0:00 Welcome home, NLP fam. This is Angela Rye. You're about to hear an episode of Cite Your Source, a show produced and presented by Native Lamb Pod. On Cite Your Source, we fact-check the headlines and debunk viral news. We say we are your two-step verification on all the BS. New 0:16 episodes drop Wednesday at 9 p.m. Eastern on Cite Your Source's YouTube channel. If you're listening and wondering what our sources are, I encourage you to check out the video where we cite our sources in real time and we 0:28 have our sources in show notes. Thank you. Enjoy the episode. 0:33 Welcome to Cite Your Source. I'm your host, Angela Rye. 0:36 We are your two-step verification on all the BS. And today we are talking about the N-word. Who can use it or should anyone at all be using it? Joining me today are Lennard Charlemagne-Lagarde McKelvey, multimedia mogul. Jordan Pierre, 0:50 youth leadership and identity advocate and founder of Voice. Delano Squires, director of the DeVos Center for human flourishing at the Heritage Foundation, and author of The Vanishing Black Family, Dr. 1:04 Elizabeth Stordor Pryor, professor of history at Smith College and author of Something We Said, Richard Pryor, A Notorious Word, and Me, Derek Johnson, president and CEO of the NAACP, and Dr. Michael Eric Dyson, distinguished professor of African American 1:20 and Diaspora Studies at Vanderbilt University. We got through it all today. We will be addressing three claims. One, the N-word is associated with the most painful aspects of black history. Two, the N-word is derived from the Amharic word nagus, which 1:37 means king. Three, it is socially acceptable for white people and individuals of other racial backgrounds to say the N-word. 1:46 So I know you all are wondering where and who is the fact checker. 1:52 Surprise, surprise! 1:54 It is me. 1:54 She is I and I is she. That is right. 1:56 I will be serving as our resident fact checker. So if any panelist is on some BS or tells a little story, I will hit that buzzer and you'll hear this sound. Then they will have to cite their source. 2:09 This is going to be good, y'all. But first, let's get to the N-word. 2:12 Nigga. 2:13 Nigga. 2:13 Nigga. 2:14 Say it right now. 2:31 Okay, so I got to ask you all this very basic question, yes or no. Should folks be using the N-word? 2:38 This is a rapid round. We're going to start with the person I know will be the rapidest. That's Dr. Dyson. 2:42 Yes. 2:44 So your answer is yes. People should use the N-word. Okay, Derek? 2:46 Black people should. Black people should. 2:48 Okay, Derek? 2:49 No one. 2:50 Okay, Liz? 2:52 Complicated. 2:53 Okay, Delano? 2:55 Depends. Okay, Jordan? 2:57 No. 2:57 Okay, Lenard? 2:59 No. 2:59 No. No? 3:00 Okay, you sound like you have the most hesitation. Why no? 3:04 I have no hesitation, but when a sister said complicated, I can see where it can be complicated. But I think that when you know better, you do better. And I know for me, whenever I've used it, I've never used it as a term of endearment. I use it 3:15 the way white supremacists use it. I be like, them goddamn, you know? So I don't see the benefit of it in 2026 to still be using it in any way, shape, or form. 3:25 For me, personally. 3:25 It just feels a little vibrational. 3:27 Yeah, well, I think it's complicated. White people should never use it. I don't want to ever hear it, and I don't say it. But I also know that it's in conversation with white supremacy when black people use it, and that to remove the word is just removing a 3:41 vocabulary word when the words in conversation with injustice, inequity, inequality, those systems have to be removed before the N-word stops meaning anything. As long as it means something, it's going to continue to be used. That's the complication for me. 3:56 Delano? 3:57 Yeah. 3:57 And I would make a distinction between private use, public use and commercial use. And a great deal of the conversation around that word, particularly over the last 40 years, is about public and commercial use, particularly if you're talking 4:09 about hip hop. But I think it's important to remember that every all language has context and you have to look at the message, the messenger, the motive and the medium. 4:19 And for me, and this is where I would. 4:20 Agree with Charlamagne. 4:22 A lot of the time, the motive, even when it's coming from our mouths, is not a clean motive. It's not a good motive. But language is fluid in the way that people talk, particularly when in a private setting, doesn't necessarily mean that they have ill intent when they. 4:35 Use particular words. 4:36 And that's why there's a difference between reading a word and using a word. And I think all the panelists would agree that using the word as a slur, regardless of whose mouth it comes out of, is off-limits. 4:48 Yeah. I say for me, I feel like we shouldn't use the N-word. And the reason why I'm saying that, because I think of when I think of words, I think about the power of language. You said in the Bible says the power of death or life relies on 4:58 the tongue. But even outside of that, it's understanding that words also have a neurological response. And depending on the field and work that you're doing, I'm trying to reaffirm young black men and who they are. I want you to reaffirm me and who we are. Why you don't 5:09 feel comfortable calling me a king? a God as such, but you want to reaffirm me in being a nigga. 5:13 And then I got to think of the responses. Words have an impact. When I call a young man a king, how he start to stand up. And we talk about facts, but also feelings matter, right? How you make a young man feel when you call him a certain word, how 5:23 you reaffirm him in his presence. And then I think about like, I studied media. I think about 1915, the first depiction of from Hollywood was the nigga through the birth of a nation. So now when we see people say we lazy or we don't have a certain type 5:35 of work ethic, that's because the only depiction you have of a black man out of America was the nigga. 5:38 You know what I mean? But reaffirm me and show me the wars that we won. Show me the people that did stand on something. Show me Hannibal. Show me the contributions we made to society. We ain't just niggas. 5:47 So not think of a nigga, I also think of those that's been lost and don't know the sense of self. 5:51 And we say that knowledge of self is not just violence prevention, but it also ignites collective liberation when you know who I am. So when I speak to young men, I understand the power of language, the neurological responses that 6:00 they ignite, but more importantly, how it makes somebody feel. 6:03 So I don't think we should use the word nigga at all. 6:05 So, Doc, and this is for Dr. Dyson, you are the one person on this panel who is like, yes, absolutely, my nigga. So on that, I'm curious to know, you know, when you hear these very visceral, passionate responses about what the N-word means to folks who are sitting here, Why 6:25 is your response so different, knowing its treacherous past, knowing its history, particularly when used to inflict pain, harm, or death upon black folks? Why is your response so different? 6:37 Look, listening to everybody here, with the exception of President Johnson, I know he shares views with others, I understand all that. 6:46 But language is flexible. Language is fluid. It evolves over space and time. And I acknowledge all of this at the same time when I was reading Dr. Hiram Smith's book, What's Up My Nigga, where he talks about the fact that very few people were actually kings. Most of us 7:04 were average black people. It's all right, I think, as Brother Jordan talked about it, to speak about us as kings and queens, but the average black person was not that. 7:16 So That's an assertion of a kind of idealized state of being as well. The reason, look, I didn't hear nigga first time from a rapper. I heard it from preachers. 7:27 If you read Dr. 7:27 Henry Mitchell's book about black preaching, he talks about an encounter between Sandy Ray out of Brooklyn and Dr. Frederick George Sampson, who happened to be my pastor in Detroit, and referring to each other or one to the other as my nigga. 7:41 Martin Luther King Jr. 7:42 the night before he died, playfully rebuked Andrew Young, by taking a pillow and saying, where you been, little nigger? Now, I don't think anybody's going to deny that Martin Luther King Jr., though he was certainly not perfect, was certainly 7:56 the embodiment of the struggle for Black self-determination and a positive self-conception as anybody ever in our community. So when I hear nigger, I hear warmth, I hear beauty, I hear terror. There's no question the fact that Black people 8:10 sometimes internalize what nigger means, but we know that it can be quite Problematic and it can also be quite complicated. 8:17 You can use it as a as a greeting. What's up, my nigga? 8:20 You can use it as an interrogation nigga Use it as celebration my nigga you can use it as a rebuff nigga so there are multiple ways in which nigga operates and we can say just like women use the B word and right, among themselves, not with us, or 8:42 gay and lesbian people have appropriated that term fag. 8:45 And use it among themselves. As Dr. Hiram Smith again points out, this didn't start with hip hop. Black people in the 1850s were using nigga. 8:55 And whether you think it's because of the deletion of the R that we did in the South or because we adopted some kind of British talk, the point is nigga is complicated and beautiful. 9:05 And what Black people have done with nigga is amazing. 9:08 What we have been able to manage a kind of complexity, a kind of nuance, a kind of rebuke to the world. 9:15 And I don't think. 9:16 that we should stop using it because white people get confused. 9:19 White people are grown. They go to the moon. They run parts of the world. They are billionaires, but they cannot say the word nigga, nigga, please. So I think that at the end of the day, we've got to assert the legitimacy of this term that has evolved out 9:33 of our culture, where we have sent messages to each other and to ourselves about both affirmation and recrimination and hurt and pain at the same time. 9:43 I want to go to Dara really quick. Because in 2007, the NAACP buried the N-word. buried the N-word. There was a whole casket. There were eulogies. From Julian Bond, y'all, to Kwame Kilpatrick. 10:12 Oh, boy. 10:13 There was a for real few. 10:14 Wow. 10:14 But I will ask you, D, what do you think has happened since that 2007 very, you know, dramatic ceremonial burial of the N-word. 10:25 So I'm going to start where Dr. Dyson left off. 10:30 As Black folks, we said culture. And people adapt how we move, how we sing, what we say. And in uses of the word, we're given license to folks outside of our community, whether we realize it or not. And so when we give that license and then we hear 10:45 it back and we get angry... Should we be getting angry or should we monitor how we want to be reflected? 10:53 You know, Birth of a Nation was mentioned earlier. 10:54 We got into trying to impact the images of black folks in 1915. We jumped on Amos and Andy, and you cannot find an Amos and Andy episode because of illegal settlement, the NAACP. 11:10 When Richard Pryor went to Africa and came back and did his standup, he said. 11:13 You know, we're not that. I will not use that word again. This is not about hip hop. This is not about how pretty or ugly a word is. This is about whether or not we're. 11:24 Gonna give other people a license. to use a word. 11:27 That has been offensive and have political and economic meaning as it relates to our well-being. 11:34 But don't you think? Y'all acting like we invented the term. 11:38 White folk invented the term. 11:39 It doesn't matter. 11:40 It does matter. It matters a whole lot. 11:42 Because if white folk invented it and now we're saying we don't want to give them license to say it, they didn't ask us for permission to say nigga. 11:48 They said it themselves. 11:50 What we did was try to engage in a kind of linguistic negotiation with the terms of our existence. And so you can take the word nigger away and they can still treat us like a nigger if they call us a hamburger or a cookie. The point is, at 12:03 the end of the day, we can't predicate our engagement with linguistic or rhetorical forces because of the fact that it might upset or it might create the belief in white people that they can't say it. 12:14 Most white folk know they can't say it. Most white folk don't say it. 12:17 The reason why you don't see people on television, on radio, and when they do as white people, they are rebuked. 12:23 They don't do it because there has been a limit established. 12:25 Brother Lenard talks about black privilege. That is a black privilege that I don't think we should easily surrender. And if we do so, if we do it based upon white people, that is the most white supremacist thing imagined, that now we have to genuflect before the altar of 12:39 their linguistic purity because they are afraid of their ears being penetrated by this word that they now feel that they have permission to say. 12:46 They ain't asking us for permission. They saying it regardless. 12:48 This ain't a black-white reality, right? If I go to Korea, I don't want to see Koreans calling me the N-word. 12:53 Absolutely. 12:54 If I go to China, I don't want them wrapping the N-word. 12:57 Because we are so domesticated, we don't realize the power of our culture and what people pick up and how they see us. 13:05 When I'm on the continent of Africa, any of the 54 countries. 13:08 They see a black American as being something from a. 13:12 Boys' hood. 13:14 We have to change the image by which people see us, how they hear us, and what they respond to. When I was in Detroit— I went to that better high school than you did. Western high school was the most diverse high school still is. If we catch one of 13:29 the white boys, Mexican or Puerto Ricans, saying it, they getting socked in the mouth. Why should we give people a license? 13:37 How are you giving them license, though? How are you using it, giving them license? 13:41 Because we set standards. We are the culture. People try to emulate us all the time. 13:46 But they know not to. But I'm saying most white people. 13:49 I'm not saying all white people. 13:50 I'm touching you right there. 13:50 Cite your sword. 13:51 You said they know not to. 13:53 I'm saying I'm saying empirically verifiable information and evidence suggests to us most white people in our presence in public. 14:01 I'm not brother. 14:02 Squires made a difference between commercial and private and public. 14:05 I'm saying in in public, most white folk are not saying the word nigger. 14:10 In our presence. 14:11 That's what I'm saying. I'm in public. 14:13 They can say, I can't control what they do at the crib. What they do at the crib is what they do at the crib. I'm saying there's a public censorship that is imposed upon white people to a degree that they don't feel. 14:25 Successfully able to do so or feel comfortable. Why do we know that? 14:29 Because when they do do it, it's news. When they do do it, it makes sense. Social media go crazy. 14:34 So my point is most white folk know what the limits are and they ain't operating with the belief that they have the ability to say it. 14:41 I just wanted to get in here five minutes ago. 14:43 Let me go to Liz. 14:43 I have a different point now, but I just feel like. 14:52 But I just think about all the different ways in which we have tried to assert ourselves with like respectability. 14:58 And it does not change the way we are perceived. 15:02 Like back in the early 19th century, there was a method that free people in the North used called moral suasion, that they were going to try to act and dress and behave in public in order to establish their citizenship. 15:14 They were not seen as citizens. It didn't matter what they were wearing and what they had on. that this white supremacy was larger than them. So I think that to me. 15:23 Elizabeth Higginbottom, that's the source she's still. 15:25 Thank you. 15:26 Thank you. 15:27 But I think, too, that there's like a. 15:29 There's a subversion. 15:31 There's a real subversion, satire, and protest when black people are using the N-word. 15:36 And I do think, listen, I don't want to use it. 15:39 I've never said it. 15:40 It is dry in my mouth. So I'm talking about people like my father, who was Richard Pryor, who stepped into that conversation and wanted to give voice to an authentic black reality. And I just think Thinking that taking that word out of black mouths is going to cure 15:58 the problem of white supremacy or white people saying it is, they had 400 years, right? They had 400 years to squash it and make it go away, and they didn't. 16:08 Yeah, go ahead. 16:08 No, I was going to say, the way I would want to come back in the conversation is to say, my decision to use or not use or my analysis of how people use the word does not begin with white people. 16:19 Right. 16:19 I grew up in New York City. I've been living in the D.C. 16:22 Area for almost 20 years. I live in a majority black county. I don't live my life saying, well, what do white people think about this particular thing? For me, what's much more important is not what other people call me. 16:32 It's what I answer to. It's what I believe about myself. 16:34 My wife and I are raising our four children. We don't raise them with specific values and principles because, well, when you go outside, a white person is going to see you this way. We raise them that way because we want them to know who they are and whose 16:45 they are. They're created in God's image. So for me, it's not whether white people use it or don't use it. And, you know, to the professor's point, I think, yes, white people don't use the word in public because there's certain 16:56 social sanctions that go along with that. My question to our community always comes back to the same thing. Why is it that we always have higher standards for white people than we do for ourselves? 17:06 Now, Delano. 17:07 I'll stand on that. Let me quote the professor. Let me quote the professor. 17:11 This is empirically true. 17:13 Hold on. 17:13 Hold on. 17:14 Hold on. 17:14 Hold on. 17:14 Hold on. 17:15 Hold on. 17:15 Hold on. 17:16 Hold on. 17:16 Hold on. 17:16 Hold on. 17:17 Hold on. 17:17 Hold on. 17:25 No, no, no. 17:26 OK, I want to hear your empirical. 17:27 We give white people more grace than we give each other. 17:30 I know that much. When it comes to language, when it comes to imagery, there's certain. 17:36 Let me tell you something. 17:37 If Eminem ever let the letters N-I-G get to the front of his lips, there would be boycotts all across urban radio. 17:43 He did as a young person. 17:44 He did, yeah. 17:45 And there's a price to pay. But there are artists who talk about GMO... Drill music as a subgenre is all GMO. Guns, murder, ops. 17:53 Right. 17:54 Nobody's getting boycotted. 17:55 The only time black artists get boycotted is if they say things against other protected communities. If they make jokes about LGBT people, if they say, oh, my money is kosher, then they have to apologize and they have to go. 18:08 Sit with a rabbi and do some training. 18:10 But that's easily explainable, right? Because you're not part of that community. That's fine. 18:15 I'm not talking about whether it's explainable. 18:16 I'm saying we should keep the standards high for ourselves because of ourselves, not in order to appease anybody else or to explain how anybody else lives. 18:25 Who said that, though? I think I'm struggling because I heard you say there was empirical data to support that we're harder on ourselves than we are to white people. 18:35 No, I'm saying we have higher standards. 18:37 Okay. 18:37 What is that source? Like, I don't, number one, I'm saying every, actually, let me go to the audience right now. 18:43 How many of you all grew up with, we have to be twice as good? Raise your hands. Okay. And even on the panel, at least, well, two of us, three of us. 18:51 Oh, Delano heard that too. Okay. 18:54 And so when we have to be twice as good as who? 19:00 Yeah. 19:00 As white people to get half as far. But but that's but here here here to make it just hit a point. 19:05 I make it a point. 19:06 I make it. 19:06 OK. 19:07 I'm saying and I'm only going to hip hop because hip hop ushered in the widespread commercial use of the word. 19:14 Right. 19:15 I'm going there because for the better part of the last 40 years, I've seen artists. 19:19 I'm at the site resource on that, too. Did hip hop. 19:22 It was hip-hop. 19:23 Widespread commercial use. 19:25 We don't need blaxploitation films. 19:27 No, not like that. 19:28 They never got as big as hip-hop. 19:30 Not hip-hop. Global phenomenon. 19:31 Widespread commercial use. 19:33 Black Power, Richard Pryor. 19:34 They didn't invent it. They glorified it. 19:36 They amplified it. 19:37 Amplification. 19:39 I'll give you that. 19:39 International. 19:40 They exported it around the world. 19:41 I mean, the reason Calvin Butts had a steamroller roll over CDs, right, in New York City and see Loris Tucker was because of the use of that language. And so, again, I'm talking about the commercial use. And the question I'll pose to the professor, the good professor is. 19:58 Do you, if you hear artists saying it, right? Okay, that's part of their. 20:02 But what if you go to a concert and you see white people in the audience repeating it? 20:07 Yes. 20:07 Would you be offended by that? 20:08 Absolutely. 20:09 That's the part that... That's the. 20:10 Point I was making earlier. Wait a minute. Are you telling me that white people are. 20:17 insignificantly unintelligent that they can't determine that you can say this, but you can't say this. I can say all this part until the N word. And if some rapper gives them permission to say so, this is what I say. 20:29 Be careful because rapper X can tell you to do that, but homeboy B outside this stadium is going to whip your ass if you try to repeat that word. 20:37 So I'm saying I don't infantilize white people. 20:39 Why do the gymnastics of it? Because it's not necessary. 20:43 I mean, you got 50 million words. 20:46 Why is that? 20:48 I got 100 million. 20:49 Why is it the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People? 20:55 I was going there next. Don't be taking my question. 20:57 No, no, no. 20:58 I'm saying. 20:58 Why? 20:59 Because I can tell you why. 21:00 Because when we were created, those around the table, they were not considered white, although we may consider them white today. 21:04 White is a social construct. So folks who sat around that table was around that table for their own protection. 21:10 If you was Irish, Italian, if you was Jewish, that's colored in that context in 1909. 21:14 2026. 21:14 That's where we are. That's why it was created then. 21:18 You asked why color. That's why. 21:20 No, I'm not asking about then. I understand then. 21:22 I'm saying right now, why is it that the NAACP hasn't changed its name? Because you have a brand. You have an identification. People understand what color means now. It's circled around. 21:31 People love color. But guess what we have done since I've been in? 21:34 We market the five letters and not the name that go under there because the brand you cannot change. Coca-Cola was about cocaine getting a drink, but they're not going to change their name from Coca-Cola. 21:43 You're making my point for me. It's complicated. 21:45 It's nuanced. 21:45 It's complicated. 21:46 No, you didn't say it was cool. She said that. 21:47 She said that. 21:49 You didn't say that. 21:49 You can't use it. It's beautiful. 21:51 You're mine. 21:52 One thing I wanted to say, because again, I... Hey, because we can't be. 21:57 Here all day, friends. 22:06 I appreciate claim one. 22:07 Dr. 22:08 Dyson, it sounds like it's changed from a hard yes to a complicated. 22:11 Oh, no. 22:11 Oh, no. Nigga. 22:14 I mean, no. 22:15 I'm straight nigga. Okay, my nigga. 22:18 We going to claim two. 22:19 Right. All right. 22:20 So before we get into the second claim, which is that the N-word is derived from the Amharic word negus, which means king. Let's roll this clip. 22:30 Negus. 22:31 Negus. 22:32 Could you use it in a sentence? 22:33 Negus. 22:34 The Negus ruled Ethiopia until the coup of 1974. 22:37 So I wanted to play that in part because our EP Geraldine has a lifeline we called earlier. Jaime Asifa told us that that was not the pronunciation, the correct pronunciation of a king. It's actually Negus, which is king. 22:56 And for women, for queen, it's Negus. And so when you hear Negus and that T is kind of soft, You know, Kendrick said, I'm going to do a little artwork here. Pulitzer Prize winning hip hop artist, Kendrick Lamar. 23:11 He is a Pulitzer Prize winning. 23:15 He is. 23:15 Anyway. 23:16 But you know that's complicated. 23:17 Well, I'm not doing this today. That's another show. And I'm going to fight it out with Kendrick. 23:22 What's up, Drake? 23:23 Oh, Lord. 23:26 Oh, that's a show. That's a show. 23:31 Y'all, this is not versus. 23:33 This is not versus. 23:34 But in relationship to what you're talking about though, Kendrick says, I am not black. 23:39 Hey, for the record, Drake can only say Nick. He can only say half of it. 23:44 Drake said, light skin still a dark nigga. 23:46 Kendrick said, I'm black, don't call me black no more. 23:49 That's your king? 23:49 All right, I'm just saying. 23:50 Anyway, back to claim two. 23:53 Yes. 23:54 We like to talk about things that come up. This is, of course, on his record, To Pimp a Butterfly. And at the end of the record, he cites that we use Negus as N-E-G-U-S. And it's a way of saying king. 24:07 How many of you all agree with Kendrick on this? 24:10 And can you cite your source? 24:11 I can say why I disagree with it. 24:14 I would love to hear it because I know you stay ready. Don't say anything bad about Kendrick. 24:17 No, I love Kendrick. Kendrick is a genius. 24:20 Yeah. 24:20 But Dr. 24:21 Hiram Smith, again, goes through this whole kind of etymological derivation. 24:25 And he shows that Negus, why would. 24:27 A slave master call his chattel enslaved people kings and queens, right? 24:32 Then he talks about the Amharic and that it had no relationship to Central and West Africa versus what was going on in Ethiopia. So it sounds great because it makes you feel good. You're calling each other king, but that's not where it derives from. Then he goes through 24:47 the Spanish version, the Portuguese version, the French version, the Latin version. It is a complicated amalgamation of different, you know, etymological derivations. 24:55 So, but that ain't one of them. 24:57 That does not represent what happens when black people are doing their thing with niggas. 25:01 Well, you brought up our good friend, Dr. Hiram Smith. 25:05 And this is his book, What's Up, My Nigga? He is in the audience with us today. He has done a ton of research, including researching more than 2,300 stories of formerly enslaved people listening to that audio podcast. Talk 25:18 to us about the real origin story, since it's not Amharic, the Amharic tradition. 25:22 Thanks for having me. Well, the origins of the term nigger, hard R, they are complicated. And one of the reasons why it's so complicated is because we don't have a lot of written documentation of the term until you get up to about the 18th and 19th centuries. But what 25:42 we do know is that the term originated with Latin, the Latin word nigger. Now, a lot of people try to pronounce it as Niger, but that is not how the word was pronounced in Latin. 25:52 The guh was. 25:53 Always hard, and the I was always pronounced as E. Now, Oxford English Dictionary lists the first attestation of nigger in English as 1577 and 1584 by educated men who knew how to read and write Latin. But we have to 26:12 take into consideration the transatlantic slave trade. all of the colonial powers who were involved in the slave trade had some form of the word that they had borrowed from Latin that meant black person, and it was related to 26:30 the term nigger in English. So in French, you had negra. 26:33 In Spanish, you had negro. In Portuguese, negro, which in Spanish and Portuguese, by the way, they weren't borrowed. They were passed down through centuries of unbroken communication. You have the Dutch neger. And the question is, how do you 26:51 adjudicate between all of these different potential contributors? Well, we know that in the Caribbean, before these islands in the Caribbean became permanent colonies, they were passed around and colonial powers were vying. 27:05 For those places. 27:09 It's possible that all of these terms, negra, neger, Negro, Niger, have contributed to what we have in the English language today. 27:21 We can't really definitively say where the word comes from, but it came from one of those sources. One of the things that we can definitely say is it did not come from Negus. Ethiopia wasn't even part of the transatlantic slave trade. You're on the wrong side of the map. 27:36 It's a beautiful, it sounds beautiful. 27:38 I wish it were true. 27:39 But it's just not true. 27:41 Sorry, Kendrick. 27:42 OK, well, that's the only place where Kendrick is losing in my eyes. I really appreciate that. Thank you so much, Dr. Smith. 27:50 Let's talk for a moment about our power. And I think that this is important, an important transition before we get to claim three, because there is something I think that you all are seeing about us holding on to this word culturally in hip hop. At home, playing a 28:06 spades game, I play dominoes, dominoes, whatever it is, there's something about it. And in an earlier conversation, Dr. Smith and I got to do my podcast about this very thing. 28:14 And I was really wrestling with this idea that we don't have much power. This is one thing that belongs to us that we are refusing to kind of give up. Liz, I want to come to you because I think about your father. When I was two, my dad had a 28:33 Richard Pryor special on My mom told my dad that was not a good idea. I repeated words he said. 28:38 They were curse words, not nigga, but I probably would have said that too if he got there. He did have kind of a pilgrimage back to the continent and changed his mind, but originally his use of the word was still a form of protest. 28:51 Yes, that's right. 28:52 I mean, he decided that he was going to give up like the comedy shtick and that he was going to embrace where he really came from, which was He came from an impoverished part of Peoria, Illinois, and he was going to speak the way that his people spoke. 29:07 And that was using the N-word in the house. That was talking about sex in a way that maybe people didn't in other families. 29:14 That was, you know, all of those things. 29:16 And even talking about racism in the police, you know, police brutality, that he was going to do that on stage and start cultivating that authentic voice. And part of that was using the N-word. Two of his Grammy Award-winning albums have the N-word in the titles. But then at 29:32 the end of that decade, he followed many people like that Alex Haley pilgrimage back to Africa. He went to Kenya, which is East Africa. Most people went to West Africa, but he still went. And he said he took stock and looked around and said, in this context of Black 29:49 people doing the most menial jobs and Black people running the country, does the N-word work here? 29:56 In this context. 29:57 And he said it didn't, that he hadn't thought it, that he hadn't said it, and that it wasn't working for him anymore. And that he said he was never going to call another black. 30:04 Man the N-word. 30:07 I'm curious to know what else you all might think about our source of power. Is this a thing that we should be leaning up against as one thing we can have that other folks can't touch? Or is it. 30:16 I don't understand why using that word would make anybody feel powerful. 30:21 You know, like the good brother. 30:24 Doc said something earlier when he was saying that white people invented the word. 30:26 I don't understand, you. 30:28 Know, using a word that we know our oppressors were using to dehumanize us and then continuing to call our own people that. And when I was younger, I read a book that I even reference now called From Niggas to Gods by a brother named Akeel. And he used 30:42 to talk about, you know, the N word being your lower nature and how you should never submit your will to your lower nature. You should submit your will to the God in you, which was your higher nature. So the name of the book was literally from N-words to gods. 30:54 And it always made me think like, I don't want to be in the N-word mind state. And if the white man did invent that word, I want to return that word to cinder. I don't have any usage of that word, you know, at 48 years old in 2026. 31:07 I don't know why that word makes people feel powerful. 31:10 It doesn't make me feel powerful when I use it. 31:12 Well, I mean, look, point taken. 31:15 But the point is that the word exists in an ecosystem of where we have been stigmatized and demonized? Have we internalized it without question? The panel has been brilliant about that. Have we reproduced the very thing that we 31:28 are arguing against? We have, but that's not all we've done. 31:31 Because when I hear the word nigga, I hear a form of collective intimacy. 31:36 I hear my hood in Detroit. I hear my pastor. 31:39 I hear the people that were associated with that church from niggas to gods. 31:44 I get that. 31:44 But I've been as a Baptist preacher for more than 40 years, I've seen some of the worst pathologies associated with Christianity or religion or God that have tried to sneak in some of the worst beliefs about the human being. 32:01 That nigga pales in comparison, so to speak. So my point is that if we have developed this word, some of us dig it, some of us don't. Some of us understand we think it has power, some of us don't. 32:12 I think it clearly has power because we're having a television show about it. We're not having a television show about cracker. We're not OFE or what's going on. This word has a unique register and it does signify a certain kind of power. And yes, we have been denied 32:29 a whole bunch of other things. Why would we surrender the privilege Right. Martin Luther King Jr. 32:35 Using it. 32:35 And if King can use it, I'm saying we can have a lot of arguments against it. But I think that it shows that there is a complicated and nuanced way we can do it now. And by saying this, yes, Red Fox, Richard Pryor, the earlier generations got mad at hip hop because hip hop. 32:51 As Brother Squire said, put it in the commercial realm, right? 32:55 We were playing those records, those were party records, but they weren't circulating to the dominant culture. There's no question that hip hop has amplified that to the world. And there's no question that if black women traveled the world, Mr. Johnson, 33:08 And they get pinched on their behind because somebody saw a rap video, right? So I'm not arguing with that. 33:14 We can't say some of this stuff is out of control and so on and so forth. But when we say out of control, you stop using the N-word. You're still a sexist. You're still a patriarch. You're still a misogynist. 33:23 So my point is, let's deal with the fact that the word has come to be what it is. Yes, white people invented it. But like gay people take the word back, like women take the word back. And they don't even mean sometimes physical, I mean, human beings, right? 33:36 When you say we up in this... Or we up in this, as Dr. Smith talked about in his book or in a speech where we talk about that cat, that nigga did this. So we understand the complicated use of that term if it has historically been associated with people on a slave plantation. 33:54 They used that term. We're talking about our ancestors. 33:56 Our ancestors saw virtue and value in a term, and they were far closer to being dominated by white supremacy than any of us are here today. So I think that our own history suggests that there is a power, a power of self-definition. a power of self-love, a power 34:12 of irreverence, and a power of making class distinctions that sometimes make bourgeois Negroes upset, that make poor black people upset, that we have to contend with in a very serious fashion. 34:22 I wonder, do we even still use it as a term of endearment in 2026? Yeah. 34:28 You know what I hear? 34:28 I hear, fuck nigger, broke nigger, bitch nigger, young nigger. 34:33 I saw some YNs. 34:34 At the gas station this weekend. I went to the other gas station. 34:36 Right, and when I went to the office. 34:38 Wait, wait, wait. 34:40 Hold on. 34:42 I didn't even get to the button. That's the anointing. 34:45 It just hovers. Jordan, before you jump in here. Leonard, you said you saw what at the gas station? 34:51 Some YNs. 34:52 What's a YN? 34:53 He just said it. 34:55 It stands for young nigga. 34:56 I know. But what he's speaking to, though, is important. 34:58 When we think about words, we also think about imagery. 35:00 When I teach young black men, so I think it's also a reference point that we could do the scholastic conversation and all the studies. But I'm talking about when you're speaking to a young man, you ask him, what's the difference between a young man and a young nigga? 35:11 He got two images in his head of himself. So we're not comparing our enslavement, our oppression to any other group because it's much different. To be brought to America, stripped of an identity, then now I'm trying to reaffirm you on who you are. Language is one of the 35:22 first bases of a naming system. We name everything not only as a classification, but as an identification. And then when you take on the word, that's a self-fulfilling prophecy, meaning I'm taking ownership of a word that was used 35:32 to not only degrade my ancestors, but to categorize me in a particular identification system. So I would never ever use the word when I'm teaching young black men. I'm not saying saying, yo, what up, my nigga? I'm saying you not a nigga. 35:43 Yeah. 35:44 Why do you feel uncomfortable calling me a God? That's another question. We talk about 5% of the nation of Islam. 35:49 All these other groups that also made a big contribution to the black male existence within America. And the terminology language that they use was never going to ever justify the use of. 35:56 A colonial term on our people. 35:58 I don't know no other group that do it. 36:00 People will be even, we even refrain from using the term, the derogatory term to refer to any other ethnic group that we know of. Because we know it comes with ramifications, but yet using nigga seemed like it was supposed to be a cultural acceptance. 36:11 Like, nah, you a nigga. No, you not. 36:13 And why is there a resistance to speaking to our higher purpose? 36:16 Why is there a resistance to say, you know what, we are better than this. And we can glamify the word. 36:22 I mean, you know, the word MF got multiple meanings. 36:25 But we don't have to go and say you're MF and you're an MF, you my MF. Why should we hold on to something? 36:31 But we definitely do. 36:34 I didn't say we didn't. Don't hit it no more. 36:36 I didn't say we didn't. 36:39 Because at the end of the day, all of us up here, we have to set an example. And if we want to move forward, young people are looking at us. 36:49 They're listening to us. 36:50 And the three things that really set an example is what we say, what we do, and how we show up. 36:56 Right. 36:56 And I think that's the most important part here. We should be operating to our highest purpose because we don't know what five-year-old, seven-year-old, 15-year-old. 37:03 But taking what you're saying, look, some African-Americans have abandoned black folks, some some colored people, some black people have. 37:11 But the niggas showed up for those people who are I'm saying who are poor, dispossessed. So they see in that particular figure, they don't see that term as derisive. 37:22 They don't see that term as necessarily derisive. emblematic of the antagonism that we've been encouraged to have. 37:29 They see something different. It doesn't have to be in their head. 37:32 And I have a question. 37:35 When you teach, have you ever asked any of the young black men in your classroom, are you a nigga? 37:40 Ask them that. Absolutely. 37:41 And what do they say to you? 37:42 Yes, I am. 37:43 And what do they mean by that? 37:44 They mean a lot of different things. They mean that I'm a. 37:47 Who is they? 37:49 Michael Eric Dyson class at Vanderbilt University. 37:51 Right? 37:53 Yeah, I'm citing my damn self. This the nigga I know best. And what I'm saying to you is that all I'm saying is that I agree. 38:02 I agree with what they're saying in terms of what it can mean, but it doesn't have to mean that, right? 38:08 Necessity is one thing. It can mean all that stuff, but it can also mean, when you talk about self-identified as a determined figure to do well, I keep saying Martin Luther King Jr. 38:18 he ain't the only one. 38:19 I'm saying a lot of other brothers and sisters that I know who are high-ranking, who are loving themselves, also understand the intimacy of that term and don't have to be seen as self-hating. 38:29 You know what else they did back then? They cooked with lard. Are you cooking with lard? 38:33 Not at all. 38:34 So why can't you drop the word? Because he said it then. 38:36 You just told me you kept color for a reason. 38:39 Because he said it then doesn't mean we have to do it now. 38:41 I understand that. We evolve. 38:43 Allow him to evolve and allow us to evolve and drop the word. 38:46 Dr. 38:46 King is here right now. 38:47 Allow me to evolve this conversation because We don't have that much time, but I do want to, you can respond in your next response. 38:56 Okay. 38:56 I want to ask a truthful question. Please be honest. 39:00 For some of you, I can hit the button because I know you very well. The question is, do you use the N-word? 39:08 No. Yes. No. 39:10 Sometimes. 39:11 No. It's complicated. 39:14 Eyes ready to light your ass up. 39:22 That's because you intimidated him and he knew. 39:25 No, I'm trying. I strive not to. You know, I. 39:28 Literally, it was this year that really made me be like, yo, I gotta dead this work. 39:31 What happened? 39:32 When the whole Fat Joe situation happened. 39:34 Because. 39:35 Hold on, Lenard. 39:36 For those of you at home that don't know what happened with Fat Joe, we're going to go ahead and run this clip. 39:40 Because I heard when that was going on, you said, yo, Fat Joe ain't black. 39:43 No, I am black. Fat Joe is the blackest. 39:46 Nigga you ever seen in your life. 39:50 Go look it up! 39:51 I don't want to say the N-word, okay? 39:53 I wish I could stop saying it. 39:54 I know better and don't do better, okay? 39:56 And I know there is nothing funnier to white supremacists than to see a bunch of black and brown people arguing. 40:02 About who can use the word nigga. 40:04 Do we not realize how silly that looks? 40:07 And I wanted to start there. This is actually the beginning of our third claim, which is it is socially acceptable for white people and individuals of other racial backgrounds to say the N-word. I want to make sure people 40:21 understand at home, Fat Joe's dad is Afro-Cuban. There's another clip we're going to play just a moment after this. But, Lenard, first, I want to hear your point. What made you change your mind about it this year? 40:32 Well, I mean, because I've always known better. 40:34 Like, you know, the first book my father ever gave me was the autobiography. 40:37 Of Malcolm X. 40:38 And then that led me to read, you know, Message to the Black Man by the Honorable Elijah Muhammad. Then I read from, you know, Niggas to God by Akil. 40:44 So I never wanted to call myself the N-word. That's why I call myself... Charlemagne the God. And then, you know, just throughout time, just being in the environments that we grow up in, you do find yourself using the word. 40:55 But then I found myself realizing I'm not using this word as a term of endearment. I'm using it the way, you know, the white people use it. And so when I heard Fat Joe have that comment, when I heard Fat Joe say that, I wasn't even mad at what 41:07 Fat Joe said when I heard the discourse around it. 41:10 Nothing made sense to me. There was no justification for using the words. 41:15 I was just like, you know what? I'm going to let it go. 41:17 Give that back to the white people because I know better. 41:19 Yeah. 41:20 And I think part of it is because we have this tension and going back to the good professor when I asked him, if you had a concert and you hear, you know, an artist use the word and you look to your left and you see, you know, a white 41:32 concert girl who paid for the ticket. Repeat the word. 41:35 Would you consider that offensive? 41:36 And he said, yes. 41:37 And I think the problem is we assume that a word can be permanently fixed for one group of people, anybody nonwhite, and permanently fluid for a second group of people, anybody who's black. 41:47 And that just doesn't make any sense. 41:48 To Charlamagne's point, you know, that word is still the last word that many thousands of black men hear. Right before another black man takes their life in this country, in the year of our Lord, 2026. 42:00 But again, to the professor's point, is that the only way that black people? Of course not. And I know a lot of older black folks and they will use the word. But again, it's private. 42:09 So how you communicate privately is different than how you communicate publicly. And that's much different than how you communicate commercially. 42:15 And the last thing I'll say is this. We live in an era where it's not just black and white. 42:19 There's an Asian kid today who's going to school and he's telling his Hispanic friend, oh, what up, man? The idea that he's saying that because, oh, man, I want to lynch this guy clearly doesn't make sense. So the word is fluid, but it's fluid for everybody. And the 42:34 question to me is not whether it's socially acceptable because nobody's asking for permission to use language nowadays. 42:40 Why is it fluid to everybody? So for you, if you're at a concert, you know, Jay just did his final show in L.A., If he says the N-word quite a bit in his performance, you see a white concert goer singing along with the N-word, your response is? 42:56 Nothing. 42:57 But again, part of it, I don't live my life based on what white people do, think, or say. 43:01 Now, Delano, that's hard for me to understand because you work at the Heritage Foundation. 43:05 Come with it. 43:06 Can I respond? 43:06 You got the mic. 43:08 Oh, so the reason I'm there and the reason that I do the work that I do around marriage and family structure is is because many of our institutions do not do that work. So my presence there is a judgment in many respects. 43:20 I got it. 43:21 With all due respect and. 43:22 Humility, Every time the NAACP has a national conference, the National Urban League has a national conference, the Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies has a national conference, the Congressional Black Caucus has a national conference. 43:51 I either go to the agenda, foundation, excuse me. 43:54 I either go to the agenda or I show up and I look to see state of the black family, decline in black marriage rates, nothing. 44:02 I was at CBC last month, nothing about marriage. Foundation, CBC Foundation. So I say that we're all- Have you. 44:08 Ever proposed a panel? 44:10 I did, actually. 44:11 You did? 44:11 Yes. 44:11 Who did you send it to? 44:12 To the president of the CBC Foundation and the vice president. 44:15 I did, actually. 44:16 Did they respond to you? 44:17 No, but I spoke to the vice president. And hopefully we'll connect. And I would love to connect with Mr. 44:21 Johnson. 44:22 And let me just say this, because I do want to get back to the N-word. And Delano knows he's welcome to come back on the show where we deal with the family. 44:28 Please do. 44:29 Because I think that we all care about the preservation of the family. I think what's tough here is there were still some illogical leaps that were made around the content of those conversations. For example, I was at the NAACP. 44:42 So this is a primary source talking. We held a panel and a live podcast where we included conversations around Nolan Wells and his family. Nolan Wells' family were centered. 44:54 You see the preservation of a black family unit. A very caring family who lost a young man who may have been called the N-word upon his death. We don't know. 45:04 And probably was not killed by a black person. So there are conversations we have around family, but they are intersectional conversations. A term that was coined by the amazing Kimberly Crenshaw. And intersectionality has a lot to do with 45:19 why you may not see marriage or family on a panel by itself, but it's absolutely discussed. 45:25 In this country, 70% of black children are born to unmarried parents. In New York City, it's 75%. In D.C., it's 77%. In Baltimore, it's 83%. In Louisiana, Mississippi, and Arkansas, it's 82%. 45:36 The idea that we would be. 45:38 The centers for disease control look up final birthday. 45:42 I'm not listening to centers of disease control right now. 45:45 For a lot of reasons. 45:47 Hold on. Hold on. 45:47 Because I think I think I think I think you made a good point. 45:51 Right. 45:51 I'm not talking about whether we discuss issues facing black families. 45:56 I'm talking about the decline of the married two-parent household. 45:59 Let me be very specific with my language. And what I'm saying is that marriage and family structure policy is not a priority on the institutions that claim to represent black people. 46:09 What is marriage and family structure policy? What does that even mean? 46:15 Is it having a job to pay as a fair wage? 46:18 Is it healthcare access? Is it quality education? 46:22 It's having access to your dad on an everyday basis because he's married to your mom and he lives with her. 46:26 Well, maybe we. 46:27 Should talk about the mass incarceration rates. 46:29 No, no, no. 46:29 Yes, we should. 46:30 You know what? 46:30 Let me do this. 46:34 The Reverend Jesse Jackson, God bless his soul, was deeply involved with speaking about family structure and argued about the particular ways in which the families were pulverized and pounded. 46:54 By these social structures. 46:56 And he talked about the relationship between, so we don't do it in a way that some of our white conservative brothers and sisters do it to extract it from the larger flow of white supremacy, social injustice, and public policy that imposed certain. 47:11 Limits upon it. We know that the The Monaghan. 47:13 Report in 1965, if I can cite the source, where he talked about a tangled web of pathology. I don't think a black mouth replicating a white supremacist logic is paying attention to the black family. 47:25 And Brother Squires, I'm glad you were there. But the Heritage Foundation has done. 47:29 More damage to African-American peoples and the conception of what the family is about than a whole bunch of other things than any niggas that I know. 47:37 So what I'm saying is that what. 47:39 We have to do is pay attention— But pay attention to the serious ways in which those issues are real, but not extracted from other issues that we pay attention to. 47:51 So did the Heritage Foundation have anything to do with Trayvon Martin and the way in which he had a mother and father who were healthy and alive? Are these other black families where they have a mother and father there? No, 48:02 because they have a preset ideological formation that judges the black family before they try to help it. So at the end of the day, I think that what you're I'm glad that you were there. But let's let's own up to the fact that the Heritage Foundation has been 48:15 wholly destructive in so many different ways. And I can cite them sources for the reports that have been done. 48:20 But let me get back to the N-word thing here in terms of what I think that look, black people have a complicated relationship. Yes, to that word. But I'm an absolutist when it comes to this. that if you are black you can do it and if you ain't 48:34 you can't and it ain't that it ain't that hard and white folk do a lot of other stuff why are we worried about uh if we say it others will say it i can guarantee you this if every black person in america stops saying the n-word right now 48:47 stop saying today it's not going to stop any of the processes that are already in place because the naacp buried that word that was resurrected in a second yeah right so i'm saying to you right and i use that metaphorically as a metonym for a particular. 49:02 Place of course we don't know what a metonym. 49:05 Is m-e-t-o-n-y-m one thing standing in for the other you say where my cash is speaking about your money so i'm saying that in that sense that you can't bury a word. The belief that you can even bury a word given the complicated and nuanced interpretation to which it 49:23 is lent and the black people who have invested serious engagement with that word, who are not stereotypes of self-hatred, who believe that young boys can be kings and girls be queens. 49:34 Who believe that black people can make an advance. 49:36 If we are so vulnerable that one word can just derail us because we use it, then who's really got the power? 49:44 And what are we saying about our own sites? 49:46 It's not about being derailed, right? I don't believe in the performative stuff. So that's why I haven't even tried to defend the barrier to N-word. I am saying, why are we not shooting for a higher purpose? 49:56 What are we saying? 50:00 What we do and how we show up. 50:01 I wrote 28 books. Most of them don't have anything in them. 50:05 Most. 50:07 Most. 50:09 Oh, I got nigga evidence. Wait a minute. My book on Tupac has to have nigga. My book about white people has. 50:14 To have nigga. I don't need you to justify why you got it in there. 50:17 All I'm saying is. 50:18 Why are we not trying to project a higher purpose? 50:22 People are watching. 50:23 Who said that? Hit the thing. Who said that's higher? 50:26 Hold on. 50:27 Hold on. 50:27 Excuse me, guys. Yes, I'll do this. But here's why. 50:30 We're still on claim three. And Claim 3 is about people of other races using this word. Okay, let me just roll this clip for you because sometimes it might be a condition. Let's roll that clip. 50:45 First BAFTA of the night for a vital part of movie making. 50:51 Okay, so in response to that clip. 50:53 Here's the problem. It's not only that he said it. 50:56 It was on delay. They didn't stop it. 50:59 They allowed it to fester before they reacted to it in response to the outrage. 51:05 Yeah. 51:06 So it wasn't just him. We have softened that culture that is OK. 51:11 Yeah. 51:12 That's the problem. 51:13 Well, let me I just have a question for you, for Delroy Lindo and for Michael B. 51:17 Jordan. 51:18 Would your responses have been the same to that? Because I don't think mine would have been. When he yells it out and they just stand in there like. 51:27 They're probably in shock. 51:28 I would have been in shock, but I would have shocked them back. 51:31 I wouldn't put the burden on them because they're trying to be decent and embodying all of the higher virtues. 51:38 That we want to see. 51:39 Because a nigga would have said, did they crack. 51:44 It? 51:45 But look, a physical symptom of a disease, yes, is a category. But here's the question. Why is it that you didn't say anything else? Why didn't you say F? 51:53 Why didn't you say B? 51:54 Why didn't you say? So even later. 51:56 Well, I'm just saying that even in the ecosystem of demonization. 52:02 that penetrates even people with those kind of diseases. So I just say at the end of the day, again, if you black, yes, if you not black, then no. 52:10 And I don't think it's any complicated to say there's some stuff, you know, right now, there's some stuff you will never say, not in public. 52:16 You know it right now, you will never utter it. 52:18 And I'm saying the so-called nigga, that censorship exists for a reason and it offers privilege to people who have very little else in this world. And we can teach them to raise, I got a PhD from Princeton. I'm a from the west side of Detroit. I was raised 52:33 by people who understood what were about, who taught me the difference between as our young brother Jordan was talking about and demonizing and hating ourselves. We can do all of that. If Martin Luther King can do it, I think anybody can do it. And we can say with 52:47 a poise and equanimity, yes, we understand what we should do and not do. We understand when we should say it and not say it. And at the end of the day, we have the right and privilege to do so. 52:56 And I think that that is not a white supremacist notion, that's a black self-determination. 53:01 Let me tell you one thing, Gok is leading on this Martin Luther King piece. You know, when white people say, I have black friends. 53:08 I have a dream. 53:10 Liz has been trying to get in, let this lovely queen reclaim her time. I mean, this is what my book is about, is that. 53:18 When they were up there on stage, there's a trauma and a shock that happens in that moment. To expect somebody to respond in that moment to being dressed up to the nines at this highfalutin award ceremony and then hear this lowest attack that you could possibly hear. 53:37 How do you respond? 53:39 What I'm trying to write about through this book is talk about intersectionality. is how the emotional and the history and the personal come together. And that's what makes this word so deeply complicated is because I could map my 53:54 entire life by the times I was called and confronted the N-word unexpectedly and reacted in some ways the same way those two did on stage. And that's, I mean, I think that's what's important is to know that they were doing the very best they could in that scene. 54:09 And what Sister Pryor is saying is true because every time we hear a white person use the N-word, we get triggered because of generational trauma. 54:17 Thank you. 54:19 So that's a good point, too. So speaking of hearing white people create a generational trauma response... Let us roll this clip where Chris Rock is with the White Kings of Comedy. 54:30 He's the blackest white guy I fucking know. 54:33 And in all the negative things we think about black people, this fucker. 54:38 You're saying I'm a nigger. 54:39 Yes, you are the niggerest fucking white man I have ever. 54:48 The context of this is very important. 54:50 OK, I can't wait to hear this. 54:51 No, because Chris started off by saying black people. But then he said, you have all of the negative traits of black people. 54:59 So then Louis C.K. 55:00 Said the N-word because in his mind, N-word is the person with all the negative traits of a black person. 55:07 Well, and also Chris Rock. 55:10 Said that in his own HBO special. 55:13 From Niggas to Black People, one of my favorite comedies. 55:15 And he repented. But he did rethink it. 55:18 Think about the comedy writers for, not Jamie Foxx, Kevin Hart. 55:24 And that stand-up and all of the offensive jokes that those writers, all white writers. 55:28 Wrote, and people read them. 55:29 Yeah, right. 55:31 That's a problem. 55:32 We should like, wait a minute, for them to feel like they have license, where's they getting it from? 55:37 They're getting it because we've set a culture that is okay. 55:40 And it's not just Chris Rock and Louis C.K. Going back to the clip with Fat Joe. When Fat Joe asserts, I'm the blackest N-word you know, he's not doing that because he said, you know, I'm the most entrepreneurial. I'm the most faithful to my wife. And this is the problem. 56:00 Oftentimes when we talk about blackness. It is defined within a context of negativity. 56:06 And even the fact... I don't think. 56:08 So first Joe said... Joe didn't just say, I'm the blackest nigga you know. He said, I'm black. 56:12 Correct. 56:12 Then he said, I'm the blackest nigga you know. 56:14 Correct. 56:14 And let's be clear. 56:15 And he's not actually saying it in a negative connotation. 56:18 He's talking about being down for the culture. 56:22 Part of what Joe Crack is saying is like, look, I was running through the Bronx doing what I was doing. 56:26 I'm putting it in its proper context. 56:28 But you can't properly contextualize it when that's not what he said. 56:33 Joe's not separate from the culture. He's in the culture. 56:36 He's Afro-Latino. We're stretching the Afro. 56:41 No, we're not. 56:42 Not at all. I cite my source because Joe himself has said his dad is Afro-Cuban. You got a DNA you want to run that we don't know about, though? 56:51 No, you go ahead. 56:52 The domestic violence is not the end of black people. 57:00 The transatlantic slave trade was from the Caribbean all the way up. 57:05 Whether it was on, I don't know, Cuba, Hispano. I mean, it's all of that. 57:09 Most black folk went to Brazil. 57:11 More blacks down in Africa. So when we get narrow and say, well, he's not part of black culture. No, he is a part of the black culture. 57:17 Oh, I agree with that. I'm saying if he's black, then he's got the right to say it. But let me tell you this. 57:22 If he weren't, if he weren't, if he were a Latino who didn't have that black culture. 57:26 No, bro. 57:27 I don't care how many. Look, did y'all ever see the series Curb Your Enthusiasm? 57:32 Absolutely. 57:32 Remember when the black guy says to Larry David, are you my nigga? What does Larry David say? First of all, he know not to say, yeah, I'm your nigga. He says, yeah, are you my Caucasian? because he understood that that was a limit. And I'm saying, why are we making this 57:48 more complicated than it is? White folk, for the most part, in public space, do not say that word because the stigma associated with it has revealed Black people's ability to take back a word that white folks said and flip it around. Now, I get the fact that you say, 58:03 why do we spend all that time doing that? We should be doing other stuff. We can eat and chew gum and spit and do things at the same time. 58:10 It's not either or. 58:11 We can talk about niggas, and we can talk about getting PhDs and doctorates and attorneys and entrepreneurs and working at the Heritage Foundation. 58:19 Jesus. And being able to do all of that at the same time. 58:23 That's the ad hominem attack. Did we really? 58:27 Jesus, the Lord of salvation. 58:29 Did we really take the word back, though? 58:31 No. 58:31 No. 58:31 Because if we took it back, why do we get offended when we hear other people say it, even if they're using it in its proper context? 58:35 Thank you. 58:36 There you go. 58:36 I can answer that. 58:37 That's not their, it's not their word. So on that. 58:39 Can I say one more thing? 58:40 Yes, sir. 58:41 You know, another thing that happens in that clip, I don't like when people use the word nigga and black as if they're synonymous with each. 58:48 Other, right? 58:49 Because the thing I used to hate the most, and y'all can explain this to me because y'all really, really came up in that era. In the 90s when they would say Bill Clinton was the first black president. 58:57 Why? Because he got some head and smoked some weed? 59:00 And played saxophone. 59:01 That's the reason they used to say it. 59:03 Toni Morrison is the one who came up for it in the New Yorker magazine. She was talking about how he was being demonized, how he was being misrepresented. as despite all of his achievements, he was still being reduced. 59:14 But demonized for what? Getting ahead. 59:18 And not ahead of him. 59:19 That was simultaneous convergence of incidental facts. 59:25 She was talking about this head, not that one, okay? 59:28 I'm just saying. 59:29 I think chronologically, didn't she write that piece before all the stuff happened with the Monica Lewinsky? 59:35 I think she was. I don't know. 59:38 We got to get that source. 59:40 I need to cite that source. 59:41 I just want to say this is why the history is so important. There's an attack on black history right now. 59:45 It's true. 59:46 And this is why black history needs to be taught so that those kids, they can make a choice. You know, you're talking about people, they don't even have a choice. 59:53 I don't think you can reclaim if you don't know the claim, right? So you have to actually know where that history came from, have conversations about where the roots of the word, you know. 60:04 Who's using it, why they're using it. 60:06 And bring that into, before people hear the hip hop, 10, 11, 12 years old, they can actually make a real decision. 60:13 Like I always talk about sex before sex education. You think people aren't going to get pregnant if they don't talk about sex. You think they're not going to start engaging with this word if we don't talk about it, but they need to understand the roots of this history. 60:26 And that's what we're- Well, Dr. 60:27 Smith, to your point, Dr. Smith in his book talks about the difference between reappropriation and reclamation. Because reappropriation is for people who- We're not the intended original source of that. 60:37 And difference, we're saying nigga, not nigger. We're acting as if we're not making a terminological and etymological derivation that signifies the black intent of a particular phrase. Talking about Kendrick, when he says, I feel uncomfortable when Drake uses the term nigga. 60:55 I feel uncomfortable when you do that. I get that. 60:57 Not too much on Kendrick. 60:58 Oh, wow. 61:01 Cite the source, a biased person who is prejudiced against Drake. 61:05 But when Drake says light skin is still a dark nigga, his daddy is from Memphis, his grandmama babysat Aretha Franklin, he spent time with black people in Memphis and inculcated that culture. 61:19 And all I'm saying at the end of the day. 61:21 And he was on stage with Backstreet Boys at his 40th birthday. 61:23 But wait a minute. 61:26 And Kendrick defended. 61:28 Iggy Azalea, when black people were trying to say she was ripping off the culture. She's literally from a colonizing country, but Drake is a colonizer because he's a black man. 61:37 All I'm saying is, we make arbitrary distinctions, and Charlamagne is right here. Sometimes black people mean by that word, nigga, just what white people mean. Yeah. But sometimes they don't. 61:46 And so it's the complicated convergence of the simultaneity that has to be dealt with. 61:50 You know what Doc said? 61:51 You said grandma's somebody, baby's out of River Franklin, somebody across the side just saw us. 61:53 Yeah. 62:00 Michael Eric Dyson talking to Drake's daddy, okay? 62:05 And it's also in Complex Magazine. 62:07 Well, I am so grateful to you all today. This has been an incredible conversation. Audience, I don't know where y'all stand now, but hopefully you have reached a conclusion about if you're gonna use the N-word. How many of 62:19 you all use the N-word? Raise your hands. I was just, oh, four, five, sometimes. 62:26 And then has your mind changed? Will you continue to use the N-word? 62:29 No. 62:29 Absolutely not. No, it hasn't changed? 62:32 No. Okay. 62:32 Please join me in thanking today's incredible panelists, Liz Pryor, Michael Eric Dyson, Leonard McKelvey, Derek Johnson, Jordan Pierre, and Delano Squires. We're so grateful for y'all. So today we discussed three claims. One, the N-word is associated with the 62:48 most painful aspects of black history. Yes, that is true. 62:52 The N-word is not only a relic of black trauma, but it is still terrorizing some people today. Number two, the N-word is derived from the Amharic word nagus, which means king, no. This is not true. We love you, Kendrick, 63:05 and appreciate your desire to redefine and reclaim. But historically, the N-word was never intended to describe black people as royalty. 63:12 That was especially for you, Doc. Number three, it is socially acceptable for white people and individuals of other racial backgrounds to say the N-word. Don't even let Chris Rock tell you this. No, at least not according to Pew Research, 63:24 and more than 70% of Americans agree that white people should never say it. For most of us, it is a slur no matter the intent. We are not a monolith, though. 63:33 Our experiences with this word differ, and certainly whether we use nigga or the n-word, I will tell y'all I'm wrestling with my own hypocrisy on this word. I can say that one day I pray that it finally rests in peace. Remember, knowledge is power, and on Cite Your Source, 63:48 we put that power back into the hands of the people. 63:50 Please subscribe to Cite Your Source on YouTube, engage with us on social media, and share with somebody. Until next time, I'm your host, Angela Rye. This is Cite Your Source. 64:03 Thank you.
Community discussion