0:17 Hello. 0:18 And welcome. 0:18 To My Favorite Murder. 0:19 That's Georgia Hartstark. 0:20 That is Karen Kilgareff. 0:23 Deep in the jungle of autumn. 0:26 Listener, today we have a floral centerpiece on the table between us. 0:31 It's very, here's one of my least favorite words, autumnal. 0:34 It is quite. 0:36 What don't you like about the word autumnal? 0:37 It's just pretentious. Yeah, it is. Isn't it? It is. 0:41 It's almost medicinal. 0:43 Ooh. 0:44 I was trying to think of another pretentious word. 0:46 Witchy? Yeah. No, this is beautiful. If you're watching on Netflix, you can see we have a beautiful floral arrangement. 0:53 That's real, by the by. 0:54 That's real. It's real. Yeah, autumnal. It's real autumnal. I have a feeling I'm going to move it soon. But we wanted to show it off. 1:01 Well, it's a beautiful idea. 1:03 You know what it is? 1:04 It feels like I've gone into a rich person's house and I'm going to get caught. 1:09 And so I'm going to get kicked out. Did you bring this runner from home? This autumnal run. I know you're big on runners and matching place settings. Well, I love to make lace. Your tablescapes are legendary. 1:21 And I just I make every piece of the scape. 1:23 That's right. 1:24 And I love to construct the tables as well. 1:26 Kind of your thing. It's like DIY meets Martha Stewart. 1:29 Just meets like casual friendship. You know, like I just want to do for others all the time. Oh, my God. 1:36 So, yeah, it's mostly. 1:36 Runners growing fresh flowers from a bulb. 1:40 You love that. 1:41 And stuffing. 1:42 And you made this glass vase as well. Blew it. 1:45 Blew the glass. 1:45 Learned how at Murano, Italy, and now I know how, and I'll pass it on to you. 1:49 I wonder if we have any glass-blowing mortarinos, because I want to learn how to do that someday. 1:53 Ah! 1:54 Really? 1:57 I was just in New York City. 1:59 New York City? 2:01 And man, that Sephora. That one Sephora, you and I went to together. 2:06 It's like you're a tourist for Sephora. 2:08 I always need something. How is it different than any other Sephora? Well, it's New York City. 2:13 So the people who work there are fucking makeup professionals. 2:16 So if you ask them a question, they literally are going to tell you like the history of the eyeshadow brush or something like that. Sure. I went into the perfume department because I'd found this orange perfume that I thought was there. So I walked up and I said 2:31 what I thought the name was to the woman. 2:32 Who worked there. 2:33 And I was like, do you have whatever it was called? 2:36 And then she was like, no, there wasn't a question in her mind. 2:40 Just no soul do. 2:41 They have hundreds of titles. And she's just like, no, we don't. And then I was like, oh, okay, thank you. 2:47 And I went to walk away. And then she goes, We do have orange-scented perfume, though. 2:51 If that's what you're. 2:51 Looking for, I can upsell you on some other ones over here. It was just that kind of thing where I was like, no, I'm going to get the one. 2:57 Intimidated in your own home, essentially. 3:00 Right? It's like when a grand chef tells you to get. 3:02 Out of the kitchen. 3:03 Right. We don't cook our steaks medium, ma'am. That's right. 3:06 No medium, well, get out of here. Get the fuck out of the kitchen. 3:09 We'll bring you what you need. 3:10 Exactly. 3:11 And I trust those people at That's Afford that they gave me exactly what I needed and nothing more. 3:16 That's amazing. You know, I went to the new Korean Sephora. 3:21 Olive Young. In Pasadena. 3:23 Yes. 3:23 And like had to run out. It was. Because of ADD. 3:26 So overwhelming. Yes. 3:28 That I haven't approached yet because I think I'd really melt down. 3:32 Get ready to spend. 24 hours just touching things and putting things on. 3:38 There's a little lion on front of the bottle. 3:40 You're going to look like Mrs. Doubtfire by the end of it, which is like layer upon layer. 3:44 That's the dream. 3:45 Do you know that sometimes I do that in the morning because I buy makeup like for fun and then I'll have it. So in the morning when I'm up doing stuff around the house, I'll go in and be like, let's try this blush. 3:56 Let's do this. 3:57 And then it's like eight in the morning and the orchid man comes. He's like, can you unlock the gate? 4:00 And I have a full on psycho face. 4:04 You've tried eight blushes. 4:05 A dark eye, a dark lip, like I'm doing the whole number. 4:08 It's pretty rough. 4:10 My buddy loves it. 4:11 Yum. 4:12 I'm holding it for one second. 4:14 Are you allergic to our beautiful centipede? 4:15 I think I might be. I might be having an allergic reaction. And I, Corey, you did such an amazing job as always. It looks gorgeous. 4:22 Once again, our autumnal set where it has literal practical effects of leaves falling down. 4:29 But I'm moving it and I'm sorry. 4:30 Yeah. 4:30 Oh, here, eat that. We're not. 4:32 How dare you try to get me to poison me like a bird and fly into a window. 4:37 Eat it. 4:38 I know what you're up to. 4:39 Okay. There we go. 4:40 There we go. 4:41 Will we flutter the leaves? 4:42 Yeah. Beautiful. 4:44 So yeah, this is before Thanksgiving comes out. Before they release Thanksgiving. 4:49 The new drop. 4:50 The holiday drop that is Thanksgiving. Here's what we're going to do. We're going to stumble into Thanksgiving. And by then, the year's over. If you make it to Thanksgiving, it's all you have to do, listener. Everybody here, we're going. 5:02 To do it. 5:03 We have the blue wave as a crested event of hope and light. There's still work to do. ICE arrested an eight-year-old child. So they're going to have to take action. 5:14 That blue wave has to fucking break on the shore and take fucking action. 5:18 No time to celebrate, guys. 5:19 Get on it. Get on it immediately, which they have. 5:22 Yes. And people have. 5:23 What was I going to say? It's gone. It's just gone. 5:26 Oh, yeah. 5:26 Is it a message of hope? No. I was going to say we'll just coast into 2027. 5:29 Yes. 5:30 So, yeah, I guess. That's right. It is. Yeah, exactly. 5:33 All we have to do is, like, slide into that first roll you bite into. We're home free. Okay. 5:38 Yeah. I'm doing it. This year, Vince is making Cheddar Bay Biscuits for all. I don't know where it came from, and I don't know why, but he wants to. 5:46 Because they're the most delicious item on the planet. 5:49 But are they Thanksgiving? They're red lobster, right? 5:51 They're red lobster, but do you know that Adrienne's mother-in-law brought them one year to her Thanksgiving and the world went insane? 5:58 I guess it could have already been a thing before red lobster brought it. 6:02 I mean, they're just perfect biscuits. 6:04 Yeah. 6:04 And if you have some carb like that on your Thanksgiving table, people are only grateful. Sure. 6:09 Okay. 6:10 Right? 6:10 Yeah. 6:11 Are you fighting Cheddar Bay Biscuit? 6:13 Never. 6:13 Just like, what's the problem? 6:15 The whole idea of Thanksgiving always confuses me, but we're going to get there. 6:20 Because it's too. 6:21 You know, all the bad stuff behind it, but also it feels like Jewish people aren't supposed to do it, which is not true. We do it every year. Like, we're cool, right? We can do this. 6:30 Yes, you can. 6:30 It just feels connected to Christmas in some way. 6:33 It is. Right. 6:34 It's the top of the slide. 6:36 Yeah. Of the chutes and ladders slide down. So it feels weird, but I'm going to take it. Should we get into this? Because we have a really big, exciting, if you fast forward or whatever. skip the Exactly Right updates, you're going to miss a really big, exciting announcement. 6:50 Come back in and fucking, I think it's going to take about 49 seconds. 6:55 Hold your horses. 6:56 Just hang out for a second because we have a podcast network and we want to tell you about it. 7:01 The darling of New York City and co-host of Brief Recess, Michael Foote, is recording the show at the Exactly Right studios this week. His guest will be Alexis, the host of In my homosexual opinion, the podcast. Love it. 7:14 Calling all Joan Crawford fans, Hollywoodland is breaking down the life of this infamous actress this week, including how she wound up at a party with Richard Nixon, J. Edgar Hoover, and Lyndon Johnson. And that was on the eve of the Kennedy assassination. 7:29 Wow. 7:30 What? 7:30 What a fascinating woman. And over in the merch corner, we're kicking off our Goodbye 2026 merch sale. It lasts until November 30th and includes all merch in the store. 7:41 Some MFM items that could make great gifts this holiday season are this fucking incredible Mothman... Purse charm. Purse charm or keychain, however you want to use it. 7:51 Or this Lock Your Fucking Door beautiful keychain purse charm, however you want to use it. 7:56 Gallatin key, Lock Your Fucking Door... And it's a bottle opener. 8:00 Which was Georgia's ad because she was like, let's not just have a thing. 8:04 Yeah. 8:04 And it says MFM up here. 8:06 I mean, this is cool. 8:07 These are so great. 8:08 Do you know someone that needs a bitter little bird ornament starring Peachy? 8:12 The best bird ever? 8:13 Or the whole MFM animated lineup for your tree. 8:17 There's so many good gifts over on the ERM store right now. 8:20 This podcast, your favorite podcast. 8:23 Oh, and one more thing. The 2027 My Favorite Murder Calendar. 8:29 Paper and wire ring calendar. 8:32 And it's all of the beautiful posters from our tour last year. 8:37 Yeah. 8:37 In one place. 8:39 The artist Daphna Sabane designed this calendar for us to basically collect all of our beautiful, I mean, that was. 8:45 Denver, right? Yeah. I think it was. So it's like, yeah. 8:49 It's so good. It's so good. 8:51 You could have one of those calendars. 8:52 So, yeah. So, if you right now go to TheExactlyRightStore.com, use code GOODBYE2026, and you get 30% off all that stuff. Also, there's a last chance section. 9:03 Nice. 9:03 Which has stuff that's even more discounted. 9:06 So, that's ExactlyRightStore.com. 9:08 And now. Okay. 9:09 Big update. Big, crazy update. 9:12 We've been doing this for so long and talking about it for so long that I kind of forgot that the audience does not know about this. 9:18 I know. Okay. 9:19 Some might because they were involved. 9:22 Right. Well, how do we explain this? Remember when we went on tour last fall, was it? 9:27 Jesus. 9:27 It was. And at some shows, you could see that there was a film crew at some of the shows, four cities to be exact. Well, we can finally tell you what it's for. 9:38 We have a four-episode HBO doc series that premieres December 3rd, I'm going to say it again, on HBO, which I just have to say, as a stand-up comic who moved to L.A. in 1994— having a show on HBO was everybody's dream. 9:55 That's amazing. 9:56 It was the top of the mountain. 9:57 Yeah. 9:58 And now it's happening. 9:59 Like, I thought all the crazy things had happened already with this podcast, you know? But no, we're going to have a four-part HBO docuseries. It debuts Thursday, December 3rd. 10:08 Please watch it and then also, like, photograph yourself watching it and tag us in it. It's basically our live show, but it's so much more than that because we really wanted to have the murderinos involved in it. So the listeners who showed up and have been with us from 10:23 the beginning are interviewed throughout the show, and it's so fucking special. 10:27 It was such a gigantic thing to take on in terms of production. Yeah. But there are lots of people who work at Exactly Right who have worked in TV for a long time and who know how to do stuff like this, and we pulled existing staff who used 10:42 to be producers who were like, come and be producers on this show. 10:45 We pulled in old friends. 10:47 We pulled in, and it is one of the most fun, coolest things. 10:52 Incredible things that that team pulled off. 10:55 Yeah. Contacting people who had tickets and then basically being like, can we interview you when you get there? 11:00 Yeah. 11:01 And then taking those interviews and making them into parts of every single show. 11:05 It's, It's the coolest thing of all time. 11:07 It is. And it's really because we wanted to show that this show isn't just about this fucking bullshit Karen and I talk on stage. It's so much more than that. 11:16 It's about the people who listen and what true crime means to them, what being a murderino means to them. 11:21 And it's just turned into this show that's like all of ours, it's not just the podcast, it's all of our show. So HBO, December 3rd premiere, it's gonna be four episodes, so one a week through December. So crazy. 11:35 So crazy. 11:35 And our producer Molly had to hold down the fort here while we were on tour because we had to record and then leave and come back. But we have a producer, Kate Schellenbach, who I used to work with. 11:47 She worked on the TV show, and then now she works on this show. And then my fucking, Julie Morgan, the makeup artist who I used to work with. 11:53 On Cooking Channel. Yep, who was the best. Incredible job. 11:56 Della Rentis' makeup, like, she's her makeup artist, and we got her. 11:59 My old friend, Vicky. 12:00 Paige Hurwitz, Vicky. 12:02 Yes, and of course, I'll just say, Paige Hurwitz, who is our executive producer, she started on Last Comic Standing. 12:08 So she literally had exactly the skill set to make this show because that's how she started. 12:13 Yeah. 12:13 And if it weren't for every single one of. 12:15 Those people that gave everything to do that show, I mean, and it looks so beautiful. The DP is like one of the best in the business. We have directors that are like Emmy award winning directors. It is. 12:28 We think you're going to like it. We really do. 12:30 It's really fucking special. 12:31 It's incredible. 12:32 Yeah. Yeah. 12:33 Very exciting. Yeah. 12:34 Smash that like button on HBO for us and show your support. 12:38 Please support. Like, it's just such a crazy thing, and we really want you guys to like it and to do well. 12:42 It's like the next level. We just did a next level thing, and please come with us. 12:46 Leveled up. We leveled it up. We leveled up. Come with us. 12:49 It's going all the way up. 12:50 Okay. 12:51 Are you first? I am. Here's what's exciting about this. 12:57 This episode comes out during Native American Heritage Month. Mm-hmm. 13:02 It also, today is about a week after Veterans Day, which is November 11th. 13:07 So you can do that the whole time. No, I'm sorry. 13:11 I'm sorry. I'm distracting. 13:12 No. 13:13 Oh, I thought you were kind of doing a bit. No, I'm fucking having a hot flash right now. 13:17 Listener, Georgia has a tiny tasteful fan that she was just fanning herself with, but I thought you were doing a bit. I'm fucking sweating. 13:24 I'm like, my skin is hot. Okay. 13:26 Okay. So all of those elements perfectly come together in this story. What's very cool is I've wanted to talk about different parts of this story separately. 13:38 We tried to approach it. 13:40 Now we found the story that kind of brings all of these elements together that are very much what we should be talking about during Native American Heritage Month here in 2026. So This story is about the debt this country owes to First Nation people because in the aftermath 13:57 of the genocide they endured only 50 years prior, they still stood up and fought for this country in World War II. And in the thick of this war, the Allies were losing, and they realized it was because Japanese codebreakers were intercepting their messages. 14:13 And the consequences of that, of course, were life and death. 14:17 The U.S. 14:17 Scrambles to secure its communications, And that means they have to develop a code no other code breakers can crack. 14:24 So they recruit 29 young men to develop this code because they speak a language that, ironically, the United States has actively and usually violently suppressed, if not almost totally eradicated. 14:37 That language is called Diné B'Zad, the language of the Navajo Nation. 14:42 And this is the story of the. 14:43 Navajo code talkers of World War II and one man in particular named Chester Nez. 14:49 What a brilliant idea. Like, you don't have to learn a whole new language. Let's get the people who know this language. That's right. Amazing. 14:56 That no one else knows because this is an oral tradition that the colonists have tried to kill out of this tribe of people. 15:05 Amazing. Love a code story, too. 15:07 So the main source for this story is the book Code Talker by Chester Nez, the man himself, and a writer named Judith Avila. The rest of the sources are in our show notes. And before we start, I just want to say, even though Navajo is the official legal 15:22 formal name of this tribe, it is and it's the accepted one that like non-tribal people use. But many members of this tribe refer to themselves as Diné. But the man in this story and at the center of it calls himself, refers to himself as Navajo. And so does 15:38 the press for the time. And it's the accepted public name. 15:41 So I'm just referring because this is all about language and it's all about the importance of language. I just want to mention that before we get into it. But we're going to do what Chester did, call himself both Navajo and his colonizer name, which was Chester Nez. 15:56 So Chester was. 15:57 Born with the Navajo name Betole in Chichila, New Mexico, in 1921. Now, every single word I'm like, after I make a point like that, I'm going to mispronounce everything. 16:08 Here we go. 16:08 He's born on the Navajo reservation. 16:11 A place he will later describe as, quote, beautiful in all seasons, a view you drank in like cold water on a sweltering day, end quote. Chester is the English name given to him by a Christian missionary when he's a child after U.S. 16:24 President Chester B. 16:25 Arthur. 16:26 It's the name that. 16:26 He uses throughout his life. 16:28 So about growing up on the reservation, Chester said, quote, we were poor from the beginning and everything was hard for us. Like many Navajo, Chester's family earns their livelihood as sheep herders. When he's a toddler, his mother dies, 16:42 so very young. And so he has to work alongside his father, tending to their flock of sheep. So he grows up learning about the persecution of the Navajo people, like hearing stories about his family members who survived the long walk of the 1860s. I'd never heard of this before. 17:00 But this is when the U.S. military burned Navajo homes, crops, and livestock, and then forced thousands of men, women, and children into to walk roughly 300 miles on foot to Fort Sumner, New Mexico, and many either died along the 17:15 way or died once they were incarcerated when they arrived. 17:19 An 1868 treaty returned a portion of the Diné homeland, and over time, families like Chester's rebuilt from literally nothing, but the government intervenes again in the early 30s when Chester's a boy. The feds claim that herds of sheep 17:34 that the Diné are raising and using for their livelihood are overgrazing the reservation. And so they enact a so-called livestock reduction program. So this is where we're talking about kind of in between those four states of Arizona, Utah, Colorado, 17:52 and New Mexico. So for this livestock reduction program, the U.S. 17:56 is promising that if tribal leaders cooperate, that they'll expand the reservation to include more of the tribe's ancestral homeland. 18:04 It's not going to surprise you or anyone that that promise is not kept as families' herds of sheep are wiped out in what Chester will refer to as, quote, the Great Livestock Massacre. His own family loses 700 of 18:18 their 1,000 sheep. He writes that families are left feeling, quote, powerless. 18:22 What was the point of working hard to build up wealth, a sizable herd, when the government. 18:27 Just stepped in and destroyed it? 18:30 End quote. And basically, Chester believes that the government did this because the Navajo people were beginning to succeed, to make money, to have like a livelihood. And they were like, can't have that happening. So in the late 20s, Chester's 18:44 father enrolls him at a government boarding school in Tehachapi, New Mexico, about 50 miles from his home. This school is part of a nationwide education system explicitly designed to forcibly assimilate Native children into white Christian society. 18:58 This was the story. 19:00 I've talked about them a little bit here and there over the years. But Maren and Molly and I have been trying to figure out how to do this story forever. Yeah. 19:08 But it's so expansive. 19:09 Yeah. 19:10 And it's so horrible. 19:11 Yeah. I was like, we need to find one person. 19:14 We need to find the way through that story. 19:16 Yeah. 19:17 And Maren did it, which is pretty amazing. 19:20 Yeah. 19:20 I mean, really, we've been talking about it for 10 years, and it is such a hard topic to like. pinpoint into one story the schools that they forced Native children into. 19:31 We got a sense of it in the Polly Pry story when she went undercover. So basically, in some cases, Native children were abducted from their homes by government agents and forced into these schools. But in this case, Chester's father hopes if he sends his son to this school, 19:47 then he'll learn English. He'll be able to find a decent job after graduation, and he'll basically get out of this generational poverty that his family's been forced into. So Chester's father only had good intentions when he enrolled him there, 20:02 but the results of this decision are devastating. Chester's eight years old when he starts kindergarten, and first of all, the children at these schools are severely underfed and they're like boarding schools. There's nowhere else to get food. That's 20:16 reportedly a common experience shared by survivors of these institutions. 20:20 Chester will later write, quote, we look for food in the trash pile out back, sometimes finding crumbs of things. 20:27 We wolf down anything that was remotely edible, spoiled or not. 20:32 End quote. Weeks later, when Chester's father comes to visit him, He's shocked by how thin his son is, and he takes him out of school immediately. Wow. So then Chester goes to a new school. That school is in Fort Defiance, Arizona, which is also an hour from his home. It's the 20:48 origin point for the long walk of the 1860s. On the first day of that school, adult staff forcibly cut the children's hair, take their tribal clothes, replace them with uniforms, and give them English names. Mm-hmm. If the kids at 21:03 this school are caught speaking Dine Bazaad, they're subjected to both physical abuse and psychological abuse. Chester reports being hit on the head and struck with rulers, his mouth painfully scrubbed with lye soap, and he was forced to watch 21:18 powerlessly as other young children who are struggling with this new language and these new names are humiliated by adults. 21:26 At night, Chester hears these students crying themselves to sleep. 21:29 So it's just the worst of colonialization. And the people who enacted it are sociopaths. I mean, it's disgusting. Chester's account is just one experience at one school in this huge government-run system. A nonprofit called the National Native American 21:46 Boarding School Healing Coalition points out that survivors of these schools report to have, quote, suffered physical, sexual, cultural, and spiritual abuse and neglect and experienced treatment that in many cases So they don't know where they are and easily 22:02 could have just been killed on site and buried on site. 22:04 So over the next several years, Chester moves around to different schools. So you can imagine the job then becomes getting out when it's bad enough. getting as much education as you can and getting away. He finally finds a 22:27 school where classes are taught in English, but where Denae Bazzat is tolerated by staff and spoken openly in hallways. 22:34 So by late 1941, Chester, just shy of 20 years old, has made it to the 10th grade. That December, Pearl Harbor is attacked by the Japanese and the United States joins World War II. A few months later in the spring of 1942, Marine recruiters show up to Chester's school saying, 22:53 that they are working on a special project and looking to recruit young men who speak fluent Diné Bazaad and English. 23:01 They don't say much more than this, but the idea appeals to Chester, and he will later say, quote, the Navajo feeling is to go to the top of the hill and see what's on the other side. And, quote, my Navajo people had always been warriors, protectors, in that 23:16 there was honor. I would concentrate on being a warrior and protecting my homeland. 23:21 Wow. Yeah. 23:23 So along with about 200 other young men, Chester raises his hand to volunteer for this project. He will become one of just 29 who are selected for it. In May of 1942, they're all put on a bus and taken to Camp Elliott in San Diego. It's the first 23:39 time Chester has ever left the reservation. The next day, basic training begins. So he barely gets to absorb anything, and then they're in basic. Once he finishes basic training about a month later, he and the other recruits finally 23:54 learn the details of what this top-secret assignment is going to be. To develop a code in their native language of Diné Bazaad to transmit messages on the battlefield that no other codebreakers could solve. Wow. There's a precedent for 24:08 this plan. So during World War I, speakers of many Native American languages, Choctaw, Cherokee, Comanche, Osage, and more, transmitted messages during battle that the Germans could not translate. 24:21 Wow, that's so cool. 24:22 But it wasn't an official code. 24:25 It was just improvised and used only in specific units and on a fairly small scale. But it was so effective that in the years following World War I, German agents infiltrated Native communities, posing as scholars, researchers, and writers, 24:41 so they could try to study tribal languages— because they thought they would need to know them for future wars. 24:48 That's so diabolical. Why don't you just concentrate on not having another war? 24:52 Yes. 24:53 No. 24:53 No, can't do that. So basically, the Marine Corps knew that that had happened in the past. They also knew that Diné Bizade was a traditionally oral language. 25:04 So in the 1940s, there. 25:06 Were no resources, no dictionaries, no way you could learn it from the outside. And in fact, at that time, Less than 30 people who are non-Navajo in the world are believed to have spoken Diné. Damn. It's such an 25:21 intricate language with unique grammar and complex pronunciations, as any speaker knows by listening to me talk about it. That unless you were raised hearing and speaking it on the reservation, it would be next to impossible to learn to be fluent in it. 25:36 Wow. 25:36 And that's exactly why the Marines think that this is the answer. Right. So the major takes Chester and these other 28 men into a big room. He tells them to get to work, and then they lock them inside. 25:48 Oh, shit. 25:49 Mm-hmm. Chester remembers, quote, I read expressions of shock on every face, a code based on the Navajo language. after we'd been so severely punished in boarding school for speaking it. 26:00 Holy shit. 26:01 Hearing that door lock click closed, I felt my stomach tense. 26:05 The windows of our classroom were protected by security bars. 26:09 Now what? So they're literally in a little jail, and they're like, make it happen for us. Wow. So these men start by focusing on the English alphabet, and they give each letter a few Dene Bazaad code words. So, A is for forgive me for this, but I'm going 26:29 to try it. So A is for bilisana, which is the Navajo word for apple, but also walachi, which means ant, another A word, and tsinil, which means axe. And they basically do this with every letter from A to Z, with the idea being that an English message could be 26:48 spelled out letter by letter in a string of corresponding Diné-Bizod words. So to avoid having to spell out every message, they also create shorthand code for military terms. For example, their word for commander general translates to war chief. But 27:05 they also get creative. There's no word in Diné for hand grenade, but since a grenade kind of looks like a potato, that's the word they use. Battleship becomes whale. 27:15 Fighter jet becomes hummingbird. Bombs become eggs. It takes 13 weeks. 27:22 Into the summer of 1942— And now Chester and the men have created a code language with hundreds of words in it, and it continues to expand over the duration of the war. It tops out around 600 words total. 27:34 And even if an eavesdropping codebreaker could somehow understand Diné, the translated message would just be a string of random words, mostly about food and animals. 27:45 Hummingbirds and eggs. Yes. So here's an example. 27:48 This is a real code talker message that was used during the Battle of Iwo Jima. Sheep. Eyes, nose, deer, destroyer, tea, mouse, turkey, onion, sick horse, three, six, two, bear. 28:01 What if I fucking just told you? Thank God. It's so hard. Oh, so good. 28:05 Oh, that's... You're just like, you tap the sides of your head. 28:08 You see math floating around me. Oh, my God. She's one of the 30. 28:12 That could speak it. I'm a meme. 28:16 Algebra. 28:16 You're just really good at this one language. Yeah. When this is decoded, it's a request for reinforcements for soldiers under fire in a specific location. 28:24 I knew that. 28:24 Right? 28:25 That's what I was going to say. 28:25 You could feel it, but you couldn't translate it. Chester and the rest of the Navajo code breakers memorize and vigorously practice this code, and right off the bat, it works. 28:35 They can transmit and decode short messages in as little as 20 seconds, which is lightning speed compared to the 30 minutes of decryption that standard codes usually require. So now it's November of 1942, and the Navajo code talkers 28:51 are ordered to prepare for deployment. They're going into battle. 28:54 They weren't just brought in like a think tank. They're the think tank that's now getting sent onto the front lines. 29:01 They need it live, basically. 29:02 Yes. They spend the next two weeks on a ship, unsure of exactly where they're headed. No one tells them anything. 29:09 Chester says, quote, Right. So their first stop is in the Pacific Theater at Guadalcanal. American Marines have been fighting Japanese forces there for about three months. And as the ship approaches, Chester can see the bodies of soldiers floating 29:33 in the water. There is so much blood that the tide is coming in red. He and the other code talkers are holding the weapon they've been trained to use. 29:41 They're also holding heavy hand crank radios. And when the ship lands, they have to get off the ship and tread water to the beach like we've seen in so many World War II movies. Chester says, quote, Navajo belief forbids contact with the dead. but we waded through floating 29:58 bodies intent on not becoming one of them. 30:00 Wow. 30:01 End quote. There's no time to think before they're immediately under fire. Chester and the team, they have to make it to the shore under fire and then rush to the tree line for cover. And there they dig themselves foxholes and it just begins. Chester has handed his first 30:17 battlefield message written in English. He translates it into the code and gets on his radio and Denae Bazad telling the code talker, In the communications center nearby, quote, enemy machine gun nest on your right flank. 30:30 Destroy. 30:30 Wow. 30:31 But potato hummingbird. 30:33 Yeah. 30:34 Not whale because that's a ship. As Chester burns the handwritten note, the other code talker has already decrypted the message and the target is hit. So these guys truly are coming in as like Wi-Fi in a time of like 1981. Yeah. 30:49 Just making everything happen. actually work. 30:51 So it's so effective that they travel, the code talkers, from one Pacific campaign to the next. They go to Bougainville, Guam, Peleliu, and Angwar, transmitting and decoding messages about battle plans and 31:05 bombing coordinates, casualties, supplies, and enemy location, all while dodging mortar fire bullets and bombs themselves. Chester writes about how the code talkers filled the airwaves, saying, quote, Everyone needed ammunition. 31:20 Everyone needed grenades. Everyone needed night flares. Messages zipped back and forth as fast as we could send them, end quote. 31:28 So just before they got there, they were trying to do this and tell each other that, and then a codebreaker would come and just like change the plan. So the bombs were just coming from somewhere else. So you can imagine code talkers never get a moment's rest. They 31:41 rush to and from communication centers and battle zones under heavy fire usually. sometimes having to fire back themselves when necessary, whatever it takes for them to get their crucial work done. 31:52 If the radios fail, which happens sometimes, then they're expected to transmit the messages on foot. One night, this happens to Chester, and to carry out his orders, he has to sprint several hundred yards. 32:04 Oh, my God. Several hundred. 32:05 Football fields, 100. Yeah. Lit only by moonlight under machine gun fire to get the message sent. Wow. But Chester and the co-talkers also faced the insidious danger of friendly fire as Navajo Marines were mistaken for Japanese infiltrators by 32:23 their fellow American troops. Chester is heading back to the communications center one day when he's stopped by two American Marines. 32:30 One puts a. 45 to his head and threatens him while Chester urges them just to walk up to the communications center and verify he is also an American Marine. 32:42 The confusion is, of course, cleared up. But of all the things Chester goes through during the war, he will later say, quote, that was the most scary thing that happened to me. 32:51 Out of everything. Out of everything. That's nuts. 32:54 Because they can't fucking rest. Yeah. They're saving everybody's fucking life. 32:58 And then it's like, well, we'll kill you. 32:59 Yeah. 33:00 Also, that could have been easily. Talk about communications. Can you just let people know right before they get there? Right. 33:07 That a very special team is coming? 33:09 Right. 33:10 Men. 33:11 Okay, now. 33:12 Three years have passed. It's 1945. The Japanese have tried to break the Navajo code. They never can. Meanwhile, the code talkers have become so inarguably indispensable to the Marines that as opposed to how it started, they're now assigned 33:27 their own bodyguards. Everybody gets hip real quick about how we cannot lose these people. Between February and March of 1945 is when the Battle of Iwo Jima takes place. 33:40 It's a bloody fight that now looms large in American culture thanks to the iconic photograph of those Marines who are raising the American flag together in victory. What's less well known, though, is that in the first 48 hours 33:52 of this battle, the code talkers send and receive around 800 messages, all without a single error. A Marine signal officer will later be quoted as saying, quote, were it not for the Navajos, the Marines would have never. 34:08 Taken Iwo Jima. 34:10 And we don't know that story. 34:11 And we don't know that and have never heard that. 34:15 And also just like in that crucial way. 34:17 Yeah. 34:17 It just you go, yep, this is how our government, whoever the powers that be, have erased the participation of like native people in this country across the board. Right. 34:30 But Chester Nez does not take part of the Battle of Iwo Jima. He was preparing to deploy when he is informed by the Marines he's eligible for discharge. So right before one of the biggest battles that there is, he basically is sent home. But he first returns to 34:46 a military hospital in San Francisco where he spends the next five months recovering from, of course, the immense psychological toll that all those battles have taken. And I mean the most extreme parts of all those battles. Yeah. He 34:59 will later say, quote, the war climbed inside my head. 35:03 On the islands I'd been busy, too busy to dwell on the horror around me. But in the hospital, I had no responsibilities. The days stretched out long as a highway, and nightmares invaded both my waking and sleeping hours. I felt lost. Wow. End quote. He's then discharged from the 35:20 hospital in the summer of 1945 and sent back to San Diego, where he is congratulated and given a bunch of medals. No. 35:28 Don't be crazy. 35:29 No. He's informed by the military that he cannot ever speak a word about the Navajo code that he helped create or about being a code talker in the Pacific because it's all classified and it must remain top secret. 35:44 In case we fight future wars. 35:47 In case. 35:47 Once again. 35:48 Yeah. Of course, Chester understands this. He's a Marine himself. 35:52 He's an adult. 35:53 But he does say, quote, I felt a twinge of disappointment when I realized I would not be able to tell my family. 36:00 Yeah. 36:00 End quote. Hey, I did this really important thing. 36:05 Right. 36:05 So in September 1945, months after the fall of Nazi Germany— World War II officially ends with Japan's formal surrender. And at this point, there are hundreds of men that have been recruited to become code talkers, learning the language that 36:20 Chester Nez and the other original 28 code talkers created. 36:25 In the years that follow World War II, Chester Nez finishes high school. He enrolls at the University of Kansas. 36:31 He studies art there. Then he returns to New Mexico. 36:34 He marries his wife, Edith, who is also Navajo. And they start a family. Chester gets a job with the Albuquerque Veterans Hospital as a painter, and he works there for 40 years. And none of his coworkers ever know he is one of the 29 men responsible for the 36:52 only oral military code in modern history that to this day has never been broken. 36:57 Damn. I would be telling everybody. Potato. Hummingbird. Guess what I did. 37:03 Then we thought of this one. Of course the battleship is the whale. 37:07 Aren't we geniuses? It would be so hard to keep your mouth shut. Yeah. What'd you do in the war? Nothing. 37:13 I can't talk about it. Right. Here, I'll talk about it quietly. 37:17 Here, I can't talk about it. 37:18 Here, let's go to the next room. 37:19 I'll tell you all about it. 37:20 So the reality of post-war America is that the members of the Navajo Nation are just receiving the right to vote in New Mexico. And Native Americans have only been considered full American citizens since the mid-20s with the passage 37:35 of the Indian Citizenship Act. So it goes that way, as we know, the years pass. And the code talkers, 13 of whom died in battle, lived their lives with no real recognition of the incredible work that they did until 1968, when the Marines finally declassify the entire operation. 37:56 They basically get new encryption methods that replace, like, because the oral codes were the only way they could do it back then. 38:02 Right. 38:02 But once all of the encryption methods get updated— They don't have to rely on it for their future wars. 38:09 So suddenly, books are being written, documentaries are being produced. 38:13 In 1971, President Richard Nixon sends a formal letter of appreciation to the Navajo Tribal Council. Chester is now around 50 years old. He's suddenly doing speaking engagements all across the country. He says, quote, I became a bit of a celebrity. That could be embarrassing. 38:31 End quote. 38:33 Then in 1982— President Ronald Reagan declares August 14th Navajo Code Talkers Day. This is the day that the Japanese announced surrender. They basically aligned those. And in the year 2000, President Bill Clinton signs legislation authorizing congressional gold medals for 38:53 the 29 original Code Talkers. The following year, 2001, President George Bush, George W., presents those gold medals to the Code Talkers. Only five of them are still alive at this point. Wow. 39:06 I think we have a picture of Chester. 39:07 Oh, wow. 39:09 Aw. 39:09 Look at him. So cute. 39:11 Now imagine him saying, I became a bit of a celebrity. 39:15 It was embarrassing. 39:16 Yes, I love it. Do it. 39:18 The greatest celebrity. I think he's 90 years old. That picture's from 2011. So Chester Nez dies of kidney failure at the age of 93. In his later years, he expressed pride in his military service, saying, quote, My fellow code talkers and I have become part of a new 39:36 oral and written tradition, a Navajo victory, with our culture contributing to our country's defeat of a wily foe. Our story is not one of sorrow like the Long Walk and the Great Livestock Massacre, but one of triumph. 39:50 End quote. 39:52 But he does say in later years, quote, all those years telling you not to speak Navajo and then to turn around and ask us to help with that same language, it still kind of bothers me. Wow. Yeah. 40:05 He's right. 40:06 And in 2025, in its frenzy to erase what it considers DEI language, the Trump administration removes all mention of the Navajo code talkers from all government websites. 40:19 Yeah. 40:20 After a public outcry, a Pentagon spokesperson claims these deletions were a mistake and that they were done by overzealous AI programs trained to target specific words. Some, but not all, of the mentions of the Navajo code. 40:35 Talkers are restored. 40:36 Clearly, we have a lot of work to do to ensure that the real history of our nation is accurately presented. 40:43 As Chester Nez says in his later years, quote, I'd like for the younger generation to know about the Code Talkers, to know how we use the language to win the war in the South Pacific, end quote. This Native American Heritage Month and every day thereafter, we can help Chester 41:00 fulfill that wish. And that's the story of Chester Nez and the Navajo Code Talkers and how the native Navajo language of Diné Bazaad helped raise that victory flag at Iwo Jima, turn the tide of World War II, and defeat fascism. 41:17 Yes. 41:18 Yay. 41:19 Great job. Thank you. 41:21 And this is a real Maren McClatchen, C. Molly Smith joint. 41:26 Great job, you guys. 41:27 Bringing this. 41:27 Yeah. Love that. 41:28 Love that story. 41:29 That I had never heard anything about. So that was so great. 41:34 Many of us are coming from a real day one education for Native American studies. 41:40 Yeah. 41:40 All those kinds of things. But it's never too late. 41:42 Great job. 41:43 Thank you. 41:46 Okay, my story is very different than yours. 41:49 As we do, as we do. 41:51 That's what we do. I got to be honest, when this story first got pitched to me by Molly and Allie, I was like, okay. 41:59 I wasn't that. 42:00 Enthralled by it. And then I watched the documentary about it. 42:03 And it's more fascinating than I'm even going to be able to cover today. 42:08 Is this my octopus teacher? 42:09 Oh, I love that book. No, this is a story about wine. 42:17 You know it? 42:20 Okay. I think so. It's September of 2003, and we are right here in Los Angeles at a two Michelin star restaurant called Milis in Santa Monica. Have you been? 42:31 I haven't. 42:32 I've always wanted to go. It's like one of those that are always at the top of the list, but I don't go to the West Side, so I haven't. 42:37 We simply can't. 42:38 The food is French with a focus on local California ingredients. 42:42 But on this particular day in 2003, the food is a bit of an afterthought because the restaurant is the setting for a wine event hosted by a mysterious young newcomer to L.A. 's wine collection scene. Yes. I used to go to these. Okay. 43:01 Megan Thee Stallion. 43:03 I used to get to go to these like alcohol dinners. 43:05 Yeah. 43:06 Because I was doing the cocktail thing. 43:07 Sure. 43:08 And they are so fucking fancy and nice. Yeah. 43:12 Yeah. 43:12 We got to get back in that circuit. 43:14 We do. 43:15 Guys, we're up for it. 43:16 What do you need? We love wine. Two-buck Chuck. Melis. 43:20 Two-buck Chuck. Canned rosé. That's my thing. 43:23 We'll drink wine coolers in the alley before the dinner. 43:25 What do you need us to do? 43:27 Wine coolers. The event has attracted most of the serious wine enthusiasts in the area, despite or maybe because of the fact that the cover price for this dinner is $ 4, 800 a head. 43:38 What? 43:41 What year, 2011? 43:42 So it's 2003. Oh. $ 4, 800 in today's money for this fucking dinner. $ 8, 100. 43:49 $ 9, 000. 43:49 Oh, that's close. 43:50 You were close. Good job. 43:52 But Jesus Christ. 43:54 I know. 43:54 $ 10, 000. 43:55 For a dinner. 43:56 Yeah. 43:56 Is everything included, including apps? 44:00 I think we got past apps when we get there. 44:02 I think all the alcohol tips are all taken care of. 44:05 Yeah. 44:05 Coffee, tea, dessert. 44:07 Exactly. So the event is supposed to feature a lineup of this wine. It's an ultra rare Petrus served in magnums, which are like the giant bottles of wine. 44:18 I love those bottles of wine. 44:20 So silly. 44:20 Yeah. 44:21 Suddenly the French are getting silly. Yeah. 44:23 What was that about? 44:24 That's true. So Petrus, this wine company, is one of the most famous French wines out of the Bordeaux region of France. I know it well. 44:32 I know it well. 44:33 Petrus is the name of the estate. This wine is a Merlot. And this event is held one year before the movie. 44:39 You said Merlot like you were a Merlot. 44:42 Like no one's heard of it before. 44:45 It's a Merlot. 44:46 Merlot. 44:47 Merlot. Merlot. 44:49 This event's held a year before the movie Sideways comes out. 44:52 So that whole like fuck Merlot thing hasn't happened yet. 44:54 It's just taken off. 44:56 That's right. What Sideways will capture when it comes out a year later and propel is a growing level of participation in wine as a hobby and kind of a collector's item, which prior to the 1990s had been more of a niche thing for like Rich, super rich old people. 45:14 Yeah. 45:14 But not anymore. The people drinking Petrus are a much, much fancier kind of wine enthusiast than the sideways folks and would never be turned against a type of grape by a movie. So, fuck you. At this event in 2003, these bottles are very old and rare, the oldest being 45:31 from 1921. Some of these bottles would fetch upwards of $ 20, 000 at auction at the time. The big ones? Yeah. 45:39 So how much is a 20-gram bottle of wine 2003 now? $ 45, 000? 45:43 $ 37, 000. 45:43 You're in the neighborhood. I'm in there. 45:46 Yeah. 45:47 I'm tapping in. 45:47 So imagine buying a fucking $ 40, 000 bottle of wine. 45:50 Which is like if you drank that whole big one. 45:52 Yeah. 45:53 You're just. 45:54 Barfing the next day, shaking. 45:56 It's 40 grand worth of barf. It's a 40 grand. 45:59 It's still a hangover. Hey, it's your life. Do your thing. 46:03 But after a while, doesn't the acid start kind of stripping your teeth away a little bit? 46:08 Yeah, and your stomach lining. 46:10 Switch to twisted teas at that point is my recommendation. 46:14 One attendee at this wine dinner is a man named Paul Wasserman who comes from a prominent wine importing family. 46:20 And he notices something kind of odd about the wine that they're there to celebrate and taste. He says that some of it tastes young. And it's supposed to be from 1920, so it shouldn't. In his tasting notes, he writes, quote, possibly fake, end quote. 46:36 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. 46:55 This is the story of Rudy Kurniawan. 46:58 Rudy! 46:59 Rudy. 47:00 Rudy, the football player who went on to fake wine. 47:03 The main source for this story are an article from New York Magazine by Benjamin Wallace, an article from Vanity Fair by Michael Steinberg, and a documentary called Sour Grapes. 47:13 You've seen it? 47:14 I haven't. I started to watch the beginning, and the tension, I had to turn it off because of whatever thing I was. 47:22 Living through at the time. 47:23 Right. And I think what it is is those are the stories that get me and then I'm like in it. 47:28 I can't stop thinking about it because I do love an antihero. 47:31 He's totally an antihero. This is a total scammer story that the kind we love done so well that it's actually impressive. 47:40 That only Paul Wasserman could tell what was going on. 47:44 So the rest of the sources could be found in the show notes. So California wine enthusiasts start noticing Rudy on the scene around 2001. Yeah. At this point, he's only in his mid-20s, and he's very much like a sideways movie kind of guy. He's drinking nice but not 48:00 rare or noteworthy bottles of wine, often from California. He becomes a regular at local wine tastings and auctions. And no one's totally clear on his backstory, but from the bits and pieces he drops, the impression people get is 48:14 that he's from a wealthy beer-importing family that's from Indonesia. Yeah. 48:19 And Rudy himself attended California State University of Northridge in the late 90s. He came back to the U.S. on a student visa around 1998. And people also know that he lives with his mother, who's an elderly woman, and they live in Arcadia. But it's thought that he must 48:33 be like a trust fund baby, essentially, and using all this fuck you money to buy wine, which gives you access to this world. And it reminds me of like, It's kind of American Psycho, but drunk. Yeah. Because, like, you've got to remember that the thing that everyone's, like, 48:50 talking about and loving is getting you slowly drunk. It kind of reminds me more of, like, the movie Swingers. Yeah. 48:56 You know, where everyone's just sitting around talking shit in the middle of the day, drinking really fucking expensive wine. Yeah. 49:02 I mean, I don't want to brag, but I am from Sonoma County, which is, like, the new Napa County. Yeah. 49:06 But when I was growing up, Napa was it. 49:08 Yeah. 49:09 And so those people were kind of everywhere. 49:11 Right. 49:12 And it is a really funny, like in the 2000s, that's when people started swirling their wine. People would tell me it's earthy, it's chocolatey, all that shit where you're like, I don't care. 49:22 Pour it or drink it. But like out of the way. 49:25 I've drank little sips of expensive wine before and I could not tell the fucking difference. You know? 49:30 Or just like make it your hobby elsewhere. Yeah. 49:33 But like there was a real. 49:35 performative and presentational wine drinking. 49:37 Exactly. And it's such a boys club, you know. And so Rudy kind of infiltrated this club. 49:43 Nice. 49:44 He's in a lot of the documentary Sour Grapes because they were making a movie about him. It's like before they knew what was going on. And he's got this cute, playful vibe. He is a great talker. He's a great bullshitter. 49:57 And he just seems interesting. And they're like, who's this really wealthy guy? We want to know more about him. 50:02 We want to hang out with him. He gets invited to all these Fancy dinners and shows up with the most fucking expensive bottles of wine you could imagine. 50:09 I mean, isn't that the sad part about scammers is that they really are kind of the best? 50:14 Yeah. 50:14 Until you find out you love them and they're like, it's like, oh, my God, thank God that guy's here. 50:19 Yes. So in this world, Rudy very quickly graduates from California wines to rare French Bordeaux wines like that Magnum from the tasting in Santa Monica. 50:28 Yeah. 50:29 And then to the highest tier of wine snobbery, which is rare French Burgundies. So Burgundy is the region where the snobbiest of wine snobs tend to focus their interest. 50:40 And Rudy basically holds his own among them. He's got an amazing palate and an amazing memory. On multiple occasions, he participates in blind taste tests and correctly identifies the exact wine and even year that he's drinking. Jesus Christ. 50:55 So that's not bullshit. Like, you kind of have to know what you're talking about. Or he got lucky. Who knows? 51:01 But to name the year? 51:02 No, totally. 51:03 That's intense. 51:03 Totally. So around this time, he starts buying up all these rare burgundies, and he basically buys all of them. 51:09 And in the early 2000s, he's a fixture at every major wine auction, and he basically bids any price until he wins these rare burgundies. So people are paying attention to him. 51:20 And in the background, is he just charging up his Discover card like crazy? How is he doing it? 51:25 We'll get into that. Okay, okay. So during this time period, the demand for these vintages skyrocket, and much of this is due to Rudy single-handedly pumping up the demand. It's very smart, you know what I mean? It's so smart. 51:36 He makes them a rare commodity, and so the value rises, right? 51:41 And so in a very short amount of time, he's driven up the prices for these wines by a staggering margin. 51:46 In 2002, a particular bottle would go for about $ 2, 600. 51:48 In 2012, 10 years later, the same one goes— for $ 124, 000. 51:55 That's more than inflation. That is its rarity. 52:00 That's almost like you should pay the employees at your company more than minimum wage and instead of having one. 52:06 Bottle of wine. How dare you think like that? 52:10 I know. 52:10 What are you, a fascist? 52:11 Hello, Zoran Mamdani, please. 52:14 It's very absurd. And these people, you know, they have so much money that they're probably bored and have collections of everything. And so wine becomes One of those many things that they try to find happiness through and probably don't. 52:28 And they also are investments because they can sell them years and years later. Yes. For this much fucking money. 52:35 I mean, it's not comparable, but I was going to say it's like me and Sephora. 52:38 That's true. I mean, one of those like benefit old like bronzers. I bet that would sell for a lot more money. 52:45 It's like you can't get this color anymore. 52:47 You can't. 52:47 I have it because I bought all of them because none of them match my skin tone. 52:50 I have all of them and never used them except for once because they look like shit on me. 52:54 Come to the big drawer in my bathroom. 52:56 Well, there's a lot of estate sale girlies online that show these random things you would pass over in an estate sale in the bathroom that are like perfumes and makeups that people just want because they canceled that scent or their mom used to wear that scent or their 53:11 grandma used to wear that. It's like a bar of soap for a fucking month of money. 53:15 There's a Clinique quad of eyeshadows that if I saw it, I don't know how much I'd pay. 53:20 That blue Maybelline with the shitty-ass little. 53:22 Yeah, with the little guy and they're real sparkly. 53:25 Yeah, amen. So by the mid-2000s, Rudy is a complete fixture on this wine scene, and he also has cornered the market on rare burgundies. It's said that he is spending a million dollars a month at wine auctions. Paul Wasserman, the guy who had some doubts about Rudy's first big 53:45 event and pretty much everyone else on the scene, is now a true believer. He's gone to plenty of dinners and tastings where Rudy has poured wines that taste to everyone like the real deal. He becomes known in this wine circle for his amazing palate, the incredible cellar he's 54:01 developed so quickly, and for being very generous with his wine. 54:04 That's the hook. 54:05 That's how you hook them in. Everyone likes Rudy. Within the wine world, Rudy falls in with a group that forms around a guy named John Capon. So John is from New York, and his family owns one of the city's oldest wine stores. Oh, wow. Yeah. So it's called Acker, Merrill, 54:24 and Condit. John is 32, so somewhere around Rudy's age, and he's trying to make his family business a major player in the world of wine auctions. John likes to be one of those guys who, quote, does things a little bit differently. That's what Allie put in there, and 54:37 I love that because we all know what that means. 54:40 He's known for his tasting notes, which are written in sort of a bad boy flair. He refers to sex all the time with his metaphors for like what a wine tastes like. It's very obnoxious. 54:49 Very 2000s. 54:49 Yeah, exactly. Details magazine. It's swingers. It's like, you know what I mean? It's the Vince Vaughn kind of vibe. 54:56 This vintage is giving me a boner. 54:58 That kind of stuff. Exactly, exactly. The good stuff. John forms this group of wine aficionados called Twelve Angry Men. 55:06 Most of them are younger finance types who've recently gotten into wine collecting. And it is funny why they named it the Angry Men Club, because they'd show up to a party or a dinner with their fabulous, amazing, expensive, rare bottle of wine. Everyone would do an ah, and 55:21 then everyone else would brag their two buck chuck. So he's like, what the fuck? I wasted this bottle of wine for who don't care. So he started this group of people who actually care and bring, you know, a are kind of trying to one-up each other, it seems like, 55:33 and trying to wow each other. 55:34 This sounds like the beginning of white nationalism, but we'll see. 55:37 You tell me. It reminds me of the Pappy... Pappy and Harriet's? No, what was the Pappy Van Winkle's? 55:42 Oh, yeah, yeah. 55:43 Whiskey thing that you did? 55:44 Yes. 55:44 Where like, if you know, you know. 55:46 And those people get taken advantage of because they so badly want to be the people who know. 55:50 Yeah, they just want to have it on their shelves and be able to say that they got it. 55:53 But it is a fun culture. It's like you're into movies, you're into whatever. 55:57 Oh, yeah. It's like you get buzzed. Exactly. 56:00 You get to get drunk and pretend that's your interest. 56:02 Exactly. Like at the end of the day, that's way more fun than going to a museum and like being into like Picasso or whatever because you get to get drunk while you're doing it. 56:10 But when that was my interest, just because I didn't know the vintage of anything, I'm a scumbag. Whatever. 56:15 And then like you probably get really close to people really quickly because when you're drunk, you just fucking spill it all. And so now they're like your best friends. 56:22 Your wine bonding. 56:23 Yes. 56:23 Vintage bonding. 56:24 And you're just like calling it tasting, but really... I was just drinking. 56:27 You're just drinking and you're exchanging your fleece vests and you're having a great finance time. 56:32 Rich drinking isn't the same as poor drinking. 56:36 Although they do do a lot of coke. Well, that'll be the next story. 56:39 And no offense to the drawing room. I love that place more than anything. I've done a lot of poor drinking there and it is the best place to be, rich or poor. Yes. 56:47 You know, very rich people love to go there. 56:49 I know. Kiefer Sutherland didn't have a photo of his pants around his ankles there. 56:54 That place was mayhem central, and that's all anyone wants. 56:58 Yeah, it still is, I bet. I'm sorry. 57:00 I will pause you one second. 57:01 Go ahead. We walked into the drawing room after not getting kicked out of the rustic inn, but just like it had died down. We go across the streets. We absolutely lit up. Me and my friend, Danny Ceballos, who most of my stories are about, sit down. I turn 57:16 to figure out what kind of beer I want or whatever. 57:18 Looking down here, I turn back around. Danny's making out with the girl that he. 57:22 Just sat down next to. 57:23 Just sat down and stood up. 57:24 I was just like, oh, it's on at the drawing room. Yeah. 57:28 That's sexy. 57:29 And that's the drawing room. 57:30 Okay. 57:30 Order a nice, rare Bordeaux as drunk Karen at the drawing room. 57:35 I don't know. Did you have the kind of 7-Up in? 57:40 Not 7-Up in it. Red? 57:42 What are the tasting notes? 57:45 It tastes like a juke perfume. 57:50 And then you realize you put your cigarette out in it. 57:53 I was like, can you light? 57:55 Thank you for doing that. 57:56 And scene. 57:57 And scene. I needed it. So John, the bad boy, and Rudy become friends. And John brings him into this group, which is all the young angry men. They all adore him. 58:08 They accept the generously shared bottles from Rudy's now massive cellar. 58:13 They often meet up at Crew, which is a restaurant in Greenwich Village in New York. which is famous for its wine focus. And what the group may or may not know is that after every dinner, which Rudy has gone to and brought his nice bottles of wine, he 58:27 always asks the restaurant to FedEx him the empty bottles. 58:30 Which he wants to catalog the great wines he's drank and maybe put the candles in them like we did in junior high school. You know what I mean? 58:37 Just different colored candles. 58:38 Yeah. 58:38 It's like not that crazy, but that is called foreshadowing. 58:42 I mean, but also you just spent, you know, three used cars worth on a bottle of wine. 58:48 You better save that bottle. 58:49 Totally. You're showing off who you are by the wine that you drink and you want to keep the memory of that. I get that. 58:55 Yeah. 58:56 So it's only natural that when Rudy decides he wants to unload some of his collection that he should do it with John and Acker's fledgling wine auctioning business, his friend's wine company. By this point, Rudy has been selling 59:08 very expensive bottles individually through online auction houses. As early as 2003, someone had complained to one of these auction houses about a suspect bottle purchased from Rudy. So people are already noticing. It must have been through these smaller-scale sales, 59:24 still with bottles going sometimes for tens of thousands at a time, that Rudy funded what looked to outsiders like a lavish lifestyle. So they never totally figure out where he gets his money. Yeah. And it's kind of interesting. 59:38 I'll get more into it, but— I. 59:40 Think that's one of the reasons why in early days in our like Gilded Age eras, there were so many scammers because it was like rude to talk about that. 59:50 Right. 59:50 So it's like, oh, well, I'm just going to assume you have a bunch of money if you're in this realm. Yeah. 59:55 Well, I was impressed that he would sit there drinking glass after glass of wine and not at the end go, you guys, I'm fucking scamming all of you. I would have done that immediately. Guess what? 60:03 That's the key. 60:04 You can't be a scammer if you're going to spill it every time. 60:07 So Rudy dresses in Hermes suits. Did you see I got the Hermes? and drives a Bentley and a Ferrari. 60:13 But it's in 2006 that he makes actual tangible millions through two auctions held by his friend John and the company. 60:21 At these two auctions, one in January, one in September, Rudy sells $ 35 million worth of wine. Holy shit. Many of these are rare Burgundies, and they go to some of the world's wealthiest and most serious wine collectors. Side note, they don't like to be made a fool of. 60:36 Side note, they're already drunk when they start drinking these fancy wines. 60:40 It's about 35,000 bottles of wine total for that $ 35 million. Goddamn. 60:45 So these are going for truly astronomical prices. 60:48 Cut to my sister in line at Target buying all the crayons for her classroom every year. 60:52 Oh, my God. You know. In today's money, the total spent, that $ 35 million on those bottles of wine, would be worth close to $ 80, 000. 61:00 What? Eighty. Eighty. 61:03 Seventy. Seventy. Damn it. I wanted you to be. 61:10 I wanted to, but then I panicked and I was like, wait, is it a million or a hundred thousand? Totally. 61:14 That's the problem with this game is I forget what I'm talking about. I know. Rudy starts spending wildly buying a mansion in Bel Air, which he starts doing extensive renovations on. He also buys a lot of art. He's a fucking wealthy dude now. 61:26 Yeah, he's going to flex. 61:28 It's these two major auctions that start arousing suspicion among major wine collectors. You've got to go low pro. You know, you can't do the big fucking crazy thing and make people feel stupid. That's right. Or they're going to come after you. 61:40 But low pro means smaller paydays. It takes too long. 61:44 And he's just like going for it. 61:45 Exactly. So these like old school, you know, more traditional wine buyers with the fucking wine cellars. And I mean, they're so wealthy. You'd go cross-eyed. 61:55 And they make their whole life of it. 61:57 Yeah. And it's generational money. So like. Some of the lots from Rudy's collection are entire cases of rare old vintages that you just don't see. So he's just going for broke. They think it's impossible for Rudy to have amassed so many of them over such a short period 62:14 of time. In January 2007, a year after the first big auction and two years after the second, a group of them get together in New Jersey to try to find some of the wines from the auction. And they find inconsistencies in some of the labels, and some just 62:29 taste simply off. So the people who actually— Exactly. It's too young. 62:33 I start saying that all the time. 62:34 It's too young. The thing is, wine fraud is probably a lot more rampant than we know about. When a wine collector or dealer has suspicions that a vintage might not be what it purports to be, there's not a lot of incentive to make a big fuss about it. 62:47 This is for a few reasons. They don't want to be blacklisted by any buyers or dealers that are involved in the sale. You know, you're telling a dealer that they're fraud, essentially. 62:57 Yeah. 62:58 And they don't like to hear that. 62:59 Or that you're a fraud. So it's something went wrong somewhere along the way. 63:03 The FBI generally doesn't prioritize billionaires getting scammed out of like 20 grand. So you know what I mean? You buy this, they don't care. And anybody involved in the industry doesn't really have an interest in tainting its reputation 63:16 by pointing out these frauds. It just looks bad for everyone. 63:20 All this is to say the wine industry is probably full of scammers and everyone just kind of accepts it. Yeah. 63:26 You know? 63:26 This feels a little bit like Dr. 63:28 Death. You know, that story where you're just like, you're telling me that because of all these insurance reasons and all this, like, saving face and all that stuff, they're going to let a spinal surgeon continue on. 63:39 Because it doesn't start here. So why am I going to start pointing fingers? It starts way back there. It's above my pay grade, you know? So everyone... Just kind of accepts it, except for a crotchety old rich man named Bill Koch. 63:57 One of the Koch brothers? 63:58 One of the Koch brothers. Oh, no. Billionaire heirs to an oil business. Charles and David, his brothers, bought out the other two, are known for being massive conservative mega donors. 64:09 Bill is less serious about politics, but he also donates to conservative causes. He's in this documentary, Sour Grapes, and he goes down to his wine cellar and is like pointing out all the fucking wine. It's crazy. And his main passion in life is collecting things. 64:23 People down in the wine cellar? 64:25 Probably. Particularly collecting wine. And he has bought many bottles of wine from Rudy's to auctions. Yeah. 64:32 Like, I think you said this earlier, but you're never going to be able to beat the generationally wealthy. No. 64:37 They know. No. Yeah. At the same time that the wine enthusiasts are in New Jersey and they're You know, starting to suspect some shit. Bill, actually, Bill Koch hired a whole investigative team to root out fake bottles from his own collection. So he, I feel like a lot 64:56 of men especially would not want to admit that they've been scammed. 64:59 No. 65:00 And he's okay with it. 65:01 Especially after they spend all this time root, root around. 65:04 Yeah, exactly. 65:05 Whirling their glass and doing all that dumb bullshit and going, yes, this is exactly. 65:10 It makes you look, makes the buyer look foolish. Yes. 65:13 So they don't say anything. 65:15 Yeah. 65:15 And it's hard to tell when something is fake. There's so many little tells, but you can't just taste it and know or you can't just look at the label and know. 65:24 It's just. 65:25 This is why we have to have confidence. 65:27 Right. 65:27 We just have to. 65:27 Right. 65:28 Because we do know. You know when something's too young as a vintage. 65:32 This is young. This is young to me. So he has his team go down to his cellar and find all the fake bottles of wine. 65:39 Do you know how many people were on the team? 65:41 I don't know. 65:41 150? 65:41 I probably, yeah. It's going to take a while. And this investigation turns out something like 400 bottles of wine that are fake in his cellar, which he paid $ 4 million about for. 65:55 Oh, now Bill Coke is mad. 65:57 Yeah, all these are fake. They find all sorts of inconsistencies on the labels. There's misspellings. There's incorrect types of wax that are used, you know, to cover the bottle. 66:06 They can even test the glue themselves. that was used to put on the labels and be like, this is Elmer's glue. And they didn't start making this until the 70s. 66:14 And so this bottle of 1920 something wine is fake. 66:17 It could be that. Yeah, it's rubber cement peeling out on the side. 66:20 It's pretty interesting. 66:21 I love that there were misspellings. 66:23 That's so where they're like, first, we're going to run the spell check test. 66:27 That's just that's the first thing to do, you guys. 66:30 And so the worst offenders seem to be the bottles from Rudy. So they're not all from Rudy, but there's a lot from Rudy. Bill's investigators send four bottles to the estate that they're supposed to have come from in France, 66:41 who are immediately able to tell these are not real. No, no, no, no, no. 66:46 So while all this is going on, Rudy is basically still at it. And he has friends in the wine industry who think maybe he has inadvertently bought and resold some fake wine. It's like maybe he's been scammed as well. 66:58 Yes. 66:58 No one in this documentary knows. thinks he would do such a thing at all. 67:02 He's an inside guy. 67:03 Yeah. And they all like him. So everyone kind of shrugs it off. And knowing it's par for the course in the wine industry, there's going to be fakes in there. 67:11 It's 400 to so many, though, for one collection. That's insane. 67:14 But then ahead of yet another of those auctions in January of 2008, a man named Laurent Ponceau He's French. 67:23 Laurent Ponceau. Exactly. He's in Burgundy and he gets a catalog. 67:27 I guess they send out these auction catalogs of what's going to be up. Yeah, I get them every quarter. 67:33 I have the Beanie Baby auction catalog. Like, what's coming up? 67:36 You know what I get is the Vermont Country Store catalog. 67:39 No. 67:39 It is the best thing you've ever seen. Slippers. 67:43 Do we have taffy and caramel? Yes. 67:45 Those big canisters of caramel corn. Yes. And a grandma nightgown. 67:49 Once in a while, someone will send us a fucking basket from wherever. 67:53 Yes. 67:54 With all the snacks and cheese that probably should be in the fridge and isn't. 67:57 Don't have to. 67:58 Love it. Love it. Give it. That's right. The Ponceau Estate, basically Laurent's estate, is one of the most celebrated winemakers in Burgundy. And Laurent, of course, takes his family's wine extremely seriously. And so when he sees this catalog, it 68:14 shows bottles of his family wine from 1959 and 1945. 68:20 But the estate had only started making that variety of wine in the 80s. 68:23 There it is. 68:24 So he sees his own fucking fraudulent wine. 68:27 That is, like, crazy. 68:30 And I love that, like, it's not just that, like, they— something's misspelled, it's that it's impossible to exist. You know what I mean? It didn't happen. 68:38 If the French didn't already hate us so much, now it's just like, how dare? 68:43 Exactly. So Laurent shows up at this auction, which is fucking ballsy, takes a seat in the back. And then when those lots come up, he stands up and demands that they be withdrawn. They're like, who are you, sir? Well, I'm fucking the guy himself. Those aren't real. Jimmy Wine Jr. 69:01 Get that shit out of here. 69:03 Yeah. So he says, quote, when you find a fake wine, it's dirt on the integrity of Burgundy and I wanted to wash it. So like it's offensive to his like family name. 69:15 You know? 69:15 Then he pulls out a sword and he says, on guard. 69:18 Exactly. So the lots are withdrawn and Laurent goes and asks the head, John Capon, the auctioneer who submitted those lots to the wine to be auctioned. And he says, who owns these that submitted them to be sold off? 69:32 And he points him to Rudy. 69:34 Is Rudy there? 69:35 I don't know. I think he's there and he kind of avoids him a lot. He becomes real squirrely and like, oh, I lost my phone and I got a new one, so I didn't get your messages. Or I can't hang out with you today. I will do it another day. 69:48 I'm busy. 69:49 Or he's just standing behind a tree holding his glass really close. 69:53 So they do, Laurent and Rudy do meet up at Jean Georges, which is a very fancy restaurant in New York. 70:00 And known for its wine list. Please get me a reservation for that. Begging. 70:04 Yes. 70:05 At this lunch, Laurent asked Rudy where those fake wines are coming from. So Rudy, he's very evasive about everything, obviously. 70:13 And he writes down two phone numbers for different people in Indonesia being like, this is where I get my wine from. So Laurent, who spent a lot of time in Asia, including Indonesia, with wealthy wine buyers, goes to Indonesia to try and track down these people. Like, you 70:26 can't fucking, like, throw this guy off your trail. 70:29 No, because he'll just buy a helicopter and go above the trail. 70:31 Exactly. He's the wrong guy to have this happen to. 70:35 Also, he's a pissed Frenchman. 70:37 Yes. 70:38 That you offended his wine. 70:40 His family name and wine and the land that they've been cultivating for hundreds of years. 70:45 You might as well go to Italy and break the spaghetti right before you boil it. I know. 70:49 Ask for some ketchup for your fucking spaghetti. Yes. So he's trying to track down where Rudy comes from, where this wine is coming from. He can't find anyone, even in Indonesia, who knows about Rudy, who's supposed to be the wealthy son of a beer importer. Like, it's just 71:05 he can't track anything down. At the same time, Bill Koch is on his trail as well, who also has a helicopter to fly over the trail. He hires a team of investigators, including a fucking ex-FBI agent. 71:18 Of course. 71:18 So, like, you can't, you're fucking with the wrong people. Like, go a little bit lower. Right. You know? 71:22 Like, just go in and steal, rip people off. 71:25 Yeah. 71:25 Steal the tip money that people leave on the table at Applebee's. Exactly. 71:29 So, Bill's team finds out when they're investigating Rudy that he's overstayed his visa. So, this triggers an investigation from the actual FBI agent. And so the FBI digs into Rudy's financials and they show that Rudy owes money all 71:43 over the place. He owes millions to Amex, millions to his friends and millions. 71:48 Sorry, how do you owe millions to Amex? You have to pay that thing off every month. I don't know. 71:52 I think it's like when you're that wealthy, they must have some like thing that you don't. I don't know. 71:58 But he also, he owns millions of friends. He's also borrowing off of the money from the auction house, his friend's auction house. 72:04 Yeah. 72:05 Where he's like, here's the case of wine that you know is going to sell at the next auction in a couple months. Give me that money. And so they really want like their auction house to become a big thing. 72:14 So they do that. 72:15 They front him. 72:15 They front him a lot of money. Yeah. So inexplicably, while this investigation is ongoing, other auction houses continue to sell Rudy's wine. Do they not know? They know that there's like people are talking, but I don't think they know if it's fake or not. 72:28 I bet they're just like, let's fucking offload this while we can. 72:30 Right. 72:31 Get our percentage. 72:32 Losses. Not our fault. 72:33 Yeah. Christie's includes his wines in the catalog for 2009 auction. 72:38 But at this point, the word is getting around in the wine community about Rudy. And so those lots are later withdrawn. This sort of cat and mouse situation actually continues for another three years before anything is done about 72:49 this on an official legal level. And this is possibly because the FBI has bigger fish to fry than billionaires almost willfully getting scammed. 72:59 Right? Yeah. It's not the saddest story in the world that you bought a bottle of wine for $ 10, 000 and it's not good. 73:06 Especially because it's like, to what? Drink it. 73:09 Right. 73:10 Drink it and you'll never know. Drink a couple of them. 73:12 Barf. 73:13 I mean, what do you want? 73:14 Yeah. 73:16 So on March 8th, it's just so absurd. On March 8th, 2012, FBI agents serve a warrant at Rudy's house in Arcadia. 73:24 They go very early to his house. Rudy answers the door in his pajamas. And when agents search the house, they find basically him running his fraud shop out of this little house in Arcadia. Yeah. They found thousands of 73:39 labels for rare, expensive wines. They find hundreds of corks, both old and new. Because remember, you have to There's many levels that you have to fake, including the taste of the wine and all its outfit that it's wearing. 73:52 And the things that affect the taste of the wine, like cork, right? 73:55 Exactly, yes. They find bottles soaking in the sink to get the labels to come off. They find bottles of wine with recipes on them, seemingly blends of wine that would convincingly replicate the taste. So he still knows what it tastes like. But then the more you do that, 74:09 when Allie and I used to create cocktails— By the end of the cocktail tasting, you're fucking drunk. Right. Who cares? 74:17 So these like measurements you've been writing down don't make any sense anymore. You know? 74:21 Do you think he was drinking while he was doing it? 74:24 I can't imagine. 74:25 Or he was like little sips. 74:27 But then eventually. 74:27 Yeah. 74:28 He must have been tasting it. Yeah. 74:30 But to know that is like, it's like when we've told stories of people who fake paintings. What are they called? 74:35 Imposters. Kind of. But whatever. 74:39 It's like they have the talent. 74:40 Yes. 74:40 They can do it. That's what's so funny. 74:42 Yeah. This is what I take away from the story. 74:45 So they find bottles of cheap wine from California with the names of much more expensive wines from France, scrawled on them, ready to be poured into doctored bottles. Like they find his whole operation. 74:55 A nice white barefoot. Barefoot. 74:57 That's what my dad always gets. 74:59 Just get the barefoot Chardonnay. 75:00 That's all they have at, like, 7-Eleven is, like, barefoot. 75:03 Just get a little barefoot. Who cares? I wouldn't know. 75:05 So the investigation winds up sourcing a lot of bottles sold by Rudy, and many of them turn out to be fake, including a fair amount of the Petro fancy burgundy. 75:14 So here's the raid. A photo of the raid at Rudy's house. So here are all like his kitchen where he's doing this crazy wine business. 75:22 Guys, I just love bottles. 75:23 Yeah. And I love labels. He's got stamps. Like he's really, really trying hard to fake it. 75:29 But he doesn't have a copy editor and that's. 75:32 Exactly. That's like his recipes. And then here's a photo of the counterfeit wine. So that looks real to me. 75:37 Looks so real. 75:38 Right. Except for the big counterfeit stamp. Yeah, I know. 75:41 It's like, what does that red stamp say? 75:43 The official story from the feds is that Rudy acted alone. 75:46 But a lot of people don't buy that because the investigation finds that some of the paper used in labels comes from Indonesia. And Laurent points out that there have to be other people helping him. 75:59 Sure. 76:00 He estimates that to fake one bottle of wine would have taken about an hour or so. But given all of the details in creating the antique-looking labels— So if that's one bottle and he has faked thousands and thousands, that doesn't add up. In this little kitchen, in this 76:16 little house, it doesn't add up to how much he faked it. So there's probably a bigger scheme behind him. 76:22 I think it's easy to imagine that if Rudy just went to some people and were like, hey, do you want to fuck over some billionaires? People are like, I'd love to any way I can. 76:31 Yes. So, yeah. I'll take a shift. So friends think that 90% of Rudy's wine is real. His friends, like, refuse to believe this. They think that most of his wine is real. There's no way he could have created so many fakes on his own in that little house. 76:44 And at the end of the day, they really don't want to know and they don't want to admit that they've been tricked by a friend. Yeah. So over two auctions, he sold about 12,000 bottles. And it would have been impossible for him to fake that many bottles. If one 77:00 bottle takes an hour to fake, let's say. We know that there was some real wine mixed in, but even so, a lot of people think he would have had to have substantial outside help and believe that part of the story has never been totally cleared up. They just caught 77:13 this one guy, punished him, and moved on. 77:15 That there's like a mini Rudy factory somewhere in Indonesia. 77:20 Laurent believes that he had help from other wine insiders because of the level of historical specificity that was correct on the fake bottles, even among all the mistakes. 77:31 Can I tell you a theory? Yeah. What if the 12 angry men wine group? 77:35 Is that what it is? I don't know. 77:37 But they're all rich guys. So like they have lawyers allegedly. 77:40 Theories theorizing personal editorial. 77:43 It doesn't seem like it. It seems like they had money and no reason to do that. You know? 77:47 Yeah. 77:48 Did they get ripped off at all? 77:49 Yes. 77:49 They totally got ripped off. But isn't that how we do it in our scams? That's right. And so this whole part of the mystery has never actually been solved. 77:57 But it does come out that Rudy's birth name is Zhen Huang Huang. which is, so it's Chinese, although it's not unusual for Chinese people living in Indonesia to have an Indonesian name. It turns out that the name Rudy Kurniawan is the name of an Indonesian badminton player from 78:15 the 1970s. But it seems like that's actually the name his dad gave him, like the American name to use. 78:23 It's not like an alias. It is an alias, but not a tricky alias. 78:28 They just needed a name that sounded less. 78:31 Yeah. 78:32 Like Chinese to adapt to Indonesian lifestyle? 78:36 Yes. And they're badminton fans. So that's the name. And his brother has a similar name, like a badminton player's name. 78:42 I would love to pick a badminton player's name for our new names if we could. 78:46 Sounds great. Can we do that? Get that done? Yes. 78:48 Okay. 78:48 In December of 2013, Rudy's convicted of fraud, becoming the first person ever to be convicted for selling fake wine in the U.S., He's sentenced to 10 years in prison. Ridiculous. 78:59 And his attorney's like, I've had mob clients with actual dead bodies, like to their name, get less time than that. 79:06 Let's get one rapist in jail for 10 years. 79:10 Truly. Oh, wait. 79:11 Russell Brand just got. 79:12 Oh, yeah. He sentenced 10 years. He has to pay $ 28. 4 million back to his victims. 79:18 Jesus. 79:19 So you know it's more than that. 79:20 He's like, I spent all that on labels and glue. 79:23 Exactly. It's so interesting to me because at what point then do these bottles that he counterfeited become worth actual money because he is part of the story now? 79:38 Yep. 79:38 Right? And like what? What a fun party trick to be like, one of these wines was counterfeited by Rudy at a party. Here's a bunch from the same batch. 79:48 One of them is counterfeit. Let's see if you can figure out which one it is. 79:52 That sounds like the two-buck-chuck blind taste test they were making people do. It's like, hey, wine snobs, you fall for this every time. So it feels like, yes, that would absolutely be the fun next level. Totally. 80:04 After completing his sentence, Rudy is released from prison in November 2020 and deported back to Indonesia. 80:10 Yeah. 80:11 In 2021. And then I found this thing that says that he has been counterfeiting wines as a party trick at exclusive dinners in Singapore. Yes. So that they can be compared. He fucking did. He's doing that now. That's his party trick. He shows up. 80:26 The rich have to guess which one is real. 80:28 And he's the guy who like bamboozled all these white American dudes out of so much money. And in Singapore, they're like, we fucking love this guy. And he still is. Like, he is a cool guy to have around. He's a fun guy to have around. Rudy! So we're all kind 80:44 of rooting for him a little bit. 80:45 Can't help it. 80:46 You can't help it. And on multiple occasions, I guess most of the guests have preferred the fakes. 80:52 I mean, even better. 80:54 It's pretty brilliant. Sour Grapes states that as many as 10,000 counterfeit bottles were created by Rudy in That may still be in private collections. So they're still out there. 81:06 Let's get the Koch brothers to donate some money and investigate everybody's wine collection. 81:10 Sure. I mean, it's pretty brilliant in terms of like a victimless collection. crime. And if the victims are billionaires, we don't really care. 81:21 There are people, if you're going to spend more than $ 5, 000 on a bottle of wine, that's on you. 81:27 If your wine cellar is worth more than like most people's salary in their entire lives, in the entire state, then we don't fucking care that you got scammed. 81:39 Sorry. If you have a collection of a thousand bottles of wine and all of it is that, like, Go fuck yourself. 81:46 And it's kind of fun. It's great. 81:48 I mean, I love this story. 81:50 And that is the story of Rudy Kurniawan, who perpetrated history's biggest wine fraud that we know of. 81:57 Good for you, Rudy. 81:58 Rudy, come to the Exactly Right Holiday Party. We'll sneak you into the country. 82:03 Rudy is the first and best mixologist of all time. 82:07 A wine mixologist. 82:09 A true tricky mixologist. 82:11 Yeah, I mean... It's pretty entertaining. Hilarious. So, like, yeah, I was like, a wine fraud? Who cares? And then I was like, this guy? This guy. Get him. 82:22 It's about having a little pluck. 82:24 Yes. 82:24 And going up against the caste system of this world. 82:28 Right. Who are bored out of their minds. They've been rich their whole lives. There is some rumors that his uncles maybe committed fraud. and stole money from banks in Indonesia. 82:40 It's all alleged, and I'm not going to get into that. 82:43 And that's where allegedly he got the money to start trading in this wine. But that's all alleged, and I don't know if it's true. 82:51 But you're saying maybe it was in his blood and he'd been trained by the best. 82:56 Yeah. I love it. But he did it. 82:58 Scammer stories forever. 82:59 For sure. 83:00 They really do bring America together. 83:02 Yeah. Well, yeah, think about that when you're opening that bottle of wine at Thanksgiving and your mom is sipping on her Chablis. 83:11 And you're like, Mom, this Chablis is so young. We've got to get it together. 83:15 It's so young. A really good fun trick to play, like tell your sister this is the game we're going to play, is whoever makes up the most ridiculous words to describe the wine and who makes the other person laugh wins. 83:27 Yes. 83:27 So haunted is a great descriptor. 83:30 That's good. 83:30 A great descriptor. Young. We've got young. Young is good. Pensive. Pensive. 83:36 This is great. 83:36 This is a pensive Chardonnay. 83:38 This is suspicious. Chardonnay. I'm getting notes of. 83:44 This Merlot is a little bit passive-aggressive in its undertones. 83:47 I'm getting mealworms. I'm getting notes of mealworm. What are you getting? I don't know. 83:53 There seems to be some anti-American, Franco-phile vibes here. 83:59 I'm drinking the coldest mocha. 84:02 That's disgusting. 84:03 It's like an old coffee in there. 84:05 Yeah. It's a fun Thanksgiving, you know, something to talk about with your family. Yeah. 84:10 This is all we want to do, listener, is we want to give you either the entertainment, the game ideas, just the attitude that you can be in the holidays with your family. 84:19 And succeed. 84:20 Yeah. Do a wine taste test with your family. Like get an expensive bottle, get a cheap bottle, get everything in between. Yeah. See if your dad talks so much shit all the time about wine. 84:28 Yeah. 84:29 Can actually fucking. Prove it. Prove it. Prove it. Dad. 84:32 And then suddenly everyone's drunk and happy. Yeah. Take pictures. 84:36 Post it as content. 84:37 Right. 84:38 Tag us. 84:38 This is the way. 84:40 All right. 84:40 Well. 84:41 A great one. 84:41 Yeah. 84:42 This was a great episode. I think we learned a lot. 84:44 I do too. Yeah. 84:45 I think we really holistically celebrated both. 84:49 The beginning of autumn, Thanksgiving. 84:52 This episode had great legs. It was very young and suspicious. 84:56 And a hot wine ass. Do they ever describe it like that? This wine has a hot ass. 85:02 This slutty, smutty wine has a hot. 85:06 Ass. 85:06 Stay sexy. And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie? 85:19 This has been an Exactly Right production. 85:21 Our managing producer is Molly Smith. 85:23 Our consulting producer is Kate Schellenbach. 85:25 Our creative lead is Allison Agosti. 85:27 Our associate producer is Tessa Hughes, and our editor is Aristotle Acevedo. 85:31 This episode was mixed by Liana Squalacci. 85:33 Our researchers are Maren McGlashan and Allie Elkin. 85:36 Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder at gmail.com and follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder. 85:42 Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. 85:47 Or watch new episodes every week on Netflix. Search for My Favorite Murder, add us to your list, and hit the double thumbs up button. 85:55 Goodbye.
Community discussion