386. A Deal With the Devil: The Murder of Kelsey Berreth
In 2016, 29-year-old flight instructor Kelsey Berreth moved from Washington to Woodland Park, Colorado, believing she had found her forever with rancher Patrick Frazee. They soon welcomed a baby girl, Kaylee. On Thanksgiving Day in 2018, Kelsey was seen on grocery store security cameras with her daughter before returning home; then she vanished. Patrick claimed she needed space and left town, a story no one who knew the devoted mom believed. Clues inside Kelsey’s condo led police across state lines, revealing a sinister plot and a web of secrets no one saw coming. To get justice for Kelsey, prosecutors had to make a controversial choice that the District Attorney himself called a "deal with the devil." Got questions about our 2028 trip to Belgium, Amsterdam and Luxembourg? Jen and Cam will be having a Zoom meeting on Thursday January 14th at 6PM Central. To register click HERE You can also email [email protected]. We hope to see you there! Thank you to our team: Listener Discretion by Edward October Music by Nico Fyffe-Vettese Editing by Jesse Fyffe-Vettese Written/researched by Lauretta Allen Sources: Murder In The Mountains: The Case Of Kelsey Berreth What Happened to Kelsey Berreth? Inside Her Brutal Murder Mum's heartbreaking two-word plea as fiancé beat her to death with baby next door - The Mirror Missing Colorado mom Kelsey Berreth: A timeline of events and what we know so far | 9news.com True Case Files: The Disappearance and Murder of Kelsey Berreth People Magazine Investigates: The Murder of Colo. Mom Kelsey Berreth Who was Kelsey Berreth? Quiet life apparently ends in tragedy - The Gazette Dec 15, 2018, page 2 - Laredo Morning Times at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Dec 22, 2018, page A7 - The Sanford Herald at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ How to Become a Flight Instructor (CFI) – Step-by-Step Guide Feb 22, 2019, page B8 - York News-Times at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Teller County, CO | Official Website Teller County, Colorado - Wikipedia May 25, 2019, page A2 - Fort Collins Coloradoan at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Nov 02, 2019, page A1 - The Times-News at Newspapers.com™ Nov 17, 2019, page A4 - The Idaho Statesman at Newspapers.com™ Nov 10, 2019, page A4 - The Idaho Statesman at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Nov 19, 2019, page A7 - The Santa Fe New Mexican at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Killer Couples-Season 14: Episode 1 Mar 27, 2021, page 3 - The Daily Sentinel at Newspapers.com™ - Newspapers.com™ Patrick Frazee's Mom Intervenes in Custody Fight | Law & Crime Patrick Frazee's ex told how his mother watched as he burned Kelsey Berreth's body | Daily Mail Online Ex-girlfriend of Patrick Frazee breaks her silence and reveals accused killer played head games | Daily Mail Online Feb 20, 2019, page A3 - Fort Collins Coloradoan at Newspapers.com™ Affidavit details events leading up to Berreth’s death Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
You May Also Like

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
MrBallen

True Crimecast
Stove Leg Media

Scared To Death
Dan Cummins, Lynze Cummins

True Crime Podcast 2025 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast
True Crime Podcast 2026

Solved Murders - True Crime Stories
RedditKing

Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings
Envision Podcast Productions

Morning Cup of Murder
Morning Cup of Murder

The Trail Went Cold
Robin Warder

Shaun Attwoods True Crime Podcast
Shaun Attwood Podcast

Have A Seat with Chris Hansen
Chris Hansen
Community discussion