0:00 Hello, it's Karen Kogareff, and I want to tell you about a new Apple original podcast from Plan B and our amazing friends at Blanchard House. It's called Heart. It tells the true story of a man whose life is saved when he gets a heart transplant. Thirteen years later, 0:15 he dies under the same circumstances as his organ donor, and that's not the only strange connection between them. This is a story like nothing you've ever heard before. I had the pleasure of hosting this show. I'm really proud of it. New episodes of Heart are available Mondays on 0:30 Apple Podcasts. And if you're an Apple TV subscriber, you can listen to the whole season right now. Here is episode one of Heart. This episode discusses suicide in detail. 0:44 If you or someone you know is struggling, help is available 24-7. Visit apple.com forward slash here to help. Listener discretion is advised. I'd like you to do something for me. 1:00 Put your hand on your heart. 1:02 Please. 1:07 Now, tell me, what's in your heart? What do you imagine? 1:15 Do you imagine muscle? 1:18 Flesh? 1:19 Blood? Vowels? 1:22 Chambers? Arteries? 1:26 Veins? 1:28 Or do you imagine something else? Do you imagine love? 1:34 Do you imagine courage? 1:36 Loyalty? 1:38 Conscience? Truth? 1:43 Truth. 1:49 April 1st, 2008. Vidalia, Georgia. Sonny Graham is 69 years old. 1:56 Inside his chest, His heart is beating, atria first, then ventricles. 2:04 And between each beat, for a brief moment, these chambers rest. 2:09 Then the cycle begins again. This is the rhythm of life. 2:17 But Sunny Graham's heart is about to beat for the last time. The tiny electrical signals firing in his heart will cease. The blood will stop flowing. The rhythm will end, and Sonny Graham will leave this earth. By a self-inflicted 2:34 gunshot wound, law enforcement will conclude. When his son arrives on the scene, he tries to get through the police lines to see his father. 2:45 And they were like, you can't go in there, you don't need to go in there. If I remember correctly, I just sat down by the tree. A lot of people showed up real quickly. 2:58 Family, friends. They love my daddy. 3:06 Now there's something you need to know about Sonny Graham's heart. 3:10 It has stopped once before, when it beat in the chest of another man, a younger man named Terry Cottle. 3:20 You see, 13 years earlier, Terry's heart was transplanted into Sonny Graham's chest. But that's not the only curious thing. 3:30 Guess how Terry died. The coroner concluded that he died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Two men who died the same way, who shared the same heart. But there's one other thing these two men shared. 3:48 A wife. 3:52 A wife. 4:07 This is Heart, an Apple original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. I'm Karen Kilgariff. Episode one, The Lion. 4:35 The Lion. You're going to hear a lot of words about Sonny Graham, but maybe two words are enough. 4:50 Sonny was the lion. 4:54 The lion. 4:55 Sonny was majestic. Sonny was a very majestic person. 5:00 This is Marcy Beach. Sonny is her boss for 20 years. 5:04 He was so charismatic. Oh my gosh. 5:07 They work together at the telephone company on Hilton Head, South Carolina. 5:12 Such a... strong, physical presence. When he walked into a room, everyone noticed, and they stopped what they were doing. He spoke, they listened. It was just. 5:29 His air. 5:31 He liked to do everything professional. 5:33 Russell Taylor also works for Sonny. 5:36 I don't care if it wasn't nothing but digging a hole. 5:39 Don't take it lightly. We was real close. He was like a father to me. He was a real father figure to me. 5:50 Always trying to tell you the right thing to do. 5:53 Larry Lockley is Sonny's nephew. 5:56 He was pretty much genuine. He's a strong-willed person. 6:04 Sonny starts dating Elaine in high school. What happens when Sonny and Elaine first meet Probably this. Adrenaline surges through Sonny's bloodstream, reaching his heart. The adrenaline has made the heart's pacemaker cells more sensitive, so they start to fire 6:26 more easily. That's why Sonny might feel like his heart is skipping a beat. But it hasn't missed a beat. 6:33 It's an extra beat. After he graduates high school, Sonny joins the Air Force. He serves four years working in communications. 6:46 That leads to the job at the telephone company on Hilton Head, where, the story goes, Sonny lays the very first phone lines. Elaine becomes a schoolteacher, and Elaine and Sonny get married. They have two children. Their partnership will 7:03 last for 38 years. Carl Drury was a lifelong friend of Sonny's. 7:10 That's all. that marriage would never end. And then all of a sudden, Sonny did what he did. 7:18 But for now, Sonny Graham's reputation and his status grows and grows. Everyone on Hilton Head knows Sonny Graham. He runs the international golf tournament on the island. He builds a football field for the local high school. They call 7:34 it Sonny Graham Field. His charity cookouts are legendary. On this tiny island, Sonny Graham is a big man, a legend, the man who helped connect Hilton Head to the world. 7:48 Sonny Graham, the beating heart of Hilton Head. 8:01 1995. 8:03 Sonny has just six months to live. 8:07 Every step is hard. Every breath is labored when you get to the point he had reached. 8:18 Sonny's 57, and he's in heart failure. Carl Drury, his old friend from his school days, is now Sonny's doctor. 8:28 People in heart failure, their heart enlarges. And his heart had enlarged and enlarged, and he got so big it literally filled his chest. 8:37 Sonny's situation is grave. 8:40 I called a friend of mine who was the chief of cardiology, a real close friend of mine, and I said, I think I got you a heart transplant patient for you. 8:49 Sonny and Elaine wear beepers, which will go off when a suitable heart is found. If Sonny's scared, he's not showing it. Sonny, the lion. 8:59 He wouldn't admit a fear if he had one, I don't think. He was afraid of fears. 9:06 He said he wasn't scared of dying, he just didn't want to. He didn't want to leave this earth. He had too much still to look forward to. 9:21 It's time. A donor has been found. A heart has been found. A heart belonging to a young man who died by suicide just a few hours earlier. A man named Terry Cottle. He was just 33 years old. Sonny's rushed into the operating room. And Sonny's 57-year-old, diseased, enlarged, 9:56 failing heart is removed. And replaced with Terry's completely healthy 33-year-old heart. The operation is a complete success. 10:12 He had almost a miraculous recovery. He was up doing things almost immediately. 10:18 He was walking on a treadmill, religiously. Like an athlete would be, he was serious about it. Every day, every day. 10:26 He was so much more vigorous and strong and active than most people his age. 10:31 He was like a different person. 10:32 Sonny got a good heart. And that's critical. 10:38 A good heart. A new heart. A change of heart. 10:46 And he's about to make some choices. 10:50 Choices. 10:51 that will change everything for Sonny Graham and change everything for everyone who knows him. 10:58 He almost didn't live. And it was like a new life to him. And that's what he made of it. 11:05 But it was the wrong life. 11:10 At the time, we thought maybe he was just humbled. 11:15 But I don't think it was that. I think he was really, he was a changed person. Not in a good way. 11:37 Sonny Graham has made a decision. He wants to make contact with the family of the man whose heart now beats in his chest. 11:48 He said he was very blessed and lucky to have such a young heart. He did reiterate that numerous times, that he felt blessed. And he wanted to know more about the persons that gave him another chance to live. 12:05 I think that he was wanting to thank them, you know. 12:10 He was that kind of person. And I think that's where he was coming from, and then he got in over his head. 12:16 Sonny asks for a letter to be forwarded to his donor's family. The letter reaches the widow of Terry Cottle. 12:23 Her name is Cheryl. Today, the official advice is this, and we're pretty sure it was the same back then. 12:32 Express gratitude. Acknowledge the donor family's loss. Tell them how the transplant has changed your life. But don't tell them your last name. Don't tell them your age. Don't tell them your city. And don't give them contact details. The 12:51 official line seems to come down to something like this. 12:55 Don't start a chain reaction you can't control. But Sonny's made a decision. Sonny doesn't just want to write to Cheryl. 13:04 He wants to meet her. Meet her and thank her. 13:09 And that's what happens. 13:14 He was excited and nervous. 13:17 And scared. 13:18 But he was happy about it. 13:23 Sonny and his wife Elaine meet Cheryl in a waterfront restaurant called California Dreaming in Charleston. The meeting seems to go well. Then, Sonny invites Cheryl and her family to a farmhouse owned by Elaine's family. Sonny's nephew Larry is there. 13:44 Sonny introduces Larry to Cheryl. 13:46 Said that her husband was the one that I got the heart from. And it was a gesture to bring her and the kids up there. And the kids was playing in the pond and fishing. And, you know, that's the first time I met her. And I was thinking, 14:02 you know, most time you don't know who the donor is. 14:04 I always felt like when they first started it, their dad wasn't there anymore. And he was trying to be a father figure to her children. Um, kind of the way I took it. 14:19 Now, there's a lot more to say here, much more. 14:24 And we'll come to all of that, but not yet. 14:27 For now, all you need to know is this. Sonny falls in love with Cheryl. Among Sonny's friends, disbelief. 14:42 That wasn't Sonny. That's not what he does. 14:47 That was just out of place for everything I knew about him. 14:50 Just a strange relationship there in my way of thinking that he got her first husband's heart and then fell in love with her. 15:00 It was like he was a totally different person somewhere in there. 15:05 Sonny later describes that first meeting in the restaurant to a local newspaper called the Island Packet. 15:11 She gave me that big smile and I said, well, looky here I felt like I had known her for years. 15:21 I couldn't keep my eyes off her. I just stared. 15:26 But in that interview, there's no mention of Elaine, no mention of Sonny's wife of 38 years. 15:34 I spent days trying my best to talk him out of leaving Elaine. 15:41 I wanted to meet this person that made Sonny so happy. 15:45 When I met her, it was like, That's not the person that he needs to be with. 15:51 He was just totally infatuated with her. She was young and pretty and funny and she was a nurse, you know. 15:59 She was a bright person. But she was just a rascal. 16:04 She was a real rascal. She wasn't the right one for him. 16:11 Carl pleads with Sonny. 16:14 You got a wife who's a great lady. You've got children, and you've got a lot of friends, and it'll hurt every one of them. It's a really selfish thing you'd be doing. It didn't make any effect. It did it anyway. 16:31 Russell Taylor also can't believe what's happening, that Sonny is turning his back on 38 years of marriage with Elaine. 16:39 Because she was a loving woman, and they seemed to be so happy. And he'd do anything. He'd bend over back before. That was his wife. That was his real wife there. I couldn't understand what in the world happened. 16:55 Whether it was psychological from getting that heart, I don't know. 17:02 Sonny and Elaine divorce on December 8, 2004. Sonny marries Cheryl. 17:10 It was just like there was somebody else there. It wasn't him. It was someone else in Sonny's body. 17:20 Remember that interview with the Island Packet newspaper? Remember what Sonny says about Cheryl? 17:26 She gave me that big smile and I said, well, looky here. I felt like I had known her for years. 17:35 I couldn't keep my eyes off her. I just stared. 17:41 But of course, they haven't known each other for years. 17:43 They've only just met. 17:48 Consciousness doesn't just consist of cognition and mental activity, but has an essentially bodily aspect. 17:57 This is the voice of Dr. Thomas Verney, an MD and trained psychiatrist who practiced clinically for decades. 18:04 There is much more to the heart than just a pump. 18:09 It does much more than just pump blood. 18:11 He's the author of eight books, including The Embodied Mind, which explores the relationship between bodily processes and psychological experience. 18:21 Sometimes you feel close to a person, even though you have never met them before, or the opposite, you don't trust them. 18:27 Dr. Verney's ideas are the subject of ongoing scientific debate. 18:33 For a very long time, our Western civilization has been very focused on the head. And we have forgotten about the body. How the body is communicating with the head, it's really one system. The head is not separate from the body. You cannot separate the mind from the body because. 18:55 They are one. 18:56 Dr. Verney has no involvement in the events described in our story and draws no conclusions about the deaths of Terry Cottle and Sunny Graham. 19:04 The heart emits a magnetic field. which is actually stronger than the head and the brain, you can measure the electromagnetic field of the heart. And that has been done. 19:17 So the signals that our heart sends out will be picked up by the person's heart who is standing next to me. When you feel attracted to a person, there is a very good chance that you are on the same vibrational level. 19:34 Someone else in Sunny's. 19:35 Body Joshua Bongard, professor of computer sciences at the University of Vermont, believes that what we are is intelligent machines made of intelligent machines made of intelligent machines all the way down. 19:55 That was just out of place for everything I knew about him. 19:58 Intelligent machines made of intelligent machines made of intelligent machines all the way down. Cells in the body are able to contain memories. And especially when all of them work together as a system, they are really quite intelligent and capable of remembering things. 20:26 I felt like I had known her for years. 20:29 I couldn't understand what in the world happened. 20:33 Which leads to this question. Is Sonny Graham's new heart which used to beat in the chest of Terry Cottle, remembering the woman Terry was married to? Is Sonny Graham's new heart remembering Cheryl? Just to be clear, most scientists 20:53 would say no. Dr. Verney's ideas are new and not widely accepted. 20:58 Academics believe what they were taught when they went to university. 21:05 And to accept a new theory is very difficult for them. 21:08 The idea that cells can carry memories is not mainstream science. 21:12 Science is always skeptical of new ideas. All new ideas are always opposed by the old guard. 21:19 But the idea is just that, an idea. There's no widely accepted evidence that personality, memories, or suicidal impulses can transfer through organ transplants. We present the idea because it's been widely discussed in relation to this story. But it 21:36 is just a theory. It is not fact. Many of those closest to Sonny Graham and Terry Cottle are skeptical, too. 21:44 They have other theories. April 1st, 2008. Radio waves ping between cell phone towers. Currents and pulses surge along telephone cables. 22:03 Maybe some of them along cables Sonny Graham himself laid. 22:11 There's news. It's about Sonny. A phone rings on the floor of the Alvin W. Vogel Electric Generating Plant, a nuclear power station. This is where Larry Lockley works, Sonny's nephew. 22:28 This morning, Larry's on the turbine floor of the power plant. 22:35 They called me on the phone. They said, come out here to the office, you got a personal call. And I went up there. 22:42 One of my nephews called me. Uncle, you heard about Mr. 22:47 Sonny? 22:48 And I told him no, and he told me what he had heard. 22:53 They told me that Sonny had killed himself. 22:58 And that thing hit me like a brick. Yes, it did. 23:04 Hit me like a ton of bricks. 23:07 It was April Fool's Day. That's what I thought first when I got the call. It was April Fool's Day, April 1st, 2008. 23:17 In the brains of Russell Taylor and Larry Lockley and Marcy Beach and Carl Drury, the likely response is this. 23:26 The hypothalamus triggers the release of adrenaline into their bloodstreams. 23:30 In their hearts, calcium is released faster. Electricity fires faster. 23:36 The muscle pumps faster. The news is spreading. Family and friends are en route to Sonny and Cheryl's house. They're now living in a town called Vidalia. Larry arrives. 23:54 And of course the coroner was there and the police and the coroner came out, which I've known him a long time. And he said, yeah, it looks like he 24:07 self-inflicted a gunshot wound to the neck with a shotgun. 24:14 Law enforcement takes statements. According to those statements, this is the sequence of events. Earlier that morning, Sonny goes to a general store. He returns to the house to take his nine-year-old stepson to the dentist. He makes a cup 24:35 of coffee. The phone rings. Sonny asks his other stepson to answer it. Meanwhile, Sonny walks out to the utility shed. 24:51 A gun goes off. Law enforcement photos and diagrams from the scene show a shotgun lying next to Sonny's body. 25:06 On a table, his cup of coffee. Sonny's son, Gray, arrives on the scene. 25:12 When we got there, I got out and tried to go to the shed. And at that point is when I knew he was dead because they wouldn't let me go. 25:20 In the shed. 25:27 The Georgia Bureau of Investigation, or the GBI, investigate. On May 27, 2008, an autopsy report concludes that Sonny Graham died by suicide. Sonny's son Gray doesn't share law enforcement's conclusion. 25:45 When I heard that the GBI had ruled it as a suicide, I did not feel that that was true. 25:53 Because, according to Gray, Sonny always made one thing very clear. 25:59 My dad always said if somebody ever said he killed himself, to have it investigated. 26:07 But there's another reason Gray is suspicious. Because Gray knows how Cheryl's former husband died, Terry Cottle, the man whose heart beat in Sonny Graham's chest until, on April 1st, 2008, the electrical signal fades, the muscle stops pumping, and the 26:26 cells themselves die. Sonny Graham and Terry Cottle died the same way. 26:33 By happenstance, it just so happens you got two people supposedly committed suicide and one common denominator in the middle. 26:42 Larry Lockley is also struck by the similarities. 26:45 That's quite a coincidence for two of her husbands to die by self-inflicted gunshot wounds. 26:52 I never thought it was just a coincidence that two people committed suicide in the same heart. 26:58 The odds are astronomical of that happening. 27:01 I link it 100% with the common denominator being Cheryl. 27:07 But of course, these are just opinions, not facts. The facts are these. The Georgia Bureau of Investigation investigate for over a year and a half. Their final investigative summary is dated September 17, 2009. 27:25 It states, All leads have been exhausted. No evidence was found during the investigation to indicate anything other than self-inflicted gunshot as manner of death. 27:39 The case is closed. Sonny Graham died by suicide. 27:45 No, he didn't. That was my instant response. No, he didn't. 27:55 Even 17 years later, Marcy, Gray, Larry... Don't believe it. 28:03 They have no proof. They have no evidence. All they have is belief. 28:09 Everyone agrees he did not kill himself. 28:13 Every friend of his that I've talked to have all agreed that my dad did not kill himself. 28:20 Everyone will tell you that's not Sonny. 28:23 I didn't think that he had taken his own life. 28:26 I know he didn't do it. I know in my heart and soul he didn't do it. 28:31 I do not believe it was suicide. 28:36 He did not shoot himself. 28:52 If you or someone you know is struggling, help is available 24-7. Visit apple.com forward slash here to help. This podcast is an investigative narrative based on interviews, public records, court filings, and contemporaneous reporting. Certain accounts reflect the recollections 29:13 and opinions of those interviewed. Nothing in this program should be understood as a determination of criminal liability. The coroner concluded that Terry Cottle died by suicide. Law enforcement concluded that Sonny Graham died by suicide. Cheryl was not charged 29:29 in connection with either death. We reached out to her for comment. She declined to respond. You've been listening to Heart. 29:40 an Apple Original podcast produced by Plan B and Blanchard House. 29:44 It's hosted by me, Karen Kilgariff. Heart is written and edited by Lawrence Grizzell. It's produced by Rosie Pye. Reporting by Alex Gatenby with Addison Nugent and James Peake. Fact-checking by Addison Nugent Medical fact-checking by Dr. Hannah Rose. Original 30:04 score by Daniel Lloyd-Evans, Louis Nank-Manel, and Toby Matamon. Sound design and mix engineering by Daniel Lloyd-Evans and Saul Rivers. 30:15 Our voice actors are Ian Porter, Madeline Potter, Adam Sims, and Nina Zendaya. Our trauma and suicide awareness advisor is consultant clinical psychologist Dr. Howard Fine of MindZone Media. Production 30:30 legal counsel is Kimberly B. Herman. Production management by Amika Shatino-Nolan. 30:36 Executive produced for Plan B by Didi Gardner, Jeremy Kleiner, Cole Emhoff, and Chris Morrow. Executive producer, me, Karen Kilgaroff. 30:46 The creative director of Blanchard House is Rosie Pye. The head of content is Lawrence Grizzell.
Community discussion