0:05 Welcome to NFL Daily, where we're part of the Bang Bang Niner game. I'm Greg Rosenthal. Maybe we're not. I'm joined by Nick Shook, and we agreed on one game last week, Shook. And we got it right. It was the Niners absolutely pasting the Raiders. Maybe you didn't have 0:22 to be geniuses to see that. But you can't complain when a team covers by about 12 points or so when they're favored by nine. You went undefeated last week, Shook. 0:33 I told you, we just got to stay in the game. 3-0, including that Niners pick. You also hit the Browns covering just barely two. in new Orleans and the giants taking care of the Eagles. Think how much better our picks would be if we had just picked against the Eagles 0:47 the last seven weeks in a row. I don't think they've covered one time. The obvious picks are sometimes true. 0:52 I went one and two disappointing my first losing week in a month, but I am not discouraged. Shook. We have about the same record overall. Also I've been giving extra picks every week and I hit those two extra picks. 1:05 You even tried to convince me to take the Broncos. 1:08 Instead of the commanders, that would have been right. I also said I'm not taking the Packers because it's anti-Patriots, but that ended up being right. And so I'm still feeling like I got it going on. But the important thing is you've turned this season around. Will you continue 1:23 to take the Niners this week? That's the real question. Yes. 1:28 Also, I had to look at my list for a second. 1:30 And also there's a lot of ball game left. So those who doubted me, stay with me because that can rip off, you know, three and oh weeks like this. 1:38 Just whatever you do, don't follow Greg's hardest rule, which is that he doesn't pick against the Patriots. 1:44 Don't pick against your team. Sometimes your team's not good. 1:49 And sometimes your. 1:49 Team is in a situation in which it makes sense to pick against your team in which you should pick against your team. 1:56 You're absolutely right. And I thought about that a lot this week because I don't love this slate of games in general. I did start by asking you and maybe it wasn't your first pick, but it sounds like you're back on the 49ers this week. And why don't we 2:12 start there? Because we might be we might be going in together once again. 2:17 Let's do it. I'm ready to go in together. 2:19 You know, we, we talked about this on NFL report cross promo on Tuesday. What are the Cowboys, you know, what's their way to beat this team. And we know the Cowboys only have one way to win games, which is by trying to outscore other teams, except they're not 2:31 going to outscore this 49ers team. And it might, you know, a four and a half point favorable line that the Niners are expected to win by. I think it's still too small because it's simply going to come down to a matter of possessions. And I think the Niners are 2:44 going to convert more of their possessions into points, touchdowns and field goals. Then the Cowboys are going to be able to match them with because their defense can't stop them. 2:53 You know anybody super consistently still so. 2:56 I feel very confident about this one i don't care that it's a road game i'm riding with the niners i'm not part of bang bang niner gang i don't even know if i like that phrase i think that phrase is kind of annoying it's a little uh not 3:09 corny but just uh it's been around it was in a chalkboard for me. 3:12 Yeah okay riding with them fair All fair points. I'm a little worried. They're short in the secondary. Diamon or Lenore and Renata green this week, at least early in the week in practice. And so we'll see if they return. 3:27 Mike Evans, not expected to be back. Debo Samuel will. 3:30 I think everything you said was on point. I do not believe in the Cowboys defensive improvement. You know, I, you played the Colts. Congratulations. The Cowboys, only problem I have is the 49ers defense has been just a little 3:47 big play dependent, like turnovers. They've had some game changing plays. 3:51 They will give up yards and the Cowboys rushing attack showed some signs. Again, it was against the Colts, but over the last few weeks of being a little more consistent, I think that's how you shorten a game against San Francisco. 4:05 So this is a rare case where I don't think the Cowboys mind shortening the game. Can they get it into a low possession game like you met and score enough on this 49ers defense? It's possible. But ultimately, I think what you said was right in a shootout in 4:21 an offense first game. My number one question when you play the 49ers this year, like, do you have a defense that can give them any problems at all? That is going to worry Kyle Shanahan completely. and Brock Purdy, the way that they're playing, you have to have a 4:36 better than average defense that can throw some different looks at you. Like even Atlanta, who at least can come up with a game plan dependent week that like might scramble you for a couple of big plays. And the Cowboys, the answer is no. And so I think they're scoring on, 4:50 you know, 70% of their drives and they're getting touchdowns on a lot of them. Yep. 4:54 I agree. 4:54 And I, I think about that Falcons game, you know, I think the Niners came out of the buy and folks were like, well, what just happened against the Falcons? 5:01 It was like splash plays. Like they got turnovers. They forced property into a couple of interceptions. They were able to do what most defenses haven't done. And it's as simple as that. I don't think the Cowboys are going to do it. 5:11 Yeah. And, I mentioned it on our preview show. It is just underrated how fresh and awesome Christian McCaffrey looks this year and how George Kittle is now full Kittle. 5:24 And I'm just not taking that for granted. I'm not taking Trent Williams for granted. Like all their best players, including Fred Warner. are playing at their peak and we'll see if Nick Bosa can get there. But that to me has been the key with all the injuries. It's 5:37 the two guys that you maybe were most concerned about that have stayed healthy. So I'm writing who I think is the best team in the league against a below average team. Who is your second pick since we agree on the first one once again? 5:49 Going in a completely opposite direction here because I just think that recency bias is starting to creep into some of these lines and I am going to go with the Panthers plus two and a half at the Saints. 6:02 I think that on their surface, just looking at them, taking full stock of them without considering opponent. I think the Panthers are a better, better football team than the Saints. 6:11 Do I believe that their defense is capable of, of competing with most teams? No, but I think that the way that they played last week was valiant. Their offense showed me that they can kind of consistently produce. And I think against the Saints team, it's riding high after 6:26 a win against the Browns whose offense was, largely anemic with Shador Sanders at quarterback save for the final four minutes of regulation, that they're going to do a better job than the Browns did. And I think it'll come down to something as simply as that. I'll take them 6:39 as the underdog on the road because I think they win this game. 6:42 And I think they win this game. 6:43 By a touchdown, if not more, despite the fact that it's an NFC South game. 6:47 That's just how I feel. 6:48 I feel like the Panthers offensively can put up enough points for the Saints to struggle to respond. Although I did see some signs from Tyler Shuck against the Browns in that final fourth quarter. And over time, I was like, oh, he's kind of getting back on track. The thing is, 7:00 is when you play the Browns, people think of them as this great defense. They have not been in recent weeks. 7:04 And I think the Panthers will hold up better against the Saints. 7:06 Than the Browns did. 7:08 You're putting me in a tough spot here, Shook, because like I said, we're on the same team. We want winners. 7:13 I was glad to see you go 3-0 last week. 7:18 I had written down New Orleans minus two and a half. 7:20 Do we do a clash this week? Come on, come on. 7:23 But then we're going 500 between the two of us. 7:26 I don't care. 7:26 I don't care. Sometimes we got to have conflict. It's good for the show. It's good to keep people entertained. 7:31 Let's do it. Okay. 7:34 Here's the thing. This was a week where I don't love a lot of picks. I settled on my three picks. 7:40 I'll mention my extra picks in the end, but I couldn't quite get there. Although bias is having a lot of, it's being too big of a factor here and I'll get to that. But I do believe the Saints are going to win this game. I'm going to take the 7:54 minus two and a half. I like a division matchup where we have some history. It's a young coaching staff for New Orleans. What did they do best last year? 8:03 Beat the Panthers 2-0. Outgained them both times once by a lot where the defense really shut down Bryce Young. 8:10 It was at a time in the season where Bryce Young was playing pretty well. The Panthers actually had a winning record at the time and the Saints were buried with two wins. They swept that season series last year in a year where you know, the saints weren't amazing. 8:22 That's just like a little extra boost to what I already was feeling, which is, I think the saints came out of their bi-week and did some things I wanted to see out of them. They ran the ball, they stopped the run. I think they, messed up that game 8:36 to even get into overtime against Cleveland. I just don't think Carolina is a great team right now. I, I, okay, go on. 8:45 That's why the recency bias leaks into this for me, because I give them credit for coming out of their buy and looking like a better football team, but I know who the Browns are like intimately know who the Browns are and the Browns cannot run the football. And 8:55 since they lost Malik, they haven't been able to stop the run. So I think both of those things are fool's gold when you look at the saints overall. And that's why they come back in the opposite direction. 9:03 Why the Panthers win this game. 9:04 So the Panthers also are getting some good news on the injury front. Jalen Phillips back at practice. Damian Lewis, their guard, who's their best player on the offensive line, also back at practice. Those are two of their very best players. And that was part of the reason why 9:19 I don't think the Panthers have been nearly as good. 9:22 But they are short in the secondary. Still, still don't have JC horn. Still don't have Mike Jackson and Jordan Tyson was out there last week. I know he fumbled the ball, but otherwise he looked like he's ready to go and is going to have an increasing role. I 9:36 think it makes their passing game a little more dynamic. 9:39 And then their defensive coordinator who they brought in Todd wash, who comes from the Seattle tree. Like he just ran a very vanilla coverage all last week, cover three, Didn't do much. They just wanted to stop the run. Okay, you can go stop Adric Estime. I think Tyler Shuck 9:58 with these receivers is... actually better situated than Bo Nix and where the Broncos are at to take advantage of a very vanilla pass defense. 10:08 And I know this week. 10:11 I don't think it will be like, this is what Todd watched. This is what they do. I think it'll be vanilla. I don't think they have a lot of talent. 10:18 I'm taking the saints at home. Minus two and a half. 10:20 We're going up against each other. Let's do it. 10:22 I like it. 10:23 A lot of trash talk in the office this week. 10:26 How about that? Like we, you can come intimidate me from your desk way down the hall. 10:32 Oh, I'm going to get on Photoshop. 10:34 I'm going to have the art folks make some sort of harassing images to just hang right over your monitor. 10:40 Oh, don't worry. 10:40 This is going to hurt me too because this is my game. We assign out the games and this is one of my games early. So I will be watching what... 10:49 Is inevitably going to be a back and forth, ugly NFC South game that I do feel good enough about. 10:55 I just, I believe in Tyler Shuck. I believe in him more than Bryce Young. I really do. All right, let's go to your third pick. We've had two, you know, similar games here. We're on the opposite side though of Saints Panthers. What's your third pick? Tell me if you 11:08 got how your thought process was. 11:10 I kind of went, I had a bit of a Greg Rosenthal week where I actually looked at some of these lines and made my list a little longer than usual. 11:17 Okay. 11:17 Which is concerning because in the weeks that you like seven or eight games, I really only like like four. 11:22 And this week I like six. And you don't like very many, which means I'm probably doing something wrong. 11:26 It doesn't matter. Neither one of us are doing well. 11:28 You always like more when you're on a winning streak. 11:30 And Shook is feeling himself after his three and a half. Sure. 11:33 We'll go with that. I'm actually torn between a couple of games. Okay. 11:36 And I have a third that I'm going to move away from. And go in an opposite direction. Somehow I picked every team I picked is on the road this week, which does not bode well for me. 11:49 It's fine. It's fine. Give me the candidates because maybe I'll pick a different one based on what you pick. 11:54 OK, I'm going to go. 11:55 My third pick is going to be Chiefs minus three and a half at the Falcons. 11:59 Not one of mine. So I'll hear your other picks afterwards. 12:02 Okay. 12:03 Um, and I, the reason that I'm going to choose, this is a little bit out of fear. I'm being a little bit conservative here. And I acknowledge that, that I'm living in my fears. I'm like what Mike Tomlin likes to do. Uh, I'm going to go chiefs at 12:13 Falcons minus three and a half, just because I believe that, that the, the overall success of the chiefs offense can carry over from one week to the next. I think the, the, the way that they've been able to throw the football 12:24 in the last, at least, especially the second half against the jets, getting Kenneth Walker, uh, especially incorporated in the passing game helps him and helps this offense kind of get on track. I like what I saw from Steve 12:35 Spagnuolo's defense last week. That's the first time where I've really seen, oh, look at them making plays and really shutting down an offense. 12:42 They hadn't done that much this season. 12:43 I think that Michael Penix and the Falcons are an ideal offense to try to shut down if you get after Michael Penix. Now, the key will be stopping Bajon Robinson, which is always a tall task. Yet, even when he has a decent day, it hasn't really factored into the 12:57 outcome for the Falcons as of late. I think the Chiefs are the better football team, and I think they're capable of going in there post-trade deadline and and taking down the Falcons. I am curious to see how much Josh Downs will get incorporated into this offense. Having just 13:09 been there this week after the trade, if he could play any sort of role, I think it only makes them better offensive because they're still too lenient on their tight ends. But I think that this is one of those, like, this is a culture team. This is a team that's 13:20 coming off of a win that seemed to kind of figure things out. Can you go do it in Atlanta? 13:25 I think they can. 13:26 And fade NFC South out of division in general, especially against quality opposition. Look, the Chiefs right now are ninth in DVOA, fourth in offense, 11th in defense, Atlanta 20th in DVOA, 21st in offense. So the chiefs have an 13:44 advantage when, when their defense ranked ninth is on the field or ranked 11th and then 10th in defense where the chiefs still have an advantage. I don't think people realize how efficient this chiefs offense has been. It's not 13:57 fun to watch, but they're getting enough plus 10 yard plays in the passing game. Like more than you would expect. 14:02 A lot of explosive plays, a lot of explosive runs, a lot of explosive screens. And I do think that, Falcons defense has taken on some water lately, not as dynamic. 14:13 They're a game plan team where they can show up in a given week. But overall, I think the lack of talent showing up. I really like this pick. Atlanta is also coming back from Munich. I probably should have written it down as one of my options. OK, I'm 14:27 going to go to my third pick and then we'll just we'll shoot around some extras afterwards. I have to go with my gut. And maybe it is recency. Maybe it is the pressure you've put on me this week. 14:41 I just don't believe in this Patriots team being equal to legit Super Bowl division contenders. I do believe the Packers are and were in that category. Said it going into last week. It made no sense to me that the Patriots were favored by three and a half. I 14:59 feel the same this week in Munich that the lines are only favored by two and a half. And I've had Nick shook in my head all week being like, you can't just have these rules. You can't, you gotta let your bias go. And if I happen to be wrong, 15:14 you know, that'll, that'll pain me deeply. So I'm in a no win scenario or I'm in a no lose scenario, depending on how you look at it. Cause the Patriots will have won if they, if they can, if they can cover here, but, but here's why. This Patriots team 15:28 is just so far from being healthy right now. I do think they'll risk like in general, a team that plays their very worst game like they did against Jacksonville earlier this year often plays one of their better games afterwards. 15:40 You respond. It's sort of how the NFL works. So I think they'll be much more competitive this week. But I think the Lions have added layers, as Jordan pointed out on a previous show, to their offense each and every week. They're adding elements to their running game. They're 15:53 adding elements to their passing game. I think their offensive line is in the best place they've been all year. 15:58 And I think their defense is in the best place it's been all year. I think this is a steadily improving team that some of the season-long metrics that include the first month, I'm throwing them out because the offense even, I think, has gotten better. And the defense, I think, 16:14 is significantly better. I just think these are two teams in different places right now. The Patriots very much in the middle of the NFL. like not great vibes, not a healthy team at a lot of key positions. They might get AJ Brown back, which is a positive for 16:30 sure for them, but I don't think it's enough for them to win this game. I think it'll be a tough game, but I think the lions win by about a touchdown and cover that two and a half points. 16:38 Okay. 16:38 See, this is where we defer a little bit. And this is one of the ones that I had. It's something that I liked. And the, after listening to you talk about it, I do agree with you largely, which is why I'm glad that I didn't go with it. 16:47 Cause I was on the other side with the Patriots plus two. 16:49 And a half. 16:50 Primarily because what you said about getting, you know, destroyed and then bouncing back the next week. Yeah, they just had an offensive bomb dropped on them by the Packers. 17:00 Christian Gonzalez's worst game of his career. And Drake May throws three interceptions, which gives the Packers those extra possessions to then, you know, build that lead. At one point in that game, it was still 24 to 14. I don't think the Patriots are that far off. Do I 17:14 think that they're a good team and a Superbowl contender? No, I mean, they're a decent team. I think they're a middle of the pack team, but I feel as though the Lions recent. 17:22 Success, I can't yet fully trust it. 17:26 And, you know, they had a good game against the Vikings, obviously the Vikings offense, not a type of team that you, you know, shut down and then think we've suddenly figured out. 17:36 Our defense Packers. That's a good win. 17:38 Yeah. They beat the Packers, which was nice. 17:41 And then they struggled mightily in Miami against the Dolphins. 17:46 Very similar. Having watched both of those games, the Patriots in Miami and Detroit in Miami played like the exact same game. So that's interesting. 17:54 And so I feel like if the Lions are going to run into a situation in which they have difficulties, it might be against a team that. can at times play scrappy defense like the Dolphins did. Right now, I would probably respect the Dolphins defense, at least for effort 18:08 and discipline more than the Patriots, which you can tell with Mike Rabel's sideline expressions every Patriots game. He's very displeased with the way his team is playing. But I feel as though. 18:18 Been a little too good. The results have been a little too good for the lions as of late. I feel like maybe this is a bit of a step back. 18:23 The international aspect of it, I think changes things. 18:26 Um, but yeah, I. 18:28 Think this is, uh, I'm glad I didn't choose this game. 18:32 I don't know what this game is now. 18:34 Yeah, I'm not really going to enjoy this one now no matter what. That's what I'm guaranteeing. Life is too short to do that, and yet I just did it. 18:43 The other ones I thought about, Jets plus 7.5, that's a lot of points. But the Bills every week just find a way to prove that they're a little even better than you think. We'll see. I think the Jets can score some points on the Bills, and so 7.5 18:55 is a lot to give away. Decided not to go there. 18:58 And then the one where the bias is coming in, and this is where... I'm almost tempted even right now to switch it for the Patriots because then I won't go through the emotional gambit. Bengals minus three and a half. 19:13 Not getting swept against the Steelers. I believed in the Steelers all year. They're coming off a bye. Cincinnati has a bad rest situation. There's a lot of factors going against Cincinnati. And I've been against Cincinnati a lot this year. 19:25 but I don't think they're getting swept against the Steelers. 19:27 I just, it's just not going to happen. I just think the way that they're set up, their strengths can, can beat the Steelers weaknesses on the outside. And I do think they cover three and a half ultimately in Cincinnati. 19:40 It's so funny that you bring that up because that was going to be my third pick. And then I pull off of it to the chiefs because of the exactly what you just said. I looked at it initially and I thought plus three and a half, I could see them losing by a field goal i can see 19:51 them winning this game and i thought do they how often do the steelers sweep a division opponent it's in cincinnati they're on fire offensively right now would this be a bad outcome for pittsburgh you know i've had a little bit of time off uh Yeah, I think I would side. 20:07 With you on that one. 20:07 Now that I look at it, I think I have a lot of faith in the Bengals. I think this is one of those games where they could make a statement to the rest of the league by taking care of business in a tight divisional race. 20:16 Yeah, I feel pretty good about that one. I feel a little better about the Lions. And so I will stick with my Lions pick Detroit minus two and a half as my third pick. But I feel good as my fourth pick. And we write these down. Last week, 20:31 I got my fourth and fifth picks right. Unfortunately, for the official record, did not get the third. I will take the Bengals, you know, minus three and a half. 20:38 Just throwing that out there for people who aren't... Stuck in a box like us having to only pick three games every week, but it's a box that we constructed shook. 20:47 And I think it makes for the best show. 20:49 It's made of hopes and dreams, which is why my fourth pick would be. 20:54 Let's get wild. Greg Vikings plus three and a half at the Packers. 20:58 Okay. 20:59 I'm with you. I thought I looked at that too. 21:01 If I had to pick a side for that, I, I agree to me that now that they have a quarterback, uh, Yeah, the hook gets me. Where if it was three points, if it was two and a half points, I'd be like, eh, let's stay away. But that defense plus a quarterback, there's 21:17 not many teams I wouldn't take three and a half against. 21:20 Like maybe if they were. 21:23 Hmm. I'm trying to think like in Buffalo, I wouldn't love that if they were in Seattle, maybe I wouldn't love that, but ultimately in green Bay, like that's close enough to a toss up. I'm with you. 21:32 And there's no tape to study for staff because Kirk Cousins is just showing up and walking into an offense, you know, as well. 21:39 I like it. Go study the 2023 tape where he was lighting it up before he tore his Achilles and then, uh, He's been all over the league since then. Good job by you, Shook. I wish I could wish you to go 3-0 again, but that would mean that I got 21:53 one wrong. Unfortunately, we can't both go 3-0 this week, but let's go 5-1 combined. Good luck to everyone out there taking our advice. Good luck to everyone listening to our show. The next time you will hear from us will be... sunday night myself nick shook jordan rodrigue it 22:11 is the week 10 recap show we'll have the munich game we'll have kirk cousins's return and yes we are past midway of the season we're starting fresh here our picks are going to be winners the rest of the way we'll see you sunday
Community discussion