The Menopause Transition and Epilepsy

Dr. Katie Krulisky talks with Dr. Kelsey Smith about the impact of menopause on women with epilepsy, including therapeutics and clinical management during midlife.

Read the related article in Neurology®Clinical Practice.

Disclosures can be found at Neurology.org.

Podcast Transcript:

Dr. Jose Merino: This is Jose Merino, Editor-in-Chief of the Neurology Family of Journals. The Neurology Podcast provides practical information to neurologists and other clinicians to help them provide better care for their patients. Thanks for listening and have a great week.

Dr. Katie Krulisky: Hello, and welcome to this episode of the Neurology Podcast. This is Katie Kruliski from the VA and University of Utah in Salt Lake City, Utah. Today, I have the pleasure of talking with Kelsey Smith. She's a neurologist and epileptologist at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota. We will be discussing her recent paper published in the Neurology Clinical Practice Journal titled The Menopause Transition and Epilepsy: A Focus on Therapeutics. Welcome, Kelsey, and thank you for joining us.

Dr. Kelsey Smith: Thank you so much for having me. I'm really excited to be here today to talk about this paper and this really important topic.

Dr. Katie Krulisky: Yes. Your paper highlighted a staggering statistic, that women spend approximately 40% of their lives post-menopause. That shook me when I was reading this for a presentation on management of women in epilepsy. Being a woman, I felt totally blindsided by the statistic. I've never thought about it this way. I feel like so much of the emphasis of our clinical practice in epilepsy is choosing the right medications for pregnancy. And there is a lack of information and focus on women in perimenopause and post-menopause, even though a much larger percentage of the lifespan is spent in this phase. Let's go ahead and start with the clinical scenario. A 45-year-old woman with focal epilepsy is having some symptoms attributed to perimenopause and is interested in pursuing hormonal treatments. As her epileptologist, what is your approach to counseling her based on the current available data?

Dr. Kelsey Smith: And when it comes to patients like this, it's a very important topic. And the first thing is that it really requires both an individualized and multidisciplinary approach. So I think first as an epileptologist, I want to understand all I can about her epilepsy, what the current seizure control is, what the current therapy is, what the epilepsy's been like over other life stages if she's had epilepsy no earlier, to understand how seizures may have been during menstrual cycles to know if there's kind of a hormonal driver of seizures that's been noticed through the lifespan. And then also I really want to understand about her menopause symptoms. What are the symptoms that are really bothering her that she's hoping to start the hormonal therapy for? And are those symptoms things like vasomotor symptoms or sleep disturbances? And are those actually also influencing her current seizure control? If the vasomotor symptoms are waking her up at night and she's not getting good rest, is this lowering the seizure threshold and actually driving worse seizure control? Understanding all of this background's really important. And then to discuss with her what the data is about menopausal hormonal therapy and how it's related to epilepsy, how that data is really limited. And so we don't have a lot of data to go off of to provide counseling in this scenario. And all the studies that have really looked at this topic are really quite old, over 20 years old and have not used the same formulations of menopause hormonal therapy we use nowadays. And a lot of these studies didn't even use the anti-seizure medicines that we use nowadays. It's important to work with a patient like this and really let her know that despite the limited data, that epilepsy itself should not be a strict contraindication to considering menopausal hormonal therapy, but there are special considerations that we would need to think about, especially interactions between the hormones and anti-seizure medications and that she would probably require close following throughout using menopause hormonal therapy. I would also collaborate closely with a women's health expert so they can help us decide what the best hormonal therapy may be if it's indicated to treat her symptoms.

Dr. Katie Krulisky: So a lot of these patients will ask, "When looking at hormones, I want to know where my hormonal levels are at now." Are you ordering their hormone levels?

Dr. Kelsey Smith: Yeah, this is a common question that patients ask and I've also been working some with the women's health experts here at Mayo. And as we've worked on papers and things, it's not standard of care to draw these levels even throughout perimenopause and into menopause because of the fact that menopause is a clinical diagnosis. And also during perimenopause, there can be such wide fluctuations in hormonal levels. And so it's difficult to know what to make of different values and how that would influence clinical care. So overall, I'm typically not ordering hormonal levels, but would work with a women's health expert and if they though it would be helpful in a specific scenario, then definitely would consider it.

Dr. Katie Krulisky: So on a very basic level, I've come to understand that in general, estrogen can make you more likely to have a seizure. Progesterone is protective. With that in mind, it sounds like you're not saying completely no to addition of estrogen in the hormone replacement therapy. Is that accurate?

Dr. Kelsey Smith: Yeah, that is accurate. One of the things I learned by putting this paper together is that although some direct comparison of estrogen levels is difficult, but overall, usually actually estrogen that's used in menopausal hormonal therapy, the estrogen is less than the estrogen in oral contraceptive pills. And we don't see epilepsy as a contraindication to considering oral contraceptive pills, although obviously we need to take into consideration interactions with anti-seizure medications and things like that. But I don't think overall it should be a broad contraindication to considering the hormonal therapy. During perimenopause, the endogenous hormonal levels can fluctuate very significantly and there could potentially be an influence of seizure control based on those fluctuations. At least in theory, even menopausal hormonal therapy could potentially help with some of those fluctuations and could potentially be helpful, especially if some of the symptoms associated with menopause, like the sleep disturbances, like the vasomotor symptoms are actually making seizure control worse by reducing the seizure threshold.

Dr. Katie Krulisky: That's a really good thing to keep in mind because there's a lot of fear-based decision-making surrounding women's health and seizure medications because a lot of that, we see a lot of that in pregnancy, right? We also see a lot of that in perimenopause and menopause. I think historically we've though, oh, estrogen is dangerous. You shouldn't have any exogenous estrogen. And then it seems like women are suffering the consequences from exactly like you've pointed out, very limited actual data. So just for review, what is the actual data that we're extrapolating this from?

Dr. Kelsey Smith: Yeah. So there's a few older studies from the late 1990s and then early 2000s that are mostly observational studies asking women with epilepsy how did their seizures change with menopause hormonal therapy and things like that. And then there's one randomized controlled trial. It was published I believe aroun