0:00 At 3.44 p.m. 0:01 On Tuesday, February 18, 2025, deputies from the Lake County Sheriff's Office and troopers with the Oregon State Police arrived with child welfare workers at a home in Lakeview, Oregon. 0:16 The Oregon Department of Human Services, or ODHS, had finally gotten a Child Protective Custody Order from the Lake County Circuit Court to remove Thomas Scott Strong, from the home for his own safety. Officers forced their way inside and 0:34 immediately detained Thomas's mother, 38-year-old Amanda Edwards, and her longtime romantic partner, 31-year-old Nathaniel Cullens, who was also known as Nathan. 0:47 As officers searched the property, they eventually made their way into the unheated garage, where they found a cardboard box with Thomas's body. 0:58 Hidden inside. Hi, lambs. Welcome to Love and Murder, Heartbreak to Homicide. I am your host, Kai. 1:05 And before we continue, make sure that you're subscribed to Love and Murder on whatever podcast platform you're currently listening on so you never miss an episode. And if you want to keep up with everything happening with this show, 1:17 come and follow Love and Murder for free at the Patreon, patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. If you'd like to get even more Love and Murder while helping me continue telling the victim's stories, You can also join one of the paid Patreon-tayors and 1:31 become part of the LAMFAM, patreon.com forward slash loveandmurder. In the meantime, though, let's get back to this case. Thomas was born in Daytona Beach, Florida, and when he was two years old, his family moved to Texas, where he 1:46 lived for about 10 years before eventually relocating to the small community of Lakeview in rural southern Oregon. Thomas had autism and attended Lakeview High School, where he was a junior on track to graduate with the class of 2026. 2:03 He loved drawing in art class and enjoyed cooking class, and people around Lakeview knew him for pulling his red wagon through town. He also had this thing with green paper ties. Thomas would make them out of construction paper, 2:17 tape them to his t-shirts, and sometimes make them for his classmates and his teachers. One of his teachers, Denae Bauer, said, quote, I think for a lot of us that had him as a student, there aren't many days that go by that I don't think about him or have some type 2:33 of memory that crosses my mind. Thomas lived with Amanda and Nathan and according to information that later came out, Amanda was struggling with substance abuse and had also been absent from work for extended periods. Over time, she became 2:49 increasingly difficult for school personnel and social service workers to reach. 2:55 Thomas had reportedly lost between 20 and 30 pounds over the summer and as much as 40 pounds overall. Educators like Denae, the school principal, and the school resource officer had also noticed that he was eating unusually large amounts 3:11 of food while he was there, which made them question whether he was getting enough to eat at home. Then, in November 2024, Amanda abruptly pulled Thomas out of school. 3:25 cutting off the regular contact he had with teachers, staff members, and classmates who had seen him every day. By December, those concerns were getting much more serious. Between December 11th and December 17th, three separate reports were submitted to ODHS 3:45 raising concerns about abuse, isolation, starvation, and Thomas' dramatic weight loss. 3:53 On December 12th, at around 9 in the morning, the principal and school resources officer went to the house themselves. 4:01 I love it. 4:01 Like, they're trying their best. They're doing above and beyond their job. Thomas was still in bed when they arrived, and they saw that he had dark circles under his eyes along with the significant weight loss that had already 4:14 concerned people at school. Inside the house, blackout curtains covered the windows and made it so dark that flashlights were needed to move around. And the home was so cluttered that piles and bags of trash blocked pathways throughout the home. 4:32 At the front entryway, they also saw a fully loaded rifle with a sleeve of ammunition positioned towards the door. 4:41 Despite the reports and what school officials had observed, ODHS screened out the first two reports. 4:49 I don't know why. I searched. There was no information. 4:53 But it was only after the third report was filed on December 17th that the agency opened a child protective investigation and ODHS held one remote meeting with Amanda and offered her voluntary counseling referrals. What? 5:13 But she didn't want to do it. 5:15 She didn't take Thomas back to school. She wouldn't take him to medical appointments. And she continued making it difficult for people to verify how he was doing. And that's all they did? That was it and then nothing? Then 5:29 between December 21st, 2024 and February 12th, 2025, there were no documented attempts by ODHS to make direct contact with Thomas, and no unannounced visits to physically verify that he was safe. 5:44 No safety plan was established either, and during that five-week period, the agency relied on voicemails and unanswered text messages while Amanda continued not responding. In the meantime, Thomas stayed inside that house. The investigation and medical findings showed that he 6:05 had been subjected to prolonged physical maltreatment, and severe deprivation. 6:11 Forensic findings placed his death on or around February 1, 2025, and an autopsy conducted by the Oregon State Medical Examiner documented widespread bruising, multiple broken ribs, severe internal injuries, and Thomas' death was attributed to blunt force trauma resulting from 6:34 severe physical maltreatment. After he died, evidence showed that Amanda and Nathan placed his body inside the cardboard box in the garage and concealed his death. On February 12th, while Thomas' body was still inside that garage, his grandfather contacted 6:52 ODHS again. He reported concerns about Amanda's ongoing substance abuse and her prolonged absence from work. Social workers went to her house that day, and no one answered the door, so they left without seeing Thomas. His 17th birthday passed 7:08 on February 17th, and the following day brings us back to where we started at the beginning of this episode. 7:15 ODHS returned with the court order, and this time they were accompanied by law enforcement. But by the time authorities were finally able to enter the house to take Thomas into protective custody, there was no longer a child there 7:29 to protect. The discovery immediately turned the case into a homicide investigation. In the days that followed, from February 19th through February 21st, the Lake County Major Crime Team was activated, bringing together the Lake County District Attorney's Office, the Lake 7:47 County Sheriff's Office, and Oregon State Police. OSP took the investigative lead while officials reassured Lakeview residents that both people connected with the case were already in custody and there was no continuing threat to the community. Amanda and Nathan 8:04 were booked into the Lake County Jail on initial charges of criminal negligent homicide, first-degree criminal mistreatment, second-degree abuse of a corpse, and tampering with physical evidence. Nathan also faced an additional charge of unlawful use of a weapon. As 8:22 state police investigators executed search warrants on electronic devices seized from the house, they found video recordings made by Amanda and Nathan. as much evidence on and around your person as possible. The footage documented the physical abuse of Thomas 8:40 and became part of the evidence investigators were building alongside the autopsy findings and what had been recovered from the property. 8:48 By late February, the Lake County Grand Jury had reviewed the evidence and returned upgraded felony indictments. Nathan was charged with first-degree murder, murder by abuse, second-degree abuse of a corpse, 9:02 and first-degree criminal mistreatment, while Amanda was charged with murder by abuse, second-degree abuse of a corpse, and first-degree criminal mistreatment. 9:13 The Lake County District Attorney then requested assistance from the Oregon Department of Justice Criminal Justice Division, and they worked alongside the local Lake County prosecutors. Amanda and Nathan initially pleaded. 9:26 Guess what they pleaded, lambs? You already know. Not guilty. 9:30 And their cases began moving through the court system. While those criminal cases were still pending, however, there was another question hanging over Thomas' death. What happened with Aldo's warnings before he died? On February 9th through the 10th, 2026, 9:49 Disability Rights Oregon's, or DRO, D-R-O, a federally mandated advocacy organization, released a 21-page investigative report titled, quote, Red Flags Ignored, DHS Fails, Boy With Autism Dies Alone. The report used 10:07 the confidential pseudonym Lucas for Thomas and explained how ODHS had handled the case. Disability Rights Organ Executive Director Jake Cornett said, quote, Despite multiple complaints from his teachers that he was being neglected, the Department of Human Services failed 10:26 to protect this child. Rather than uncovering a completely different sequence of events, Drou went over the decisions that had already been made and concluded that ODHS had failed at several critical points. The organization called the decision to screen 10:42 out the first two December reports unresolved. The report was also sharply critical of how ODHS handled the period after the investigation was finally open. Quote, At no point during this five-week period did DHS establish a safety plan, make 11:13 unannounced visits to verify Strong's well-being, seek legal authority to intervene, or treat the mountain evidence. A mother who wouldn't answer calls, wouldn't engage in services, wouldn't bring her child to school or medical appointments, as the emergency it was. Dro also 11:31 raised serious concerns about what happened after Thomas died. ODHS convened a critical incident review team to examine the agency's handling of the case. According to Droh, organ status prohibits local caseworkers involved in a child fatality case from servicing 11:49 on that review team because of the conflict of interest that could create. Even with those rules in mind, five local ODHS staff members participated in the review of Thomas' case. 12:04 Droh condemned the process as nothing more than a public relations exercise and a work of fiction, arguing that it failed to provide the independent examination the circumstances required. The report basically explained the conflict by saying this, quote, It 12:21 would be hard to have a full-fledged and open discussion of the events surrounding a child's death if some findings might be directly critical of someone in the room. A community of people who cared deeply for Lucas Thomas included teachers, 12:35 concerned citizens, and his own grandfather begged ODHS to take meaningful action. They saw the warning signs. They sounded the alarm. 12:45 They did everything right. And DHS did very little. The organization called for broader reforms, saying, quote, Oregon must strengthen its protections for children in care. and ensure that the Department of Human Services is following the law. ODHS responded 13:04 through spokeswoman Sarah Campos saying, quote, Safety is the highest priority of the work we do in child welfare. We are continuously making changes aimed at improving safety of all children, including those in foster care and those who come to 13:18 our attention through the Oregon Child Abuse Hotline. Our hearts goes out to the family, friends, and community who a year later remain impacted by this tragic loss. Disability Rights Oregon and other child advocates continued pushing the Oregon legislature 13:35 for mandatory public reporting on child welfare reviews. Um, yeah, why would that be private? So they were pushing for mandatory public reporting on the child welfare reviews, independent oversight, and stronger enforcement of child protection laws. Meanwhile, Amanda and 13:54 Nathan's criminal case were still pending, but neither case would ultimately go through a full jury trial. Although both had originally pleaded not guilty, they entered formal plea agreements in July 2026. Nathan's case was resolved first. On Tuesday, July 21st, 2026, 14:13 33-year-old Nathan pleaded guilty to first-degree murder, first-degree criminal mistreatment, and second-degree abuse of a corpse. 14:22 And let me also say this. 14:25 I want to make it completely clear that both of them didn't plead guilty because they were taking accountability and felt bad for what they did. They pled guilty because they felt like that was the best outcome for them. 14:39 Their lawyers spoke to them and probably told them that, you know, If you don't, you might get the death penalty or something like this. And so they pled guilty so they can get a lesser charge. I'm not saying that 100% that I know this, but I'm assuming this. 14:57 So Nathan was sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole for at least 35 years on the murder conviction, along with concurrent 60-month sentences for the criminal mistreatment and abuse of a corpse convictions. Six days later, 15:12 on Monday, July 27th, 40-year-old Amanda pleaded guilty to murder by abuse, first-degree criminal mistreatment, and second-degree abuse of a corpse. 15:22 She was sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole for at least 25 years, along with concurrent terms for the remaining convictions. Thomas' family, teachers, classmates, and other members of the Lakeview community filled the courthouse during 15:38 the sentencing proceedings, and many of them wore green paper ties in his honor. The Oregon Department of Justice said, quote, At sentencing, Thomas' family and the Lake County community remembered him as a vibrant, young person who cared deeply about 15:54 everyone around him. They recalled the green paper ties he made for others, how he pulled his little red wagon around Lakeview, and how he made friends wherever he went. 16:05 Community members expressed satisfaction that both Amanda and Nathan received life sentences And on July 30, 2026, the Oregon Department of Justice formally announced the conclusion of the prosecutions and the sentences secured. A memorial bench now stands outside Lakeview 16:24 High School in Thomas' honor. And that is the case of Thomas Scott Strong, a vulnerable young man who needed the help of his mother, you know, the one who brought him into this world, and the system, but they all failed him. 16:38 What do y'all think about. 16:40 This case, especially how the Oregon Department of Human Services handled all those reports? Do you think the people responsible for those decisions should be held accountable? And if you can't tell, I think ODHS failed Thomas, and I don't 16:56 understand how you can have that many people reporting concerns about a child and still not make sure the child is safe. We're talking about teachers, the principal, the school resources officer, and even his own grandfather was trying to 17:11 get somebody to do something. And these people weren't calling because they had a random suspicion. They were seeing things that generally concerned them. The weight loss, how they pulled him out of school. His mother wasn't cooperating. 17:28 She wasn't even showing up to work. 17:30 And I just don't even understand how they let that happen. 17:35 She wasn't answering phone calls. She wasn't taking him to medical appointments. So at what point does somebody say like, okay, enough with the phone calls and text messages. We need to actually see this child. We need to lay eyeballs 17:47 on him. At what point does that happen? I understand the Child Protective Services deals with a lot of cases and I understand that they can't be everywhere at once, but that's not an excuse for what happened here. And 18:01 I have a problem with how the review was handled afterwards, too, because how are we supposed to trust the findings when there are questions about whether. 18:09 The review was truly independent in the first place? 18:13 I'm not saying that everyone involved had bad intentions, but when an agency is being investigated for its own failures, the people conducting that review shouldn't have any connection to the decisions being questioned. Otherwise, how can anyone trust that 18:27 the mistakes are going to be acknowledged and addressed instead of being swept under the rug? If the whole point of the review is to figure out what went wrong and prevent it from happening again, then someone needs to be willing to hold that agency accountable too, right? I 18:42 don't think it's unreasonable to expect an agency responsible for protecting children to actually verify that a child is safe when they're receiving repeated reports of possible abuse and neglect. 18:53 And I definitely don't think it's unreasonable to expect an independent investigation when the agency fails to protect a child. 19:02 And that investigative report should be made public. Amanda and Nathan are now in prison, and that's exactly where they belong. 19:11 But I don't think the conversation about what happened to Thomas should end with their sentences because there was an opportunity to intervene before he died, and nobody did. Thomas had people looking out for him, people who saw something 19:24 was wrong and tried to get him help. And unfortunately, the help came well after the time it should have come. 19:31 And that's what makes this case even more heartbreaking. So what are your thoughts on this case? let me know in the comments below. You already heard mine. And do not let this case stop you from contacting anyone if you suspect child abuse. 19:48 Instead, it should. 19:50 put a fire under you to do even more. So if you suspect child abuse, call the Child Help National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-4-CHILD or 1-800-422-4453 or go to childhelp.org 20:07 All calls are toll-free and confidential, and the hotline is available 24-7 in more than 170 languages. And if you need more resources or you can't remember the number that I just gave here, you can find all of that 20:20 on my website at murderandlove.com. That's love and murder backwards, murderandlove.com. 20:27 And I hope that when people remember Thomas, they remember more than what just happened to him. Remember the young man who loved making green paper ties enjoyed art and cooking, and had an entire community of people who cared about him. 20:41 So if this case raised questions for you about how we protect vulnerable children, please share it. These are the conversations worth having, especially when there are serious questions about whether the systems meant to protect children are doing their jobs. 20:57 And my lambs, if you haven't already, come follow Love and Murder on Facebook where I share additional cases, updates, and stories that don't always make it onto the podcast. Watching, commenting, and sharing those videos also helps support the show and 21:11 it doesn't cost you anything. The link to my Facebook is in the show notes below. And that is all I have for you today. Thank you so much for listening. 21:20 Thank you so much for your time. Thank you so much for your support. 21:23 And I will see you in the next case. Bye.
Community discussion