care, 21:11 wants to build out the infrastructure all over the world. 21:13 He wants to be part of that. 21:14 It wants his company to be part of that. 21:16 And so he wants to sell the chips. 21:17 And so he gets to, 21:19 because this is the way that our government works now, 21:21 because he gets the president's ear. 21:23 He gets to be on the side of the people 21:24 who want the chips to be sold 21:26 and Howard Lutnick and the rest of them. 21:27 And Marco Rubio says, 21:28 maybe that's not such a good idea 21:30 because we shouldn't give China a control 21:32 over this technology. 21:33 But it's like, is Marco Rubio right or wrong? 21:36 I don't know, because the other side of the argument 21:37 is just people who want to make a lot of money 21:39 who have the president's ears. 21:40 And like Jason Calicanus or the All in Pod 21:43 just tweeted right before he recorded, 21:45 China hawks are going to get a chip ban 21:47 and Americans are going to get a recession. 21:49 So this is, I mean, like they, their, their whole argument now, their argument used to 21:53 be like, we got to, we got to keep going and not have regulations because we got to win 21:57 the war against China. 21:58 Now that that's done because of Jensen, now they're just like, well, China, it doesn't 22:02 matter about what China, like we got to, we can't, we can't just pop this bubble 22:05 because we got to keep the good times going. 22:08 But also their entire argument is we have to, to beat China by giving them our best 22:12 chips. 22:12 I mean, the AI, the AI maximalist argument has never made any sense. 22:16 It's like, we need to sell China or chips 22:17 so we get them hooked on our stuff 22:19 so then we can beat them. 22:20 Like it never made sense. 22:21 It never made sense. 22:21 There's not even a business case 22:22 because companies like Evidia 22:25 cannot make enough chips to sell. 22:27 That is the problem. 22:28 Like every single chip that has ever been made 22:29 is being purchased. 22:30 I think the big picture thing that's so weird to me is 22:33 when we got to the end of the 2024 race, 22:35 it felt like the only consensus opinion 22:37 in Washington was China Hawk. 22:39 Both sides seem to try to outdo each other 22:41 on China hawkishness. 22:43 And Trump has systematically, 22:45 Like, if you look at the AI chip case, Trump has systematically loosened or gotten rid 22:51 of export controls on chips in ways that benefit China. 22:55 Like, there were Biden era rules that would have prevented the export of these chips to 22:59 mega speed in Singapore. 23:01 They just didn't enforce those. 23:03 He allowed the export of the H20 and the H200 to turn increasingly powerful Nvidia 23:07 chips to the Chinese. 23:09 And the question is always just why? 23:11 Is he just getting bought off? 23:13 Does he not really care? 23:14 Did he never care? Was he never a China hawk? I think it's probably a combination of both, 23:18 but it's worth getting to the bottom of. We should be clear that Jensen Wang was an intel 23:22 goldmine for Alice Wang and the Chinese. He could tell you what Trump is thinking, 23:25 what the Trump administration officials were thinking. He could tell you where the global 23:29 compute of Nvidia chips was distributed, which is unbelievably valuable information. 23:33 He could tell you who is going to get future access to chips. He knew everything. He's 23:37 more valuable than Trump. Yeah. I mean, what is clear from all this is the Trump 23:41 administration, all of the rhetoric about, with the exception of Rubio, I guess, all 23:45 of the rhetoric about we're in a race against China for this. 23:48 It doesn't really mean anything. 23:50 What they really want, what Trump wants, is he doesn't want the AI bubble to pop and 23:55 the stock market to go down and the economy to crash. 23:58 And now all of the, you know, the Jason Calacanicuses and the fucking, and David 24:01 Saxon, all them, they're going to use, well, Americans, you want AI regulated? 24:05 Because if you want that, you're going to get a recession. 24:08 You want to protect our national security from potential, you know, Chinese, you know, winning the race, then you're going to get a recession. 24:15 So now they're going to scare everyone with a recession in order to make sure that AI is not regulated. 24:19 Yeah, there's also, there's the way in which this is about who wins the race in the future. 24:24 And maybe some merit to the Jensen Wong argument that over time we're building the expertise in how to make the chips of the future and other countries are relying on. 24:32 Like I can, there's a way in which that argument makes sense. 24:35 But we're past the point now where this technology has terrifying power in the future. 24:41 Like these models are getting more powerful and more efficient. 24:45 You can do a lot on the chips China has already been given. 24:48 It's not just about at this point. 24:50 It's no longer just about like who wins this abstract idea of the race, right? 24:54 Like what is, what can the Chinese government do with these chips right now? 25:00 What can it do with these models, right? 25:02 Like what are the potential for cyber attack already, right? 25:04 We're part of what we're dealing with is that when you find out that outlook is down or you find out that I know 25:10 You're immediately like well is this it? Is this one of the first of many? 25:13 I go has the has the is this are we gonna look back on this week as the time the site the great cyber wars began 25:18 And we don't know right like who fucking knows but like a lot of this is is this 25:23 Conversation about like who's gonna win when like I think sometimes people don't truly understand that right now 25:28 You can on your own use these models in ways that are incredibly incredibly dangerous 25:34 already. It's not in the future. It's just a matter of when it like now this episode is 25:46 brought to you by made in. I am a huge fan of made in. I was a fan of made in long before 25:52 they were a sponsor of this podcast. I have these great serving plates and a serving bowl 25:57 that this great stripe on them that I thought just look really cool and simple that I use 26:01 constantly. I have a made in knife that I've been using forever. I now have a couple of 26:06 made in pans that are fantastic. 26:08 And I'm a maniac about research when it comes to things 26:11 I get for the kitchen because if I'm gonna get something, 26:14 I wanna get to the end of the internet to find the best one. 26:17 And Made In really is one of my favorite brands. 26:20 That's why I picked it and I haven't been disappointed. 26:23 Made In has a long standing relationship 26:24 with professional chefs. 26:26 They make exactly what demanding chefs are looking for 26:28 including a wide selection of curated products 26:30 from carbon steel to stainless clad 26:32 plus plate wear, glassware and more. 26:34 I go for the stainless. 26:35 I'm a huge fan of stainless 26:36 on this because I don't want, 26:37 part of the reason I went with Made-In is like, 26:38 I don't like the non-stick stuff. 26:42 I don't like any of that. 26:42 I just have all stainless stuff 26:44 because it's just the easiest 26:45 and you just have to, once you learn how to use it, 26:47 it really is the best. 26:49 And perhaps the biggest pro is that Made-In 26:50 is sold online and delivered to your door. 26:53 If you wanna take your cooking to the next level, 26:54 invest in Made-In Cookware. 26:56 Once you try it, you'll be pro Made-In too. 26:59 For full details, visit Made-InCookware.com. 27:02 That's M-A-D-E-I-N Cookware.com. 27:06 Positive America is brought to you by Sundays. 27:08 Sundays for dogs is a different kind of pet food company. 27:11 Why? 27:12 Because it's vet led and vet operated. 27:14 Dr. Tori Waxman is a practicing veterinarian 27:17 and a dog parent. 27:18 She holds every recipe to her own standard. 27:20 Yes, real human grade food. 27:22 She feels good about feeding her own dog. 27:24 She formulates the food and she runs the company. 27:27 That's the whole story. 27:28 The person behind the food is a vet 27:29 and it's what she feeds her own dog. 27:32 Packed with 80% all natural meat 27:33 and nutrient-rich kale, ginger, and blueberries, sundaes is gently air-dried, never cooked 27:38 with high heat, no fillers, no synthetic additives, or chemicals, just simple, complete nutrition. 27:44 It doesn't look or smell like dog food. 27:45 It looks like high-quality jerky, and the best part? 27:48 It's effortless. 27:49 No fridge, no freezer, no prep, no mess. 27:51 Just scoop and serve. 27:52 You get the quality of a home-cooked meal with the ease of kibble. 27:55 Over 100,000 dogs are now eating sundaes, and many dog parents notice the same things. 28:00 Shine your coats, better digestion, more energy, 28:02 and finally getting excited at mealtime, 28:04 even the pickiest eaters. 28:06 I can confirm the dogs get very excited 28:08 when they are offered Sundays, 28:10 because whenever we try to feed a dog Sundays 28:12 here at the office, every single pet, 28:15 every single fluffy good boy or girl in the office 28:18 sprints to try to eat some 28:19 because it's delicious and they love it. 28:21 And also it's just really easy. 28:23 There's no fridge, there's no freezer, 28:24 there's no prep, it's just one mealtime moment 28:26 where you give your dog the food 28:27 and they're genuinely pumped to eat it. 28:30 It's the Sunday's Black Friday sale. 28:32 They're biggest sale of the year. 28:33 Dog people, this one is for you. 28:34 If you've been meaning to try Sundays, 28:36 now's your chance. 28:37 50% off, no more excuses. 28:40 Make the switch at Sundays. 28:41 Go right now to sundaysfordogs.com slash crooked 28:44 and get 50% off your first order. 28:47 Or you can use the code crooked at checkout. 28:49 That's 50% off your first order 28:51 at sundaysfordogs.com slash crooked. 28:55 Sunday's ForDogs.com slash Cricut or use code Cricut to check out. 29:02 So Howard Lutnick is like the Trump senior official, probably most in favor of selling 29:06 the chips to China. Scott Besant made sure we knew that when he said that commerce was 29:10 the only agency that didn't want to put mega speed on the trade blacklist, threw him 29:14 right under the bus on CNBC last week. Surely Lutnick's position has nothing at 29:19 all to do with the New York Times report that some of the companies operating data 29:22 centers on behalf of Chinese firms are, in fact, clients of Lutnik's own former company, 29:27 Canterford-Gerald, which is now run by his sons. Trump, who famously frowns on such arrangements, 29:32 addressed the feud between Lutnik and Treasury Secretary Scott Besen, 29:36 as well as the swirling rumors that Lutnik's time in the administration was up. Take a look. 29:41 One wants to be friendly with China, and one wants to have a blow up with China. 29:48 I mean, honestly, they have two different views. 29:54 If you couldn't hear that, that's Trump saying no to replacing Lutnick, who's traveling with 29:59 Trump to China as we speak, as his besant. Do you think Lutnick's safe from getting fired and or 30:05 punched in the face by the Treasury Secretary of Border Force One? Did you see that in the 30:10 release explaining how they're now going to do stronger export controls, that Commerce made 30:16 a point of saying that it was at the behest of the National Security Council and the 30:19 Treasury Department. Really strange, right? A strange thing to do when you're trying to 30:25 prove that you're not the one that's responsible for why these controls weren't already in place. 30:30 Commerce has been asleep at the switch for like 18 months. These rules they put out today are 30:34 actually pretty good, but it's been like, why have they not done this for a very long time? 30:39 The challenge of chips getting sent to places like Singapore and then the Chinese 30:44 leasing access to them has been well known like an end run around our export controls 30:49 for a very long time. So like, why didn't they do anything? And like what, like what 30:52 Lutnik's done should be investigated deeply maybe by DOJ. I mean, like the financial conflict 31:00 of interest here is crazy. These kids are, Cantor is the brokerage to help finance these 31:05 billion dollar deals and they take like a one or two percent commission off the sale. 31:09 That's crazy. They're like, they're making so much money off these data centers. 31:13 Commerce gets information that mega speed is potentially run by a Chinese spy. They 31:19 They didn't block their access to chips after that. 31:21 They did nothing. 31:22 The New York Times reported that the undersecretary at the Commerce Department talked with NVIDIA 31:26 about their investigation into Megaspeed. 31:29 So think about that. 31:30 They're investigating a company for breaking US laws. 31:32 They call their largest, closest corporate partner and enabler to discuss that investigation. 31:39 What is happening over there? 31:41 The reporting is like they have a meeting in the Oval Office. 31:43 as Trump is like cracked down on these, you know, 31:46 these people going around our export controls 31:48 and then Lutnik just refuses to implement it. 31:51 Which is not, that's where it's like, 31:52 I just don't fucking buy it. 31:54 This is where it like all comes back to Trump. 31:55 The idea that like Trump is demanding something 31:59 and then it doesn't happen at the commerce department 32:01 because Lutnik won't do it. 32:03 Like this is where all of these guys, 32:05 like Besson going after Lutnik, 32:06 Lutnik going after Besson or whatever. 32:09 Sean Duffy going after, you know, 32:10 going back and forth with Mark Wayne Mullen. 32:11 it is all because these people cannot, cannot push blame up, right? Donald Trump is responsible, 32:19 so they have to be these sort of warring viziers beneath, kind of blaming each other, 32:23 the way they're all failing Trump and that Trump cannot fail. But in the end result, 32:27 like why is this happening? Well, either because Donald Trump is corrupt himself, right? Or he 32:33 is too weak and disengaged from these issues and focused on the ballroom and the fucking 32:38 golf courses to really lock in and everybody below him knows that he is either too feeble 32:43 or too distracted or too dumb, too ignorant to actually participate in this debate. So 32:49 they just have them without him. Yeah, that sounds about right. 32:52 And Trump owns $62 million in video stock. That was probably him 32:56 just kind of owning what the S&P 500 index represented, like the percentage of the 33:01 S&P that is in video. But still, it's a lot of money. He's making a lot of money off 33:06 As he said on 60 minutes to rust out that you should have put your money in the stock market. That's true 33:10 That's that's that's our problem. We all need trillions. One other thing too 33:13 I do think one of the reasons that people like must want Jensen Huang back 33:16 I think they genuinely believe he's a they believe in the kind of like magical man 33:20 And they think he's a magical man, but also they don't like the idea that he has accountability for this 33:24 Oh, no, right. Like like it's that it's you know, if he told this this person's secrets fine 33:30 But like, you know, their view would be that the board should be like supplying him with 33:35 if he's able to get the fucking numbers up, right? 33:38 Like the guy from one trillion to four trillion, 33:41 like how many fucking hookers does he need? 33:43 That's their mentality. 33:44 Yeah, that's the same Altman comes back to the board. 33:47 Jensen Wong comes back. 33:48 They want him back. 33:49 Like these guys can do no wrong. 33:51 They're great men. 33:52 That's that. 33:53 I did buy the dip and I would like Jensen Wong 33:54 to be released too. 33:57 And I think Trump, I think there's where, 33:59 I think Trump having 62 million or 82 million in the stock 34:02 is partly why he wants Jensen Wong back too. 34:04 Yeah, sure, for sure. 34:05 Last thing before we leave this topic, 34:08 Tommy Trump mentioned both the possibility 34:10 of seeing his old buddy Kim Jong-un on the trip 34:13 and of discussing denuclearization with Putin and Xi. 34:19 What are you expecting from this trip to China 34:21 and this trial at? 34:23 Nothing. 34:24 Was this like a surprise? 34:25 I didn't know this was coming. 34:27 The Apex, it's Ozzy on an Apex, it's like summits. 34:30 It's, it's, um, I like, this is probably going to be like she's 34:34 tripped to the US where there's lots of events and pomp and 34:37 circumstance and they get nothing done. 34:38 Like he'll probably, like he'll sign like a trade deal with 34:40 Thailand or Vietnam or write something that's kind of like a 34:43 fig leaf or a deal. 34:44 Yeah. 34:45 An agreement to have a trade deal. 34:46 Well, they're pretending they're going to talk about this 34:47 big chip agreement. 34:48 But he also said he won't bring up this. 34:50 He's not going to bring up. 34:52 So the Chinese like just on the nonproliferation stuff, 34:55 they, the Chinese have been very clear. 34:56 They have no interest in talking about nonproliferation 34:58 or nuclear weapons until they're at parity with the U.S. and Russia, so I just don't know that 35:02 they're going to move off of that one. And then the idea that Trump would go see Kim Jong-un 35:06 right after the North Koreans stole $6.5 billion from Binance seems like suspect timing. 35:13 There's also like a logistical question like, is this going to happen in Manila? 35:16 Are they going to, is he going to go to Shenzhen because that's a long train ride 35:19 because dear leader like, I think doesn't have a plane at this point. He rides on this 35:21 little fancy train. That's a very long ride. If Trump's not going to go to Pyongyang, 35:26 he's probably not going to drop this on the South Korean select whatever the logistics side like 35:30 what's the fucking point just to get on TV just to meet with all your all your favorite guys it's 35:37 also you have all these experts in AI basically sort of screaming from the rooftops like just 35:43 trying to do anything they can to get people to pay attention to how we are careening towards 35:48 an abyss it is it is unconstrained nothing is slowing down it is not being taken seriously 35:54 And while that is going on the idea that we're going to have this summit and they did talk about it at their last meeting 35:59 But the idea that like this isn't the biggest and most important thing 36:03 We ought to be talking about in part beat like this Jensen Wong story to tell the reason it has to be like top of the agenda 36:09 Is is outrageous? I mean lost in all this last week because the the Jensen Wong Alice Wong stuff was so salacious 36:15 Is this organization meter put out a report that found anthropic is improving its model capabilities by roughly 36:21 1.9 times. It's historical baseline rates. So they're just accelerating and accelerating 36:27 and accelerating. And all the AI experts are like, Hey, this is officially careening out 36:32 of control. We cannot keep this safe. We don't know what's happening here. And nothing. 36:37 Yeah. And many of them are saying like, the best case scenario is the next 18 months, 36:42 two years, which is going to, there could be like daily disruptions, kind of like 36:46 what we saw the last, the last two weeks. 36:48 And I really like I do to I do think they have internalized this idea that even even like you know 36:55 Anthropic exists in part because they were trying to build a company that cared about safety, right and yet they are 37:01 Moving as fast as anyone else in part because I do think they've just all come to believe that until this first crisis 37:09 That really is that they have to get to that crisis and then that crisis will cause the possibility of some kind of like 37:15 like focusing agenda, maybe. 37:17 Yeah, and the speed up isn't like all the previous acceleration 37:19 was because of more access to chips and raw compute. 37:22 This is all like better software, coding, R and D, 37:25 paying off, so. 37:27 And increasing involvement of the models themselves 37:29 in the testing, right? 37:30 Like we are getting more and more recursive. 37:33 But their argument is not just like, 37:36 we got to get to this first crisis 37:37 and then we'll deal with it. 37:38 Their argument is we got to speed up development 37:40 because the only way to stop a bad guy with AI 37:43 is a good guy with AI. 37:44 Like that they really that's this is yes their best hope now is building and developing AI that can be defensive against offensive AI 37:53 That might cause us some problems and also they go mumble mumble mumble beat China 37:56 Right of being China. Why why do we need to beat China? I don't even know 38:00 Well one one reason would be because if one model gets too far ahead 38:04 You end up in a scenario where there's just one model that has succeeded and surpassed all the rest where a 38:10 situation where we have competing models that have 38:14 value and that can hold their own against each other is one in which maybe 38:16 there is a better hope of some kind of safety, right? Like that is, I think, a 38:19 legitimate, a legitimate belief. Like I am, I am more worried about a world in 38:24 which one of these companies just obliterates the rest than I am about a 38:28 world in which you have Gemini, you have Claude, you have chat, GPT, you have 38:32 these different models competing with one another, like as, I think, provides 38:35 some kind of a backstop, but who fucking knows. On Capitol Hill, the big 38:39 story right now among Democrats is the race for incoming Senate majority 38:42 leader. Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for the position based on the argument 38:47 that midterm voters demanded change. So in a bunch of TV appearances this weekend, Van Hollen drew 38:52 a contrast with Schumer on Iran, suggesting that he'd be in favor of shutting down the government 38:57 next month over defunding the war and Schumer wouldn't. Tommy spoke to Van Hollen just a 39:01 little while ago. You'll hear the full interview at the end of this episode, but we did just 39:06 want to play his answer on the filibuster. Isn't pretty much everything Democrats want 39:10 to do in the next two years downstream of getting rid of the filibuster? Because otherwise, 39:15 Republicans just kind of block everything? So, Tommy, I do think we need to use all our power 39:22 to answer the call of the American people. I think for starters, we would begin with legislation, 39:28 say, for example, on the political corruption front. I think there's consensus that we move 39:35 forward on something like banning stock trades by members of Congress or the administration. 39:40 And let's see if we can get four Senate Republicans to join with us in that action. 39:47 At some point, we're not going to get Republicans to join with us on some of these changes we 39:52 need to root out political corruption and change the economic system. 39:55 So I do believe we need to socialize the conversation in the caucus from day one regarding 40:03 the need to end the supermajority, to end a filibuster. 40:07 because as you know and I know, that is an anti-democratic provision. It prohibits 40:13 the Senate from doing the will of the American people. We've never really had a 40:17 caucus discussion on this. What? How is that possible? This has been like a top 40:23 issue from progressives for years and years. The caucus is never convened to 40:26 talk about getting rid of the filibuster? We've never had a conversation in the 40:30 full caucus about the filibusters. Certainly not in a very, very, 40:35 very long time. 40:36 All right. 40:37 So what did you guys think? 40:39 Tommy, what did you think of the interview? 40:40 I mean, I really like Senator Van Hollen. 40:42 I think he's done a lot of interesting, thoughtful things on foreign policy. 40:46 So, you know, I'm a fan of his. 40:49 I think when you listen to the conversation, you'll get a sense of why it's like very 40:53 hard to campaign for this job because you're not running to be the president where 40:57 you get to implement your agenda. 40:58 You're running to be the person that kind of reflects the consensus of the 41:03 caucus, kind of take slings and arrows in the media on behalf of your members raises 41:10 a lot of money, kind of sets the legislative priorities, but ultimately like your personal 41:14 views are less important than what the majority of your colleagues want, otherwise they 41:19 can just bounce you at any time. 41:20 So I think I try to press him for specificity, but it's hard to get there because he's, 41:27 you know, this isn't like an election where people are the people listening to the 41:30 show or voting it's an inside game where the members of the caucus are going to 41:34 vote in the secret ballot to decide who leads them so we can't get out ahead of 41:37 them. So it's an interesting tension. It does seem it seems like from the 41:41 interview he's he's running to try to be a good leader and a good leader does 41:47 take the temperature of the caucus before making any proclamations which 41:52 is why in the interview you know he doesn't commit to holding a vote on 41:55 Medicare for all we just heard in that clip he doesn't commit to saying 41:58 we're going to get rid of the filibuster because a leader can't do that, which is something 42:02 that, you know, everyone listening and who watches it from the outside should realize 42:07 of Schumer or Van Hollen or wherever the leader is that, like, they, you know, we've 42:11 sort of said this before, but, like, they have less power than I think it might seem 42:17 from the outside. 42:18 Yeah. 42:19 Like, I came away, you know, you asked him point blank, like, what are the specific 42:24 ways you would have done things differently than Chuck Schumer? 42:26 He didn't really answer that question, which I think is just really disappointing. 42:29 I can't tell if that's because that's an answer he's providing to individual members 42:33 or if really is running something that's more about an overall vibe of what a leader 42:37 should be. 42:38 And that some of these questions are things he wants to talk about in private with the 42:42 other members. 42:43 Like the idea that, look, there's always, whenever you had these kind of leadership 42:47 challenges in the house, in the Senate, wherever one of the great complaints from 42:50 senators is, oh, the leadership isn't listening to me enough and I want a leader that'll 42:53 listen and that's what you promise when you're running for leader and what I 42:57 found was let's do the interview is like all right well you either you 43:00 either lose a Van Hollen or you live long enough to become a Schumer right 43:03 like he could succeed and then sure enough the same complaints would be 43:06 coming for him. But to Tommy's point that's why a running an election for 43:13 leader that's like an outside game where you're talking to audiences is 43:17 difficult because what you just said that's the promise you make to the 43:20 people inside the caucus like they all know their own business and how it's been 43:24 and so you say to people like I know your pissed that he hasn't listened over 43:27 the last couple years I'll do better than this and I'll have an open prop but 43:30 it's like it's such inside baseball that it's hard to make that like a public 43:34 pitch and some it's like I know you want the subcommittee on blah blah blah 43:37 I'll get you that or I know you're sick of the heart building we'll get you 43:39 over to Dirksen right like I get Schumer promises something I'll 43:43 honor it right take some some issues off the table but like fundamentally I 43:46 think that I think a lot of people's frustration with Schumer as a 43:48 communications problem with Schumer. 43:50 And I think that's a legitimate question, right? 43:52 Like, do we want, when someone is gonna be going 43:55 toe-to-toe with Trump in the press, 43:58 like, do you want someone who's just a better communicator? 44:01 Like, maybe that's a good enough reason, 44:03 but it doesn't seem like that's the reason 44:05 he's offering, right? 44:06 He's claiming that he would be a different kind 44:08 of leader to get some of these things done, 44:10 but like, would previous shutdowns have ended 44:13 differently with Van Hollen? 44:14 He doesn't really say, like, 44:15 what did Schumer do wrong in the past? 44:16 He doesn't really say. 44:17 So you know I'm not a voter in this election. So I leave it up to them 44:20 I was thinking about this after listening to it 44:22 I was like, what is the best case to me and I think the best case is like and he sort of made this 44:28 He gave you this answer when you asked about like why he's why it's different with Jefferies because he's supporting Jefferies for leader 44:32 And he said well Jefferies hasn't had a chance to actually lead in the majority it right? 44:36 And so let's give Jefferies a chance to do that Schumer has had his chance 44:39 And so really the argument is like we just need a new we need a new face and a new voice and 44:44 and Schumer has had his chance. 44:46 And there's not a lot of like, like you said, 44:48 there's issue positions where personally he disagrees 44:50 but how that manifests itself 44:52 and how the caucus will be different is unclear. 44:54 And I guess the case you make is like 44:55 when it comes time for a tough fight, 44:57 like I'm less likely to back down 45:00 than maybe Schumer will be. 45:02 And maybe then, and Tommy you talked to him 45:03 about like getting involved in primaries, 45:05 like yeah, when we head into 2028 45:07 and there's more Senate primaries, 45:09 would I rather the DSCC not get involved 45:13 to put their finger on the scale, 45:15 their thumb on the scale for one person 45:17 that Chuck Schumer believes is the better challenger 45:20 because his, say all you want about, you know, 45:23 Maine and Plattner and everything, 45:25 like Chuck Schumer recruiting Janet Mills 45:27 was kind of a fail. 45:29 Haley Stevens as well. 45:31 Big win on Peltola and Sherrod Brown, right? 45:33 But like maybe recruit, 45:35 but don't quite get involved 45:37 and put your thumb on the scale 45:38 for one challenger, for one candidate or another. 45:40 Yeah, the problem too though, 45:41 like we're two years away from the possibility of a democratic president, a democratic Senate. 45:46 When we had that, we talked about this on Friday, I think that's where you, 45:49 where Chuck Schumer actually has his best case, right? He got a bunch of stuff through the Senate 45:53 when he was the majority leader. I think a lot of more of the criticism. And I think there are 45:57 some people that have criticism of that era, which is really more about wishing the world 46:01 were a different place and that he could do things that were not possible, right? Like he 46:04 got a lot through, including with Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema. That was really hard to 46:08 do. Maybe there's people that can claim they could have done better. Fine, make that case. 46:11 the criticism tends to be around how he was as a minority leader, right? And during the shutdowns 46:16 and sort of the fighting against Trump. And that to me is where I want to understand why Van 46:21 Hollen thinks he would be so different. Yeah, well, and a lot of the progressive energy behind 46:25 Van Hollen is around Gaza and the US-Israel relationship. And he's in a far more progressive 46:30 place on that than Senator Schumer. So I think a lot of this is kind of derivative of those 46:35 issues. And those are very important issues to the base of this party, to me personally, 46:40 to all of you guys, right? 46:41 But I think it's gonna be like a tiny fraction 46:44 of your time as the leader. 46:46 So the question is what other, 46:47 I tried to focus on other big priorities. 46:49 And would you be able to affect a different outcome 46:52 as a leader on that issue by virtue of being leader 46:55 versus being, you know, and that we don't know 46:57 because we don't know how the vote comes up. 46:58 Like, could you go, when there was that shutdown 47:00 over healthcare and a bunch of people peeled off 47:02 and reopened the government, 47:04 a lot of people were pretty upset with Schumer 47:05 because he apparently even briefed all along, right? 47:07 Like, was that something Schumer did wrong? 47:09 was he just being a good leader by understanding what his caucus was up to? Would pressure have 47:13 worked? Would it not have worked? Would Van Hollen having buy-in from Progressive given him more 47:17 power in that fight to keep some people in line? Like, that's kind of, I don't know the answer, 47:20 but I would like to, I would like him to like really like lay out those differences, but he 47:23 kind of was reluctant. All right. Well, when we come back, you'll hear Leavitt's conversation 47:27 with Rachel Maddow about Trump's weaponization of the Justice Department and her new book, 47:31 The Department of Fate. And then that will be followed by Tommy's conversation with 47:35 Van Hollen about challenging and Schumer for Senate Majority Leader. 47:46 Pod Save America is brought to you by ZipRecruiter. 47:49 The holidays are fast approaching, which means thousands of companies have seasonal positions 47:53 to fill, from extra retail workers to real, bearded Santas to snowplow drivers. 47:59 Whether you're hiring for one of these roles or any other role, the best way to 48:01 find qualified people who are genuinely excited about your role is on ZipRecruiter. 48:06 And right now you can try it for free at ziprecruiter.com slash crooked. 48:10 Crooked. 48:10 Zippercruiter has a new feature that shows you the most interested, qualified candidates 48:14 first, so you meet the right people faster. 48:17 Zippercruiter's powerful matching technology finds quality candidates quickly. 48:21 Candidates can tell you in their own words why they're excited about the job you're 48:24 hiring for. 48:25 No wonder Zippercruiter is the number one rated hiring site based on G2. 48:29 That we've used Zippercruiter here at Crooked, it has drastically sped up the process. 48:33 We found great candidates, we found them faster, we didn't have to sort through a 48:37 ton of resumes for folks that just like, 48:39 we're not good fits for the job. 48:40 We highly recommend it 48:41 and think you'll love ZipRecruiter too. 48:43 Let ZipRecruiter find the right people for your roles, 48:46 seasonal or otherwise, try it for free today 48:48 at ZipRecruiter.com slash Crooked. 48:50 That ZipRecruiter.com slash Crooked 48:52 meet your match on ZipRecruiter. 48:55 Pots of America is brought to you by Bombas. 48:57 There's no reason to dread the cold days 48:59 and nights of winter with Bombas. 49:01 They make socks, slippers and footwear 49:02 that will keep you warm all winter long. 49:04 From fuzzy Sunday slippers for lounging around in 49:07 to water resistant suede boots that can handle the snow 49:10 and the rain, bomba socks are the winter go-to. 49:13 Merino wool and cashmere blend socks for warmth, 49:15 fuzzy socks and plush gripper socks for cozy vibes 49:18 when you're at home. 49:19 I love bomba socks. 49:21 I pretty recently, throughout all my old socks 49:23 and bought a bunch of new ones, all in bombas, 49:25 they have the great like workout, no-show socks, 49:27 a little hug for your feet. 49:29 But the best part about them is, you know, 49:30 if you're trying to wear them 49:31 with normal shoes out or something, 49:33 They have a good elastic grip. 49:35 Like they don't fall down all the time. 49:36 They don't fall apart. 49:37 You know, they're not going to just be like 49:38 slipping down your foot all day. 49:40 They're super high quality. 49:41 They last forever. 49:42 They're great. 49:43 They're comfortable. 49:43 I just highly recommend them. 49:45 And if you're looking for gifts this season, 49:46 Bombas is something for everyone. 49:48 They have cozy socks. 49:49 They got slippers. 49:50 They got cushy footwear. 49:51 They can take on the winter. 49:52 Sport socks for runners, skiers, everybody. 49:54 There's something for everyone on your list 49:56 and the best part about Bombas 49:57 for every item you purchase, 49:59 they donate an essential clothing item 50:01 to someone facing housing insecurity, 50:03 one purchase equals one donated 50:05 with over 200 million donations and counting. 50:08 Head over to bombas.com slash crooked 50:10 and use code crooked for 20% off your first purchase. 50:13 That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash crooked, 50:17 code crooked at checkout. 50:22 Joining me in studio, she needs no introduction, 50:24 but she is Rachel Maddow. 50:25 Hi. 50:26 And the author of a new book, 50:28 Department of Fate, The Promise, the Power 50:30 and the Collapse of America's 50:31 most consequential institution. 50:35 I don't think it's a spoiler to say it's about the Department of Justice. 50:39 So in just the last week, Trump has accused Democrats of extortion. 50:44 He's called for members of Congress to be prosecuted. 50:46 The White House counsel wrote to House oversight Democrats suggesting their investigations 50:50 could amount to blatant criminality. 50:52 You have U.S. attorneys sending letters to Richard Blumenthal, Alyssa Slotkin, 50:56 Elizabeth Warren, uh, suggesting that they may face consequences for looking into Trump's allies. 51:02 Meanwhile, Trump is trying to have the convictions of Steve Bannon and the Oath Keepers erased. 51:08 He's promising tremendous pardons. There is no hope that any of the brazen corruption that 51:13 he's engaged in making billions of dollars will be prosecuted by this DOJ. This is a book 51:18 about the history of this department. And I just want to start by asking is right now 51:25 The low point in the history of the Department of Justice, a department with many low points? 51:31 Yes. I think that what's happening now is qualitatively different and I don't want to, 51:36 part of the reason I wrote the book is because I don't want to fall into the trap of saying 51:40 Trump era bad, everything before this, good. Lots of bad stuff at the Justice Department 51:46 in its 150 years. But what's happened now is not just the Justice Department being 51:51 misused, or having bad leadership, or having a corruption problem, or doing what the president 51:56 intends rather than what the law requires, like it's not all of those things which we 52:00 have faced before. 52:01 I think the Justice Department is essentially kaput. 52:05 And so, yes, it's like a Department of Lawyers now. 52:08 It's a Department of Lawyers where Trump has like comic sans font legal filings 52:13 and letters sent to people like Richard Blumenthal. 52:15 But it's not a functional Justice Department in any regular sense. 52:20 It doesn't do any of its normal work. 52:22 So there's also been a series of purges and firings, and people have quit in huge numbers 52:28 by the thousands. 52:29 And so we know about the ways in which they're doing these attempts to target Trump's enemies, 52:36 and that's raiding Elon, Omar, and all the—like, there's a lot that's happening, 52:41 and it has tended to fall apart in court, or a grand jury will not indict the six 52:47 people that Trump is so set on indicting. 52:52 There's, Comey's prosecutions have not come to anything. 52:56 But then there's just the other work that DOJ is meant to be doing, white collar crime, 53:03 all sorts of public corruption cases that don't involve Trump and Trump's allies. 53:08 National security. 53:09 National security. 53:10 And are you saying those things are happening less? 53:13 They're not happening? 53:14 Correct. 53:14 Correct. 53:15 Correct. 53:15 The National Security Division is effectively closed. 53:18 So we just had John Eisenberg leave as the head of the National Security Division. 53:23 It was gone underneath him, and the remaining lawyers there were being assigned to redact 53:28 the Epstein trials. 53:30 That's national security. 53:32 The Public Integrity Division is gone. 53:33 The Tax Division is gone. 53:35 Even the Office of Legislative Affairs is gone. 53:38 They really have shut down the main work of the Justice Department, which is bad. 53:43 I mean, you don't want a bad Justice Department, but you do want a Justice Department. 53:48 And so that's the pickle that we're in and also the opportunity, which is that by essentially 53:53 wiping it out, the Democrats controlling Congress now have the opportunity to rebuild 54:00 it in a way that accounts not just for the problems that it has now and the way that 54:04 Trump and Bill Barr killed it, but for the problems that it has had in the past. 54:09 I don't want them rebuilding it in a way that just fights the last war. 54:12 I want them to know the other things that Justice Department has don't have done wrong in the last hundred fifty years, too 54:17 now there was another direction Trump could have gone when he became president which is to 54:23 Build up the Department of Justice in a terrifying way 54:25 Yeah, right like in the in the two choices between 54:28 decimating the Department of Justice and building it up into an even more frightening organization that is actually 54:34 Sophisticated and able to go after its enemies. I don't know. I'd rather live in this timeline. I think right because it's it does mean that 54:41 that we are not seeing, I think, a level of success 54:45 of in their efforts to intimidate people, right? 54:48 Yes, and I was totally wrong about that. 54:50 At the end of Trump's first term, 54:52 I thought, oh, if he ever gets back in office, 54:54 he is gonna turn this weapon into a nuclear weapon. 54:58 How, you know, they're gonna triple the size of the FBI, 55:00 they're gonna triple the size of the Justice Department, 55:02 they're gonna triple its budget, 55:03 and it is going to become this, 55:06 it's gonna become the thing that we all keep warning about. 55:08 It's gonna become his sword and his shield, 55:10 he's going to use it to, you know, do all the things. 55:14 And he didn't at all. 55:16 And I think that is, it was a surprise as part of why I wrote the book, why was I wrong 55:21 about this. 55:22 But it's also, I think, ominous because I think the core and first, like chronologically 55:30 first function of the Justice Department is to make sure that we all, or at least 55:36 some of us have the benefit of the protections that the constitution affords us. And if you 55:42 want to get rid of the constitutional republic and have nobody benefit from those protections, 55:47 it's better to have this department, this uniquely consequential department gone than it is to have 55:55 it alive while you try to pervert its course. Let's talk about some of the examples from 55:59 the past. I want to get to your thoughts on where we need to go from here, but you talk 56:04 about Amos Ackerman who was the attorney general under Grant. He becomes attorney general before 56:09 there's really even a department, right? The department is set up behind him. And this 56:13 is a former slaveholder. He goes to the south and he has something like an epiphany 56:20 about what it is going to take to actually defeat the Ku Klux Klan and the terror it's 56:27 inflicting. And I think there's an interesting lesson there about legitimacy in a polarized 56:33 time and what, I'm so curious what you took away from his story and what you think people 56:39 should know about it. 56:40 The thing about Aikerman is that it was not at all like a chronicle foretold that that 56:45 is how it would go. 56:46 As you note, there was no Justice Department, there was just an Attorney General. 56:50 And before the Congress created Department of Justice in 1870 after the Civil War, 56:57 the Attorney General was just kind of the lawyer for the president and the lawyer 57:00 for the cabinet. 57:01 And it was a small enough job that most people had a side hustle to while they did it, and 57:06 they had to kind of raise their own funds and stuff. 57:09 And under Ackerman, they stood up the Justice Department, and it wasn't the wake of the 57:13 Civil War, and it wasn't the wake of the Civil, or the Constitutional Amendments, like 57:17 the 14th Amendment, every equal protection under the law, and all those important 57:21 things that were supposed to make us into the multiracial democracy that we fought 57:26 the Civil War to establish. 57:29 and Ackerman is the only Southerner in Grant's cabinet as the former slaveholder, 57:34 former Confederate officer. He, as a Southerner, just comes to this realization, 57:40 he accepts that the South lost. He accepts that the South's cause was wrong and that the country 57:46 needs to change. But he, as a Southerner, believes that as long as there is effectively 57:52 terrorist rule in the South, we're never gonna get to where we need to get to. 57:56 the North will never really have one. 57:59 And the Constitution will just be paper 58:03 and it will not be anything that reflects the way we live. 58:06 And so he decides to go uproot the Klan in South Carolina. 58:08 And he has remarkable success 58:12 and it brings thousands of prosecutions, 58:15 gets lots and lots and lots of convictions. 58:18 They suspend habeas corpus and give him 58:20 a division of the army to work with, 58:22 but he nevertheless decides to give people due process 58:26 and afford people their constitutional rights even though he legally doesn't have to. 58:30 And he's just like a really remarkably morally farsighted person. 58:36 And then of course his political support collapses and Washington at all falls apart 58:42 and we end reconstruction. 58:43 But in 1870 and 1871 what he did was I think the founding moral vision 58:50 of what the U.S. Department of Justice is and should be, 58:53 which is not allowable under a leader like this one. 58:58 Well, what was striking about that story is, 59:02 this is, some of my roll their eyes, 59:05 but I was thinking about Merrick Garland, right? 59:07 And the conception of legitimacy that some have had 59:09 about the Department of Justice, 59:10 which is trying to prove that it is independent, right? 59:14 And trying to kind of prove even to its enemies 59:16 that it can be trusted, right? 59:18 That is not what you have with Acremen. 59:21 You have someone who is saying no, there's a deeper kind of moral legitimacy that we are striving for here 59:27 And that requires doing things that is going to end that is that that are going to antagonize a lot of people 59:32 Yes, but those things are necessary. Yes, because we are trying to achieve a 59:38 An outcome that 59:41 We believe is legitimate even if there are people that don't 59:44 Ascribe to it. He thought the country wouldn't survive 59:47 We just barely made it through the Civil War and he thought the country would not survive unless we lived up to the ideals that we 59:53 established in the Constitution at the end of the Civil War. And in order to live up to those ideals all those guys needed to be 60:00 prosecuted. And the thing about the clan which he understood and which was an operational principle for the way 60:07 they brought those prosecutions was that the guys who were the mayors and the bankers and the business leaders and the 60:14 ministers and all of the leading 60:16 white men of York County, South Carolina were running the town and were the establishment 60:22 of the day by daylight and at night they put on hoods and raped and murdered their way through 60:27 the countryside. 60:28 And he knew that they had every resource on their side in terms of trying to prosecute 60:33 them and he factored that into the way that he went after them. 60:36 And they were of course total cowards and they lied and they tried to make other 60:43 people take the blame for what they'd done and a whole bunch of them fled and 60:45 went to Canada. 60:46 He went to Canada and chased them and brought them back. 60:48 I mean, he was really aggressive and really committed 60:53 and it really alienated him from everybody else 60:56 in the cabinet who did not want to keep fighting 60:59 these fights. 61:00 And so reconstruction ends, the amendments, 61:05 the implications, the Supreme Court limits 61:08 the civil rights law and the reach of these amendments 61:10 and then all of a sudden a lot of these people 61:14 who had been denying their involvement, 61:16 suddenly feel proud and start bragging 61:19 about their involvement in the Klan 61:20 and some of the killings and the lynchings 61:21 that they participated in. 61:23 We talk about Trump and pardoning of insurrectionists. 61:27 There was a successful coup in Wilmington, North Carolina, 61:29 and then there was a debate about whether 61:32 to go after those responsible 61:35 and the administration decides not to. 61:38 Can you talk about that? 61:39 Let the coup stand, exactly. 61:41 Exactly. 61:41 I mean, that and the Tulsa Race Massacre and the, I mean, the Grant Administration is willing 61:49 to let Ackerman fight this fight to a certain extent. 61:54 They tire of him immediately. 61:55 The other thing that happens though in addition to sort of losing the appetite for that fight 62:00 is that Ackerman is the first attorney general that has a Department of Justice. 62:06 He does this incredibly effective thing with the Department of Justice. 62:09 I mean, it just turns out to be this very potent tool. 62:13 And when he is pushed out, part of the reason he's pushed out, I believe it's a little bit 62:19 of a controversial assertion historically, but I believe, I have convinced myself that 62:23 it's in part because people in the cabinet realized, oh, there's this new very effective 62:28 tool that we can use for our purposes. 62:31 We would prefer to be using it for the things that we want rather than using it 62:35 to stir up this fight with the South again, 62:37 or to stand up for the freedmen, who cares about them? 62:40 And they very quickly start to use 62:43 the new Department of Justice for the purposes 62:46 of standing up for the rich and moneyed 62:49 and white supremacist interests in the country. 62:51 And so, you know, by 18, by the 18, 62:55 Ackerman's there in 1870, by the 1890s, 62:57 you've got Richard Olney in there 62:59 using the Justice Department to crush the labor movement. 63:02 Like that was not what the department 63:04 was founded for and you wouldn't have thought under Ackerman that it could 63:08 have ever been something like that, but you get the wrong guy in there with a 63:11 real understanding about how to use power and the Justice Department just has 63:14 absolutely unparalleled power to shape the course of the nation, to ruin 63:19 people's lives, to end people's lives, to, you know, wield physical force 63:23 against the population, but also just to change the way the country works, 63:29 like no other agency does. What Ackerman does is a kind of creative 63:33 use of power and this structure and the law, right? Suspends habeas corpus, never had been 63:40 done in peacetime, and does it to root out the clan. You also have only abusing the Sherman 63:48 Antitrust Act, which had not been used effectively in its corporations, but used really the first 63:52 time effectively against unions, not the intent. Yeah, to help corporations. To help 63:56 corporations. You have a young Jay Edgar Hoover, who's living with his parents, rounding up 64:02 supposed radicals and trying to have them all deported by the arresting people by the thousands, 64:07 another creative use of the law. And this is why I come back to this idea of legitimacy. Well, 64:15 what's the difference between the creative use of habeas corpus to root out the clan and one 64:19 that's used to go after supposed radicals and have them deported without due process or going 64:23 after the labor unions? Well, I think we can come up with some sophisticated argument for how 64:27 different, but we just think one is right and one is wrong, and we want a Department of Justice 64:32 that has the right morals, and that if it's using its power creatively and aggressively, 64:36 it's towards ends we view as just. Or is there more to it? 64:39 I mean, it should be to follow the strictures of the Constitution, right? It should be to 64:43 follow the law. Like, there should be our sense of what is right, and it should also be 64:50 coincident with what we think is allowable. And so, you know, if the 14th Amendment 64:54 Amendment is going to afford us all equal protection under the law, then you can't have 65:00 a terrorist regime murdering people for voting. 65:04 You can't do that. 65:06 And that's, even if you don't have any other moral sense about it, if you were just following 65:11 the 14th Amendment, it would lead you to that conclusion. 65:14 But yeah. 65:15 But they would argue, right, that like, and I obviously agree with you, but that, 65:18 well, they were worried about a communist menace, the communist menace. 65:21 And by the way, people who have taken an oath of citizenship, I think this 65:24 This applies to what's happening right now with Trump and going after Elon Omar, right? 65:27 They would, like, I don't think there's, I don't think these people are acting in good 65:29 faith. 65:30 I don't think they were acting in good faith back then, but communism is a menace. 65:33 If you take a note to the Constitution and you take in a note and foresworn communism, 65:36 if you are subscribing to communism, then you're at risk of deportation. 65:39 We have the right to go after you to protect the American people. 65:42 We believe that's a necessary and noble act. 65:44 So in the Red Scare part of the book about, this is about the first Red Scare in 65:48 the 1920s, the Palmer Raids, and, you know, there's this, a lot of people 65:51 who talk about Jared Gerhoover, talk about this as his origin story in the Red Raids. 65:55 The thing that I think is underappreciated about Hoover in the Red Raids and his 66:00 first big splash in public life is that he was humiliated. He was totally had, he completely 66:06 had his hat handed to him over the Red Raids. He botched it and I think never recovered from 66:12 it psychologically and that explains a lot of how he became the bureaucratic infighter that 66:16 he later became. But the hero in the book about the red raids is this guy, Louis Post. 66:24 At the time, the Labor Department, for inexplicable reasons, had responsibility for deportations 66:29 and immigration. And Louis Post was at the Labor Department. That's supposed to be handling 66:35 immigration and deportations, but the Justice Department comes in with Jared Gerhoover and 66:39 the radical squad, and they decided to deport people by the thousands purely on the basis 66:43 that their political beliefs. And Lewis Post, from his position at the Labor Department, decides 66:51 I think that this is all being done illegally. And he doesn't object to the communism as bad 66:58 part of it. And in fact, communism has been defined and narrowly in statute as something that 67:05 does having communist affiliations of very specific kinds does lay you bare to deportation. 67:10 and Louis Post accepted that, but when they threw people down the stairs and locked them 67:17 in hot boxes and tortured them and went out and grabbed people and then wrote the warrants 67:22 after the fact. 67:23 While they're being custody for weeks. 67:25 Exactly. 67:26 While they were doing all of this stuff that was slovenly and illegal and lawless and 67:32 brutal, Louis Post used each of those types of things to cancel the warrants 67:38 and cancel the deportations. 67:40 And so it wasn't that he took issue, the type of argument that you were saying was like 67:45 defense would defend this sort of thing. 67:48 He didn't take issue with that. 67:50 He took issue with the Justice Department acting like a bunch of thugs very effectively 67:55 in a way that really did harm the reputation of Palmer who wanted to be president, very 68:00 much harmed the reputation of J. Edgar Hoover and very much saved thousands of people 68:06 from unjust deportations and incarceration. 68:09 And post happened to have been one of the people that had been working for Aikerman in the 68:16 50 years earlier when he was very young. 68:19 He was doing the transcriptions of the interviews with the Klan members. 68:24 Is that right? 68:24 Yes. 68:25 It's so crazy. 68:26 50 years later, the same guy, so he's like 21 years old when he's hired as, he's 68:32 hired literally to take notes. 68:33 he's hired as a stenographer for the clan prosecutions under Aikerman, that I argue in 68:40 the book sort of gives him a moral cornerstone that becomes something that he relies on for 68:45 the rest of his life. And then 50 years later, he's doing a completely different kind of 68:49 work. And thank God he's got that moral cornerstone and he just takes this brilliant and immovable 68:56 stand and saves thousands of families. 68:58 So the attention seeking for the raids that Hoover was seeking the coverage right having the coverage all lined up 69:07 Couldn't help but remind me of Steven Miller of the efforts of Christine Ohm and and and that team was trying to creating chains 69:15 Yeah, but there's also 69:18 The ways in which the sort of the Department of Justice has 69:22 overlooked corruption or participated in corruption and 69:26 And you know, you, you talk about what was happening under, in Harding administration, 69:31 you have the teapot dome scandal, which no matter how many times I learned with the teapot 69:35 dome scandals, I'm like, why is it called teapot dome? 69:38 And I remember it's a name of a place. 69:40 I never retain that information. 69:41 And here's the thing. 69:42 If you look, it's, it's supposedly called the teapot dome scandal because there's 69:46 this rock formation where they drilled for oil and they had a big oil reserve. 69:50 And the rock formation looked just like a teapot. 69:52 If you have seen the rock formation, it looks nothing like a teapot. 69:55 It's bullshit. 69:55 And I take issue. 69:58 I agree with you. 69:59 Terrible name. 69:59 We should have a new name. 70:00 Yeah. 70:00 Especially because it was freaking lurid. 70:02 There was like sex and murder and bags of cash. 70:05 And it was. 70:06 Valium, right? 70:07 I also would say also XYZ affair. 70:09 Same thing. 70:10 I think we need a new name for that one, 70:11 but we can deal with that later. 70:12 So. 70:13 I think it shouldn't be called ranked choice voting. 70:15 I think it should be called one, two, three voting. 70:19 Put that on the list. 70:20 You and I should be in charge. 70:21 I also want to rename the lab grown meat. 70:23 We got to beat that. 70:24 Cultivated meat doesn't work. 70:25 You know what? 70:25 Another topic. 70:26 another topic. So you've got two things happening at once. You've got a corrupt 70:30 Department of Justice that is in which you have the teapot dome scandal and 70:36 this sort of brazen bribery scheme which by today's standards is pretty quaint. 70:40 At the same time they're overlooking or refusing to investigate the Tulsa 70:43 race masquerades. This is a group of white supremacists killing hundreds of 70:46 people in Tulsa. Do you see a connection between a corrupt Department 70:52 of justice that is willing to look past its own allies' failures and not going after genuine 70:59 injustices, why do those things tend to move hand in hand? 71:02 Yeah, I think that in fiction or when you imagine these things in the abstract, 71:08 they don't have to go together, but in real life they almost always do. 71:11 If you are approaching your government employment the way Attorney General Harry 71:17 already did, the purpose of the Justice Department is to deliver bribes to yourself and to deliver, 71:24 occasionally like to deliver favors to your friend but the president for whom you were 71:29 campaign manager before you became AG and all these things, but mostly it's just to get money. 71:34 If that's the way you see your department, I think it's just unlikely that you would also 71:39 use your department for the purposes that it was intended for. Like I think once Corey 71:45 Kori Lewandowski is reportedly, you know, approaching the geogroup to put him on retainer 71:53 so that they can maintain their Department of Homeland Security contracts. 71:59 I don't think that Kori Lewandowski is probably also making sure that things are efficient 72:04 at TSA. 72:06 You know, I just, I just don't think those things go together. 72:09 Well, part of it too is, you know, you don't make more when you get good conviction. 72:13 You know, there has to be motivated. 72:14 there has to be some sort of fire in you, right? 72:17 And that's sort of either it's for a government that works 72:19 or you've experienced corrupt government in your own life 72:22 or you've just been a person that was motivated by history, 72:25 right? 72:26 Like part of the prestige of working at this place is not 72:29 is sort of the enjoyment of making the bastards pay, right? 72:33 Like that has to be something that really animates you, 72:35 right? 72:35 I think it's James Comey's quote, right? 72:37 That like when all these, all his prosecutors 72:39 were getting 100% conviction rates 72:41 and he called it the chicken shit caucus 72:42 or something like that. 72:43 because he was like, hey, we got to be tougher. 72:46 This is back when I liked James Comey. 72:47 But the idea of like, hey, we're doing this 72:49 because we have a fire in our belly to actually do this. 72:52 And if these are people that are motivated, 72:54 either Todd Blanche, seeing himself as the president's lawyer, 72:58 he's not gonna see himself as, 72:59 he's not gonna imagine that he could just decide 73:01 that his job is going after the worst white collar 73:03 criminals in the world and getting great pleasure 73:05 and prestige and kind of a claim for doing that. 73:09 No, he has said that like, 73:11 Like what he thinks about his job is, I love you. 73:14 I would just say to the president, I love you. 73:16 I love you. 73:17 And he's there to serve the man he loves 73:19 and to hopefully earn his love back, I'm guessing, 73:22 I don't know. 73:23 Therapy, people need therapy. 73:25 So you have a lot of contempt for Bill Barr in the book. 73:27 He had two stints, roughly 30 years apart. 73:33 What did you think of the headshot? 73:34 Part of the reason I wanted to write about him, 73:35 I like committed myself to this early on 73:37 because I always, I just think that this headshot 73:40 It's one of these things I can just stare at it indefinitely. 73:44 Oh, you know what? 73:45 I know that head shot, of course. 73:47 It's a very, yes. 73:49 I think it looks like he just ate a little person. 73:53 Yeah, like a little, he just like... 73:56 He looks like he is the villain in an 80s movie 74:00 and is trying to build the factory 74:03 where the skate park is. 74:06 Yes, exactly. 74:07 Like he's, he's actively like gassing the puppies, like he's that kind of. 74:12 That's just business, that kind of thing. 74:14 So, you talk about the way in which he was kind of serving as George H.W. Bush's lawyer 74:21 and protector and then- And Reagan. 74:24 And Reagan and then Trump's. 74:28 Now, you sort of hold him as someone who's sort of more than most, if not more than all, 74:33 kind of brought the DOJ to where it is now. 74:35 And yet at the end of Trump's first term, 74:39 he does turn on Trump, doesn't he? 74:41 Like he does a little bit. 74:44 So there is some line that he has, right? 74:46 Or no, what is your conclusion about Bill Barr? 74:49 I will confess to you, John, because we're friends. 74:52 We've known each other a long time 74:53 that I have feelings about this. 74:55 And so my feelings may have driven 74:57 some of my interest in this topic. 75:00 Like I have feelings about that picture. 75:01 I really wanted to make sure 75:02 that that picture was in the book. 75:04 And so because I wanted that picture to be in the book, 75:07 then I made sure that the book was divided into parts 75:09 so I could put a picture of another main character 75:12 in each of the other six parts of the book. 75:13 Boy, this is sort of a little bit of a sort of, 75:16 you know, a personalized prosecution in a sense. 75:18 Well, my grievance, as I get older, 75:20 my grievances are all I have. 75:21 And I have one with, it's not actually with Bill Barr, 75:26 it's about Bill Barr. 75:27 And that is that he gets way too much credit 75:29 for having done very little in resistance to Trump's effort to overthrow the constitutional 75:37 republic and stay in power despite losing an election. And I really go into detail in the 75:42 book about the things that Barr did to absolutely advance and in some cases accelerate Trump's 75:50 false claims about election fraud. It was only when we got to the precipice of January 6th 75:57 and Barr is smart enough to know what's about to happen. 76:00 And I think smart enough to know that he himself 76:02 might get in trouble for being part of that. 76:05 And so he balks at the very last second. 76:09 I wonder if also, but also he also is a creature of DC. 76:12 And like a lot of others in that moment 76:15 believe Trump was done. 76:16 And I wonder if he knew then, 76:18 because, you know, he is, that was a moment 76:20 where Lindsey Graham is being pretty direct 76:24 about the insurrection. 76:25 Mitch McConnell is, right, a lot of them are. 76:27 They think Trump is over so don't have to worry about him anymore. So now they're playing to the history books 76:30 So right I was always against this general wonder. There's heroes in this book 76:35 But I guess I'm wondering like are there times where you think oh, this is when the DOJ was not just one person 76:41 Fighting for it to be better, but actually kind of the best embodiment of of what it could be 76:48 Yeah, it's a good question. This is the book is not like a beginning to end history in the Justice Department 76:54 at all. It's just, it's basically a half dozen anecdotes or stories from the history of the 76:58 department that I think are illustrative about how consequential the department is and that have 77:04 some good stories for us, some good analogies for us, some good references for us when we think 77:10 about the challenges that we have today. Like the Harry Doherty thing about him taking all 77:14 these bribes in the Justice Department, it ends up being less important than the fact that 77:20 the teapot dome scandal is happening and he's not prosecuting it. So that, I think, is analogous to 77:26 Todd Blanche. Like, whatever Todd Blanche is doing that's bad with the Justice Department, 77:29 the things he's letting the Trump administration at large get away with without prosecuting them 77:35 is a bigger deal. And the Doherty history kind of gives us a precedent for that. So that's 77:40 kind of how I picked the stories that I did. I do think that the post-Watergate reforms 77:44 reforms were sound and wise and they weren't enough. 77:48 I think that if we were going to refound the department now, if Congress was going to re-establish 77:54 it in a way that was meant to make it stronger and more resilient and less likely to fall 77:58 into the bad patterns that it's had in the past, you would start with the Watergate 78:02 reforms and sort of triple down on them. 78:04 And so I think the post-Watergate Justice Department sort of until Reagan is probably 78:10 a good example. 78:11 I think the prosecution of Spiro Agnew, for example, 78:15 was a high point. 78:15 I wrote a book about that, too. 78:16 So there's... 78:17 And there's the Antigua podcast. 78:18 Thank you very much. 78:18 Thank you very much. 78:21 So there's good stuff. 78:22 Is that Bagman? 78:22 No, it's Bagman. 78:23 Bagman, yeah. 78:24 So there's been good stuff. 78:28 And there's stuff to build on. 78:30 But I think that the conclusion 78:33 that I sort of talked myself into 78:35 in researching the book, 78:36 and it's another justification for having, 78:38 you know, a half dozen parts each of which 78:40 starts with a little picture of a main character is that personnel really, really, really is 78:46 policy and at a department of government, at a division of the government that is just 78:52 uniquely consequential the way this one is, we have to be uniquely careful about what 78:58 people we put there and give this power to. 79:01 And so therefore, it should be really hard to get confirmed to a high-level position 79:06 of the Justice Department. 79:07 Like, I just think it should be a higher threshold. 79:08 I think there should be all sorts of restrictions on what kind of expertise and qualifications 79:14 you need to have. 79:16 I think if you've been the president's personal lawyer, you can't ever work at the 79:19 Justice Department. 79:21 I just think that we should be really careful about who gets in there because the power 79:26 that they wield is unlike any other thing in government. 79:29 There's a point where the Independent Council statute is before the Supreme Court and 79:35 upheld, I think it's seven to one, and the one dissent with Scalia, which begins our march towards 79:41 a unitary executive. You know, we've just been through a bunch of rulings where Congress had 79:46 set up these institutions that were meant to be partially executive, partially legislative, 79:51 right? They were kind of supposed to sit between the two. And the court just said, 79:53 nope, those are all executive, that they basically, the president has total control over 79:58 those bodies. We have moved so far away from having any kind, independence, if it could exist 80:06 at all right now, the Department of Justice would have to just be cultural, right? Because 80:09 it is the view of the majority of the Supreme Court. It is a view of most Republicans now 80:15 that all power flows from the president. That is what the Constitution promises, 80:20 and therefore the president can hire and fire anybody. In that context, how do you have 80:24 an independent Department of Justice when one of our two parties does not believe in 80:30 the rule of law. 80:31 Yeah. 80:31 Right? 80:31 Like that, whatever rules you have, whatever controls you have, if the president can hire 80:35 and fire, and one party doesn't really think it should be independent. 80:40 Yeah. 80:40 I mean, the Unitary Executive Theory is bananas. 80:43 And it came from a totally liminal, bizarre place. 80:47 And it was embraced in the Reagan administration while they were scurrying around looking 80:53 for some tendentious thing they could use to try to save Reagan from the disaster that 80:59 was Iran-Contra. 81:01 I mean, the Unitary Executive during Iran-Contra had me used to claim that the president could 81:07 break a law if it was about national security and he issued a presidential finding that 81:15 said he needed to do something for national security reasons regarding this other law. 81:19 and issuing a presidential finding 81:22 by the end of the Iran-Contra scandal 81:24 came to mean he thought a thing. 81:26 So we could have a mental finding. 81:29 Yeah. 81:30 Well, what's funny about that is that, 81:32 so that's, so Nixon, you know, 81:33 there's the Nixon, if the president does it, 81:35 it's not illegal. 81:36 Later, Trump says a version of this 81:38 that sounds ludicrous coming from his mouth, 81:40 but it actually is the justification 81:42 that they were offering during the Reagan administration. 81:44 Absolutely. 81:45 And the idea that, I mean, 81:47 And the mental finding thing, if I think it, even if I don't say it to another person, 81:52 let alone write it down, it then immunizes me from all consequences and allows me to 81:58 break any law that I want. 81:59 I mean, that's just bananas. 82:02 But that actually was the way that Trump claimed he declassified all the stuff that 82:07 he put in his pooper at the Mar-a-Lago bathroom. 82:11 Even though it would have to have been after he left office, so pretty tough to 82:14 do. 82:14 Yeah, the, you know, you start with this speech 82:19 that Robert Jackson gave. 82:23 And I actually, I stumbled upon this speech 82:25 when I was interviewing Michael Shannon 82:26 who played Robert Jackson in the movie Nuremberg. 82:29 And it is this stunning and beautiful speech 82:32 about the power of the prosecutor. 82:35 The danger of what happens when we prosecute, 82:38 when we look for laws that were broken 82:40 rather than people who broke the laws. 82:41 And you just talk about sort of, 82:43 I think is a place to leave it, 82:44 like what you hope for at the Department of Justice 82:47 and what other kind of changes you'd like to see. 82:52 Jackson's speech is like the text everybody cites 82:56 about federal prosecutors, about the Justice Department. 83:01 People on every side of every argument 83:04 cite the Jackson speech as if it supports their claims. 83:07 It's like the Bible of, 83:08 it's the Bible of arguing about the Justice Department. 83:14 And so I'm sort of making a meta point about it which is the Justice Department can be 83:19 all things to all people. 83:20 You can use it for the worst possible things and you can use it for the best possible things. 83:23 And we should learn about the best things that it's done and try to hold those up and 83:27 support more of those and figure out a way to get less of the worst things. 83:32 But the, I argue because everybody arguing about the Justice Department must cite that 83:37 speech. 83:37 I argue that it also supports my take on it, which is that when Jackson is talking to that 83:46 roomful of prosecutors about what it means, what it looks like to do the job right, 83:53 he's basically just telling them to be good people, like this gentlemanly spirit of fair play, 83:58 right? And I, as quaint as that sounds and as maybe dissatisfying as that sounds in terms 84:06 of political warfare and reform and refounding this institution and everything the Democrats 84:12 need to investigate and they need to do, and I really think they do need to refound this 84:17 institution. Ultimately, I think the lesson of the past 150 years is don't let bad guys in 84:23 there. It's the same thing with the presidency. There's no thing that you can do with laws and 84:29 oversight and strictures on the president that can make up for the kind of harm that 84:36 can be done if you just put a demon in there. 84:39 In the same way that our democracy relies on people using words as they were meant, 84:48 or at least in good faith as they could be used, right, like a fair interpretation 84:52 of their meaning. 84:53 And if people are willing to have words mean anything, up to including the president 84:57 and it can break the law 84:57 as long as he writes a little memo afterwards. 85:00 But I would say I have a little bit of a different lesson 85:03 from the book. 85:04 And it is because I think I, 85:06 whatever Bill Barr is to you, 85:08 for Merrick Garland is that for me a little bit. 85:12 Just that, and James Comey in part 85:15 because I think they just had a misunderstanding 85:17 of what legitimacy is. 85:20 Because why does going after the clan work? 85:23 Well, because you have to go really hard 85:24 and you can't stop. 85:26 Yeah, because there's no they're not gonna practice forbearance. Yes, right? 85:30 And so like what kind of oversight do we need? What do we do after the Trump administration? 85:35 Yes, we should have reforms and we should kind of bound behind the Department of Justice in the 85:39 ways that we can from its worst successes. But really we need to have thousands of lawyers 85:44 come back in and start looking for all the crimes we missed. Yes. And we have to make 85:49 them all pay. 85:50 We have to put, yeah, public corruption should be structurally at the heart of what the 85:56 Justice Department does because it does that in a way that is irreplaceable that nobody 86:00 else can do it. 86:01 And you have to do it despite the fact that you will be accused of being part of a tit 86:05 for tat, right? 86:07 There is a difference between going after your enemies because you're a part of 86:13 a red scare and going after the Klan in South Carolina, and you have to bear the 86:17 fact that there were people who accuse you of doing what you said they did, or will accuse 86:21 you of politicizing the Justice Department, but they're going to accuse you of that no 86:25 matter what. 86:26 I mean, they accused the Obama Justice Department of having weaponized the Justice Department 86:31 and Lois Lerner and the IRS and the Tea Party groups and the hanging out. 86:35 I mean, all of that was horse hockey. 86:38 But you know, to people who want to believe that it is just, it's a very potent what 86:43 about ism kind of claim. 86:44 And so you just I mean if you act in good faith and you argue in good faith you can't let bad faith argument slow you down 86:52 Yeah, and trust that in time you will be vindicated in a in a world where you will be facing a politicized opposite 86:59 You know polarized 87:00 Response like you're not going to win by like there there's so many examples in this book where 87:06 You can't appease your way 87:08 Yes 87:09 To sort of comedy comedy with these people it will not work it will not work 87:13 Well, the book, Department of Fate, it's fascinating, it's a great read. 87:18 I really think you should do less, Rachel Maddow. 87:21 I'm going to take a little bit of, I think you should take some me time. 87:25 I agree. 87:26 You know, because I feel like I talked to you a few months ago and you had a documentary. 87:30 And you seem to be continuing to make these programs week after week. 87:33 So I just think it's like. 87:35 Time to stop. 87:36 Yeah. 87:36 I agree. 87:37 I think I'm going to take up some sort of hobby that immobilizes me for long 87:42 periods of time so that I'm fentanyl perhaps or moon boots this thing where 87:46 you have what's it's gravity boots this thing you hang upside down sure all the 87:50 blood goes to your hand you always think it's gonna feel better if you see 87:52 people hang upside down you think oh it's gonna feel like such a great stretch 87:55 it doesn't I during the pandemic I bought one of those things where you go 87:58 like this yeah nothing was it like a table it was like you let you go on it 88:02 like this you put your feet down here and then you roll all the way back 88:04 and you're hanging upside down I wanted it to feel different I had in my mind 88:08 how I was gonna feel I thought it feel like I'm getting stretched yeah 88:11 It didn't, it was just, you were just upside down. 88:13 Just upside down. 88:14 What'd you do with it? 88:15 It's in the basement. 88:16 You didn't like Facebook Marketplace it 88:18 or whatever you're supposed to do? 88:20 Well, you know, this is a longer story, 88:22 but it turns out that there was a, 88:26 there was a free box of protein powder 88:28 and a rat got it and then it ate the, 88:30 the rats ate the protein powder 88:31 and then the rats ate the machine. 88:33 Oh, so you have a, you have a, 88:35 you have a wounded useless hang upside down tool. 88:39 I'm gonna cut this thing about the rats. 88:40 All right, Rachel Maddow, thank you so much. 88:43 So good to talk to you. 88:44 It's good to see you. 88:52 This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. 88:55 Overthinking can take over your day, 88:56 but you don't need to carry that burden around. 88:58 With therapy, you can quiet the noise 89:00 and take back control of your peace of mind. 89:02 Take the first step today with BetterHelp. 89:04 BetterHelp therapists are licensed 89:05 experienced professionals. 89:07 They have at least three years 89:08 and 1,000 hours of hands-on experience 89:10 and have the required education, 89:12 training, exams, and practice. 89:14 BetterHelp does the initial matching work for you 89:16 so you can focus on your therapy goals. 89:18 A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences in their 10 or more years 89:22 of experience. 89:23 An industry-leading match fulfillment rate means they typically get it right the first 89:26 time. 89:27 If you aren't happy with your match, switch to a new therapist at any time from a tailored 89:31 recommendation list with no hassles. 89:34 There is a lot going on in this world. 89:35 There is all the political news you listen to here every week. 89:39 There is stuff we all are dealing with, with families, with work, interpersonal stuff, 89:44 relationships, everything. Everyone would benefit from seeing a therapist. You have nothing 89:49 to lose. Give it a shot. And right now, BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health 89:54 plans, with many co-pays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible 90:00 insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 10% off your first month. Sign 90:05 up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com slash PSA. That's betterhelp.com slash PSA. 90:14 of the world. 90:15 Discover a spectacular island 90:16 destination with crystal blue 90:18 seas, endless sunshine, and the 90:20 cool Bahamian breeze. 90:22 Bahamar, located in Nassau, 90:24 Bahamas, offers your choice of 90:26 three luxury hotels, the richly 90:28 refined rosewood, the playfully 90:29 hip SLS, and the stylishly 90:31 modern Grand Hyatt. 90:33 With over 45 restaurants, bars 90:35 and lounges, Bahamar serves up 90:37 delicious dining from world-renowned 90:38 chefs like Daniel Balloud and 90:40 Marcus Sandelson. 90:41 Nightlife venues like the new 90:43 John Batiste Jazz Club and the Caribbean's most luxurious casino. At Baja Mar, you'll find 90:49 every pleasure under the sun and one-of-a-kind experiences for the entire family, like Baja 90:54 Bay, our 15-acre lush tropical water park. Interactive wildlife experiences, including 90:59 our daily flamingo parade, world-class golf, tennis, spa, and so much more. Visit BajaMar.com today 91:06 and discover a vacation destination where memories are made for a lifetime. Baja Mar, 91:12 life spectacular. This is Martha Stewart. Have you ever started a new tradition? 91:18 Here's a hint. Do it with Lennox. This year Lennox will make the holiday 91:22 something truly special. How exciting it is every year to unbox all of our 91:27 favorite decor and smile at the memories. The Lennox Spice Village is the 91:32 perfect holiday gift for someone you love, including yourself. Calling back 91:37 to the originals from 1989, now you can share the memories and the flavors of the season. 91:44 It's a charming collection of hand-painted houses. Imagine ginger from a Georgian townhouse, 91:50 or pepper from your Swiss chalet. Lennox has brought timeless beauty and quality to tables and homes 91:56 for generations. Baking together, sharing recipes, decorating, suddenly simple pleasures become 92:03 part of your holiday story forever. With Lennox, collect those moments every year or treat your 92:10 favorite someone. Remember, when you give a gift that lasts beyond the holidays, it's an amazing 92:16 feeling. When you give Lennox, you just might start a new tradition. Discover the full collection 92:22 at Lennox.com slash Spice Village. My guest today is a U.S. Senator from Maryland who is 92:32 currently vying to unseat Chuck Schumer as the leader of the Senate Democrats. Senator 92:37 Chris Van Hollen, thanks for joining the show. 92:39 It was great to be with you. 92:40 It was great to see you at Kirkukon. Thank you for being there. It was a very, 92:43 it was a fun couple of days. You know, people were happy. 92:45 It was great. You guys put together a great sort of post-election celebration, 92:49 but also look to the future. 92:51 Yeah, we tried. Luckily, we had some good news to talk about. 92:54 So speaking of the future, you're challenging Senator Schumer to become the Senate 92:58 majority leader next year. Can you give us a few specific examples of things you think Senator Schumer 93:05 did poorly or did wrong and how you would lead the caucus differently? 93:09 Sure, Tommy. And let me start by saying that this was a great day for American democracy. We 93:14 have 56 seats now. We need to use this power to move forward on breaking a system that's rigged 93:21 in favor of the rich and against working people and fueled by political corruption. 93:25 And I do think that to move forward, we need to demonstrate change in leadership. 93:33 I'm not talking about generational change, but I am talking about a new page when it 93:38 comes to democratic leadership. 93:40 And I think that is the view of the overwhelming number of Democrats outside of the Senate. 93:46 And I think there's a desire for change in how we conduct business inside the Senate. 93:51 I think to make sure that we punch through on these issues that have 70% 93:57 popular support in the country but are going to be attacked by all sorts of 94:02 special interests in Washington and an army of lobbyists, we need someone with 94:07 a record of taking on those special interests and that's true whether it 94:12 comes to trying to change our healthcare system or tax system no matter 94:16 what it is. So look one of the big you know votes that we should have had 94:20 a few years ago was to better empower working people in this country. 94:25 And that was the proact that came out of the Labor Committee, never got a vote on the floor 94:31 of the Senate. 94:32 We're also right now, I think, have a responsibility to end the war against Iran and do it as 94:39 soon as possible to help bring down prices and to help better protect our troops. 94:45 And I don't see how we can vote to spend one penny more to keep this illegal war going 94:53 and prices up. 94:55 And then finally, there are issues, and we're talking about Iran here. 94:59 And Democrats have made clear that the Trump administration should never ripped up the 95:05 JCPOA, the agreement we had with Iran back in the day, but the current majority leader 95:12 actually opposed that legislation that we say is the way forward. So look there 95:19 there are a couple there are a number of big issues beyond that and I'll just 95:23 close with these two points that Tommy. I don't think the majority leader the 95:28 Democratic leader should make it their business to try to pick fights in 95:35 in contested open Democratic primaries and I do have two colleagues in the 95:39 Senate, senators elect from Michigan and Minnesota who wouldn't be here if the current leader hadn't 95:46 sided with APAC and crypto in those races. And there's also another situation in Maine. 95:51 And finally, I think there's a consensus within the Senate Democratic Caucus that we need 95:57 more meaningful input from members and a little more democracy in the way we conduct 96:03 the Democratic caucus. So there are a whole range of areas where we'd see a difference in approach 96:09 and difference in leadership. I want to dig into a bunch of things you just said before that. 96:14 I mean, I saw you on with Jen Psaki the other night. You said in this past election, 96:19 wasn't only a rejection of Donald Trump, it was also about a call for a larger change to take 96:24 on a broken economic system that is rigged in favor of the very wealthy against working 96:28 people that is fueled by a corrupt political system. Are you saying that Senator Schumer 96:32 is part of a corrupt system or is personally corrupt in some way? 96:36 No. 96:37 Not at all. 96:37 I'm saying that we need to attack tooth and nail. 96:42 A rigged economic system, one that is rigged by powerful special interests and the billionaire 96:48 class against working people and the political corruption that fuels it, absolutely not. 96:53 I'm not suggesting that at all, but I'm suggesting that there was a huge call for 96:59 significant change in Washington, D.C. 97:03 So clearly this past election was a referendum on the Iran war. 97:08 Voters do not like the war. 97:09 They don't like what it's done to cost and to inflation. 97:11 So Democrats are gearing up for a big fight over Iran funding 97:14 even before they take power. 97:16 You've argued for using the upcoming government funding fight 97:19 to cut off funding for the Iran war and just to end it. 97:22 I am very much with you in support of that effort. 97:25 I want this war over immediately, 97:27 But I kind of want to better understand the strategy and how this would work in practice 97:31 and kind of what the end game looks like. 97:32 Is the plan basically that Democrats demand that language be in the bill or if not, they 97:39 filibuster the bill, which would shut the government down in perpetuity? 97:44 How does this work? 97:46 So, we would at the very least, Tommy, demand a vote on a provision that I'm working 97:52 on with Senators Cain and Duckworth and Bennett and others, that would effectively say that 97:59 we're not going to allow any more taxpayer dollars to be spent on offensive operations 98:06 against Iran. After all, this war was never authorized. And in fact, it's being conducted now 98:13 despite a congressional action on a war power's resolution, a concurrent resolution. 98:19 So, number one, I don't see how Democrats, after the resounding message from people across 98:25 the country, can vote for more money to fuel the war. 98:30 So what would it mean? 98:32 It would put the question to Donald Trump, whether Donald Trump wants to close down 98:38 the government and close down federal agencies in order to continue offensive operations 98:44 against Iran that are illegal and have not been authorized and are driving prices 98:48 up. I mean, prices are going to keep going up. Diesel prices, home heating oil prices, 98:53 we need to bring those prices down as soon as possible, and that means ending the war. 98:57 Speaking of the filibuster, I know you've said you're personally in favor of getting rid of it 99:01 or reforming it, but that you'd need to discuss it with the full caucus first and wouldn't 99:05 want to impose those views on the caucus. But isn't pretty much everything Democrats 99:10 want to do in the next two years downstream of getting rid of the filibuster? Because 99:15 Because otherwise, Republicans just kind of block everything? 99:18 I do think we need to use all our power to answer the call of the American people. 99:24 I think for starters, we would begin with legislation, say, for example, on the political 99:31 corruption front. 99:32 I think there's consensus that we move forward on something like banning stock trades by 99:37 members of Congress or the administration. 99:39 And let's see if we can get four Senate Republicans to join with us in that action. 99:46 At some point, we're not going to get Republicans to join with us on some of these changes we 99:52 need to root out political corruption and change the economic system. 99:55 So I do believe we need to socialize the conversation in the caucus from day one regarding 100:02 the need to end the supermajority to end a filibuster. 100:06 because as you know and I know that is an anti-democratic provision, it prohibits 100:12 the Senate from doing the will of the American people. We've never really had a 100:16 caucus discussion on this. What? How is that possible? This has been like a top 100:22 issue from progressives for years and years. The caucus is never convened to 100:26 talk about getting rid of the filibuster? We've never had a conversation in the 100:30 full caucus about the filibusters. Certainly not in a very, very, 100:35 very long time. And I think it's overdue. And what I'm saying, Tommy, is that we need 100:43 to begin to talk to our members. At what point do we recognize that Republicans are 100:52 using the filibuster to block the will of the American people? And I think it is going 100:56 to require trying to move some legislation forward, common-sense legislation, legislation 101:02 is popular with American people and for them to block it and then lay the argument for 101:08 moving forward. 101:09 But we should start now on sort of laying the groundwork for what would be triggering 101:16 in terms of changing the filibuster supermajority. 101:20 And I think that conversation needs to start now and that we need to have a plan to 101:26 put that in action if we get that kind of instruction, which I expect from Republicans 101:31 the Senate. Yeah, me too. You keep saying that there are colleagues who want to come out in 101:37 support of you to be leader, but they fear retaliation or retribution if they do so. 101:42 What does that mean exactly? What does retaliation look like in a Senate sort of capacity? 101:48 So there are obviously huge advantages for incumbency, right? The current leader right 101:54 right after the election begins to talk to folks about everything from committee assignments 102:00 to other sort of perks around the Senate, whether people get pages, they're a whole 102:06 slew of things that fall under the power of incumbency. 102:11 And there are people now who obviously are seeking committee assignments or other changes 102:16 that are fearful that if they were to publicly support me and I was not to prevail that there 102:26 could be consequences for them. 102:30 Which is one of the reasons I've said, Tommy, to everybody that I would honor if I was successful, 102:37 I would honor the agreements that they've reached with Senator Schumer so that they 102:44 they're not going to be losing anything that they were promised in this process. 102:49 Let me make one other point here. 102:51 After the last election, the Democratic caucus chose to change its rules to make sure that 102:57 there was not a leadership election before December 1st. 103:02 Why did we do that? 103:03 We did that because we thought that we should have a little room for competition 103:08 for these leadership offices because if you go from election day and just a few 103:13 days later to a leadership fight, you are essentially coronating the incumbent because 103:20 there's no time for debate and discussion in the caucus. 103:24 That's why we moved it to December 1st, and I think it's telling that there's an ongoing 103:28 effort right now, according to reports from the current leaders team, to try to short-circuit 103:36 that debate and, again, move the date forward, which tells me that they recognize the longer 103:43 this debate and discussion goes on, the stronger the agents of change are. 103:50 There were some reports that the vote could happen as soon as this week. 103:53 Is that still a possibility? 103:55 Are you able to prevent that sort of speeding up of the process? 103:57 I think there's overwhelming opposition in the caucus to speeding up the process 104:03 because it would signal that, you know, just after a big election across America 104:10 where democracy and debate had its day, that we were trying to cut short debate 104:15 and democracy in the Senate Democratic Caucus. The fact that people were 104:22 considering doing that, though, should be telling, I think, that there's an 104:26 effort to try to shut down debate. A little bit of democracy in the 104:30 Senate Democratic caucus I think is healthy. 104:33 Yeah, absolutely. 104:34 Let's talk about what reform would look like 104:36 when it comes to fundraising. 104:38 Would you commit to having the DSCC, let's say, 104:42 reject PAC money, reject lobbyist money, 104:44 reject corporate money? 104:46 And would you sort of put in place the same guidelines 104:48 for, you know, unfortunately these days, 104:50 there's always a Senate Democratic Party PAC 104:55 that kind of controls a lot of the flows of funds? 104:57 Would you put it in place for that PAC as well? 104:59 Yeah. So Tommy, I think two things are true. I think every individual has to decide for 105:04 themselves what the rules of their fundraising are, right? Like no corporate pack of money 105:10 or not. With respect to the DSCC, my view is number one, we should increase the amount 105:18 of funds raised at the DSCC through small-dollar contributions. And I think we have a great 105:24 opportunity with these new members that were just elected to increase the amount of funds 105:32 raised at the DSCC at the grassroots level. 105:35 But I would not without consulting with the caucus impose a new set of rules immediately 105:41 on the DSCC because while I am a huge proponent of reform and I have tried to lead by example, 105:49 I am also against unilateral disarmament and so I want to change the rules in the country 105:56 I'd like to get rid of since United I want to get rid of secret money in politics 105:59 I want to get rid of the Elon Musk loophole when it comes to government contractors 106:06 But I'm not for you know going within 20 I'm not for unilateral disarmament 106:11 I want to change the system and I do want to make it so the DSCC is 106:17 able to raise more grassroots funds? 106:20 I hear you on this. 106:21 I don't want to unilaterally disarm either. 106:23 I just do worry about Republicans being able to stoke cynicism and say, look, they're 106:28 taking corporate money. 106:29 They're taking PAC money. 106:30 They're taking lobbyists too. 106:31 These politicians, they're all the same. 106:34 Why does it matter? 106:35 I wonder if taking a firmer, like I know you and your personal capacity have taken 106:39 a firmer, stand on fundraising issues like this and being Senate majority leader is 106:45 challenging because you will have your own personal views, but you also have to represent 106:49 the consensus views of the caucus and kind of work with people and do politics. 106:53 But wouldn't we benefit from being seen as the party that wants to get big money out 106:58 of politics in some way, or at least corporate money or PAC money? 107:01 The short answer is yes. 107:03 I think we would benefit from that. 107:05 But I think we'd need a transition plan and I wouldn't sort of impose that rule without 107:12 consulting with my colleagues. 107:13 But, to your point, we do need to shake up a big money, a political system. 107:22 That is why I try to lead by example on that, but I do think Tommy before, you know, a new 107:28 leader imposes that rule that there needs to be a caucus discussion. 107:33 But again, I think, let me just mention these other things. 107:36 I mean, getting rid of secret money in politics, Republicans have opposed it. 107:40 Mitch McConnell has made it one of his priorities to continue to allow dark money to flow into 107:45 elections. 107:46 I think by saying we're going to close the Elon Musk loophole where if you were a private 107:54 contractor with the government, you had a contract to provide consulting services to 107:57 the U.S. government, you would not be able to contribute to federal candidates, right? 108:01 But Elon Musk is the CEO of companies that get billions and billions of dollars 108:08 of government contracts and yet he can give unlimited amounts unlike the 108:14 individual government contractor. That is a huge loophole and as you know he's 108:19 spent close to 450 million dollars in the last election. So I think there's 108:23 systemic changes we could make. I mean I am also a supporter of campaign 108:28 finance reform and and public funding of elections. I think that would save 108:33 us all the country, a lot of money at the end of the day by essentially overriding the 108:41 power of special interest money. 108:42 So I am determined to try to move that reform agenda forward. 108:48 And I think a lot of the folks, I think that was one of the big messages from the 108:52 incoming folks. 108:53 I mean, if you look at really all of them, but, you know, Talarico in Texas and others, 108:58 they were really zeroed in on that. 109:00 So I think we need to move for change and I will work with our caucus to see 109:05 what they're willing to do with respect to organizations like the DSCC. 109:10 And then also on the open elections, you said you don't want to meddle in open senate elections. 109:17 I appreciate that one. Like as someone who supported Abdul Al Sayed, I found that frustrating. 109:21 I think there were some things that were overly heavy-handed where you had the DSCC 109:25 running for or helping candidates raise money while the primary was still ongoing. 109:31 I think that is a mistake. 109:32 But also, I think Senator Schumer deserves some credit for recruiting some great candidates, 109:37 like in North Carolina, for example. 109:39 Do you really want to give up the right to try to convince great people to run for 109:44 office in states where there's an open primary? 109:47 Isn't that a little bit too far? 109:48 I think, though, Tommy, there's a distinction right between North Carolina or in Ohio 109:53 where Sherrod Brown is coming back, 109:57 where you quickly reach out and get a candidate 110:00 that does have consensus of the Democratic Party 110:03 is a very different situation 110:06 than what we witnessed in Michigan or in Minnesota. 110:10 So yeah, are you saying, 110:12 I think that the Democratic leaders should work 110:14 to have the power to try to recruit good candidates, 110:18 but that is very, very different 110:21 than jumping into already heavily contested primaries 110:26 in these open seats. 110:28 Okay, guys, so you're okay with recruiting 110:29 great candidates like a Sherrod Brown? 110:32 It's just that there was the meddling 110:33 that was too far for you when it was open. 110:35 Look, I mean, I have twice chaired the DCCC 110:38 and chaired the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee. 110:41 So yes, I'm in favor of recruiting candidates, 110:44 but I'm not in favor of a Democratic leader 110:48 jumping into a heavily contested Senate primary, like we witnessed in Michigan and Minnesota, 110:55 because I think the people of Michigan and Minnesota, the Democratic voters there, should 111:00 make those decisions free of Washington interference. 111:05 And again, in both those races, you had the Democratic leader siding with some of these 111:11 very big special interests, especially crypto, especially APAC, in both those races. 111:17 And we shouldn't be doing that. Yeah, agree with that if you win this leadership race 111:21 I think it will be in large part due to support from 111:25 Progressives does that mean that you're gonna commit to a bunch of votes on progressive priorities like Medicare for all or abolishing ice 111:32 And how would you balance? 111:35 You know those priorities and the desire to advance them 111:39 Legislatively with maybe concern from new more moderate members who don't want to be forced to be on the record 111:44 taking votes that they think maybe could be difficult for them politically and 111:48 ultimately are likely to be symbolic, be as Donald Trump is so president. 111:51 Yeah, so look, I think this election underscored what many of us have been 111:57 saying, including myself for a long time now, which is that the, you know, old sort 112:02 of Washington labels of progressive versus moderate versus conservative had 112:07 outlived their usefulness. I just say, tell me what you're for. And we've 112:12 move much more in this election to the one narrative that pulled all the Democrats together, 112:19 regardless of state, regardless of where they fell out within the Democratic Party political 112:22 spectrum, which is this idea that our economy has been rigged for a long time in favor of 112:30 powerful special interests and the billionaire class against working people fueled by political 112:35 corruption. 112:35 So, that is the umbrella under which I would lead as the Senate Majority Leader. 112:43 So let's take some examples. 112:45 Yes, I am for Medicare for All, but no, I'm not for forcing a vote on Medicare for All 112:54 in the first 100 days or forcing a vote anytime. 112:57 I think we can move there, and I think we all agree that the healthcare system 113:03 is broken. 113:04 It's become a money-making system, not a healthcare system. 113:08 It does put profits over patients. 113:10 And there are lots of things we can do from the start. 113:12 So yes, of course we should reverse the damage 113:15 that Trump did, but that's just cleaning things up. 113:19 That doesn't get us to some of the fundamental issues. 113:22 So when it comes to the healthcare system, 113:25 I do think we should move forward 113:27 on having a public option, right, 113:31 within the Affordable Care Act. 113:32 I believe that when it comes to Medicare, we should allow people 55 to 65 to buy in and 113:38 I support Andy Kim's Medicaid, Medicaid's proposal. So there are ways we can move in the right 113:44 direction and have very meaningful changes without having to go there all at once. 113:52 How do you think about the need to kind of showcase some of the new stars the party 113:57 you just elected with the need to preserve caucus unity and keep everyone together, knowing 114:04 that sometimes people can have competing priorities and those two things could be intentional. 114:07 Like how would you think about showcasing this great new crop of communicators in a 114:12 way that is maybe improved from what has been done in the past? 114:15 So I think there are two pieces to making sure that every member of the caucus, including 114:19 these new members, can meaningfully participate. 114:22 One is on communications, but one is on substance, right, ironing out differences. 114:26 And I think there is a perception in the caucus that there has not been meaningful inclusion 114:33 of members. 114:34 And I'm talking about veteran members. 114:36 And so I think there are some ways we can formalize changes to ensure that there's 114:43 not as much power concentrated solely in the majority leader and more meaningful participation 114:51 among all members. 114:53 And that should include a meaningful opportunity for new members who just come off the campaign trail to participate. 114:59 And then there's the communication piece as well. 115:01 And I do think that this is an incredibly talented group of communicators. 115:07 I think there's a lot of excitement around the country about the change. 115:11 And I do think that they should be front and center when it comes to communicating these priorities. 115:17 But again, Tommy, I do think we are united as a caucus when it comes to the economic 115:21 populism themes. 115:23 We should not underestimate the extent to what is popular in the country is unpopular 115:29 with a whole lot of special interests. 115:31 I mean, I mentioned healthcare.
Community discussion