0:01 You're listening to the Mind Over Murder podcast. 0:06 My name is Bill Thomas. I'm a writer, consulting producer, and now podcaster. I am now trying to use my experience as the brother of a murder victim to help other victims of violent crime. I'm working on a book 0:18 on the unsolved Colonial Parkway murders, and I'm the co-administrator of the Colonial Parkway Murders Facebook group, together with Kristen Dilley. 0:26 My name is Kristen Dilley. 0:27 I'm a writer, a researcher, a teacher, and a victim's advocate, as well as the social media manager and co-administrator for the Colonial Parkway Murders Facebook page with my partner in crime, Bill Thomas. 0:40 Welcome to Mind Over Murder. I'm Kristen Dilley. 0:43 And I'm Bill Thomas. 0:45 We're joined today. 0:45 By Jonathan Rocks and Beth McNamara, hosts of the Missing Candy Heiress podcast. 0:52 John and Beth. 0:53 Thank you so much for joining us today. 0:54 We're so excited to have you here. 0:55 Thanks for having us. 0:57 Thank you for having us. Appreciate it. 0:59 So start off by telling us about how you partnered up to create this really fascinating investigative podcast. 1:06 I'll let John start. 1:08 We actually met through a different case that both of us were investigating on separate tracks. And through that case and getting to know one another, we started thinking about other projects that we might come together on, something that 1:22 we could approach in the same way. We both have this victim-centered ideology when it comes to these stories. And the way that we came to it was I had been hired several years before we met to do an adaptation of a book called Unbridled Rage. It was the story, 1:37 it's a great Chicago story. It's the oldest unsolved murder in Chicago history to ever be solved. It's the Peterson-Schussler murders. 1:45 Within that book, there's a thin segment about Helen Brock's case. 1:49 From the moment I read it, I always stuck it in the back of my head. And when Beth and I were thinking about how could we work together on something else, I wrote that up. And both of us, I think, sometimes it takes a partner to really have 2:02 something come to fruition and open up in front of you. 2:04 And when we both looked at it closely, it became obvious this is what we should work on together. 2:09 So neither one of you are from Chicago originally. 2:12 No. 2:13 No. 2:13 Is that just a coincidence that you ended up researching and getting really going down deep on two Chicago cases? 2:22 Oh, no, we did. The other case that we have in common is Philadelphia based. So this is the only Chicago project that we have. And John had never been to Chicago right before this project. So what's interesting and maybe you guys can relate is especially during the pandemic, 2:42 you start to realize that you can do so much remotely. 2:45 It was almost like we were from two sides of the country, like hovering over Chicago at 30,000 feet. 2:53 Which was really cool. 2:54 Because then when we actually dropped down in real life, we were like, this is weird. This is like a movie. Wow, we've been looking at this property remotely forever. And then here we are walking through her house. I felt like we were in a movie that somebody else was filming. 3:10 That makes any sense? 3:11 Yeah. 3:13 It definitely feels that way sometimes. 3:14 Yeah. 3:15 I think that it was definitely a pandemic era sort of saving grace. It kept us sane during a time when really you couldn't do much. And also because Beth wasn't from Philadelphia, the case that she was looking into, it dawned on me. I find a lot of times 3:28 if you're diving into a case that takes place somewhere that you're not familiar with, you don't have any preconceived notions. 3:34 You don't know what questions not to ask. You only know what questions you want to ask and who you want to ask of them. So you have no fear of a well-trod path. 3:44 Of a case. 3:45 And I think that's what we have here. We're coming out from two different sides of the country. Neither of us have much of a connection to Chicago. So we were coming to it very much clean. We didn't have any, anything, any weight coming into the project. So the candy heiress 3:58 herself is Helen Brock. Many people would know Brock's candy that many of us grew up with. So tell us a little bit about her and this multimillion dollar company and family that she married into. 4:15 Her name is Helen Voorhees. 4:17 And so she was born in Ohio and she did not meet the man connected to the Brock candy fortune until she was in her late 30s. And they met in Florida because as rich people would winter in Florida and they were rich. 4:34 She was not rich. 4:35 So when she met him, he was older than her and the company was not as well known. It was still known. They got together and he married her. She became wife number three. And then he sold the company for a large amount of money. And so then when 4:53 he died, she became the sole heir to that fortune. 4:57 They never had any children. She had dogs that were like her kids. And she had a will, which became a big part of the story. And obviously, when she goes missing at age 65 and people are looking for motive, money is something that they automatically look at. 5:17 It's interesting. 5:17 When I started listening to the podcast, I had never heard money. of Helen Brock's case before. It sounds like it is something that people who live in Chicago would be. 5:29 Very familiar with. 5:30 Had you both heard of Helen Brock and her mysterious disappearance before the case kinda came onto your radar? No. 5:39 I had, again, having been hired to write the adaptation of the book, Umbrato Rage. But prior to that, I was only aware of it in as much as it's on a few lists of some of the most well-known missing people. Where did these people go? It's D.B. Cooper. 5:53 It's a few people like that. And Helen was always on those lists. I didn't know much about it other than she had gone missing and was never found. 6:01 When she went missing, did it stay a fairly regional story, like to Chicago, or was it national almost immediately that Helen Brock has disappeared? 6:11 She's the missing candy heiress. What kind of story was it in the 70s? 6:16 I think what's really interesting and it's revealed in the first episode, second episode, is that the police didn't want anyone to know right away and neither did the family. 6:26 So there was a delay. So there was a delay in reporting her missing and there was a delay in the media knowing that she was missing. And then once she was missing, it was almost treated like maybe somebody just can't reach her because in the 70s, they couldn't 6:43 always reach you. And there wasn't a way to track people like we can now. 6:48 So, oh, maybe she's in Brazil. She's rich. 6:52 She can just do whatever she wants. And I think that it wasn't as sensational as news is today. So once it became clear that she's still gone here, like nobody can reach her, she's still gone. That's when they started reporting on it. And that's when other newspapers started 7:12 picking it up. And then it became the story that was like an anniversary story. 7:17 And it still is today. 7:19 There is a newscaster who has stamped this as his story. 7:24 He listened to them and reached out to us. 7:27 And so it's become like Chicago lore. There's a lot of public reporting that was great. It wasn't always accurate, but it gave us great names and great dates and pieces of information to hunt down, to track down and verify, which is one of our favorite things when we try 7:46 to put a story together. 7:48 Question for you, Beth. Steering back to something you said a moment ago, and maybe it's reflexive on our part because we've had so much trouble with law enforcement being less than straightforward in the Colonial Parkway murders. I think 8:00 that's fair. I think you said that law enforcement and the families didn't want to go public. 8:08 We actually have that in a document. 8:10 Why? 8:11 Why? 8:12 It could be who they were looking at to see if that person of interest was going to indicate something to them. I think the FBI also did not get involved. 8:25 And there is a little bit of there was some family tension that they didn't want to be aired publicly. So, yeah, that's it just kind of and it was a small town police department. 8:38 That was what I was thinking. The police department in Glendale, especially in the 70s, were not accustomed to murder, certainly not accustomed to disinsurances. There was also tinges of misogyny of maybe she just went hysterical and she's getting older. 8:51 And that's where these stories of she may be in Brazil getting a facelift. She's an older woman now. And those sorts of things tended to delay the investigation quite a bit. But yet, I also think the family, to the extent that they could wish to keep it quiet, 9:05 like a lot of families might, until they could see if this was really happening. To Beth's point, I think it stayed that way until the point seven years in when she's declared dead. And I think that's when the media really started picking up on, she's still missing. Now 9:21 she's declared dead and we don't know what happened. And I think that's where it blooms media-wise from there, 1984. 9:28 As I was listening to the podcast, of course, I couldn't help but compare it to Nancy Guthrie's disappearance and how very different the media treatment of Nancy Guthrie's disappearance was compared to Helen Brock. And I just wonder, how 9:42 would the media have treated Helen Brock if she had disappeared today in 2026? What would the media coverage have been like? That's really, that was something that I was just pondering as we went through and how different this case would have been if it had that media pressure. 9:57 At a 24-7 standpoint like Nancy Guthrie's did. 10:01 In episode one, we tried to make that point. We are by saying like, this is like Harris Hilton or like an heiress that everyone knows, say Kim Kardashian was missing. 10:09 Someone with that kind of money and clout. That's what we're talking about. But back then, to Beth's point, the media really didn't jump on it in that way. 10:18 And Helen was not a Chicago socialite. So it wasn't that, oh, she didn't show up for this big event or at the country club because she did spend a lot of her time in Florida. She lived in the suburbs. Glenview is a suburb of Chicago that a lot of people, 10:35 they moved out of the city because they could get a lot of land and the equestrian world. So you don't, you're not seeing your neighbor at the mailbox. So if she's not there, and especially she disappeared in winter, People 10:49 might be like, oh, I haven't seen the purple Rolls Royce. 10:51 She must be in Florida. If they were even thinking about her at all, with Nancy Guthrie, her daughter is a famous person. Helen did not have any children. Her family was very small town and lived in another state. 11:06 So there wasn't somebody who was ringing the bell like, you got to find her, you got to find her, you got to find her. Until the people who had benefited from her fortune came. All of a sudden, we're like, oh, wait, she gives my animal foundation $ 200, 000 every year. 11:23 Which is a lot of money back then. 11:26 You got to find her. And if you don't find her, you need to give me the money because that's what she would want. And it becomes that missing person. Nancy Guthrie will be considered missing until legally declared dead. And that means that, like with Helen, it's a guardian ad 11:43 litem situation, which is somebody to act... the way Helen would have acted if she was present. 11:51 I know we want to encourage people to listen to the Missing Candy Heiress podcast, but if you don't mind, give us a little bit of a flavor for what's the prevailing theory now in 2026 for Helen Brock's disappearance. 12:07 The story of Helen's disappearance, as it's been known, is that she had been to the Mayo Clinic once, for a battery of tests, about five days worth of tests, which was something she would do back then. The story is that she came home to Glenview, Illinois, and then 12:21 was planning to go to Florida after a long weekend. 12:24 And there's really no proof that she ever came home from the Mayo Clinic. And there's certainly no proof that she ever made it to Florida. So the story is somewhere between the Mayo Clinic and when she went missing, nobody knows what happened to her. The only person who 12:39 would have known, the only person who actively said he had seen her was her house man, Jack Matlick. He said they picked her up from the airport, brought her home for the weekend, and then brought her back to the airport to go to Florida. And from there, he 12:50 said he's never seen her. So that was the story of her disappearance. The series, Beth, I think there are several. 12:59 They're all interconnected, but Beth, what would you say the prevailing theory is? 13:03 Ugh. 13:04 The one people love to latch onto and amplify is a very, in my opinion, convoluted conspiracy about the horse industry and many men conspiring to kill her for her money. 13:22 That's something that we kept saying, okay, motive is... She has a fortune and they're basically alluding to motive. So that was one of the questions the podcast set out to answer is, OK, who ended up with the money? 13:37 And if you look at that, then you can also relook at the case and go, OK, who are the people of interest? Who are the people who might have been alleged to be involved in this conspiracy? And what actually ended up being convictions? And that spans a very 13:56 long period of time. She goes missing in 77, and somebody gets sent to prison for life in 1995. 14:05 I was surprised by that, that so much of a gap had gone by between her disappearance and, I think we're talking about Richard Bailey now, being charged. How do you all choose to cover the suspects and the passage of time on the podcast? 14:23 You can make suppositions and you can repeat other people's reporting. 14:30 We like to re-examine everything and we like documents and we like firsthand accounts. And so we spent the better part of three years going after original material and to verify it. So we tracked down anybody that was alive and we could find them. 14:49 We called them. 14:49 Anybody. Everybody and everybody. It was a lot. 14:53 And if they didn't call us back, we might call them a year later. John traveled to places and we interviewed a lot of people. And even the questions we asked people in year one were not the same questions we wanted to ask them in year three. So for us, 15:11 it was always if we found something or we thought something or we were like, this person said this, we had to make that argument to each other. 15:21 Versiferously? 15:24 Yeah. 15:24 With a lot of energy behind it. And we will argue. 15:28 For anyone listening who would like to have a partner and make a podcast, you will argue. You will certainly argue. 15:36 You will stand your ground. You will lose ground. You will. 15:39 We had a lot of that because I'm just going to put this out there. We've disagreed on a lot of things about what we we agree on what ultimately happened. 15:46 Right. 15:47 But the way in which it happened and things that have happened since and all of that, we have our own beliefs about that, which is fine. I think everyone that's, what's interesting about the way we've approached this is very much very cinematic and very much like a doc series 16:00 where we lead you down these possibilities based on factual information, based on documents. We start with the, the most commonly told version of the story, which is that Ellen was dating Richard Bailey. This is the story as it's been told, 16:16 and that he had sold her horses. And they were supposedly bum horses, and she was angered by this, and she was going to go to the attorney general and the mayor and the governor and all that and get people in trouble. So that gave them impetus to have 16:30 her killed. From the outset, both of us felt that was very convenient and also not really backed up by anything we were finding to the level that we could believe it completely. And again, there are splintering pieces where 16:41 we followed all of the splinters. Some of them panned out, some of them didn't. But that's why we start with the established story, start with what's understood about the case, and then backtrack and re-examine all of it. We really 16:53 did a true re-investigation of the story because we just, we had too many questions that weren't being answered by the accepted version of the story. 17:02 It was interesting to me because I know nothing about the criminal enterprise that is horse buying, selling, and swindling. 17:11 So this was a lot to learn. It was very interesting. 17:15 Did you guys have any familiarity with the horse swindling enterprise before you stumbled down that rabbit hole? 17:23 Neither of us are, neither of us own a horse. 17:26 Or horse people. 17:28 I have a cat. 17:29 But also what we realized, because we were like, okay, this is how John and I do everything is, okay, we need to be a semi-expert on this topic. And then we do a deep dive. And one of the things we realized was that in the world of extreme wealth, 17:47 there are places to put your money. Art is, collectible cars, horses. 17:54 And that's for value reasons, tax reasons, hiding money. 18:01 And so we were like, oh, wow. Yeah, this is... 18:06 Because those. 18:07 Those worlds are very rich people who are maybe not being forthright about taxes, and there's gambling involved too. I mean, that is right there going to tell you that some of the people in that world are a little finger to the side of the nose. And so we looked 18:24 at that and thought, okay, these characters in that world who are now being pulled into possibly one of the theories that Yeah, they're sketchy people. They're sketchy people capable of committing murder. As we were looking at it, we 18:41 always kept saying to each other, this is like a Coen Brothers movie. 18:45 It is, yeah. 18:47 Insane, the names, the stories around people, how they presented to the world from Helen being a redhead, wearing pink and purple and driving these very elaborate vehicles super, super expensive cars through the suburbs. And then a guy who's 19:09 quote unquote, the horse mafia driving his car with the big horns on it through the suburbs and everyone's scared of him. It's almost like a sliding doors kind of narrative. 19:21 Yeah. 19:21 And I can see the Coen brothers analogy here coming through big time. 19:26 And we just kept, we really wanted in the podcast to take the listener and right into the scene like we felt we were, that you could feel like, or you almost could smell what Helen might smell like. 19:40 Like, for sure, Chanel No. 5. 19:44 Sure. 19:45 Just because it was the best of the best. 19:47 Also, to be very straightforward, about it, we base everything on what we can find and what we can look at. 19:54 And that story of her finding out these were bum horses and getting angered by that, a few things bumped us, really. Because, one, she had so much money that it really wouldn't be that much of an expenditure for her. But beyond that, Again, 20:08 with the documents that we have, we found in the two years after she went missing, those bum horses made upwards of $ 80, 000 or $ 90, 000. So they weren't so bum. 20:20 No. 20:21 And that's why we were like, okay, so if they're not bum horses, we have to go back to trace that back and see where that story began and why it would be convenient to say they had been. Because $ 80, 000 in 1978, $ 8, 000. 20:31 Yeah. 20:31 That's a good profit on horses that were supposedly bummed. 20:39 It was a wild ride for a couple of episodes, just getting into this world of shady characters. I was listening to one episode when I was driving one day. 20:48 I listened to you guys a lot while I was out on a walk or a run, but one day I happened to be driving and doing a bunch of errands. 20:53 And I got to the episode where a particularly intense moment happened outside of some stables. I'm not going to ruin it for anybody else because I want them to be surprised too. But it was particularly violent. It was something I didn't expect. I actually yelled, oh my God. 21:09 I swerved my car because I didn't expect it. 21:13 Can I tell you, my wife, my own wife, said the exact same thing. She had been driving. I was so shocked by that. 21:20 Yeah. 21:21 And she knows the story. I think she's probably sick of hearing the story, but she knew the story. But still, because to Beth's point, it puts you there, puts you in the scene. We tried to insert a little bit of cinematic approach to the recreation type stuff. And I'm 21:34 glad that here it seems to have worked. 21:36 Yeah, the only thing is if you're in accidents, I don't think that's the goal, is it? You're listening to Mind Over Murder. We'll be right back after this word from our sponsors. We're back here at Mind Over Murder. 21:55 But I think in addition to the FOIA that we filed, we also had amazing access to audio tapes that had never been heard. And so it allows you to hear these characters' voices. And one of the characters who is not as well known as... Richard Bailey, The Golden Tongue, 22:17 or Jack Malick. The houseman is this sort of nibbly little conniving guy, and he's got a high voice. And when we first heard it, we were, is that a woman? 22:27 And that he just was this character that you're like, I don't know if he's such a good talker, but he believes his own bullshit. And right up to the end, and also from listening to the podcast, you know that there's a constant thread of people I'm going to get 22:46 a movie deal out of this from the beginning, which for us, we just found to be hilarious, like laughing at these people. Everybody thinks that they have total main character syndrome, including the prosecutor, Stephen Miller. And we wanted 23:03 to make sure to put that in the timeline so that the listener could go, is that influencing anything? 23:10 Their decision-making, et cetera. Yes. 23:12 And again, from that perspective of victim-centered, our sort of guiding light from the beginning was Helen was a victim here, right? 23:20 How do we look at that in terms of everyone that's trying to wiggle in around this case, get a movie deal, get a book deal. it's all still pulling away from Helen. The money pulls away from her. The fame pulls away from her. All of it takes the 23:35 eye off of the person who's still to this day missing. 23:38 And that was really frustrating. I want to say the funny thing, It's funny, not that we're laughing at the case, but something like the guy Beth's referring to is Joe Clemens. 23:47 And he says he, at a certain point, he had a meeting about a possible movie in Hollywood. And he goes, oh, Hollywood, LA? 23:53 And he goes, no, it was Hollywood, Florida. 23:55 Not the same, yeah. 23:58 Not exactly what I was thinking, but those sorts of things, it does make you laugh because it's so ridiculous. But again, it goes to this idea that everybody was saying, what can I take? What can I take? What can I take? 24:10 And that's the problem with the case. I think to a large extent, that's why the case hasn't been solved. 24:14 There was one point where Beth had asked Richard Bailey straight up a question. And I knew before he said it, I knew he was going to say something. 24:25 Oh, it's in the book. You can read it in the book. 24:27 Well, it's in the book. I was like, I knew it. 24:30 I freaking knew it because he's out to sell his book, which is then going to get turned. 24:35 Into a movie. 24:36 I can see this guy and read him like a cheap manuscript. 24:40 That's what he wanted. 24:41 I don't care that Helen disappeared because allegedly he loved her and he was going to marry her, but he doesn't really care. He wants to sell the book and sell the movie. What a character he was. And you guys did a great job capturing him, I think, as 24:54 a character. I love that you included his, I like that you included his voicemail message. 25:00 This is the golden tongue. 25:01 I'm like, oh my God. 25:02 What a creep. 25:04 Really? 25:05 I still have them on my phone. I just I even though I've sent them all to John, I still have them on my phone. I feel nervous to delete them. 25:15 I don't know. Just I keep things in multiple places. 25:19 Google Drive, external drives. John has a copy. Emails, my phone. 25:24 And my husband keeps saying, you keep running out of storage space on your phone. Why do you need so much storage space? And I was like, because I take screenshots of things that I need to keep and I have voicemails that I cannot let go of. And he's, 25:37 oh my God, get some media management skills. 25:42 And I'll credit the best for the incredible interviews with Richard. 25:47 This is the interesting thing about a flexibility with a partner. 25:51 When we got in touch with Richard, what listeners will find out is Richard was a huge fan of men. 25:56 He liked to sort of operate with women. So very early on, he had a, who are you? I was on the first call and he was like, is this your husband? Who is this guy? Off the line. So I backed away because he wanted to speak to Beth and the relationship they're in, and you can hear it 26:11 in the calls, became very interesting. Very interesting. I think it's one of the more key elements of the podcast is that sort of never before heard point of view from Richard Bailey almost 50 years later after the case. 26:24 Did the two of you as podcasters strategize off air about that? Did one of you say, hey, he clearly doesn't like men as much as he likes chatting up the women? 26:34 I was on the line nearly to record the calls. 26:38 I was just there. 26:38 I am the nudge. I am the cold caller. Of the two of us, my favorite, I love hunting documents and I love tracking down people and getting them to talk to me. And so if I find somebody and I get him, he's the first person I call. 26:57 I'm like, we got him. Let's set up the interview. 26:59 We're doing it. 27:01 With Richard, the story behind that is, there's more to it. 27:06 Because when I first called him, he was 98. 27:11 I was about to say, how old is this man by this point? Because a lot of years have gone by. 27:15 He's 92. 27:17 And my reference point was my own surviving parent who's now. 27:21 And so I don't have eyes on him. He's got a flip phone. He spent 25 years in federal prison. 27:29 He's got health issues and he's 92 and he's alone. 27:33 Wow. 27:36 In some of the calls, there's one call in particular that I did with him. And I thought he was like, just, I thought he was just being a pain in the ass. 27:45 And I was like, God damn it. You are your own worst enemy. I'm yelling at him. 27:49 Oh, you actually said that to him. 27:51 Yeah. 27:51 I said, you are your own worst enemy. Just what are you talking about? And he didn't fight me. And there was like a pause and I was like, oh, this is, ah, okay. I need to be more mindful of what is possibly going on here. And so then I would call John and say, I think that within 28:14 the calls, there are things that are consistently factual. And so we were very careful about what calls to include. 28:24 Okay. 28:25 Because it would have been very easy to say, this guy's a lying piece of shit, based on his ideas of what was true this long after. 28:35 The conversations were never preloaded. So in other words, we never shepherded him into certain answers. It became a genuine check-in call. After 25 years in prison, at his age, over 90 years old, he had no one. And at a certain point, I think we were some of the 28:51 only people in the world in contact with him. So it was an interesting sort of balancing act of, okay, we really want to speak to him about what he knows, but we need to also be mindful that we're not putting words in his mouth or guiding him any certain 29:08 way and letting him speak, and it could be very frustrating. 29:11 Did you end up liking this guy? Did you feel like you had a rapport with him? Because he seems like he would be a. 29:19 Likable con artist he's like your your sort of slick willy kind of grandfatherly dude but did you ever end up realizing i kind of like this guy he's a rascally scamper did you realize at a certain point i can't actually. 29:31 Trust him i think we have different answers okay all right okay seth first i. 29:36 Would say that oh sorry that's i know you go that I ended up, if you're a human being, I think there's a sense of pity for someone that has no one in the world and that is a person out of time. I think in one instance, he makes 29:52 the declaration that he's going to go back to Chicago and talk to some of his business contacts in the city. 29:58 And he's told that You've been out of the loop for 30 years. And he says, I'm fine. And he gets himself, we don't know quite how he does this stuff, but he gets himself to Chicago and he comes back and he's dejected. And he says, I don't know anything 30:12 or anyone. Everything is different. And it's hard not to feel bad just for another human being experiencing that sort of existential crisis. Yeah. But we did have different takes on what to do with that personally. And Beth? 30:28 I found him. 30:29 It changed the more I talked to him, the better sense I had of, because the prosecutors, the two prosecutors, one who provided us with an interview and one who said he couldn't unless he got permission from Disney because of his movie deal, which I was like, dude, that 30:49 was like 30 years ago. But anyway, keep telling that at cocktail parties. Their whole story was, oh, federal prosecutors. 30:57 I could go on all day. Their story was that he was the most evil man they had ever prosecuted. 31:03 So you're going into it like. 31:06 I don't buy it. 31:06 Okay, but again, prosecutors, it's a narrative. John and I, it's a narrative. Everybody's got a narrative. And so the more I talked to him and then he would call me, and even if you... All of the voicemails he left me, I left the relationship with him, and I still see 31:27 it this way, as. 31:29 Somebody. 31:29 Who really wanted you to understand that his claim was that he had nothing to do with it. And John and I kept saying, what if we were in that position or somebody we knew was in that position? And that's why we really wanted people to understand and we 31:49 wanted to understand as best as we could as being lay people. How much of a RICO case is legitimately quicksand? 31:59 If you end up in the crosshairs of a RICO case, will you ever get out of it? Because that's what sends him to prison and gets this long sentencing. 32:07 Yeah, I was amazed that he actually served the full 25 years. A lot of times when you end up with a 30-year sentence, you serve far less than that. 32:18 But he actually ended up serving the bulk of his sentence. 32:22 Do you have any idea why that happened? 32:25 That judge. 32:27 That judge who stayed on the bench until he was 92 and a half himself. 32:32 Wow. 32:33 And a month before he retired, heard Richard's final appeal and was like, nope. He retires and then he dies and Richard is still in prison. 32:46 Wow. 32:46 Wow. 32:47 I think effectively, initially he was given a life sentence, which was downgraded to the 27 years. I think effectively at 65 years old, 27 years is a life sentence. 32:57 They expected him to die in prison. That's what the expectation was. And I will say about Richard, even at 92, he was sharp. He maintained... He sounded it, yeah. When you get to the granular details of things, he wasn't. 33:11 But I will say this as just an aside. When Beth said that she was from L.A. in Hollywood, he goes, oh, I have plans to come out there. Just like that. 33:20 Really? 33:20 He goes, yeah. She says, where are you going to stay? 33:23 He goes, I think I'll stay with you. He was very much still in the sort of golden tongue type of deal, which was interesting to see, because during that same conversation, we brought up his age, his advanced age. 33:37 According to him, he said, I have another 30, 35 years in me. 33:41 Wow. 33:42 It shows you where he is mentally. I believe the world stopped for him at 65, and when he got out, he's a 65-year-old man. 33:49 Yeah. 33:49 But he wasn't. 33:51 Helen still has nieces and nephews and grandnieces and grandnephews who want to know what happened to her. What do you think it would ultimately take to get real solid answers for Helen's family? 34:03 Or is that even possible at this point? 34:05 I think if you listen to the podcast and you come to the end. 34:09 We've always, the measure that we want to live up to is that as soon as you've given us your time and listening, that you trust what we're telling you. 34:19 And so by the end of episode seven, we tell you something that we don't have a recording for. 34:25 Yes. 34:27 And I will tell you that another media outlet went and decided to ask for their comment on that. Because they did listen to the podcast, Glenview Police. And their comment was that we mischaracterized the meeting and that the case is still open. 34:44 Ish. 34:46 Open-ish. 34:47 No, they said open. They said open. Interesting. 34:50 Why does this sound familiar? 34:51 Case is still open. 34:54 And that they only met with us, two citizens who are podcasters that they don't know, for more than two hours because they thought they could get information from us. 35:08 Boy, does that not smell past the smell test. 35:11 And so I said, we have all the emails that were the coordination to be there. 35:17 Happy to share those. And I said... Did you ask. 35:21 Them about the evidence that we reveal that they have not revealed publicly? 35:28 What did they say about that? 35:30 Oh, yeah. 35:31 They said, oh, we're going to have to get back to you on that. 35:33 Yeah. 35:34 And they wouldn't do it. 35:34 Wait for that call. 35:35 And they wouldn't do an interview on record. 35:38 Of course not. 35:39 And the local news came back to us and said, you know, what's your response? And I said, ask them if the case is open, then why didn't they just deny my. 35:50 FOIA with the very easy answer of it's an open investigation? 35:54 Yeah, that's the standard answer. 35:56 I said they used burdensome. as the exemption, and I appealed and I won. So either they're really bad at their jobs or they're lying. 36:07 And did they go the burdensome step of providing you with much more documentation, which you'd asked for? 36:14 Oh, yes. 36:15 We got way more than we thought we were asking for. 36:19 They sent it to you electronically, by the way, or in big file boxes? 36:23 Oh, no, electronically. 36:25 And then how heavily redacted was it? 36:28 We had another source, so we already had some similar documents and audio that had come from another source. So at one point, it was an interesting game, and I hope that anybody's listening. I highly recommend just basically getting 36:45 to understand the Sunshine Laws. and as a citizen, what you're entitled to, that public records are owned by the public. 36:53 We pay with our tax dollars for public agencies who are paid by tax dollars to maintain those records. Now, of course, privacy laws and that there can be. 37:07 Nefarious situations, of course. 37:10 But in requesting those documents, I have always been, and I'm sure Kristen, you would agree, that If they are going to reject your request because it would impede an investigation that could bring justice for the victim, I completely understand that. 37:29 Yeah. 37:29 But this was such an old case, and they were so weird about answering John's very basic question from the very first phone call, which is, what's the status of the case? 37:42 Yeah, they don't like those questions. 37:44 So to do the FOIA, it was like, hi, I'm about to put in a FOIA. Just introducing myself. 37:51 Sure. 37:51 Great. No problem. Put it in. And then all of a sudden the tone changes and it's like, this is too broad. You need it narrow. So it was like narrow. 38:01 Denied. 38:01 Yep. 38:04 And the appeal was their exemption of burdensome. wasn't seen as legitimate by the state attorney general of Illinois. 38:12 And he said, release it all. And all of a sudden it was like a flood. 38:16 And I was like, John, get ready for an, with an external drive because that's how big it was. And then he immediately was like, hold on a second. I need to cross-reference. And he was like, there's five pages missing. 38:27 And they were very, very specific pages. And this is where this would fall under not lying, but stupid. I went back and said, oh, actually, there's five pages missing. 38:41 Oh, no problem. And sent them to me. 38:44 Wow. 38:45 And that basically gave us the matching page that was the, I'm going to call it the smoking gun evidence because I don't want to reveal what it is. 38:54 Sure. 38:55 But that was somebody just very quickly not trying to be a pain in the ass or protect anything, just going, no problem, I'll give you the five pages. And it was a monumental moment in our investigation. 39:07 And I can believe a lot of things. But to leave it to chance that one page, one page in particular, was left out of the hundreds and hundreds of pages we got, I just can't delete it. 39:19 Right. 39:19 So it was not a coincidence that five pages with this one pivotal page were among the missing. 39:26 Right. 39:27 I wouldn't think so. Correct. 39:28 And they just didn't fight us on it. 39:30 And I think, I can't imagine that the village of Glenview has had a contentious FOIA battle with anybody but me. 39:38 And look, we didn't force our way into the flea station. 39:43 We were invited there. We flew across the country. We're a completely independent podcast on our own dime. The fact is, if they're going to say that, you know, it was under false pretenses or something, if it's an open case, 39:56 you invited two citizens that have no jurisdiction whatsoever in to have a conversation about for about two and a half, three hours. I think that's not our fault. We were there under completely good faith, everything out in the open. 40:11 But potentially my favorite line in the podcast is when we arrived there and the one detective says, are you recording? 40:18 And Beth just out of nowhere says, yeah, we're here for a podcast. We were hiding these things. We were wearing our moccasins outside of our shirts. This isn't a gotcha moment. But it was so natural. We said, yeah, this is a podcast. And we were just there completely, 40:34 in all honesty, just trying to find out what happened. 40:37 And unfortunately, like we were talking about earlier, it's not always viewed positively when you're looking over the shoulder of some of these agencies. 40:46 Join us again next time as we continue our conversation with Jonathan Rocks and Beth McNamara, producers and hosts of The Missing Candy Heiress. That's next time on Mind Over Murder. 40:59 John and Beth, this has been wonderful. Thank you guys for joining us so much. 41:02 Thank you so much. 41:02 Thank you so much for having us. 41:04 That is going to do it for this episode of Mind Over Murder. Thank you so much for listening. We'll see you next time. 41:20 Mind Over Murder is a production of Absolute Zero and Another Dog Productions. 41:26 Our executive producers are Bill Thomas and Kristen Dilley. 41:29 Our logo art is by Pamela Arnois. 41:32 Our theme music is by Kevin MacLeod. 41:35 Mind Over Murder is distributed in partnership with Crawl Space Media. 41:40 You can follow us on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram. 41:43 You can also follow our page on the Colonial Parkway Murders on Facebook. 41:47 And finally, you can follow Bill Thomas on Twitter at BillThomas56. 41:53 Thank you for listening to Mind Over Murder.
Community discussion