Andy Baldwin for the Defense: Scott Schuck and the Murder of Rebecca Cassidy

In 2010, a woman named Rebecca Cassidy disappeared in Shelbyville, Indiana. In 2014, police found her remains buried on her boyfriend Scott Schuck's property. Schuck was charged with murder, but that was just the beginning.

In this episode, The Murder Sheet will recap the latest court happenings in this case, defense attorney Andy Baldwin's role in defending his client, and the various twists and turns that have resulted in this case remaining unresolved for almost a decade.

Our episode on the Caden Smith case: https://art19.com/shows/murder-sheet/episodes/59edcfb1-a293-47db-ade0-849a0c18c4d6

Part one of our profile series on Andy: https://art19.com/shows/murder-sheet/episodes/e8bdc5c3-bfa5-456a-bbfa-c1b07b68552b

Part two of our profile series on Andy: https://art19.com/shows/murder-sheet/episodes/d7af57b9-0e7d-4676-9122-341ed82af537

Part three of our profile series on Andy: https://art19.com/shows/murder-sheet/episodes/63aa4337-a51a-48de-8922-9b74938da437

Send tips to [email protected].

The Murder Sheet is a production of Mystery Sheet LLC .

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

We’re thrilled to work with our sponsor Brilliant Earth. This company offers the very best in engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry, all the while acting as an ethical trailblazer in the diamond industry. 

This is the firm to go to if you’re looking for a beautiful piece of jewelry, but you don’t want to worry about contributing to unethical sourcing or unsustainable practices. They’re so far ahead of the competition. Less than 1% of other diamond suppliers meet their sky high ethical standards, specifically their game-changing Beyond Conflict Free guarantee. They are committed to only accepting diamonds from countries and companies that strictly follow international labor, trade, and environmental standards.

You’re getting the very best without compromising on quality. Their wide selection offers both natural and lab diamonds, while 98% of their gold and 97% of their silver comes from recycled sources. Plus, shopping at Brilliant Earth is fun. There’s something for everyone, like classic freesia diamond rings or their secret halo rings for all of us who love subtle, intricate details. Plus their Design Your Own Engagement Ring tool allows you to pick your favorite setting or diamond, customizing a gorgeous ring that fits your personality.

If you’re not looking for an engagement or wedding ring, there are plenty of other delightful options to choose from. If you're looking for the perfect gift for a loved one, you can find stunning gemstone necklaces, bracelets, and earrings to buy as a present for someone you care about. Plus, you can feel good about your purchase knowing that you’re supporting a brand that cares about its ethical impact, and wants to lead a positive change in the jewelry business. 

Check out all of their beautiful pieces at brilliantearth.com.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.