0:00 Welcome home, NLP fam. This is Angela Rye. You're about to hear an episode of Cite Your Source, a show produced and presented by Native Lamb Pod. On Cite Your Source, we fact-check the headlines and debunk viral news. We say we are your two-step verification on all the BS. New 0:16 episodes drop Wednesday at 9 p.m. Eastern on Cite Your Source's YouTube channel. If you're listening and wondering what our sources are, I encourage you to check out the video where we cite our sources in real time and we 0:28 have our sources in show notes. Thank you. Enjoy the episode. 0:35 Welcome to Cite Your Source. I'm your host, Angela Rye. 0:38 We are your two-step verification on all the BS. Let's talk about gender. Why has gender become such a point of division? Today's show is who profits from the gender war? 0:50 And can we recover? Please welcome our experts. We have Shaheen McLaurin, licensed clinical social worker, therapist, public educator, and podcast host. Soraya Nadia McDonald, culture critic, journalist, and publisher 1:03 of Soraya.press. John Graham Jr., relationship advisor, founder, and CEO of Upfront Marital Technologies Incorporated. And Roxy Beckles, content creator, writer, and host of That Black Catholic Chick, to which my mom should probably subscribe. The gender gap at the ballot 1:21 box is as old as me. The culture war was declared by name in 1992. The thing that is actually new is this. Starting around 2015, young women moved sharply left and young men did not move at all. Everything we're discussing today sits on top of that. We will 1:38 be addressing three claims. One, gender has been politicized as a distraction. Two, trans and non-binary people have always existed. Three, traditional gender roles no longer exist. Thank you to our partners at Onyx Impact for supporting our research and last week, 1:56 I had so much fun, y'all. I'm still serving as your resident fact checker. If any panelist stretches the truth, oh, the audience liked it too. If any panelist stretches the truth or shares some data that sounds a little off, I will hit the buzzer and you will hear this sound. 2:11 Then they will have to cite their source. Today, I want to test the first claim with our incredible audience. 2:32 Has gender been used as a source of distraction for us? 2:36 How many of you all agree with that? Okay, let me go to the young lady in the back here. 2:41 You think it's been a distraction? I want to hear why you think so. 2:44 Yeah, I do think that gender has been a distraction away from a lot of other issues that are at play and powers that are at be. to distract us from things that are actually, you know, dystopian and concerning and making gender the top thing. And what this administration 3:14 is saying about like the trans community is just a distraction from the real people who are making this world worse. 3:23 Thank you. Thank you. Well, The data shows transgender and non-binary people constitute about 1.6% of all U.S. 3:33 Adults. 3:33 Yet, conversations on gender fuel online debates and are often touted as one of the nation's most pressing issues. But why all the fear-mongering? To make sure we're all on the same page, here are the definitions. Trans is an 3:47 umbrella term for anyone whose internal gender identity does not align with the sex they were assigned at birth. Non-binary is a gender identity for people whose gender does not fit exclusively into the male or female binary. Most recently 4:02 at a Michigan rally, Trump said rapper Nicki Minaj had quote, one hell of a beautiful ass, end quote. And when Nicki Minaj got to the mic, got her ass to the mic, here's what she had to say. 4:15 And we're not gonna give up because we want our children to grow up in a place where we can be proud of. We don't want our children to be bombarded with sex changes, right? We don't want that for our children. We want people to leave the children alone, 4:31 leave them out of it, right? 4:33 Thanks to her colored contacts. Now we're going to hear from the experts. Why do you all think this discourse on gender continues to be so prevalent in today's society? 4:43 Frankly, it's just a manipulation tactic if you ask me to distract people from real issues, similar to what someone in the audience said. Like you said, 1%, close to 1% of people over 13 identify as trans or non-binary. And yet, 5:01 I think it's somewhere around 600, the ACLU tracked that since 2024, around 600 new anti-LGBTQ laws have been kind of proposed. And I think it goes to show, despite people having their major priority when they go to the polls being the economy, that the amount of money that 5:24 a lot of these conservative politicians kind of funnel into anti-trans advertising, it showcases that it's just simply to bait and switch and to distract people from the real issues. 5:35 History shows that when conservatives are in office, that the economy suffers because And I think it's easier for them to, and when I say manipulative, I want to be even clearer. 5:46 It's easier for them to get people to react by attacking something that's so personal to everyone. Everybody experiences gender to some extent. And when the conservatives and people on the right can have people feel riled up by using 6:04 emotionally charged language, like protecting the children, because everybody's been a child before. 6:08 Most people care about kids. 6:10 But the language centered around 1% of the population. It really goes to show that there's an overemphasis, even down to the amount of money they're spending in advertising dollars. 6:21 Since 2024, and I. 6:23 Do, I fact check this, it's around closer to $ 200 million that they spent on talking about trans people in sports, attacking trans people in their advertisements. This is the conservatives and people who lean towards the right. That is almost 6:39 five times the amount of money that they've spent on the economy and talking points and ads for elections. And it really highlights that our minds are worried about the wrong thing. Our politicians kind of steer us in the 6:52 wrong direction. People who are really worried about real issues, like people being able to survive and eat and feed their families, don't really care about what the next person is doing. 7:05 Yeah. And I think there's a lot of truth to that. 7:07 I'm curious from the rest of you, who's benefiting from this? 7:11 Like if there are 200 plus million dollars being spent, the reality of it is, is that's not just the fault of the Republican Party who's been pushing these ads is working. That's what that number tells you, because there's actually been an increase from 2024 where they spent at 7:26 least 215 million dollars on anti-trans television advertisement. So who really is to blame and who benefits from this divide? 7:35 Well, I think part of what we're seeing is that historically, stirring up this sort of panic is a key tool of authoritarian politics, particularly when it comes to nosing in on a group and scapegoating them and saying, these people 7:55 are different and these people are the reasons for whatever happens. 8:01 unpleasantness that you're experiencing in your life, whether that happens to be financial or emotional or cultural. It's easy to pick out a group and then say, you see all this anxiety that you have about things changing too fast is the result of and the fault of this particular 8:24 group of people. And, you know, I've seen this happen over and over again in my lifetime. You know, I remember when George W. Bush was running for reelection. And at the time, same-sex marriage was the big calling card 8:42 for sending panic, like, throughout the country. So queer people have often, I think, been the target of this kind of blame that is really undue. And if you go back, say, further in history, particularly when we think about the last time that there was really the sort of rise of 9:04 authoritarian and fascistic politics during the 1930s and 40s, establishing really rigid binaries and gender roles was very much a part of that project. It becomes part of a bigger project of setting a kind of nationalism, right, that says 9:28 we are going to reward like a very narrow cishet construction of what it means to be, you know, an ideal citizen to the point that, you know, we saw the Nazi government of Germany literally offering German women, like they were incentivizing them to have more children So this 9:54 always sort of comes back to issues of control and scapegoating. 9:59 The other fact that I think is important to point out is across 49 states in 2025, more than a thousand anti-trans bills were introduced into state legislature. 10% of them at least were passed, 126 passed, 701 introduced in 2024. 10:11 So again, there's something about this that where people see 10:19 a wedge. They see an opportunity. There's data that our research partner, Onyx Impact Pool, that says within 20 minutes of creating online accounts on TikTok, they steer boys and girls into sharply divergent online environments, right? So there is 10:34 a wedge that is being developed. You all are working in some ways to combat some of that wedge. Talk about why it's important to bring people together, particularly in the way you're trying to do it, John, especially in this very tense environment where politics is at stake? 10:50 Yeah, I appreciate the question. I think it's very much so that distraction is the lead, division is the outcome. 10:59 When you have people focused on issues that aren't germane to their day-to-day experience, but become the dominant psychological forefront of their of their lived experience, they're easier to manipulate and control. I think you used the perfect word, Shane. 11:14 That manipulation is ultimately serving an outcome either legislatively, economically, a lot of times. And historically, when we've seen this impact black community, going back as far as post-emancipation, the pathologization and the demonization of black men as the prominent 11:41 threat to dominant group men has created narratives that have put black men in particular in a negative light socially. 11:51 That has downstream impacts all the way up through to the mid 60s where policy shifts around who could be in the household to receive benefits. mass incarceration policies, wars on drugs, crime, and poverty, all of those things to 12:07 remove stable households as a means of support and stability. 12:13 And I think that's one of the things that has not changed, and oddly enough is not talked about much. 12:19 The gender war conversation now that the algorithms are amplifying is more so the divide between black men and black women, but not talking about the historical underpinnings that have gotten us to this point over the last 50, 60 years. 12:33 Yeah, Roxy, I want to come to you because amidst this gender divide, this gender war that is at place, you are leaning into traditional values. That doesn't create much space for what I think somewhat fills a spectrum or 12:48 a growing acceptance for what has become non-binary and trans. 12:52 So talk about your place in this conversation right now and why it's important to lean in traditionally. 12:58 Absolutely. I mean, I think that one of the things I want to start off with is that when we talk about this idea of who benefits and is there a political divide, I think that we should definitely look at the fact that, yes, these things that are being 13:13 brought up are important, but at the same time, we shouldn't minimize what other concerns. Like gender is important. Gender is specific to who we are as people. but we can also care about those issues as well as issues of the economy, issues that affect all. 13:27 Of us and how we live. 13:29 And at the core of it, as I'm listening to everyone, and I get and I understand exactly what you mean, but I feel like what happens a lot of times is that one side is always demonizing the other, as though it's like only one side that's kind of like 13:46 stoking the flames. When you look at the fact that The people who are identified as trans, you said it's about 1% or so, a little over that. That's such a small amount of people. But we're all being dragged into this heightened, emotionally heightened conversation that at the end 14:03 of it, it's getting to an ontological question of who we are as human beings and how that affects everything that we do. So it affects education. It affects jobs. 14:11 It affects health. So from that standpoint, I kind of wanted to lean into that a little bit. Now, as far as traditional roles are concerned, I question what is the definition of traditional? Like whose definition are we working off of? What country, what time in society are we 14:29 working off of when it comes to traditional? This traditional could mean something to someone else. Is it a 1950s traditional? 14:36 Is it traditional that goes back to biblical times? Is it traditional? What is traditional? 14:40 Well, that's our third claim. So we're not even there yet. No, we're not there yet. I want to just stay here for a moment on the fact that gender has been politicized to create this divide. And I think if part of what you discuss, you can hit the buzzer if 14:56 I'm wrong, but part of what you discuss is, you know, the importance of these, you know, there are, it's male and female. God created male and female. There's a binary option to you, which essentially erases people that are having 15:08 a different existence and have for centuries, right? If we look at the data. So I'm curious to know where, like, what do you do with people who don't see themselves as in that binary construct? 15:21 Absolutely. 15:21 This is a beautiful question, actually. I mean, and again, it gets down to that question of who we are as people. And from my standpoint, representing that Christian type of ideology, we are each created in the image and 15:32 likeness of God. And that doesn't mean male, female, black, white. 15:35 But what is the essence of God? God is love. 15:37 That means that we were created by love, for love, and to give love. That's what that means. And from that heart there, every human person has a dignity that must be respected at all times. Now, as far as male and female, there is a true anthropological and physiological 15:56 difference between man and woman physically that cannot be ignored, because that would be ignoring an objective truth. But how someone feels in that body, how someone feels in that expression, this is where I. 16:08 I'm going to have to fact check you on that. Yeah, please, absolutely. 16:11 Part of the reason why I would ask you to cite your source is, there are different biological ways in which people are born. Would you acknowledge that? 16:21 Are you, are you talking about intersex? Are you doing, are you bringing that into the equation? Are we just talking about male? 16:25 I think you just brought it into the equation, which means that your last point is not true. 16:30 However. 16:30 Okay. 16:31 So let's have a, okay. So yeah, exactly. You got it. 16:35 Listen, I'm running on no sleep here, so I'm going to try to speak it out. 16:38 All right. Um, sure. 16:40 But how, what percentage of people are actually intersex? 16:43 Right. 16:44 So it's like what happens in these conversations that we bring in, again, a small amount, a small number of people. 16:49 But small doesn't mean non-existent. And I think as black people in particular, shout out to y'all, as black people in particular, we can't afford to do that because it's a form of erasure. So even if it's small, it 17:01 doesn't mean non-existent. It doesn't mean they don't, as you said, God is love. So it doesn't mean they don't have the right to exist. We can't simply say, you know, God only created male and female and there is no exception to that rule. That's Now, true. 17:15 This is true. And this is where I think the misunderstanding in this happens, because the first thing, OK, if there is a let's just talk on the binary of male and female. Let's just go on that for now. OK, we can also acknowledge there are people who are born 17:30 that are intersex. And guess what? Their value and dignity matters, too. 17:35 And you don't get to erase that. You have to respect that. Now, when we're dealing with someone who, again, you're a male if you express as female or you feel that that's what you or vice versa. And we're talking about someone who has the physiological and biological instruments 17:51 of what that specific sex is. I can hold a dignity for you. I can hold a respect for you. 17:58 I cannot necessarily accept what's not an objective truth. However, charity, care, love, and understanding will temper the way that I may express that to someone. If I know that not saying someone's, or what they call dead naming or so, or referring 18:17 to someone by a gender that they don't feel comfortable with, and I'm in your presence, I'm going to go on charity. 18:22 I'm going to go on understanding. I'm going to go on love to address you in a way that is respectful for your dignity, despite what I might actually feel. 18:29 I don't have to change what I believe or know as truth or as an objective truth. in order to show you respect and dignity. 18:37 Shaheem, I saw you wiggling. 18:38 Sorry. 18:39 So I'm coming to you. Well, what I'll say is, you know. 18:44 But wait, before you say that, and the only reason why I'm doing this is because I think it's important. 18:48 This point is on how gender has been politicized as a distraction. What we know is there are a number of people who think like Roxy do about this issue. 18:58 And that, I believe, is where the wedge has been drawn to get people to focus on that you know, that singular point of belief in disagreement. Shaheem, I want you to go ahead. 19:08 I have so much to say, my goodness. So everything is connected. Thank you for bringing up fascistic governments into this. 19:18 That is often paired, especially with the 1930s and 40s, when it was the rise of figures like Hitler, Mussolini, with Christian nationalism. And I will start by saying I am a big believer in people believing whatever they need to believe to get through life. Like I've worked with 19:36 people from every walk of life as a clinician, as a social worker. And I just believe in people's autonomy. 19:43 Not everybody believes in God. Not everybody has to. Some people have different experiences and walks through life. 19:49 You can go year to year. 19:50 However you need to build your universe, but you can't build everybody's universe. And plus, I kind of wanted to bring in to this like the construct of a social construct. 20:02 Social constructs are. 20:03 Things that we all agree to believe in, but it doesn't necessarily make them real. Similar to like money. Money is just paper. It does not hold real value. It only holds value because we all agree that it holds value. 20:15 And the same can be said about gender. Just because you have your perception of what gender is, just because you have your own thoughts and beliefs around it, it doesn't make it reality. 20:25 It does not make it law. And it doesn't mean that it's real. 20:29 When we say things, for example, like identify as, these people don't identify as anything. 20:34 They are trans and that's okay. They don't identify as. 20:38 Women or men or intersex or non-binary. 20:41 They just are that. 20:43 We have a tendency to dehumanize other people and their experiences because we have been indoctrinated to believe our own. 20:50 I respect Christians, Christianity, well, people's choice to participate in it. 20:57 But I also don't ignore the history of violence that comes with that and how it's perpetuated through statements like that. 21:05 There is no objective truth because everybody has a different walk across life. You're not the only person in the universe. 21:12 And that's why I go back to quite often in these conversations, why do you care what the next person is doing? Because that's their life. Everybody isn't going to believe the same things you do. Everybody isn't going to buy into the same social constructs as you. People exist 21:26 outside of our own experiences. And I'm not going to ignore how Christianity is tied to colonialism, and that's a huge part of this conversation too. A lot of the reasons why people have these strong opinions about gender, especially 21:40 in communities of color, is because they've been indoctrinated through colonialism. 21:45 And I can cite and point to so many experiences, like people being arrested or sentenced to death for being queer throughout history, especially during early colonialism. If you look to Brazil, there are so many cases of people having 21:59 to experience that. That is a direct result of colonialism. 22:03 I just think it all comes down to though, everybody doesn't believe what you believe and that's okay. And I would ask people to kind of look within and ask why is it that your worldview is so important to you that you can't empathize with the reality that other 22:18 people have different experiences. 22:19 May I respond to that? 22:20 Of course. 22:23 You laid out a lot. You threw out a lot of rabbit holes that are hard to go down in one easy conversation here. The first thing I would ask is that if objective truth is not real and relative truth is real, then how do we know what is truth? 22:39 If everyone's own reality is what exists. 22:41 Because everybody has different realities. 22:43 That's not the answer. 22:44 You think that God is the End all, be all for everybody. But everybody doesn't believe what you do. 22:50 I never said that. 22:50 I never said that. 22:52 You said we're all made in God's. 22:53 Light and love. And I'll say that some people don't believe that. 22:57 Some people are atheist. 22:58 Some people believe in different practices. And I'm not trying to disrespect you or cut over you. 23:03 Well, may I finish? Because you did have a good chance to speak. And I'd like to actually get to this. Again, the issue that I have with what you said is that everybody has their own reality and their own truth. 23:13 But if that's true, science couldn't even exist. Everything is just based off of how you feel or what you want. 23:17 There is an objective truth. However, what I have said is that I respect someone's choice to be whoever they want. 23:28 But it doesn't mean, now, if you get to live in the area of relative truth, then why can't I believe or live in that area of relative truth? So that line for you is a very hard divide. If it agrees with what you agree, then it's fine. But 23:42 if it doesn't, then it's not. I've said that if I don't agree, that's fine. However, I don't have to change what I believe is truth. It doesn't cost me to respect you or to show you love or to show you dignity. It does not cost me anything. So 23:58 that's one thing. And then, I mean, Honestly speaking, you don't have to believe in God to have dignity and respect and love for people. Like you can believe in whatever you want. You could be a complete atheist. But at the end of the day, I'm still going to 24:12 look at you that you are human. You were created. 24:15 We have dignity, male, female, black, white, whatever. You don't have to believe what I believe, but I'm still going to respect you for who you are. But I do not, just as you get to live in your relative truth, so do I. 24:26 This is interesting because we're just in claim one. And I think what we saw here, just in this conversation, why gender has been weaponized really as a point of distraction. 24:38 And what's unfortunate even about my own word choice here is a distraction could seem like it is trivializing people with different experiences, different existences. And I think that that is part of the challenge. We got to go to 24:52 claim two, though. And claim two is trans and non-binary people have always existed. So we talked a little bit about colonialism. Let us first run this clip about a concept called Two-Spirit within indigenous communities. 25:08 Used since the 90s, the concept of the Two-Spirit is something indigenous groups have identified with for centuries. But what does Two-Spirit actually mean? The Two-Spirit Society of Denver offers the following definition. Two-Spirit refers to another gender role believed 25:24 to be common among most, if not all, first peoples of Turtle Island, North America. one that had a proper and accepted place within Native societies. This acceptance was rooted in the spiritual teachings that say all life is sacred. 25:37 So I wanted to run that. I thought it was fascinating when I first learned about Two-Spirit folks. And I don't know if you all have a reaction. How many in the audience have heard of Two-Spirit? New to some, not to all. Okay, very good. And then for you all, 25:53 reactions to this concept of Two-Spirit. This is a concept that existed before colonialism. 25:59 Yeah, I wanted to ask for clarification on one thing, just about in terms of what is it that we are being distracted from? 26:08 Yeah, to me, now I'm on the panel, happy to be on the panel. I would say distraction, how I see it, is a wedge that is being put in the community to divide us on things that, one, we might be afraid of, lack understanding about. don't care to 26:26 learn about because nobody has ever been in our midst that, you know, is trans or non-binary. And as the numbers increase, people are born and then their parents are like, what are you talking about? 26:38 Right. 26:39 That is starting to become more prevalent in communication, in, you know, conversations online, in school, people, you know, kids are learning about trans identity and what it means to be non-binary. Those aren't conversations I had in school. 26:53 Right. Right. 26:54 These aren't ads that I saw being run when I was growing up. So now there's a whole ecosystem of conversation happening, again, for such a small percentage of people. 27:03 The small percentage doesn't mean they don't matter. 27:06 Right. 27:06 But it does mean that we're focusing a lot more than that than on them damn eggs. 27:10 Right. 27:11 We're focusing a lot more than that. Regardless of where you fall on the gender spectrum, are you being paid your worth at your job? 27:18 Right. 27:18 Regardless of where you sit on the gender spectrum, can you afford to live in the house you live in? 27:23 Although often, where you sit on the gender spectrum has a direct influence on those factors. But the other thing I would say is, I mean, I think there's a couple reasons why we are talking more about this subject. 27:39 And I think that one of those is because of the success of the modern day gay rights movement in the United States, starting with Stonewall, not too far from us in New York City. The fact that there have been many, many decades and centuries of folks, particularly in 28:00 the United States, advocating for themselves and their rights because they were being denied. 28:05 And then on. 28:06 Top of that, we have this incredible thing that's allowing all of us to communicate with everybody, which is the internet. 28:15 I don't know if I call it incredible, but go off. 28:18 But go off. 28:20 Uncredible. 28:21 And so, you know, when we're talking about, you know, the two spirits. 28:25 Wait, wait, because I just want to try. 28:28 I don't know. 28:29 Who said that shit's incredible? 28:32 I don't know. 28:32 I think it was Al Gore. 28:35 That was good. You win that point. You know, like, I think. 28:44 As we've seen, you know, just over the growth and evolution of the Internet and particularly algorithmic social media and black box algorithms, we don't necessarily understand or can see how they work or being manipulated. But there have been 29:01 a lot of studies that have been done that show when the incentives are to keep people on a particular platform, for longer and longer periods of time. 29:13 How do you do that? 29:15 You make them angry. It incentivizes misinformation, confirmation bias, like feeding into what people already believe. But the other thing, you know, and there are very good reasons why we've been spending a lot more time talking and thinking about 29:34 those things. But I think the other thing that we've forgotten about the beauty of the internet, you know, starting from when it really became something being used by a vast number of consumers, was the way that it allowed 29:48 for people, particularly people who were members of marginalized groups like queer people or trans people, to connect with one another, to feel less alone and less alienated. Particularly if you're someone like me, I'm 42, I grew up in the 90s. 30:05 One of the, I think, moments that I will always remember from my childhood was when Matthew Shepard was murdered in this really horrifically violent way. And if you're a queer kid growing up in a small town somewhere, and you're the only person you know, like you, or maybe 30:29 one of two or three, and what you know about yourself and your existence is that that means that you're going to be a target for violence and repression. That's, I think, incredibly heartbreaking and damaging and contributed, in fact, 30:52 to larger rates of suicide and self-harm among queer youth. 30:57 So when we're talking about something like two-spirit people, right, who have long existed, you know, when North America was still known as Turtle Island before Christopher Columbus ever like had a notion. 31:12 He did not have a notion. He was lost. 31:17 He got lost. 31:18 That man was lost. Everybody at home, kids with bad textbooks, that man was lost. The only Christopher we recognize as Wallace, and that's Biggie Smalls. He got lost, right? 31:29 And he ends up blown off course into Hispaniola and then immediately proceeds to enslave the Native population there and torture them and do a whole lot of rape and pillaging and everything else. But when we look at indigenous 31:45 societies all over the world, not just in North America, but in Asia and Africa and Oceania, there have been folks, sometimes people refer to as a third gender, as the Hegira in South Asia. 32:04 There's one point I have on that. South Asia has long recognized at least eight gender expansive identities documented throughout regional texts and traditions. 32:12 Yeah. 32:13 To your point. 32:13 Right. 32:14 So the thing that the Internet basically does is that, you know, when people can find each other and talk about their experiences and share them the way that we do on social media. I think that just speaks to the curiosity of humanity as a whole, because the other thing is like. 32:30 Well, I didn't know these people. There wasn't anybody that I grew up with like this. 32:35 And then you can just kind. 32:36 Of fall down a rabbit hole that way. And I think because one of the side effects of this sort of social media-driven information environment that we have now is that everyone has a different algorithm, right? 32:52 So everyone can sort of be in their own. 32:54 Little silos. 32:56 Of reality and that can be manipulated in certain ways. 33:00 That doesn't mean those folks didn't always, you know, exist or were looking for each other or were building community. Yeah. 33:06 I'm going to tell you the silo I'm in. And that is the silo and tribe of Janelle Monae. Let's see what she had to say about gender. 33:16 I'm non-binary. Yeah. So I just don't see myself as a woman or.... 33:23 Right. 33:24 I feel all of my energy. I feel like God is so much bigger than the he or the she. 33:32 It's like something. And if I am from God, I am everything. I am everything. But I will always, always stand with women. I will always stand with black women. 33:43 But I just see everything that I am beyond the binary. 33:50 I wanted to play that because I think, you know, it's important for people to understand that things are also evolving. 33:57 I would love to know, John, from you, we haven't heard from you in a little while. When did you first learn about pronouns and how did you receive that conversation? 34:07 Can I just speak to Janelle? 34:10 Yeah. 34:10 Listen, my wife and I danced to Ark Android in our loft when it first came out. Like nobody was watching. 34:18 Love Janelle. 34:19 I just want to call out that in that clip, she's everything, she's God, but she never mentioned, I will stand with black men too. And I find that, right? 34:28 So I just want to call out the removal, the erasure, the elevation and celebration of black women is well-deserved, well-earned, but it doesn't have to come with the diminishment of black men as an equal. 34:41 Now, hold on. Cite your source on that. I've never seen Janelle belittle, disrespect, not support black men. She's been very supportive, actually. I don't know what the question was that prompted that answer to also be fair to her. 34:55 So contextually, it could have been focused just. 34:56 On black women. 34:57 That's a fair point. And I'm not going to say that she in that clip diminished black men. I'm just suggesting that she didn't also. equalize the platform. 35:05 You all lives matter in this moment, John. 35:06 Not at all. 35:07 Okay, I'm just checking. 35:08 I'm saying that. Listen, for us in the community, the audience. 35:10 Is like, what? 35:10 They're like, he might be. 35:12 Let me back up. 35:14 When did I first learn pronouns? I used to lead the diversity, equity, and inclusion function in a few spaces in corporate. I wrote a book called Plantation Theory, The Black Professional Struggle Between Freedom and Security. And understanding the 35:30 experiences historically For us, gender has always played a part, specifically in a colonial context, because the division of men and women, specifically for labor and particular functions to the enterprise, mattered greatly. And those things have not changed, thus plantation 35:49 theory still exists. Point being, pronouns as a means of clear delineation, identification, as a means of introduction, as a means of living life, I would say that's probably within the last 10 to 15 years, but has caught, I 36:08 would say, more mainstream focus in the last five to 10, if I'm being honest. 36:15 I'm going to admit a bias here, and I want you all to... It's not Soraya raising her eyebrows. I'm telling you all, I've struggled with this. I went to law school, so grammar and stuff is very important to me. 36:29 The they... them is very hard for me because that is plural. Now, Janelle says she's everything. So maybe it's like, this is my way of saying, look, I'm all things. 36:39 Y'all got to deal with all of the many, you know, ways that I come at you. That's fine. But it is, I really wish there was an additional pronoun that I'm going to get to you, Shaheen. 36:50 Don't worry. 36:51 But I wish there was an additional pronoun or something that we could create that was not plural. And I'd love to understand why that is. It drives me nuts. 36:59 I'm not going to lie to you. I'll call you whatever you want to be called. But it drives me nuts. Shaheen, what you got? I think it exists. 37:06 Oh, no, go ahead. I'm non-binary. So I love this conversation. 37:10 I think a lot of the. 37:12 Times, like the outrage culture that we exist in makes these conversations really difficult. hard to have, but I think there's space for, again, empathy. I will say we're in an empathy crisis as a society. We label it a lot of other things, but I think it really boils 37:27 down to that. 37:28 I need an amen button for that. 37:31 It makes a lot of sense for people who grow up in a society that really emphasizes the binary to have a hard time conceptualizing and understanding. 37:40 They actually isn't plural. 37:42 If somebody was in the other room, you didn't know who this person was, but you know that you needed a cup, You would say, can you ask them to grab me the cup? 37:50 Like, and I get it. I do. I empathize with, yes. Okay, so. 37:56 I don't know if I would do that. If I knew it was, if I knew it was the person, well, I would assume the person's gender, I would say he or she. 38:04 Yeah. 38:05 I would. Therein lies the problem. 38:06 I'm not saying, I'm not, yeah, I'm not saying that it's right, but I'm not going to lie to you either. I'm, you know, I'm standing next to a fact checking buzzer. 38:11 Can't do that. 38:12 But you didn't really go down like a linguistics rabbit hole with that, right? 38:16 Because we were sort of centering this on... So I just go down it fast because we got to get to the third claim. 38:21 Right. 38:21 Because, I mean, not every single language necessarily has the same grammatical structure or even recognizes the difference in gender. 38:31 So in English, certainly, right? I mean, I think this is a thing that throws a lot of people, but you know, linguistics I think is really interesting in part because of what it tells us about ourselves and our. 38:46 Own cultures, right? 38:47 And the way that we come up with language to express things. And so, you know, like there've always been pronouns because we use them all the time. 39:01 Can I jump in real quick with something? I want, I mean, this is the first time I'm hearing Janelle Monae's And I just find it interesting. I mean, I kind of wanted to be like this when she's talking about, well, God, I'm God, I'm everything. But where does that come from 39:18 and where is she getting that from? 39:21 Her spirit. Well, let me get at this. 39:25 Respectfully, I mean, you, Shaheen? 39:28 Shaheen. 39:31 You identify as being non-binary. 39:35 No, I am. Okay. 39:36 You are non-binary, but presenting wise, you present as a male. 39:41 You present as a man. And I, of course, listen, if That's how you want to be addressed. That's fine. 39:48 But there's still what I'm getting at, even with what Janelle Monáe is saying, there's still an ontological and physiological truth to her anatomy. It's like you can be whoever you want, but at the end of the day, she is a woman. And I would assume that you are a man. 40:10 This is a relative truth issue. 40:15 But anatomy refers to sex, not necessarily gender. 40:20 I am curious, why do you care? Because you asked. 40:29 No, I didn't. 40:29 I actually did. You asked, you said, can I chime in right here? So that's not, I did not ask you that specific question. You are saying, you're insistent on clarifying who Janelle is to the world based on how she shows up, how she seems to you. Why do you care? 40:47 It's not that I care. I don't go around worrying about who's binary and non-binary and who's this gender. That doesn't cross my mind. 40:53 You went from Janelle to Shaheen. 40:55 However, because we are in a conversation where it is brought up, now this is where it actually is a place where I converse about it. Is this something that I talk about every day that rules my life? Absolutely not. However- 41:05 When her example was brought up, Shaheen volunteered that information. 41:10 Shaheen. 41:11 Shaheen. 41:11 I'm sorry, Shaheen. He volunteered that. What are the pronouns that you respectfully? 41:17 Maybe that's why. Okay. 41:19 That information was volunteered. So once it's out there, it can be asked about and it can be criticized. 41:25 But I think I want to just drill down here just a little bit. And I think the criticism isn't necessary, but I guess... I'm willing to scrutinize. 41:33 Scrutinize. 41:33 Yeah, not criticize. 41:34 Fine. 41:35 But I guess I really am curious about why do you care? Like, my brought up mind. I care because from the English language perspective, I'm struggling. Y'all help me. 41:45 They graciously... They were like, look, you can go speak another language, sis, if you want to. I got it. Okay? 41:51 I'm clear. But I'm curious to know why you personally. 41:53 Why I personally care because I think it comes down to... 41:57 the word relative truth, which was brought up, which hinges on. 42:01 A lot of this. You triggered. You triggered. 42:03 No, it's not triggered. I mean, it's conversation, right? It's conversation. 42:07 It's not triggering. But if we're going to, in my standpoint and from my worldview, like I'm not parsing that I am Catholic, I'm Christian. And there is in our worldview that there is a truth in the human body. 42:23 And that for me to say that just because You might feel within the construct of gender, of your male, female, binary, all that. It's not who fits you. 42:33 That's fine. 42:34 That's okay. 42:34 But it still doesn't erase the truth of your biology or your DNA or your chromosomes. It just simply now intersects. Okay, we have that other issue, but I'm just talking about in general. 42:44 Well, let's not say another issue. 42:46 Go ahead, John. 42:46 I don't know that. I think this is probably the macrocosm of the conversation. We are talking about things that are hyper-individualized. In the context of community, I think we all have to have agreements. We have to agree that we are going to treat each other with a certain 43:01 level of respect, dignity, clarity on what our boundaries are, what are our standards. In order for this to look at, I look at our historical self-sufficient black communities of which there were nearly 1,200 post-emancipation all the way up to 43:15 the early 1900s. There had to be agreements in order for us to survive as a community. Yes, trans and non-binary communities And all of the flavors of love existed. 43:29 But in the context of survival, the hyper individualism would not have made it possible for them to make it through. 43:36 And I think that is the bigger question around the division, the divisiveness. The distraction is when we are divided, we don't have communal agreement. Therefore, things can be imposed. Policies and legislation can be pushed through without division. with actually 43:52 significant consent because people have been manipulated into support. And that really benefits the minority in the power structure, the dominant group that ultimately creates wedges amongst subordinate group while they maintain dominant group power positions. And I use dominant 44:10 and subordinate group in the context of social dominance theory or social dominance orientation, Sedanius and Pareto, 1999, if I want to cite my source. 44:17 Thank you for your source. 44:19 Yes, ma'am. 44:20 But the context there is the dominant group can pathologize the subordinate group, but at the same time, the subordinate group upholds the dominant group standard. So much so it becomes the aspiration. So that's why you see people make 44:33 it to a certain level and forget where they came from or close the door, pull the ladders up behind them, because the aspiration is to get to the dominant group. 44:40 Point being, you have to shed subordinate group identity to get into dominant group. You can't exist as a subordinate group community if, in fact, you are divided. That is the point. Dominant group cannot survive or else it switches 44:54 and flips. And historically, as long as human beings have made social contracts, agreements, communities, those who control power, resources, and access define themselves as dominant group. Subordinate group did 45:08 not have those things until the subordinate group overtakes dominant group. 45:13 And they become now the dominant group and ultimately it becomes cyclical. 45:17 Okay. 45:18 So are you saying that like transgender people or non-binary people or queer people who are black need to subordinate themselves to sort of a cis-heterobinary in order, like as a form of racial solidarity? 45:38 Not at all. 45:39 What I'm saying is that we don't get to determine our own pathologizations. Dominant group determines that. We are, whether you're black, woman, whether you're non-binary, trans, Islamic, whatever the non-dominant group standard is, you are in the subordinate group. 45:59 I'm not saying you have to subordinate yourself. I'm just saying how the dynamic is split. 46:03 I think you're using subordinate as we would probably normally use minority, like a minority group. 46:07 Minority group, yes, for sure. 46:10 Non-power group. 46:11 Non-power holding group. 46:12 I reject the claim that we have no power. I summarily reject that. Now, do we have as much as we need? It is a different show, but I have to reject it. 46:23 Individual. 46:24 The other thing is that we have this wonderful thing called the Constitution. 46:28 That nobody's abiding by right now, my friend. Especially not your Supreme Court. 46:34 It only has as much power as we Like, give it, right? 46:39 Or as much as the Supreme Court will enforce it. 46:43 Right. 46:43 But just because the Supreme Court says that there is, let's say, you know, no law that a white man has to respect with regard to a black person, right? 46:58 That we are not. 47:01 Equal under the law. Like, the Supreme Court can say that, but that doesn't mean that it is true or correct. 47:10 But we have this wonderful thing. 47:11 That's going to also have to be another show. 47:14 And the 14th Amendment that gives all of us. 47:17 I support the amendments. Let's just ask the Supreme Court justices if they will enforce them. But I absolutely agree with you. If only one of us were on the bench. 47:26 Let's get to our final claim. It doesn't mean that you can't bring in other points, but y'all, we got a little bit of time left. For our final claim, claim three is traditional gender roles no longer exist. It's clear that gender roles have shifted over time, from women 47:41 excelling in the workforce to Me Too. One thing remains, women advocating for societal advancement, parity, and equity seem to upset some men and maybe highlight some insecurities. Let's take this pastor, for example. 47:55 You've called for repealing women's right to vote, which is protected by the 19th Amendment. 48:01 Why? 48:04 Because it's a good idea. 48:08 A lot of women wouldn't think so. 48:10 A lot of women wouldn't agree. 48:11 Right. 48:12 But this is one of my favorite questions now, too. 48:17 This is not an XXXY chromosome issue. Because I don't want women voting as individuals because I don't want men voting as individuals. So what I envision is a system that we have practiced in our church here for four decades, and that is household voting. 48:43 Shout out to that promo for Handmaid's Tale. Soraya, I want to go to you. You wrote that the women's movement did not create male insecurity, it merely exposed it. 48:55 Talk to us about that. 48:58 Sure. 48:59 I mean, I think you can say that probably about any social movement that's bringing about a change to the status quo. When people who are fighting to have you know, their constitutionally guaranteed rights recognized and realized, you know, when 49:22 they lean on that, and that is the thing that they are relying upon to advocate for themselves, we see this over and over again. We saw this with the disapproval ratings among white Americans during the Civil Rights Movement. 49:38 You know, I think we see this every time there is a group of people who is simply advocating for what is fair. You know, whether that be pay equity, whether that be enfranchisement as voters, as citizens, whether that be recognition that they are indeed American citizens if they 50:05 have been born in the United States of America, right? 50:09 But just because there are folks who don't necessarily want that, you know, like this pastor, I'm not sure what his name is in this clip. 50:18 Doug Wilson, I think. Oh, okay, Doug Wilson. 50:22 Yeah, that doesn't necessarily mean that just because Doug Wilson wants this and that's the way that he has constructed his church, that he gets to impose that on everyone else in America because that's not acceptable. The social contract that we've all agreed upon as citizens. 50:40 That is true. But there's also this growing movement, at least online, called Tradwives. And the Tradwives have supported that. Roxy, I'm curious to know how you see this Tradwife concept being different. from the roles and responsibilities of traditional womanhood 50:56 in Catholicism. 50:57 I knew this question was coming right through. 50:59 I'm glad you knew me. It was a great handoff, Soraya. 51:02 It was fantastic. Well, let me just preface this with the viewpoint that was shared was clearly shared by a Protestant pastor. That's not something that the Catholic Church actually supports at all. In fact, in Mulieris Dignitas, which was 51:17 written by Pope John Paul II, He outlined the dignity of women, not only in the home, but their contribution to the world, to work. And so for us, male and female, it's not like we're pitted against each other. 51:35 We're complementary to each other. And we have dignity for who we are as both male and female. So that ideology that he has, that's something that is to his own ideology and to his church, not on the general whole. 51:50 for Catholicism. What was the second question that you had asked? 51:54 The question was just on where do you see the difference between trad wives and traditional roles and responsibilities of women in the Catholic church? 52:00 Absolutely. Now this is interesting because I did a whole like video on this topic. The idea of the trad wife, once again, is not something that is inherent to the Catholic church. That's something that a lot of Protestants actually uphold. 52:16 And it's, it, In many ways, it's because of the fact that we see the dignity of the woman. The greatest human, aside from Jesus Christ, to a Catholic person is the Blessed Mother, His Mother, who is upheld in the highest degree. And we have a veneration towards her. 52:35 So the woman and the female is important. The role of the woman is important. You want to bring Christianity into it. Jesus Christ, upon rising, He appeared to a woman first. He didn't appear to a man. He appeared to a woman, Mary Magdalene, right? So this idea for us. 52:50 But y'all didn't know you was coming to Bible study today. Hey, what's up? 52:54 That was just part one. I ain't going to go deeper. 52:56 Because we ain't got no time. 52:58 But just to say that from my own standpoint, and I can absolutely say this from the Catholic standpoint, that the voice of women matter, that our voice is important, that we are to be active members of our society. 53:12 We have papal documents all the way from the 1800s with Pope Leo XIII writing about the dignity of the human, the dignity of the worker, the dignity of women and children. 53:21 Can you see there being a woman pope? 53:24 No, absolutely not. Okay, that's a loaded question. 53:26 Absolutely not. It was no load. My clip was empty. 53:31 I didn't know I was stepping in. You just was uplifting us so high. Hold on. 53:40 The answer is no, because it's rooted in a liturgical reason. 53:45 It's rooted in what Christ left behind. It's rooted in the Levitical line of priests. It's rooted in the line of Aaron. It's rooted in the line of Melchizedek and what Jesus Christ chose, 12 men who handed down the tradition of the priesthood. And therefore we cannot change that 54:03 because it's something that was from 2,000 years ago. That is a tradition to us. 54:07 The Pope changed stuff all the time, but go off. 54:09 But the Pope changes things, not things that have to do with dogma and things that have to do with the actual teachings of the church that have been passed on over time. 54:17 I'm going to let you argue my mama on that. 54:20 John? 54:21 I'll only add outside of the Catholic church construct in terms of traditional. I think traditional is still very much here. 54:33 I think the modern context is what's clashing with it. 54:35 And that's what we see a lot on online. For instance, I think, and I'll always root everything in the context of the black community, but black women have now, they earned 68% of doctoral degrees, right? And when we look 54:50 at the advancements of black women, both educationally, professionally, socially, that is to be celebrated. What has not kept pace policy-wise or even socialization-wise, is black men coming along with them. 55:06 And so what we're seeing in terms of traditional relationships, up front, our platform, 85% of the women on the platform suggest that emotional availability is a non-negotiable in their next relationship. And I say that's not an unreasonable ask. 55:22 Touché. 55:22 It is an unreasonable expectation. 55:24 Why? 55:25 Well, because there has largely been no change in the socialization of black boys in the household. When you, right? 55:32 So if you've known or met a black man that grew up in tune with his emotions, can name his emotions in the expansiveness, right? The over 3000 words we have for the 34,000 emotions, men typically have access to about eight to. 55:47 12, right? 55:48 And that's not by accident. We are taught to suppress emotion, right? 55:51 And I know Shaheem, you can speak to this. We are taught to protect, to guard, to not show that. 55:56 And we have no social incentive or reward system for men being emotionally ill. 56:00 Who's responsible for that reward system? 56:03 Both men and women. 56:05 Mothers, right? 56:06 So if we're at 77% single parent homes, the majority of those by single mothers. 56:12 I feel like we carrying enough. 56:14 Listen, I'm not going to blame, but I'm just stating. 56:16 Facts, right? And I'm not trying to assign blame. I'm curious about, like, if this is the case, Shaheem, I'd love to see you, like, have you weigh in on this. 56:24 And then definitely, because Soraya's face already has. So definitely, Soraya. 56:29 I feel it on my neck. I'm with you, sis. 56:31 I do the same thing. 56:32 You're at home. 56:33 It's a safe place. But I saw your face. I'm going to come to you next. But, Shaheem, I'm curious because there is something around emotional availability, the spaces that black men have to feel and be safe. And that 56:46 lack of safety does absolutely impact their relationships, but also every other aspect of their lives. So whose responsibility is this and how do we fix this on top of a growing gender divide, on top of people mad, traditional roles don't exist, on top of, you know, the world's 57:02 changing and we got to keep up. 57:04 I'm going to keep my team brief. 57:06 If you are a black man, I highly recommend that you read The Wheel of Change by Bell Hooks. 57:12 Patriarchy as a- It's. 57:14 The first time Soraya's been out in five minutes, but keep going. 57:18 Patriarchy hurts men too, especially black men because you stand at a lot of intersections. What I will say is also I think we just have a language problem in general. 57:29 I think a lot of people don't have a lot of shared definitions. There is like, for example, a difference between gender expression, like how a person dresses, gender identity. 57:40 Who they are internally. 57:42 And a lot of people don't understand these concepts and terms, which I feel like is why our conversations get muddled so much. A lot more things are subjective than we think. 57:51 For example, science used to say that black people weren't 100% people. 57:56 Science changes, truth changes, truth is subjective. All of these things mean different things. As far as the patriarchy goes, I wouldn't say that that responsibility is on women. I would say men have to take the mantle and do that. 58:09 That happens through conversation. And when we shift the blame towards the people who are the most impacted by these systems and institutions, that takes away from the actual work that needs to be done through dismantling. 58:21 Can I also say, just to add on to the wisdom, brother, I would encourage people to read The Man Not by Dr. 58:27 Tommy J. 58:28 Curry as well. 58:29 Because Also, we're not talking about the impact to black boys, which carries into black men. Frederick Douglass' famous quote, it's easier to raise strong children than to fix broken men. 58:41 That responsibility, I did not say was solely on the women. 58:44 It is the man's responsibility, for sure, as well as the woman's. Two-parent households ensure, or at least. 58:52 Give more chance to those outcomes. 58:55 I disagree. 58:56 I don't know if that's necessarily true. Two parent households? 59:01 I mean, you can be raised by two parents who are completely closed off emotionally. 59:05 Healthy household. 59:08 Healthy is subjective, too. Well, yeah. 59:11 Well, I mean, we do have a lot of subjectivity, but I will say that there are some things that also remain the same. Hopefully, we understand what a healthy two-parent household looks like. 59:22 Hopefully. I think we have to agree on that. 59:23 I also hope that we don't assign... what the sex of the parents have to be to have a healthy household. 59:29 I think that's important. I know you wanted to weigh in, Roxy. 59:32 I'll allow you to do that really quick. And then we got to wrap up because we go over time. Absolutely. 59:36 No, I think that every single person on here brought up amazing points. I think that we each have to digest in order to get to understand each other. I feel sometimes in these conversations, particularly from the Christian standpoint, 59:50 that we often are marginalized in a box that everyone thinks a certain way or that the way that we might think is invalidating. And what I hope especially is not that I didn't come across to disrespect what you guys stand for and what you believe. But at the 60:06 same time, I think that it's really important that if we are going to talk about this divide, that it's not just one side or one type of people that's doing it. 60:14 It's everyone. 60:15 And that's this whole thing about division that we've been talking about the whole time. And just to finish off, I firmly believe definitely agree with what you brought up about the importance of caring about our young men, our boys. 60:27 They're suffering. And there isn't, in my point of view, enough that is given to their health because healthy boys are as important as healthy girls and healthy families. And not even bringing in whether it's two men, two women, two, whatever, okay? 60:48 Healthy home, healthy home. I can agree to that. But our black boys need to have recognition as well and should not be ignored in this conversation. 60:56 I don't think they have been. Hopefully y'all don't feel that way. Well, I will say I couldn't agree with you more, Roxy, that all Catholics don't agree because my mama is Catholic and I think she might have some words today. I can't wait to see what my mama 61:09 says after watching this. This has been fantastic. Please join me in thanking today's panelists, Soraya, Nadia McDonald, Shahee McClurin, Roxy Beckles, and John Graham. We discussed three claims today. One, gender has been politicized as a distraction, whether online or 61:27 behind a political desk. The national focus on less than 2% of the population is probably keeping us from addressing the issues that impact our daily lives. Two, Trans and non-binary people have always existed. This is a fact. No one 61:43 source has authority over the many diverse ways in which humans exist. Three, traditional gender roles no longer exist. This is not true. While gender roles have evolved over time, it is up to each individual to determine how they 61:58 would like to move throughout the world. Remember, knowledge is power, and on Cite Your Source, we put that power back into the hands of the people Please join us again next week. We're talking about something really exciting. We're going 62:09 to break it to you later. And subscribe to Cite Your Source on YouTube. Engage with us on social media and share with somebody. Until next time, I'm your host, Angela Rye. This is Cite Your Source.
Community discussion