Show full transcript 0:28 a different kind of sleep tracker 0:30 designed to help you understand your sleep 0:32 without adding another score to obsess over 0:34 or another goal to chase. 0:36 It's very low pressure, honey. 0:38 With contactless sleep tracking right from your nightstand, 0:41 there's nothing to wear or recharge. 0:42 I always get super stressed out 0:44 about things I have to recharge. 0:45 Hatch Sleep Clock provides personalized insights 0:48 and recommendations to help you discover 0:50 what works best for your personal sleep. 0:53 Plus with relaxing audio options like meditation, 0:56 sound baths and sleep music, 0:58 Hatch helps make winding down so much easier. 1:01 I am such a lover of my hatch. 1:03 I have the hatch alarm clock 1:05 and I have obviously the app that goes with it. 1:07 It turns off my phone at nine o'clock at night. 1:10 I can still use my phone if I want to, 1:12 but then sometimes I feel a little silly 1:13 like going past it 1:15 when I have a huge notification that says good night phone. 1:18 So that's one thing that I love. 1:20 And then the other thing I really love about hatch 1:22 is their meditations. 1:23 There are so many to choose from. 1:26 There's even like silly ones 1:27 that like don't make you like crack up laughing but like gives you a little chuckle while you're 1:31 relaxing. And I think they have kid ones too. I'm obsessed with Hatch and I really think you guys 1:36 will be too. Give the gift of better sleep with Hatch Sleep Clock. On sale this holiday season 1:41 on hatch.co and amazon.com. Terry Cottle died by suicide but his heart lived on transplanted 1:50 into Sunny Graham. Years later Sunny died the exact same way. Same heart, same fate. But 1:55 But that wasn't the strangest connection between them. 1:57 Sunny also married Terry's widow. 1:59 Hosted by Karen Kilgarov, this is Heart, 2:02 an Apple original podcast 2:03 produced by Plan B in Blanchard House. 2:06 New episodes are available Mondays 2:07 and Apple TV subscribers get special early access 2:10 to the entire season. 2:11 Follow and listen on Apple podcasts. 2:14 Every good detective needs a partner 2:16 to support them on important cases. 2:19 Think of a state farm agent like your sidekick 2:21 there to help you along the way 2:22 in your search for coverage. 2:24 state farm can help you choose the coverage you need whether it's for your 2:28 home car boat or even RV with so many options it's nice knowing you have help 2:34 finding what fits for you so you can get back to solving all of life's bigger 2:37 cases go to statefarm.com or use the award-winning app to connect with a 2:42 local agent and get a quote like a good neighbor state farm is there hey 2:46 Hey, weirdos, I'm Ash. 2:48 And I'm Alaina. 2:49 And this is Moabid. 3:05 This is Moabid. 3:06 And we're in November, folks. 3:08 We are in November. 3:09 Halloween happened, it was great. 3:11 Yeah, and here we are. 3:12 It really happened this time, 3:14 because last time it was November, 3:15 but Halloween hadn't happened yet. 3:17 Exactly. 3:18 I hope you guys all had a good Halloween, 3:19 like we really actually did. 3:21 Yeah, it was actually a nice Halloween. 3:22 And I hope today everybody went out and voted. 3:25 Yes. 3:27 And I know it'll be after that, 3:29 that this comes in. 3:30 We'll find out if you voted or not. 3:32 You know what, everybody, we did great. 3:34 Yeah. 3:35 Good job. 3:36 We did great. 3:37 I'm wearing blue to manifest. 3:39 We're manifesting, we're doing great. 3:41 And that's that. 3:42 Use your right to vote. 3:45 Why is that? 3:45 Do it. 3:46 Thank you. 3:48 And thank you for being here today. 3:50 Thank you. 3:50 And with that, we can probably just get right into it 3:52 because it's part two. 3:53 And I want to know what the fuck is up, Kyle. 3:54 Part two, and this is a kooky, kooky case. 3:57 Yeah, it's crazy and when we last left you a Dr. Linda Reynolds had started to be like 4:04 mm-hmm, huh? What's going on over there? I love a bad bitch stepping in and taking taking survey 4:09 He's taking survey. So she and hey you can clock it. We're starting the story. Oh 4:16 That's a quick one 4:18 So let's talk about Linda Reynolds. She moved to the area in late 1996 the year of ash 4:24 there you go, taking a position as one of the partners at Brooke's surgery, not far from where 4:30 Shipman was practicing. Prior to that, she'd spent 20 years treating patients in another 4:36 part of England. And that meant that while she might not have been familiar with the patients 4:40 in her new practice, she was very familiar with the patterns of declining health and death 4:45 among a population. And it wasn't long before she got the feeling that something wasn't 4:51 adding up here. Something is not right. Not wanting to cause any problems. So early on 4:57 at a new practice, she didn't voice her concerns right away, which is understandable. 5:02 Then near the end of 1997, she decided it was time. She was going to start sharing her thoughts 5:08 with the other partners. She Mariah carried it. She said, it's time. She did. Dr. Jeremy Dirks, 5:16 I think his name is, she told us that it became very apparent to her that there was 5:20 there's certainly more deaths than she would expect. 5:23 And Dr. Jeremy there was one of the partners 5:25 at Brooke's surgery at the time. 5:27 I don't trust a single man named Jeremy, 5:29 and it's your fault. 5:30 I love that. 5:31 I've ruined all Jeremy's. 5:32 You literally have. 5:33 That's my job. 5:34 Sorry, Jeremy. 5:35 Sorry, good Jeremy. 5:36 Sorry, good, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. 5:39 All that to say, sorry, sorry, sorry. 5:41 If you're out there. 5:43 Yeah, you did. 5:44 I don't know. 5:44 Have we seen him? 5:45 I don't know. 5:46 Well, Dr. Jeremy here said she wasn't particularly aware 5:49 at the time of the circumstances of each death, 5:52 but it was the numbers, 5:53 and that raised definite suspicions in her mind. 5:55 That makes sense. 5:56 Now, the other partners at the center listened to these concerns, 5:59 but they simply couldn't fathom 6:01 that Shipman was doing something 6:03 to actually cause the death of his patients. 6:06 Yeah. 6:06 Which why would you think that a doctor would do that? 6:09 Yeah, so our Dr. Jeremy there said, 6:12 Dr. Reynolds was quite sure 6:13 there was something more sinister to it. 6:15 The rest of us didn't dare think that. 6:18 Instead, they did their best to pet her concerns a little bit, trying to rationalize things, 6:26 coming up with reasonable explanations. 6:29 There's got to be some reason that the deaths are this high. 6:32 It can't be that he's doing something. 6:34 People love to try to pet a woman. 6:36 Yeah. 6:37 It's like pull the wool over your eyes. 6:39 It's okay, girl. 6:39 You're wrong. 6:40 Yeah, you're wrong on this. 6:41 Stop it. 6:42 But despite their resistance, Reynolds' fellow partners wanted to be supportive, though. 6:46 Okay. So they all agreed that it would be best to take their concerns to the coroner. 6:50 All right. Who would be most knowledgeable about this matter and would know what, if anything, 6:55 should or could be done. Okay. Not surprisingly, the coroner was shocked 6:59 by what Reynolds told him and agreed this was a very serious matter. 7:04 But he explained that the only way he could investigate the situation would be to report 7:08 it to police who would act on his behalf. That in itself seemed a little risky since 7:15 So it immediately alerted Shipman to their suspicions. 7:18 There was also a question of libel. 7:20 Yeah. 7:21 If Reynolds and the others made a, you know, 7:23 serious allegations and turned out to be wrong, 7:25 there could be serious personal 7:27 and professional consequences here. 7:29 Yeah. 7:29 Dr. Jeremy said, 7:31 Dr. Shipman was the most well-respected doctor in Hyde. 7:34 And calling into question 7:35 any colleague's practices and behavior is a major step. 7:38 It could have backfired. 7:39 That's tough. 7:40 They were up against a lot here. 7:42 But still the matter was serious enough 7:44 that they felt obligated to go forward with their complaint. 7:48 Wow, okay. 7:48 Yeah. 7:49 And so the Greater Manchester Police 7:50 opened up their investigation. 7:52 I did not expect this. 7:53 Badass. 7:54 Very. 7:54 They put it all on the line here. 7:57 Like in every sense of the phrase, yeah. 7:59 Years later, when the Crown launched an inquiry 8:01 into the systems that allowed shipmen. 8:03 I love the Crown. 8:05 The Crown. 8:05 Just like the Crown, like, I literally picture 8:07 a Crown launching an investigation. 8:10 A Crown being like time to investigate. 8:12 Do it. 8:12 Go forth. 8:12 Well, years later when the crowd did launch an inquiry into the systems that honestly 8:17 allowed shipment to avoid detecting for so long, an investigation committee would conclude 8:22 that the greater Manchester police had never taken the initial reports very seriously. 8:27 Oh, yeah. 8:29 Dr. Jeremy said, I believe it was generally held by the police that the concerns were 8:34 purely those expressed by Dr. Reynolds and not the rest of the practice. 8:38 That certainly wasn't the case. 8:39 Damn. 8:40 Now, the investigators assigned to look into the matter never bothered to interview the 8:44 other doctors at Brooke's surgery. 8:46 In fact, it seems that they had more of an investigative interest in Dr. Reynolds than 8:52 they did in Dr. Shipman. 8:53 Of course. 8:54 Among other things, they questioned her about why she'd left her previous practice, implying 8:58 that she had been resentful of a male doctor in a more senior position and that 9:03 she must have left due to repeated conflicts with him. 9:07 You ever just want to punch a punch ahead? 9:09 And Dr. Jeremy said they were almost hinting that she had a similar problem with Dr. Shipman. 9:14 Fuck off with that. These people off with that. 9:18 Exactly. So sexist investigators weren't only the problem here. They were not the only problem. 9:25 Okay. There was also the fact that they never bothered to collect all the documentation on 9:28 recent deaths and the fact that in a small town like Hyde, many of the investigators 9:33 new and revered Fred Shipman, uh-huh. 9:37 Anne Alexander, who was a solicitor for one of the families, 9:40 said the most significant thing for me 9:42 was that I had always believed it was a policeman's job 9:45 to ask questions. 9:46 And in this particular case, 9:48 the lead investigators didn't ask questions. 9:50 He sat and waited for information to be given to him. 9:53 That's not how investigating works. 9:54 He sat on his ass. 9:55 Yeah, that's the laziest shit I've ever heard. 9:57 After just a few weeks, 9:59 the cursory investigation came to nothing 10:00 and was just quickly closed without any determination. 10:03 Of course it came to nothing because they did nothing. 10:05 They didn't investigate. 10:07 The local police might not have taken Dr. Reynolds' concerns seriously, 10:10 but as it turned out, the doctors at brick surgery weren't the only ones 10:14 who had started to become suspicious of friendship. 10:16 It was like too bad nobody talked to them. 10:18 Exactly. 10:19 After retiring from the police force in 1988, John Shaw opened up K-Cabs, 10:25 a one-man cab company that consisted of Shaw and his blue Volvo. 10:29 I'm obsessed with the fact that he was like retiring, not for me. 10:32 No, I'm just going to drive a cab, drive a cab, just one cab. 10:35 It's my cab. 10:36 Almost immediately Shaw saw a gap in the local market and he seized on it. 10:40 Two great success. 10:41 Very smart. 10:42 And he said, I found that there was a niche in the market of elderly people who wanted 10:46 just short journeys and who wanted to be able to afford to do it in a taxi. 10:50 Nice. 10:51 So he framed the situation as purely opportunistic, but whether because of his personality 10:57 or the fact that he was a retired police officer, 10:59 elderly clients were immediately at ease with him. 11:02 And he quickly gained a very good reputation 11:05 and a very large clientele. 11:08 He's like, oh, it was just because people needed it. 11:10 And it's like, no, you were a really good at that. 11:12 He said, all my customers, I classed as friends. 11:15 I love him. 11:16 That's really sweet. 11:17 Before long, John Shaw became more than just a cab driver 11:20 for the elderly. 11:21 He would help them inside, listen to them 11:23 when others wouldn't, 11:24 and even fix little problems around their houses 11:26 whenever he could. He's a straight-up caretaker. Like a saint. This motherfucker is an empath. 11:30 As a result, he became very familiar with their lives, and as their driver, he knew their patterns 11:36 and routines. It was because of these things that Shaw began to notice when customers of his 11:41 began dying in surprising numbers. He said, I noticed that various ladies were dying suddenly, 11:47 ladies that I'd seen possibly days before their death when they seemed in good health. 11:53 Now, after years of losing clients one after the other, Shah grew suspicious that something 11:59 was going on here. 12:00 He's also a police officer. 12:01 Yeah, he's got that nose. 12:03 When Joan Harding died suddenly in January 1994, he decided to start keeping a list of 12:08 the deaths. 12:10 He said, because again, he's organized, he's a police officer. 12:13 The thing that made me suspicious, he said, was my customers had all been in good 12:16 health prior to their deaths. 12:18 So by 1998 he comprised a list of 20 names of elderly customers who died 12:23 unexpectedly. Wow. Because he'd been driving for men, you know, driving the 12:27 same people for many years including to their appointments. When he looked over 12:31 the list he noticed that they all shared one thing in common. They had the same 12:36 doctor. Dr. Fred Shipman. And that was likely the last place he ever drove them. 12:41 Yep. Wow. John Shaw suspected that the city's most well respected doctor 12:46 might be hiding a very dark, very nefarious secret. 12:50 But the problem was, no matter how confident he was, 12:54 he realized the theory was quote unquote fantastic. 12:57 And even coming from a former police officer, 12:59 they were still unlikely to be believed. 13:02 He said they were so fantastic, 13:04 I couldn't grasp what my mind was telling me. 13:06 I was equally frightened of being right 13:08 as I was of being wrong. 13:09 Yeah, I can see that, absolutely. 13:11 Like Linda Reynolds before him, 13:13 John Shaw was conflicted about what he should do. 13:16 Then came the death of Kathleen Grundy. 13:19 By all accounts, Kathleen was a lively 13:21 and relatively healthy woman in the spring of 1998. 13:25 Shaw said she was a 25-year-old and an 80-year-old body, 13:29 despite her age as the former mayor of Hyde. 13:32 Wow. 13:33 Grundy kept a fairly full social calendar. 13:36 Period. 13:36 And regularly went out on Saturday nights. 13:39 Obsessed. 13:40 When the evening events had come to an end, 13:42 Grundy would always call John Shaw for a ride home and when he drop her off, Kathleen would 13:46 always flash the light on the front porch to let him know she'd gotten in the house safely. 13:50 That is the sweetest. Right? Yeah. 13:52 Given how spry and just full of life and independent Kathleen had been, 13:58 it came to a big shock to everyone when in June 1998, Kathleen died unexpectedly. 14:04 Her daughter Angela said, I was very shocked because I had spoken to her a few days 14:08 before on the phone, and she was always very well. So Angela called Dr. Shipman to find out what the 14:14 fuck had happened to her mom, but he was vague, saying he hadn't seen her the day before she died 14:19 and mentioned something about, or excuse me, saying he'd seen her the day before she died 14:24 and had mentioned something about chest pains. It was only later that Angela learned from her 14:29 mother's friend that Shipman had actually called on Grundy because he wanted her to sign 14:33 in some papers. 14:35 Interesting. 14:36 So he was now, like it sounds like he was now like 14:39 bringing them, bringing the lambs to the slaughter. 14:42 Essentially he was bringing them in. 14:44 It's not like they were coming in for an appointment. 14:46 Right. 14:47 He was actually like reaching out to get them. 14:49 And like choosing who he was going to do this to 14:51 ahead of time. 14:52 Now in the days that followed, 14:53 the story from Shipman became even more opaque. 14:56 He said she died of cardiac arrest, 14:59 but she had no history of heart disease. 15:01 Okay. 15:02 Even more concerning was the fact that on Grundy's death certificate, the registrar's 15:07 office had listed the cause of death as simply old age. 15:11 A decision they'd arrived at with significant input from Shipman. 15:16 Angela recalled later, it was all very strange. 15:19 I couldn't understand how she died. 15:21 It just didn't make any sense to me. 15:22 Right. 15:23 Like, which one is it? 15:24 Yeah, old age or heart attack. 15:25 Yeah. 15:26 Those are two very different things. 15:27 A few days after her mother's death, 15:29 Angela and her husband arrived at her mother's house 15:31 to start dealing with her affairs. 15:33 And what they found there made even less sense. 15:36 Looking around the house, 15:38 there was no signs that a chronically ill person 15:40 resided there. 15:41 The garden was perfectly tended to, 15:43 something Kathleen always did herself. 15:46 The lawn was perfectly mowed and there was no medications. 15:50 She was on no medications. 15:51 No medications. 15:52 Angela pushed her suspicions aside. 15:55 She's going through grief. 15:56 Of course. 15:57 But, and she said about making plans for the funeral, but a few weeks later, things got 16:02 even more confusing. 16:04 One afternoon, Angela was at home when she got a call from a solicitor and hide that she 16:09 didn't know. 16:10 Okay. 16:10 The man said that he didn't know her mother, but he had been tasked with executing her 16:14 mother's will, which she had filed on June 9th, 1998, just a few days before she 16:19 died. 16:20 Okay. 16:20 It had arrived at their office with a typewritten letter asking that they be her executors, 16:25 and it was simply signed Kay Grundy. Weird. When Angelo was finally able to 16:31 review this will in the accompanying letter a few days later, she knew 16:35 immediately this was not written by her mother. Really? This episode is brought to 16:49 you by Rover. Let's talk about our pets, honey. You guys know all about the cats, 16:54 but I feel like I don't talk about Dolo too too much. Dolo is a particular 16:58 girly, honey. Let me tell you, she's got her spot on the couch that she 17:02 sleeps on, she literally will only sleep on a certain kind of blanket because she's bougie 17:06 like her mother and she has certain toys that she will only play with and like screw 17:11 the rest of them to be honest. 17:13 Every pet has their quirks and comfort rituals from a favorite squeak toy to that one bush 17:18 that absolutely must be sniffed on every walk. 17:21 We have particular babies, don't we? 17:23 And when you're at work or traveling, finding care that feels right for your pet's unique 17:27 needs matters. 17:29 Rover is a community of independent pet sitters and dog walkers who can provide personalized 17:34 care while you're away. 17:36 On Rover, you can browse sitter profiles and choose one who understands your pet's particular 17:40 brand of adorable weirdness they all have their own. 17:43 You can also read verified reviews from other pet parents before you make your choice 17:47 and opt to receive photo updates of your furry friend while you're away because 17:52 when it comes to your pet, the little things are kind of a big deal, right? 17:55 Download the Rover app and get started. 17:58 And exclusively for new users of Rover, 18:00 use code MorbidPodcast for a $20 discount 18:03 off your first booking, valid only on eligible bookings. 18:07 That's code MorbidPodcast. 18:08 Offer expires January 24th, 2027, Terms Apply. 18:13 This is a paid ad by BetterHelp. 18:16 You know those super awkward moments 18:17 that you just wake up in the middle 18:18 of the night thinking about? 18:20 Like for example, when I used to be a server, 18:21 sometimes I would just walk up to a table 18:23 and jumble my words so badly that I'd essentially say, 18:26 hi saboo-du-bah! 18:28 And I wake up in the middle of the night 18:29 and I think about that all the time. 18:30 I wish I could delete that from my brain. 18:33 But the good news is, 18:34 by connecting you to a qualified therapist online, 18:36 better help can help you find 18:38 an experienced professional to talk through the thoughts 18:40 that are taking up way too much mental real estate. 18:44 With thousands of therapists 18:45 and millions of members across more than 100 countries, 18:48 it's helped many people make meaningful progress 18:50 toward feeling better. 18:51 After you take a short questionnaire 18:52 that helps identify your needs and your preferences, BetterHelp does all the initial matching work 18:57 for you, and typically gets it right the first time. And if you're not happy with your match, 19:01 you can switch to a different therapist at any time from their tailored recommendations. 19:05 Plus, BetterHelp makes it easy to fit therapy into your routine with flexible ways to connect. 19:10 As we head toward the end of the year, it can be a good time to make some space for yourself. 19:14 Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com slash morbid. That's betterhelp-h-e-l-p.com 19:20 Every good detective needs a partner to support them on important cases. 19:24 Think of a state farm agent like your sidekick, there to help you along the way in your search 19:29 for coverage. 19:30 State Farm can help you choose the coverage you need, whether it's for your home, car, 19:35 boat, or even RV. 19:36 With so many options, it's nice knowing you have help finding what fits for you, 19:41 so you can get back to solving all of life's bigger cases. 19:44 Go to statefarm.com or use the award-winning app to connect with a local agent and get a quote. 19:50 Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. 19:56 Kathleen Grundy had been known, among other things, for having beautiful handwriting. 20:01 She's also the mayor, so there had been. 20:03 Yeah. 20:03 Right? 20:04 Her signature was probably gorge. 20:05 And not only that, there's probably so many accounts of her handwriting. 20:09 Yeah. 20:09 Like, and this letter was typewritten and quite badly at that. 20:13 Something Angela knew her mother never would have done. 20:16 Yeah. 20:16 Yeah. 20:16 Even more surprising was the fact that in her final days, Angela's mother had changed 20:21 her will and was now leaving everything to her doctor, Fred Shipman. 20:28 In what world? 20:31 That is an incredibly bold thing to do. 20:35 Also, like, are you completely dumb at this point? 20:39 That's like, wow. 20:40 You lost your mind to that level that you thought you were going to get away with 20:44 that. 20:44 that she has a daughter, she has friends, she has family, 20:48 and she's gonna leave everything to her doctor? 20:51 And you already know people are suspicious of you, babe. 20:53 Yeah, I'm like, are you serious? 20:56 Yeah, that's not walking a fine line. 20:58 That's stomping around town in your big boots, brother. 21:01 Exactly. 21:02 Now, among the things that allowed him 21:05 to go on killing undetected for so long 21:07 was the fact that he would sign, 21:08 he would often sign off on cremation of his victims 21:11 before anyone in the family could say otherwise. 21:14 This time, however, 21:16 Grundy's daughter, Angela, had arranged for a burial. 21:19 Good. 21:19 After all the odd interactions with Shipman, 21:22 and especially this discovery of a new will 21:24 naming Shipman as the sole fucking heir, 21:27 Angela had started to wonder whether her mother's doctor 21:29 might actually be responsible for her death. 21:32 I'm also like, dude, did you not realize she had a daughter? 21:34 Yeah. 21:35 And like, that was gonna look sus. 21:36 I have no idea, but it's hubris. 21:39 It's just they think they're above everything. 21:41 One, he's been getting away with it for so long. 21:43 Well, so she did something really bold. 21:47 She asked that her mother's body be exhumed 21:50 and subjected to a postmortem examination. 21:53 Okay. 21:53 She said, let's go. 21:55 And you have to point out to like the heartache 21:59 that would come along with already having buried 22:01 your parent to dig them up and then have them go 22:05 through an autopsy when you don't necessarily 22:08 what you want to. 22:09 That is so traumatic to have to even do that. 22:13 I'm like, ugh. 22:13 Yeah. 22:14 For more than a decade, 22:15 Fred Shipman had managed to avoid questions 22:17 from suspicious family members 22:19 by just feigning outrage at their disbelief 22:21 and shaming them for how could you not trust my expertise. 22:26 By exploiting some of the most difficult 22:28 human emotions to navigate, 22:29 he was easily able to manipulate anyone 22:32 who questioned his authority 22:33 and make them feel like the guilty ones, 22:35 like bad people. 22:36 One of the keys to his survival as a serial killer was the fact that his victims' families 22:42 knew next to nothing about medicine and lacked the confidence necessary to really, like, confront 22:47 someone with any serious accusations when you don't have the knowledge and the background 22:53 in something especially medicine is so complex and it's like, you do feel stupid sometimes 23:00 like questioning a doctor. 23:03 We've been in positions where we've questioned doctors before. 23:06 For sure. 23:06 And you end up feeling silly sometimes. 23:09 Yeah, because sometimes if you get a good doctor, 23:13 which a lot of doctors are great, 23:15 they're going to be like, you know what? 23:16 I understand that you want to know more about this 23:18 or that you're confused by this. 23:19 Sometimes they'll just write you off. 23:21 But sometimes they can be like real shitty sometimes. 23:24 So if you get the wrong one that's like, 23:27 you idiot, like how dare you. 23:29 Yeah. 23:29 Yeah. 23:29 Yeah. 23:31 But Angela was a highly respected professional in her own right and a lawyer at that. 23:37 And she wasn't easily intimidated by the likes of little Fred Shipman. 23:42 He done fucked up this time. 23:44 You fucked with the wrong way. 23:45 I'm like, you didn't do your research, babe, which thank goodness. 23:49 Also Angela's confidence made John Shaw feel like he might not be alone after all in thinking 23:54 this. 23:54 Yeah. 23:54 And in August, Shaw went to the police to add his concerns 23:58 to the growing cloud of suspicion. 24:00 And good for him too to put his neck out there. 24:02 Because he said, well, you know what? 24:04 Angela's out here going through grief and sticking her neck out. 24:07 She's a professional. 24:09 She could lose stuff doing this. 24:10 Yeah. 24:11 I'm going to do it too. 24:12 Yeah. 24:13 And he cared about, you know, he cared about Kathleen. 24:16 Now, Fred Shipman had already avoided capture once 24:19 when the investigation prompted by Reynolds 24:22 and the other doctors at Brooke's surgery didn't even start, essentially, and it seemed 24:26 likely that had he not changed his routine, he probably would have kept going on killing 24:33 for a long time. 24:34 But for reasons that are pretty unclear still, when he came to the murder of Kathleen Grundy 24:40 in the summer of 1998, he did something he'd never done before. 24:44 He tried to profit from the crime. 24:46 Yeah. 24:47 When the coroner examined Kathleen's body after she was exhumed, he found a large quantity 24:53 of morphine in her muscle tissues. 24:55 And for years, Shippman had been altering his patient's medical records to support whatever 25:00 cause of death he put on the certificate, but this time he made a mistake. 25:06 He altered Kathleen's medical records to indicate that, quote, she was overdosing 25:11 on codeine, which might have made sense if the coroner had found codeine in her body. 25:18 Instead, they found morphine. 25:21 The morphine discovered in the body of a woman who is not known to use or need morphine 25:27 only added to the suspicion that he had killed Kathleen. 25:31 Not only morphine, but any other. 25:32 She didn't have any other medicines. 25:34 And it's also, it's adding to the suspicion that he not only killed Kathleen, 25:38 but killed her to inherit the money left to him. 25:40 in this questionable-ass will. 25:42 Your motive is right there. 25:44 A few weeks later, investigators obtained a search warrant 25:46 for Shipman's house. 25:48 Stop it. 25:48 Where they found, among other things, 25:50 a large supply of morphine, the typewriter 25:54 that matched the letter that accompanied the will 25:57 when it was sent to the solicitor's office. 25:58 Dude. 25:59 They also found evidence that Shipman had forged 26:01 Grundy's signature on a number of documents, 26:04 and his fingerprint was found on the letter 26:07 and the will that was sent to the lawyers. 26:09 Shut the fuck up. 26:12 On September 7th, 1998, Fred Shipman 26:15 was arrested and charged with murdering Kathleen Grundy. 26:18 And a few days later, a second charge was added 26:21 for his attempts to forge her will. 26:23 Good, finally. 26:24 Yeah. 26:25 Now, the evidence against Fred Shipman and the death 26:27 and attempted defrauding of Kathleen Grundy 26:30 was like pretty immense. 26:31 It was pretty considerable. 26:32 Yeah, I'd say so. 26:33 But after hearing what John Shaw had to say, 26:35 investigators began to wonder whether 26:38 there might be some more names. 26:40 Did investigators begin to investigate? 26:42 They actually were like, 26:43 hmm, maybe there could be more to this. 26:46 And it's like, yeah. 26:46 Maybe we should have done something back then. 26:48 Maybe to give it a shot, I don't know. 26:50 But when the news of the arrest broke, 26:52 investigators were quick to caution the press 26:54 and the public against reading too much 26:56 into their actions, necessarily in the investigation. 26:59 Detective Superintendent Bernard Postal said, 27:02 I can confirm an investigation is being undertaken 27:04 into the circumstances surrounding Mrs. Grundy's death. 27:08 I would like to stress that people should not panic 27:11 about our investigation. 27:12 Okay, Bernard. 27:13 Which like, I guess that makes sense 27:15 because it's like this is a prominent doctor. 27:18 So it's like, everyone chill. 27:20 Now, while investigators made a point of staying tight lipped 27:23 about the case with the press, 27:24 behind the scenes, the evidence against Shipman 27:26 was piling up. 27:28 Following the exhumation of Kathleen, 27:31 court orders for additional exhumations 27:33 were being made for patients who died under Shipman's care. 27:36 Okay. 27:37 Each one revealing new evidence of foul play. 27:39 Which again, horrific for the family members. 27:43 Oh my God, it's awful. 27:44 In early October, three additional murder charges were added 27:48 following the exhumation of 73-year-old Joan Malia, 27:51 73-year-old Winifred Miller, 27:54 and 49-year-old Bianca Palmfreet. 27:58 49. 27:59 Following the arraignment, Bernard Postles 28:01 gave a statement to the press indicating that the Greater Manchester Police expected the 28:06 lengthy inquiry with many difficult areas of investigation. Although the investigation appeared 28:13 to be moving along, it was like relatively slow because of the sensitive nature of the 28:19 accusations and the general difficulty of dealing with such a large number of victims here. 28:25 This was all made exponentially more difficult by the media who had seized on the story. 28:30 That's crazy. 28:31 With the less reputable outlets harassing family members 28:34 for comment or additional information. 28:36 Go away. 28:37 That's so gross. 28:38 It's really fucked up. 28:39 In the days and weeks that followed, 28:41 investigators worked tirelessly 28:43 to track down patients and family members, 28:46 but Shipman had altered or destroyed so many records 28:49 that it made it so difficult. 28:51 Yeah. 28:51 When they would come across a patient 28:53 who was determined to have died 28:54 under maybe suspicious circumstances, 28:57 the remains would need to be exhumed, 28:58 which was a process they chose to do under cover of night 29:01 to avoid curious members of the press and public. 29:04 Yeah. Although they were a necessary part of the investigation, 29:07 the seriousness of the exhumations was not lost on any of the detectives 29:11 or the forensic technicians. 29:13 Father Dennis Maher told reporters, there's a finality to a burial. 29:18 You are saying goodbye and there is a healing in that. 29:21 Now we have to go back and do that. 29:23 It's terribly upsetting. 29:24 It is. And it is like there really is like a finality 29:26 and closing that coffin lid and saying goodbye. 29:30 There's like a ritual that comes along with death, 29:33 and that's part of it. 29:34 Yeah. 29:34 Now, given how many patients Shipman served 29:37 since opening his practice in the early 90s, 29:39 it seemed entirely possible to detectives 29:42 that they were looking at one of the worst cases 29:44 of serial murder in England's history. 29:46 Wow. 29:47 Yet no one on the case dared even to guess 29:49 a potential number of victims. 29:51 Wow, can you even at that point? 29:52 Yeah. 29:53 Instead, they continued digging through the evidence, 29:55 which included years worth of complex medical records and more than 3,000 prescriptions for morphine. 30:03 Wow! By mid-November, their work was continuing to show results. On November 13, 30:09 two more murders were added to the charges. After the bodies of 63-year-old Ivy Lomas 30:16 and 67-year-old Marie Quinn were found to contain large amounts of morphine. 30:20 By that time, Shipman had been denied bail 30:23 and a tentative trial date for the Grundy murder 30:25 had been set for January, 1999. 30:29 But there were more discoveries that were gonna come. 30:32 In January, Shipman's trial date came and went 30:35 with the prosecutor's office asking for additional time 30:38 to complete the investigation. 30:39 Because again, new information was surfacing rapidly. 30:44 A judge granted the request and in late February 30:46 an additional eight murder charges 30:48 were added to the following victims, Muriel Grimshaw, age 76, Nora Nuddle, age 65, Laura 30:56 Wagstaff, age 81, Maureen Alice Ward, age 57, Pamela Hillier, age 68, Marie West, age 81, 31:06 and Lizzie Adams, age 77. When asked whether they expected to find additional victims or 31:12 would continue digging into his patient files, Detective Superintendent Postal said, 31:17 said, we will not enter into speculation about whether there will be any further charges 31:21 or whether we have drawn a line under the inquiry now. Whether or not there would be 31:25 additional charges or victims, the prosecution was expected to go to trial against Shipman 31:30 for 15 murders. That was just what they, like, definitively 31:35 connected. So his trial began October 5th, 1999 at Preston Crown Court, where he repeatedly 31:42 and strenuously denied killing any of his patients. 31:46 And he definitely didn't forge Kathleen Grundy's will. 31:49 She just did that. 31:50 Why is your fingerprint on it? 31:52 No idea. 31:53 Now, jury selection took more than a week. 31:55 And once they were finally sworn in, 31:57 members of the jury were warned 31:58 that due to the size and scope, 32:00 the case could potentially last as long as five months. 32:02 Wow. 32:03 In fact, opening statements from the prosecutor, 32:05 Richard Henriquez lasted three days 32:09 as he laid out the evidence in all 15 murders. 32:13 He said, all of them died most unexpectedly. 32:15 All of them had seen Dr. Shipman on the day of their death. 32:18 There is no question of euthanasia. 32:20 The defendant killed these 15 patients 32:22 because he enjoyed doing so. 32:24 He was exercising the ultimate power 32:26 of controlling life and death 32:28 and repeated the act so often, 32:30 he must have found the drama of taking life to his taste. 32:34 That's an open statement. 32:36 Yeah, for real. 32:36 Among other things, he walked through the evidence showing how Shipman had forged his 32:40 medical records to align with whatever circumstances of death he decided, and explained that they 32:46 would hear testimony from family members who were convinced or bullied into foregoing 32:50 postmortem examinations. 32:53 He said, of course, from Dr. Shipman's perspective, it was imperative in each case 32:57 that he avoid a postmortem. 32:59 In other cases, he used his position of power and authority to manipulate others. 33:03 When paramedics arrived at the home of 68-year-old Pamela Hillier, 33:07 they suggested someone needed to report the death to the police, 33:10 but Shipman told them, I don't see there's a need to do that. 33:14 Why? 33:15 Now, the evidence against him was persuasive, 33:17 but his case was made all the more compelling by the testimony 33:21 from the victim's friends and family regarding his callousness after the deaths. 33:27 In the case of Marie Westmurder, 33:29 Shipman wasn't aware that as he was killing Murray, 33:32 his, her friend, Mary and Hadfield 33:34 was waiting for her in the next room. 33:37 What? 33:39 Mm-hmm. 33:40 According to Hadfield, when Shipman realized she was there, 33:43 he said, she's collapsed on me. 33:45 She's gone. 33:46 What the fuck? 33:48 Mm-hmm. 33:48 One room away. 33:50 Yeah. 33:50 And he didn't even realize it. 33:51 And then he just didn't give a shit. 33:52 Had the gall to just be like, yep, is what it is by. 33:55 Yeah, whoops. 33:55 When Hadfield expressed her shock and disbelief, 33:59 Shipman grabbed West's head and opened her eyes. 34:02 And he said, see, there's no life in there. 34:04 Oh my God. 34:06 Then he let the woman's head fall back against her shoulder. 34:09 Oh my God. 34:10 Literally opened her eyes. 34:10 See, there's no life in there to her friend. 34:13 That is so fucked up. 34:14 Callus is fucked. 34:15 Imagine how traumatizing that must have been 34:17 for her friend. 34:18 In each instance, Henriquez walked the jury 34:21 through what he called Shipman's quote, 34:22 far-fetched explanations for the deaths and the circumstances surrounding his 34:27 presence. In the case of 67-year-old Marie Quinn, for example, Shipman claimed that 34:32 she had called him at his office to say she thought she was having a stroke. 34:36 Shipman claimed he told her to leave the door unlocked and he would be over 34:39 immediately, but when he arrived she was quote, breathing her last. But 34:43 investigators checked the phone records on both ends and wouldn't you 34:47 know, no such call took place. 34:49 Dude, how are you like, how do you think you're going to get away with that? 34:54 And like, nobody's going to check into it. 34:56 That's what I don't get. 34:57 And the details provided by Shipman seemed entirely unlikely, if not impossible. 35:02 He said it is so he, the prosecutor said it is inconceivable 35:07 that Mrs. Quinn partially paralyzed, went from her living room to open 35:11 the door, then went to the kitchen where Shipman found her. 35:14 Like, let's be real. 35:15 If you've been thinking about securing your home with SimplySafe, now is the time. 35:29 Right now, you can save 70% on a new system, their biggest savings of the year. 35:34 Unlike traditional security systems that only alert you after a break-in is already underway, 35:39 SimplySafe is built to stop that break-in before it even starts. 35:42 Smart AI-powered cameras watch for potential threats and alert a live US-based agent 35:47 ready to intervene. 35:49 The agent intervenes in under 30 seconds, speaking through the camera to stop an intruder 35:53 in their tracks and even calling for urgent 911 dispatch when it's needed the 35:58 most. I've been a SimplySafe user for years. I love arming my system at night 36:03 knowing that I am protecting everybody in my house. You know we got Dru Dru, we 36:07 got the pets, the dog, the cats, all of them. The thing that made us want to get 36:11 SimplySafe by the way was we got this like weird knock on the door at like 36:14 3 a.m. in the middle of a blizzard. It was super creepy. I was like oh great 36:18 this is a horror movie and this is how it all ends. Knowing that I 36:21 I'd never have to deal with that 36:22 and have that sinking feeling again 36:24 in that I can just open a camera and see what's going on 36:27 or that these SimplySafe agents are always checking in for me. 36:31 It just gives me so much peace of mind. 36:33 SimplySafe is offering their biggest savings of the year, 36:36 70% off your new system with professional monitoring 36:39 when you visit simplysafe.com slash morbid. 36:42 That's simplysafe.com slash morbid. 36:44 And when you order, write in morbid at checkout. 36:46 It tells them that we sent you 36:48 and it really helps the show. 36:49 So, simply safe, ahead of crime in real-time. 36:54 Somewhere in a run, things get fun. 36:57 You stop counting, you stop trying, you're just here, weightless, wide open, more alive 37:02 than you've been all day. 37:03 That's the run doing what it does, clearing the noise, loosening the grip the day had 37:07 on you, reminding you what your body is capable of when you finally let it go there. 37:13 And now that feeling fits wherever you need it to. 37:15 you. 37:16 The new Peloton Treadflex is designed to fit your life, moveable and foldable so you can 37:21 run, walk or hike when you need to and roll it away when you don't. 37:25 With instructors worth showing up for and workouts that meet you where you are, you've 37:30 got the freedom to move on your own terms. 37:32 That's what running gives you back. 37:34 Let yourself run. 37:35 Explore Treadflex at OnePeloton.com 37:38 From leaky faucets to faulty ovens, home breakdowns are inevitable and repair 37:44 bills add up fast. 37:45 That's why an American HomeShield warranty is a homeowner's sanity saver. 37:50 AHS can repair or maven replace covered parts of home systems and appliances no matter how old. 37:56 And as a benefit with select plans, you can video chat with a repair expert in real time. 38:01 American HomeShield, don't worry, be warranty. 38:04 Get 20% off any plan at aahs.com slash morbid and see promo details. 38:08 See aahs.com slash contracts for coverage details including service fees, limitations, and exclusions. 38:14 The stories about the lives and deaths of Shipman's patients and his behavior before 38:23 and after their deaths were a large part of the Crown's case, but they had the evidence 38:28 to back their theories up. 38:30 In mid-November, Detective Constable Dave O'Brien told the jury that during the search 38:36 of Shipman's home, they discovered a massive, like a ton of morphine and diamorphine stored 38:42 in a bedroom. 38:43 When they ran the numbers of each vial, investigators discovered that the drugs 38:47 had been recorded by Shipman as having been destroyed, 38:51 as far back as 1995. 38:54 Dude. Yeah. 38:56 Meanwhile, you just have a legit stockpile in your home. 38:59 Yeah. Like. 39:01 Now the defense put forth by Shipman's lawyer, 39:04 Ian Winter, was very simple. 39:05 There was no murder. 39:06 The women had heart disease or other illnesses 39:08 and that led to their deaths. 39:10 But they didn't, babe. 39:11 That's like the worst defense I've ever heard. 39:13 Yeah. 39:13 Winter said, Bianca Palmfreet and Winifred Miller 39:17 complained to him of chest pains on the day they died. 39:20 Joan Malia complained of a severe cough 39:22 on the day she died. 39:23 And as for backdating and altering the records, 39:26 Shipman told the court he did that because, quote, 39:28 it helped him to research effective treatments. 39:31 I don't, you can't just change your records. 39:36 Don't worry about it. 39:36 You can maybe update them with new information, 39:40 but you're acting like that was information 39:42 that previously existed. 39:44 Well, and he's also using that whole, like, 39:45 don't question me. 39:46 I'm a doctor. 39:47 Yeah. 39:47 Okay. 39:48 In early December, when he took the stand in his own defense, 39:51 how did I know you were gonna say that? 39:54 Shipman had weak or somewhat, 39:56 somewhat implausible explanations 39:58 for pretty much everything that made him look guilty. 40:02 And Richard Henriques had no trouble poking holes in his story. 40:06 But he just thinks he's so much smarter than everybody else. 40:08 He thinks he's got it. 40:09 On several occasions, Shipman was interviewed by police 40:12 and gave his account of the treatments and his proximity to the patients at or around the time of 40:17 death. But as Henrique has pointed out repeatedly, when Shipman was testifying in court, his story 40:23 didn't match his early interviews. Yeah, Shipman claimed I was considerably stressed at the time 40:28 of the police interviews. I agree the version taken down in the police station was different 40:32 in what I said today. So did you lie because you were stressed out? Well, once again, he always 40:37 always has an answer for why it is the way it is. 40:41 The arguments from both sides finally came to an end in late January 2000. 40:46 And that's when Justice Forbes began his summation of the case of the jury. 40:50 He said, this is a tragic and deeply disturbing case. 40:53 You will have heard evidence which may have aroused feelings of anger, strong disapproval, 40:58 disgust, profound dismay, or deep sympathy. 41:01 You must put all those such feelings or emotions to one side and not allow it 41:05 to influence your judgment. 41:06 You must decide this case only on the evidence 41:08 you have heard, seen, and read in court. 41:11 And with his summation and guidance imparted to the jury, 41:15 they were dismissed for deliberation. 41:16 Okay. 41:17 They deliberated for 34 hours before merging 41:20 to find Shipman guilty on all 15 murders. 41:23 Wow. 41:23 And the forgery of Kathleen Grundy's will. 41:26 Good. 41:26 As the foreman read through each verdict, 41:28 Shipman stared straight ahead. 41:30 He had no emotional response. 41:32 I've inside of his head must have just been, 41:37 like, how do I get out of this, how did I get myself into the like, you know, cause he just he thought he was gonna, oh yeah, pull the 41:45 wool over everybody's eyes forever. 41:46 Oh yeah. 41:47 Justice Forbes said, each of your victims was your patient and you killed each and every one of your victims by calculated and cold blooded perversion of your medical skills. 41:57 Yours was not a healing touch. 41:58 None of them knew that it brought them death, which was disguised as the caring attention of a good doctor. 42:04 With that said, he sentenced Fred Shipman to 15 life sentences 42:08 and announced he would be recommending a whole life tariff, 42:12 meaning that Shipman would spend the rest of his natural life in prison never to be released. 42:16 Bye-bye. 42:17 As soon as the case ended, the speculation about just how many victims Shipman had killed began. 42:23 Of course. 42:24 In addition to the 15 victims for which he had been clearly found guilty of in sentence, 42:29 the prosecution had prepared files on 23 other victims. 42:32 Wow. 42:33 Whose cases weren't seen as strong enough to bring to trial. 42:36 That's always so frustrating. 42:38 On top of that, sources within the Greater Manchester Police Forest told reporters, detectives 42:42 had looked into 141 other deaths. 42:46 Holy shit. 42:47 By the time the investigation and inquiry concluded, Fred Shipman would be suspected 42:51 of killing more than 250 people. 42:54 That is insane. 42:56 Making him England's most prolific serial killer. 42:59 Yeah. 42:59 which shocked the press in the public 43:01 more than the number of victims 43:03 was the fact that the murders had happened at all 43:05 and that Shemin had gone on killing out in the open 43:08 for so fucking long. 43:09 And that he was a doctor. 43:12 Imagine, like people are already afraid of dentists 43:14 and doctors in general. 43:15 Just imagine the fear that must have ignited 43:18 in everybody after this. 43:20 And especially as like an elderly person, 43:22 like, yeah, you have to go to the doctor. 43:24 You're supposed to trust that your doctor 43:27 is gonna do the best for you. 43:28 You're so, like, and people take advantage of them so easily. 43:31 It's so sad. Yeah. 43:33 Now, just days after the trial ended, 43:35 the police began reporting that Shipman had, in fact, 43:37 been under investigation 18 months earlier 43:40 when Dr. Reynolds reported her fucking suspicion 43:43 to the coroner, but nothing had been done. 43:45 Yikes. 43:46 You know Linda's sitting there like, told ya.
Community discussion