Mysteries and Histories artwork
Podcast · True Crime

Mysteries and Histories

593 episodes 0 followers
Support

At the table this season

NEW Season 1 Nov 18, 2026 · 50 min

Triple Murder in Quiet Town Still Shocks... But What Secrets Were the Victims Hiding?

On July 17, 1966, Vernon Shipman and Charles Glass disappeared from Hendersonville, North Carolina. Five days later, workers discovered their bodies in an isolated clearing near Lake Summit, alongside a third victim: Louise Davis Shumate, a woman from nearby Asheville whose connection to the men remained unclear. All three had been beaten to death, their bodies arranged in a rough semicircle. Shipman and Glass had co-founded the town’s Tempo Music Shop. As investigators examined their private lives, theories emerged involving jealousy, blackmail, and violence targeting gay men but none established a motive. Fear of exposure discouraged some potential witnesses from speaking, while crime-scene contamination and poor information-sharing between investigators further undermined the search for answers. Years later, several former investigators named convicted murderer Edward Thompson Jr. as their strongest suspect, citing reported confessions and similarities to his other crimes. But Thompson died in prison in 1989 without being charged in the case. The Hendersonville triple murders remain unresolved: despite decades of speculation about the victims’ supposed secrets, no one has proved who killed them, or why.

Moments: 0
0:00 50:12
Ask the hosts

Your questions for the next episode

When Mysteries and Histories joins OndaCast, the hosts see these first.

Your question goes to the community board, tied to Mysteries and Histories. The most upvoted ones get answered on air.

No questions yet

Ask Mysteries and Histories anything. When the hosts join OndaCast they will see every question.

The Mysteries and Histories table

Notes from the hosts, episode talk and everything posted with #mysteriesandhistories on the Community Board.
Be the first at the Mysteries and Histories table

Share a thought about an episode, suggest a guest or say hello.

Lines people keep sharing

Make the first clip

Pick 15 seconds you love and share them.